Phosphorescence studies of the interaction of myelin basic protein with phosphatidylserine vesicles

Myelin basic protein-diverse conformational states of an intrinsically unstructured protein and its roles in myelin assembly and multiple sclerosis

The 18.5 kDa isoform of myelin basic protein (MBP) is a major component of the myelin sheath in the central nervous system of higher vertebrates, and a member of a larger family of proteins with a multiplicity of forms and post-translational modifications (PTMs). The 18.5 kDa protein is the exemplar of the family, being most abundant in adult myelin, and thus the most-studied. It is peripherally membrane-associated, but has generally been investigated in isolated form. MBP is an 'intrinsically unstructured' protein with a high proportion (approximately 75%) of random coil, but postulated to have core elements of beta-sheet and alpha-helix. We review here the properties of the MBP family, especially of the 18.5 kDa isoform, and discuss how its three-dimensional (3D) structure may be resolved by direct techniques available to us, viz., X-ray and electron crystallography, and solution and solid-state NMR spectrometry. In particular, we emphasise that creating an appropriate environment in which the protein can adopt a physiologically relevant fold is crucial to such endeavours. By solving the 3D structure of 18.5 kDa MBP and the effects of PTMs, we will attain a better understanding of myelin architecture, and of the molecular mechanisms that transpire in demyelinating diseases such as multiple sclerosis.

Interaction of the 18.5-kD isoform of myelin basic protein with Ca2+ -calmodulin: effects of deimination assessed by intrinsic Trp fluorescence spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering, and circular dichroism

The effects of deimination (conversion of arginyl to citrullinyl residues) of myelin basic protein (MBP) on its binding to calmodulin (CaM) have been examined. Four species of MBP were investigated: unmodified recombinant murine MBP (rmMBP-Cit(0)), an engineered protein with six quasi-citrullinyl (i.e., glutaminyl) residues per molecule (rmMBP-qCit(6)), human component C1 (hMBP-Cit(0)), and human component C8 (hMBP-Cit(6)), both obtained from a patient with multiple sclerosis (MS). Both rmMBP-Cit(0) and hMBP-Cit(0) bound CaM in a Ca(2+)-dependent manner and primarily in a 1:1 stoichiometry, which was verified by dynamic light scattering. Circular dichroic spectroscopy was unable to detect any changes in secondary structure in MBP upon CaM-binding. Inherent Trp fluorescence spectroscopy and a single-site binding model were used to determine the dissociation constants: K(d) = 144 +/- 76 nM for rmMBP-Cit(0), and K(d) = 42 +/- 15 nM for hMBP-Cit(0). For rmMBP-qCit(6) and hMBP-Cit(6), the changes in fluorescence were suggestive of a two-site interaction, although the dissociation constants could not be accurately determined. These results can be explained by a local conformational change induced in MBP by deimination, exposing a second binding site with a weaker association with CaM, or by the existence of several conformers of deiminated MBP. Titration with the collisional quencher acrylamide, and steady-state and lifetime measurements of the fluorescence at 340 nm, showed both dynamic and static components to the quenching, and differences between the unmodified and deiminated proteins that were also consistent with a local conformational change due to deimination.

The structure and function of central nervous system myelin

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is characterized by the active degradation of central nervous system myelin, a multilamellar membrane system that insulates nerve axons. MS arises from complex interactions between genetic, immunological, infective, and biochemical mechanisms. Although the circumstances of MS etiology remain hypothetical, one persistent theme involves immune system recognition of myelin-specific antigens derived from myelin basic protein, the most abundant extrinsic myelin membrane protein, and/or another equally suitable myelin protein or lipid. Knowledge of the biochemical and physical-chemical properties of myelin proteins, and lipids, particularly their composition, organization, structure, and accessibility with respect to the compacted myelin multilayers, thus becomes central to understanding how and why these antigens become selected during the development of MS. This article focuses on the current understanding of the molecular basis of MS as it may relate to the protein and lipid components of myelin, which dictate myelin morphology on the basis of protein-lipid and lipid-lipid interactions, and the relationship, if any, between the protein/lipid components and the destruction of myelin in pathological situations.

The basic protein of CNS myelin: its structure and ligand binding

Consideration of the evidence presented in this review leads to the following conclusions: (a) Isolated MBP in aqueous solution has little ordered secondary or tertiary structure. (b) In this state, the protein can associate with a wide range of hydrophobic and amphiphilic compounds, these interactions involving limited sections of the protein. (c) The strength of binding to bilayers and the accompanying conformational changes in the protein are greatest for systems containing acidic lipids, presumably because of the involvement of ionic interactions. (d) When bound to bilayers of acidic lipids, MBP will have substantially more ordered secondary structure than it manifests in aqueous solution, and it is likely to be oligomeric (possibly hexameric). (e) MBP does affect the organization of lipid aggregates. It influences strongly the separation of bilayers in multilayers of purified lipids, and at present this must be viewed as its prime role within myelin. The greatest impediment to our understanding of MBP is the lack of an assayable biological activity. In contrast to the situation with enzymes, for example, we have no functional test for changes in protein structure or changes accompanying interactions with other molecules. Current evidence suggests that the protein has a structural role within myelin and that its own three-dimensional structure is strongly dependent on the molecules with which it is associated. If this picture is correct, studies of the isolated protein or of the protein in reconstituted lipid systems may yield, at best, a rough guide to the structure within its biological environment. Further clarification of the structure and function of MBP may have to await development of more powerful techniques for studying proteins bound to large molecular aggregates, such as lipid bilayers. The paucity of generally applicable methods is reflected in the fact that even low resolution structures are known for only a handful of intrinsic membrane proteins, and even more limited information exists for proteins associated with membrane surfaces. However, the increasing use of a combination of electron microscopy and diffraction on two-dimensional arrays of proteins formed on lipid bilayers (Henderson et al., 1990) offers the hope that it may not be too long before it will be possible to study at moderate resolution the three-dimensional structure of MBP bound to a lipid membrane.

Enzymic methylation of myelin basic protein in myelin

Myelin fractions with different degrees of compaction were isolated from bovine brain, and post-translational methylation of membrane-associated proteins was studied. When the purified myelin-basic-protein-specific protein methylase I and S-adenosyl-L-[methyl-14C]methionine were added exogenously, the most compact myelin fraction exhibited higher methyl-accepting activity than the less compact dense fractions. The methylated protein was identified as myelin basic protein (18.4 kDa) exclusively among the several myelin proteins from all membrane fractions, by SDS/PAGE/radioautography of methyl-14C-labelled membrane proteins. The methyl-14C-labelled amino acid residue in the basic protein was identified by h.p.l.c. as NG-methylarginine, indicating the high degree of specificity for the arginine residue as well as the myelin basic protein in the intact myelin membranes. The possibility of a charge alteration of myelin basic protein resulting from its arginine methylation was investigated by using the purified component 1 of myelin basic protein. The methylated component was shown to be less cationic than the unmethylated component by Bio-Rex 70 cation-exchange chromatography, since the former preceded the latter. However, in the presence of the denaturant (guanidinium chloride), the two species were co-eluted, indicating that the charge difference between methylated and unmethylated myelin basic protein can only be shown under the renatured condition.

Central nervous system myelin: structure, function, and pathology

Multiple sclerosis (MS) and a number of related distinctive diseases are characterized by the active degradation of central nervous system (CNS) myelin, an axonal sheath comprised essentially of proteins and lipids. These demyelinating diseases appear to arise from complex interactions of genetic, immunological, infective, and biochemical mechanisms. While circumstances of MS etiology remain hypothetical, one persistent theme involves recognition by the immune system of myelin-specific antigens derived from myelin basic protein (MBP), the most abundant extrinsic myelin membrane protein, and/or another equally susceptible myelin protein or lipid component. Knowledge of the biochemical and physical-chemical properties of myelin proteins and lipids, particularly their composition, organization, structure, and accessibility with respect to the compacted myelin multilayers, thus becomes central to the understanding of how and why these antigens become selected during the development of MS. This review focuses on current understanding of the molecular basis underlying demyelinating disease as it may relate to the impact of the various protein and lipid components on myelin morphology; the precise molecular architecture of this membrane as dictated by protein-lipid and lipid-lipid interactions; and the relationship, if any, between the protein/lipid components and the destruction of myelin in pathological situations.

Interactions of myelin basic protein with mixed dodecylphosphocholine/palmitoyllysophosphatidic acid micelles

The interactions of myelin basic protein and peptides derived from it with detergent micelles of lysophosphatidylglycerol, lysophosphatidylserine, palmitoyllysophosphatidic acid, and sodium lauryl sulfate, and with mixed micelles of the neutral detergent dodecylphosphocholine and the negatively charged detergent palmitoyllysophosphatidic acid, were investigated by 1H NMR spectroscopy and circular dichroic spectropolarimetry. The results with single detergents suggested that there are discrete interaction sites in the protein molecule for neutral and anionic detergent micelles and that at least some of these sites are different for each type of detergent. The data on the binding of the protein and peptides to mixed detergent micelles suggested that intramolecular interactions in the intact protein and in one of the longer peptides limited the formation of helices and also that a balance between hydrophobic and ionic forces is achieved in the interactions of the peptides with the detergents. At high detergent/protein molar ratios, hydrophobic interactions appeared to be favored.

Tryptophan phosphorescence at room temperature as a tool to study protein structure and dynamics

Fluorescence and phosphorescence resemble each other and in many ways can give the same type of information. Both originate from a dipolar interaction between light and the molecule. In this regard, both are polarized and subject to the same type of quenching phenomena. In other respects the information which they divulge are complementary. The fluorescence quantum yield is higher for exposed tryptophans and this is expressed in longer lifetime (Grinvald and Steinberg, 1976); in contrast long lifetime of phosphorescence appears to correlate with burial. Phosphorescence, spin-disallowed, is much longer lived than fluorescence. This allows the structural/dynamic characterization of proteins to be studied on a new time regime. A really remarkable finding of studies of protein phosphorescence is that there is such variability both in phosphorescence lifetime and quenchability. We would interpret this to indicate that the tryptophan environment can range from essentially a crystal, almost comparable in rigidity as found at 77 K, to tryptophans in a flexible environment, almost as flexible as free in solution. An interesting task will be to examine the relationship between the yield and lifetime of phosphorescence and details of the tryptophan environment in terms of rigidity and adjacent amino acids among the proteins with known three dimensional structure.

Photolabeling of myelin basic protein in lipid vesicles with the hydrophobic reagent 3-(trifluoromethyl)-3-(m-[125I]iodophenyl)diazirine

The hydrophobic photolabel 3-(trifluoromethyl)-3-(m-[125I]iodophenyl)diazirine([125I]TID) was used to label myelin basic protein or polylysine in aqueous solution and bound to lipid vesicles of different composition. Although myelin basic protein is a water soluble protein which binds electrostatically only to acidic lipids, unlike polylysine it has several short hydrophobic regions. Myelin basic protein was labeled to a significant extent by TID when in aqueous solution indicating that it has a hydrophobic site which can bind the reagent. However, myelin basic protein was labeled 2-4-times more when bound to the acidic lipids phosphatidylglycerol, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidic acid, and cerebroside sulfate than when bound to phosphatidylethanolamine, or when in solution in the presence of phosphatidylcholine vesicles. It was labeled 5-7-times more than polylysine bound to acidic lipids. These results suggest that when myelin basic protein is bound to acidic lipids, it is labeled from the lipid bilayer rather than from the aqueous phase. However, this conclusion is not unequivocal because of the possibility of changes in the protein conformation or degree of aggregation upon binding to lipid. Within this limitation the results are consistent with, but do not prove, the concept that some of its hydrophobic residues penetrate partway into the lipid bilayer. However, it is likely that most of the protein is on the surface of the bilayer with its basic residues bound electrostatically to the lipid head groups.

Interaction of myelin basic protein with different ionization states of phosphatidic acid and phosphatidylserine

Myelin basic protein (BP) has a perturbing effect on some lipids, causing, among other effects, a decrease in the temperature and enthalpy of the phase transition. This is believed to be a result of penetration of some hydrophobic residues of the protein partway into the lipid bilayer. Variations in the perturbing effect of BP on different acidic lipids has been attributed to the ability of the lipids to participate in intermolecular hydrogen bonding which inhibits penetration of the protein. Participation in intermolecular hydrogen bonding depends on the ionization state of the lipid as well as the type of lipid. In order to further test the dependence of the degree of penetration of BP on the intermolecular hydrogen bonding properties of lipids, the effect of BP on the phase transition of lipids in different ionization states was studied using differential scanning calorimetry. Dipalmitoylphosphatidic acid (DPPA) and dimyristoylphosphatidylserine (DMPS) were studied at different pH-values from 4 to 9.5. The results were compared to data obtained earlier with phosphatidylglycerol (PG), which is in the same ionization state at pH-values above 4, in order to distinguish the effects of pH on the protein from effects on the lipids. The perturbing effect of BP on PG increases with increase in pH. This is probably a result of the increasing hydrophobicity of the protein as the histidines become deprotonated, which allows greater penetration of the protein into the bilayer. In contrast, the effect on DPPA was greatest at low pH, where the state of ionization of the lipid is less than 1 and protein binding utilizes all of the hydrogen bond accepting sites (P-O-) on the lipid. BP had no perturbing effect on DPPA at higher pH where the state of ionization is between 1 and 1.5, and hydrogen bond accepting and donating sites (P-OH) are still available even after binding of the protein. Thus hydrogen bonding occurs at high pH and penetration of hydrophobic residues of the protein into DPPA is inhibited. BP had a large perturbing effect on DMPS at all pH values above 4 suggesting that lipid intermolecular hydrogen bonding does not occur in the presence of the protein and its hydrophobic residues consequently can penetrate into the bilayer. The protein may inhibit hydrogen bonding by binding electrostatically to the anionic hydrogen bond accepting group of PS.

Membrane proteins in reverse micelles: myelin basic protein in a membrane-mimetic environment

The solubility, reactivity, and conformational dynamics of myelin basic protein (MBP) from bovine brain were studied in reverse micelles of sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate (AOT)-isooctane and water. Such a membrane-mimetic system resembles the aqueous spaces of native myelin sheath in terms of physicochemical properties as reflected in the high affinity of MBP for interfacial bound water. This is marked by the unusual profile of the solubility curve of the protein in reverse micelles, which shows optimal solubility at a much lower molar ratio of water to surfactant ([ H2O]/[AOT] = w0) than that reported for other water-soluble proteins. The role of counterions and/or charged polar head groups in the solubilization process is revealed by comparison of the solubility of MBP in nonionic surfactant micellar solutions. Whereas MBP is unfolded in aqueous solutions, insertion into reverse micelles generates a more folded structure, characterized by the presence of 20% alpha-helix. This conformation is unaffected by variations in the water content of the system (in the 2.0-22.4 w0 range). The reactivity of epsilon-amino groups of lysine residues with aqueous solutions of o-phthalaldehyde demonstrates that segments of the peptide chain are accessible to water. Similar results were obtained with the sequence involved in heme binding. In contrast, the sole tryptophan residue, Trp-117, is shielded from the aqueous solvent, as indicated by lack of reaction with N-bromosuccinimide. The invariance of the wavelength maximum emission in the fluorescence spectra as a function of w0 is consistent with this result.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Monitoring membrane protein rotational diffusion using time-averaged phosphorescence

Rotational motions of membrane proteins have previously been measured using time-dependent phosphorescence techniques. This paper discusses a method of examining membrane protein mobility at temperatures relevant to biological systems, using a technique similar to steady-state fluorescence. The method is demonstrated using sarcoplasmic reticulum ATPase labelled with erythrosin isothiocyanate, both in its natural condition and crosslinked by incubation with glutaraldehyde. The experimentally-observed dependence of phosphorescence anisotropy on temperature is compared to a calculated anisotropy-temperature curve. Comparison is made between the anisotropy decay curves obtained by time-averaged phosphorescence and steady-state fluorescence.

Myelin basic protein-enhanced fusion of membranes

Myelin basic protein caused rapid aggregation of vesicles containing acidic phospholipids. Aggregation could be reversed by trypsin digestion of the myelin basic protein. Aggregated vesicles containing gel phase phospholipids or vesicles containing greater than 15 mol% lysolecithin underwent fusion. The extent of fusion was measured by irreversible changes in the light-scattering intensities or diffusion coefficients of the vesicles. Fusion was also measured by the fluorescence quenching which occurred when vesicles containing a covalently bound fluorophore. N-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole, were fused with vesicles containing the covalently bound spin label, 4,4-dimethyl-oxazolidine-N-oxyl. The kinetics of fusion were first order in phospholipid and had half-times of 0.5-5 min depending on lysolecithin composition. This protein-enhanced membrane fusion may provide a valuable model system for studying some types of biological membrane fusions.

1H-nuclear magnetic resonance study of the association of the basic protein of central nervous system myelin with lysophosphatidylcholine

High-resolution 270 MHZ 1H-nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy has been used to follow the interaction of myristoyllysophosphatidylcholine with bovine myelin basic protein. At lipid/protein ratios up to 30:1 it proved possible to follow changes in the spectra of both the protein and the lipid. Lysophosphatidylcholine induced several changes in the protein spectrum. Foremost amongst these changes were downfield shifts of histidine C2 protons, and upfield shifts and broadening of the phenylalanine aromatic proteins. Several other resonances assigned to nonpolar amino acid side chains also broadened. But even at a lipid/protein molar ratio of 30:1 the majority of the protein appeared to remain in a loosely coiled conformation. In the presence of the protein the lipid acyl chain peaks were moved upfield and broadened, whereas the resonances associated with the head-group protons were unaffected. These changes were consistent with partial immobilization of the acyl chain of lysophosphatidylcholine on binding to the basic protein, with hydrophobic interactions providing the predominant attraction between this lipid and the basic protein.