15N and 13C NMR studies of ligands bound to the 280,000-dalton protein porphobilinogen synthase elucidate the structures of enzyme-bound product and a Schiff base intermediate

Pb2+ complexes of small-cavity azamacrocyclic ligands: thermodynamic and kinetic studies

The synthesis and Pb²⁺ coordination of azamacrocyclic ligands have been described. This paper includes one of the few kinetic studies so far reported on the acid-promoted dissociation of Pb²⁺ macrocyclic complexes.

Structural studies of substrate and product complexes of 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase from humans,Escherichia coliand the hyperthermophilePyrobaculum calidifontis

A number of X-ray analyses of an enzyme involved in a key early stage of tetrapyrrole biosynthesis are reported. Two structures of human 5-aminolaevulinate dehydratase (ALAD), native and recombinant, have been determined at 2.8 Å resolution, showing that the enzyme adopts an octameric quaternary structure in accord with previously published analyses of the enzyme from a range of other species. However, this is in contrast to the finding that a disease-related F12L mutant of the human enzyme uniquely forms hexamers [Breiniget al.(2003),Nature Struct. Biol.10, 757–763]. Monomers of all ALADs adopt the TIM-barrel fold; the subunit conformation that assembles into the octamer includes the N-terminal tail of one monomer curled around the (α/β)8barrel of a neighbouring monomer. Both crystal forms of the human enzyme possess two monomers per asymmetric unit, termedAandB. In the native enzyme there are a number of distinct structural differences between theAandBmonomers, with the latter exhibiting greater disorder in a number of loop regions and in the active site. In contrast, the second monomer of the recombinant enzyme appears to be better defined and the active site of both monomers clearly possesses a zinc ion which is bound by three conserved cysteine residues. In native human ALAD, theAmonomer also has a ligand resembling the substrate ALA which is covalently bound by a Schiff base to one of the active-site lysines (Lys252) and is held in place by an ordered active-site loop. In contrast, these features of the active-site structure are disordered or absent in theBsubunit of the native human enzyme. The octameric structure of the zinc-dependent ALAD from the hyperthermophilePyrobaculum calidifontisis also reported at a somewhat lower resolution of 3.5 Å. Finally, the details are presented of a high-resolution structure of theEscherichia coliALAD enzyme co-crystallized with a noncovalently bound moiety of the product, porphobilinogen (PBG). This structure reveals that the pyrrole side-chain amino group is datively bound to the active-site zinc ion and that the PBG carboxylates interact with the enzymeviahydrogen bonds and salt bridges with invariant residues. A number of hydrogen-bond interactions that were previously observed in the structure of yeast ALAD with a cyclic intermediate resembling the product PBG appear to be weaker in the new structure, suggesting that these interactions are only optimal in the transition state.

The Remarkable Character of Porphobilinogen Synthase

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS), also known as 5-aminolevulinate dehydratase, is an essential enzyme in the biosynthesis of all tetrapyrroles, which function in respiration, photosynthesis, and methanogenesis. Throughout evolution, PBGS adapted to a diversity of cellular niches and evolved to use an unusual variety of metal ions both for catalytic function and to control protein multimerization. With regard to the active site, some PBGSs require Zn²⁺; a subset of those, including human PBGS, contain a constellation of cysteine residues that acts as a sink for the environmental toxin Pb²⁺. PBGSs that do not require the soft metal ion Zn²⁺ at the active site instead are suspected of using the hard metal Mg²⁺. The most unexpected property of the PBGS family of enzymes is a dissociative allosteric mechanism that utilizes an equilibrium of architecturally and functionally distinct protein assemblies. The high-activity assembly is an octamer in which intersubunit interactions modulate active-site lid motion. This octamer can dissociate to dimer, the dimer can undergo a hinge twist, and the twisted dimer can assemble to a low-activity hexamer. The hexamer does not have the intersubunit interactions required to stabilize a closed conformation of the active site lid. PBGS active site chemistry benefits from a closed lid because porphobilinogen biosynthesis includes Schiff base formation, which requires deprotonated lysine amino groups. N-terminal and C-terminal sequence extensions dictate whether a specific species of PBGS can sample the hexameric assembly. The bulk of species (nearly all except animals and yeasts) use Mg²⁺ as an allosteric activator. Mg²⁺ functions allosterically by binding to an intersubunit interface that is present in the octamer but absent in the hexamer. This conformational selection allosteric mechanism is purported to be essential to avoid the untimely accumulation of phototoxic chlorophyll precursors in plants. For those PBGSs that do not use the allosteric Mg²⁺, there is a spatially equivalent arginine-derived guanidium group. Deprotonation of this residue promotes formation of the hexamer and accounts for the basic arm of the bell-shaped pH vs activity profile of human PBGS. A human inborn error of metabolism known as ALAD porphyria is attributed to PBGS variants that favor the hexameric assembly. The existence of one such variant, F12L, which dramatically stabilizes the human PBGS hexamer, allowed crystal structure determination for the hexamer. Without this crystal structure and octameric PBGS structures containing the allosteric Mg²⁺, it would have been difficult to decipher the structural basis for PBGS allostery. The requirement for multimer dissociation as an intermediate step in PBGS allostery was established by monitoring subunit disproportionation during the turnover-dependent transition of heteromeric PBGS (comprised of human wild type and F12L) from hexamer to octamer. One outcome of these studies was the definition of the dissociative morpheein model of protein allostery. The phylogenetically variable time scales for PBGS multimer interconversion result in atypical kinetic and biophysical behaviors. These behaviors can serve to identify other proteins that use the morpheein model of protein allostery.

Catalytic mechanism of porphobilinogen synthase: the chemical step revisited by QM/MM calculations

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) catalyzes the asymmetric condensation and cyclization of two 5-aminolevulinic acid (5-ALA) substrate molecules to give porphobilinogen (PBG). The chemical step of PBGS is herein revisited using QM/MM (ONIOM) calculations. Two different protonation states and several different mechanisms are considered. Previous mechanisms based on DFT-only calculations are shown unlikely to occur. According to these new calculations, the deprotonation step rather than ring closure is rate-limiting. Both the C-C bond formation first mechanism and the C-N bond formation first mechanism are possible, depending on how the A-site ALA binds to the enzyme. We furthermore propose that future work should focus on the substrate binding step rather than the enzymatic mechanism.

5-Aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase: characterization of the alpha and beta metal-binding sites of the Escherichia coli enzyme

The alpha and beta metal-binding sites of 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase (ALAD) (porphobilinogen synthase, EC 4.2.1.24) from Escherichia coli were investigated to determine the function of each metal ion and the role of the reactive cysteines in metal binding. Occupancy of the alpha site by Zn2+ restored virtually all catalytic activity to the inactive metal-depleted ALAD (apoALAD). Occupancy of the alpha site by Co2+ also yielded an active enzyme and resulted in a charge-transfer band indicative of a single cysteine amongst the metal ligands. Subsequent labelling of this cysteine residue with 14C-labelled N-ethylmaleimide, followed by peptide analysis, indicated the involvement of Cys-130. The metal ion at the alpha site is thought to be essential for binding of the second molecule of substrate at the A substrate-binding site that forms the acetic acid side of the product, porphobilinogen. Binding of Zn2+ to the beta site restored little activity if the alpha site was unfilled. Metal ion binding to the beta site could be monitored by following the change in protein fluorescence with Zn2+ titration of apoALAD at pH 6. A conformational change upon beta site occupancy may explain why binding of Mg2+ at the alpha site can occur only if Zn2+ is bound at the beta site. The binding of Co2+ at the beta site produced an inactive enzyme that exhibited a charge-transfer band indicative of at least three cysteine ligands.

Substrate-induced interconversion of protein quaternary structure isoforms

Human porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) can exist in two dramatically different quaternary structure isoforms, which have been proposed to be in dynamic equilibrium. The quaternary structure isoforms of PBGS result from two alternative conformations of the monomer; one monomer structure assembles into a high activity octamer, whereas the other monomer structure assembles into a low activity hexamer. The kinetic behavior of these oligomers led to the hypothesis that turnover facilitates the interconversion of the oligomeric structures. The current work demonstrates that the interactions of ligands at the enzyme active site promote the structural interconversion between human PBGS quaternary structure isoforms, favoring formation of the octamer. This observation illustrates that the assembly and disassembly of oligomeric proteins can be facilitated by the protein motions that accompany enzymatic catalysis.

The porphobilinogen synthase catalyzed reaction mechanism

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) catalyzes the first common reaction in the biosynthesis of the tetrapyrroles, the asymmetric condensation of two molecules of delta-aminolevulinic acid to form porphobilinogen. There is a variable requirement for an essential active site zinc that necessitates consideration of PBGS as an enzyme that may exhibit phylogenetic diversity in its chemical reaction mechanism. Recent crystal structures suggest reaction mechanisms that involve two covalent Schiff base linkages between adjacent active site lysine residues and each of the two substrate molecules. The reaction appears to stall at a covalently bound almost-product intermediate that is poised for breakdown to product upon binding of a substrate molecule to an adjacent active site and a subsequent conformational change.

X-ray structure of a putative reaction intermediate of 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase

The X-ray structure of yeast 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase, in which the catalytic site of the enzyme is complexed with a putative cyclic intermediate composed of both substrate moieties, has been solved at 0.16 nm (1.6 A) resolution. The cyclic intermediate is bound covalently to Lys(263) with the amino group of the aminomethyl side chain ligated to the active-site zinc ion in a position normally occupied by a catalytic hydroxide ion. The cyclic intermediate is catalytically competent, as shown by its turnover in the presence of added substrate to form porphobilinogen. The findings, combined with those of previous studies, are consistent with a catalytic mechanism in which the C-C bond linking both substrates in the intermediate is formed before the C-N bond.

Species-specific inhibition of porphobilinogen synthase by 4-oxosebacic acid

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) catalyzes the condensation of two molecules of 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA), an essential step in tetrapyrrole biosynthesis. 4-Oxosebacic acid (4-OSA) and 4,7-dioxosebacic acid (4,7-DOSA) are bisubstrate reaction intermediate analogs for PBGS. We show that 4-OSA is an active site-directed irreversible inhibitor for Escherichia coli PBGS, whereas human, pea, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Bradyrhizobium japonicum PBGS are insensitive to inhibition by 4-OSA. Some variants of human PBGS (engineered to resemble E. coli PBGS) have increased sensitivity to inactivation by 4-OSA, suggesting a structural basis for the specificity. The specificity of 4-OSA as a PBGS inhibitor is significantly narrower than that of 4,7-DOSA. Comparison of the crystal structures for E. coli PBGS inactivated by 4-OSA versus 4,7-DOSA shows significant variation in the half of the inhibitor that mimics the second substrate molecule (A-side ALA). Compensatory changes occur in the structure of the active site lid, which suggests that similar changes normally occur to accommodate numerous hybridization changes that must occur at C3 of A-side ALA during the PBGS-catalyzed reaction. A comparison of these with other PBGS structures identifies highly conserved active site water molecules, which are isolated from bulk solvent and implicated as proton acceptors in the PBGS-catalyzed reaction.

5-Chlorolevulinate modification of porphobilinogen synthase identifies a potential role for the catalytic zinc

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) is a Zn(II) metalloenzyme which catalyzes the asymmetric condensation of two molecules of 5-aminolevulinate (ALA). The nitrogen of the first substrate ends up in the pyrrole ring of product (P-side ALA); by contrast, the nitrogen of the second substrate molecule remains an amino group (A-side ALA). A reactive mimic of the substrate molecules, 5-chlorolevulinate (5-CLA), has been prepared and used as an active site directed irreversible inhibitor of PBGS. Native octameric PBGS binds eight substrate molecules and eight Zn(II) ions, with two types of sites for each ligand. As originally demonstrated by Seehra and Jordan [(1981) Eur. J. Biochem. 113, 435-446], 5-CLA inactivates the enzyme at the site where one of the two substrate molecules binds, and modification at four sites per octamer (one per active site) affords near-total inactivation. Here we report that 5-CLA-modified PBGS (5-CLA-PBGS) can bind up to four substrate molecules and four Zn(II) ions. Contrary to the conclusion of Seehra and Jordan, we find that the preferential site of 5-CLA inactivation is the A-side ALA binding site. On the basis of the dissociation constants, the metal ion binding sites lost upon 5-CLA modification are assigned to the four catalytic Zn(II) sites. 5-CLA-PBGS is shown to be modified at cysteine-223 on half of the subunits. We conclude that cysteine-223 is near the amino group of A-side ALA and propose that this cysteine is a ligand to the catalytic Zn(II). The vacant substrate binding site on 5-CLA-PBGS is that of P-side ALA. We have used 13C and 15N NMR to view [4-13C]ALA and [15N]ALA bound to 5-CLA-PBGS. The NMR results are nearly identical to those obtained previously for the enzyme-bound P-side Schiff base intermediate [Jaffe et al. (1990) Biochemistry 29, 8345-8350]. It appears that, in the absence of the catalytic Zn(II), 5-CLA-PBGS does not catalyze the condensation of the amino group of the P-side Schiff base intermediate with the C4 carbonyl derived from 5-CLA. On this basis we propose that Zn(II) plays an essential role in formation of the first bond between the two substrate molecules.

Inhibition studies of porphobilinogen synthase from Escherichia coli differentiating between the two recognition sites

Porphobilinogen synthase condenses two molecules of 5-aminolevulinate in an asymmetric way. This unusual transformation requires a selective recognition and differentiation between the substrates ending up in the A site or in the P site of porphobilinogen synthase. Studies of inhibitors based on the key intermediate first postulated by Jordan allowed differentiation of the two recognition sites. The P site, whose structure is known from X-ray crystallographic studies, tolerates ester functions well. The A site interacts very strongly with nitro groups, but is not very tolerant to ester functions. This differentiation is a central factor in the asymmetric handling of the two identical substrates. Finally, it could be shown that the keto group of the substrate bound at the A site is not only essential for the recognition, but that an increase in electrophilicity of the carbon atom also increases the inhibition potency considerably. This has important consequences for the recognition process at the A site, whose exact structure is not yet known.

Mechanistic implications of mutations to the active site lysine of porphobilinogen synthase

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) is a homo-octameric protein that catalyzes the complex asymmetric condensation of two molecules of 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA). The only characterized intermediate in the PBGS-catalyzed reaction is a Schiff base that forms between the first ALA that binds and a conserved lysine, which in Escherichia coli PBGS is Lys-246 and in human PBGS is Lys-252. In this study, E. coli PBGS mutants K246H, K246M, K246W, K246N, and K246G and human PBGS mutant K252G were characterized. Alterations to this lysine result in a disabled but not totally inactive protein suggesting an alternate mechanism in which proximity and orientation are major catalytic devices. (13)C NMR studies of [3,5-(13)C]porphobilinogen bound at the active sites of the E. coli PBGS and the mutants show only minor chemical shift differences, i.e. environmental alterations. Mammalian PBGS is established to have four functional active sites, whereas the crystal structure of E. coli PBGS shows eight spatially distinct and structurally equivalent subunits. Biochemical data for E. coli PBGS have been interpreted to support both four and eight active sites. A unifying hypothesis is that formation of the Schiff base between this lysine and ALA triggers a conformational change that results in asymmetry. Product binding studies with wild-type E. coli PBGS and K246G demonstrate that both bind porphobilinogen at four per octamer although the latter cannot form the Schiff base from substrate. Thus, formation of the lysine to ALA Schiff base is not required to initiate the asymmetry that results in half-site reactivity.

Dynamic frequency shifts of complexed ligands: An NMR study of D--1-13C,1-2H-glucose complexed to the Escherichia coli periplasmic glucose/galactose receptor

The 13C multiplet structure of D--1-13C,1-2H-glucose complexed to the Escherichia coli periplasmic glucose/galactose receptor has been studied as a function of temperature. Asymmetric multiplet patterns observed are shown to arise from dynamic frequency shifts. Multiplet asymmetry contributions resulting from shift anisotropy-dipolar cross correlations were found to be small, with optimal fits of the data corresponding to small, negative values of the correlation factor, chiCD-CSA. Additional broadening at higher temperatures most probably results from ligand exchange between free and complexed states. Effects of internal motion are also considered theoretically, and indicate that the order parameter for the bound glucose is >/=0.9.

Bradyrhizobium japonicum porphobilinogen synthase uses two Mg(II) and monovalent cations

Bradyrhizobium japonicum porphobilinogen synthase (B. japonicum PBGS) has been purified and characterized from an overexpression system in an Escherichia coli host (Chauhan, S., and O'Brian, M. R. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 19823-19827). B. japonicum PBGS defines a new class of PBGS protein, type IV (classified by metal ion content), which utilizes a catalytic MgA present at a stoichiometry of 4/octamer, an allosteric MgC present at a stoichiometry of 8/octamer, and a monovalent metal ion, K+. However, the divalent MgB or ZnB present in some other PBGS is not present in B. japonicum PBGS. Under optimal conditions, the Kd for MgA is <0.2 microM, and the Kd for MgC is about 40 microM. The response of B. japonicum PBGS activity to monovalent and divalent cations is mutually dependent and varies dramatically with pH. B. japonicum PBGS is also found to undergo a dynamic equilibrium between active multimeric species and inactive monomers under assay conditions, a kinetic characteristic not reported for other PBGSs. B. japonicum PBGS is the first PBGS that has been rigorously demonstrated to lack a catalytic ZnA. However, consistent with prior predictions, B. japonicum PBGS can bind Zn(II) (presumably as ZnA) at a stoichiometry of 4/octamer with a Kd of 200 microM; but this high concentration is outside a physiologically significant range.

On the formation of the mixed pyrrole catalysed by porphobilinogen synthase from Rhodobacter spheroides

This enzyme porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) catalyses the formation of porphobilinogen (PBG) from two molecules of 5-amino-levulinic acid (ALA). It has been claimed that the PBGS from Rhodobacter spheroides is able to form a mixed pyrrole, from one molecule of 5-aminolevulinic acid and one molecule of levulinic acid. The chemical synthesis of this mixed pyrrole allowed us to show that the compound formed from 5-aminolevulinic acid and levulinic acid with PBGS from R. spheroides has not the proposed structure. The putative enzyme-catalysed formation of the mixed pyrrole has been used as an argument for the postulated mechanism of PBGS. In view of our results, this line of argument has be re-evaluated.

The phylogenetically conserved histidines of Escherichia coli porphobilinogen synthase are not required for catalysis

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) is a metalloenzyme that catalyzes the first common step of tetrapyrrole biosynthesis, the asymmetric condensation of two molecules of 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) to form porphobilinogen. Chemical modification data implicate histidine as a catalytic residue of PBGS from both plants and mammals. Histidine may participate in the abstraction of two non-ionizable protons from each substrate molecule at the active site. Only one histidine is species-invariant among 17 known sequences of PBGS which have high overall sequence similarity. In Escherichia coli PBGS, this histidine is His128. We performed site-directed mutagenesis on His128, replacing it with alanine. The mutant protein H128A is catalytically active. His128 is part of a histidine- and cysteine-rich region of the sequence that is implicated in metal binding. The apparent Kd for Zn(II) binding to H128A is about an order of magnitude higher than for the wild type protein. E. coli PBGS also contains His126 which is conserved through the mammalian, fungal, and some bacterial PBGS. We mutated His126 to alanine, and both His126 and His128 simultaneously to alanine. All mutant proteins are catalytically competent; the Vmax values for H128A (44 units/mg), H126A (75 units/mg), and H126/128A (61 units/mg) were similar to wild type PBGS (50 units/mg) in the presence of saturating concentrations of metal ions. The apparent Kd for Zn(II) of H126A and H126/128A is not appreciably different from wild type. The activity of wild type and mutant proteins are all stimulated by an allosteric Mg(II); the mutant proteins all have a reduced affinity for Mg(II). We observe a pKa of approximately 7.5 in the wild type PBGS kcat/Km pH profile as well as in those of H128A and H126/128A, suggesting that this pKa is not the result of protonation/deprotonation of one of these histidines. H128A and H126/128A have a significantly increased Km value for the substrate ALA. This is consistent with a role for one or both of these histidines as a ligand to the required Zn(II) of E. coli PBGS, which is known to participate in substrate binding. Past chemical modification may have inactivated the PBGS by blocking Zn(II) and ALA binding. In addition, the decreased Km for E. coli PBGS at basic pH allows for the quantitation of active sites at four per octamer.

A structural assignment for a stable acetaldehyde-lysine adduct

Acetaldehyde is the first oxidation product of ethanol in vivo. Lysine residues in proteins such as hemoglobin have been implicated as target structures for acetaldehyde adducts resulting from ethanol consumption. Although the presence of both stable and unstable acetaldehyde-hemoglobin adducts has been established, the structural characterization of the adducts has received relatively little attention. As a model for such adduct formation, we studied the peptide pentalysine in vitro. Pentalysine has several potential sites for adduct formation. The amino-terminal amine group as well as the epsilon-amine groups of each lysine side chain can serve as potential sites for modification by acetaldehyde. Mass spectrometry, nuclear magnetic resonance, and Raman spectroscopy were employed to demonstrate that acetaldehyde forms a stable linkage to lysine amine groups via a Schiff base.

Porphobilinogen synthase, the first source of heme's asymmetry

Porphobilinogen is the monopyrrole precursor of all biological tetrapyrroles. The biosynthesis of porphobilinogen involves the asymmetric condensation of two molecules of 5-aminolevulinate and is carried out by the enzyme porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS), also known as 5-aminolevulinate dehydratase. This review documents what is known about the mechanism of the PBGS-catalyzed reaction. The metal ion constituents of PBGS are of particular interest because PBGS is a primary target for the environmental toxin lead. Mammalian PBGS contains two zinc ions at each active site. Bacterial and plant PBGS use a third metal ion, magnesium, as an allosteric activator. In addition, some bacterial and plant PBGS may use magnesium in place of one or both of the zinc ions of mammalian PBGS. These phylogenetic variations in metal ion usage are described along with a proposed rationale for the evolutionary divergence in metal ion usage. Finally, I describe what is known about the structure of PBGS, an enzyme which has as yet eluded crystal structure determination.

Characterization of the two 5-aminolaevulinic acid binding sites, the A- and P-sites, of 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase from Escherichia coli

Experiments are described in which the individual properties of the two 5-aminolaevulinic acid (ALA) binding sites, the A-site and the P-site, of 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase (ALAD) have been investigated. The ALA binding affinity at the A-site is greatly enhanced (at least 10-fold) on the binding of the catalytic metal ion (bound at the alpha-site). The nature of the catalytic metal ion, Mg2+ or Zn2+, also gave major variations in the substrate Km, P-site affinity for ALA, the effect of potassium and phosphate ions and the pH-dependence of substrate binding. Modification of the P-site by reaction of the enzyme-substrate Schiff base with NaBH4 and analysis of the reduced adduct by electro-spray mass spectrometry indicated a maximum of 1 mol of substrate incorporated/mol of subunit, correlating with a linear loss of enzyme activity. The reduced Schiff-base adduct was used to investigate substrate binding at the A-site by using rate-of-dialysis analysis. The affinity for ALA at the A-site of Mg alpha Zn beta ALAD was found to determine the Km for the reaction and was pH-dependent, with its affinity increasing from 1 mM at pH 6 to 70 microM at pH 8.5. The affinity of ALA at the P-site of Zn alpha An beta ALAD is proposed to limit the Km at pH values above 7, since the measured Kd for ALA at the A-site in 45 microM Tris, pH 8, was well below the observed Km (600 microM) under the same conditions. The amino group of the ALA molecule bound at the P-site was identified as a critical binding component for the A-site, explaining why ALA binding to ALAD is ordered, with the P-site ALA binding first. Structural requirements for ALA binding at the A- and P-sites have been identified: the P-site requires the carbonyl and carboxylate groups, whereas the A-site requires the amino, carbonyl and carboxylate groups of the substrate.