Determination of the kinetic and chemical mechanism of malic enzyme using (2R,3R)-erythro-fluoromalate as a slow alternate substrate

Trifluorosubstrates as mechanistic probes for an FMN-dependent l-2-hydroxy acid-oxidizing enzyme

A controversy exists with respect to the mechanism of l-2-hydroxy acid oxidation by members of a family of FMN-dependent enzymes. A so-called carbanion mechanism was initially proposed, in which the active site histidine abstracts the substrate α-hydrogen as a proton, followed by electron transfer from the carbanion to the flavin. But an alternative mechanism was not incompatible with some results, a mechanism in which the active site histidine instead picks up the substrate hydroxyl proton and a hydride transfer occurs. Even though more recent experiments ruling out such a mechanism were published (Rao & Lederer (1999) Protein Science 7, 1531-1537), a few authors have subsequently interpreted their results with variant enzymes in terms of a hydride transfer. In the present work, we analyse the reactivity of trifluorolactate, a substrate analogue, with the flavocytochrome b2 (Fcb2) flavodehydrogenase domain, compared to its reactivity with an NAD-dependent lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), for which this compound is known to be an inhibitor (Pogolotti & Rupley (1973) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun, 55, 1214-1219). Indeed, electron attraction by the three fluorine atoms should make difficult the removal of the α-H as a hydride. We also analyse the reactivity of trifluoropyruvate with the FMN- and NAD-dependent enzymes. The results substantiate a different effect of the fluorine substituents on the two enzymes compared to their normal substrates. In the discussion we analyse the conclusions of recent papers advocating a hydride transfer mechanism for the family of l-2-hydroxy acid oxidizing FMN-dependent enzymes.

Dependence of Transition State Structure on Substrate: The Intrinsic C-13 Kinetic Isotope Effect Is Different for Physiological and Slow Substrates of the Ornithine Decarboxylase Reaction Because of Different Hydrogen Bonding Structures

Ornithine decarboxylase is the first and the rate-controlling enzyme in polyamine biosynthesis; it decarboxylates l-ornithine to form the diamine putrescine. We present calculations performed using a combined quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical (QM/MM) method with the AM1 semiempirical Hamiltonian for the wild-type ornithine decarboxylase reaction with ornithine (the physiological substrate) and lysine (a "slow" substrate) and for mutant E274A with ornithine substrate. The dynamical method is variational transition state theory with quantized vibrations. We employ a single reaction coordinate equal to the carbon-carbon distance of the dissociating bond, and we find a large difference between the intrinsic kinetic isotope effect for the physiological substrate, which equals 1.04, and that for the slow substrate, which equals 1.06. This shows that, contrary to a commonly accepted assumption, kinetic isotope effects on slow substrates are not always good models of intrinsic kinetic isotope effects on physiological substrates. Furthermore, analysis of free-energy-based samples of transition state structures shows that the differences in kinetic isotope effects may be traced to different numbers of hydrogen bonds at the different transition states of the different reactions.

The use of isotope effects to determine enzyme mechanisms

Isotope effects are one of the most powerful kinetic tools for determining enzyme mechanisms. There are three methods of measurement. First, one can compare reciprocal plots with labeled and unlabeled substrates. The ratio of the slopes is the isotope effect on V/K, and the ratio of the vertical intercepts is the isotope effect on V(max). This is the only way to determine V(max) isotope effects, but is limited to isotope effects of 5% or greater. The second method is internal competition, where the labeled and unlabeled substrates are present at the same time and the change in their ratio in residual substrate or in product is used to calculate an isotope effect, which is that on V/K of the labeled reactant. This is the method used for tritium or (14)C, or with the natural abundances of (13)C, (15)N, or (18)O. The third method involves perturbations from equilibrium when a labeled substrate and corresponding unlabeled product are present at chemical equilibrium. This also gives just an isotope effect on V/K for the labeled reactant. The chemistry is typically not fully rate limiting, so that the isotope effect on V/K is given by: (x)(V/K)=((x)k+c(f)+c(r)(x)K(eq))/(1+c(f)+c(r)) where x defines the isotope (D, T, 13, 15, 18 for deuterium, tritium, (13)C, (15)N, or (18)O), and (x)(V/K), (x)k, and (x)K(eq) are the observed isotope effect, the intrinsic one on the chemical step, and the isotope effect on the equilibrium constant, respectively. The constants c(f) and c(r) are commitments in forward and reverse directions, and are the ratio of the rate constant for the chemical reaction and the net rate constant for release from the enzyme of the varied substrate (direct comparison) or labeled substrate (internal competition and equilibrium perturbation) for c(f), or the first product released or the one involved in the perturbation for c(r). The intrinsic isotope effect, (x)k, can be estimated by comparing deuterium and tritium isotope effects on V/K, or by comparing the deuterium isotope effect with (13)C ones with deuterated and undeuterated substrates. Adding a secondary deuterium isotope effect and its effect on the (13)C one can give an exact solution for all intrinsic isotope effects and commitments. The effect of deuteration on a (13)C isotope effect allows one to tell if the two isotope effects are on the same or different steps. Applications of these methods to several enzyme systems will be presented.

Determination of the mechanism of human malic enzyme with natural and alternate dinucleotides by isotope effects

Human malic enzyme was studied by steady state kinetics, deuterium isotope effects, and 13C isotope effects with both the physiological dinucleotide cofactor and several alternate cofactors. The log V vs pH profile with NAD revealed two pK(a) values too close to be separately determined, but with an average value of 7.33. The log V/K vs pH profile with NAD revealed two pK(a) values at 7.4 and 5.6. Deuterium and 13C isotope effects indicate that the mechanism of human malic enzyme is stepwise with both NAD and epsilonNAD, but that hyperconjugation in the transition state for hydride transfer is detectable only with the former. With thioNAD and APAD, the isotope effects do not clearly indicate whether the mechanism is stepwise or concerted. The intrinsic 13C isotope effect for decarboxylation was calculated to be 1.0485 by measurement of the partition ratio of oxaloacetate in the presence of NADH and human malic enzyme (decarboxylation to pyruvate/reduction to malate = 2.33). The isotope effect and partitioning data suggest that the energy barrier for decarboxylation of oxaloacetate is not as high relative to the barrier for reduction of oxaloacetate as with the chicken liver enzyme.

Potent and competitive inhibition of malic enzymes by lanthanide ions

The catalytic activity of malic enzyme (ME), a member of a new class of oxidative decarboxylases, requires the presence of divalent cations (Mn(2+), Mg(2+), and others). The crystal structure at 2.9 A resolution of human mitochondrial NAD(+)-dependent malic enzyme in a ternary complex with NAD(+) and the lanthanide ion Lu(3+), which has similar radius as Mn(2+), reveals a new conformation of the enzyme. The active site in this ternary complex is in an open form, while the organization of the tetramer of the enzyme actually resembles that with a closed active site. The Lu(3+) ion is bound to the enzyme at the same site as Mn(2+). Kinetic studies showed that Lu(3+) is a potent inhibitor of both the human NAD(P)(+)-dependent ME and the NADP(+)-dependent ME from pigeon liver, and is competitive with respect to the divalent cation, consistent with the structural information.

Characterization of the functional role of Asp141, Asp194, and Asp464 residues in the Mn2+-L-malate binding of pigeon liver malic enzyme

Pigeon liver malic enzyme was inactivated and cleaved at Asp141, Asp194, and Asp464 by the Cu2+-ascorbate system in acidic environment. Site-specific mutagenesis was performed at these putative metal-binding sites. Three point mutants, D141N, D194N, and D464N; three double mutants, D(141,194)N, D(194,464)N, and D(141,464)N; and a triple mutant, D(141,194,464)N; as well as the wild-type malic enzyme (WT) were successfully cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli cells. All recombinant enzymes, except the triple mutant, were purified to apparent homogeneity by successive Q-Sepharose and adenosine-2',5'-bisphosphate-agarose columns. The mutants showed similar apparent Km,NADP values to that of the WT. The Km,Mal value was increased in the D141N and D194N mutants. The Km,Mn value, on the other hand, was increased only in the D141N mutant by 14-fold, corresponding to approximately 1.6 kcal/mol for the Asp141-Mn2+ binding energy. Substrate inhibition by L-malate was only observed in WT, D464N, and D(141,464)N. Initial velocity experiments were performed to derive the various kinetic parameters. The possible interactions between Asp141, Asp194, and Asp464 were analyzed by the double-mutation cycles and triple-mutation box. There are synergistic weakening interactions between Asp141 and Asp194 in the metal binding that impel the D(141,194)N double mutant to an overall specificity constant [k(cat)/(Kd,Mn Km,Mal Km,NADP)] at least four orders of magnitude smaller than the WT value. This difference corresponds to an increase of 6.38 kcal/mol energy barrier for the catalytic efficiency. Mutation at Asp464, on the other hand, has partial additivity on the mutations at Asp141 and Asp194. The overall specificity constants for the double mutants D(194,464)N and D(141,464)N or the triple mutant D(141,194,464)N were decreased by only 10- to 100-fold compared to the WT. These results strongly suggest the involvement of Asp141 in the Mn2+-L-malate binding for the pigeon liver malic enzyme. The Asp194 and Asp464, which may be oxidized by nonspecific binding of Cu2+, are involved in the Mn2+-L-malate binding or catalysis indirectly by modulating the binding affinity of Asp141 with the Mn2+.