Resonance energy transfer between the active sites of rabbit muscle creatine kinase: analysis by steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence

A FLIM Microscopy Based on Acceptor-Detected Förster Resonance Energy Transfer

Time-resolved donor-detected Förster resonance energy transfer (trDDFRET) allows the observation of molecular interactions of dye-labeled biomolecules in the ∼10-100 Å region. However, we can observe longer-range interactions when using time-resolved acceptor-detected FRET (trADFRET), since the signal/noise ratio can be improved when observing the acceptor emission. Therefore, we propose a new methodology based on trADFRET to construct a new fluorescence lifetime microscopy (FLIM-trADFRET) technique to observe biological machinery in the range of 100-300 Å in vivo, the last frontier in biomolecular medicine. The integrated trADFRET signal is extracted in such a way that noise is canceled, and more photons are collected, even though trADFRET and trDDFRET have the same rate of transfer. To assess our new methodology, proof of concept was demonstrated with a set of well-defined DNA scaffolds.

Proteolytic susceptibility of creatine kinase isozymes and arginine kinase

The time course and dose-response to proteolysis of three dimeric isozymes of creatine kinase, CK-MM (muscle), CK-BB (brain), and CK-MB (heart) and the homologous monomer, arginine kinase were compared. Chymotrypsin and trypsin cause a rapid and significant loss of intact CK-BB, but limited hydrolysis of CK-MM. After 1h of hydrolysis by chymotrypsin, 80% of CK-MM is intact as judged by quantification of monomers after electrophoresis in sodium dodecyl sulfate. While 50% of the intact monomers of CK-MB remain under these conditions, no CK-BB monomers are detected. These results indicate that treatment with chymotrypsin leads to a CK-MB devoid of the B-subunit. When treated with trypsin for 1h, CK-MM is totally resistant to hydrolysis and all CK-BB is highly degraded. However, CK-MB exhibits approximately 90% intact monomers, indicating survival of intact B-subunit in CK-MB. This suggests that heterodimerization of a B-subunit with an M-subunit may have a protective effect against hydrolysis by trypsin. In view of the considerably larger number of potentially tryptic sensitive sites on the muscle isozyme, the resistance of CK-MM and susceptibility of CK-BB dimers to trypsin implies that differences in subunit tertiary structure are a factor in proteolysis of the homodimeric isozymes. Arginine kinase is rapidly degraded by trypsin, but is minimally affected by chymotrypsin. The finding that both a monomeric (arginine kinase) and dimeric (CK-BB) phosphagen kinase are highly susceptible to proteolysis by trypsin indicates that quaternary structure is not, in and of itself, an advantage in resistance to proteolysis. Since both arginine kinase and muscle creatine kinase are resistant to chymotryptic hydrolysis, it seems unlikely that in general, the increased packing density, which may result from dimerization can account for the stability of CK-MM towards trypsin.

Studies on the stability of creatine kinase isozymes

Research on the stabilizing properties of creatine kinase isozymes CK-BB, CK-MB, and CK-MM showed that minor alteration of their sequence and structure influenced their stability significantly. An analysis of the stability of the isozymes in storage after freeze drying indicates that creatine kinase isozymes are all in monomer form because of the loss of subunit interactions. Freeze-drying leads to the oxidization of CK-BB and rearrangement of CK-MB. There are also differences in the unfolding of the isozymes in urea. CK-BB and CK-MB are unfolded in lower urea concentrations than CK-MM. Differences in the thermal unfolding were also examined by differential scanning calorimetry. This paper discusses the potential biological significance of these results.

Crystal structure of brain-type creatine kinase at 1.41 A resolution

Excitable cells and tissues like muscle or brain show a highly fluctuating consumption of ATP, which is efficiently regenerated from a large pool of phosphocreatine by the enzyme creatine kinase (CK). The enzyme exists in tissue--as well as compartment-specific isoforms. Numerous pathologies are related to the CK system: CK is found to be overexpressed in a wide range of solid tumors, whereas functional impairment of CK leads to a deterioration in energy metabolism, which is phenotypic for many neurodegenerative and age-related diseases. The crystal structure of chicken cytosolic brain-type creatine kinase (BB-CK) has been solved to 1.41 A resolution by molecular replacement. It represents the most accurately determined structure in the family of guanidino kinases. Except for the N-terminal region (2-12), the structures of both monomers in the biological dimer are very similar and closely resemble those of the other known structures in the family. Specific Ca2+-mediated interactions, found between two dimers in the asymmetric unit, result in structurally independent heterodimers differing in their N-terminal conformation and secondary structure. The high-resolution structure of BB-CK presented in this work will assist in designing new experiments to reveal the molecular basis of the multiple isoform-specific properties of CK, especially regarding different subcellular locations and functional interactions with other proteins. The rather similar fold shared by all known guanidino kinase structures suggests a model for the transition state complex of BB-CK analogous to the one of arginine kinase (AK). Accordingly, we have modeled a putative conformation of CK in the transition state that requires a rigid body movement of the entire N-terminal domain by rms 4 A from the structure without substrates.

Subunit conformation and dynamics in a heterodimeric protein: studies of the hybrid isozyme of creatine kinase

Several physical properties of creatine kinase (EC 2.7.3.2) isozymes MM (CK-MM, muscle-type) and BB (CK-BB, brain-type), both homodimers, and isozyme MB (CK-MB), a heterodimer, were compared to determine how formation of the hybrid modifies subunit conformation and dynamics. Circular dichroic spectra revealed additional alpha-helical content for the hybrid isozyme. Double-beam absorption difference spectra between CK-MB and a stoichiometric mixture of CK-MM and CK-BB revealed decreased exposure of intrinsic chromophores in the hybrid. The relative intensity of the intrinsic fluorescence of CK-MB was between the two homodimers, but was 16% closer to the less fluorescent CK-MM. Steady state anisotropy spectra and decay of the anisotropy of CK derivatized on a single subunit with the fluorescent sulfhydryl reagent 5-[2-(iodoacetyl)amino-ethyl]aminonaphthalene-1-sulfonate indicated that the derivatized sites are more flexible in the heterodimer. The slow component in the anisotropy decay suggests that hybridization results in a small increase in the packing density or contraction of overall conformation of the B-subunit. The KM for MgATP with singly derivatized CK-MB was the same as the KM for the native enzyme. However, derivatization of a single subunit caused the Vmax to decrease by greater than 50%, which indicates that subunit-subunit interactions may modulate the activity of CK. A model for assembly of CK-MB is proposed which includes subunit characteristics more similar to those found in the muscle-type homodimer than in the brain-type homodimer and increased flexibility of the active site domain of both subunits.

Purification, characterization, and hydrodynamic properties of arginine kinase from gulf shrimp (Penaeus aztecus)

Arginine kinase from the tail muscle of the Gulf shrimp (Penaeus aztecus) was purified to apparent homogeneity, using a rapid, high-yield method. The protein exhibits a molecular weight of 40 kDa according to the methods of gel filtration and gel electrophoresis in sodium dodecyl sulfate, also indicating that arginine kinase from shrimp is a monomer. The amino acid content of arginine kinase from shrimp is similar to arginine kinases from several species and to creatine kinase from rabbit muscle. Arginine kinase derivatized at the reactive sulfhydryl with 2-(4'-(iodoacetamido)anilino)naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid exhibits significant changes in fluorescence anisotropy only in the presence of the guanidino substrate and the so-called "dead-end complex" containing arginine + MgADP. Several compounds structurally similar to arginine, e.g., ornithine do not interact with arginine kinase, suggesting a narrow specificity for substrate binding. The most suitable description of the decay of the fluorescence of arginine kinase derivatized with 5-[(((acetyl)-amino)ethyl)amino]naphthalene-1-sulfonate (AEDANS-AK), from among discrete and distributed models, is a triple exponential discrete decay. The presence of the dead-end complex only marginally increases the rate of decay, but significantly shifts the magnitude of the preexponentials (amplitudes) between the two major decay components. One interpretation of these results is that multiple conformational isomers may occur, in which the relative concentrations are dependent upon the presence of the dead-end complex. Measurement of the time-dependent anisotropy decay of AEDANS-AK reveals a two-term decay law with rotational correlation times of 0.88 and 15.2 ns. The slower component is close to the theoretical value of 16.7 ns for an isotropic rotator of the molecular mass of arginine kinase. This finding suggests that the overall conformation of arginine kinase may differ considerably from the prolate ellipsoidal subunits of the functionally analogous creatine kinase.

An equilibrium study of the dependence of secondary and tertiary structure of creatine kinase on subunit association

Several physical properties of dimeric creatine kinase in increasing concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride (GDN/HCl) were evaluated and correlated with degree of subunit dissociation, determined by isozyme competitive hybridization. Three distinct stages were observed that correlated with phases before, during and after dissociation. In 0.2 M GDN/HCl, before significant dimer dissociation, creatinine kinase has 75% of its original activity, and exhibits only small decreases in circular dichroism, intrinsic fluorescence and emission maximum. The spectral characteristics of creatine kinase (CK) derivatized with 5-[(((2-iodoacetyl)amino)ethyl)amino]naphthalene-1- sulfonate (AEDANS-CK) at the cysteine near the active site are suggestive of a slightly more non-polar environment. A decrease in steady-state anisotropy (0.140 to 0.132) was characterized by time-resolved methods. The slow component of the time-resolved anisotropy decay law, which reflects global protein rotation, is decreased only from 36.6 to 33.4 ns. The faster component decreases from 1.95 to 0.74 ns which suggests the active-site domain is more sensitive to conformation perturbation than the protein as a whole. Overall these observations suggest the subunits within the dimeric state are rather stable in dilute denaturant, but undergo a minor contraction in conformation. The region of the active site, as reported by the extrinsic fluorophore, is less polar but apparently more flexible in dilute denaturant. Between 0.5 M and 1 M GDN/HCl, most of the dimers dissociate, 63% of helical content is lost and inactivation is complete. The intrinsic fluorescence shifts 8 nm to the red and increases by 35%, indicating exposure of tryptophans to solvent and release of quenching, perhaps between residues on separate subunits. Over the same denaturant range, the spectral characteristics and lifetime of AEDANS-CK suggests less exposure of the active site to solvent. Time-resolved anisotropy measurements show that the sharp decrease in steady-state anisotropy to 0.086 is due to a decrease in macromolecular rotation to 22 ns. This may represent the rotational correlation time of a relatively intact subunit, and suggests limited subunit unfolding accompanying dissociation. Dissociation is complete in 1.5 M GDN/HCl. The subunits still retain 20% helical content in 2 M denaturant and not until 5 M GDN/HCl is all helical structure eliminated. Above 2 M GDN/HCl, AEDANS-CK exhibits sharp decreases in steady-state anisotropy, fluorescence lifetime and the long-lived component in the time-resolved anisotropy decay law. These results reveal a catastrophic loss of tertiary structure by the subunits and may define the physical properties of the random coil.

Energy-transfer measurements of the Cys35-Cys84 distance in bovine cardiac troponin C

Bovine cardiac troponin C (cTnC) has cysteine residues located in the non-functional Ca(2+)-binding loop I (Cys-35) and at the N-terminal end of the central helix (Cys-84) near site II, the regulatory Ca(2+)-binding site. Recently, we reported that the excimer fluorescence resulting from the dimerization of adjacent pyrene groups attached to the two Cys residues is reduced by Ca2+ binding to site II (Liou, Y.-M. and Fuchs, F. (1992) Biophys. J. 61, 892-901). This result would suggest that Ca2+ binding causes a separation of the two Cys residues, a conclusion at variance with predictions from molecular modeling studies (Herzberg, O., Moult, J. and James, M.N.G. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 2638-2644). Alternatively, the reduction in excimer fluorescence could be accounted for by an immobilization of the pyrene attached to Cys-84 by a Ca(2+)-induced hydrophobic pocket. To arrive at a more definitive interpretation of these experiments, we carried out steady-state fluorescence resonance energy-transfer measurements of the Cys35-Cys84 distance. We used three different donor-acceptor pairs: 2-(4'-(iodoacetamido)anilino) naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid (IAANS) and 4-dimethylamino-phenylazophenyl-4-maleimide (DABMI), IAANS and N-(4-(dimethyl-amino)-3,5-dinitrophenyl) maleimide (DDPM), and 5-((((2-iodoacetyl)amino)ethyl)amino)naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (IAEDANS) and DDPM. At pCa 8.0, the distances were 23.8, 21.0, and 22.0 A with the donor-acceptor pairs, IAANS-DABMI, IAANS-DDPM and IAEDAN-DDPM, respectively. At pCa 4.0, the distances were 25.8, 24.1 and 21.2 A. The distances at pCa 8 and pCa 4.0 were not significantly altered when labeled cTnC was complexed with cardiac troponin I (cTnI). Thus, Ca2+ has little, if any, effect on the Cys35-Cys84 distance. These results are consistent with a model in which Ca2+ binding induces a separation of helices B and C from helix D, without any relative movement of the two N-terminal Ca(2+)-binding domains.

Heterogeneous flexibilities of the active site domains of homodimeric creatine kinase: effect of substrate

(1) A single subunit and both subunits of creatine kinase from rabbit muscle was derivatized at the active site with the thiol-specific reagent 2-(4'-(iodoacetamido)anilino)-naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid. (2) The highly biphasic kinetics of the labelling reaction were characterized from measurements of activity, steady-state fluorescence and anisotropy. Derivatization of one thiol and both thiols resulted in 48 and 100% inhibition, respectively. The dead-end complex (DEC), consisting of creatine, MgADP and protein, inhibited the rate, but not the extent, of derivatization and resulted in a 2-fold increase in fluorescence. (3) The fluorescence of singlylabelled (1AANS/CK) and doublylabelled (2AANS/CK) protein exhibited three discrete lifetime components or a two-term Lorentzian distribution. The decay laws for both preparations were not remarkably different, except that, unlike 1AANS/CK, the longer decay component of 2AANS/CK was distributed, which narrowed in the presence of the DEC. (4) The steady-state anisotropies of 1AANS/CK and 2AANS/CK at 25 degrees C were 0.305 and 0.240, respectively. It was concluded that the fast reacting site was immobile and the slow reacting site was flexible. Kinetics of labelling and anisotropy emission spectra indicated that the DEC immobilized the flexible site. (5) The anisotropy decay of 1AANS/CK with and without the DEC was described by a rotational correlation time of about 50 ns, characteristic of the molecular rotation of the CK dimer. At least two terms were required to fit the data for 2AANS/CK, indicating additional segmental motion which was eliminated upon formation of the DEC. (6) Energy transfer from tryptophans to AANS indicated movement of approx. 3 A accompanying formation of the DEC.

Conformational heterogeneity of creatine kinase determined from phase resolved fluorometry

Fluorescence lifetimes of dimeric rabbit muscle creatine kinase specifically dansylated at both active sites and the homologous monomeric lobster muscle arginine kinase singly dansylated were determined using phase-modulation methods with global analysis of overdetermined data sets. For both proteins, the data is adequately described by three discrete exponential decays or a Lorentzian double distributed decay. Analogue phase resolved spectroscopy also reveals the presence of at least two distinct fluorophore domains for the dansyl moieties of creatine kinase. The model fluorophore, dansyllysine, exhibits a monoexponential decay with a value that is highly solvent dependent. Because the monomeric arginine kinase exhibits essentially the same decay law as doubly derivatized dimeric creatine kinase, it is proposed that the multiple lifetimes of creatine kinase reflect two or more isomeric dimeric states and not subunit asymmetry within a conformationally homogeneous dimeric population. Exposure of arginine kinase to 6 M guanidinium chloride results in a shift to shorter lifetimes and narrowing of the lifetime distributions. Creatine kinase displays a small narrowing of the distribution, but little change in fractional populations or lifetimes. These results suggest the presence of structural elements resistant to denaturation. The longest lifetime component in the triexponential discrete decay law of doubly dansylated creatine kinase is totally unquenched by acrylamide, whereas the two shorter lifetime components exhibit limited dynamic quenching. Steady-state quenching by acrylamide is significant and reveals a sharp distinction between accessible and non accessible dansyl groups. The major mechanism for interaction between the dansyl moieties and acrylamide is, atypically, static quenching. The results are consistent with two dansyl domains, one accessible and hydrophilic according to lifetime values and the other inaccessible and hydrophobic in solvent characteristics.Energy transfer between the dansyl group and the eight tryptophan residues of dimeric creatine kinase give similar results(~ 35%) from measurements of lifetimes, steady-state donor quenching and sensitized acceptor emission. The similarity suggests that the overall flexibility of the dimeric protein is limited. The occurrence of multiple conformers of muscle creatine kinase provides an explanation for several previous observations, most notably the structural origins for compartmentation of the muscle isozyme observed in the myofibril.

A physicochemical comparison of the isozymes of creatine kinase from rabbit brain and muscle

A comparison of specific structural features of creatine kinase from rabbit muscle and brain was undertaken to determine if the observed isozyme specific differences in catalytic cooperativity are related to conformational differences, particularly differences in packing density. The intrinsic fluorescence of the brain isozyme is 2-fold higher than the muscle isozyme. In the denatured state, both proteins display the characteristic red shift in emission maximum; however, the emission intensity of the brain isozyme increases only 5% upon denaturation compared to nearly 100% increase for the muscle protein. The fluorescence lifetimes are 2.65 ns (67%) and 0.48 ns for native muscle enzyme and 4.38 ns (65%) and 0.80 ns for brain enzyme. Upon denaturation, the lifetimes are 3.98 ns (77%) and 0.99 ns for muscle protein and 3.82 ns (79%) and 0.86 ns for brain protein. Stern-Volmer plots of quenching by acrylamide are essentially the same for both native isozymes indicating that the differences of the intrinsic fluorescence of the native proteins are not due to differences in solvent accessibility. The spectral and lifetime differences in the isozymes in the native state and changes accompanying denaturation are consistent with the occurrence of energy transfer in native muscle isozyme. The rotational correlation times of 5-[2-(iodoacetyl)aminoethyl]aminonaphthalene-1-sulfonate conjugated proteins, derivatized at the active site reactive thiol, are best described by two term decay laws. The slower rotations, 45.1 ns (75%) and 40.6 ns (71%) reflect overall macromolecular rotation for the muscle and brain isozymes, respectively. The faster motions, 2.4 ns for muscle isozyme and 0.4 ns for the brain isozyme, are attributed to the probe or probe associated segmental motions and indicate these motions are more restricted in the muscle protein. Reactivity of creatine kinase (2.5-10 microM) with the amino-specific reagent trinitrobenzene sulfonate (0.4-2 mM) was analyzed by pseudo-first-order and second order models, neither of which was adequate for the entire range of data. However, in every case, the rate constants were faster for brain creatine kinase but the extent of reaction was greater for muscle creatine kinase. The faster initial reactivity of the brain isozyme is consistent with greater accessibility for lysine derivatization.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Resonance energy transfer between the active sites of creatine kinase from rabbit brain

Resonance energy transfer was measured between the active site domains of the brain isozyme of creatine kinase (CK-BB). The reactive thiol near the active sites, one on each subunit of the dimeric protein, was derivatized using 5-[2-[iodoacetyl)amino)ethyl]aminonaphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (AED), 2-[4'-iodoacetamidoanilino]naphthalene-6-sulfonic acid (AANS) and 5-iodoacetamidofluorescein (AF). Suitable donor/acceptor protein conjugated hybrids were prepared by controlled kinetics producing CK-BB-AED/AF and CK-BB-AANS/AF. Transfer efficiencies, measured from the quenching of the donor lifetime and steady-state sensitized acceptor emission, ranged from 0.10 to 0.17. From determination of the donor/acceptor overlap integrals, donor quantum yields and attempts to delimit the orientation factor using steady-state and phase-resolved anisotropy measurements, it was found that a suitable estimate of the range between the active sites was between 45 and 57 A. This range is similar to that reported previously for the muscle isozyme of creatine kinase (Grossman, S.H. (1989) Biochemistry 28, 4894-4902) but is a significantly greater distance than detected for the hybrid, myocardial specific isozyme (Grossman, S.H. (1983) Biochemistry 22, 5369-5375).

Is the subunit the minimal function unit of creatine kinase?

The dimeric rabbit muscle isozyme of creatine kinase (MM) is modified by iodoacetamide to produce the inactive dimer (M'M') and then hybridized with native dimeric brain isozyme (BB). The hybrid enzyme (M'B), as isolated by PAGE, has the same Km for both ATP and creatine but half the specific activity of the brain isozyme (BB). Likewise, the hybrid of the modified brain with the native muscle isozyme (MB') has half the activity of the native muscle enzyme. The M'B, MB' and MB hybrid dimers all have essentially the same electrophoretic properties, and their intrinsic fluorescence and CD spectra in the far-ultraviolet region are very similar to those of the homodimers MM and BB. Similar results were obtained for the hybrid (M"B) containing the muscle enzyme subunit modified at both the thiol group with iodoacetamide and the Trp residue with dimethyl(2-hydroxy-5-nitrobenzyl)sulfonium bromide and the native brain enzyme submit. The above results suggest strongly the independent catalytic function of the subunit of creatine kinase.