Structure and dynamics of transmembrane signaling by the Escherichia coli aspartate receptor

Mutational analysis of the transmembrane helix 2-HAMP domain connection in the Escherichia coli aspartate chemoreceptor tar

Transmembrane helix 2 (TM2) of the Tar chemoreceptor undergoes an inward piston-like displacement of 1 to 3 Å upon binding aspartate. This signal is transmitted to the kinase-control module via the HAMP domain. Within Tar, the HAMP domain forms a parallel four-helix bundle consisting of a dimer of two amphipathic helices connected by a flexible linker. In the nuclear magnetic resonance structure of an archaeal HAMP domain, residues corresponding to the MLLT sequence between Arg-214 at the end of TM2 and Pro-219 of Tar are an N-terminal helical extension of AS1. We modified this region to test whether it behaves as a continuous helical connection between TM2 and HAMP. First, one to four Gly residues were inserted between Thr-218 and Pro-219. Second, the MLLT sequence was replaced with one to nine Gly residues. Third, the sequence was shortened or extended with residues compatible with helix formation. Cells expressing receptors in which the MLLT sequence was shortened to MLL or in which the MLLT sequence was replaced by four Gly residues performed good aspartate chemotaxis. Other mutant receptors supported diminished aspartate taxis. Most mutant receptors had biased signal outputs and/or abnormal patterns of adaptive methylation. We interpret these results to indicate that a strong, permanent helical connection between TM2 and the HAMP domain is not necessary for normal transmembrane signaling.

A fraction of the BglG transcriptional antiterminator from Escherichia coli exists as a compact monomer

Expression of the bgl operon in Escherichia coli, induced by beta-glucosides, is positively regulated by BglG, a transcriptional antiterminator. In the presence of inducer, BglG dimerizes and binds to the bgl transcript to prevent premature termination of transcription. The dimeric state of BglG is determined by BglF, a membrane-bound enzyme II of the phosphoenolpyruvate-dependent phosphotransferase system (PTS), which reversibly phosphorylates BglG according to beta-glucoside availability. BglG is composed of an RNA-binding domain followed by two homologous PTS regulation domains (PRD1 and PRD2). The predicted structure of dimeric LicT, a BglG homologue from Bacillus subtilis, suggests that the two PRDs adopt a similar structure and that the interactions within the dimer are PRD1-PRD1 and PRD2-PRD2. We have shown recently that the PRD1 and PRD2 domains of BglG can form a stable heterodimer. We report here, based on in vitro and in vivo cross-linking experiments, that a fraction of BglG is present in the cell in a compact form in which PRD1 and PRD2 are in close proximity. The compact form is present mainly in the BglG monomers. Our results imply that the monomer-dimer transition involves a conformational change. The possible role of the compact form in preventing untimely induction of the bgl operon is discussed.

Mapping of the dimer interface of the Escherichia coli mannitol permease by cysteine cross-linking

A cysteine cross-linking approach was used to identify residues at the dimer interface of the Escherichia coli mannitol permease. This transport protein comprises two cytoplasmic domains and one membrane-embedded C domain per monomer, of which the latter provides the dimer contacts. A series of single-cysteine His-tagged C domains present in the native membrane were subjected to Cu(II)-(1,10-phenanthroline)(3)-catalyzed disulfide formation or cysteine cross-linking with dimaleimides of different length. The engineered cysteines were at the borders of the predicted membrane-spanning alpha-helices. Two residues were found to be located in close proximity of each other and capable of forming a disulfide, while four other locations formed cross-links with the longer dimaleimides. Solubilization of the membranes did only influence the cross-linking behavior at one position (Cys(73)). Mannitol binding only effected the cross-linking of a cysteine at the border of the third transmembrane helix (Cys(134)), indicating that substrate binding does not lead to large rearrangements in the helix packing or to dissociation of the dimer. Upon mannitol binding, the Cys(134) becomes more exposed but the residue is no longer capable of forming a stable disulfide in the dimeric IIC domain. In combination with the recently obtained projection structure of the IIC domain in two-dimensional crystals, a first proposal is made for alpha-helix packing in the mannitol permease.

Chemotaxis receptors: a progress report on structure and function

Recent biochemical and structural studies have provided many new insights into the structure and function of bacterial chemoreceptors. Aspects of their ligand binding, conformational changes, and interactions with other members of the signaling pathway are being defined at the structural level. It is anticipated that the combined effort will soon provide a detailed, unified view of an entire response system.

HtrI is a dimer whose interface is sensitive to receptor photoactivation and His-166 replacements in sensory rhodopsin I

Single cysteine substitutions were introduced into three positions of otherwise cysteineless HtrI, a phototaxis transducer found in Halobacterium salinarum that transmits signals from the photoreceptor sensory rhodopsin I (SRI) to a cytoplasmic pathway controlling the cell's motility. Oxidative cross-linking of the monocysteine HtrI mutants in membrane suspensions resulted in dimer forms evident in SDS-polyacrylamide gels. The rate of cross-linking of I64C on the cytoplasmic side of HtrI was accelerated by SRI binding in the dark and further increased by SRI photoactivation. Several residue replacements of His-166 in SRI accelerated the cross-linking rate of I64C in the dark and His-166 mutants that exhibit "inverted signaling" (mediating repellent instead of the normally attractant response to orange light) inverted the light effect on the cross-linking rate of I64C. Secondary structure prediction of HtrI indicates a coiled coil structure in the cytoplasmic region following TM2, a dimerization domain found in a diverse group of proteins. We conclude that 1) HtrI exists as a dimer both in the absence of SRI and in the SRI-HtrI complex, 2) binding of SRI in the dark increases reactivity of the two cysteines at position 64 in the dimer by increasing their proximity or mobility, 3) light activation of wild-type SRI further increases their reactivity, 4) His-166 replacements in the SRI receptor have conformational effects on the structure of HtrI at position 64, and 5) inverted signaling by His-166 mutants likely results from an inverted conformational change at this region induced by SRI photoactivation.

Analysis of protein structure in intact cells: crosslinking in vivo between introduced cysteines in the transmembrane domain of a bacterial chemoreceptor

Oxidative crosslinking of cysteines introduced by site-specific mutagenesis is a powerful tool for structural analysis of proteins, but the approach has been limited to studies in vitro. We recently reported that intact cells of Escherichia coli could be treated with Cu(II)-(o-phenanthroline)3 or molecular iodine in a way that left unperturbed flagellar function or general chemotactic response, yet crosslinks were quantitatively formed between select cysteines in adjoining transmembrane helices of chemoreceptor Trg. This suggested that oxidative crosslinking might be utilized for structural analysis in vivo. Thus, we used our comprehensive collection of Trg derivatives, each containing a single cysteine at one of the 54 positions in the two transmembrane segments of the receptor monomer to characterize patterns of crosslinking in vivo and in vitro for this homodimeric protein. We found that in vivo crosslinking compared favorably as a technique for structural analysis with the more conventional in vitro approach. Patterns of crosslinking generated by oxidation treatments of intact cells indicated extensive interaction of transmembrane segment 1 (TM1) with its homologous partner (TM1') in the other subunit and a more distant placement of TM2 and TM2', the same relationships identified by crosslinking in isolated membranes. In addition, the same helical faces for TM1-TM1' interaction and TM2-TM2' orientation were identified in vivo and in vitro. The correspondence of the patterns also indicates that structural features identified by analysis of in vitro crosslinking are relevant to the organization of the chemoreceptor in its native environment, the intact, functional cell. It appears that the different features of the two functionally benign treatments used for in vivo oxidations can provide insights into protein dynamics.

Detecting the conformational change of transmembrane signaling in a bacterial chemoreceptor by measuring effects on disulfide cross-linking in vivo

Transmembrane signaling by bacterial chemoreceptors is thought to involve relative movement among the four transmembrane helices of the homodimer. We assayed that movement by measuring effects of ligand occupancy on rates of oxidative cross-linking between cysteines introduced into neighboring helices of the transmembrane domain of chemoreceptor Trg from Escherichia coli. Measurements were done on chemoreceptors in their native environment, intact cells that were motile and chemotactically responsive. Receptor occupancy did not appear to cause drastic rearrangement of the four-helix structure since, among 67 cysteine pairs tested, the same 19 exhibited oxidative cross-linking in the presence or absence of saturating chemoattractant. However, occupancy did cause subtle changes that were detected as effects on rates of cross-linking. Among the seven disulfides appropriate for measurements of initial rates of formation, ligand occupancy had significant and different effects on all three cross-links that connected the two helices within a subunit but had minimal effects on the four that spanned the packing interface between subunits. This constitutes direct evidence that the conformational change of transmembrane signaling involves significant movement within a subunit and minimal movement between subunits, a pattern deduced from several previous studies and now documented directly. Among possible modes of movement between the two helices of a subunit, axial sliding of one helix relative to the other was the conformational change that best accounted for the observed effects on cross-linking.

Molecular mechanism of transmembrane signaling by the aspartate receptor: a model

The aspartate receptor of bacterial chemotaxis is representative of a large class of membrane-spanning receptors found in prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. These receptors, which regulate histidine kinase pathways and possess two putative transmembrane helices per subunit, appear to control a wide variety of cellular processes. The best characterized subgroup of the two-helix receptor class is the homologous family of chemosensory receptors from Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, including the aspartate receptor. This receptor binds aspartate, an attractant, in the periplasmic compartment and undergoes an intramolecular, transmembrane conformational change, thereby modulating the autophosphorylation rate of a bound histidine kinase in the cytoplasm. Here, we analyze recent results from x-ray crystallographic, solution 19F NMR, and engineered disulfide studies probing the aspartate-induced structural change within the periplasmic and transmembrane regions of the receptor. Together, these approaches provide evidence that aspartate binding triggers a "swinging-piston" displacement of the second membrane-spanning helix, which is proposed to communicate the signal across the bilayer.

The N-terminal cytoplasmic tail of the aspartate receptor is not essential in signal transduction of bacterial chemotaxis

To determine the role in transmembrane signaling of the N-terminal peptide of the first transmembrane region of the aspartate receptor, it was subjected to extensive mutagenesis. Drastic changes did not alter the chemotactic ability of the receptor to aspartate significantly. Thus the cytoplasmic N terminus of the first transmembrane region does not play an essential role in transmembrane signaling, and the entire signal that is transmitted to the cytoplasmic domain must be sent through the second transmembrane region. This eliminates the models requiring an interaction of this N-terminal peptide with the remaining cytoplasmic portion of the receptor.

Lock on/off disulfides identify the transmembrane signaling helix of the aspartate receptor

The aspartate receptor of the bacterial chemotaxis pathway regulates the autophosphorylation rate of a cytoplasmic histidine kinase in response to ligand binding. The transmembrane signal, which is transmitted from the periplasmic aspartate-binding domain to the cytoplasmic regulatory domain, is carried by an intramolecular conformational change within the homodimeric receptor structure. The present work uses engineered cysteines and disulfide bonds to probe the nature of this conformational change, focusing in particular on the role of the second transmembrane alpha-helix. Altogether 26 modifications, consisting of 13 cysteine pairs and the corresponding disulfide bonds, have been introduced into the contacts between the second transmembrane helix and adjacent helices. The effects of these modifications on the transmembrane signal have been quantified by in vitro assays which measure (i) ligand binding, (ii) receptor-mediated regulation of kinase activity, and (iii) receptor methylation. All three parameters are observed to be highly sensitive to perturbations of the second transmembrane helix. In particular, 13 of the 26 modifications (6 cysteine pairs and 7 disulfides) significantly increase or decrease aspartate affinity, while 15 of the 26 modifications (6 cysteine pairs and 10 disulfides) destroy transmembrane kinase regulation. Importantly, 3 of the perturbing disulfides are found to lock the receptor in the "on" or "off" signaling state by covalently constraining the second transmembrane helix, demonstrating that it is possible to use engineered disulfides to lock the signaling function of a receptor protein. A separate aspect of the study probes the thermal motions of the second transmembrane helix: 4 disulfides designed to trap large amplitude twisting motions are observed to disrupt function but form readily, suggesting that the helix is mobile. Together the results support a model in which the second transmembrane helix is a mobile signaling element responsible for communicating the transmembrane signal.

Transmembrane signaling characterized in bacterial chemoreceptors by using sulfhydryl cross-linking in vivo

Transmembrane signaling by bacterial chemoreceptors is thought to involve conformational changes within a stable homodimer. We investigated the functional consequences of constraining movement between pairs of helices in the four-helix structure of the transmembrane domain of chemoreceptor Trg. Using a family of cysteine-containing receptors, we identified oxidation treatments for intact cells that catalyzed essentially complete sulfhydryl cross-linking at selected positions and yet left flagellar and sensory functions largely unperturbed. Constraining movement by cross-links between subunits had little effect on tactic response, but constraining movement between transmembrane segments of the monomer drastically reduced function. We deduce that transmembrane signaling requires substantial movement between transmembrane helices of a monomer but not between interacting helices across the interface between subunits.

Transmembrane signalling and the aspartate receptor

BACKGROUND

The aspartate receptor is a transmembrane protein that mediates bacterial chemotaxis. The structures of the periplasmic ligand-binding domain reveal a dimer, each subunit with four alpha-helix bundles, with aspartate binding to one of two sites at the subunit interface. The transmembrane regions of the receptor were not included in these structures.

RESULTS

To investigate the structure of the transmembrane region, we have made a mutant protein with two cross-links, restraining the subunit-subunit interface on both sides of the membrane, and have made an energy-minimized model of the transmembrane region. We demonstrate that the transmembrane helices form a coiled coil which extends from the periplasmic subunit through the membrane. We have constructed a model of the ligand-binding domains with the amino-terminal transmembrane helices.

CONCLUSIONS

We draw three conclusions from our model. Firstly, the interface between receptor subunits in the intact receptor consists of an uninterrupted coiled coil. Secondly, this structure rules out several postulated mechanisms of signalling. Thirdly, side chain packing constraints within the helices dictate that local structural changes must be small, but are propagated over a long distance rather than being dissipated locally. Low energy changes in the conformation of side chains are a probable mechanism of signal transduction in the aspartate receptor.

Specificity and promiscuity in membrane helix interactions

The membrane-spanning portions of many integral membrane proteins consist of one or a number of transmembrane α-helices, which are expected to be independently stable on thermodynamic grounds. Side-by-side interactions between these transmembrane α-helices are important in the folding and assembly of such integral membrane proteins and their complexes. In considering the contribution of these helix–helix interactions to membrane protein folding and oligomerization, a distinction between the energetics and specificity should be recognized. A number of contributions to the energetics of transmembrane helix association within the lipid bilayer will be relatively non-specific, including those resulting from charge–charge interactions and lipid–packing effects. Specificity (and part of the energy) in transmembrane α-helix association, however, appears to rely mainly upon a detailed stereochemical fit between sets of dynamically accessible states of particular helices. In some cases, these interactions are mediated in part by prosthetic groups.

"Frozen" dynamic dimer model for transmembrane signaling in bacterial chemotaxis receptors

The crystal structures of the ligand binding domain of a bacterial aspartate receptor suggest a simple mechanism for transmembrane signaling by the dimer of the receptor. On ligand binding, one domain rotates with respect to the other, and this rotational motion is proposed to be transmitted through the membrane to the cytoplasmic domains of the receptor.