Free-energy landscapes of ion-channel gating are malleable: changes in the number of bound ligands are accompanied by changes in the location of the transition state in acetylcholine-receptor channels

The effect of unliganded gating on agonist response in nicotinic receptors

Understanding the agonist concentration-response curve (CRC) is the cornerstone in pharmacology. While CRC parameters, agonist potency (EC50) and efficacy (maximum response, Imax) are well-studied, the role of unliganded gating (minimum response, Imin) on CRC is often overlooked. This study explores the effect of unliganded gating on agonist response in muscle-type acetylcholine (ACh) receptors, focusing on the underexplored role of Imin in modulating EC50 and Imax. Three Gain-of-Function (GOF) mutations that increase, and two Loss-of-Function (LOF) mutations that decrease the unliganded gating equilibrium constant (L0) were studied using automated patch-clamp electrophysiology. GOF mutations enhanced agonist potency, whereas LOF mutations reduced it. The calculated CRC aligned well with empirical results, indicating that agonist CRC can be estimated from knowledge of L0. Reduction in agonist efficacy due to LOF mutations was calculated and subsequently validated using single-channel patch-clamp electrophysiology, a factor often obscured in normalized CRC. The study also evaluated the combined impact of mutations (L0) on CRC, confirming the predictive model. Further, no significant energetic coupling between distant residues (>15 Å) was found, indicating that the mutations' effects are localized and do not alter overall agonist affinity. These findings substantiate the role of unliganded gating in modulating agonist responses and establishes a predictive model for estimating CRC parameters from known changes in L0. The study highlights the importance of intrinsic activity in receptor theory.

Mechanism of hydrophobic gating in the acetylcholine receptor channel pore

Neuromuscular acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) are hetero-pentameric, ligand-gated ion channels. The binding of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine (ACh) to two target sites promotes a global conformational change of the receptor that opens the channel and allows ion conduction through the channel pore. Here, by measuring free-energy changes from single-channel current recordings and using molecular dynamics simulations, we elucidate how a constricted hydrophobic region acts as a "gate" to regulate the channel opening in the pore of AChRs. Mutations of gate residues, including those implicated in congenital myasthenia syndrome, lower the permeation barrier of the channel substantially and increase the unliganded gating equilibrium constant (constitutive channel openings). Correlations between hydrophobicity and the observed free-energy changes, supported by calculations of water densities in the wild-type versus mutant channel pores, provide evidence for hydrophobic wetting-dewetting transition at the gate. The analysis of a coupled interaction network provides insight into the molecular mechanism of closed- versus open-state conformational changes at the gate. Studies of the transition state by "phi"(φ)-value analysis indicate that agonist binding serves to stabilize both the transition and the open state. Intersubunit interaction energy measurements and molecular dynamics simulations suggest that channel opening involves tilting of the pore-lining M2 helices, asymmetric outward rotation of amino acid side chains, and wetting transition of the gate region that lowers the barrier to ion permeation and stabilizes the channel open conformation. Our work provides new insight into the hydrophobic gate opening and shows why the gate mutations result in constitutive AChR channel activity.

Pathways for nicotinic receptor desensitization

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) are ligand-gated ion channels that generate transient currents by binding agonists and switching rapidly between closed- and open-channel conformations. Upon sustained exposure to ACh, the cell response diminishes slowly because of desensitization, a process that shuts the channel even with agonists still bound. In liganded receptors, the main desensitization pathway is from the open-channel conformation, but after agonists dissociate the main recovery pathway is to the closed-channel conformation. In this Viewpoint, I discuss two mechanisms that can explain the selection of different pathways, a question that has puzzled the community for 60 yr. The first is based on a discrete-state model (the “prism”), in which closed, open, and desensitized conformational states interconnect directly. This model predicts that 5% of unliganded AChRs are desensitized. Different pathways are taken with versus without agonists because ligands have different energy properties (φ values) at the transition states of the desensitization and recovery reactions. The second is a potential energy surface model (the “monkey saddle”), in which the states connect indirectly at a shared transition state region. Different pathways are taken because agonists shift the position of the gating transition state relative to the point where gating and desensitization conformational trajectories intersect. Understanding desensitization pathways appears to be a problem of kinetics rather than of thermodynamics. Other aspects of the two mechanisms are considered, as are experiments that may someday distinguish them.

The atypical cation-conduction and gating properties of ELIC underscore the marked functional versatility of the pentameric ligand-gated ion-channel fold

The superfamily of pentameric ligand-gated ion channels (pLGICs) is unique among ionotropic receptors in that the same overall structure has evolved to generate multiple members with different combinations of agonist specificities and permeant-ion charge selectivities. However, aside from these differences, pLGICs have been typically regarded as having several invariant functional properties. These include pore blockade by extracellular quaternary-ammonium cations in the micromolar-to-millimolar concentration range (in the case of the cation-selective members), and a gain-of-function phenotype, which manifests as a slower deactivation time course, as a result of mutations that reduce the hydrophobicity of the transmembrane pore lining. Here, we tested this notion on three distantly related cation-selective members of the pLGIC superfamily: the mouse muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR), and the bacterial GLIC and ELIC channels. Remarkably, we found that, whereas low millimolar concentrations of TMA(+) and TEA(+) block the nAChR and GLIC, neither of these two quaternary-ammonium cations blocks ELIC at such concentrations; instead, both carry measurable inward currents when present as the only cations on the extracellular side. Also, we found that, whereas lidocaine binding speeds up the current-decay time courses of the nAChR and GLIC in the presence of saturating concentrations of agonists, the binding of lidocaine to ELIC slows this time course down. Furthermore, whereas mutations that reduce the hydrophobicity of the side chains at position 9' of the M2 α-helices greatly slowed the deactivation time course of the nAChR and GLIC, these mutations had little effect--or even sped up deactivation--when engineered in ELIC. Our data indicate that caution should be exercised when generalizing results obtained with ELIC to the rest of the pLGICs, but more intriguingly, they hint at the possibility that ELIC is a representative of a novel branch of the superfamily with markedly divergent pore properties despite a well-conserved three-dimensional architecture.

Functional anatomy of an allosteric protein

Synaptic receptors are allosteric proteins that switch on and off to regulate cell signalling. Here, we use single-channel electrophysiology to measure and map energy changes in the gating conformational change of a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Two separated regions in the α-subunits--the transmitter-binding sites and αM2-αM3 linkers in the membrane domain--have the highest ϕ-values (change conformation the earliest), followed by the extracellular domain, most of the membrane domain and the gate. Large gating-energy changes occur at the transmitter-binding sites, α-subunit interfaces, the αM1 helix and the gate. We hypothesize that rearrangements of the linkers trigger the global allosteric transition, and that the hydrophobic gate unlocks in three steps. The mostly local character of side-chain energy changes and the similarly high ϕ-values of separated domains, both with and without ligands, suggest that gating is not strictly a mechanical process initiated by the affinity change for the agonist.

End-plate acetylcholine receptor: structure, mechanism, pharmacology, and disease

The synapse is a localized neurohumoral contact between a neuron and an effector cell and may be considered the quantum of fast intercellular communication. Analogously, the postsynaptic neurotransmitter receptor may be considered the quantum of fast chemical to electrical transduction. Our understanding of postsynaptic receptors began to develop about a hundred years ago with the demonstration that electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve released acetylcholine and slowed the heart beat. During the past 50 years, advances in understanding postsynaptic receptors increased at a rapid pace, owing largely to studies of the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) at the motor endplate. The endplate AChR belongs to a large superfamily of neurotransmitter receptors, called Cys-loop receptors, and has served as an exemplar receptor for probing fundamental structures and mechanisms that underlie fast synaptic transmission in the central and peripheral nervous systems. Recent studies provide an increasingly detailed picture of the structure of the AChR and the symphony of molecular motions that underpin its remarkably fast and efficient chemoelectrical transduction.

The α1K276E startle disease mutation reveals multiple intermediate states in the gating of glycine receptors

Loss-of-function mutations in human glycine receptors cause hyperekplexia, a rare inherited disease associated with an exaggerated startle response. We have studied a human disease mutation in the M2-M3 loop of the glycine receptor α1 subunit (K276E) using direct fitting of mechanisms to single-channel recordings with the program HJCFIT. Whole-cell recordings from HEK293 cells showed the mutation reduced the receptor glycine sensitivity. In single-channel recordings, rat homomeric α1 K276E receptors were barely active, even at 200 mM glycine. Coexpression of the β subunit partially rescued channel function. Heteromeric mutant channels opened in brief bursts at 300 μM glycine (a concentration that is near-maximal for wild type) and reached a maximum one-channel open probability of about 45% at 100 mm glycine (compared to 96% for wild type). Distributions of apparent open times contained more than one component in high glycine and, therefore, could not be described by mechanisms with only one fully liganded open state. Fits to the data were much better with mechanisms in which opening can also occur from more than one fully liganded intermediate (e.g., "primed" models). Brief pulses of glycine (∼3 ms, 30 mM) applied to mutant channels in outside-out patches activated currents with a slower rise time (1.5 ms) than those of wild-type channels (0.2 ms) and a much faster decay. These features were predicted reasonably well by the mechanisms obtained from fitting single-channel data. Our results show that, by slowing and impairing channel gating, the K276E mutation facilitates the detection of closed reaction intermediates in the activation pathway of glycine channels.

Glycine hinges with opposing actions at the acetylcholine receptor-channel transmitter binding site

The extent to which agonists activate synaptic receptor-channels depends on both the intrinsic tendency of the unliganded receptor to open and the amount of agonist binding energy realized in the channel-opening process. We examined mutations of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor transmitter binding site (α subunit loop B) with regard to both of these parameters. αGly147 is an "activation" hinge where backbone flexibility maintains high values for intrinsic gating, the affinity of the resting conformation for agonists and net ligand binding energy. αGly153 is a "deactivation" hinge that maintains low values for these parameters. αTrp149 (between these two glycines) serves mainly to provide ligand binding energy for gating. We propose that a concerted motion of the two glycine hinges (plus other structural elements at the binding site) positions αTrp149 so that it provides physiologically optimal binding and gating function at the nerve-muscle synapse.

Relationships between structural dynamics and functional kinetics in oligomeric membrane receptors

Recent efforts to broaden understanding of the molecular mechanisms of membrane receptors in signal transduction make use of rate-equilibrium free-energy relationships (REFERs), previously applied to chemical reactions, enzyme kinetics, and protein folding. For oligomeric membrane receptors, we distinguish between a), the Leffler parameter α_L, to characterize the global transition state for the interconversion between conformations; and b), the Fersht parameter, ϕ_F, to assign the degree of progression of individual residue positions at the transition state. For both α_L and ϕ_F, insights are achieved by using harmonic energy profiles to reflect the dynamic nature of proteins, as illustrated with single-channel results reported for normal and mutant nicotinic receptors. We also describe new applications of α_L based on published results. For large-conductance calcium-activated potassium channels, data are satisfactorily fit with an α_L value of 0.65, in accord with REFERs. In contrast, results reported for the flip conformational state of glycine and nicotinic receptors are in disaccord with REFERs, since they yield α_L values outside the usual limits of 0–1. Concerning published ϕ_F values underlying the conformational wave hypothesis for nicotinic receptors, we note that interpretations may be complicated by variations in the width of harmonic energy profiles.

Energetics of gating at the apo-acetylcholine receptor transmitter binding site

Acetylcholine receptor channels switch between conformations that have a low versus high affinity for the transmitter and conductance for ions (R↔R*; gating). The forward isomerization, which begins at the transmitter binding sites and propagates ∼50 Å to the narrow region of the pore, occurs by approximately the same sequence of molecular events with or without agonists present at the binding sites. To pinpoint the forces that govern the R versus R* agonist affinity ratio, we measured single-channel activation parameters for apo-receptors having combinations of mutations of 10 transmitter binding site residues in the α (Y93, G147, W149, G153, Y190, C192, and Y198), ε (W55 and P121), or δ (W57) subunit. Gating energy changes were largest for the tryptophan residues. The αW149 energy changes were coupled with those of the other aromatic amino acids. Mutating the aromatic residues to Phe reduces the R/R* equilibrium dissociation constant ratio, with αY190 and αW149 being the most sensitive positions. Most of the mutations eliminated long-lived spontaneous openings. The results provide a foundation for understanding how ligands trigger protein conformational change.

Decremental response to high-frequency trains of acetylcholine pulses but unaltered fractional Ca2+ currents in a panel of "slow-channel syndrome" nicotinic receptor mutants

The slow-channel congenital myasthenic syndrome (SCCMS) is a disorder of the neuromuscular junction caused by gain-of-function mutations to the muscle nicotinic acetylcholine (ACh) receptor (AChR). Although it is clear that the slower deactivation time course of the ACh-elicited currents plays a central role in the etiology of this disease, it has been suggested that other abnormal properties of these mutant receptors may also be critical in this respect. We characterized the kinetics of a panel of five SCCMS AChRs (αS269I, βV266M, εL221F, εT264P, and εL269F) at the ensemble level in rapidly perfused outside-out patches. We found that, for all of these mutants, the peak-current amplitude decreases along trains of nearly saturating ACh pulses delivered at physiologically relevant frequencies in a manner that is consistent with enhanced entry into desensitization during the prolonged deactivation phase. This suggests that the increasingly reduced availability of activatable AChRs upon repetitive stimulation may well contribute to the fatigability and weakness of skeletal muscle that characterize this disease. Also, these results emphasize the importance of explicitly accounting for entry into desensitization as one of the pathways for burst termination, if meaningful mechanistic insight is to be inferred from the study of the effect of these naturally occurring mutations on channel function. Applying a novel single-channel–based approach to estimate the contribution of Ca²⁺ to the total cation currents, we also found that none of these mutants affects the Ca²⁺-conduction properties of the AChR to an extent that seems to be of physiological importance. Our estimate of the Ca²⁺-carried component of the total (inward) conductance of wild-type and SCCMS AChRs in the presence of 150 mM Na⁺, 1.8 mM Ca²⁺, and 1.7 mM Mg²⁺ on the extracellular side of cell-attached patches turned out be in the 5.0–9.4 pS range, representing a fractional Ca²⁺ current of ∼14%, on average. Remarkably, these values are nearly identical to those we estimated for the NR1-NR2A N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor (NMDAR), which has generally been considered to be the main neurotransmitter-gated pathway of Ca²⁺ entry into the cell. Our estimate of the rat NMDAR Ca²⁺ conductance (using the same single-channel approach as for the AChR but in the nominal absence of extracellular Mg²⁺) was 7.9 pS, corresponding to a fractional Ca²⁺ current of 13%.

Unliganded gating of acetylcholine receptor channels

We estimated the unliganded opening and closing rate constants of neuromuscular acetylcholine receptor-channels (AChRs) having mutations that increased the gating equilibrium constant. For some mutant combinations, spontaneous openings occurred in clusters. For 25 different constructs, the unliganded gating equilibrium constant (E(0)) was correlated with the product of the predicted fold-increase in the diliganded gating equilibrium constant caused by each mutation alone. We estimate that (i) E(0) for mouse, wild-type alpha(2)beta delta epsilon AChRs is approximately 1.15 x 10(-7); (ii) unliganded AChRs open for approximately 80 micros, once every approximately 15 min; (iii) the affinity for ACh of the O(pen) conformation is approximately 10 nM, or approximately 15,600 times greater than for the C(losed) conformation; (iv) the ACh-monoliganded gating equilibrium constant is approximately 1.7 x 10(-3); (v) the C-->O isomerization reduces substantially ACh dissociation, but only slightly increases association; and (vi) ACh provides only approximately 0.9 k(B)T more binding energy per site than carbamylcholine but approximately 3.1 k(B)T more than choline, mainly because of a low O conformation affinity. Most mutations of binding site residue alphaW149 increase E(0). We estimate that the mutation alphaW149F reduces the ACh affinity of C only by 13-fold, but of O by 190-fold. Rate-equilibrium free-energy relationships for different regions of the protein show similar slopes (Phi values) for un- vs. diliganded gating, which suggests that the conformational pathway of the gating structural change is fundamentally the same with and without agonists. Agonist binding is a perturbation that (like most mutations) changes the energy, but not the mechanism, of the gating conformational change.

Structural answers and persistent questions about how nicotinic receptors work

The electron diffraction structure of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) from Torpedo marmorata and the X-ray crystallographic structure of acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP) are providing new answers to persistent questions about how nAChRs function as biophysical machines and as participants in cellular and systems physiology. New high-resolution information about nAChR structures might come from advances in crystallography and NMR, from extracellular domain nAChRs as high fidelity models, and from prokaryotic nicotinoid proteins. At the level of biophysics, structures of different nAChRs with different pharmacological profiles and kinetics will help describe how agonists and antagonists bind to orthosteric binding sites, how allosteric modulators affect function by binding outside these sites, how nAChRs control ion flow, and how large cytoplasmic domains affect function. At the level of cellular and systems physiology, structures of nAChRs will help characterize interactions with other cellular components, including lipids and trafficking and signaling proteins, and contribute to understanding the roles of nAChRs in addiction, neurodegeneration, and mental illness. Understanding nAChRs at an atomic level will be important for designing interventions for these pathologies.

Estimating binding affinities of the nicotinic receptor for low-efficacy ligands using mixtures of agonists and two-dimensional concentration-response relationships

The phenomenon of ligand-induced ion channel gating hinges upon the ability of a receptor channel to bind ligand molecules with conformation-specific affinities. However, our understanding of this fundamental phenomenon is notably limited, not only because the changes in binding site structure and ligand conformation that occur upon gating are largely unknown but, also, because the strength of these ligand–receptor interactions are experimentally elusive. Both high- and low-efficacy ligands pose a number of analytical and experimental challenges that can render the estimation of their conformation-specific binding affinities impossible. In this paper, we present a novel assay that overcomes some of the hurdles presented by weak agonists of the muscle nicotinic receptor and allows the estimation of their closed-state affinities. The method, which we have termed the “activation-competition” assay, consists of a single-channel concentration–response assay performed in the presence of a binary mixture of ligands of widely different efficacies. By plotting the channel response (i.e., the open probability) as a function of the concentration of each agonist in the mixture, interpreting the observed response in the framework of a plausible kinetic scheme, and fitting the open probability surface with the corresponding function, the affinities of the closed receptor for the two agonists can be simultaneously extracted as free parameters. Here, we applied this methodology to estimate the closed-state affinity of the muscle nicotinic receptor for choline (a very weak agonist) using acetylcholine (ACh) as the partner in the mixture. We estimated the dissociation equilibrium constant of choline (K_D) from the wild type's closed state to be 4.1 ± 0.5 mM (and that of ACh to be 106 ± 6 μM). We also discuss the use of accurate estimates of affinities for low-efficacy agonists as a tool to discriminate between binding and gating effects of mutations, and in the context of the rational design of therapeutic drugs.

Block of muscle nicotinic receptors by choline suggests that the activation and desensitization gates act as distinct molecular entities

Ion channel block in muscle acetylcholine nicotinic receptors (AChRs) is an extensively reported phenomenon. Yet, the mechanisms underlying the interruption of ion flow or the interaction of the blocker with the channel's gates remain incompletely characterized. In this paper, we studied fast channel block by choline, a quaternary-ammonium cation that is also an endogenous weak agonist of this receptor, and a valuable tool in structure-function studies. Analysis of the single-channel current amplitude as a function of both choline concentration and voltage revealed that extracellular choline binds to the open-channel pore with millimolar apparent affinity (K(B) congruent with 12 mM in the presence of approximately 155 mM monovalent and 3.5 mM divalent, inorganic cations), and that it permeates the channel faster than acetylcholine. This, together with its relatively small size ( approximately 5.5 A along its longest axis), suggests that the pore-blocking choline binding site is the selectivity filter itself, and that current blockages simply reflect the longer-lived sojourns of choline at this site. Kinetic analysis of single-channel traces indicated that increasing occupancy of the pore-blocking site by choline (as judged from the reduction of the single-channel current amplitude) is accompanied by the lengthening of (apparent) open interval durations. Consideration of a number of possible mechanisms firmly suggests that this prolongation results from the local effect of choline interfering with the operation of the activation gate (closure of blocked receptors is slower than that of unblocked receptors by a factor of approximately 13), whereas closure of the desensitization gate remains unaffected. Thus, we suggest that these two gates act as distinct molecular entities. Also, the detailed understanding gained here on how choline distorts the observed open-time durations can be used to compensate for this artifact during activation assays. This correction is necessary if we are to understand how choline binds to and gates the AChR.

Probing ion-channel pores one proton at a time

Although membrane proteins often rely on ionizable residues for structure and function, their ionization states under physiological conditions largely elude experimental estimation. To gain insight into the effect of the local microenvironment on the proton affinity of ionizable residues, we have engineered individual lysines, histidines and arginines along the alpha-helical lining of the transmembrane pore of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. We can detect individual proton binding-unbinding reactions electrophysiologically at the level of a single proton on a single side chain as brief blocking-unblocking events of the passing cation current. Kinetic analysis of these fluctuations yields the position-dependent rates of proton transfer, from which the corresponding pK(a) values and shifts in pK(a) can be calculated. Here we present a self-consistent, residue-by-residue description of the microenvironment around the pore-lining transmembrane alpha-helices (M2) in the open-channel conformation, in terms of the excess free energy that is required to keep the engineered basic side chains protonated relative to bulk water. A comparison with closed-channel data leads us to propose that the rotation of M2, which is frequently invoked as a hallmark of the gating mechanism of Cys-loop receptors, is minimal, if any.

Phi-value analysis of a linear, sequential reaction mechanism: theory and application to ion channel gating

We derive the analytical form of a rate-equilibrium free-energy relationship (with slope Phi) for a bounded, linear chain of coupled reactions having arbitrary connecting rate constants. The results confirm previous simulation studies showing that Phi-values reflect the position of the perturbed reaction within the chain, with reactions occurring earlier in the sequence producing higher Phi-values than those occurring later in the sequence. The derivation includes an expression for the transmission coefficients of the overall reaction based on the rate constants of an arbitrary, discrete, finite Markov chain. The results indicate that experimental Phi-values can be used to calculate the relative heights of the energy barriers between intermediate states of the chain but provide no information about the energies of the wells along the reaction path. Application of the equations to the case of diliganded acetylcholine receptor channel gating suggests that the transition-state ensemble for this reaction is nearly flat. Although this mechanism accounts for many of the basic features of diliganded and unliganded acetylcholine receptor channel gating, the experimental rate-equilibrium free-energy relationships appear to be more linear than those predicted by the theory.

Dynamics of the acetylcholine receptor pore at the gating transition state

Neuromuscular acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) are ion channels that alternatively adopt stable conformations that either allow (open) or prohibit (closed) ionic conduction. We probed the dynamics of pore (M2) residues at the diliganded gating transition state by using single-channel kinetic and rate-equilibrium free energy relationship (phi-value) analyses of mutant AChRs. The mutations were at the equatorial (9') position of the alpha, beta, and epsilon subunits (n = 15) or at sites between the equator and the extracellular domain in the alpha-subunit (n = 8). We also studied AChRs having only one of the two alpha-subunits mutated. The results indicate that the alpha-subunit, like the delta-subunit, has a region of flexure near the middle of M2, that the two alpha-subunits experience distinct energy barriers to gating at the equator (but not elsewhere), and that the collective subunit motions at the equator are asymmetric during the AChR gating isomerization.

Plasticity of acetylcholine receptor gating motions via rate-energy relationships

Like other protein conformational changes, ion channel gating requires the protein to achieve a high-energy transition-state structure. It is not known whether ion channel gating takes place on a broad energy landscape on which many alternative transition state structures are accessible, or on a narrow energy landscape where only a few transition-state structures are possible. To address this question, we measured how rate-equilibrium free energy relationships (REFERs) for di-liganded and unliganded acetylcholine receptor gating vary as a function of the gating equilibrium constant. A large slope for the REFER plot indicates an openlike transition state, whereas a small slope indicates a closedlike transition state. Due to this relationship between REFERs and transition-state structure, the sensitivity of the REFER slope to mutation-induced energetic perturbations allows estimation of the breadth of the energy landscape underlying gating. The relatively large sensitivity of di-liganded REFER slopes to energetic perturbations suggests that the motions underlying di-liganded gating take place on a broad, shallow energy landscape where many alternative transition-state structures are accessible.

Structural dynamics of the M4 transmembrane segment during acetylcholine receptor gating

The transition state structures that link the stable end states of allosteric proteins are largely unresolved. We used single-molecule kinetic analysis to probe the dynamics of the M4 transmembrane segments during the closed<==>open isomerization of the neuromuscular acetylcholine receptor ion channel (AChR). We measured the slopes (phi) of the free energy relationships for 87 mutants, which reveal the open- versus closed-like characters of the mutated residues at the transition state and hence the sequence and organization of gating molecular motions. phi was constant throughout the length of the alpha subunit M4 segment with an average value of 0.54, suggesting that this domain moves as a unit, approximately midway through the reaction. Analysis of a hybrid construct indicates that the two alpha subunits move synchronously. Between subunits, the sequence of M4 motions is alpha-epsilon-beta. The AChR ion channel emerges as a dynamic nanomachine with many moving parts.

Gating of acetylcholine receptor channels: brownian motion across a broad transition state

Acetylcholine receptor channels (AChRs) are proteins that switch between stable "closed" and "open" conformations. In patch clamp recordings, diliganded AChR gating appears to be a simple, two-state reaction. However, mutagenesis studies indicate that during gating dozens of residues across the protein move asynchronously and are organized into rigid body gating domains ("blocks"). Moreover, there is an upper limit to the apparent channel opening rate constant. These observations suggest that the gating reaction has a broad, corrugated transition state region, with the maximum opening rate reflecting, in part, the mean first-passage time across this ensemble. Simulations reveal that a flat, isotropic energy profile for the transition state can account for many of the essential features of AChR gating. With this mechanism, concerted, local structural transitions that occur on the broad transition state ensemble give rise to fractional measures of reaction progress (Phi values) determined by rate-equilibrium free energy relationship analysis. The results suggest that the coarse-grained AChR gating conformational change propagates through the protein with dynamics that are governed by the Brownian motion of individual gating blocks.

A speed limit for conformational change of an allosteric membrane protein

Neuromuscular acetylcholine receptors are synaptic ion channels that open and close with rate constants of approximately equal to 48,000 s(-1) and approximately equal to 1,700 s(-1), respectively (in adult mouse, at 24 degrees C, -100 mV membrane potential). Perturbations of many different sites in the protein can change these rate constants, with those in the extracellular domain mainly affecting channel-opening and many of those in the membrane and intracellular domains mainly affecting channel-closing. We used single-channel recordings to measure the total open time per activation (tau(b)) elicited by a low concentration of the natural transmitter, acetylcholine. tau(b) increased in constructs with mutations that increased the gating equilibrium constant by either increasing the opening or decreasing the closing rate constant. However, tau(b) did not approach the same asymptote in fast-opening and slow-closing constructs. The maximum value for the slow closers was about twice that for the fast openers. One interpretation of this difference is that there is an upper limit to the channel-opening rate constant, which we estimate to be approximately 0.86 mus(-1). One possibility is that this limit is the rate of conformational change in the absence of an overall activation barrier and thus reflects the kinetic prefactor for the acetylcholine receptor opening isomerization.