A direct real-time spectroscopic investigation of the mechanism of open complex formation by T7 RNA polymerase

Fluorescent methods to study transcription initiation and transition into elongation

The DNA-dependent RNA polymerases induce specific conformational changes in the promoter DNA during transcription initiation. Fluorescence spectroscopy sensitively monitors these DNA conformational changes in real time and at equilibrium providing powerful ways to estimate interactions in transcriptional complexes and to assess how transcription is regulated by the promoter DNA sequence, transcription factors, and small ligands. Ensemble fluorescence methods described here probe the individual steps of promoter binding, bending, opening, and transition into the elongation using T7 phage and mitochondrial transcriptional systems as examples.

Fluorescent DNA-based enzyme sensors

Fluorescent sensors that make use of DNA structures have become widely useful in monitoring enzymatic activities. Early studies focused primarily on enzymes that naturally use DNA or RNA as the substrate. However, recent advances in molecular design have enabled the development of nucleic acid sensors for a wider range of functions, including enzymes that do not normally bind DNA or RNA. Nucleic acid sensors present some potential advantages over classical small-molecule sensors, including water solubility and ease of synthesis. An overview of the multiple strategies under recent development is presented in this critical review, and expected future developments in microarrays, single molecule analysis, and in vivo sensing are discussed (160 references).

Effect of transition metal ions on the fluorescence and Taq-catalyzed polymerase chain reaction of tricyclic cytidine analogs

The cytosine analogs 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenothiazine (tC) and 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenoxazine (tCo) stand out among fluorescent bases due to their unquenched fluorescence emission in double-stranded DNA. Recently, we reported a method for the generation of densely tCo-labeled DNA by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) that relied on the use of the extremely thermostable Deep Vent polymerase. We have now developed a protocol that employs the more commonly used Taq polymerase. Supplementing the PCR with Mn(2+) or Co(2+) ions dramatically increased the amount of tCo triphosphate (dtCoTP) incorporated and, thus, enhanced the brightness of the PCR products. The resulting PCR products could be easily detected in gels based on their intrinsic fluorescence. The Mn(2+) ions modulate the PCR by improving the bypass of template tCo and the overall catalytic efficiency. In contrast to the lower fidelity during tCo bypass, Mn(2+) improved the ability of Taq polymerase to distinguish between dtCoTP and dTTP when copying a template dA. Interestingly, Mn(2+) ions hardly affect the fluorescence emission of tC(o), whereas the coordination of Co(2+) ions with the phosphate groups of DNA and nucleotides statically quenches tC(o) fluorescence with small reciprocal Stern-Vollmer constants of 10-300μM.

Sensing DNA opening in transcription using quenchable Förster resonance energy transfer

Many biological processes, such as gene transcription and replication, involve opening and closing of short regions of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Few techniques, however, can study these processes in real time or at the single-molecule level. Here, we present a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay that monitors the state of DNA (double- vs single-stranded) at a specific region within a DNA fragment, at both the ensemble level and the single-molecule level. The assay utilizes two closely spaced fluorophores: a FRET donor fluorophore (Cy3B) on the first DNA strand and a FRET acceptor fluorophore (ATTO647N) on the complementary strand. Because our assay is based on quenching and dequenching FRET processes, i.e., the presence or absence of contact-induced fluorescence quenching, we have named it a "quenchable FRET" assay or "quFRET". Using lac promoter DNA fragments, quFRET allowed us to sense transcription bubble expansion and compaction during abortive initiation by bacterial RNA polymerase. We also used quFRET to confirm the mode of action of gp2 (a phage-encoded protein that acts as a potent inhibitor of Escherichia coli transcription) and rifampicin (an antibiotic that blocks transcription initiation). Our results demonstrate that quFRET should find numerous applications in many processes involving DNA opening and closing, as well as in the development of new antibacterial therapies involving transcription.

Fluorescence intensity decays of 2-aminopurine solutions: lifetime distribution approach

The fluorescent adenine analog 2-aminopurine (2AP) has been used extensively to monitor conformational changes and macromolecular binding events involving nucleic acids because its fluorescence properties are highly sensitive to changes in chemical environment. Furthermore, site-specific incorporation of 2AP permits local DNA and RNA conformational events to be discriminated from the global structural changes monitored by UV-Vis spectroscopy and circular dichroism. However, although the steady-state fluorescence properties of 2AP have been well defined in diverse settings, interpretation of 2AP fluorescence lifetime parameters has been hampered by the heterogeneous nature of multiexponential 2AP intensity decays observed across populations of microenvironments. To resolve this problem, we tested the utility of multiexponential versus continuous Lorentzian lifetime distribution models to describe fluorescence intensity decays from 2AP in diverse chemical backgrounds and within the context of RNA. Heterogeneity was introduced into 2AP intensity decays by mixing solvents of differing polarities or by adding quenchers under high viscosity to evaluate the transient effect. Heterogeneity of 2AP fluorescence within the context of a synthetic RNA hairpin was introduced by structural remodeling using a magnesium salt. In each case except folded RNA (which required a bimodal distribution), 2AP lifetime properties were well described by single Lorentzian distribution functions, abrogating the need to introduce additional discrete lifetime subpopulations. Rather, heterogeneity in fluorescence decay processes was accommodated by the breadth of each distribution. This approach also permitted solvent relaxation effects on 2AP emission to be assessed by comparing lifetime distributions at multiple wavelengths. Together, these studies provide a new perspective for the interpretation of 2AP fluorescence lifetime properties that will further the utility of this fluorophore in analyses of the complex and heterogeneous structural microenvironments associated with nucleic acids.

Structural confirmation of a bent and open model for the initiation complex of T7 RNA polymerase

T7 RNA polymerase is known to induce bending of its promoter DNA upon binding, as evidenced by gel-shift assays and by recent end-to-end fluorescence energy transfer distance measurements. Crystal structures of promoter-bound and initially transcribing complexes, however, lack downstream DNA, providing no information on the overall path of the DNA through the protein. Crystal structures of the elongation complex do include downstream DNA and provide valuable guidance in the design of models for the complete melted bubble structure at initiation. In the current study, we test a specific structural model for the initiation complex, obtained by alignment of the C-terminal regions of the protein structures from both initiation and elongation and then simple transferal of the downstream DNA from the elongation complex onto the initiation complex. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer measurement of distances from a point upstream on the promoter DNA to various points along the downstream helix reproduce the expected helical periodicity in the distances and support the model's orientation and phasing of the downstream DNA. The model also makes predictions about the extent of melting downstream of the active site. By monitoring fluorescent base analogues incorporated at various positions in the DNA, we have mapped the downstream edge of the bubble, confirming the model. The initially melted bubble, in the absence of substrate, encompasses 7-8 bases and is sufficient to allow synthesis of a three base transcript before further melting is required. The results demonstrate that despite massive changes in the N-terminal portion of the protein and in the DNA upstream of the active site, the DNA downstream of the active site is virtually identical in both initiation and elongation complexes.

Extended upstream A-T sequence increases T7 promoter strength

Bacteriophage T7 promoters contain a consensus sequence from -17 to +6 relative to the transcription start site, +1. In addition, the strong class III promoters are characterized by an extended AT-rich region upstream of -17, which is often interrupted by one or more GC base pairs in the weaker class II promoters. Herein we studied the role of the AT-rich region upstream of -17 in transcription regulation of T7 RNA polymerase. Equilibrium DNA binding studies with promoter fragments of consensus sequence truncated at various positions between -17 and -27 showed that the polymerase-promoter complex is significantly stabilized as the upstream AT-rich sequence is extended to and beyond -22. Similarly, promoters in which the AT-rich region from -17 to -22 is interrupted by several GC base pairs showed weak binding. Kinetic studies indicated that the presence of extended AT-rich sequence slows the dissociation rate constant of the polymerase-promoter complex and slightly stimulates the association rate constant, thereby increasing the stability of the complex. Measurement of the transcription activity revealed that the extended AT-rich region does not affect the kinetics of abortive synthesis up to the formation of 8-nucleotide RNA but causes accumulation of longer abortive products between 9 and 13 nucleotides. The observed effects of the upstream DNA region were AT sequence-specific, and the results suggested a larger role for the extended AT-rich sequence that has been unappreciated previously. We propose that the AT-rich DNA sequence upstream of -17 plays a role in modulating the efficiency of transcription initiation by affecting both the affinity of T7 RNA polymerase for the promoter and the efficiency of promoter clearance.

Promoter binding, initiation, and elongation by bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. A single-molecule view of the transcription cycle

A single-molecule transcription assay has been developed that allows, for the first time, the direct observation of promoter binding, initiation, and elongation by a single RNA polymerase (RNAP) molecule in real-time. To promote DNA binding and transcription initiation, a DNA molecule tethered between two optically trapped beads was held near a third immobile surface bead sparsely coated with RNAP. By driving the optical trap holding the upstream bead with a triangular oscillation while measuring the position of both trapped beads, we observed the onset of promoter binding, promoter escape (productive initiation), and processive elongation by individual RNAP molecules. After DNA template release, transcription re-initiation on the same DNA template is possible; thus, multiple enzymatic turnovers by an individual RNAP molecule can be observed. Using bacteriophage T7 RNAP, a commonly used RNAP paradigm, we observed the association and dissociation (k(off)= 2.9 s(-1)) of T7 RNAP and promoter DNA, the transition to the elongation mode (k(for) = 0.36 s(-1)), and the processive synthesis (k(pol) = 43 nt s(-1)) and release of a gene-length RNA transcript ( approximately 1200 nt). The transition from initiation to elongation is much longer than the mean lifetime of the binary T7 RNAP-promoter DNA complex (k(off) > k(for)), identifying a rate-limiting step between promoter DNA binding and promoter escape.

Signaling of transcriptional chemistry in the on-line detection format

A critical analysis of optical and acoustic wave instrumentation for examining the transcription apparatus and its regulation is given in the present review. The physico-chemical parameters derived from such in vitro experiments are important from a biophysical standpoint. The overall mechanism of transcription is composed of several mechanisms such as DNA-binding and promoter selection, closed and open polymerase complex formation, initiation of RNA synthesis, elongation and termination. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and fluorescence spectroscopy are widely employed techniques for investigating these mechanisms in real time. Although the binding of nucleotides, transcription factors (TFs) and inhibitors to RNA polymerase (RNAP) and the DNA template have been studied extensively, the synthesis of mRNA has not been investigated in detail except by methods based on electrophoresis. The use of acoustic wave physics for investigating transcriptional chemistry offers not only a time-course analysis but also the potential to gain insight into structural changes that occur during the process.

A fluorescence-based assay for transcription using a novel fluorescent GTP analogue

A new fluorescent analogue of GTP (Cm-GTP) was synthesized, which contained a coumarin fluorophore attached to the gamma phosphorus. This compound was tested in transcription assays using T7 RNA polymerase as a model system. The fluorescent nucleotide was incorporated specifically at the 5' end of nascent RNA synthesized in two different modes of transcription initiation. In the first mode, with only Cm-GTP (+GTP), reiterative slippage synthesis occurred and poly rG ladders of up to 14 nucleotides were synthesized. In the second mode, with Cm-GTP (+GTP)+ATP+CTP, abortive transcripts of up to seven or eight nucleotides were synthesized. The fluorescence properties of the two types of RNA were studied in detail. There was greater reduction in fluorescence intensity in G-ladders than in abortive transcripts. Steady-state anisotropy and anisotropy decay indicated that the fluorophore motion was constrained in G-ladder RNAs as compared to abortive RNAs. Quenching experiments by using extraneous quenchers showed that the excited state of fluorophore at the 5' end of G-ladder RNA was less efficiently quenched as compared to the free fluorophore. These studies suggested that the fluorescent GTP analogue sensed the structural features that distinguished G-ladder RNAs from abortive RNAs. The results suggested that G-ladder RNAs adapt unusual conformations such as G-quartets. Thus, the new fluorescent probe can be useful for structural studies on RNA.

Fluorescence characterization of the transcription bubble in elongation complexes of T7 RNA polymerase

The various kinetic and thermodynamic models for transcription elongation all require an understanding of the nature of the melted bubble which moves with the RNA polymerase active site. Is the general nature of the bubble system-dependent or are there common energetic requirements which constrain a bubble in any RNA polymerases? T7 RNA polymerase is one of the simplest RNA polymerases and is the system for which we have the highest-resolution structural information. However, there is no high-resolution information available for a stable elongation complex. In order to directly map melted regions of the DNA in a functionally paused elongation complex, we have introduced fluorescent probes site-specifically into the DNA. Like 2-aminopurine, which substitutes for adenine bases, the fluorescence intensity of the new probe, pyrrolo-dC, which substitutes for cytosine bases, is sensitive to its environment. Specifically, the fluorescence is quenched in duplex DNA relative to its fluorescence in single-stranded DNA, such that the probe provides direct information on local melting of the DNA. Placement of this new probe at specific positions in the non-template strand shows clearly that the elongation bubble extends about eight bases upstream of the pause site, while 2-aminopurine probes show that the elongation bubble extends only about one nucleotide downstream of the last base incorporated. The positioning of the active site very close to the downstream edge of the bubble is consistent with previous studies and with similar studies of the promoter-bound, pre-initiation complex. The results show clearly that the RNA:DNA hybrid can be no more than eight nucleotides in length, and characterization of different paused species suggests preliminarily that these dimensions are not sequence or position dependent. Finally, the results confirm that the ternary complex is not stable with short lengths of transcript, but persists for a substantial time when paused in the middle or at the (runoff) end of duplex DNA.

Characterization of the interaction of lambda exonuclease with the ends of DNA

Lambda exonuclease processively degrades one strand of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) in the 5"-3" direction. To understand the mechanism through which this enzyme generates high processivity we are analyzing the first step in the reaction, namely the interaction of lambda exonuclease with the ends of substrate DNA. Endonuclease mapping of lambda exonuclease bound to DNA has shown that the enzyme protects approximately 13-14 bp on dsDNA, and no nucleo-tides on the single-stranded tail of the DNA product. We have developed a rapid fluorescence-based assay using 2-aminopurine and measured the steady-state rate constants for different end-structures of DNA. The relative k(cat)for 5" ends decreases in the order 5" recessed > blunt >> 5" overhang. However, k(cat)/K(m)remains relatively constant for these different structures suggesting they are all used equally efficiently as substrates. From these data we propose that a single-stranded 5" overhang end can bind non-productively to the enzyme and the non-hydrolyzed strand is required to aid in the proper alignment of the 5" end. We have also measured the length-dependence of the steady-state rate para-meters and find that they are consistent with a high degree of processivity.

A real-time fluorescence method to monitor the melting of duplex DNA during transcription initiation by RNA polymerase

The melting of duplex DNA in the vicinity of the transcription start site is an essential step of transcription initiation. Here we describe a fluorescent promoter technique which allows the melting of promoter DNA to be observed in a real-time manner with high sensitivity. We have constructed a 114-bp lacUV5 promoter fragment (-89 to +25) which contains a fluorescence probe in the region between the -10 consensus hexamer and the transcription start site. This region was chosen to incorporate a fluorescence probe as it undergoes strand separation subsequent to binding RNA polymerase (RNAP) (i.e., open complex formation). Upon mixing RNAP and fluorochrome-labeled promoter a time-dependent biphasic change in fluorescence was observed. The second slower component was shown to be due to the open complex by comparing the fluorescence data with the kinetics of open complex formation as measured by using alternative methods of open complex detection. The rate constants for open complex formation and dissociation were determined and found to be in excellent agreement with previously reported values. The techniques presented herein can generally be applied to other systems. Furthermore, this method will serve as an important research tool as well as it could be used in designing high-throughput assays involving transcription complexes.

Site-specific labeling of RNA with fluorophores and other structural probes

Site-specific probes provide a powerful tool for structure and function studies of nucleic acids, especially in elucidating tertiary structures of large ribozymes and other folded RNA molecules. Among many types of extrinsic labels, fluorophores are most attractive because they can provide structural information at millisecond time resolution, thus allowing real-time observation of structural transition during biological function. Methods for introducing fluorophores in RNA molecules are summarized here. These methods are robust and readily applicable to the labeling of other types of probes. However, as each case of RNA modification is unique, fine tuning of the general methodology is beneficial.

Stopped-flow kinetic analysis of the interaction of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase with the bacteriophage T7 A1 promoter

We have conducted a detailed kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of open complex formation between Escherichia coli RNA polymerase and the A1 promoter from bacteriophage T7 by monitoring alterations in the intrinsic protein fluorescence of RNA polymerase in stopped-flow kinetic studies. The stopped-flow kinetic data are consistent with a minimal model involving four steps for the formation of the open complex. Arrhenius plots for both the association and dissociation reactions for the equilibrium binding step leading to the formation of the closed complex were linear. With a positive van't Hoff enthalpy (DeltaHobs=18(+/-3) kcal mol-1) and a positive entropy (DeltaSobs=94(+/-15) e.u.) change for the equilibrium binding process, formation of the closed complex is entropy driven. The value of the apparent association rate constant for this binding step was approximately three orders of magnitude less than that expected for facilitated binding. Thus, a minimum of two steps is required to describe the formation of the closed complex. A fast facilitated binding step appears to be followed by a conformational change in RNA polymerase which leads to the formation of the closed complex. A non-linear Arrhenius plot obtained for the isomerization step in the conversion of the closed complex to an open one indicates that there are at least two steps in the conversion of the closed complex to an open one. We have assigned the apparent activation energy of 9.1(+/-1.9) kcal mol-1 to the step involving a conformational change in the protein and nucleation of strand separation and the apparent activation energy of 46(+/-12) kcal mol-1 to the step involving strand separation. At 37 degreesC, the value of the macroscopic isomerization rate constant (0.26(+/-0.02) s-1) in the conversion of the closed complex to an open one was an order of magnitude greater than the value reported in abortive initiation assays. This suggests that open complex formation is not the rate-determining step in the initiation of transcription in the case of the A1 promoter. To gain greater insight into the mechanism of initiation at the A1 promoter, we investigated the process of abortive product formation (pppApU) under conditions of non-saturating concentrations of the initiating nucleotide. A comparison of the lag times in the approach to the steady-state rate of abortive product formation when the reaction was initiated by the addition of UTP, ATP, the enzyme and the A1 promoter, respectively, indicates that the initiating nucleotide plays a key regulatory role in the initiation of transcription in the case of the A1 promoter.

Properties of strand displacement synthesis by Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase: mechanistic implications

Previous results indicated that Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase is capable of extensive synthesis under conditions where it must simultaneously displace a downstream non-template DNA strand. To investigate more fully the mechanistic basis for displacement synthesis and to characterize the activity with natural viral templates, displacement and non-displacement synthesis were compared under a variety of conditions using the viral long terminal repeat plus strand as the template. Although the rates of both displacement and non-displacement synthesis varied regionally over the template, on the average, displacement synthesis was slower by a factor of approximately 3 to 4. Surprisingly, with one particular primer situated downstream of the tRNA primer binding site, displacement synthesis was found to be at least tenfold more processive than non-displacement synthesis, approaching a value of 500 nucleotides. The sequence features associated with pausing during the two modes of synthesis are different in both nucleotide preference and position relative to the enzyme, suggesting that the enzyme contacts the DNA differently under the two modes of synthesis. It was found that pausing during displacement synthesis did not reflect those local regions of DNA with a predicted high degree of thermal stability. Moreover, the very similar effects of temperature on the rates of displacement and non-displacement synthesis make unlikely a strictly passive mechanism of displacement synthesis whereby breathing of the downstream duplex is sufficient for advancement of the polymerase. Together, these results suggest a mechanism of displacement synthesis in which reverse transcriptase actively participates in the process of strand separation in front of the translocating polymerase.

2-Aminopurine as a fluorescent probe for DNA base flipping by methyltransferases

DNA base flipping, which was first observed for the C5-cytosine DNA methyltransferase M. Hha I, results in a complete removal of the stacking interactions between the target base and its neighbouring bases. We have investigated whether duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing the fluorescent base analogue 2-aminopurine can be used to sense DNA base flipping. Using M. Hha I as a paradigm for a base flipping enzyme, we find that the fluorescence intensity of duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine at the target site is dramatically enhanced (54-fold) in the presence of M. Hha I. Duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine adjacent to the target cytosine show little fluorescence increase upon addition of M. Hha I. These results clearly demonstrate that duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine at the target site can serve as fluorescence probes for base flipping. Another enzyme hypothesized to use a base flipping mechanism is the N6-adenine DNA methyltransferase M. Taq I. Addition of M. Taq I to duplex oligodeoxynucleotides bearing 2-aminopurine at the target position, also results in a strongly enhanced fluorescence (13-fold), whereas addition to duplex oligodeoxynucleotides containing 2-aminopurine at the 3'- or 5'-neighbouring position leads only to small fluorescence increases. These results give the first experimental evidence that the adenine-specific DNA methyltransferase M. Taq I also flips its target base.

Direct real time observation of base flipping by the EcoRI DNA methyltransferase

DNA methyltransferases are excellent prototypes for investigating DNA distortion and enzyme specificity because catalysis requires the extrahelical stabilization of the target base within the enzyme active site. The energetics and kinetics of base flipping by the EcoRI DNA methyltransferase were investigated by two methods. First, equilibrium dissociation constants (KDDNA) were determined for the binding of the methyltransferase to DNA containing abasic sites or base analogs incorporated at the target base. Consistent with a base flipping mechanism, tighter binding to oligonucleotides containing destabilized target base pairs was observed. Second, total intensity stopped flow fluorescence measurements of DNA containing 2-aminopurine allowed presteady-state real time observation of the base flipping transition. Following the rapid formation of an enzyme-DNA collision complex, a biphasic increase in total intensity was observed. The fast phase dominated the total intensity increase with a rate nearly identical to k(methylation) determined by rapid chemical quench-flow techniques (Reich, N. O., and Mashoon, N. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 9191-9193). The restacking of the extrahelical base also revealed biphasic kinetics with the recovered amplitudes from these off-rate experiments matching very closely to those observed during the base unstacking process. These results provide the first direct and continuous observation of base flipping and show that at least two distinct conformational transitions occurred at the flipped base subsequent to complex formation. Furthermore, our results suggest that the commitment to catalysis during the methylation of the target site is not determined at the level of the chemistry step but rather is mediated by prior intramolecular isomerization within the enzyme-DNA complex.

The role of base flipping in damage recognition and catalysis by T4 endonuclease V

The process of moving a DNA base extrahelical (base flipping) has been shown in the co-crystal structure of a UV-induced pyrimidine dimer-specific glycosylase, T4 endonuclease V, with its substrate DNA. Compared with other enzymes known to use base flipping, endonuclease V is unique in that it moves the base opposite the target site extrahelical, rather than moving the target base itself. Utilizing substrate analogs and catalytically inactive mutants of T4 endonuclease V, this study investigates the discrete steps involved in damage recognition by this DNA repair enzyme. Specifically, fluorescence spectroscopy analysis shows that fluorescence changes attributable to base flipping are specific for only the base directly opposite either abasic site analogs or the 5'-thymine of a pyrimidine dimer, and no changes are detected if the 2-aminopurine is moved opposite the 3'-thymine of the pyrimidine dimer. Interestingly, base flipping is not detectable with every specific binding event suggesting that damage recognition can be achieved without base flipping. Thus, base flipping does not add to the stability of the specific enzyme-DNA complex but rather induces a conformational change to facilitate catalysis at the appropriate target site. When used in conjunction with structural information, these types of analyses can yield detailed mechanistic models and critical amino acid residues for extrahelical base movement as a mode of damage recognition.