Probing the oligomeric assemblies of pea porphobilinogen synthase by analytical ultracentrifugation

More indications for redox-sensitive cysteine residues of the Arabidopsis 5-aminolevulinate dehydratase

Redox-dependent thiol-disulfide switches of cysteine residues are one of the significant posttranslational modifications of proteins to control rapidly their stability, activity, and protein interaction. Redox control also modulates the tetrapyrrole biosynthesis (TBS). Among the redox-dependent TBS enzymes, 5-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALAD) was previously recognized to interact with reductants, such a thioredoxins or NADPH-dependent thioredoxin reductase C. In this report, we aim to verify the redox sensitivity of ALAD and identify the redox-reactive cysteine residues among the six cysteines of the mature protein form Arabidopsis. Based on structural modelling and comparative studies of wild-type ALAD and ALAD mutants with single and double Cys➔Ser substitutions under oxidizing and reducing conditions, we aim to predict the dimerization and oligomerisation of ALAD as well as the crucial Cys residues for disulfide bridge formation and enzyme activity. The Cys404Ser mutation led to a drastic inactivation of ALAD and redox-dependent properties of ALAD were severely impaired, when Cys71 was simultaneously mutated with Cys152 or Cys251. Cys71 is located in a flexible N-terminal arm of ALAD, which could allow intramolecular disulfide bridges with Cys residues at the surface of the remaining globule ALAD structure. As a result, we propose different roles of Cys residues for redox control, catalytic activity and Mg2+-dependent assembly.

Wrangling Shape-Shifting Morpheeins to Tackle Disease and Approach Drug Discovery

Homo-multimeric proteins that can come apart, change shape, and reassemble differently with functional consequences have been called morpheeins and/or transformers; these provide a largely unexplored context for understanding disease and developing allosteric therapeutics. This article describes such proteins within the context of protein structure dynamics, provides one detailed example related to an inborn error of metabolism and potential herbicide development, and describes the context for applying these ideas for understanding disease and designing bioactive molecules, such as therapeutics.

Towards Initial Indications for a Thiol-Based Redox Control of Arabidopsis 5-Aminolevulinic Acid Dehydratase

Thiol-based redox control is one of the important posttranslational mechanisms of the tetrapyrrole biosynthesis pathway. Many enzymes of the pathway have been shown to interact with thioredoxin (TRX) and Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH)-dependent thioredoxin reductase C (NTRC). We examined the redox-dependency of 5-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALAD), which catalyzed the conjugation of two 5-aminolevulinic acid (ALA) molecules to porphobilinogen. ALAD interacted with TRX f, TRX m and NTRC in chloroplasts. Consequently, less ALAD protein accumulated in the trx f1, ntrc and trx f1/ntrc mutants compared to wild-type control resulting in decreased ALAD activity. In a polyacrylamide gel under non-reducing conditions, ALAD monomers turned out to be present in reduced and two oxidized forms. The reduced and oxidized forms of ALAD differed in their catalytic activity. The addition of TRX stimulated ALAD activity. From our results it was concluded that (i) deficiency of the reducing power mainly affected the in planta stability of ALAD; and (ii) the reduced form of ALAD displayed increased enzymatic activity.

Structural studies of substrate and product complexes of 5-aminolaevulinic acid dehydratase from humans,Escherichia coliand the hyperthermophilePyrobaculum calidifontis

A number of X-ray analyses of an enzyme involved in a key early stage of tetrapyrrole biosynthesis are reported. Two structures of human 5-aminolaevulinate dehydratase (ALAD), native and recombinant, have been determined at 2.8 Å resolution, showing that the enzyme adopts an octameric quaternary structure in accord with previously published analyses of the enzyme from a range of other species. However, this is in contrast to the finding that a disease-related F12L mutant of the human enzyme uniquely forms hexamers [Breiniget al.(2003),Nature Struct. Biol.10, 757–763]. Monomers of all ALADs adopt the TIM-barrel fold; the subunit conformation that assembles into the octamer includes the N-terminal tail of one monomer curled around the (α/β)8barrel of a neighbouring monomer. Both crystal forms of the human enzyme possess two monomers per asymmetric unit, termedAandB. In the native enzyme there are a number of distinct structural differences between theAandBmonomers, with the latter exhibiting greater disorder in a number of loop regions and in the active site. In contrast, the second monomer of the recombinant enzyme appears to be better defined and the active site of both monomers clearly possesses a zinc ion which is bound by three conserved cysteine residues. In native human ALAD, theAmonomer also has a ligand resembling the substrate ALA which is covalently bound by a Schiff base to one of the active-site lysines (Lys252) and is held in place by an ordered active-site loop. In contrast, these features of the active-site structure are disordered or absent in theBsubunit of the native human enzyme. The octameric structure of the zinc-dependent ALAD from the hyperthermophilePyrobaculum calidifontisis also reported at a somewhat lower resolution of 3.5 Å. Finally, the details are presented of a high-resolution structure of theEscherichia coliALAD enzyme co-crystallized with a noncovalently bound moiety of the product, porphobilinogen (PBG). This structure reveals that the pyrrole side-chain amino group is datively bound to the active-site zinc ion and that the PBG carboxylates interact with the enzymeviahydrogen bonds and salt bridges with invariant residues. A number of hydrogen-bond interactions that were previously observed in the structure of yeast ALAD with a cyclic intermediate resembling the product PBG appear to be weaker in the new structure, suggesting that these interactions are only optimal in the transition state.

Interaction of Rio1 kinase with toyocamycin reveals a conformational switch that controls oligomeric state and catalytic activity

Rio1 kinase is an essential ribosome-processing factor required for proper maturation of 40 S ribosomal subunit. Although its structure is known, several questions regarding its functional remain to be addressed. We report that both Archaeoglobus fulgidus and human Rio1 bind more tightly to an adenosine analog, toyocamycin, than to ATP. Toyocamycin has antibiotic, antiviral and cytotoxic properties, and is known to inhibit ribosome biogenesis, specifically the maturation of 40 S. We determined the X-ray crystal structure of toyocamycin bound to Rio1 at 2.0 Å and demonstrated that toyocamycin binds in the ATP binding pocket of the protein. Despite this, measured steady state kinetics were inconsistent with strict competitive inhibition by toyocamycin. In analyzing this interaction, we discovered that Rio1 is capable of accessing multiple distinct oligomeric states and that toyocamycin may inhibit Rio1 by stabilizing a less catalytically active oligomer. We also present evidence of substrate inhibition by high concentrations of ATP for both archaeal and human Rio1. Oligomeric state studies show both proteins access a higher order oligomeric state in the presence of ATP. The study revealed that autophosphorylation by Rio1 reduces oligomer formation and promotes monomerization, resulting in the most active species. Taken together, these results suggest the activity of Rio1 may be modulated by regulating its oligomerization properties in a conserved mechanism, identifies the first ribosome processing target of toyocamycin and presents the first small molecule inhibitor of Rio1 kinase activity.

The morpheein model of allostery: evaluating proteins as potential morpheeins

An equilibrium mixture of alternate quaternary structure assemblies can form a basis for allostery. The morpheein model of allostery is a concerted dissociative model that describes an equilibrium of alternate quaternary structure assemblies whose architectures are dictated by alternate conformations in the dissociated state. Kinetic and biophysical anomalies that suggest that the morpheein model of allostery applies for a given protein of interest are briefly described. Two methods are presented for evaluating proteins as potential morpheeins. One is a subunit interchange method that uses chromatography, dialysis, and mass spectroscopy to monitor changes in multimer composition. The other is a two-dimensional native gel electrophoresis method to monitor ligand-induced changes in an equilibrium of alternate multimeric assemblies.

Allostery and the dynamic oligomerization of porphobilinogen synthase

The structural basis for allosteric regulation of porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) is modulation of a quaternary structure equilibrium between octamer and hexamer (via dimers), which is represented schematically as 8mer ⇔ 2mer ⇔ 2mer∗⇔ 6mer∗. The "∗" represents a reorientation between two domains of each subunit that occurs in the dissociated state because it is sterically forbidden in the larger multimers. Allosteric effectors of PBGS are both intrinsic and extrinsic and are phylogenetically variable. In some species this equilibrium is modulated intrinsically by magnesium which binds at a site specific to the 8mer. In other species this equilibrium is modulated intrinsically by pH with the guanidinium group of an arginine being spatially equivalent to the allosteric magnesium ion. In humans, disease associated variants all shift the equilibrium toward the 6mer∗ relative to wild type. The 6mer∗ has a surface cavity that is not present in the 8mer and is proposed as a small molecule allosteric binding site. In silico and in vitro approaches have revealed species-specific allosteric PBGS inhibitors that stabilize the 6mer∗. Some of these inhibitors are drugs in clinical use leading to the hypothesis that extrinsic allosteric inhibition of human PBGS could be a mechanism for drug side effects.

Crystal structure of Toxoplasma gondii porphobilinogen synthase: insights on octameric structure and porphobilinogen formation

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) is essential for heme biosynthesis, but the enzyme of the protozoan parasite Toxoplasma gondii (TgPBGS) differs from that of its human host in several important respects, including subcellular localization, metal ion dependence, and quaternary structural dynamics. We have solved the crystal structure of TgPBGS, which contains an octamer in the crystallographic asymmetric unit. Crystallized in the presence of substrate, each active site contains one molecule of the product porphobilinogen. Unlike prior structures containing a substrate-derived heterocycle directly bound to an active site zinc ion, the product-bound TgPBGS active site contains neither zinc nor magnesium, placing in question the common notion that all PBGS enzymes require an active site metal ion. Unlike human PBGS, the TgPBGS octamer contains magnesium ions at the intersections between pro-octamer dimers, which are presumed to function in allosteric regulation. TgPBGS includes N- and C-terminal regions that differ considerably from previously solved crystal structures. In particular, the C-terminal extension found in all apicomplexan PBGS enzymes forms an intersubunit β-sheet, stabilizing a pro-octamer dimer and preventing formation of hexamers that can form in human PBGS. The TgPBGS structure suggests strategies for the development of parasite-selective PBGS inhibitors.

Diverse clinical compounds alter the quaternary structure and inhibit the activity of an essential enzyme

An in vitro evaluation of the Johns Hopkins Clinical Compound Library demonstrates that certain drugs can alter the quaternary structure of an essential human protein. Human porphobilinogen synthase (HsPBGS) is an essential enzyme involved in heme biosynthesis; it exists as an equilibrium of high-activity octamers, low-activity hexamers, and alternate dimer configurations that dictate the stoichiometry and architecture of further assembly. Decreased HsPBGS activity is implicated in toxicities associated with lead poisoning and 5-aminolevulinate dehydratase (ALAD) porphyria, the latter of which involves hexamer-favoring HsPBGS variants. A medium-throughput native PAGE mobility-shift screen coupled with evaluation of hits as HsPBGS inhibitors revealed 12 drugs that stabilize the HsPBGS hexamer and inhibit HsPBGS activity in vitro. A detailed characterization of these effects is presented. Drug inhibition of HsPBGS in vivo by inducing hexamer formation would constitute an unprecedented mechanism for side effects. We suggest that small-molecule perturbation of quaternary structure equilibria be considered as a general mechanism for drug action and side effects.

Serum amyloid A 2.2 refolds into a octameric oligomer that slowly converts to a more stable hexamer

Serum amyloid A (SAA) is an inflammatory protein predominantly bound to high-density lipoprotein in plasma and presumed to play various biological and pathological roles. We previously found that the murine isoform SAA2.2 exists in aqueous solution as a marginally stable hexamer at 4-20°C, but becomes an intrinsically disordered protein at 37°C. Here we show that when urea-denatured SAA2.2 is dialyzed into buffer (pH 8.0, 4°C), it refolds mostly into an octameric species. The octamer transitions to the hexameric structure upon incubation from days to weeks at 4°C, depending on the SAA2.2 concentration. Thermal denaturation of the octamer and hexamer monitored by circular dichroism showed that the octamer is ∼10°C less stable, with a denaturation mid point of ∼22°C. Thus, SAA2.2 becomes kinetically trapped by refolding into a less stable, but more kinetically accessible octameric species. The ability of SAA2.2 to form different oligomeric species in vitro along with its marginal stability, suggest that the structure of SAA might be modulated in vivo to form different biologically relevant species.

MORPHEEINS - A NEW PATHWAY FOR ALLOSTERIC DRUG DISCOVERY

The morpheein model of allosteric regulation can be applied as a novel approach to the discovery of small molecule allosteric modulators of protein function. Morpheeins are homo-oligomeric proteins where, under physiological conditions, the oligomer can dissociate, the dissociated units can change conformation, and the altered conformational state can reassociate to a structurally and functionally distinct oligomer. This phenomenon serves as a basis for allostery, as a basis for conformational diseases, as a basis for drug discovery, and may be applicable to personalized medicine such as in the prediction of drug side effects. Each of these relationships has been established for the prototype morpheein, porphobilinogen synthase, where the conformational disease is a porphyria and the drug application is in antimicrobial discovery. These data are presented along with a discussion of other drug targets for which the morpheein model of allostery may apply. Such targets include HIV integrase, TNFα, β-tryptase, and p53.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa porphobilinogen synthase assembly state regulators: hit discovery and initial SAR studies

Porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) catalyzes the first common step in the biosynthesis of the essential heme, chlorophyll and vitamin B(12) heme pigments. PBGS activity is regulated by assembly state, with certain oligomers exhibiting biological activity and others either partially or completely inactive, affording an innovative means of allosteric drug action. Pseudomonas aeruginosa PBGS is functionally active as an octamer, and inactive as a dimer. We have identified a series of compounds that stabilize the inactive P. aeruginosa dimer by a computational prescreen followed by native PAGE gel mobility shift analysis. From those results, we have prepared related thiadiazoles and evaluated their ability to regulate P. aeruginosa PBGS assembly state.

Plastid-associated porphobilinogen synthase from Toxoplasma gondii: kinetic and structural properties validate therapeutic potential

Apicomplexan parasites (including Plasmodium spp. and Toxoplasma gondii) employ a four-carbon pathway for de novo heme biosynthesis, but this pathway is distinct from the animal/fungal C4 pathway in that it is distributed between three compartments: the mitochondrion, cytosol, and apicoplast, a plastid acquired by secondary endosymbiosis of an alga. Parasite porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) resides within the apicoplast, and phylogenetic analysis indicates a plant origin. The PBGS family exhibits a complex use of metal ions (Zn(2+) and Mg(2+)) and oligomeric states (dimers, hexamers, and octamers). Recombinant T. gondii PBGS (TgPBGS) was purified as a stable approximately 320-kDa octamer, and low levels of dimers but no hexamers were also observed. The enzyme displays a broad activity peak (pH 7-8.5), with a K(m) for aminolevulinic acid of approximately 150 microM and specific activity of approximately 24 micromol of porphobilinogen/mg of protein/h. Like the plant enzyme, TgPBGS responds to Mg(2+) but not Zn(2+) and shows two Mg(2+) affinities, interpreted as tight binding at both the active and allosteric sites. Unlike other Mg(2+)-binding PBGS, however, metal ions are not required for TgPBGS octamer stability. A mutant enzyme lacking the C-terminal 13 amino acids distinguishing parasite PBGS from plant and animal enzymes purified as a dimer, suggesting that the C terminus is required for octamer stability. Parasite heme biosynthesis is inhibited (and parasites are killed) by succinylacetone, an active site-directed suicide substrate. The distinct phylogenetic, enzymatic, and structural features of apicomplexan PBGS offer scope for developing selective inhibitors of the parasite enzyme based on its quaternary structure characteristics.

Docking to large allosteric binding sites on protein surfaces

The inactive porphobilinogen synthase (PBGS) hexamer has an oligomer-specific and phylogenetically variable surface cavity that is not present in the active octamer. The octamer and hexamer are components of a dynamic quaternary structure equilibrium characteristic of morpheeins. Small molecules that bind to the hexamer-specific surface cavity, which is at the interface of three subunits, are predicted to act as allosteric inhibitors that function by drawing the oligomeric equilibrium toward the hexamer. We used GLIDE as a tool to enrich a 250,000 molecule library for molecules with enhanced probability of acting as hexamer-stabilizing allosteric inhibitors of PBGS from Yersinia enterocolitica. Eighty-six compounds were tested in vitro and five showed hexamer stabilization. We discuss the application of computational docking to surface cavities as an approach to find allosteric modulators of protein function with specific reference to morpheeins that function as an equilibrium of non-additive quaternary structure assemblies.