Fragment-based de novo ligand design by multiobjective evolutionary optimization

Streamlining Computational Fragment-Based Drug Discovery through Evolutionary Optimization Informed by Ligand-Based Virtual Prescreening

Recent advances in computational methods provide the promise of dramatically accelerating drug discovery. While mathematical modeling and machine learning have become vital in predicting drug-target interactions and properties, there is untapped potential in computational drug discovery due to the vast and complex chemical space. This paper builds on our recently published computational fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) method called fragment databases from screened ligand drug discovery (FDSL-DD). FDSL-DD uses in silico screening to identify ligands from a vast library, fragmenting them while attaching specific attributes based on predicted binding affinity and interaction with the target subdomain. In this paper, we further propose a two-stage optimization method that utilizes the information from prescreening to optimize computational ligand synthesis. We hypothesize that using prescreening information for optimization shrinks the search space and focuses on promising regions, thereby improving the optimization for candidate ligands. The first optimization stage assembles these fragments into larger compounds using genetic algorithms, followed by a second stage of iterative refinement to produce compounds with enhanced bioactivity. To demonstrate broad applicability, the methodology is demonstrated on three diverse protein targets found in human solid cancers, bacterial antimicrobial resistance, and the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Combined, the proposed FDSL-DD and a two-stage optimization approach yield high-affinity ligand candidates more efficiently than other state-of-the-art computational FBDD methods. We further show that a multiobjective optimization method accounting for drug-likeness can still produce potential candidate ligands with a high binding affinity. Overall, the results demonstrate that integrating detailed chemical information with a constrained search framework can markedly optimize the initial drug discovery process, offering a more precise and efficient route to developing new therapeutics.

Multi-and many-objective optimization: present and future in de novo drug design

de novo Drug Design (dnDD) aims to create new molecules that satisfy multiple conflicting objectives. Since several desired properties can be considered in the optimization process, dnDD is naturally categorized as a many-objective optimization problem (ManyOOP), where more than three objectives must be simultaneously optimized. However, a large number of objectives typically pose several challenges that affect the choice and the design of optimization methodologies. Herein, we cover the application of multi- and many-objective optimization methods, particularly those based on Evolutionary Computation and Machine Learning techniques, to enlighten their potential application in dnDD. Additionally, we comprehensively analyze how molecular properties used in the optimization process are applied as either objectives or constraints to the problem. Finally, we discuss future research in many-objective optimization for dnDD, highlighting two important possible impacts: i) its integration with the development of multi-target approaches to accelerate the discovery of innovative and more efficacious drug therapies and ii) its role as a catalyst for new developments in more fundamental and general methodological frameworks in the field.

STAGAN: An approach for improve the stability of molecular graph generation based on generative adversarial networks

With the wide application of deep learning in Drug Discovery, deep generative model has shown its advantages in drug molecular generation. Generative adversarial networks can be used to learn the internal structure of molecules, but the training process may be unstable, such as gradient disappearance and model collapse, which may lead to the generation of molecules that do not conform to chemical rules or a single style. In this paper, a novel method called STAGAN was proposed to solve the difficulty of model training, by adding a new gradient penalty term in the discriminator and designing a parallel layer of batch normalization used in generator. As an illustration of method, STAGAN generated higher valid and unique molecules than previous models in training datasets from QM9 and ZINC-250K. This indicates that the proposed method can effectively solve the instability problem in the model training process, and can provide more instructive guidance for the further study of molecular graph generation.

BMaps: A Web Application for Fragment-Based Drug Design and Compound Binding Evaluation

Fragment-based drug design uses data about where, and how strongly, small chemical fragments bind to proteins, to assemble new drug molecules. Over the past decade, we have been successfully using fragment data, derived from thermodynamically rigorous Monte Carlo fragment-protein binding simulations, in dozens of preclinical drug programs. However, this approach has not been available to the broader research community because of the cost and complexity of doing simulations and using design tools. We have developed a web application, called BMaps, to make fragment-based drug design widely available with greatly simplified user interfaces. BMaps provides access to a large repository (>550) of proteins with 100s of precomputed fragment maps, druggable hot spots, and high-quality water maps. Users can also employ their own structures or those from the Protein Data Bank and AlphaFold DB. Multigigabyte data sets are searched to find fragments in bondable orientations, ranked by a binding-free energy metric. The designers use this to select modifications that improve affinity and other properties. BMaps is unique in combining conventional tools such as docking and energy minimization with fragment-based design, in a very easy to use and automated web application. The service is available at https://www.boltzmannmaps.com.

Linkers in fragment-based drug design: an overview of the literature

INTRODUCTION

In fragment-based drug design, fragment linking is a popular strategy where two fragments binding to different sub-pockets of a target are linked together. This attractive method remains challenging especially due to the design of ideal linkers.

AREAS COVERED

The authors review the types of linkers and chemical reactions commonly used to the synthesis of linkers, including those utilized in protein-templated fragment self-assembly, where fragments are directly linked in the presence of the protein. Finally, they detail computational workflows and software including generative models that have been developed for fragment linking.

EXPERT OPINION

The authors believe that fragment linking offers key advantages for compound design, particularly for the design of bivalent inhibitors linking two distinct pockets of the same or different subunits. On the other hand, more studies are needed to increase the potential of protein-templated approaches in FBDD. Important computational tools such as structure-based de novo software are emerging to select suitable linkers. Fragment linking will undoubtedly benefit from developments in computational approaches and machine learning models.

Docking-based generative approaches in the search for new drug candidates

Despite the popularity of virtual screening (VS) of existing compound libraries, the search for new potential drug candidates also takes advantage of generative protocols, where new compound suggestions are enumerated using various algorithms. To increase the activity potency of generative approaches, they have recently been coupled with molecular docking, a leading methodology of structure-based drug design (SBDD). In this review, we summarize progress since docking-based generative models emerged. We propose a new taxonomy for these methods and discuss their importance for the field of computer-aided drug design (CADD). In addition, we discuss the most promising directions for the further development of generative protocols coupled with docking.

A molecular evolution algorithm for ligand design in DOCK

As a complement to virtual screening, de novo design of small molecules is an alternative approach for identifying potential drug candidates. Here, we present a new 3D genetic algorithm to evolve molecules through breeding, mutation, fitness pressure, and selection. The method, termed DOCK_GA, builds upon and leverages powerful sampling, scoring, and searching routines previously implemented into DOCK6. Three primary experiments were used during development: Single-molecule evolution evaluated three selection methods (elitism, tournament, and roulette), in four clinically relevant systems, in terms of mutation type and crossover success, chemical properties, ensemble diversity, and fitness convergence, among others. Large scale benchmarking assessed performance across 651 different protein-ligand systems. Ensemble-based evolution demonstrated using multiple inhibitors simultaneously to seed growth in a SARS-CoV-2 target. Key takeaways include: (1) The algorithm is robust as demonstrated by the successful evolution of molecules across a large diverse dataset. (2) Users have flexibility with regards to parent input, selection method, fitness function, and molecular descriptors. (3) The program is straightforward to run and only requires a single executable and input file at run-time. (4) The elitism selection method yields more tightly clustered molecules in terms of 2D/3D similarity, with more favorable fitness, followed by tournament and roulette.

Artificial Intelligence in De novo Drug Design: Are We Still There?

BACKGROUND

The artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted design of drug candidates with novel structures and desired properties has received significant attention in the recent past, so related areas of forward prediction that aim to discover chemical matters worth synthesizing and further experimental investigation.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose behind developing AI-driven models is to explore the broader chemical space and suggest new drug candidate scaffolds with promising therapeutic value. Moreover, it is anticipated that such AI-based models may not only significantly reduce the cost and time but also decrease the attrition rate of drug candidates that fail to reach the desirable endpoints at the final stages of drug development. In an attempt to develop AI-based models for de novo drug design, numerous methods have been proposed by various study groups by applying machine learning and deep learning algorithms to chemical datasets. However, there are many challenges in obtaining accurate predictions, and real breakthroughs in de novo drug design are still scarce.

METHODS

In this review, we explore the recent trends in developing AI-based models for de novo drug design to assess the current status, challenges, and opportunities in the field.

CONCLUSION

The consistently improved AI algorithms and the abundance of curated training chemical data indicate that AI-based de novo drug design should perform better than the current models. Improvements in the performance are warranted to obtain better outcomes in the form of potential drug candidates, which can perform well in in vivo conditions, especially in the case of more complex diseases.

Fragment-Based Drug Discovery by NMR. Where Are the Successes and Where can It Be Improved?

Over the last century, the definitions of pharmaceutical drug and drug discovery have changed considerably. Evolving from an almost exclusively serendipitous approach, drug discovery nowadays involves several distinct, yet sometimes interconnected stages aimed at obtaining molecules able to interact with a defined biomolecular target, and triggering a suitable biological response. At each of the stages, a wide range of techniques are typically employed to obtain the results required to move the project into the next stage. High Throughput Screening (HTS) and Fragment Based Drug Design (FBDD) are the two main approaches used to identify drug-like candidates in the early stages of drug discovery. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has many applications in FBDD and is used extensively in industry as well as in academia. In this manuscript, we discuss the paths of both successful and unsuccessful molecules where NMR had a crucial part in their development. We specifically focus on the techniques used and describe strengths and weaknesses of each stage by examining several case studies. More precisely, we examine the development history from the primary screening to the final lead optimisation of AZD3839 interacting with BACE-1, ABT-199 interacting with BCL2/XL and S64315 interacting with MCL-1. Based on these studies, we derive observations and conclusions regarding the FBDD process by NMR and discuss its potential improvements.

LEADD: Lamarckian evolutionary algorithm for de novo drug design

Given an objective function that predicts key properties of a molecule, goal-directed de novo molecular design is a useful tool to identify molecules that maximize or minimize said objective function. Nonetheless, a common drawback of these methods is that they tend to design synthetically unfeasible molecules. In this paper we describe a Lamarckian evolutionary algorithm for de novo drug design (LEADD). LEADD attempts to strike a balance between optimization power, synthetic accessibility of designed molecules and computational efficiency. To increase the likelihood of designing synthetically accessible molecules, LEADD represents molecules as graphs of molecular fragments, and limits the bonds that can be formed between them through knowledge-based pairwise atom type compatibility rules. A reference library of drug-like molecules is used to extract fragments, fragment preferences and compatibility rules. A novel set of genetic operators that enforce these rules in a computationally efficient manner is presented. To sample chemical space more efficiently we also explore a Lamarckian evolutionary mechanism that adapts the reproductive behavior of molecules. LEADD has been compared to both standard virtual screening and a comparable evolutionary algorithm using a standardized benchmark suite and was shown to be able to identify fitter molecules more efficiently. Moreover, the designed molecules are predicted to be easier to synthesize than those designed by other evolutionary algorithms.

Comprehensive assessment of deep generative architectures for de novo drug design

Recently, deep learning (DL)-based de novo drug design represents a new trend in pharmaceutical research, and numerous DL-based methods have been developed for the generation of novel compounds with desired properties. However, a comprehensive understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of these methods is still lacking. In this study, the performances of different generative models were evaluated by analyzing the properties of the generated molecules in different scenarios, such as goal-directed (rediscovery, optimization and scaffold hopping of active compounds) and target-specific (generation of novel compounds for a given target) tasks. In overall, the DL-based models have significant advantages over the baseline models built by the traditional methods in learning the physicochemical property distributions of the training sets and may be more suitable for target-specific tasks. However, both the baselines and DL-based generative models cannot fully exploit the scaffolds of the training sets, and the molecules generated by the DL-based methods even have lower scaffold diversity than those generated by the traditional models. Moreover, our assessment illustrates that the DL-based methods do not exhibit obvious advantages over the genetic algorithm-based baselines in goal-directed tasks. We believe that our study provides valuable guidance for the effective use of generative models in de novo drug design.

Update and New Insights on Future Cancer Drug Candidates From Plant-Based Alkaloids

Cancer is a complex multifactorial disease that results from alterations in many physiological and biochemical functions. Over the last few decades, it has become clear that cancer cells can acquire multidrug resistance to conventional anticancer drugs, resulting in tumor relapse. Thus, there is a continuous need to discover new and effective anticancer drugs. Natural products from plants have served as a primary source of cancer drugs and continue to provide new plant-derived anticancer drugs. The present review describes plant-based alkaloids, which have been reported as active or potentially active in cancer treatment within the past 4 years (2017-2020), both in preclinical research and/or in clinical trials. In addition, recent insights into the possible molecular mechanism of action of alkaloid prodrugs naturally present in plants are also highlighted.

CHARMM-GUI Ligand Designer for Template-Based Virtual Ligand Design in a Binding Site

Rational drug design involves a task of finding ligands that would bind to a specific target protein. This work presents CHARMM-GUI Ligand Designer that is an intuitive and interactive web-based tool to design virtual ligands that match the shape and chemical features of a given protein binding site. Ligand Designer provides ligand modification capabilities with 3D visualization that allow researchers to modify and redesign virtual ligands while viewing how the protein-ligand interactions are affected. Virtual ligands can also be parameterized for further molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and free energy calculations. Using 8 targets from 8 different protein classes in the directory of useful decoys, enhanced (DUD-E) data set, we show that Ligand Designer can produce similar ligands to the known active ligands in the crystal structures. Ligand Designer also produces stable protein-ligand complex structures when tested using short MD simulations. We expect that Ligand Designer can be a useful and user-friendly tool to design small molecules in any given potential ligand binding site on a protein of interest.

Kinase Inhibitor Scaffold Hopping with Deep Learning Approaches

The protein kinase family contains many promising drug targets. Many kinase inhibitors target the ATP-binding pocket, leading to approved drugs in past decades. Scaffold hopping is an effective approach for drug design. The kinase ATP-binding pocket is highly conserved, crossing the whole kinase family. This provides an opportunity to develop a scaffold hopping approach to explore diversified scaffolds among various kinase inhibitors. In this work, we report the SyntaLinker-Hybrid scheme for kinase inhibitor scaffold hopping. With this scheme, we replace molecular fragments bound at the conserved kinase hinge region with deep generative models. Thus, we are able to generate new kinase-inhibitor-like structures hybridizing the privileged fragments against the hinge region. We demonstrate that this scheme allows generation of kinase-inhibitor-like molecules with novel scaffolds, while retaining the binding features of existing kinase inhibitors. This work can be employed in lead identification against kinase targets.

Targeting RNA structures in diseases with small molecules

RNA is crucial for gene expression and regulation. Recent advances in understanding of RNA biochemistry, structure and molecular biology have revealed the importance of RNA structure in cellular processes and diseases. Various approaches to discovering drug-like small molecules that target RNA structure have been developed. This review provides a brief introduction to RNA structural biology and how RNA structures function as disease regulators. We summarize approaches to targeting RNA with small molecules and highlight their advantages, shortcomings and therapeutic potential.

Advances in de Novo Drug Design: From Conventional to Machine Learning Methods

. De novo drug design is a computational approach that generates novel molecular structures from atomic building blocks with no a priori relationships. Conventional methods include structure-based and ligand-based design, which depend on the properties of the active site of a biological target or its known active binders, respectively. Artificial intelligence, including machine learning, is an emerging field that has positively impacted the drug discovery process. Deep reinforcement learning is a subdivision of machine learning that combines artificial neural networks with reinforcement-learning architectures. This method has successfully been employed to develop novel de novo drug design approaches using a variety of artificial networks including recurrent neural networks, convolutional neural networks, generative adversarial networks, and autoencoders. This review article summarizes advances in de novo drug design, from conventional growth algorithms to advanced machine-learning methodologies and highlights hot topics for further development.

Computational Approaches for De Novo Drug Design: Past, Present, and Future

Drug discovery is time- and resource-consuming. To this end, computational approaches that are applied in de novo drug design play an important role to improve the efficiency and decrease costs to develop novel drugs. Over several decades, a variety of methods have been proposed and applied in practice. Traditionally, drug design problems are always taken as combinational optimization in discrete chemical space. Hence optimization methods were exploited to search for new drug molecules to meet multiple objectives. With the accumulation of data and the development of machine learning methods, computational drug design methods have gradually shifted to a new paradigm. There has been particular interest in the potential application of deep learning methods to drug design. In this chapter, we will give a brief description of these two different de novo methods, compare their application scopes and discuss their possible development in the future.

Artificial intelligence in the early stages of drug discovery

Although the use of computational methods within the pharmaceutical industry is well established, there is an urgent need for new approaches that can improve and optimize the pipeline of drug discovery and development. In spite of the fact that there is no unique solution for this need for innovation, there has recently been a strong interest in the use of Artificial Intelligence for this purpose. As a matter of fact, not only there have been major contributions from the scientific community in this respect, but there has also been a growing partnership between the pharmaceutical industry and Artificial Intelligence companies. Beyond these contributions and efforts there is an underlying question, which we intend to discuss in this review: can the intrinsic difficulties within the drug discovery process be overcome with the implementation of Artificial Intelligence? While this is an open question, in this work we will focus on the advantages that these algorithms provide over the traditional methods in the context of early drug discovery.

Autonomous molecule generation using reinforcement learning and docking to develop potential novel inhibitors

We developed a computational method named Molecule Optimization by Reinforcement Learning and Docking (MORLD) that automatically generates and optimizes lead compounds by combining reinforcement learning and docking to develop predicted novel inhibitors. This model requires only a target protein structure and directly modifies ligand structures to obtain higher predicted binding affinity for the target protein without any other training data. Using MORLD, we were able to generate potential novel inhibitors against discoidin domain receptor 1 kinase (DDR1) in less than 2 days on a moderate computer. We also demonstrated MORLD's ability to generate predicted novel agonists for the D4 dopamine receptor (D4DR) from scratch without virtual screening on an ultra large compound library. The free web server is available at http://morld.kaist.ac.kr .

An up-to-date overview of computational polypharmacology in modern drug discovery

INTRODUCTION

In recent years, computational polypharmacology has gained significant attention to study the promiscuous nature of drugs. Despite tremendous challenges, community-wide efforts have led to a variety of novel approaches for predicting drug polypharmacology. In particular, some rapid advances using machine learning and artificial intelligence have been reported with great success.

AREAS COVERED

In this article, the authors provide a comprehensive update on the current state-of-the-art polypharmacology approaches and their applications, focusing on those reports published after our 2017 review article. The authors particularly discuss some novel, groundbreaking concepts, and methods that have been developed recently and applied to drug polypharmacology studies.

EXPERT OPINION

Polypharmacology is evolving and novel concepts are being introduced to counter the current challenges in the field. However, major hurdles remain including incompleteness of high-quality experimental data, lack of in vitro and in vivo assays to characterize multi-targeting agents, shortage of robust computational methods, and challenges to identify the best target combinations and design effective multi-targeting agents. Fortunately, numerous national/international efforts including multi-omics and artificial intelligence initiatives as well as most recent collaborations on addressing the COVID-19 pandemic have shown significant promise to propel the field of polypharmacology forward.

Substituted oxindol-3-ylidenes as AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) inhibitors

AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) is a central metabolic regulator that promotes cancer growth and survival under hypoxia and plays a role in the maintenance of cancer stem cells. A major challenge to interrogating the potential of targeting AMPK in cancer is the lack of potent and selective small molecule inhibitors. Compound C has been widely used as an AMPK inhibitor, but it lacks potency and has a poor selectivity profile. The multi-kinase inhibitor, sunitinib, has demonstrated potent nanomolar inhibition of AMPK activity and has scope for modification. Here, we have designed and synthesized several series of oxindoles to determine the structural requirements for AMPK inhibition and to improve selectivity. We identified two potent, novel oxindole-based AMPK inhibitors that were designed to interact with the DFG motif in the ATP-binding site of AMPK, this key feature evades interaction with the common recptor tyrosine kinase targets of sunitinib. Cellular engagement of AMPK by these oxindoles was confirmed by the inhibition of phosphorylation of acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC), a known substrate of AMPK, in myeloid leukemia cells. Interestingly, although AMPK is highly expressed and activated in K562 cells these oxindole-based AMPK inhibitors did not impact cell viability or result in significant cytotoxicity. Our studies serve as a platform for the further development of oxindole-based AMPK inhibitors with therapeutic potential.

Deep Generative Models for 3D Linker Design

Rational compound design remains a challenging problem for both computational methods and medicinal chemists. Computational generative methods have begun to show promising results for the design problem. However, they have not yet used the power of three-dimensional (3D) structural information. We have developed a novel graph-based deep generative model that combines state-of-the-art machine learning techniques with structural knowledge. Our method ("DeLinker") takes two fragments or partial structures and designs a molecule incorporating both. The generation process is protein-context-dependent, utilizing the relative distance and orientation between the partial structures. This 3D information is vital to successful compound design, and we demonstrate its impact on the generation process and the limitations of omitting such information. In a large-scale evaluation, DeLinker designed 60% more molecules with high 3D similarity to the original molecule than a database baseline. When considering the more relevant problem of longer linkers with at least five atoms, the outperformance increased to 200%. We demonstrate the effectiveness and applicability of this approach on a diverse range of design problems: fragment linking, scaffold hopping, and proteolysis targeting chimera (PROTAC) design. As far as we are aware, this is the first molecular generative model to incorporate 3D structural information directly in the design process. The code is available at https://github.com/oxpig/DeLinker.

AutoGrow4: an open-source genetic algorithm for de novo drug design and lead optimization

We here present AutoGrow4, an open-source program for semi-automated computer-aided drug discovery. AutoGrow4 uses a genetic algorithm to evolve predicted ligands on demand and so is not limited to a virtual library of pre-enumerated compounds. It is a useful tool for generating entirely novel drug-like molecules and for optimizing preexisting ligands. By leveraging recent computational and cheminformatics advancements, AutoGrow4 is faster, more stable, and more modular than previous versions. It implements new docking-program compatibility, chemical filters, multithreading options, and selection methods to support a wide range of user needs. To illustrate both de novo design and lead optimization, we here apply AutoGrow4 to the catalytic domain of poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP-1), a well characterized DNA-damage-recognition protein. AutoGrow4 produces drug-like compounds with better predicted binding affinities than FDA-approved PARP-1 inhibitors (positive controls). The predicted binding modes of the AutoGrow4 compounds mimic those of the known inhibitors, even when AutoGrow4 is seeded with random small molecules. AutoGrow4 is available under the terms of the Apache License, Version 2.0. A copy can be downloaded free of charge from http://durrantlab.com/autogrow4.

In silico Strategies to Support Fragment-to-Lead Optimization in Drug Discovery

Fragment-based drug (or lead) discovery (FBDD or FBLD) has developed in the last two decades to become a successful key technology in the pharmaceutical industry for early stage drug discovery and development. The FBDD strategy consists of screening low molecular weight compounds against macromolecular targets (usually proteins) of clinical relevance. These small molecular fragments can bind at one or more sites on the target and act as starting points for the development of lead compounds. In developing the fragments attractive features that can translate into compounds with favorable physical, pharmacokinetics and toxicity (ADMET-absorption, distribution, metabolism, excretion, and toxicity) properties can be integrated. Structure-enabled fragment screening campaigns use a combination of screening by a range of biophysical techniques, such as differential scanning fluorimetry, surface plasmon resonance, and thermophoresis, followed by structural characterization of fragment binding using NMR or X-ray crystallography. Structural characterization is also used in subsequent analysis for growing fragments of selected screening hits. The latest iteration of the FBDD workflow employs a high-throughput methodology of massively parallel screening by X-ray crystallography of individually soaked fragments. In this review we will outline the FBDD strategies and explore a variety of in silico approaches to support the follow-up fragment-to-lead optimization of either: growing, linking, and merging. These fragment expansion strategies include hot spot analysis, druggability prediction, SAR (structure-activity relationships) by catalog methods, application of machine learning/deep learning models for virtual screening and several de novo design methods for proposing synthesizable new compounds. Finally, we will highlight recent case studies in fragment-based drug discovery where in silico methods have successfully contributed to the development of lead compounds.

Identification and characterization of fragment binding sites for allosteric ligand design using the site identification by ligand competitive saturation hotspots approach (SILCS-Hotspots)

BACKGROUND

Fragment-based ligand design is used for the development of novel ligands that target macromolecules, most notably proteins. Central to its success is the identification of fragment binding sites that are spatially adjacent such that fragments occupying those sites may be linked to create drug-like ligands. Current experimental and computational approaches that address this problem typically identify only a limited number of sites as well as use a limited number of fragment types.

METHODS

The site-identification by ligand competitive saturation (SILCS) approach is extended to the identification of fragment bindings sites, with the method termed SILCS-Hotspots. The approach involves precomputation of the SILCS FragMaps following which the identification of Hotspots, performed by identifying of all possible fragment binding sites on the full 3D structure of the protein followed by spatial clustering.

RESULTS

The SILCS-Hotspots approach identifies a large number of sites on the target protein, including many sites not accessible in experimental structures due to low binding affinities and binding sites on the protein interior. The identified sites are shown to recapitulate the location of known drug-like molecules in both allosteric and orthosteric binding sites on seven proteins including the androgen receptor, the CDK2 and Erk5 kinases, PTP1B phosphatase and three GPCRs; the β2-adrenergic, GPR40 fatty-acid binding and M2-muscarinic receptors. Analysis indicates the importance of considering all possible fragment binding sites, and not just those accessible to experimental methods, when identifying novel binding sites and performing ligand design versus just considering the most favorable sites. The approach is shown to identify a larger number of known binding sites of drug-like molecules versus the commonly used FTMap and Fpocket methods.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

The present results indicate the potential utility of the SILCS-Hotspots approach for fragment-based rational design of ligands, including allosteric modulators.

New Data Structure for Computational Molecular Design with Atomic or Fragment Resolution

A new molecular data structure and molecular structure operation algorithms are proposed for general purpose molecular design. The data structure allows for a variety of molecular operations for creating new molecules. Two types of molecular operations were developed, unimolecular and bimolecular operations. In unimolecular operations, a child molecule can be created from a parent via addition of a functional group, deletion of a fragment, mutation of an atom, etc. In bimolecular operations, children molecules are generated from two parent molecules through combination or crossover (hybridization). These molecular operations are essential for the creation and modification of molecules for the purpose of molecular design. The data structure is capable of representing linear, branched, multifunctional, and multivalent compounds. Algorithms are developed for deriving the molecular data structure of a molecule from its atomic coordinates and vice versa. We show that this new molecular data structure and the developed algorithms, referred to as Molecular Assembling and Representation Suite, allow one to generate a comprehensive library of new molecules via performing every possible molecular structure modification.

Efficient multi-objective molecular optimization in a continuous latent space

One of the main challenges in small molecule drug discovery is finding novel chemical compounds with desirable properties. In this work, we propose a novel method that combines in silico prediction of molecular properties such as biological activity or pharmacokinetics with an in silico optimization algorithm, namely Particle Swarm Optimization. Our method takes a starting compound as input and proposes new molecules with more desirable (predicted) properties. It navigates a machine-learned continuous representation of a drug-like chemical space guided by a defined objective function. The objective function combines multiple in silico prediction models, defined desirability ranges and substructure constraints. We demonstrate that our proposed method is able to consistently find more desirable molecules for the studied tasks in relatively short time. We hope that our method can support medicinal chemists in accelerating and improving the lead optimization process.

Concepts of Artificial Intelligence for Computer-Assisted Drug Discovery

Artificial intelligence (AI), and, in particular, deep learning as a subcategory of AI, provides opportunities for the discovery and development of innovative drugs. Various machine learning approaches have recently (re)emerged, some of which may be considered instances of domain-specific AI which have been successfully employed for drug discovery and design. This review provides a comprehensive portrayal of these machine learning techniques and of their applications in medicinal chemistry. After introducing the basic principles, alongside some application notes, of the various machine learning algorithms, the current state-of-the art of AI-assisted pharmaceutical discovery is discussed, including applications in structure- and ligand-based virtual screening, de novo drug design, physicochemical and pharmacokinetic property prediction, drug repurposing, and related aspects. Finally, several challenges and limitations of the current methods are summarized, with a view to potential future directions for AI-assisted drug discovery and design.

Approaching Target Selectivity by De Novo Drug Design

Introduction: The development of drug candidates with a defined selectivity profile and a unique molecular structure is of fundamental interest for drug discovery. In contrast to the costly screening of large substance libraries, the targeted de novo design of a drug by using structural information of either the biological target and/or structure-activity relationship data of active modulators offers an efficient and intellectually appealing alternative. Areas covered: This review provides an overview on the different techniques of de novo drug design (ligand-based drug design, structure-based drug design, and fragment-based drug design) and highlights successful examples of this targeted approach toward selective modulators of therapeutically relevant targets. Expert opinion: De novo drug design has established itself as a very efficient method for the development of potent and selective modulators for a variety of different biological target classes. The ever-growing wealth of structural data on therapeutic targets will certainly further enhance the importance of de novo design for the drug discovery process in the future. However, a consistent use of the terminology of de novo drug design in the scientific literature should be sought.

Multi-objective de novo drug design with conditional graph generative model

Recently, deep generative models have revealed itself as a promising way of performing de novo molecule design. However, previous research has focused mainly on generating SMILES strings instead of molecular graphs. Although available, current graph generative models are are often too general and computationally expensive. In this work, a new de novo molecular design framework is proposed based on a type of sequential graph generators that do not use atom level recurrent units. Compared with previous graph generative models, the proposed method is much more tuned for molecule generation and has been scaled up to cover significantly larger molecules in the ChEMBL database. It is shown that the graph-based model outperforms SMILES based models in a variety of metrics, especially in the rate of valid outputs. For the application of drug design tasks, conditional graph generative model is employed. This method offers highe flexibility and is suitable for generation based on multiple objectives. The results have demonstrated that this approach can be effectively applied to solve several drug design problems, including the generation of compounds containing a given scaffold, compounds with specific drug-likeness and synthetic accessibility requirements, as well as dual inhibitors against JNK3 and GSK-3β.

In silico fragment-based drug design with SEED

We report on two fragment-based drug design protocols, SEED2XR and ALTA, which start by high-throughput docking. SEED2XR is a two-stage protocol for fragment-based drug design. The first stage is in silico and consists of the automatic docking of 10³-10⁴ fragments using SEED, which requires about 1 s per fragment. SEED is a docking software developed specifically for fragment docking and binding energy evaluation by a force field with implicit solvent. In the second stage of SEED2XR, the 10-10² fragments with the most favorable predicted binding energies are validated by protein X-ray crystallography. The recent applications of SEED2XR to bromodomains demonstrate that the whole SEED2XR protocol can be carried out in about a week of working time, with hit rates ranging from 10% to 40%. Information on fragment-target interactions generated by the SEED2XR protocol or directly from SEED docking has been used for the discovery of hundreds of hits. ALTA is a computational protocol for screening which identifies candidate ligands that preserve the interactions between the optimal SEED fragments and the protein target. Medicinal chemistry optimization of ligands predicted by ALTA has resulted in pre-clinical candidates for protein kinases and bromodomains. The high-throughput, very low cost, sustainability, and high hit rate of the SEED-based protocols, unreachable by purely experimental techniques, make them perfectly suitable for both academic and industrial drug discovery research.

Recent applications of machine learning in medicinal chemistry

In recent decades, artificial intelligence and machine learning have played a significant role in increasing the efficiency of processes across a wide spectrum of industries. When it comes to the pharmaceutical and biotechnology sectors, numerous tools enabled by advancement of computer science have been developed and are now routinely utilized. However, there are many aspects of the drug discovery process, which can further benefit from refinement of computational methods and tools, as well as improvement of accessibility of these new technologies. In this review, examples of recent developments in machine learning application are described, which have the potential to impact different parts of the drug discovery and development flow scheme. Notably, new deep learning-based approaches across compound design and synthesis, prediction of binding, activity and ADMET properties, as well as applications of genetic algorithms are highlighted.

Binding-Site Compatible Fragment Growing Applied to the Design of β2-Adrenergic Receptor Ligands

Fragment-based drug discovery is intimately linked to fragment extension approaches that can be accelerated using software for de novo design. Although computers allow for the facile generation of millions of suggestions, synthetic feasibility is however often neglected. In this study we computationally extended, chemically synthesized, and experimentally assayed new ligands for the β₂-adrenergic receptor (β₂AR) by growing fragment-sized ligands. In order to address the synthetic tractability issue, our in silico workflow aims at derivatized products based on robust organic reactions. The study started from the predicted binding modes of five fragments. We suggested a total of eight diverse extensions that were easily synthesized, and further assays showed that four products had an improved affinity (up to 40-fold) compared to their respective initial fragment. The described workflow, which we call "growing via merging" and for which the key tools are available online, can improve early fragment-based drug discovery projects, making it a useful creative tool for medicinal chemists during structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies.

De Novo Design of Ligands Using Computational Methods

De novo design technique is complementary to high-throughput virtual screening and is believed to contribute in pharmaceutical development of novel drugs with desired properties at a very low cost and time-efficient manner. In this chapter, we outline the basic de novo design concepts based on computational methods with an example.

Structure-based prediction of ligand-protein interactions on a genome-wide scale

We report a template-based method, LT-scanner, which scans the human proteome using protein structural alignment to identify proteins that are likely to bind ligands that are present in experimentally determined complexes. A scoring function that rapidly accounts for binding site similarities between the template and the proteins being scanned is a crucial feature of the method. The overall approach is first tested based on its ability to predict the residues on the surface of a protein that are likely to bind small-molecule ligands. The algorithm that we present, LBias, is shown to compare very favorably to existing algorithms for binding site residue prediction. LT-scanner's performance is evaluated based on its ability to identify known targets of Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved drugs and it too proves to be highly effective. The specificity of the scoring function that we use is demonstrated by the ability of LT-scanner to identify the known targets of FDA-approved kinase inhibitors based on templates involving other kinases. Combining sequence with structural information further improves LT-scanner performance. The approach we describe is extendable to the more general problem of identifying binding partners of known ligands even if they do not appear in a structurally determined complex, although this will require the integration of methods that combine protein structure and chemical compound databases.

Computer-Aided Drug Discovery in Plant Pathology

Control of plant diseases is largely dependent on use of agrochemicals. However, there are widening gaps between our knowledge on plant diseases gained from genetic/mechanistic studies and rapid translation of the knowledge into target-oriented development of effective agrochemicals. Here we propose that the time is ripe for computer-aided drug discovery/design (CADD) in molecular plant pathology. CADD has played a pivotal role in development of medically important molecules over the last three decades. Now, explosive increase in information on genome sequences and three dimensional structures of biological molecules, in combination with advances in computational and informational technologies, opens up exciting possibilities for application of CADD in discovery and development of agrochemicals. In this review, we outline two categories of the drug discovery strategies: structure- and ligand-based CADD, and relevant computational approaches that are being employed in modern drug discovery. In order to help readers to dive into CADD, we explain concepts of homology modelling, molecular docking, virtual screening, and de novo ligand design in structure-based CADD, and pharmacophore modelling, ligand-based virtual screening, quantitative structure activity relationship modelling and de novo ligand design for ligand-based CADD. We also provide the important resources available to carry out CADD. Finally, we present a case study showing how CADD approach can be implemented in reality for identification of potent chemical compounds against the important plant pathogens, Pseudomonas syringae and Colletotrichum gloeosporioides.

Fragment-based drug discovery as alternative strategy to the drug development for neglected diseases

Neglected diseases (NDs) affect large populations and almost whole continents, representing 12% of the global health burden. In contrast, the treatment available today is limited and sometimes ineffective. Under this scenery, the Fragment-Based Drug Discovery emerged as one of the most promising alternatives to the traditional methods of drug development. This method allows achieving new lead compounds with smaller size of fragment libraries. Even with the wide Fragment-Based Drug Discovery success resulting in new effective therapeutic agents against different diseases, until this moment few studies have been applied this approach for NDs area. In this article, we discuss the basic Fragment-Based Drug Discovery process, brief successful ideas of general applications and show a landscape of its use in NDs, encouraging the implementation of this strategy as an interesting way to optimize the development of new drugs to NDs.

Bayesian molecular design with a chemical language model

The aim of computational molecular design is the identification of promising hypothetical molecules with a predefined set of desired properties. We address the issue of accelerating the material discovery with state-of-the-art machine learning techniques. The method involves two different types of prediction; the forward and backward predictions. The objective of the forward prediction is to create a set of machine learning models on various properties of a given molecule. Inverting the trained forward models through Bayes’ law, we derive a posterior distribution for the backward prediction, which is conditioned by a desired property requirement. Exploring high-probability regions of the posterior with a sequential Monte Carlo technique, molecules that exhibit the desired properties can computationally be created. One major difficulty in the computational creation of molecules is the exclusion of the occurrence of chemically unfavorable structures. To circumvent this issue, we derive a chemical language model that acquires commonly occurring patterns of chemical fragments through natural language processing of ASCII strings of existing compounds, which follow the SMILES chemical language notation. In the backward prediction, the trained language model is used to refine chemical strings such that the properties of the resulting structures fall within the desired property region while chemically unfavorable structures are successfully removed. The present method is demonstrated through the design of small organic molecules with the property requirements on HOMO-LUMO gap and internal energy. The R package iqspr is available at the CRAN repository.

Computational polypharmacology: a new paradigm for drug discovery

INTRODUCTION

Over the past couple of years, the cost of drug development has sharply increased along with the high rate of clinical trial failures. Such increase in expenses is partially due to the inability of the "one drug - one target" approach to predict drug side effects and toxicities. To tackle this issue, an alternative approach, known as polypharmacology, is being adopted to study small molecule interactions with multiple targets. Apart from developing more potent and effective drugs, this approach allows for studies of off-target activities and the facilitation of drug repositioning. Although exhaustive polypharmacology studies in-vitro or in-vivo are not practical, computational methods of predicting unknown targets or side effects are being developed. Areas covered: This article describes various computational approaches that have been developed to study polypharmacology profiles of small molecules. It also provides a brief description of the algorithms used in these state-of-the-art methods. Expert opinion: Recent success in computational prediction of multi-targeting drugs has established polypharmacology as a promising alternative approach to tackle some of the daunting complications in drug discovery. This will not only help discover more effective agents, but also present tremendous opportunities to study novel target pharmacology and facilitate drug repositioning efforts in the pharmaceutical industry.

Chemical-Space-Based de Novo Design Method To Generate Drug-Like Molecules

To discover drug compounds in chemical space containing an enormous number of compounds, a structure generator is required to produce virtual drug-like chemical structures. The de novo design algorithm for exploring chemical space (DAECS) visualizes the activity distribution on a two-dimensional plane corresponding to chemical space and generates structures in a target area on a plane selected by the user. In this study, we modify the DAECS to enable the user to select a target area to consider properties other than activity and improve the diversity of the generated structures by visualizing the drug-likeness distribution and the activity distribution, generating structures by substructure-based structural changes, including addition, deletion, and substitution of substructures, as well as the slight structural changes used in the DAECS. Through case studies using ligand data for the human adrenergic alpha2A receptor and the human histamine H1 receptor, the modified DAECS can generate high diversity drug-like structures, and the usefulness of the modification of the DAECS is verified.

Fragment-Based De Novo Design of Cyclin-Dependent Kinase 2 Inhibitors

Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) are core components of the cell cycle machinery that govern the transition between phases during cell cycle progression. Abnormalities in CDKs activity and regulation are common features of cancer, making CDK family members attractive targets for the development of anticancer drugs. One of the main bottlenecks hampering the development of drugs for kinase is the difficulty to attain selectivity. A huge variety of small molecules have been reported as CDK inhibitors, as potential anticancer agents, but none of these has been approved for commercial use. Computer-based molecular design supports drug discovery by suggesting novel new chemotypes and compound modifications for lead candidate optimization. One of the methods known as de novo ligand design technique has emerged as a complementary approach to high-throughput screening. Several automated de novo software programs have been written, which automatically design novel structures to perfectly fit in known binding site. The de novo design supports drug discovery assignments by generating novel pharmaceutically active agents with desired properties in a cost as well as time efficient approach. This chapter describes procedure and an overview of computer-based molecular de novo design methods on a conceptual level with successful examples of CDKs inhibitors.

TD-DFT based fine-tuning of molecular excitation energies using evolutionary algorithms

An evolutionary de novo design method is presented to fine-tune the excitation energies of molecules calculated using time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT).