Binding of protoporphyrin IX and metal derivatives to the active site of wild-type mouse ferrochelatase at low porphyrin-to-protein ratios

Iron insertion into coproporphyrin III-ferrochelatase complex: Evidence for an intermediate distorted catalytic species

Understanding the reaction mechanism of enzymes at the molecular level is generally a difficult task, since many parameters affect the turnover. Often, due to high reactivity and formation of transient species or intermediates, detailed information on enzymatic catalysis is obtained by means of model substrates. Whenever possible, it is essential to confirm a reaction mechanism based on substrate analogues or model systems by using the physiological substrates. Here we disclose the ferrous iron incorporation mechanism, in solution, and in crystallo, by the coproporphyrin III-coproporphyrin ferrochelatase complex from the firmicute, pathogen, and antibiotic resistant, Listeria monocytogenes. Coproporphyrin ferrochelatase plays an important physiological role as the metalation represents the penultimate reaction step in the prokaryotic coproporphyrin-dependent heme biosynthetic pathway, yielding coproheme (ferric coproporphyrin III). By following the metal titration with resonance Raman spectroscopy and x-ray crystallography, we prove that upon metalation the saddling distortion becomes predominant both in the crystal and in solution. This is a consequence of the readjustment of hydrogen bond interactions of the propionates with the protein scaffold during the enzymatic catalysis. Once the propionates have established the interactions typical of the coproheme complex, the distortion slowly decreases, to reach the almost planar final product.

Active site architecture of coproporphyrin ferrochelatase with its physiological substrate coproporphyrin III: Propionate interactions and porphyrin core deformation

Coproporphyrin ferrochelatases (CpfCs) are enzymes catalyzing the penultimate step in the coproporphyrin-dependent (CPD) heme biosynthesis pathway, which is mainly utilized by monoderm bacteria. Ferrochelatases insert ferrous iron into a porphyrin macrocycle and have been studied for many decades, nevertheless many mechanistic questions remain unanswered to date. Especially CpfCs, which are found in the CPD pathway, are currently in the spotlight of research. This pathway was identified in 2015 and revealed that the correct substrate for these ferrochelatases is coproporphyrin III (cpIII) instead of protoporphyrin IX, as believed prior the discovery of the CPD pathway. The chemistry of cpIII, which has four propionates, differs significantly from protoporphyrin IX, which features two propionate and two vinyl groups. These findings let us to thoroughly describe the physiological cpIII-ferrochelatase complex in solution and in the crystal phase. Here, we present the first crystallographic structure of the CpfC from the representative monoderm pathogen Listeria monocytogenes bound to its physiological substrate, cpIII, together with the in-solution data obtained by resonance Raman and UV-vis spectroscopy, for wild-type ferrochelatase and variants, analyzing propionate interactions. The results allow us to evaluate the porphyrin distortion and provide an in-depth characterization of the catalytically-relevant binding mode of cpIII prior to iron insertion. Our findings are discussed in the light of the observed structural restraints and necessities for this porphyrin-enzyme complex to catalyze the iron insertion process. Knowledge about this initial situation is essential for understanding the preconditions for iron insertion in CpfCs and builds the basis for future studies.

Ferrochelatase: Mapping the Intersection of Iron and Porphyrin Metabolism in the Mitochondria

Porphyrin and iron are ubiquitous and essential for sustaining life in virtually all living organisms. Unlike iron, which exists in many forms, porphyrin macrocycles are mostly functional as metal complexes. The iron-containing porphyrin, heme, serves as a prosthetic group in a wide array of metabolic pathways; including respiratory cytochromes, hemoglobin, cytochrome P450s, catalases, and other hemoproteins. Despite playing crucial roles in many biological processes, heme, iron, and porphyrin intermediates are potentially cytotoxic. Thus, the intersection of porphyrin and iron metabolism at heme synthesis, and intracellular trafficking of heme and its porphyrin precursors are tightly regulated processes. In this review, we discuss recent advances in understanding the physiological dynamics of eukaryotic ferrochelatase, a mitochondrially localized metalloenzyme. Ferrochelatase catalyzes the terminal step of heme biosynthesis, the insertion of ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX to produce heme. In most eukaryotes, except plants, ferrochelatase is localized to the mitochondrial matrix, where substrates are delivered and heme is synthesized for trafficking to multiple cellular locales. Herein, we delve into the structural and functional features of ferrochelatase, as well as its metabolic regulation in the mitochondria. We discuss the regulation of ferrochelatase via post-translational modifications, transportation of substrates and product across the mitochondrial membrane, protein-protein interactions, inhibition by small-molecule inhibitors, and ferrochelatase in protozoal parasites. Overall, this review presents insight on mitochondrial heme homeostasis from the perspective of ferrochelatase.

Insertion of cobalt into tetrapyrroles

Vitamin B₁₂ is one of the most complex cofactors known, and this chapter will discuss current understanding with regards to the cobalt insertion step of its syntheses. Two total syntheses of vitamin B₁₂ were reported in the 1970s, which remain two of the most exceptional achievements of natural product synthesis. In subsequent years, two distinct biosynthetic pathways were identified in aerobic and anaerobic organisms. For these biosynthetic pathways, selectivity for Co(II) over other divalent metal ions with similar ionic radii and coordination chemistry remains an open question with three competing hypotheses proposed: metal affinity, tetrapyrrole distortion, and product inhibition. A 20 step biosynthetic route to convert 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) to vitamin B₁₂ was elucidated in aerobic organisms in the 1990s, where cobalt is inserted relatively late in the pathway by the CobNST multi-protein complex. This chapter includes a mechanistic proposal for this reaction, but the majority of the proposal is based upon analogy to the ChlDHI magnesium chelatase complex as critical data for the cobalt chelatase is lacking. Later, in the 2010s, a distinct 21 step pathway from ALA to vitamin B₁₂ was reported in anaerobic organisms, where cobalt is inserted early in the pathway by the enzyme CbiK. A recent study strongly suggests that the cobalt affinity of CbiK is the origin of cobalt selectivity for CbiK, but several important mechanistic questions remain unanswered. In general, it is expected that significant insight into the cobalt insertion mechanisms of CobNST and CbiK could be derived from additional structural, spectroscopic, and computational data.

The Red Color of Life Transformed - Synthetic Advances and Emerging Applications of Protoporphyrin IX in Chemical Biology

Protoporphyrin IX (PPIX) is the porphyrin scaffold of heme b, a ubiquitous prosthetic group of proteins responsible for oxygen binding (hemoglobin, myoglobin), electron transfer (cytochrome c) and catalysis (cytochrome P450, catalases, peroxidases). PPIX and its metallated derivatives frequently find application as therapeutic agents, imaging tools, catalysts, sensors and in light harvesting. The vast toolkit of accessible porphyrin functionalization reactions enables easy synthetic modification of PPIX to meet the requirements for its multiple uses. In the past few years, particular interest has arisen in exploiting the interaction of PPIX and its synthetic derivatives with biomolecules such as DNA and heme-binding proteins to evolve molecular devices with new functions as well as to uncover potential therapeutic toeholds. This review strives to shine a light on the most recent developments in the synthetic chemistry of PPIX and its uses in selected fields of chemical biology.

CfbA promotes insertion of cobalt and nickel into ruffled tetrapyrroles in vitro

The nickel chelatase CfbA is the smallest member of the chelatase family, but the mechanism by which this enzyme inserts nickel into sirohydrochlorin is unknown. In order to gain mechanistic insight, metal binding, tetrapyrrole binding, and enzyme activity were characterized for a variety of substrates using several spectroscopic and computational approaches. Mass spectrometery and magnetic circular dichroism experiments revealed that CfbA binds an octahedral, high-spin metal substrate. UV/Vis absorption spectroscopy demonstrated that the enzyme binds a wide range of tetrapyrrole substrates and perturbs their electronic structures. Based upon activity assays, CfbA promotes insertion of cobalt and nickel into several tetrapyrroles, including cobalt insertion into protopophyrin IX. Finally, density functional theory models were developed which strongly suggest that observed spectral changes upon binding to the enzyme can be explained by tetrapyrrole ruffling, but not deprotonation or saddling. The observation of an octahedral, high-spin metal bound to CfbA leads to a generalization for all class II chelatases: these enzymes bind labile metal substrates and metal desolvation is not a rate-limiting step. The conclusion that CfbA ruffles its tetrapyrrole substrate reveals that the CfbA mechanism is different from that currently proposed for ferrochelatase, and identifies an intriguing correlation between metal substrate specificity and tetrapyrrole distortion mode in chelatases.

Molecular Engineering of Free-Base Porphyrins as Ligands-The N-H⋅⋅⋅X Binding Motif in Tetrapyrroles

The core N-H units of planar porphyrins are often inaccessible to forming hydrogen-bonding complexes with acceptor molecules. This is due to the fact that the amine moieties are "shielded" by the macrocyclic system, impeding the formation of intermolecular H-bonds. However, methods exist to modulate the tetrapyrrole conformations and to reshape the vector of N-H orientation outwards, thus increasing their availability and reactivity. Strategies include the use of porpho(di)methenes and phlorins (calixphyrins), as well as saddle-distorted porphyrins. The former form cavities due to interruption of the aromatic system. The latter are highly basic systems and capable of binding anions and neutral molecules via N-H⋅⋅⋅X-type H-bonds. This Review discusses the role of porphyrin(oid) ligands in various coordination-type complexes, means to access the core for hydrogen bonding, the concept of conformational control, and emerging applications, such as organocatalysis and sensors.

Ferrochelatase π-helix: Implications from examining the role of the conserved π-helix glutamates in porphyrin metalation and product release

Protoporphyrin ferrochelatase catalyzes the insertion of Fe²⁺ into protoporphyrin IX to form heme. To determine whether a conserved, active site π-helix contributes to the translocation of the metal ion substrate to the ferrochelatase-bound porphyrin substrate, the invariant π-helix glutamates were replaced with amino acids with non-negatively charged side chains, and the kinetic mechanisms of the generated variants were examined. Analysis of yeast wild-type ferrochelatase-, E314Q- and E318Q-catalyzed reactions, under multi- and single-turnover conditions, demonstrated that the mutations of the π-helix glutamates hindered both protoporphyrin metalation and release of the metalated porphyrin, by slowing each step by approximately 30-50%. Protoporphyrin metalation occurred with an apparent pK_a of 7.3 ± 0.1, which was assigned to binding of Fe²⁺ by deprotonated Glu-314 and Glu-314-assisted Fe²⁺ insertion into the porphyrin ring. We propose that unwinding of the π-helix concomitant with the adoption of a protein open conformation positions the deprotonated Glu-314 to bind Fe²⁺ from the surface of the enzyme. Transition to the closed conformation, with π-helix winding, brings Glu-314-bound Fe²⁺ to the active site for incorporation into protoporphyrin.

Synthesis, Acid-Base Properties, Kinetics and Mechanism of Cu2+ Incorporation into Water-Soluble Highly Substituted Porphyrins

The synthesis, acid-base properties, and kinetics of Cu[Formula: see text] incorporation into water-soluble highly substituted porphyrins were studied. The basicity increased and the stepwise acid-base equilibrium was clarified by increasing the number of phenyl groups at the [Formula: see text] position, and the basicity of a dodeca-substituted porphyrin increased with the ionic strength. The metalation reaction of the dodeca-substituted porphyrin with Cu[Formula: see text] in aqueous solution revealed a biphasic absorbance change at 453 nm. Plots of [Formula: see text] or[Formula: see text] vs. the Cu[Formula: see text] concentration and of log ([Formula: see text] or[Formula: see text]/[Formula: see text] 0) vs. the ionic strength show that [Formula: see text] is dependent on the Cu[Formula: see text] concentration and ionic strength, while [Formula: see text] is independent of these parameters. These results confirm the stepwise metalation mechanism and the existence of an intermediate in aqueous solution, which is indicated by the biphasic absorbance change at 453 nm.

Human Ferrochelatase: Insights for the Mechanism of Ferrous Iron Approaching Protoporphyrin IX by QM/MM and QTCP Free Energy Studies

Ferrochelatase catalyzes the insertion of ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX, the terminal step in heme biosynthesis. Some disputes in its mechanism remain unsolved, especially for human ferrochelatase. In this paper, high-level quantum mechanical/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) and free-energy studies were performed to address these controversial issues including the iron-binding site, the optimal reaction path, the substrate porphyrin distortion, and the presence of the sitting-atop (SAT) complex. Our results reveal that the ferrous iron is probably at the binding site coordinating with Met76, and His263 plays the role of proton acceptor. The rate-determining step is either the first proton removed by His263 or the proton transition within the porphyrin with an energy barrier of 14.99 or 14.87 kcal/mol by the quantum mechanical thermodynamic cycle perturbation (QTCP) calculations, respectively. The fast deprotonation step with the conservative residues rather than porphyrin deformation found in solution provides the driving force for biochelation. The SAT complex is not a necessity for the catalysis though it induces a modest distortion on the porphyrin ring.

The conserved active site histidine-glutamate pair of ferrochelatase coordinately catalyzes porphyrin metalation

Ferrochelatase catalyzes the insertion of ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX to generate heme. Despite recent research on the reaction mechanism of ferrochelatase, the precise roles and localization of individual active site residues in catalysis, particularly those involved in the insertion of the ferrous iron into the protoporphyrin IX substrate, remain controversial. One outstanding question is from which side of the macrocycle of the bound porphyin substrate is the ferrous iron substrate inserted. Pre-steady state kinetic experiments done under single-turnover conditions conclusively demonstrate that metal ion insertion is pH-dependent, and that the conserved active site His-Glu pair coordinately catalyzes the metal ion insertion reaction. Further, p[Formula: see text] calculations and molecular dynamic simulations indicate that the active site His is deprotonated and the protonation state of the Glu relates to the conformational state of ferrochelatase. Specifically, the conserved Glu in the open conformation of ferrochelatase is deprotonated, while it remains protonated in the closed conformation. These findings support not only the role of the His-Glu pair in catalyzing metal ion insertion, as these residues need to be deprotonated to bind the incoming metal ion, but also the importance of the relationship between the protonation state of the Glu residue and the conformation of ferrochelatase. Finally, the results of this study are consistent with our previous proposal that the unwinding of the [Formula: see text]-helix, the major structural determinant of the closed to open conformational transition in ferrochelatase, is associated with the Glu residue binding the Fe[Formula: see text] substrate from a mitochondrial Fe[Formula: see text] donor.

Resonance Raman Spectroscopic Examination of Ferrochelatase-induced Porphyrin Distortion

Ferrochelatase, the terminal enzyme of the heme biosynthetic pathway, catalyzes the insertion of ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX to give heme. Resonance Raman spectroscopy has been instrumental in defining the distortion (mode and extent) of the porphyrin substrate, which is a critical step in the catalytic mechanism of ferrochelatase. Saddling is the predominant porphyrin out-of-plane deformation induced upon binding to ferrochelatase. Our analysis demonstrated that the intensity of the γ(15) line, which is assigned to an out-of-plane porphyrin vibration, in resonance Raman spectra obtained for wild-type- and variant ferrochelatase-bound porphyrin, correlates with the saddling deformation undergone by the porphyrin substrate. Further analysis of the three dimensional X-ray structures of bacterial, human and yeast ferrochelatases and the type and extent of distortion of the protein-bound porphyrin substrate and inhibitors using normal structure decomposition, support the view that ferrochelatase catalysis involves binding of a distorted porphyrin substrate and releasing of a flatter, metalated porphyrin.

Nickel(II) chelatase variants directly evolved from murine ferrochelatase: porphyrin distortion and kinetic mechanism

The heme biosynthetic pathway culminates with the ferrochelatase-catalyzed ferrous iron chelation into protoporphyrin IX to form protoheme. The catalytic mechanism of ferrochelatase has been proposed to involve the stabilization of a nonplanar porphyrin to present the pyrrole nitrogens to the metal ion substrate. Previously, we hypothesized that the ferrochelatase-induced nonplanar distortions of the porphyrin substrate impose selectivity for the divalent metal ion incorporated into the porphyrin ring and facilitate the release of the metalated porphyrin through its reduced affinity for the enzyme. Using resonance Raman spectroscopy, the structural properties of porphyrins bound to the active site of directly evolved Ni(2+)-chelatase variants are now examined with regard to the mode and extent of porphyrin deformation and related to the catalytic properties of the enzymes. The Ni(2+)-chelatase variants (S143T, F323L, and S143T/F323L), which were directly evolved to exhibit an enhanced Ni(2+)-chelatase activity over that of the parent wild-type ferrochelatase, induced a weaker saddling deformation of the porphyrin substrate. Steady-state kinetic parameters of the evolved variants for Ni(2+)- and Fe(2+)-chelatase activities increased compared to those of wild-type ferrochelatase. In particular, the reduced porphyrin saddling deformation correlated with increased catalytic efficiency toward the metal ion substrate (Ni(2+) or Fe(2+)). The results lead us to propose that the decrease in the induced protoporphyrin IX saddling mode is associated with a less stringent metal ion preference by ferrochelatase and a slower porphyrin chelation step.

Co-expression of ferrochelatase allows for complete heme incorporation into recombinant proteins produced in E. coli

Over-expression of heme binding proteins in Escherichia coli often results in sub-optimal heme incorporation and the amount of heme-bound protein produced usually varies with the protein of interest. Complete heme incorporation is important for biochemical characterization, spectroscopy, structural studies, and for the production of homogeneous commercial proteins with high activity. We have determined that recombinant proteins expressed in E. coli often contain less than a full complement of heme because they rather are partially incorporated with free-base porphyrin. Porphyrin-incorporated proteins have similar spectral characteristics as the desired heme-loaded targets, and thus are difficult to detect, even in purified samples. We present a straightforward and inexpensive solution to this problem that involves the co-expression of native ferrochelatase with the protein of interest. The method is shown to be effective for proteins that contain either Cys- or His-ligated hemes.

Porphyrin binding and distortion and substrate specificity in the ferrochelatase reaction: the role of active site residues

The specific insertion of a divalent metal ion into tetrapyrrole macrocycles is catalyzed by a group of enzymes called chelatases. Distortion of the tetrapyrrole has been proposed to be an important component of the mechanism of metallation. We present the structures of two different inhibitor complexes: (1) N-methylmesoporphyrin (N-MeMP) with the His183Ala variant of Bacillus subtilis ferrochelatase; (2) the wild-type form of the same enzyme with deuteroporphyrin IX 2,4-disulfonic acid dihydrochloride (dSDP). Analysis of the structures showed that only one N-MeMP isomer out of the eight possible was bound to the protein and it was different from the isomer that was earlier found to bind to the wild-type enzyme. A comparison of the distortion of this porphyrin with other porphyrin complexes of ferrochelatase and a catalytic antibody with ferrochelatase activity using normal-coordinate structural decomposition reveals that certain types of distortion are predominant in all these complexes. On the other hand, dSDP, which binds closer to the protein surface compared to N-MeMP, does not undergo any distortion upon binding to the protein, underscoring that the position of the porphyrin within the active site pocket is crucial for generating the distortion required for metal insertion. In addition, in contrast to the wild-type enzyme, Cu(2+)-soaking of the His183Ala variant complex did not show any traces of porphyrin metallation. Collectively, these results provide new insights into the role of the active site residues of ferrochelatase in controlling stereospecificity, distortion and metallation.

Substrate interactions with human ferrochelatase

Ferrochelatase, the terminal enzyme in heme biosynthesis, catalyzes the insertion of ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX to form protoheme IX. Human ferrochelatase is a homodimeric, inner mitochondrial membrane-associated enzyme that possesses an essential [2Fe-2S] cluster. In this work, we report the crystal structure of human ferrochelatase with the substrate protoporphyrin IX bound as well as a higher resolution structure of the R115L variant without bound substrate. The data presented reveal that the porphyrin substrate is bound deep within an enclosed pocket. When compared with the location of N-methylmesoporphyrin in the Bacillus subtilis ferrochelatase, the porphyrin is rotated by approximately 100 degrees and is buried an additional 4.5 A deeper within the active site. The propionate groups of the substrate do not protrude into solvent and are bound in a manner similar to what has been observed in uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase. Furthermore, in the substrate-bound form, the jaws of the active site mouth are closed so that the porphyrin substrate is completely engulfed in the pocket. These data provide insights that will aid in the determination of the mechanism for ferrochelatase.

Modulation of inhibition of ferrochelatase by N-methylprotoporphyrin

Protoporhyrin IX ferrochelatase catalyses the terminal step of the haem-biosynthetic pathway by inserting ferrous iron into protoporphyrin IX. NMPP (N-methylprotoporphyrin), a transition-state analogue and potent inhibitor of ferrochelatase, is commonly used to induce haem deficiency in mammalian cell cultures. To create ferrochelatase variants with different extents of tolerance towards NMPP and to understand further the mechanism of ferrochelatase inhibition by NMPP, we isolated variants with increased NMPP resistance, bearing mutations in an active-site loop (murine ferrochelatase residues 248-257), which was previously shown to mediate a protein conformational change triggered by porphyrin binding. The kinetic mechanisms of inhibition of two variants, in which Pro255 was replaced with either arginine (P255R) or glycine (P255G), were investigated and compared with that of wild-type ferrochelatase. While the binding affinity of the P255X variants for NMPP decreased by one order of magnitude in relation to that of wild-type enzyme, the inhibition constant increased by approximately two orders of magnitude (K(i)(app) values of 1 microM and 2.3 microM for P255R and P255G respectively, as against 3 nM for wild-type ferrochelatase). Nonetheless, the drastically reduced inhibition of the variants by NMPP was not paralleled with a decrease in specificity constant (kcat/K(m, protoporhyrin IX)) and/or catalytic activity (kcat). Further, although NMPP binding to either wild-type ferrochelatase or P255R occurred via a similar two-step kinetic mechanism, the forward and reverse rate constants associated with the second and rate-limiting step were comparable for the two enzymes. Collectively, these results suggest that Pro255 has a crucial role in maintaining an appropriate protein conformation and modulating the selectivity and/or regiospecificity of ferrochelatase.

Chelatases: distort to select?

Chelatases catalyze the insertion of a specific metal ion into porphyrins, a key step in the synthesis of metalated tetrapyrroles that are essential for many cellular processes. Despite apparent common structural features among chelatases, no general reaction mechanism accounting for metal ion specificity has been established. We propose that chelatase-induced distortion of the porphyrin substrate not only enhances the reaction rate by decreasing the activation energy of the reaction but also modulates which divalent metal ion is incorporated into the porphyrin ring. We evaluate the recently recognized interaction between ferrochelatase and frataxin as a way to regulate iron delivery to ferrochelatase, and thus iron and heme metabolism. We postulate that the ferrochelatase-frataxin interaction controls the type of metal ion that is delivered to ferrochelatase.

Chelatases: distort to select?

Chelatases catalyze the insertion of a specific metal ion into porphyrins, a key step in the synthesis of metalated tetrapyrroles that are essential for many cellular processes. Despite apparent common structural features among chelatases, no general reaction mechanism accounting for metal ion specificity has been established. We propose that chelatase-induced distortion of the porphyrin substrate not only enhances the reaction rate by decreasing the activation energy of the reaction but also modulates which divalent metal ion is incorporated into the porphyrin ring. We evaluate the recently recognized interaction between ferrochelatase and frataxin as a way to regulate iron delivery to ferrochelatase, and thus iron and heme metabolism. We postulate that the ferrochelatase-frataxin interaction controls the type of metal ion that is delivered to ferrochelatase.

Crosstalk between metal ions in Bacillus subtilis ferrochelatase

Ferrochelatase (EC 4.99.1.1), the terminal enzyme in the heme biosynthetic pathway, catalyzes the insertion of Fe2+ into protoporphyrin IX, generating heme. In vitro assays have shown that all characterized ferrochelatases can also incorporate Zn2+ into protoporphyrin IX. Previously Zn2+ has been observed at an inner metal binding site close to the porphyrin binding site. Mg2+, which stimulates Zn2+ insertion by Bacillus subtilis ferrochelatase, has been observed at an outer metal binding site. Exchange of Glu272 to a serine eliminated the stimulative effect of Mg2+. We found that Zn2+ quenched the fluorescence of B. subtilis ferrochelatase and this quenching was used to estimate the metal affinity. Trp230 was identified as the intrinsic fluorophore responsible for the observed quenching pattern. The affinity for Zn2+ could be increased by incubating the ferrochelatase with the transition state analogue N-methyl mesoporphyrin IX, which reflected a close collaborative arrangement between the two substrates in the active site. We also showed that the affinity for Zn2+ was lowered in the presence of Mg2+ and that bound Zn2+ was released upon binding of Mg2+. In the ferrochelatase with a Glu272Ser modification, the interaction between Zn2+ and Mg2+ was abolished. It could thereby be demonstrated that the presence of a metal at one metal binding site affected the metal affinity of another, providing the enzyme with a site that regulates the enzymatic activity.

Metallation of the Transition-state Inhibitor N-methyl Mesoporphyrin by Ferrochelatase: Implications for the Catalytic Reaction Mechanism

Insertion of metals into various tetrapyrroles is catalysed by a group of enzymes called chelatases, e.g. nickel, cobalt, magnesium and ferro-chelatase. It has been proposed that catalytic metallation includes distorting the porphyrin substrate by the enzyme towards a transition state-like geometry in which at least one of the pyrrole rings will be available for metal chelation. Here, we present a study of metal insertion into the transition-state inhibitor of protoporphyrin IX ferrochelatase, N-methyl mesoporphyrin (N-MeMP), by time-resolved crystallography and mass spectrometry with and without the presence of ferrochelatase. The results show that metallation of N-MeMP has a very limited effect on the conformation of the residues that participate in porphyrin and metal binding. These findings support theoretical data, which indicate that product release is controlled largely by the strain created by metal insertion into the distorted porphyrin. The results suggest that, similar to non-catalytic metallation of N-MeMP, the ferrochelatase-assisted metallation depends on the ligand exchange rate for the respective metal. Moreover, ferrochelatase catalyses insertion of Cu(II) and Zn(II) into N-MeMP with a rate that is about 20 times faster than non-enzymatic metallation in solution, suggesting that the catalytic strategy of ferrochelatase includes a stage of acceleration of the rate of ligand exchange for the metal substrate. The greater efficiency of N-MeMP metallation by Cu(II), as compared to Zn(II), contrasts with the K(m) values for Zn(II) (17 microM) and Cu(II) (170 microM) obtained for metallation of protoporphyrin IX. We suggest that this difference in metal specificity depends on the type of distortion imposed by the enzyme on protoporphyrin IX, which is different from the intrinsic non-planar distortion of N-MeMP. A mechanism of control of metal specificity by porphyrin distortion may be general for different chelatases, and may have common features with the mechanism of metal specificity in crown ethers.

Porphyrin-substrate binding to murine ferrochelatase: effect on the thermal stability of the enzyme

Ferrochelatase (EC 4.99.1.1), the terminal enzyme of the haem biosynthetic pathway, catalyses the chelation of Fe(II) into the protoporphyrin IX ring. The energetics of the binding between murine ferrochelatase and mesoporphyrin were determined using isothermal titration calorimetry, which revealed a stoichiometry of one molecule of mesoporphyrin bound per protein monomer. The binding is strongly exothermic, with a large intrinsic enthalpy (DeltaH=-97.1 kJ x mol(-1)), and is associated with the uptake of two protons from the buffer. This proton transfer suggests that hydrogen bonding between ferrochelatase and mesoporphyrin is a key factor in the thermodynamics of the binding reaction. Differential scanning calorimetry thermograms indicated a co-operative two-state denaturation process with a single transition temperature of 56 degrees C for wild-type murine ferrochelatase. An increase in the thermal stability of ferrochelatase is dependent upon mesoporphyrin binding. Similarly, murine ferrochelatase variants, in which the active site Glu-289 was replaced by either glutamine or alanine and, when purified, contained specifically-bound protoporphyrin, exhibited enhanced protein stability when compared with wild-type ferrochelatase. However, in contrast with the wild-type enzyme, the thermal denaturation of ferrochelatase variants was best described as a non-co-operative denaturation process.

Metal binding to Bacillus subtilis ferrochelatase and interaction between metal sites

Ferrochelatase, the terminal enzyme in heme biosynthesis, catalyses metal insertion into protoporphyrin IX. The location of the metal binding site with respect to the bound porphyrin substrate and the mode of metal binding are of central importance for understanding the mechanism of porphyrin metallation. In this work we demonstrate that Zn(2+), which is commonly used as substrate in assays of the ferrochelatase reaction, and Cd(2+), an inhibitor of the enzyme, bind to the invariant amino acids His183 and Glu264 and water molecules, all located within the porphyrin binding cleft. On the other hand, Mg(2+), which has been shown to bind close to the surface at 7 A from His183, was largely absent from its site. Activity measurements demonstrate that Mg(2+) has a stimulatory effect on the enzyme, lowering K(M) for Zn(2+) from 55 to 24 micro M. Changing one of the Mg(2+) binding residues, Glu272, to serine abolishes the effect of Mg(2+). It is proposed that prior to metal insertion the metal may form a sitting-atop (SAT) complex with the invariant His-Glu couple and the porphyrin. Metal binding to the Mg(2+) site may stimulate metal release from the protein ligands and its insertion into the porphyrin.

Origin of the red shifts in the optical absorption bands of nonplanar tetraalkylporphyrins

The view that the large red shifts seen in the UV-visible absorption bands of peripherally crowded nonplanar porphyrins are the result of nonplanar deformations of the macrocycle has recently been challenged by the suggestion that the red shifts arise from substituent-induced changes in the macrocycle bond lengths and bond angles, termed in-plane nuclear reorganization (IPNR). We have analyzed the contributions to the UV-visible band shifts in a series of nickel or zinc meso-tetraalkylporphyrins to establish the origins of the red shifts in these ruffled porphyrins. Structures were obtained using a molecular mechanics force field optimized for porphyrins, and the nonplanar deformations were quantified by using normal-coordinate structural decomposition (NSD). Transition energies were calculated by the INDO/S semiempirical method. These computational studies demonstrate conclusively that the large Soret band red shifts ( approximately 40 nm) seen for very nonplanar meso-tetra(tert-butyl)porphyrin compared to meso-tetra(methyl)porphyrin are primarily the result of nonplanar deformations and not IPNR. Strikingly, nonplanar deformations along the high-frequency 2B(1u) and 3B(1u) normal coordinates of the macrocycle are shown to contribute significantly to the observed red shifts, even though these deformations are an order of magnitude smaller than the observed ruffling (1B(1u)) deformation. Other structural and electronic influences on the UV-visible band shifts are discussed and problems with the recent studies are examined (e.g., the systematic underestimation of the 2B(1u) and 3B(1u) modes in artificially constrained porphyrin structures that leads to a mistaken attribution of the red shift to IPNR). The effect of nonplanar deformations on the UV-visible absorption bands is then probed experimentally with a series of novel bridled nickel chiroporphyrins. In these compounds, the substituent effect is essentially invariant and the amount of nonplanar deformation decreases as the length of the straps connecting adjacent meso-cyclopropyl substituents decreases (the opposite of the effect observed for conventional strapped porphyrins). Several spectroscopic markers for nonplanarity (UV-visible bands, resonance Raman lines, and (1)H NMR resonances) are found to correlate with time-averaged deformations obtained from an NSD analysis of molecular dynamics snapshot structures. These results suggest that UV-visible band shifts of tetrapyrroles in proteins are potentially useful indicators of changes in nonplanarity provided other structural and electronic factors can be eliminated.