Evidence for structural changes in carboxyl-terminal peptides of transducin alpha-subunit upon binding a soluble mimic of light-activated rhodopsin

Evidence that the Rhodopsin Kinase (GRK1) N-Terminus and the Transducin Gα C-Terminus Interact with the Same "Hydrophobic Patch" on Rhodopsin TM5

Phosphorylation of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) terminates their ability to couple with and activate G proteins by increasing their affinity for arrestins. Unfortunately, detailed information regarding how GPCRs interact with the kinases responsible for their phosphorylation is still limited. Here, we purified fully functional GPCR kinase 1 (GRK1) using a rapid method and used it to gain insights into how this important kinase interacts with the GPCR rhodopsin. Specifically, we find that GRK1 uses the same site on rhodopsin as the transducin (Gt) Gtα C-terminal tail and the arrestin "finger loop", a cleft formed in the cytoplasmic face of the receptor upon activation. Our studies also show GRK1 requires two conserved residues located in this cleft (L226 and V230) that have been shown to be required for Gt activation due to their direct interactions with hydrophobic residues on the Gα C-terminal tail. Our data and modeling studies are consistent with the idea that all three proteins (Gt, GRK1, and visual arrestin) bind, at least in part, in the same site on rhodopsin and interact with the receptor through a similar hydrophobic contact-driven mechanism.

Structural mechanism of G protein activation by G protein-coupled receptor

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are a family of membrane receptors that regulate physiology and pathology of various organs. Consequently, about 40% of drugs in the market targets GPCRs. Heterotrimeric G proteins are composed of α, β, and γ subunits, and act as the key downstream signaling molecules of GPCRs. The structural mechanism of G protein activation by GPCRs has been of a great interest, and a number of biochemical and biophysical studies have been performed since the late 80's. These studies investigated the interface between GPCR and G proteins and the structural mechanism of GPCR-induced G protein activation. Recently, arrestins are also reported to be important molecular switches in GPCR-mediated signal transduction, and the physiological output of arrestin-mediated signal transduction is different from that of G protein-mediated signal transduction. Understanding the structural mechanism of the activation of G proteins and arrestins would provide fundamental information for the downstream signaling-selective GPCR-targeting drug development. This review will discuss the structural mechanism of GPCR-induced G protein activation by comparing previous biochemical and biophysical studies.

Structural Aspects of GPCR-G Protein Coupling

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are membrane receptors; approximately 40% of drugs on the market target GPCRs. A precise understanding of the activation mechanism of GPCRs would facilitate the development of more effective and less toxic drugs. Heterotrimeric G proteins are important molecular switches in GPCR-mediated signal transduction. An agonist-activated receptor interacts with specific sites on G proteins and promotes the release of GDP from the Gα subunit. Because of the important biological role of the GPCR-G protein coupling, conformational changes in the G protein upon receptor coupling have been of great interest. One of the most important questions was the interface between the GPCR and G proteins and the structural mechanism of GPCR-induced G protein activation. A number of biochemical and biophysical studies have been performed since the late 80s to address these questions; there was a significant breakthrough in 2011 when the crystal structure of a GPCR-G protein complex was solved. This review discusses the structural aspects of GPCR-G protein coupling by comparing the results of previous biochemical and biophysical studies to the GPCR-G protein crystal structure.

Fluorescence spectroscopy of rhodopsins: insights and approaches

Fluorescence spectroscopy has become an established tool at the interface of biology, chemistry and physics because of its exquisite sensitivity and recent technical advancements. However, rhodopsin proteins present the fluorescence spectroscopist with a unique set of challenges and opportunities due to the presence of the light-sensitive retinal chromophore. This review briefly summarizes some approaches that have successfully met these challenges and the novel insights they have yielded about rhodopsin structure and function. We start with a brief overview of fluorescence fundamentals and experimental methodologies, followed by more specific discussions of technical challenges rhodopsin proteins present to fluorescence studies. Finally, we end by discussing some of the unique insights that have been gained specifically about visual rhodopsin and its interactions with affiliate proteins through the use of fluorescence spectroscopy. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Retinal Proteins - You can teach an old dog new tricks.

Linking receptor activation to changes in Sw I and II of Gα proteins

G-protein coupled receptors catalyze nucleotide exchange on G proteins, which results in subunit dissociation and effector activation. In the recent β2AR-Gs structure, portions of Switch I and II of Gα are not fully elucidated. We paired fluorescence studies of receptor-Gαi interactions with the β2AR-Gs and other Gi structures to investigate changes in Switch I and II during receptor activation and GTP binding. The β2/β3 loop containing Leu194 of Gαi is located between Switches I and II, in close proximity to IC2 of the receptor and the C-terminus of Gα, thus providing an allosteric connection between these Switches and receptor activation. We compared the environment of residues in myristoylated Gαi proteins in the heterotrimer to that upon receptor activation and subsequent GTP binding. Upon receptor activation, residues in both Switch regions are less solvent-exposed, as compared to the heterotrimer. Upon GTPγS binding, the environment of several residues in Switch I resemble the receptor-bound state, while Switch II residues display effects on their environment which are consistent with their role in GTP binding and Gβγ dissociation. The ability to merge available crystal structures with solution studies is a powerful tool to gain insight into conformational changes associated with receptor-mediated Gi protein activation.

What site-directed labeling studies tell us about the mechanism of rhodopsin activation and G-protein binding

Rhodopsin is the photoreceptor protein responsible for dim-light vision in mammals. Due to extensive biophysical, structural and computational analysis of this membrane protein, it is presently the best understood G-protein coupled receptor (GPCR). Here I briefly review one approach that has been extensively used to identify dynamic and structural changes in rhodopsin--the use of site-directed labeling methods (SDL) coupled with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and fluorescence spectroscopy. These SDL studies involve introducing individual cysteine residues into the receptor, then labeling them with cysteine-reactive probes for subsequent analysis by the appropriate spectroscopy. I will give a brief overview of how SDL methods are carried out and how the data is analyzed. Then, I will discuss how SDL studies were carried out on rhodopsin, and how they were used to identify a key structural change that occurs in rhodopsin upon activation--movement of transmembrane helix 6 (TM6). I will also briefly discuss how the SDL studies of rhodopsin compare with SDL studies of other GPCRs, and compare the SDL data with early and recent crystal structures of rhodopsin. Finally, I will discuss why the TM6 movement is required for rhodopsin to couple with the G-protein transducin, and speculate how this mechanism might be a universal method used by all GPCRs to bind G-proteins and perhaps other proteins involved in visual signal transduction, such as arrestin and rhodopsin kinase.

Signal transducing membrane complexes of photoreceptor outer segments

Signal transduction in outer segments of vertebrate photoreceptors is mediated by a series of reactions among multiple polypeptides that form protein-protein complexes within or on the surface of the disk and plasma membranes. The individual components in the activation reactions include the photon receptor rhodopsin and the products of its absorption of light, the three subunits of the G protein, transducin, the four subunits of the cGMP phosphodiesterase, PDE6 and the four subunits of the cGMP-gated cation channel. Recovery involves membrane complexes with additional polypeptides including the Na(+)/Ca(2+), K(+) exchanger, NCKX2, rhodopsin kinases RK1 and RK7, arrestin, guanylate cyclases, guanylate cyclase activating proteins, GCAP1 and GCAP2, and the GTPase accelerating complex of RGS9-1, G(beta5L), and membrane anchor R9AP. Modes of membrane binding by these polypeptides include transmembrane helices, fatty acyl or isoprenyl modifications, polar interactions with lipid head groups, non-polar interactions of hydrophobic side chains with lipid hydrocarbon phase, and both polar and non-polar protein-protein interactions. In the course of signal transduction, complexes among these polypeptides form and dissociate, and undergo structural rearrangements that are coupled to their interactions with and catalysis of reactions by small molecules and ions, including guanine nucleotides, ATP, Ca(2+), Mg(2+), and lipids. The substantial progress that has been made in understanding the composition and function of these complexes is reviewed, along with the more preliminary state of our understanding of the structures of these complexes and the challenges and opportunities that present themselves for deepening our understanding of these complexes, and how they work together to convert a light signal into an electrical signal.

Relative strength of cation-pi vs salt-bridge interactions: the Gtalpha(340-350) peptide/rhodopsin system

Interactions between cationic and aromatic side chains of amino acid residues, the so-called cation-pi interaction, are thought to contribute to the overall stability of the folded structure of peptides and proteins. The transferred NOE NMR structure of the G(t)alpha(340-350) peptide bound to photoactivated rhodopsin (R*) geometrically suggests a cation-pi interaction stabilizing the structure between the epsilon-amine of Lys341 and the aromatic ring of the C-terminal residue, Phe350. This interaction has been explored by varying substituents on the phenyl ring to alter the electron density of the aromatic ring of Phe350 and observing the impact on binding of the peptide to R*. The results suggest that while a cation-pi interaction geometrically exists in the G(t)alpha(340-350) peptide when bound to R*, its energetic contribution to the stability of the receptor-bound structure is relatively insignificant, as it was not observed experimentally. The presence of an adjacent and competing salt-bridge interaction between the epsilon-amine of Lys341 and the C-terminal carboxylate of Phe350 effectively shields the charge of the ammonium group. Experimental data supporting a significant cation-pi interaction can be regained through a series of Phe350 analogues where the C-terminal carboxyl has been converted to the neutral carboxamide, thus eliminating the shielding salt-bridge. TrNOE NMR experiments confirmed the existence of the cation-pi interaction in the carboxamide analogues. Various literature estimates of the strength of cation-pi interactions, including some that estimate strengths in excess of salt-bridges, are compromised by omission of the relevant anion in the calculations.

G protein-coupled receptor rhodopsin

The rhodopsin crystal structure provides a structural basis for understanding the function of this and other G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). The major structural motifs observed for rhodopsin are expected to carry over to other GPCRs, and the mechanism of transformation of the receptor from inactive to active forms is thus likely conserved. Moreover, the high expression level of rhodopsin in the retina, its specific localization in the internal disks of the photoreceptor structures [termed rod outer segments (ROS)], and the lack of other highly abundant membrane proteins allow rhodopsin to be examined in the native disk membranes by a number of methods. The results of these investigations provide evidence of the propensity of rhodopsin and, most likely, other GPCRs to dimerize, a property that may be pertinent to their function.

Modular architecture of protein structures and allosteric communications: potential implications for signaling proteins and regulatory linkages

BACKGROUND

Allosteric communications are vital for cellular signaling. Here we explore a relationship between protein architectural organization and shortcuts in signaling pathways.

RESULTS

We show that protein domains consist of modules interconnected by residues that mediate signaling through the shortest pathways. These mediating residues tend to be located at the inter-modular boundaries, which are more rigid and display a larger number of long-range interactions than intra-modular regions. The inter-modular boundaries contain most of the residues centrally conserved in the protein fold, which may be crucial for information transfer between amino acids. Our approach to modular decomposition relies on a representation of protein structures as residue-interacting networks, and removal of the most central residue contacts, which are assumed to be crucial for allosteric communications. The modular decomposition of 100 multi-domain protein structures indicates that modules constitute the building blocks of domains. The analysis of 13 allosteric proteins revealed that modules characterize experimentally identified functional regions. Based on the study of an additional functionally annotated dataset of 115 proteins, we propose that high-modularity modules include functional sites and are the basic functional units. We provide examples (the Galphas subunit and P450 cytochromes) to illustrate that the modular architecture of active sites is linked to their functional specialization.

CONCLUSION

Our method decomposes protein structures into modules, allowing the study of signal transmission between functional sites. A modular configuration might be advantageous: it allows signaling proteins to expand their regulatory linkages and may elicit a broader range of control mechanisms either via modular combinations or through modulation of inter-modular linkages.

Alternate Binding Mode of C-terminal Phenethylamine Analogs of Gt?(340?350) to Photoactivated Rhodopsin

The C-terminus of the Galpha-subunit of transducin plays an important role in receptor recognition. Synthetic peptides corresponding to the last 11 residues of the subunit have been shown to stabilize the photoactivated form of rhodopsin, Rh*. The Rh*-bound structure of the G(t)alpha(340-350) peptide has been determined using transferred nuclear overhauser effect NMR. In that structure, we observed two interactions between Lys341 and Phe350, a cation-pi interaction between the epsilon-amine and the aromatic ring of Phe350 and a salt-bridge between the epsilon-amine and the C-terminal carboxylate. A series of C-terminal phenethylamine analogs of the G(t)alpha(340-350) peptide were synthesized, lacking the C-terminal carboxylate group, to investigate the forces that contribute to the stability of the Rh*-bound conformation of the peptide. Rh*-stabilization assay data suggest that the C-terminal carboxylate is not necessary to maintain binding affinity. Transferred nuclear overhauser effect NMR experiments reveal that these C-terminal phenethylamine peptides adopt an Rh*-bound structure that is similar overall, but lacking some of the intramolecular interactions observed in the native Rh*-bound G(t)alpha(340-350) structure. These studies suggest that the binding site for G(t)alpha(340-350) on Rh* is adaptable, and we propose that the charged carboxylate of Phe350 does not play a significant role in the interaction with Rh*, but helps stabilize the Rh*-bound confirmation of the native peptide.

NMR analysis of rhodopsin–transducin interactions

Heterotrimeric G-protein activation by an agonist-stimulated G-protein coupled receptor (R*) requires the propagation of structural signals from the receptor interacting surfaces to the guanine nucleotide-binding pocket. Employing high-resolution NMR methods, we are probing heterotrimer-associated and rhodopsin-stimulated changes in an isotope-labeled G-protein alpha-subunit (G(alpha)). A key aspect of the work involves the trapping and interrogation of discrete R*-bound conformations of G(alpha). Our results demonstrate that functionally important changes in G(alpha) structure and dynamics can be detected and characterized by NMR, enabling the generation of robust models for the global and local structural changes accompanying signal transfer from R* to the G-protein.

Rhodopsin-transducin coupling: role of the Galpha C-terminus in nucleotide exchange catalysis

In the early steps of visual signal transduction, light-activated rhodopsin (R*) catalyzes GDP/GTP exchange in the heterotrimeric G protein (Galphabetagamma) transducin. We recently reported that the catalytic interaction involves two sequential steps. An initial docking between R* and Gbetagamma leads to conformational changes which make the C-terminus of Galpha (CTalpha) available for binding to R*. Binding of CTalpha by R* then triggers GDP/GTP exchange in the Galpha subunit. To further study this two-step mechanism, we investigated different single amino acid substitutions within CTalpha and discuss the effects of high affinity mutations on nucleotide exchange catalysis.

Conformational changes associated with receptor-stimulated guanine nucleotide exchange in a heterotrimeric G-protein alpha-subunit: NMR analysis of GTPgammaS-bound states

Solution NMR studies of a (15)N-labeled G-protein alpha-subunit (G(alpha)) chimera ((15)N-ChiT)-reconstituted heterotrimer have shown previously that G-protein betagamma-subunit (G(betagamma)) association induces a "pre-activated" conformation that likely facilitates interaction with the agonist-activated form of a G-protein-coupled receptor (R*) and guanine nucleotide exchange (Abdulaev, N. G., Ngo, T., Zhang, C., Dinh, A., Brabazon, D. M., Ridge, K. D., and Marino, J. P. (2005) J. Biol. Chem. 280, 38071-38080). Here we demonstrated that the (15)N-ChiT-reconstituted heterotrimer can form functional complexes under NMR experimental conditions with light-activated, detergent-solubilized rhodopsin (R*), as well as a soluble mimic of R*. NMR methods were used to track R*-triggered guanine nucleotide exchange and release of guanosine 5'-O-3-thiotriphosphate (GTPgammaS)/Mg(2+)-bound ChiT. A heteronuclear single quantum correlation (HSQC) spectrum of R*-generated GTPgammaS/Mg(2+)-bound ChiT revealed (1)HN, (15)N chemical shift changes relative to GDP/Mg(2+)-bound ChiT that were similar, but not identical, to those observed for the GDP.AlF(4)(-)/Mg(2+)-bound state. Line widths observed for R*-generated GTPgammaS/Mg(2+)-bound (15)N-ChiT, however, indicated that it is more conformationally dynamic relative to the GDP/Mg(2+)- and GDP.AlF(4)(-)/Mg(2+)-bound states. The increased dynamics appeared to be correlated with G(betagamma) and R* interactions because they are not observed for GTPgammaS/Mg(2+)-bound ChiT generated independently of R*. In contrast to R*, a soluble mimic that does not catalytically interact with G-protein (Abdulaev, N. G., Ngo, T., Chen, R., Lu, Z., and Ridge, K. D. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 39354-39363) is found to form a stable complex with the GTPgammaS/Mg(2+)-exchanged heterotrimer. The HSQC spectrum of (15)N-ChiT in this complex displays a unique chemical shift pattern that nonetheless shares similarities with the heterotrimer and GTPgammaS/Mg(2+)-bound ChiT. Overall, these results demonstrated that R*-induced changes in G(alpha) can be followed by NMR and that guanine nucleotide exchange can be uncoupled from heterotrimer dissociation.

Heterotrimeric G-protein α-Subunit Adopts a “Preactivated” Conformation When Associated with βγ-Subunits

Activation of a heterotrimeric G-protein by an agonist-stimulated G-protein-coupled receptor requires the propagation of structural signals from the receptor binding interface to the guanine nucleotide binding pocket of the G-protein. To probe the molecular basis of this signaling process, we are applying high resolution NMR to track structural changes in an isotope-labeled, full-length G-protein alpha-subunit (G(alpha)) chimera (ChiT) associated with G-protein betagamma-subunit (G(betagamma)) and activated receptor (R(*)) interactions. Here, we show that ChiT can be functionally reconstituted with G(betagamma) as assessed by aluminum fluoride-dependent changes in intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence and light-activated rhodopsin-catalyzed guanine nucleotide exchange. We further show that (15)N-ChiT can be titrated with G(betagamma) to form stable heterotrimers at NMR concentrations. To assess structural changes in ChiT upon heterotrimer formation, HSQC spectra of the (15)N-ChiT-reconstituted heterotrimer have been acquired and compared with spectra obtained for GDP/Mg(2+)-bound (15)N-ChiT in the presence and absence of aluminum fluoride and guanosine 5'-3-O-(thio)triphosphate (GTPgammaS)/Mg(2+)-bound (15)N-ChiT. As anticipated, G(betagamma) association with (15)N-ChiT results in (1)HN, (15)N chemical shift changes relative to the GDP/Mg(2+)-bound state. Strikingly, however, most (1)HN, (15)N chemical shift changes associated with heterotrimer formation are the same as those observed upon formation of the GDP.AlF(4)(-)/Mg(2+)- and GTPgammaS/Mg(2+)-bound states. Based on these comparative analyses, assembly of the heterotrimer appears to induce structural changes in the switch II and carboxyl-terminal regions of G(alpha) ("preactivation") that may facilitate the interaction with R(*) and subsequent GDP/GTP exchange.

G protein-coupled receptors show unusual patterns of intrinsic unfolding

Intrinsically unstructured proteins (IUPs) or IUP-like regions often play key roles in controlling processes ranging from transcription to the cell cycle. In silico such proteins can be identified by their sequence properties; they have low hydrophobicity and high net charge. In this study, we applied the FoldIndex (http://bioportal.weizmann.ac.il/fldbin/findex) program to analyze human G protein-coupled receptors and compared them with membrane proteins of known structure and with IUPs. We show that human G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) extramembranous domains include long (>50 residues) disordered segments, unlike membrane proteins of known structure. The predicted disorder occurred primarily in the N-terminal, C-terminal and third intracellular domain regions: 55, 69 and 56% of the human GPCRs were disordered in these regions, respectively. This increased flexibility may therefore be critical for GPCR function. Surprisingly, however, the kinds of residues used in GPCR unstructured regions were different than in hitherto-identified IUPs. The GPCR third intracellular loop domains contain very high percentages of Arg, Lys and His residues, especially Arg, but the percentage of Glu, Asp and Pro is no higher than in folded proteins. We propose that this has structural and functional consequences.

Rhodopsin activation exposes a key hydrophobic binding site for the transducin alpha-subunit C terminus

Conformational changes enable the photoreceptor rhodopsin to couple with and activate the G-protein transducin. Here we demonstrate a key interaction between these proteins occurs between the C terminus of the transducin alpha-subunit (G(Talpha)) and a hydrophobic cleft in the rhodopsin cytoplasmic face exposed during receptor activation. We mapped this interaction by labeling rhodopsin mutants with the fluorescent probe bimane and then assessed how binding of a peptide analogue of the G(Talpha) C terminus (containing a tryptophan quenching group) affected their fluorescence. From these and other assays, we conclude that the G(Talpha) C-terminal tail binds to the inner face of helix 6 in a retinal-linked manner. Further, we find that a "hydrophobic patch" comprising key residues in the exposed cleft is required for transducin binding/activation because it enhances the binding affinity for the G(Talpha) C-terminal tail, contributing up to 3 kcal/mol for this interaction. We speculate the hydrophobic interactions identified here may be important in other GPCR signaling systems, and our Trp/bimane fluorescence methodology may be generally useful for mapping sites of protein-protein interaction.

G protein signaling: insights from new structures

A large body of experimental evidence exists that links heterotrimeric guanosine triphosphate-binding protein (G protein) structure to function. The determination of the crystal structures of G proteins in various activational states and, more recently, in complexes with effectors and other signaling partners highlights the varied mechanisms involved in G protein regulation. Signaling complexes, such as the recently solved complex of Gbetagamma and G protein receptor kinase 2 (GRK2), provide new insights into the mechanisms underlying the regulation of these highly conserved signaling molecules. In this Review, we discuss the latest findings and their implications for G protein-signaling paradigms.

Phototransduction: crystal clear

Vertebrate visual phototransduction represents one of the best-characterized G-protein-coupled receptor-mediated signaling pathways. Structural analyses of rhodopsin, G protein, arrestin and several other phototransduction components have revealed common folds and motifs that are important for function. Static and dynamic information has been acquired through the application of X-ray diffraction, solution and solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy's, electron and atomic force microscopy's, and a host of indirect structural methods. A comprehensive understanding of phototransduction requires further structural work on individual components and their relevant complexes in solution and the native disk membrane. Given the accelerated pace of structure determination, it is anticipated that this will be the first G-protein-coupled pathway for which a complete molecular description is ultimately available.