Allosteric control in Limulus polyphemus hemocyanin: functional relevance of interactions between hexamers

Differential regulation of hexameric and dodecameric hemocyanin from A. leptodactylus

The oxygen binding properties of hemocyanins are regulated on a short time scale by effectors such as l-lactate, urate and protons, and on longer time scales by expression of the different types of subunits. For Astacus leptodactylus it was shown previously that acclimation to higher temperatures leads to increased levels of a 6-meric hemocyanin species, whereas at lower temperatures the 12-meric form prevails. Here we show that the temperature dependence of the two forms supports the idea, that the maintenance of high affinity towards oxygen is the driving force for the differential expression of these hemocyanins. Furthermore, the two different types of hemocyanin differ not only in the affinity to oxygen, but also with respect to their interaction with l-lactate: while the 12-meric form displays a normal shift in oxygen affinity upon the addition of l-lactate this allosteric regulation is absent in the 6-meric form. Exclusive binding of l-lactate to the 12-meric form was supported by isothermal titration calorimetry. These results indicate that l-lactate binds either at the interface between the two hexamers or at subunit α' which is responsible for the formation of the 12-mers and is not present in the 6-meric form. Urate has a comparable effect on the oxygen affinity of 6-meric and 12-meric forms and also binds to a similar extent to the oxygenated state as determined by isothermal titration calorimetry. Thus, urate and l-lactate do not seem to share the same binding sites. Interestingly, urate binding sites with no allosteric effect seem to exist, which is unusual. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Oxygen Binding and Sensing Proteins.

Molecular and functional characterization of hemocyanin of the giant African millipede, Archispirostreptus gigas

In contrast to other terrestrial arthropods where gaseous O2 that fuels aerobic metabolism diffuses to the tissues in tracheal tubes, and most other metazoans where O2 is transported to tissues by circulating respiratory proteins, the myriapods (millipedes and centipedes) strikingly have tracheal systems as well as circulating hemocyanin (Hc). In order to elucidate the evolutionary origin and biological significance of millipede Hc we report the molecular structure (subunit composition and amino acid sequence) of multimeric (36-mer) Hc from the forest-floor dwelling giant African millipede Archispirostreptus gigas and its allosteric oxygen binding properties under various physico-chemical conditions. A. gigas Hc consists of only a single subunit type with differential glycosylation. Phylogenic analysis reveals that millipede Hc is a sister group to centipede HcA, which supports an early divergence of distinct Hc subunits in myriapods and an ancient origin of multimeric Hcs. A. gigas Hc binds O2 with a high affinity and shows a strong normal Bohr effect. O2 binding is moreover modulated by Ca2+ ions, which increase the O2 affinity of the Hc in the T (tense; deoxygenated) as well as the R (relaxed; oxygenated) states, and by (L)-lactate, which modulates Hc-O2 affinity by changing the allosteric equilibrium constant, L. Cooperativity in O2-binding at half O2-saturation (n50) is pH-dependent and maximal at pH ~7.4 and the number of interacting O2 binding sites (q) is markedly increased by binding Ca2+. The data is discussed in the light of the role of mutually supplementary roles of Hc and the tracheal system for tissue O2 supply.

Limulus polyphemus Hemocyanin: 10 Å Cryo-EM Structure, Sequence Analysis, Molecular Modelling and Rigid-body Fitting Reveal the Interfaces Between the Eight Hexamers

The blue copper protein hemocyanin from the horseshoe crab Limulus polyphemus is among the largest respiratory proteins found in nature (3.5 MDa) and exhibits a highly cooperative oxygen binding. Its 48 subunits are arranged as eight hexamers (1x6mers) that form the native 8x6mer in a nested hierarchy of 2x6mers and 4x6mers. This quaternary structure is established by eight subunit types (termed I, IIA, II, IIIA, IIIB, IV, V, and VI), of which only type II has been sequenced. Crystal structures of the 1x6mer are available, but for the 8x6mer only a 40 A 3D reconstruction exists. Consequently, the structural parameters of the 8x6mer are not firmly established, and the molecular interfaces between the eight hexamers are still to be defined. This, however, is crucial for understanding how allosteric transitions are mediated between the different levels of hierarchy. Here, we show the 10 A structure (FSC(1/2-bit) criterion) of the oxygenated 8x6mer from cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and single-particle analysis. Moreover, we show its molecular model as obtained by DNA sequencing of subunits II, IIIA, IV and VI, and molecular modelling and rigid-body fitting of all subunit types. Remarkably, the latter enabled us to improve the resolution of the cryo-EM structure from 11 A to the final 10 A. The 10 A structure allows firm assessment of various structural parameters of the 8x6mer, the 4x6mer and the 2x6mer, and reveals a total of 46 inter-hexamer bridges. These group as 11 types of interface: four at the 2x6mer level (II-II, II-IV, V-VI, IV-VI), three form the 4x6mer (V-V, V-VI, VI-IIIB/IV/V), and four are required to assemble the 8x6mer (IIIA-IIIA, IIIA-IIIB, II-IV, IV-IV). The molecular model shows the amino acid residues involved, and reveals that several of the interfaces are intriguingly histidine-rich and likely to transfer allosteric signals between the different levels of the nested hierarchy.

Bohr-effect and buffering capacity of hemocyanin from the tarantula E. californicum

A previous report showed that binding of oxygen to the 24-meric hemocyanin from E. californicum does not correlate linearly with the release of protons as known from hemoglobin. However, this unusual complex phenomenological observation could not be explained at that time. Here, I present a full analysis of the thermodynamic coupling between protons and oxygen for the 24-meric tarantula hemocyanin in Ringer-solution based on the Nested-MWC-model. A strategy is presented which allows to reduce the number of free parameters when fitting the model to the data by including explicitly the equilibrium constants for binding of protons to the different conformations. The results show that the Nested-MWC-model presents a good description of the cooperative and allosteric properties of spider hemocyanin also under physiological conditions and additional constraints imposed by proton-binding data. The analysis allowed to estimate the average number of allosteric proton-binding sites per subunit and the corresponding pK for each conformation. Furthermore, an estimate of the number and affinity of proton buffering binding sites could be given. Approximately 80% of all proton-binding sites are non-allosteric buffering binding sites. The results obtained in this study allow to predict the relative contribution of the four different conformations under conditions found in vivo. The conformational distribution indicates that the conformation with the highest proton affinity (tR) might be important for the proton transport in the hemolymph.

The allosteric effector l-lactate induces a conformational change of 2x6-meric lobster hemocyanin in the oxy state as revealed by small angle x-ray scattering

Hemocyanins are multisubunit respiratory proteins found in many invertebrates. They bind oxygen highly cooperatively. However, not much is known about the structural basis of this behavior. We studied the influence of the physiological allosteric effector l-lactate on the oxygenated quaternary structure of the 2x6-meric hemocyanin from the lobster Homarus americanus employing small angle x-ray scattering (SAXS). The presence of 20 mm l-lactate resulted in different scattering curves compared with those obtained in the absence of l-lactate. The distance distribution functions p(r) indicated a more compact molecule in presence of l-lactate, which is also reflected in a reduction of the radius of gyration by about 0.2 nm (3%). Thus, we show for the first time on a structural basis that a hemocyanin in the oxy state can adopt two different conformations. This is as predicted from the analysis of oxygen binding curves according to the "nesting" model. A comparison of the distance distribution functions p(r) obtained from SAXS with those deduced from electron microscopy revealed large differences. The distance between the two hexamers as deduced from electron microscopy has to be shortened by up to 1.1 nm to agree well with the small angle x-ray curves.

Two types of urate binding sites on hemocyanin from the crayfish Astacus leptodactylus: an ITC study

The oxygen binding behaviour of hemocyanins from Crustacea is regulated by small organic compounds such as urate and L-lactate. We investigated the binding characteristics of urate and the related compound caffeine to the 2 x 6-meric hemocyanin of A. leptodactylus under fully oxygenated conditions employing isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). An analysis of urate and caffeine binding based on a model of n identical binding sites resulted in approximately four binding sites for caffeine and eight for urate. This result suggests that the binding process for these effectors is more complex than this most simple model. Therefore, we introduced a number of alternative models. Displacement experiments helped to select the appropriate model. Based on these experiments, at least two different types of binding sites for urate and caffeine exist on the 2 x 6-meric hemocyanin of A. leptodactylus. The two binding sites differ strongly in their specificity towards the two analogues. It can be hypothesized that two different subunit types (beta and gamma) are responsible for the two types of binding sites.

Allostery in very large molecular assemblies

In contrast to small allosteric systems (like hemoglobin) those containing very large numbers (n) of binding sites never exhibit cooperativity (as measured by the Hill coefficient, nH) even approaching the potential limit, n. The reason for this appears to be that in such macromolecules the cooperative unit always represents some sub-structure of the entire structure. On the other hand, it is frequently observed that such sub-structures, when isolated, do not exhibit cooperativity at all. This paper describes studies of some molluscan hemocyanins that explore this apparent anomaly. It is concluded that it is the higher order structure of the molecule that provides a framework within which the sub-structures may exhibit their allosteric behavior.

Small-angle X-ray scattering reveals differences between the quaternary structures of oxygenated and deoxygenated tarantula hemocyanin

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) curves have been recorded for the oxygenated and deoxygenated states of the 4 x 6-meric hemocyanin from the tarantula Eurypelma californicum. A comparison of the curves shows that the quaternary structures of the two states are different by three criteria, which all indicate that the hemocyanin is less compact in the oxygenated compared to the deoxygenated form: (a) The radius of gyration is 8.65 +/- 0.05 nm for the deoxy- and 8.80 +/- 0.05 nm for the oxy-form. (b) The maximum particle dimension amounts to 25.0 +/- 0.5 nm for the deoxy- and to 27.0 +/- 0.5 nm for the oxy-form. (c) A dip in the intramolecular distance distribution function p(r) is more pronounced and shifted to larger distances in the oxy-form. The p(r) functions based on SAXS measurements were compared to p(r) functions deduced from published electron microscopical images of three different 4 x 6-meric hemocyanins from closely related species. The p(r) functions of SAXS and electron microscopy were similar in one case, whereas in the other two cases the distance between the two 12-meric half-molecules had to be changed by 1-1.5 nm to obtain good agreement. The differences between the p(r) functions of oxygenated and deoxygenated 4 x 6-meric tarantula hemocyanin are much larger than one would expect from a comparison of X-ray structures of the oxygenated and deoxygenated states of a closely related 6-meric hemocyanin. Thus, the conformational changes upon oxygenation occur at various levels of the quaternary structure, as postulated by hierarchical theories of allosteric interactions.

Reformulation of thermodynamic systems with aggregation and theoretical methods for the analysis of ligand binding in proteins with monomer-multimer equilibria

The reformulation of complex thermodynamic systems is a useful tool for their analysis as demonstrated by the theoretical analysis of conformationally mediated cooperativity in a dimeric protein. Many chemical and biochemical systems exhibit monomer-multimer equilibria, behavior not addressed in the original reformulation. A method for reformulating such systems, and the mathematical methods necessary for relating alternative models, are therefore developed. The basic principles of the reformulation are illustrated on homodimeric and heterodimeric systems. The mathematical methods necessary to relate alternative models are then derived from probabilistic considerations. Higher-order models (more interacting subunits) are related to lower-order models (fewer interacting subunits) by a polynomial expansion of the sum of species in the lower-order model to give the sum of species in the higher-order model. Using these methods, the equations describing the ligand binding behavior of a homomeric monomer-dimer system are derived. These methods are also used to relate the two alternative models for cooperativity for a homotetrameric protein; one model where the dimer is the cooperative unit and the other where the tetramer is the cooperative unit.

Inversion of the Bohr effect upon oxygen binding to 24-meric tarantula hemocyanin

The Bohr effect describes the usually negative coupling between the binding of oxygen and the binding of protons to respiratory proteins. It was first described for hemoglobin and provides for an optimal oxygen supply of the organism under changing physiological conditions. Our measurements of both oxygen and proton binding to the 24-meric tarantula hemocyanin establish the unusual case where a respiratory protein binds protons at low degrees of oxygenation but releases protons at high degrees of oxygenation. In contrast to what is observed with hemoglobin and other respiratory proteins, this phenomenon amounts to the inversion of the Bohr effect in the course of an oxygen-binding curve at a given pH value. Therefore, protons in spider blood can act either as allosteric activators or as allosteric inhibitors of oxygen binding, depending on the degree of oxygenation of hemocyanin. These functional properties of tarantula hemocyanin, which cannot be explained by classical allosteric models, require at least four different conformational states of the subunits. Inspection of the known x-ray structures of closely related hemocyanins suggests that salt bridges between completely conserved histidine and glutamate residues located at particular intersubunit interfaces are responsible for the observed phenomena.

Crystal structure of deoxygenated Limulus polyphemus subunit II hemocyanin at 2.18 A resolution: clues for a mechanism for allosteric regulation

The crystal structure of Limulus polyphemus subunit type II hemocyanin in the deoxygenated state has been determined to a resolution of 2.18 A. Phase information for this first structure of a cheliceratan hemocyanin was obtained by molecular replacement using the crustacean hemocyanin structure of Panulirus interruptus. The most striking observation in the Limulus structure is the unexpectedly large distance of 4.6 A between both copper ions in the oxygen-binding site. Each copper has approximate trigonal planar coordination by three histidine N epsilon atoms. No bridging ligand between the copper ions could be detected. Other important new discoveries are (1) the presence of a cis-peptide bond between Glu 309 and Ser 310, with the carbonyl oxygen of the peptide plane hydrogen bonded to the N delta atom of the copper B ligand His 324; (2) localization of a chloride-binding site in the interface between the first and second domain; (3) localization of a putative calcium-binding site in the third domain. Furthermore, comparison of Limulus versus Panulirus hemocyanin revealed considerable tertiary and quaternary rigid body movements, although the overall folds are similar. Within the subunit, the first domain is rotated by about 7.5 degrees with respect to the other two domains, whereas within the hexamer the major movement is a 3.1 degrees rotation of the trimers with respect to each other. The rigid body rotation of the first domain suggests a structural mechanism for the allosteric regulation by chloride ions and probably causes the cooperative transition of the hexamer between low and high oxygen affinity states. In this postulated mechanism, the fully conserved Phe49 is the key residue that couples conformational changes of the dinuclear copper site into movements of the first domain.

Role of oligomeric interactions in the cooperativity of crayfish hemocyanin

To examine the effect of interactions between the hexameric units in the dodecameric hemocyanin, crayfish (Procambarus clarki) hemocyanin was partially dissociated. Gel-filtration yielded fractions containing the undissociated dodecamer and a mixture of the hexamer and heptamer (referred to as 'half-dodecamer'). Their O2 equilibria were compared and were analyzed by curve fitting of cooperativity models. The partial dissociation of the dodecamer significantly lowered the cooperativity but little affected the O2 affinities. The O2 equilibrium of the half-dodecamer could be described by the two-state allosteric model of Monod-Wyman-Changeux on the assumption that the cooperative unit is composed of six subunits. We tested the applicability of allosteric models for the dodecamer that deal with the interactions between the hexamers. To reduce the arbitrariness of the fitting, we presumed that some parameters are equal to the two-state model parameters for the half-dodecamer. It was found that the 'nesting model', which assumes allosteric equilibria at two different hierarchical levels, could be applied successfully to the dodecamer.