Effects of adenyl nucleotides and carbachol on cooperative interactions among G proteins

Ligand-Induced Coupling between Oligomers of the M2 Receptor and the Gi1 Protein in Live Cells

Uncertainty over the mechanism of signaling via G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) relates in part to questions regarding their supramolecular structure. GPCRs and heterotrimeric G proteins are known to couple as monomers under various conditions. Many GPCRs form oligomers under many of the same conditions, however, and the biological role of those complexes is unclear. We have used dual-color fluorescence correlation spectroscopy to identify oligomers of the M₂ muscarinic receptor and of G_i1 in purified preparations and live Chinese hamster ovary cells. Measurements on differently tagged receptors (i.e., eGFP-M₂ and mCherry-M₂) and G proteins (i.e., eGFP-Gα_i1β₁γ₂ and mCherry-Gα_i1β₁γ₂) detected significant cross-correlations between the two fluorophores in each case, both in detergent micelles and in live cells, indicating that both the receptor and G_i1 can exist as homo-oligomers. Oligomerization of differently tagged G_i1 decreased upon the activation of co-expressed wild-type M₂ receptor by an agonist. Measurements on a tagged M₂ receptor (M₂-mCherry) and eGFP-Gα_i1β₁γ₂ co-expressed in live cells detected cross-correlations only in the presence of an agonist, which therefore promoted coupling of the receptor and the G protein. The effect of the agonist was retained when a fluorophore-tagged receptor lacking the orthosteric site (i.e., M₂(D103A)-mCherry) was co-expressed with the wild-type receptor and eGFP-Gα_i1β₁γ₂, indicating that the ligand acted via an oligomeric receptor. Our results point to a model in which an agonist promotes transient coupling of otherwise independent oligomers of the M₂ receptor on the one hand and of G_i1 on the other and that an activated complex leads to a reduction in the oligomeric size of the G protein. They suggest that GPCR-mediated signaling proceeds, at least in part, via oligomers.

Fine-tuning of GPCR signals by intracellular G protein modulators

Heterotrimeric G proteins convey receptor signals to intracellular effectors. Superimposed over the basic GPCR-G protein-effector scheme are three types of auxiliary proteins that also modulate Gα. Regulator of G protein signaling proteins and G protein signaling modifier proteins respectively promote GTPase activity and hinder GTP/GDP exchange to limit Gα activation. There are also diverse proteins that, like GPCRs, can promote nucleotide exchange and thus activation. Here we review the impact of these auxiliary proteins on GPCR signaling. Although their precise physiological functions are not yet clear, all of them can produce significant effects in experimental systems. These signaling changes are generally consistent with established effects on isolated Gα; however, the activation state of Gα is seldom verified and many such changes appear also to reflect the physical disruption of or indirect effects on interactions between Gα and its associated GPCR, Gβγ, and/or effector.

Heterotropic cooperativity within and between protomers of an oligomeric M(2) muscarinic receptor

At least four allosteric sites have been found to mediate the dose-dependent effects of gallamine on the binding of [(3)H]quinuclidinylbenzilate (QNB) and N-[(3)H]methylscopolamine (NMS) to M(2) muscarinic receptors in membranes and solubilized preparations from porcine atria, CHO cells, and Sf9 cells. The rate of dissociation of [(3)H]QNB was affected in a bell-shaped manner with at least one Hill coefficient (n(H)) greater than 1, indicating that at least three allosteric sites are involved. The level of binding of [(3)H]QNB was decreased in a biphasic manner, revealing at least two allosteric sites; binding of [(3)H]NMS was affected in a triphasic, serpentine manner, revealing at least three sites, and values of n(H) >1 pointed to at least four sites. Several lines of evidence indicate that all effects of gallamine were allosteric in nature and could be observed at equilibrium. The rates of equilibration and dissociation suggest that the receptor was predominately oligomeric, and the heterogeneity revealed by gallamine can be attributed to differences in its affinity for the constituent protomers of a tetramer. Those differences appear to arise from inter- and intramolecular cooperativity between gallamine and the radioligand.

Cleavage-resistant fusion proteins of the M(2) muscarinic receptor and Gα(i1). Homotropic and heterotropic effects in the binding of ligands

BACKGROUND

G protein-coupled receptors fused to a Gα-subunit are functionally similar to their unfused counterparts. They offer an intriguing view into the nature of the receptor-G protein complex, but their usefulness depends upon the stability of the fusion.

METHODS

Fusion proteins of the M(2) muscarinic receptor and the α-subunit of G(i1) were expressed in CHO and Sf9 cells, extracted in digitonin-cholate, and examined for their binding properties and their electrophoretic mobility on western blots.

RESULTS

Receptor fused to native α(i1) underwent proteolysis near the point of fusion to release a fragment with the mobility of α(i1). The cleavage was prevented by truncation of the α-subunit at position 18. Binding of the agonist oxotremorine-M to the stable fusion protein from Sf9 cells was biphasic, and guanylylimidodiphosphate promoted an apparent interconversion of sites from higher to lower affinity. With receptor from CHO cells, the apparent capacity for N-[(3)H]methylscopolamine was 60% of that for [(3)H]quinuclidinylbenzilate; binding at saturating concentrations of the latter was inhibited in a noncompetitive manner at low concentrations of unlabeled N-methylscopolamine.

CONCLUSIONS

A stable fusion protein of the M(2) receptor and truncated α(i1) resembles the native receptor-G protein complex with respect to the guanyl nucleotide-sensitive binding of agonists and the noncompetitive binding of antagonists.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Release of the α-subunit is likely to occur with other such fusion proteins, rendering the data ambiguous or misleading. The properties of a chemically stable fusion protein support the notion that signaling proceeds via a stable multimeric complex of receptor and G protein.

Heterooligomers of the muscarinic receptor and G proteins purified from porcine atria

Muscarinic receptor extracted from porcine atria in digitonin-cholate copurified with Galpha(o), Galpha(i1-3), and caveolins. The presence of complexes was confirmed by coimmunoprecipitation of the receptor, alpha-subunits, and caveolins in various combinations. Homooligomers of alpha(i2) were detected on Western blots, and heterooligomers of alpha(i2) and alpha(o) were identified by coimmunoprecipitation; thus, a complex may contain at least two alpha-subunits. Other combinations of alpha-subunit were not detected. The ratio of total alpha-subunit to receptor was near 1, as measured by [(35)S]GTPgammaS and the antagonist [(3)H]quinuclidinylbenzilate, and the binding of [(35)S]GTPgammaS was manifestly biphasic. The ratio of alpha(o) to alpha(i1,2) also was near 1, as determined from the intensity of Western blots. Cardiac muscarinic receptors therefore can be purified as a mixture of complexes that contain caveolins and oligomers of alpha-subunit, some of which are heteromeric. Each complex would appear to contain equal numbers of alpha-subunit and the receptor.

Activation of G protein-coupled receptors: beyond two-state models and tertiary conformational changes

Transformation of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) from a quiescent to an active state initiates signal transduction. All GPCRs share a common architecture comprising seven transmembrane-spanning alpha-helices, which accommodates signal propagation from a diverse repertoire of external stimuli across biological membranes to a heterotrimeric G protein. Signal propagation through the transmembrane helices likely involves mechanistic features common to all GPCRs. The structure of the light receptor rhodopsin may serve as a prototype for the transmembrane architecture of GPCRs. Early biochemical, biophysical, and pharmacological studies led to the conceptualization of receptor activation based on the context of two-state equilibrium models and conformational changes in protein structure. More recent studies indicate a need to move beyond these classical paradigms and to consider additional aspects of the molecular character of GPCRs, such as the oligomerization and dynamics of the receptor.

Cholesterol as a determinant of cooperativity in the M2 muscarinic cholinergic receptor

M2 muscarinic receptor extracted from Sf9 cells in cholate-NaCl differs from that extracted from porcine sarcolemma. The latter has been shown to exhibit an anomalous pattern in which the capacity for N-[3H]methylscopolamine (NMS) is only 50% of that for [3H]quinuclidinylbenzilate (QNB), yet unlabeled NMS exhibits high affinity for all of the sites labeled by [3H]QNB. The effects can be explained in terms of cooperativity within a receptor that is at least tetravalent [Park PS, Sum CS, Pawagi AB, Wells JW. Cooperativity and oligomeric status of cardiac muscarinic cholinergic receptors. Biochemistry 2002;41:5588-604]. In contrast, M2 receptor extracted from Sf9 membranes exhibited no shortfall in the capacity for [3H]NMS at either 30 or 4 degrees C, although there was a time-dependent inactivation during incubation with [3H]NMS at 30 degrees C; also, any discrepancies in the affinity of NMS were comparatively small. The level of cholesterol in Sf9 membranes was only 4% of that in sarcolemmal membranes, and it was increased to about 100% by means of cholesterol-methyl-beta-cyclodextrin. M2 receptors extracted from treated Sf9 membranes were stable at 30 and 4 degrees C and resembled those from heart. Cholesterol induced a marked heterogeneity detected in the binding of both radioligands, including a shortfall in the apparent capacity for [3H]NMS, and there were significant discrepancies in the apparent affinity of NMS as estimated directly and via the inhibition of [3H]QNB. The data can be described quantitatively in terms of cooperative effects among six or more interacting sites. Cholesterol therefore appears to promote cooperativity in the binding of antagonists to the M2 muscarinic receptor.

Quantitative Analysis of Muscarinic Acetylcholine Receptor Homo- and Heterodimerization in Live Cells

Although previous pharmacological and biochemical data support the notion that muscarinic acetylcholine receptors (mAChR) form homo- and heterodimers, the existence of mAChR oligomers in live cells is still a matter of controversy. Here we used bioluminescence resonance energy transfer to demonstrate that M(1), M(2), and M(3) mAChR can form constitutive homo- and heterodimers in living HEK 293 cells. Quantitative bioluminescence resonance energy transfer analysis has revealed that the cell receptor population in cells expressing a single subtype of M(1), M(2), or M(3) mAChR is predominantly composed of high affinity homodimers. Saturation curve analysis of cells expressing two receptor subtypes demonstrates the existence of high affinity M(1)/M(2), M(2)/M(3), and M(1)/M(3) mAChR heterodimers, although the relative affinity values were slightly lower than those for mAChR homodimers. Short term agonist treatment did not modify the oligomeric status of homo- and heterodimers. When expressed in JEG-3 cells, the M(2) receptor exhibits much higher susceptibility than the M(3) receptor to agonist-induced down-regulation. Coexpression of M(3) mAChR with increasing amounts of the M(2) subtype in JEG-3 cells resulted in an increased agonist-induced down-regulation of M(3), suggesting a novel role of heterodimerization in the mechanism of mAChR long term regulation.

Oligomerization of G protein-coupled receptors: past, present, and future

G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR)-mediated signal transduction has been studied for more than a century. Despite the intense focus on this class of proteins, a molecular understanding of what constitutes the functional form of the receptor is still uncertain. GPCRs have traditionally been conceptualized as monomeric proteins, and this view has changed little over the years until relatively recently. Recent biochemical and biophysical studies have challenged this traditional concept, and point instead to a mechanistic view of signal transduction wherein the receptor functions as an oligomer. Cooperative interactions within such an oligomeric array may be critical for the propagation of an external signal across the cell membrane and to the G protein, and may therefore underlie the mechanistic basis of signaling.

Effects of N-ethylmaleimide on conformational equilibria in purified cardiac muscarinic receptors

Muscarinic receptors purified from porcine atria and devoid of G protein underwent a 9-27-fold decrease in their apparent affinity for the antagonists quinuclidinyl benzilate, N-methylscopolamine, and scopolamine when treated with the thiol-selective reagent N-ethylmaleimide. Their apparent affinity for the agonists carbachol and oxotremorine-M was unchanged. Conversely, the rate of alkylation by N-ethylmaleimide, as monitored by the binding of [(3)H]quinuclidinyl benzilate, was decreased by antagonists while agonists were without effect. The receptor also underwent a time-dependent inactivation that was hastened by N-ethylmaleimide but slowed by quinuclidinyl benzilate and N-methylscopolamine. The destabilizing effect of N-ethylmaleimide was counteracted fully or nearly so at saturating concentrations of each antagonist and the agonist carbachol. Similar effects occurred with human M(2) receptors differentially tagged with the c-Myc and FLAG epitopes, coexpressed in Sf9 cells, and extracted in digitonin/cholate. The degree of coimmunoprecipitation was unchanged by N-ethylmaleimide, which therefore was without discernible effect on oligomeric size. The data are quantitatively consistent with a model in which the purified receptor from porcine atria interconverts spontaneously between two states (i.e. R R*). Antagonists favor the R state; agonists and N-ethylmaleimide favor the comparatively unstable R* state, which predominates after purification. Occupancy by a ligand stabilizes both states, and antagonists impede alkylation by favoring R over R*. Similarities with constitutively active receptors suggest that R and R* are akin to the inactive and active states, respectively. Purified M(2) receptors therefore appear to exist predominantly in their active state.

Distinct interactions of GTP, UTP, and CTP with G(s) proteins

Early studies showed that in addition to GTP, the pyrimidine nucleotides UTP and CTP support activation of the adenylyl cyclase (AC)-stimulating G(s) protein. The aim of this study was to elucidate the mechanism by which UTP and CTP support G(s) activation. As models, we used S49 wild-type lymphoma cells, representing a physiologically relevant system in which the beta(2)-adrenoreceptor (beta(2)AR) couples to G(s), and Sf9 insect cell membranes expressing beta(2)AR-Galpha(s) fusion proteins. Fusion proteins provide a higher sensitivity for the analysis of beta(2)AR-G(s) coupling than native systems. Nucleoside 5'-triphosphates (NTPs) supported agonist-stimulated AC activity in the two systems and basal AC activity in membranes from cholera toxin-treated S49 cells in the order of efficacy GTP > or = UTP > CTP > ATP (ineffective). NTPs disrupted high affinity agonist binding in beta(2)AR-Galpha(s) in the order of efficacy GTP > UTP > CTP > ATP (ineffective). In contrast, the order of efficacy of NTPs as substrates for nucleoside diphosphokinase, catalyzing the formation of GTP from GDP and NTP was ATP > or = UTP > or = CTP > or = GTP. NTPs inhibited beta(2)AR-Galpha(s)-catalyzed [gamma-(32)P]GTP hydrolysis in the order of potency GTP > UTP > CTP. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that UTP is accommodated more easily within the binding pocket of Galpha(s) than CTP. Collectively, our data indicate that GTP, UTP, and CTP interact differentially with G(s) proteins and that transphosphorylation of GDP to GTP is not involved in this G protein activation. In certain cell systems, intracellular UTP and CTP concentrations reach approximately 10 nmol/mg of protein and are higher than intracellular GTP concentrations, indicating that G protein activation by UTP and CTP can occur physiologically. G protein activation by UTP and CTP could be of particular importance in pathological conditions such as cholera and Lesch-Nyhan syndrome.

Characterization and comparison of RGS2 and RGS4 as GTPase-activating proteins for m2 muscarinic receptor-stimulated G(i)

RGS2 and RGS4 were studied for their effects as GTPase activating proteins (GAPs) on receptor-activated G(i) in a novel steady-state assay using membranes from Sf9 cells quadruply infected with baculoviruses encoding the m2 muscarinic receptor, G(alphai2), G(beta1), and G(gamma2). In the presence of the muscarinic agonist carbachol, regulator of G protein signaling 2 (RGS2) and RGS4 each produced up to a 10-fold increase in agonist-dependent GTPase activity. The observed K(m) for GTP in this system was increased in the presence of RGS4. NaCl and KCl inhibited the GAP activities of both RGS2 and RGS4, although they had no effect on GTPase activity in the absence of RGS proteins. MgCl(2) had a complex effect on GTPase activity, with optimal RGS2 and RGS4 GAP activities occurring, respectively, at high micromolar and low millimolar concentrations of free Mg(2+). The concentration dependence of RGS GAP activity was assessed, and RGS4 was found to be more potent than RGS2 by up to an order of magnitude. This direct observation confirms a similar difference in potency found when these two RGS proteins were compared for their ability to inhibit signaling downstream of G(i). RGS2 yielded Hill coefficients greater than 2.0, suggesting that it may bind in a positively cooperative manner to oligomeric structures containing more than one G protein. Furthermore, RGS4 yielded a bell-shaped dose-dependence under low magnesium (0.5 mM) conditions, which is also consistent with the idea of RGS cooperativity.

Dimerization of G-protein-coupled receptors

The evolutionary trace (ET) method, a data mining approach for determining significant levels of amino acid conservation, has been applied to over 700 aligned G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) sequences. The method predicted the occurrence of functionally important clusters of residues on the external faces of helices 5 and 6 for each family or subfamily of receptors; similar clusters were observed on helices 2 and 3. The probability that these clusters are not random was determined using Monte Carlo techniques. The cluster on helices 5 and 6 is consistent with both 5,6-contact and 5,6-domain swapped dimer formation; the possible equivalence of these two types of dimer is discussed because this relates to activation by homo- and heterodimers. The observation of a functionally important cluster of residues on helices 2 and 3 is novel, and some possible interpretations are given, including heterodimerization and oligomerization. The application of the evolutionary trace method to 113 aligned G-protein sequences resulted in the identification of two functional sites. One large, well-defined site is clearly identified with adenyl cyclase, beta/gamma and regulator of G-protein signaling (RGS) binding. The other G-protein functional site, which extends from the ras-like domain onto the helical domain, has the correct size and electrostatic properties for GPCR dimer binding. The implications of these results are discussed in terms of the conformational changes required in the G-protein for activation by a receptor dimer. Further, the implications of GPCR dimerization for medicinal chemistry are discussed in the context of these ET results.

Apparent capacity of cardiac muscarinic receptors for different radiolabeled antagonists

Muscarinic receptors in sarcolemmal membranes, digitonin-solubilized extracts, and purified preparations from porcine atria have revealed a shortfall in the apparent capacity for N-[3H]methylscopolamine, which was only about 75% of that for [3H]quinuclidinylbenzilate. Since binding at near-saturating concentrations of [3H]quinuclidinylbenzilate was inhibited fully at comparatively low concentrations of unlabeled N-methylscopolamine, the data are inconsistent with the notion that [3H]quinuclidinylbenzilate binds selectively to a subclass of distinct, non-interconverting, and mutually independent sites. The discrepancy is resolved by adjusting the specific activity of N-[3H]methylscopolamine to account for unlabeled scopolamine that was identified in some batches of the radioligand. Also, there was no shortfall in capacity when N-[3H]methylscopolamine was devoid of scopolamine, and the predicted effect was obtained when pure N-[3H]methylscopolamine was supplemented with known amounts of scopolamine. A small discrepancy in the levels of scopolamine estimated pharmacologically and by mass spectrometry can be attributed largely to a difference in the efficiency of ionization between scopolamine and N-methylscopolamine. Different capacities for different radioligands are not uncommon with muscarinic and other G protein-coupled receptors, and in some cases the effect may have been due wholly or in part to an unlabeled impurity. Binding data can be mechanistically ambiguous, particularly when acquired only at graded concentrations of the radioligand. The predicted effects of an unlabeled impurity mimic or resemble those of alternative scenarios such as sequestration behind a hydrophobic barrier, a nucleotide-regulated interconversion from one state of affinity to another, and cooperativity between interacting sites.

Interaction of the retinal G-protein transducin with uracil nucleotides

Little is known about the interaction of pyrimidine nucleotides with G-proteins. Here we report that under experimental conditions that exclude transphosphorylation reactions, nucleoside 5'-triphosphates inhibited transducin-catalyzed GTP hydrolysis in the order of potency guanosine 5'-[gamma-thio]triphosphate > GTP > guanosine 5'-[beta,gamma-imido]triphosphate > uridine 5'-[gamma-thio]triphosphate > UTP > CTP. Nucleoside 5'-diphosphates inhibited GTP hydrolysis in the order of potency GDP approximately guanosine 5'-[beta-thio]thiodiphosphate > uridine 5'-[beta-thio]diphosphate >> UDP (no effect). UTP inhibited GTP hydrolysis competitively, indicative for nucleotide binding to the same site. Uracil nucleotides had a distinct activity profile with respect to disruption of the transitory complex between photoexcited rhodopsin and nucleotide-free transducin. We conclude that (i) uracil nucleotides bind to transducin-alpha with lower affinity than the corresponding guanine nucleotides, (ii) phosphorothioate modification of uracil nucleotides increases their affinity for transducin, and (iii) uracil nucleotides induce conformational changes in G-proteins that are different from the conformational changes induced by guanine nucleotides.

Regulation of guanine nucleotide turnover on Gi/Go by agonist-stimulated and spontaneously active muscarinic receptors in cardiac membranes

Muscarinic receptor regulation of guanine nucleotide turnover on Gi/Go proteins in ventricular sarcolemma was investigated. In the absence of a muscarinic receptor (MR) agonist, GTP bound to background sites with a Kapp value of 60 nM and a Bmax of 50 pmol/mg. The addition of the MR agonist, carbachol, further increased GTP binding by 50 pmol/mg to sites with the same Kapp value of 60 nM. Pertussis toxin treatment reduced GTP binding to carbachol-regulated and background binding sites, thus identifying both sites as Gi/Go. The identity of the carbachol-regulated GTP binding sites was further confirmed by demonstrating that carbachol stimulated GTP binding and inhibited adenylyl cyclase with an EC50 value of 200 nM. Background and carbachol-regulated guanine nucleotide binding sites bound GDP with a Kapp value of 150 nM. However, maximal background GDP binding was 50 pmol/mg, whereas maximal carbachol-regulated GDP binding was only 12-15 pmol/mg. In sarcolemma preloaded with [3H]GDP, carbachol-regulated [3H]GDP release was strictly dependent on the presence of guanine nucleotides. The Kapp values for GTP and GDP to support carbachol-regulated [3H]GDP release were 60 nM and 150 nM, respectively. Guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) (GDPbetaS) facilitated carbachol-regulated [3H]GDP release with a Kapp value of 2 microM. However, GTP was two times more efficacious than GDP or GDPbetaS in facilitating carbachol-regulated [3H]GDP release. Mn2+ also stimulated [3H]GDP release from carbachol-regulated sites by a mechanism not requiring guanine nucleotides. These studies indicate that two pools of muscarinic receptors, carbachol regulated and spontaneously active, regulate guanine nucleotide turnover on pertussis toxin sensitive Gi/Go. These studies further suggest that guanine nucleotide binding provides the signal to stimulate GDP release from receptor activated Gi/Go proteins. A quaternary mechanism involving G-protein interactions may be necessary to promote guanine nucleotide exchange on Gi/Go.

Effects of an agonist, allosteric modulator, and antagonist on guanosine-gamma-[35S]thiotriphosphate binding to liposomes with varying muscarinic receptor/Go protein stoichiometry

We investigated whether alcuronium, an allosteric modulator of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors, can induce receptor-mediated activation of Go proteins in liposomal membranes incorporating purified M2 receptors and Go proteins and whether its action is affected by the receptor/Go protein (R/Go) ratio. The binding of guanosine-gamma-[35S]thiotriphosphate ([35S]GTPgammaS) served as the indicator of G protein activation. It was stimulated by empty receptors at high receptor densities, and the dose-response curve was shifted to the left by the agonist carbachol and to the right by the antagonist atropine. At an R/Go ratio of 300:100, the rate of [35S]GTPgammaS binding was the same in the presence or absence of 0. 1 mM carbachol. Alcuronium increased the binding of [35S]GTPgammaS at R/Go ratios of <3:100 and diminished it at R/Go ratios of >10:100, similar to previous observations on intact cells expressing muscarinic receptors at different densities. The apparent biphasicity of alcuronium action indicates that the allosteric modulator has at least two effects on muscarinic receptor/G protein interaction but its mechanistic basis is unclear. The "active state" of muscarinic receptors induced by alcuronium probably is different from that induced by carbachol. Changes in the densities of receptors and Go proteins had little effect on the kinetics of [35S]GTPgammaS binding and on receptor affinity for carbachol, provided the R/Go ratio was kept constant. This suggests that the receptors and G proteins are located in microdomains in which their concentrations remain constant, despite variations in the amounts of lipidic membranes in the system.

Rethinking receptor-G protein-effector interactions

Hundreds of different receptors regulate the activity of effector proteins with the assistance of heterotrimeric guanine nucleotide-binding proteins (G proteins). The hypothesis that G protein-coupled receptors (R) govern their effectors (E) indirectly via a shuttling mechanism involving the exchange of heterotrimeric G proteins (G[alpha betagamma]) or parts thereof (G[alpha], G[betagamma]) between ephemeral R-G and G-E complexes has become firmly established. While there is no direct evidence for the cyclical formation and dissociation of these complexes during signalling, experimental changes in second messenger production, GTPase activity, and the binding characteristics of agonists, antagonists, and guanine nucleotides commonly are believed to reflect perturbations in the equilibria between G protein and the other two components. However, a growing body of evidence seems to argue against the shuttling model. The random, transient association of G protein and receptor is largely inconsistent with the binding of agonists to receptors and the allosteric regulation of that binding by guanine nucleotides. Also, the prevailing paradigm does not readily account for receptor-effector coupling specificity, as the promiscuous interaction of most G proteins with both receptors and effectors in vitro is at odds with the general failure of G proteins to be shared among ostensibly congruous signal transduction pathways in vivo. The latter paradox would be obviated by the simultaneous interaction of G protein with both receptor and effector. Indeed, various findings indicate that R-G-E complexes do occur. How and where in the cell such complexes are assembled and disassembled should provide important clues to the true mechanism of G protein-linked transduction.

[Gamma-35S]GTP autoradiography allows region-specific detection of muscarinic receptor-dependent G-protein activation in the chick optic tectum

A recently introduced technique of [gamma-35S]GTP autoradiography was used to localize and characterize muscarinic receptor-dependent activation of G-proteins in tissue sections of the chick optic tectum, a brain region with relatively high expression of G-protein-coupled receptors for the neurotransmitter acetylcholine. Within the highly stratified tectal structure, the bulk of muscarinic receptor-mediated [gamma-35S]GTP signal was localized to the stratum griseum et fibrosum superficiale with considerably lower binding responses in other tectal layers. Quantitative comparison of [gamma-35S]GTP binding responses in tectal sections and membranes revealed a close match between the two tissue preparations for the response elicited by the cholinergic agonist carbachol, its dose-dependent reversal with the non-selective muscarinic antagonist atropine, its approximately 100-fold sensitivity towards blockade with M1-type (pirenzepine) over M2-type (gallamine) muscarinic antagonists, as well as absolute requirement for micromolar concentrations of GDP (EC50 approximately 10 microM) for the receptor-mediated [gamma-35S]GTP response. The pharmacological profile is consistent with that of cm4, a recently cloned chicken homolog of the mammalian m4 muscarinic acetylcholine receptor. Moreover, the strict GDP-dependence of the binding response suggest activation of Gi/o, the inhibitory class of G-proteins. These data provide the first functional characterization of the chick tectal muscarinic receptors. A close match between [gamma-35S]GTP responses in membranes and tissue sections strongly suggest that [gamma-35S]GTP autoradiography offers great potential for studies on G-protein-mediated signaling, with particular use within anatomically restricted regions that are not readily approached with more conventional techniques. It is anticipated that [gamma-35S]GTP autoradiography should greatly facilitate studies on signaling capacity of an individual receptor subtype whilst in its native cellular environment.

Cooperativity manifest in the binding properties of purified cardiac muscarinic receptors

Muscarinic receptors were solubilized from porcine atria in digitonin-cholate and were purified by chromatography on DEAE-Sepharose and 3-(2'-aminobenzhydryloxy)tropane-Sepharose. The product identified on Western blots migrated with an apparent molecular mass of 60-75 kDa, with additional bands indicative of homotrimers (190 kDa) and homotetramers (240 kDa). Receptor eluted from the affinity column was accompanied by a mixture of guanyl nucleotide-binding proteins (G-proteins) identified on Western blots as Gi1/2, G(o), Gq/11, and Gs (preparation M2G); the G-proteins were largely removed by further processing on hydroxyapatite (preparation M2). Solubilized purified receptors bound muscarinic ligands in an apparently cooperative manner. In studies at equilibrium, the antagonists [3H]AF-DX 384, N-[3H]methylscopolamine (NMS), and [3H]quinuclidinylbenzilate (QNB) revealed Hill coefficients between about 0.8 and 1.2. Also, the apparent capacity for [3H]QNB exceeded that for [3H]AF-DX 384 and [3H]NMS by about 1.5-fold in M2 and by 2-fold in M2G. Binding to M2G at high concentrations of [3H]QNB was fully inhibited by unlabeled NMS, which therefore affected sites not labeled at similar concentrations of [3H]NMS. Oxotremorine-M displayed a biphasic inhibitory effect on the binding of [3H]AF-DX 384 in M2 and M2G, suggesting that multiple states of affinity are intrinsic to the receptor; 5'-guanylylimidodiphosphate was without appreciable effect in M2 but resulted in a bell-shaped binding profile for the agonist in M2G. All of the data can be described in terms of cooperative interactions within a receptor that is at least tetravalent and presumably an oligomer. In the context of the model, copurifying G-proteins and guanyl nucleotides serve to regulate the degree of cooperativity between successive equivalents of muscarinic ligands.

Characterization of two alternatively spliced forms of a metabotropic glutamate receptor in the central nervous system of the rat

Amplification of complementary DNA by the polymerase chain reaction and anti-peptide antibodies were used to characterize the expression of two alternatively spliced forms of a metabotropic glutamate receptor (mGluR1 alpha and mGluR1 beta) in the central nervous system of the rat. Polymerase chain reaction analysis showed that mGluR1 alpha was the predominate of the two forms in the cerebellum, diencephalon, mesencephalon, olfactory bulb and brainstem, while mGluR1 beta was the major form present in the hippocampus. Approximately equal amounts of the two receptors were expressed in the cerebral cortex, septum and striatum. Immunochemical analyses of the two receptors were conducted in the rat cerebellum and hippocampus. An mGluR1 alpha-specific antibody labelled a protein with a relative molecular weight of 146,000 on immunoblots of the hippocampus and cerebellum. Immunoblot analysis of the developmental expression of mGluR1 alpha in the hippocampus and cerebellum demonstrated that in both structures, the levels of mGluR1 alpha were at or near their maximum levels in the adult brain. In contrast, two mGluR1 beta-specific antibodies failed to detect mGluR1 beta on immunoblots of brain tissue, thus precluding an immunocytochemical analysis of this receptor. Although low levels of a higher-molecular weight protein, possibly a dimeric form of mGluR1 beta were seen with one of the mGluR1 beta-specific antibodies, we hypothesize that some of the mGluR1 beta present in brain tissue may undergo proteolytic cleavage of the carboxy terminus. Immunocytochemical analysis of mGluR1 alpha showed that very high levels of this receptor were expressed in Purkinje cell bodies and dendrites. In the granule cell layer, some Golgi neurons were immunostained. The granule cells were not labelled. In the hippocampus, mGluR1 alpha immunoreactivity was present in interneurons of the stratum oriens and the dentate hilar region. Double-labelling studies demonstrated that these interneurons were also immunopositive for the neuropeptide somatostatin. The presence of mGluR1 alpha in cells of the hippocampus that are associated with the release of somatostatin, suggest that this receptor could play a role in regulating hippocampal excitability in both normal and epileptic tissues.

Pharmacological characterization of acetylcholine-stimulated [35S]-GTP gamma S binding mediated by human muscarinic m1-m4 receptors: antagonist studies

1. We have used dose-ratio analysis to estimate functionally the affinity constants (pKb) and Schild slope factors of a range of selective or atypical antagonists at human muscarinic m1-m4 receptors. 2. The functional response was the stimulation by acetylcholine of [35S]-GTP gamma S binding to membranes from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells stably expressing individual receptor subtypes. 3. A novel experimental design and analysis was used which allowed the estimation of affinity and Schild slope factor from a single antagonist inhibition curve, and the results were compared with other methods of analysis, both theoretically valid and invalid. 4. In general, the affinity estimates were very similar to previously reported values obtained in binding studies with animal tissues and cloned human receptors and the Schild slope factors were close to unity. 5. These results demonstrate the validity of the assay and provide no evidence for species differences in antagonist affinity for muscarinic receptor subtypes. 6. The results confirm both the utility of himbacine in distinguishing between m1 and m4 receptors and a previously reported modest m4-selectivity for tropicamide and secoverine. 7. The cholinesterase inhibitor, tacrine (THA), had a potency profile similar to that of gallamine but with less selectivity. Its affinity could not be determined since it had Schild slope factors of about 2 at all subtypes. 8. o-Methoxy-sila-hexocyclium had only a modest selectivity for the m1 subtype.

Intracellular ATP and GTP are both required to preserve modulation of N-type calcium channel current by norepinephrine

Norepinephrine (NE) inhibits voltage-dependent calcium channels of sympathetic neurons. We investigated the role of intracellular nucleotides in this inhibition for clues to receptor-channel coupling mechanisms. Both ATP and GTP are required to preserve NE responsiveness during whole-cell dialysis. The response to NE was gradually lost in bullfrog sympathetic neurons dialyzed with GTP as the only nucleotide, ATP only, or no nucleotides. Replacing ATP with ATP[gamma-S] resulted in spontaneous modulation of calcium channel current, possibly because of production of GTP[gamma-S]. The nonhydrolyzable ATP analog p[NH]ppA could substitute for ATP to preserve NE responsiveness. The protein phosphatase inhibitors okadaic acid and calyculin-A did not affect NE inhibition of calcium channel current, or recovery from that inhibition. These results suggest protein phosphorylation is not involved in the inhibition of calcium channel current, but binding of ATP to some intracellular site is required for the coupling of adrenergic receptors to calcium channels.