Site-directed mutagenesis, fluorescence, and two-dimensional NMR studies on microenvironments of effector region aromatic residues of human c-Ha-Ras protein

Tyrosyl phosphorylation of KRAS stalls GTPase cycle via alteration of switch I and II conformation

Deregulation of the RAS GTPase cycle due to mutations in the three RAS genes is commonly associated with cancer development. Protein tyrosine phosphatase SHP2 promotes RAF-to-MAPK signaling pathway and is an essential factor in RAS-driven oncogenesis. Despite the emergence of SHP2 inhibitors for the treatment of cancers harbouring mutant KRAS, the mechanism underlying SHP2 activation of KRAS signaling remains unclear. Here we report tyrosyl-phosphorylation of endogenous RAS and demonstrate that KRAS phosphorylation via Src on Tyr32 and Tyr64 alters the conformation of switch I and II regions, which stalls multiple steps of the GTPase cycle and impairs binding to effectors. In contrast, SHP2 dephosphorylates KRAS, a process that is required to maintain dynamic canonical KRAS GTPase cycle. Notably, Src- and SHP2-mediated regulation of KRAS activity extends to oncogenic KRAS and the inhibition of SHP2 disrupts the phosphorylation cycle, shifting the equilibrium of the GTPase cycle towards the stalled ‘dark state’.

Deregulation of the RAS GTPase cycle due to mutations in RAS genes is commonly associated with cancer development. Here authors use NMR and mass spectrometry to shows that KRAS phosphorylation via Src alters the conformation of switch I and II regions and thereby impacts the GTPase cycle.

Ras Conformational Ensembles, Allostery, and Signaling

Ras proteins are classical members of small GTPases that function as molecular switches by alternating between inactive GDP-bound and active GTP-bound states. Ras activation is regulated by guanine nucleotide exchange factors that catalyze the exchange of GDP by GTP, and inactivation is terminated by GTPase-activating proteins that accelerate the intrinsic GTP hydrolysis rate by orders of magnitude. In this review, we focus on data that have accumulated over the past few years pertaining to the conformational ensembles and the allosteric regulation of Ras proteins and their interpretation from our conformational landscape standpoint. The Ras ensemble embodies all states, including the ligand-bound conformations, the activated (or inactivated) allosteric modulated states, post-translationally modified states, mutational states, transition states, and nonfunctional states serving as a reservoir for emerging functions. The ensemble is shifted by distinct mutational events, cofactors, post-translational modifications, and different membrane compositions. A better understanding of Ras biology can contribute to therapeutic strategies.

RGK family G-domain:GTP analog complex structures and nucleotide-binding properties

The RGK family of small G-proteins, including Rad, Gem, Rem1, and Rem2, is inducibly expressed in various mammalian tissues and interacts with voltage-dependent calcium channels and Rho kinase. Many questions remain regarding their physiological roles and molecular mechanism. Previous crystallographic studies reported RGK G-domain:guanosine di-phosphate structures. To test whether RGK proteins undergo a nucleotide-induced conformational change, we determined the crystallographic structures of Rad:GppNHp and Rem2:GppNHp to 1.7 and 1.8 Å resolutions, respectively. Also, we characterized the nucleotide-binding properties and conformations for Gem, Rad, and several structure-based mutants using fluorescence spectroscopy. The results suggest that RGK G-proteins may not behave as Ras-like canonical nucleotide-induced molecular switches. Further, the RGK proteins have differing structures and nucleotide-binding properties, which may have implications for their varied action on effectors.

An economical method for producing stable-isotope labeled proteins by the E. coli cell-free system

Improvement of the cell-free protein synthesis system (CF) over the past decade have made it one of the most powerful protein production methods. The CF approach is especially useful for stable-isotope (SI) labeling of proteins for NMR analysis. However, it is less popular than expected, partly because the SI-labeled amino acids used for SI labeling by the CF are too expensive. In the present study, we developed a simple and inexpensive method for producing an SI-labeled protein using Escherichia coli cell extract-based CF. This method takes advantage of endogenous metabolic conversions to generate SI-labeled asparagine, glutamine, cysteine, and tryptophan, which are much more expensive than the other 16 kinds of SI-labeled amino acids, from inexpensive sources, such as SI-labeled algal amino acid mixture, SI-labeled indole, and sodium sulfide, during the CF reaction. As compared with the conventional method employing 20 kinds of SI-labeled amino acids, highly enriched uniform SI-labeling with similar labeling efficiency was achieved at a greatly reduced cost with the newly developed method. Therefore, our method solves the cost problem of the SI labeling of proteins using the CF.

Reversible movement of switch 1 loop of myosin determines actin interaction

The conserved switch 1 loop of P-loop NTPases is implicated as a central element that transmits information between the nucleotide-binding pocket and the binding site of the partner proteins. Recent structural studies have identified two states of switch 1 in G-proteins and myosin, but their role in the transduction mechanism has yet to be clarified. Single tryptophan residues were introduced into the switch 1 region of myosin II motor domain and studied by rapid reaction methods. We found that in the presence of MgADP, two states of switch 1 exist in dynamic equilibrium. Actin binding shifts the equilibrium towards one of the MgADP states, whereas ATP strongly favors the other. In the light of electron cryo-microscopic and X-ray crystallographic results, these findings lead to a specific structural model in which the equilibrium constant between the two states of switch 1 is coupled to the strength of the actin-myosin interaction. This has implications for the enzymatic mechanism of G-proteins and possibly P-loop NTPases in general.

Improving cell-free protein synthesis for stable-isotope labeling

Cell-free protein synthesis is suitable for stable-isotope labeling of proteins for NMR analysis. The Escherichia coli cell-free system containing potassium acetate for efficient translation (KOAc system) is usually used for stable-isotope labeling, although it is less productive than other systems. A system containing a high concentration of potassium L-glutamate (L-Glu system), instead of potassium acetate, is highly productive, but cannot be used for stable-isotope labeling of Glu residues. In this study, we have developed a new cell-free system that uses potassium D-glutamate (D-Glu system). The productivity of the D-Glu system is approximately twice that of the KOAc system. The cross peak intensities in the 1H-15N HSQC spectrum of the uniformly stable-isotope labeled Ras protein, prepared with the D-Glu system, were similar to those obtained with the KOAc system, except that the Asp intensities were much higher for the protein produced with the D-Glu system. These results indicate that the D-Glu system is a highly productive cell-free system that is especially useful for stable-isotope labeling of proteins.

Structure of a transient intermediate for GTP hydrolysis by ras

The flexibility of the conserved 57DTAGQ61 motif is essential for Ras proper cycling in response to growth factors. Here, we increase the flexibility of the 57DTAGQ61 motif by mutating Gln61 to Gly. The crystal structure of the RasQ61G mutant reveals a new conformation of switch 2 that bears remarkable structural homology to an intermediate for GTP hydrolysis revealed by targeted molecular dynamics simulations. The mutation increased retention of GTP and inhibited Ras binding to the catalytic site, but not to the distal site of Sos. Most importantly, the thermodynamics of RafRBD binding to Ras are altered even though the structure of switch 1 is not affected by the mutation. Our results suggest that interplay and transmission of structural information between the switch regions are important factors for Ras function. They propose that initiation of GTP hydrolysis sets off the separation of the Ras/effector complex even before the GDP conformation is reached.

Fluorescently labelled guanine nucleotide binding proteins to analyse elementary steps of GAP-catalysed reactions

Downregulation of small guanine nucleotide-binding proteins (GNBPs) requires the interaction with their corresponding GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs), which increase the slow intrinsic GTPase reaction by several orders of magnitude. On the basis of the structure of H-Ras in complex with the catalytic domain of p120-GAP, we have developed a set of site-specifically labelled Ras-variants, one of which turned out to be particularly sensitive for studying the interaction with Ras-specific GAPs. This specific fluorescent reporter group and the use of manganese to increase the rate of the chemical reaction step allowed us to identify differences in the rate-limiting step of either the GAP-334 or NF1-333 catalyzed reaction. The assay was also applied to study the interaction of the Ras-related protein Rap1B with Rap1GAP, for which no detailed kinetic analysis was available. Single-turnover experiments of this reaction show that the low affinity of the complex (50 microM) is due to a slow association rate as well as a fast dissociation rate. RapGAP promotes AlFx binding to Rap1B, even though it does not contain a catalytic arginine. The rate-limiting step of the RapGAP catalysed reaction is release of inorganic phosphate, which is about five times slower than the chemical cleavage step. Our data reveal marked differences in GAP/target interactions even between closely related systems and suggest that the fluorescent reporter group method might be generally applicable to many other GNBPs and their cognate GAPs.

Rap-specific GTPase activating protein follows an alternative mechanism

Rap1 is a small GTPase that is involved in signal transduction cascades. It is highly homologous to Ras but it is down-regulated by its own set of GTPase activating proteins (GAPs). To investigate the mechanism of the GTP-hydrolysis reaction catalyzed by Rap1GAP, a catalytically active fragment was expressed in Escherichia coli and characterized by kinetic and mutagenesis studies. The GTPase reaction of Rap1 is stimulated 10(5)-fold by Rap1GAP and has a k(cat) of 6 s(-1) at 25 degrees C. The catalytic effect of GAPs from Ras, Rho, and Rabs depends on a crucial arginine which is inserted into the active site. However, all seven highly conserved arginines of Rap1GAP can be mutated without dramatically reducing V(max) of the GTP-hydrolysis reaction. We found instead two lysines whose mutations reduce catalysis 25- and 100-fold, most likely by an affinity effect. Rap1GAP does also not supply the crucial glutamine that is missing in Rap proteins at position 61. The Rap1(G12V) mutant which in Ras reduces catalysis 10(6)-fold is shown to be efficiently down-regulated by Rap1GAP. As an alternative, Rap1(F64A) is shown by kinetic and cell biological studies to be a Rap1GAP-resistant mutant. This study supports the notion of a completely different mechanism of the Rap1GAP-catalyzed GTP-hydrolysis reaction on Rap1.

The Ras mutant D119N is both dominant negative and activated

The introduction of mutation D119N (or its homolog) in the NKxD nucleotide binding motif of various Ras-like proteins produces constitutively activated or dominant-negative effects, depending on the system and assay. Here we show that Ras(D119N) has an inhibitory effect at a cell-specific concentration in PC12 and NIH 3T3 cells. Biochemical data strongly suggest that the predominant effect of mutation D119N in Ras-a strong decrease in nucleotide affinity-enables this mutant (i) to sequester its guanine nucleotide exchange factor, as well as (ii) to rapidly bind GTP, independent of the regulatory action of the exchange factor. Since mutation D119N does not affect the interaction between Ras and effector molecules, the latter effect causes Ras(D119N) to act as an activated Ras protein at concentrations higher than that of the exchange factor. In comparison, Ras(S17N), which also shows a strongly decreased nucleotide affinity, does not bind to effector molecules. These results point to two important prerequisites of dominant-negative Ras mutants: an increased relative affinity of the mutated Ras for the exchange factor over that for the nucleotide and an inability to interact with the effector or effectors. Remarkably, the introduction of a second, partial-loss-of-function, mutation turns Ras(D119N) into a strong dominant-negative mutant even at high concentrations, as demonstrated by the inhibitory effects of Ras(E37G/D119N) on nerve growth factor-mediated neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells and Ras(T35S/D119N) on fetal calf serum-mediated DNA synthesis in NIH 3T3 cells. Interpretations of these results are discussed.

Transient kinetic studies on the interaction of Ras and the Ras-binding domain of c-Raf-1 reveal rapid equilibration of the complex

Transient kinetic methods have been used to analyze the interaction between the Ras-binding domain (RBD) of c-Raf-1 and a complex of H-Ras and a GTP analogue. The results obtained show that the binding is a two-step process, with an initial rapid equilibrium step being followed by an isomerization reaction occurring at several hundred per second. The reversal of this step determines the rate constant for dissociation, which is on the order of 10 s-1. The lifetime of the complex is therefore on the order of 50-100 ms, which is much shorter than the lifetime of GTP at the active site of H-Ras as determined by the intrinsic GTPase reaction. This suggests that multiple interactions of a single activated Ras molecule and Raf can occur, the number being limited by the competing interaction with GAP. The GDP complex of H-Ras binds more than 2 orders of magnitude more weakly than the GTP-analogue complex, mainly due to a significant weakening of the initial binding equilibrium reaction in the GDP state, thereby avoiding even short-lived recruitment of Raf to the plasma membrane by the inactive Ras form.

Crystal structures of the small G protein Rap2A in complex with its substrate GTP, with GDP and with GTPgammaS

The small G protein Rap2A has been crystallized in complex with GDP, GTP and GTPgammaS. The Rap2A-GTP complex is the first structure of a small G protein with its natural ligand GTP. It shows that the hydroxyl group of Tyr32 forms a hydrogen bond with the gamma-phosphate of GTP and with Gly13. This interaction does not exist in the Rap2A-GTPgammaS complex. Tyr32 is conserved in many small G proteins, which probably also form this hydrogen bond with GTP. In addition, Tyr32 is structurally equivalent to a conserved arginine that binds GTP in trimeric G proteins. The actual participation of Tyr32 in GTP hydrolysis is not yet clear, but several possible roles are discussed. The conformational changes between the GDP and GTP complexes are located essentially in the switch I and II regions as described for the related oncoprotein H-Ras. However, the mobile segments vary in length and in the amplitude of movement. This suggests that even though similar regions might be involved in the GDP-GTP cycle of small G proteins, the details of the changes will be different for each G protein and will ensure the specificity of its interaction with a given set of cellular proteins.

Regional polysterism in the GTP-bound form of the human c-Ha-Ras protein

The backbone 1H, 13C, and 15N resonances of the c-Ha-Ras protein [a truncated version consisting of residues 1-171, Ras(1-171)] bound with GMPPNP (a slowly hydrolyzable analogue of GTP) were assigned and compared with those of the GDP-bound Ras(1-171). The backbone amide resonances of amino acid residues 10-13, 21, 31-39, 57-64, and 71 of Ras(1-171).GMPPNP, but not those of Ras(1-171).GDP, were extremely broadened, whereas other residues of Ras(1-171).GMPPNP exhibited amide resonances nearly as sharp as those of Ras(1-171). GDP. The residues exhibiting the extreme broadening, except for residues 21 and 71, are localized in three functional loop regions [loops L1, L2 (switch I), and L4 (switch II)], which are involved in hydrolysis of GTP and interactions with other proteins. From the temperature and magnetic field strength dependencies of the backbone amide resonance intensities, the extreme broadening was ascribed to the exchange at an intermediate rate on the NMR time scale. It was shown that the Ras(1-171) protein bound with GTP or GTPgammaS (another slowly hydrolyzable analogue of GTP) exhibits the same type of broadening. Therefore, it is a characteristic feature of the GTP-bound form of Ras that the L1, L2, and L4 loop regions, but not other regions, are in a rather slow interconversion between two or more stable conformers. This phenomenon, termed a "regional polysterism", of these loop regions may be related with their multifunctionality: the GTP-dependent interactions with several downstream target groups such as the Raf and RalGDS families and also with the GTPase activating protein (GAP) family. In fact, the binding of Ras(1-171).GMPPNP with the Ras-binding domain (residues 51-131) of c-Raf-1 was shown to eliminate the regional polysterism nearly completely. It was indicated, therefore, that each target/regulator selects its appropriate conformer among those presented by the "polysteric" binding interface of Ras. As the downstream target groups exhibit no apparent sequence homology to each other, it is possible that one target group prefers a conformer different from that preferred by another group. The involvement of loop L1 in the regional polysterism might suggest that the negative regulators, GAPs, bind to the polysteric binding interface (loops L2 and L4) of Ras and cooperatively select a conformer suitable for transition of the GTPase catalytic center, involving loops L1 and L4, into the highly active state.

Conformational and dynamic differences between N-ras P21 bound to GTPgammaS and to GMPPNP as studied by NMR

Heteronuclear-edited proton-detected NMR methods are used to study the nucleotide-dependent conformational changes between the GMPPNP form of human N-ras P21 as compared to GDP and GTPgammaS forms. Full-length N-ras P21 was also compared with protein truncated beyond residue 167, to search for interaction points between the more invariant part of the protein and the variable C-terminal section. In both cases, the reporter was the 15N-H 2D spectrum of aspartate amide groups labeled with 15N. Small truncation-induced changes were seen in the spectrum at the resonances of Asp-54, -108, and -109 which are not far from the C-terminal and, surprisingly, at Asp-57 which is more remote. The spectrum obtained for the GMPPNP-ligated form is similar to that of the GTPgammaS form, except that peaks of several residues are weak at low temperature, and strongly temperature-dependent in their intensity, and a new resonance appears at 15 degrees C and above. The observations are discussed in terms of a two-state model for the GMPPNP-ligated protein, previously proposed by Geyer et al. [(1996) Biochemistry 35, 10308-10320].

Conformational transitions in p21ras and in its complexes with the effector protein Raf-RBD and the GTPase activating protein GAP

31P NMR revealed that the complex of p21ras with the GTP analog GppNHp.Mg2+ exists in two conformational states, states 1 and 2. In wild-type p21ras the equilibrium constant K1(12) between the two states is 1.09. The population of these states is different for various mutants but independent of temperature. The activation enthalpy delta H ++ and activation entropy delta S ++ for the conformational transitions were determined by full-exchange matrix analysis for wild-type p21ras and p21ras(S65P). For the wild-type protein one obtains delta H ++ = 89 +/- 2 kJ mol-1 and delta S ++ = 102 +/- 20 J mol-1 K-1 and for the mutant protein delta H ++ = 93 +/- 7 kJ mol-1 and delta S ++ = 138 +/- 30 J mol-1 K-1. The study of various p21ras mutants suggests that the two states correspond to different conformations of loop L2, with Tyr-32 in two different positions relative to the bound nucleotide. High-field EPR at 95 GHz suggest that the observed conformational transition does not directly influence the coordination sphere of the protein-bound metal ion. The influence of this transition on loop L4 was studied by 1H NMR with mutants E62H and E63H. There was no indication that L4 takes part in the transition described in L2, although a reversible conformational change could be induced by decreasing the pH value. The exchange between the two states is slow on the NMR time scale (< 10 s-1): at approximately pH 5 the population of the two states is equal. The interaction of p21ras-triphosphate complexes with the Ras-binding domain (RBD) of the effector protein c-Raf-1, Raf-RBD, and with the GTPase activating protein GAP was studied by 31P NMR spectroscopy. In complex with Raf-RBD the second conformation of p21ras (state 2) is stabilized. In this conformation Tyr-32 is located in close proximity to the phosphate groups of the nucleotide, and the beta-phosphate resonance is shifted upfield by 0.7 ppm. Spectra obtained in the presence of GAP suggest that in the ground state GAP does not interact directly with the nucleotide bound to p21ras and does not induce larger conformational changes in the neighborhood of the nucleotide. The experimental data are consistent with a picture where GAP accelerates the exchange process between the two states and simultaneously increases the population of state 1 at higher temperature.

p120 Ras GTPase-activating protein interacts with Ras-GTP through specific conserved residues

Previous structural studies of RasGAP have failed to clearly localize sites of Ras interaction to individual amino acids. Hypothesizing that sites of interaction with Ras-GTP would be conserved, 11 of the most highly conserved amino acid residues of RasGAP were changed by mutation. Each mutant protein was purified as a glutathione S-transferase catalytic domain fusion and analyzed for protein stability, Ras GTPase stimulating activity, affinity for Ras-GTP, and when possible, secondary structure. The majority of conserved positions were found to be important structurally but with no direct role in Ras interactions. However, Arg786, Lys831, and Arg925 were observed to be essential for binding to Ras-GTP but not for protein structure. RasGAP residues 890-902 (block 3A) were observed to be homologous to residues 1540-1552 of the yeast adenylyl cyclase with amino acid substitutions in both regions resulting in increased affinity for Ras. This is the first example of a conserved Ras interaction motif in distinct Ras effector proteins. Our data are supportive of a model for GAP/Ras-GTP association in which the conserved, positively charged Arg786, Lys831, and Arg925 residues form salt bridges with the conserved, negatively charged residues in the Ras effector loop.

Differential structural requirements for interaction of Ras protein with its distinct downstream effectors

Ras proteins have multiple effectors of distinct structures that do not share significant structural homology at their Ras interaction sites. To prove possible differences in their recognition mechanisms of Ras, we screened 44 human Ha-Ras proteins carrying mutations in the effector region and its flanking sequences for interaction with human Raf-1, Schizosaccharomyces pombe Byr2, and Saccharomyces cerevisiae adenylyl cyclase. The Ras binding specificities were largely shared between Raf-1 and Byr2 although Ras mutants, Y32F, T35S, and A59E, had their affinities for Byr2 selectively reduced. The only exception was Ras(D38N), which lost the ability to bind Raf-1 while retaining the activity to bind Byr2 and complement the Byr2- phenotype of S. pombe. On the other hand, adenylyl cyclase had quite distinct requirements for Ras residues; mutations P34G and T58A selectively abolished the ability to bind and activate it without considerably affecting the interaction with Raf-1 and Byr2. Y32F mutant, whereas losing the ability to activate Raf-1 and Byr2, could activate adenylyl cyclase efficiently. In addition, V45E mutation was found to impair the ability of Ras to activate both Raf-1 and adenylyl cyclase without significantly affecting the binding affinities for them. These results demonstrate that significant differences exist in the recognition mechanisms by which the three effector molecules associate with Ras and suggest that a region of Ras required for activation of the effectors in general may exist separately from that for binding the effectors.

Ras binding to a C-terminal region of GAP

Using fluorescence spectroscopy we have identified a binding region for Ras on the GTPase activating protein (GAP) lying within residues 715-753. A synthetic peptide Y922, corresponding to residues 716-753 of GAP binds to wild type Ras showing 3.3-fold higher affinity for the GTP- over the GDP-bound forms of Ras. Binding is stabilised by Mg2+, although Y922 does not stimulate the GTPase activity of Ras. Peptide binding to the Y32A and Y40F Ras mutants showed equal affinity for both GDP- and GTP-bound forms, with binding to Y32A.GDP abolished in the absence of Mg2+. These results suggest that Y922 mimics the in vivo interactions shown by the intact p120GAP protein and provide the first direct demonstration of Ras interaction with GAP in the region 715-753.

A constitutive effector region on the C-terminal side of switch I of the Ras protein

The "switch I" region (Asp30-Asp38) of the Ras protein takes remarkably different conformations between the GDP- and GTP-bound forms and coincides with the so-called "effector region." As for a region on the C-terminal side of switch I, the V45E and G48C mutants of Ras failed to promote neurite outgrowth of PC12 cells (Fujita-Yoshigaki, J., Shirouzu, M., Koide, H., Nishimura, S., and Yokoyama, S. (1991) FEBS Lett. 294, 187-190). In the present study, we performed alanine-scanning mutagenesis within the region Lys42-Ile55 of Ras and found that the K42A, I46A, G48A, E49A, and L53A mutations significantly reduced the neurite-inducing activity. This is an effector region by definition, but its conformation is known to be unaffected by GDP-->GTP exchange. So, this region is referred to as a "constitutive" effector (Ec) region, distinguished from switch I, a "switch" effector (Es) region. The Ec region mutants exhibiting no neurite-inducing activity were found to be correlatably unable to activate mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase in PC12 cells. Therefore, the Ec region is essential for the MAP kinase activation in PC12 cells, whereas mutations in this region only negligibly affect the binding of Ras to Raf-1 (Shirouzu, M., Koide, H., Fujita-Yoshigaki, J., Oshio, H., Toyama, Y., Yamasaki, K., Fuhrman, S. A., Villafranca, E., Kaziro, Y., and Yokoyama, S. (1994) Oncogene 9, 2153-2157).

Quantitative analysis of the complex between p21ras and the Ras-binding domain of the human Raf-1 protein kinase

The Ras-binding domain (RBD) of human Raf-1 was purified from Escherichia coli, and its interaction with Ras was investigated. Its dissociation constant with p21ras.guanyl-5'-yl imidodiphosphate was found to be 18 nM, with a slight preference for H-ras over K- and N-ras. Oncogenic forms bind with slightly lower affinity. The affinity of RBD for effector region mutants or the GDP-bound form of p21ras is in the micromolar range, which means that 100-fold lower affinity is not sufficient for signal transduction. The rate of the GTPase of p21ras is not modified by RBD. Since P(i) release is found not to be rate limiting, the Ras-Raf signal of the cell may be terminated by the intrinsic GTPase of p21ras.