Hydrogen exchange kinetics in a membrane protein determined by 15N NMR spectroscopy: use of the INEPT experiment to follow individual amides in detergent-solubilized M13 coat protein

Ultrastructural modeling of small angle scattering from photosynthetic membranes

The last decade has seen a range of studies using non-invasive neutron and X-ray techniques to probe the ultrastructure of a variety of photosynthetic membrane systems. A common denominator in this work is the lack of an explicitly formulated underlying structural model, ultimately leading to ambiguity in the data interpretation. Here we formulate and implement a full mathematical model of the scattering from a stacked double bilayer membrane system taking instrumental resolution and polydispersity into account. We validate our model by direct simulation of scattering patterns from 3D structural models. Most importantly, we demonstrate that the full scattering curves from three structurally typical cyanobacterial thylakoid membrane systems measured in vivo can all be described within this framework. The model provides realistic estimates of key structural parameters in the thylakoid membrane, in particular the overall stacking distance and how this is divided between membranes, lumen and cytoplasmic liquid. Finally, from fitted scattering length densities it becomes clear that the protein content in the inner lumen has to be lower than in the outer cytoplasmic liquid and we extract the first quantitative measure of the luminal protein content in a living cyanobacteria.

Impact of Differential Detergent Interactions on Transmembrane Helix Dimerization Affinities

Interactions between transmembrane (TM) helices play a critical role in the fundamental processes required for cells to communicate and exchange materials with their surroundings. Our understanding of the factors that promote TM helix interactions has greatly benefited from our ability to study these interactions in the solution phase through the use of membrane-mimetic micelles. However, less is known about the potential influence of juxtamembrane regions flanking the interacting TM helices that may modulate dimerization affinities, even when the interacting surface itself is not altered. To investigate this question, we used solution NMR to quantitate the dimerization affinity of the major coat protein from the M13 bacteriophage in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), a well-characterized model of a single-spanning self-associating TM protein. Here, we showed that a shorter construct lacking the N-terminal amphipathic helix has a higher dimerization affinity relative to that of the full-length protein, with no change in the helical structure between the monomeric and dimeric states in both cases. Although this translated into a 0.6 kcal/mol difference in free energy when the SDS solvent was approximated as a continuous phase, there were deviations from this model at high protein to detergent ratios. Instead, the equilibria were better fit to a model that treats the empty micelle as an active participant in the reaction, giving rise to standard free energies of association that were the same for both full-length and TM-segment constructs. According to this model, the higher apparent affinity of the shorter peptide could be completely explained by the enhanced detergent binding by the monomer relative to that bound by the dimer. Therefore, differential detergent binding between the monomeric and dimeric states provides a mechanism by which TM helix interactions can be modulated by noninteracting juxtamembrane regions.

pH-dependent random coil (1)H, (13)C, and (15)N chemical shifts of the ionizable amino acids: a guide for protein pK a measurements

The pK a values and charge states of ionizable residues in polypeptides and proteins are frequently determined via NMR-monitored pH titrations. To aid the interpretation of the resulting titration data, we have measured the pH-dependent chemical shifts of nearly all the (1)H, (13)C, and (15)N nuclei in the seven common ionizable amino acids (X = Asp, Glu, His, Cys, Tyr, Lys, and Arg) within the context of a blocked tripeptide, acetyl-Gly-X-Gly-amide. Alanine amide and N-acetyl alanine were used as models of the N- and C-termini, respectively. Together, this study provides an essentially complete set of pH-dependent intra-residue and nearest-neighbor reference chemical shifts to help guide protein pK a measurements. These data should also facilitate pH-dependent corrections in algorithms used to predict the chemical shifts of random coil polypeptides. In parallel, deuterium isotope shifts for the side chain (15)N nuclei of His, Lys, and Arg in their positively-charged and neutral states were also measured. Along with previously published results for Asp, Glu, Cys, and Tyr, these deuterium isotope shifts can provide complementary experimental evidence for defining the ionization states of protein residues.

Detection and characterization of serine and threonine hydroxyl protons in Bacillus circulans xylanase by NMR spectroscopy

Hydroxyl protons on serine and threonine residues are not well characterized in protein structures determined by both NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography. In the case of NMR spectroscopy, this is in large part because hydroxyl proton signals are usually hidden under crowded regions of (1)H-NMR spectra and remain undetected by conventional heteronuclear correlation approaches that rely on strong one-bond (1)H-(15)N or (1)H-(13)C couplings. However, by filtering against protons directly bonded to (13)C or (15)N nuclei, signals from slowly-exchanging hydroxyls can be observed in the (1)H-NMR spectrum of a uniformly (13)C/(15)N-labeled protein. Here we demonstrate the use of a simple selective labeling scheme in combination with long-range heteronuclear scalar correlation experiments as an easy and relatively inexpensive way to detect and assign these hydroxyl proton signals. Using auxtrophic Escherichia coli strains, we produced Bacillus circulans xylanase (BcX) labeled with (13)C/(15)N-serine or (13)C/(15)N-threonine. Signals from two serine and three threonine hydroxyls in these protein samples were readily observed via (3)JC-OH couplings in long-range (13)C-HSQC spectra. These scalar couplings (~5-7 Hz) were measured in a sample of uniformly (13)C/(15)N-labeled BcX using a quantitative (13)C/(15)N-filtered spin-echo difference experiment. In a similar approach, the threonine and serine hydroxyl hydrogen exchange kinetics were measured using a (13)C/(15)N-filtered CLEANEX-PM pulse sequence. Collectively, these experiments provide insights into the structural and dynamic properties of several serine and threonine hydroxyls within this model protein.

Structure, dynamics, and ionization equilibria of the tyrosine residues in Bacillus circulans xylanase

We have developed NMR spectroscopic methods to investigate the tyrosines within Bacillus circulans xylanase (BcX). Four slowly exchanging buried tyrosine hydroxyl protons with chemical shifts between 7.5 and 12.5 ppm were found using a long-range (13)C-HSQC experiment that exploits the (3)J(CH) coupling between the ring (1)H(η) and (13)C(ε) nuclei. The NMR signals from these protons were assigned via (13)C-tyrosine selective labelling and a suite of scalar and (13)C,(15)N-filtered/edited NOE correlation spectra. Of the fifteen tyrosines in BcX, only the buried Tyr79 and Tyr105 showed four distinct, rather than two averaged, signals from ring (13)C-(1)H pairs, indicative of slow flipping on the chemical shift timescale. Ring flipping rate constants of ~10 and ~0.2 s(-1) were measured for the two residues, respectively, using a (13)C longitudinal exchange experiment. The hydrogen bonding properties of the Tyr79 and Tyr105 hydroxyls were also defined by complementary NOE and J-coupling measurements. The (1)H(η) hydrogen-deuterium exchange rate constants of the buried tyrosines were determined from (13)C/(15)N-filtered spectra recorded as a function of pH. These exchange rate constants correspond to estimated protection factors of ~10(4)-10(8) relative to a random coil tyrosine. The phenolic sidechain pK (a) values were also measured by monitoring their pH-dependent (13)C(ζ) chemical shifts via (1)H(ε/δ)((13)C(ε))(13)C(ζ) correlation spectra. Exposed tyrosines had unperturbed pK (a) values of ~10.2, whereas buried residues remained predominantly neutral at or even above pH 11. Combined with selective isotope labelling, these NMR experiments should prove useful for investigating the structural and electrostatic properties of tyrosines in many interesting proteins.

Protein fluctuations as the possible origin of the thermal activation of rod photoreceptors in the dark

Efficient retinal photoisomerization, signal transduction, and amplification contribute to single-photon electrical responses in vertebrates visual cells. However, spontaneous discrete electrical signals arising in the dark, with identical intensity and time profiles as those generated by genuine single photons (dark events), limit the potential capability of the rod visual system to discern single photons from thermal noise. It is accepted that the light and the thermal activation of the rod photoreceptor rhodopsin (Rho) triggers the light and the dark events, respectively. However the activation barrier for the dark events (80-110 kJ/mol) appears to be only half of the barrier for light-dependent activation of Rho (> or =180 kJ/mol). On the basis of these observations, it has been postulated that both processes should follow different pathways, but the molecular mechanism for the thermal activation process still remains an open question and subject of debate. Here, performing infrared difference spectroscopy measurements, we found that the -OH group of Thr118 from bovine Rho exhibits a slow but measurable hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) under native conditions. Given the location of Thr118 in the X-ray structures, isolated from the aqueous phase and in steric contact with the buried retinal chromophore, we assume that a protein structural fluctuation must drive the retinal binding pocket (RBP) transiently open. We characterized the kinetics (rate and activation enthalpy) and thermodynamics (equilibrium constant and enthalpy) of this fluctuation from the global analysis of the HDX of Thr118-OH as a function of the temperature and pH. In parallel, using HPLC chromatography, we determined the kinetics of the thermal isomerization of the protonated 11-cis retinal in solution, as a model for retinal thermal isomerization in an open RBP. Finally, we propose a quantitative two-step model in which the dark activation of Rho is triggered by thermal isomerization of the retinal in a transiently opened RBP, which accurately reproduced both the experimental activation barrier and the rate of the dark events. We conclude that the absolute sensitivity threshold of our visual system is limited by structural fluctuations of the chromophore binding pocket rather than in the chromophore itself.

Protein-lipid interactions of bacteriophage M13 major coat protein

During the past years, remarkable progress has been made in our understanding of the replication cycle of bacteriophage M13 and the molecular details that enable phage proteins to navigate in the complex environment of the host cell. With new developments in molecular membrane biology in combination with spectroscopic techniques, we are now in a position to ask how phages carry out this delicate process on a molecular level, and what sort of protein-lipid and protein-protein interactions are involved. In this review we will focus on the molecular details of the protein-protein and protein-lipid interactions of the major coat protein (gp8) that may play a role during the infection of Escherichia coli by bacteriophage M13.

Deuterium/hydrogen exchange factors measured by solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy as indicators of the structure and topology of membrane proteins

Deuterium/hydrogen exchange factors (chi) were measured for the backbone amide sites of the membrane-bound forms of the 50-residue fd coat protein and the 23-residue magainin2 peptide in lipid micelles by solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. By combining kinetic and thermodynamic effects, deuterium/hydrogen exchange factors overcome the principal limitations encountered in the measurements of kinetic protection factors and thermodynamic fractionation factors for membrane proteins. The magnitudes of the exchange factors can be correlated with the structure and topology of membrane-associated polypeptides. In fd coat protein, residues in the transmembrane helix have exchange factors that are substantially smaller than those in the amphipathic surface helix or the loop connecting the two helices. For the amphipathic helical peptide, magainin2, the exchange factors of residues exposed to the solvent are appreciably larger than those that face the hydrocarbon portion of membrane bilayers. These examples demonstrate that deuterium/hydrogen exchange factors can be measured by solution NMR spectroscopy and used to identify residues in transmembrane helices as well as to determine the polarity of amphipathic helices in membrane proteins.

Solid-state NMR and hydrogen-deuterium exchange in a bilayer-solubilized peptide: structural and mechanistic implications

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange has been monitored by solid-state NMR to investigate the structure of gramicidin M in a lipid bilayer and to investigate the mechanisms for polypeptide insertion into a lipid bilayer. Through exchange it is possible to observe 15N-2H dipolar interactions in oriented samples that yield precise structural constraints. In separate experiments the pulse sequence SFAM was used to measure dipolar distances in this structure, showing that the dimer is antiparallel. The combined use of orientational and distance constraints is shown to be a powerful structural approach. By monitoring the hydrogen-deuterium exchange at different stages in the insertion of peptides into a bilayer environment it is shown that dimeric gramicidin is inserted into the bilayer intact, i.e., without separating into monomer units. The exchange mechanism is investigated for various sites and support for a relayed imidic acid mechanism is presented. Both acid and base catalyzed mechanisms may be operable. The nonexchangeable sites clearly define a central core to which water is inaccessible or hydroxide or hydronium ion is not even momentarily stable. This provides strong evidence that this is a nonconducting state.

fd coat protein structure in membrane environments: structural dynamics of the loop between the hydrophobic trans-membrane helix and the amphipathic in-plane helix

By performing multidimensional solution NMR experiments on micelle samples it was possible to determine the structure of the membrane-bound form of fd coat protein based on short-range distance and dihedral angle constraints using distance geometry and simulated annealing calculations. Its dynamics were described by 15N relaxation measurements (T1, T2, heteronuclear nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOE)) fitted with the Lipari-Szabo model-free formalism adapted for the transmembrane and in-plane helices of a membrane protein. The overall correlation time of the protein in micelles was found to be approximately 9 ns, and the local motion of each backbone N-H vector was described by an order parameter and an effective correlation time. The 50 residue protein has an amphipathic alpha-helix (residues 7 to 16) and a hydrophobic alpha-helix (residues 27 to 44), which were found to be approximately perpendicular on the basis of NOEs in the residues that connect the two helices. The residues connecting the helices are of particular interest in membrane proteins, and in this case the loop consists of two turns. The relaxation data show the presence of an extra motion in the amphipathic alpha-helix on the nanosecond timescale and additional flexibility of several residues in the loop connecting the two helices.

Structure and dynamics of the M13 coat signal sequence in membranes by multidimensional high-resolution and solid-state NMR spectroscopy

The polypeptide corresponding to the signal sequence of the M13 coat protein and the five N-terminal residues of the mature protein was prepared by solid-phase peptide synthesis with a 15N isotopic label at the alanine-12 position. Multidimensional solution NMR spectroscopy and molecular modeling calculations indicate that this polypeptide assumes helical conformations between residues 5 and 20, in the presence of sodium dodecylsulfate micelles. This is in good agreement with circular dichroism spectroscopic measurement, which shows an alpha-helix content of approximately 42%. The alpha-helix comprises an uninterrupted hydrophobic stretch of < or = 12 amino acids, which is generally believed to be too short for a stable transmembrane alignment in a biological bilayer. The monoexponential proton-deuterium exchange kinetics of this hydrophobic helical region is characterized by half-lives of 15-75 minutes (pH 4.2, 323 K). When the polypeptide is reconstituted into phospholipid bilayers, the broad anisotropy of the proton-decoupled 15N solid-state NMR spectroscopy indicates that the hydrophobic helix is immobilized close to the lipid bilayer surface at the time scale of 15N solid-state NMR spectroscopy (10(-4) seconds). By contrast, short correlation times, immediate hydrogen-deuterium exchange as well as nuclear Overhauser effect crosspeak analysis suggest that the N and C termini of this polypeptide exhibit a mobile random coil structure. The implications of these structural findings for possible mechanisms of membrane insertion and translocation as well as for membrane protein structure prediction algorithms are discussed.

Hydrogen bond stabilities in membrane-reconstituted alamethicin from amide-resolved hydrogen-exchange measurements

Amide-resolved hydrogen-deuterium exchange-rate constants were measured for backbone amides of alamethicin reconstituted in dioleoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles by an exchange-trapping method combined with high-resolution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. In vesicles containing alamethicin at molar ratios between 1:20 and 1:100 relative to lipid, the exchange-rate constants increased with increasing volume of the D20 buffer in which the vesicles were suspended, indicating that exchange under these conditions is dominated by partitioning of the peptide into the aqueous phase. This was supported by observation of a linear relationship between the exchange-rate constants for amides in membrane-reconstituted alamethicin and those for amides in alamethicin dissolved directly into D2O buffer. Significant protection of amides from exchange with D2O buffer in membrane-reconstituted alamethicin is interpreted in terms of stabilization by helical hydrogen bonding. Under conditions in which amide exchange occurred by partitioning of the peptide into solution, only lower limits for hydrogen-bond stabilities in the membrane were determined; all the potentially hydrogen-bonded amides of alamethicin are at least 1000-fold exchange protected in the membrane-bound state. When partitioning of alamethicin into the aqueous phase was suppressed by hydration of reconstituted vesicles in a limiting volume of water [D2O:dioleoylphosphatidylcholine:alamethicin; 220:1:0.05; (M:M:M)], the exchange-protection factors exhibited helical periodicity with highly exchange-protected, and less well-protected, amides on the nonpolar and polar helix faces, respectively. The exchange data indicate that, under the conditions studied, alamethicin adopts a stable helical structure in DOPC bilayers in which all the potentially hydrogen-bonded amides are stabilized by helical hydrogen bonds. The protection factors define the orientation of the peptide helix with respect to an aqueous phase, which is either the bulk solution or water within parallel or antiparallel transmembrane arrays of reconstituted alamethicin.

Methods to study membrane protein structure in solution

Membrane protein structure is difficult to determine by any technique. NMR spectroscopy of membrane proteins in solution can proceed using methods identical to those that have been successfully applied to numerous water-soluble proteins providing suitable solubilization conditions can be found. Organic solvents and small detergent micelles have correlation times short enough for structure determination based on 1H NOEs. Although it is difficult to generalize as each system is unique, organic solvents and micelles of strong detergents such as SDS are useful for amphiphilic peptides and small membrane proteins, whereas larger proteins need milder treatment to preserve the tertiary structure. Small unilamellar phospholipid vesicles are much too large for NOE-based structure determination, but they still fall under the domain of solution-state NMR and can be useful in certain circumstances.

Secondary structure of M13 coat protein in phospholipids studied by circular dichroism, Raman, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy

There is considerable uncertainty about the precise secondary structure adopted by the M13 coat protein when embedded in a phospholipid bilayer. Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy suggests that a major change in the structure of the coat protein occurs upon membrane insertion. It is reported that the structure of the protein in the membrane has only about 50% alpha-helix, the rest being mainly in a beta-sheet conformation, whereas the protein is almost completely alpha-helical when intact in the phage. In this study we have undertaken a spectroscopic analysis using Fourier transform infrared, Raman, and CD spectroscopy to characterize the secondary structure of M13 coat protein when present in membranes consisting of dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol and dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol. In sharp contrast to earlier CD studies, our results indicate that the coat protein in its membrane-embedded state has a very high alpha-helical content with virtually no beta-sheet structures present. This result indicates that the structures of the coat protein when intact in the phage or when embedded in the membrane are similar. Although our results differ from earlier CD studies, they are consistent with a recent NMR study, which showed that the M13 coat protein in sodium dodecyl sulfate micelles is primarily alpha-helical with no evidence for beta-sheet structure [Henry, G. D., & Sykes, B.D. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 5284-5297]. These results lead to the conclusion that the M13 coat protein can insert from the membrane-bound state into a virus particle with a similar secondary structure, without large energy implications.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Assignment of 1H, 15N, and backbone 13C resonances in detergent-solubilized M13 coat protein via multinuclear multidimensional NMR: a model for the coat protein monomer

The major coat protein (gVIIIp) of bacteriophage M13 complexed with SDS detergent micelles was used as a model system to study the lipid-bound conformation of the protein. Conditions were found that allowed the recording of good quality of NMR spectra. By making extensive use of three-dimensional heteronuclear (13C, 15N) NMR, we obtained a complete set of resonance assignments for 1HN, 1H alpha, 1H beta, 13C alpha, CO, and 15N and partially assigned the rest of the 1H spectrum. Analysis of NOE and chemical shift data reveals that gVIIIp is composed of two alpha-helical domains, one ranging from Pro-6 to Glu20 and the other ranging from Tyr-24 all the way to the C-terminus Ser-50. In contrast to the results reported by Henry and Sykes [Henry, G.D., & Sykes, B.D. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 5285-5297], at a high SDS to protein ratio the protein appears to be monomeric.

Conformational behavior of Escherichia coli OmpA signal peptides in membrane mimetic environments

Nuclear magnetic resonance and circular dichroism (CD) studies of isolated peptides corresponding to WT and mutant OmpA signal sequences are reported; all of the peptides adopt substantial amounts of alpha-helical structure both in 1:1 (v/v) trifluoroethanol (TFE)/water and in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles. In TFE/water, the helix begins after the positively charged N-terminal residues and is most stable in the hydrophobic core, which correlates with results obtained previously for other signal sequences. The helix is weaker between the hydrophobic core and the C-terminus; such a break in the helix appears to be common to other signal peptides studied previously and could be of functional importance. No clear correlation could be established between the helicity of the peptides in TFE/water and their in vivo activities. All the peptides have a higher alpha-helix content in SDS than in TFE/water, and there is a good correlation between helix content in SDS and in vivo activity. Helicity in SDS for the functional peptides increases both at the N-terminus and in the hydrophobic core, and is driven by a strong association of the core with the hydrophobic chains of the detergent. The extension of the helix toward the N-terminus may be a result of neutralization of the N-terminal positive charges by the headgroups of the micelles, which removes unfavorable electrostatic interactions with the helix dipole. All these comparisons were facilitated by the use of upfield shifts of H alpha protons in helical regions relative to random coil chemical shifts, which also yielded estimates of helical content that correlated well with the CD results.

NMR studies of the structure and dynamics of membrane-bound bacteriophage Pf1 coat protein

Filamentous bacteriophage coat protein undergoes a remarkable structural transition during the viral assembly process as it is transferred from the membrane environment of the cell, where it spans the phospholipid bilayer, to the newly extruded virus particles. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies show the membrane-bound form of the 46-residue Pf1 coat protein to be surprisingly complex with five distinct regions. The secondary structure consists of a long hydrophobic helix (residues 19 to 42) that spans the bilayer and a short amphipathic helix (residues 6 to 13) parallel to the plane of the bilayer. The NH2-terminus (residues 1 to 5), the COOH-terminus (residues 43 to 46), and residues 14 to 18 connecting the two helices are mobile. By comparing the structure and dynamics of the membrane-bound coat protein with that of the viral form as determined by NMR and neutron diffraction, essential features of assembly process can be identified.