Biomimetic studies of terminal oxidases: trisimidazole picket metalloporphyrins

The Biologically Relevant Coordination Chemistry of Iron and Nitric Oxide: Electronic Structure and Reactivity

Nitric oxide (NO) is an important signaling molecule that is involved in a wide range of physiological and pathological events in biology. Metal coordination chemistry, especially with iron, is at the heart of many biological transformations involving NO. A series of heme proteins, nitric oxide synthases (NOS), soluble guanylate cyclase (sGC), and nitrophorins, are responsible for the biosynthesis, sensing, and transport of NO. Alternatively, NO can be generated from nitrite by heme- and copper-containing nitrite reductases (NIRs). The NO-bearing small molecules such as nitrosothiols and dinitrosyl iron complexes (DNICs) can serve as an alternative vehicle for NO storage and transport. Once NO is formed, the rich reaction chemistry of NO leads to a wide variety of biological activities including reduction of NO by heme or non-heme iron-containing NO reductases and protein post-translational modifications by DNICs. Much of our understanding of the reactivity of metal sites in biology with NO and the mechanisms of these transformations has come from the elucidation of the geometric and electronic structures and chemical reactivity of synthetic model systems, in synergy with biochemical and biophysical studies on the relevant proteins themselves. This review focuses on recent advancements from studies on proteins and model complexes that not only have improved our understanding of the biological roles of NO but also have provided foundations for biomedical research and for bio-inspired catalyst design in energy science.

Proton Relay in Iron Porphyrins for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction

The efficiency of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) can be facilitated by the presence of proton-transfer groups in the vicinity of the catalyst. A systematic investigation of the nature of the proton-transfer groups present and their interplay with bulk proton sources is warranted. The HERs electrocatalyzed by a series of iron porphyrins that vary in the nature and number of pendant amine groups are investigated using proton sources whose pK_a values vary from ∼9 to 15 in acetonitrile. Electrochemical data indicate that a simple iron porphyrin (FeTPP) can catalyze the HER at this Fe^I state where the rate-determining step is the intermolecular protonation of a Fe^III-H^- species produced upon protonation of the iron(I) porphyrin and does not need to be reduced to its formal Fe⁰ state. A linear free-energy correlation of the observed rate with pK_a of the acid source used suggests that the rate of the HER becomes almost independent of pK_a of the external acid used in the presence of the protonated distal residues. Protonation to the Fe^III-H^- species during the HER changes from intermolecular in FeTPP to intramolecular in FeTPP derivatives with pendant basic groups. However, the inclusion of too many pendant groups leads to a decrease in HER activity because the higher proton binding affinity of these residues slows proton transfer for the HER. These results enrich the existing understanding of how second-sphere proton-transfer residues alter both the kinetics and thermodynamics of transition-metal-catalyzed HER.

Selective Convergence to Atropisomers of a Porphyrin Derivative Having Bulky Substituents at the Periphery

Four kinds of possible atropisomers of a porphyrin derivative (1), having mesityl groups at one of the o-positions of each meso-aryl group, can be selectively converged to targeted atropisomers among the four isomers (αααα, αααβ, αβαβ, and ααββ) under appropriate conditions for each atropisomer. For example, protonation and subsequent neutralization of a free base porphyrin (H₂-1) induces a convergence reaction to the αβαβ atropisomer, H₂-1-αβαβ, from an atropisomeric mixture. The αααα isomer, H₂-1-αααα, was also obtained by heating a solution of H₂-1 in CHCl₃ in 60% isolated yield, probably owing to a template effect of the solvent molecule. Remarkably, when an atropisomeric mixture of its zinc complex, Zn-1, was heated at 70 °C in a ClCH₂CH₂Cl/MeOH mixed solvent, crystals composed of only Zn-1-αααα were formed. The hydrophobic space formed by the four mesityl groups in the αααα isomer can be used for repeatable molecular encapsulation of benzene, and the encapsulation structure was elucidated by powder X-ray diffraction analysis. Heating the solid of an atropisomeric mixture of Zn-1 to 400 °C afforded the ααββ isomer almost quantitatively. On the other hand, the solid of H₂-1-αααα can be converted by heating, successively to H₂-1-αααβ at 286 °C and then to H₂-1-ααββ at 350 °C.

Synthetic Fe/Cu Complexes: Toward Understanding Heme-Copper Oxidase Structure and Function

Heme-copper oxidases (HCOs) are terminal enzymes on the mitochondrial or bacterial respiratory electron transport chain, which utilize a unique heterobinuclear active site to catalyze the 4H+/4e- reduction of dioxygen to water. This process involves a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) from a tyrosine (phenolic) residue and additional redox events coupled to transmembrane proton pumping and ATP synthesis. Given that HCOs are large, complex, membrane-bound enzymes, bioinspired synthetic model chemistry is a promising approach to better understand heme-Cu-mediated dioxygen reduction, including the details of proton and electron movements. This review encompasses important aspects of heme-O2 and copper-O2 (bio)chemistries as they relate to the design and interpretation of small molecule model systems and provides perspectives from fundamental coordination chemistry, which can be applied to the understanding of HCO activity. We focus on recent advancements from studies of heme-Cu models, evaluating experimental and computational results, which highlight important fundamental structure-function relationships. Finally, we provide an outlook for future potential contributions from synthetic inorganic chemistry and discuss their implications with relevance to biological O2-reduction.

Three toxic gases meet in the mitochondria

The rationale of the study was two-fold: (i) develop a functional synthetic model of the Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) active site, (ii) use it as a convenient tool to understand or predict the outcome of the reaction of CcO with ligands (physiologically relevant gases and other ligands). At physiological pH and potential, the model catalyzes the 4-electron reduction of oxygen. This model was immobilized on self-assembled-monolayer (SAM) modified electrode. During catalytic oxygen reduction, electron delivery through SAMs is rate limiting, similar to the situation in CcO. This model contains all three redox-active components in CcO's active site, which are required to minimize the production of partially-reduced-oxygen-species (PROS): Fe-heme (“heme a3”) in a myoglobin-like model fitted with a proximal imidazole ligand, and a distal tris-imidazole Copper (“Cu_B”) complex, where one imidazole is cross-linked to a phenol (mimicking “Tyr244”). This functional CcO model demonstrates how CcO itself might tolerate the hormone NO (which diffuses through the mitochondria). It is proposed that Cu_B delivers superoxide to NO bound to Fe-heme forming peroxynitrite, then nitrate that diffuses away. Another toxic gas, H₂S, has exceptional biological effects: at ~80 ppm, H₂S induces a state similar to hibernation in mice, lowering the animal's temperature and slowing respiration. Using our functional CcO model, we have demonstrated that at the same concentration range H₂S can reversibly inhibit catalytic oxygen reduction. Such a reversible catalytic process on the model was also demonstrated with an organic compound, tetrazole (TZ). Following studies showed that TZ reversibly inhibits respiration in isolated mitochondria, and induces deactivation of platelets, a mitochondria-rich key component of blood coagulation. Hence, this program is a rare example illustrating the use of a functional model to understand and predict physiologically important reactions at the active site of CcO.

Respiratory conservation of energy with dioxygen: cytochrome C oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is the terminal oxidase of cell respiration which reduces molecular oxygen (O₂) to H2O coupled with the proton pump. For elucidation of the mechanism of CcO, the three-dimensional location and chemical reactivity of each atom composing the functional sites have been extensively studied by various techniques, such as crystallography, vibrational and time-resolved electronic spectroscopy, since the X-ray structures (2.8 Å resolution) of bovine and bacterial CcO have been published in 1995.X-ray structures of bovine CcO in different oxidation and ligand binding states showed that the O₂reduction site, which is composed of Fe (heme a 3) and Cu (CuB), drives a non-sequential four-electron transfer for reduction of O₂to water without releasing any reactive oxygen species. These data provide the crucial structural basis to solve a long-standing problem, the mechanism of the O₂reduction.Time-resolved resonance Raman and charge translocation analyses revealed the mechanism for coupling between O₂reduction and the proton pump: O₂is received by the O₂reduction site where both metals are in the reduced state (R-intermediate), giving the O₂-bound form (A-intermediate). This is spontaneously converted to the P-intermediate, with the bound O₂fully reduced to 2 O²⁻. Hereafter the P-intermediate receives four electron equivalents from the second Fe site (heme a), one at a time, to form the three intermediates, F, O, and E to regenerate the R-intermediate. Each electron transfer step from heme a to the O₂reduction site is coupled with the proton pump.X-ray structural and mutational analyses of bovine CcO show three possible proton transfer pathways which can transfer pump protons (H) and chemical (water-forming) protons (K and D). The structure of the H-pathway of bovine CcO indicates that the driving force of the proton pump is the electrostatic repulsion between the protons on the H-pathway and positive charges of heme a, created upon oxidation to donate electrons to the O₂reduction site. On the other hand, mutational and time-resolved electrometric findings for the bacterial CcO strongly suggest that the D-pathway transfers both pump and chemical protons. However, the structure for the proton-gating system in the D-pathway has not been experimentally identified. The structural and functional diversities in CcO from various species suggest a basic proton pumping mechanism in which heme a pumps protons while heme a 3 reduces O₂as proposed in 1978.

Architectural spiroligomers designed for binuclear metal complex templating

The first structurally, spectroscopically, and electronically characterized metal-spiroligomer complexes are reported. The binuclear [M2L2](4+) ions (M = Mn, Zn) are macrocyclic "squares" and are characterized by X-ray diffraction, (1)H and (13)C NMR, electronic absorption, emission, and mass spectroscopies. The manganese complex contains two spin-independent Mn(II) ions and is additionally characterized using EPR and CD spectroscopies and CV.

Recent applications of a synthetic model of cytochrome c oxidase: beyond functional modeling

This account reports recent developments of a functional model for the active site of cytochrome c oxidase (CcO). This CcO mimic not only performs the selective four-electron reduction of oxygen to water but also catalytically reduces oxygen using the biological one-electron reductant, cytochrome c. This functional model has been used to understand other biological reactions of CcO, for example, the interaction between the gaseous hormone, NO, and CcO. A mechanism for inactivating NO-CcO complexes is found to involve a reaction between oxygen and Cu(B). Moreover, NO is shown to be capable of protecting CcO from toxic inhibitors such as CN(-) and CO. Finally, this functional CcO model has been used to show how H(2)S could induce hibernation by reversibly inhibiting the oxygen binding step involved in respiration.

Inhibition of electrocatalytic O(2) reduction of functional CcO models by competitive, non-competitive, and mixed inhibitors

Electrocatalytic reduction of O(2) by functional cytochrome C Oxidase (CcO) models is studied in the presence of several known inhibitors like CO, N(3)(-), CN(-), and NO(2)(-). These models successfully reproduce the inhibitions observed in CcO at similar concentrations reported for these inhibitors. Importantly, the data show very different electrochemical responses depending on the nature of the inhibitor, that is, competitive, non-competitive and mixed. Chemical models have been provided for these observed differences in the electrochemical behavior. Using the benchmark electrochemical behaviors for known inhibitors, the inhibition by NO(2)(-) is investigated. Electrochemical data suggests that NO(2)(-) acts as a competitive inhibitor at high concentrations. Spectroscopic data suggests that NO released during oxidation of the reduced catalyst in presence of excess NO(2)(-) is the source of the competitive inhibition by NO(2)(-). Presence of the distal Cu(B) lowers the inhibitory effect of CN(-) and NO(2)(-). While for CN(-) it weakens its binding affinity to the reduced complex by approximately 4.5 times, for NO(2)(-), it allows regeneration of the active catalyst from a catalytically inactive, air stable ferrous nitrosyl complex via a proposed superoxide mediated pathway.

Water may inhibit oxygen binding in hemoprotein models

Three distal imidazole pickets in a cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) model form a pocket hosting a cluster of water molecules. The cluster makes the ferrous heme low spin, and consequently the O(2) binding slow. The nature of the rigid proximal imidazole tail favors a high spin/low spin cross-over. The O(2) binding rate is enhanced either by removing the water, increasing the hydrophobicity of the gas binding pocket, or inserting a metal ion that coordinates to the 3 distal imidazole pickets.

Functional biomimetic models for the active site in the respiratory enzyme cytochrome c oxidase

A functional analog of the active site in the respiratory enzyme, cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) reproduces every feature in CcO's active site: a myoglobin-like heme (heme a3), a distal tridentate imidazole copper complex (Cu(B)), a phenol (Tyr244), and a proximal imidazole. When covalently attached to a liquid-crystalline SAM film on an Au electrode, this functional model continuously catalyzes the selective four-electron reduction of dioxygen at physiological potential and pH, under rate-limiting electron flux (as occurs in CcO).

Model studies of azide binding to functional analogues of CcO

N3- binding to a functional model of CcO is investigated in its Fe3+, Fe3+Cu+, and Fe3+Cu2+ forms. A combination of EPR and FTIR indicates that N3- binds in a bridging mode in the bimetallic sites and signature N3- bands are identified for several forms of N3- binding to the site. The presence of the distal metal increases the binding affinity of N3-. This bridging enables antiferromagnetic interaction between the two metal centers in the Fe3+Cu2+ state, which results in an EPR-silent ground state.

Interaction of nitric oxide with a functional model of cytochrome c oxidase

Cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) is a multimetallic enzyme that carries out the reduction of O2 to H2O and is essential to respiration, providing the energy that powers all aerobic organisms by generating heat and forming ATP. The oxygen-binding heme a(3) should be subject to fatal inhibition by chemicals that could compete with O2 binding. Near the CcO active site is another enzyme, NO synthase, which produces the gaseous hormone NO. NO can strongly bind to heme a(3), thus inhibiting respiration. However, this disaster does not occur. Using functional models for the CcO active site, we show how NO inhibition is avoided; in fact, it is found that NO can protect the respiratory enzyme from other inhibitors such as cyanide, a classic poison.

Synthesis of nitric oxide reductase active site models bearing key components at both distal and proximal sites

Porphyrins 1ab and 2ab were successfully synthesized from cis-alpha2-bisimidazole-beta-imidazole-tail porphyrins and two newly synthesized imidazole pickets containing an aliphatic ester chain following a [2+1] approach. The four compounds possess a distal trisimidazole set, a distal carboxylic acid, and a proximal imidazole, which constitute all the key features of the coordination environment of the active site in Bacterial Nitric Oxide Reductase (NOR) and make them the closest synthetic NOR model ligands to date.

A cytochrome C oxidase model catalyzes oxygen to water reduction under rate-limiting electron flux

We studied the selectivity of a functional model of cytochrome c oxidase's active site that mimics the coordination environment and relative locations of Fe(a3), Cu(B), and Tyr(244). To control electron flux, we covalently attached this model and analogs lacking copper and phenol onto self-assembled monolayer-coated gold electrodes. When the electron transfer rate was made rate limiting, both copper and phenol were required to enhance selective reduction of oxygen to water. This finding supports the hypothesis that, during steady-state turnover, the primary role of these redox centers is to rapidly provide all the electrons needed to reduce oxygen by four electrons, thus preventing the release of toxic partially reduced oxygen species.

Syntheses of hemoprotein models that can be covalently attached onto electrode surfaces by click chemistry

Five alkyne-containing hemoprotein models have been synthesized in a convergent manner. Sonogashira coupling was used to introduce the alkyne functional group on the proximal imidazole before or after being attached on the porphyrin. One model was immobilized onto a gold electrode surface via copper(I)-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition (Sharpless click chemistry).

Efficient synthesis of trisimidazole and glutaric acid bearing porphyrins: ligands for active-site models of bacterial nitric oxide reductase

Ligands (1) for active-site models of bacterial nitric oxide reductase (NOR) have been efficiently synthesized. These compounds (1) feature three imidazolyl moieties and one carboxylic acid residue at the FeB site, which represent the closest available synthetic model ligands of NOR active center. The stereo conformations of these ligands are established on the basis of steric effects and 1H NMR chemical shifts under the ring current effect of the porphyrin.

Single-turnover intermolecular reaction between a Feiii–superoxide–Cuicytochrome c oxidase model and exogeneous Tyr244 mimics

An Fe(III)-superoxide-Cu(I) cytochrome c oxidase model reacts intermolecularly with hindered phenols leading to phenoxyl radicals, as was observed in the enzyme and evidence for the formation of an Fe(IV)-oxo is presented.

5,10,15-Tris(o-aminophenyl) Corrole (TAPC) as a Versatile Synthon for the Preparation of Corrole-Based Hemoprotein Analogs

[structure: see text] The atropisomers of 5,10,15-tris(o-aminophenyl) corrole (alphabetaalpha, alphaalphabeta, and alphaalphaalpha) are metastable at room temperature as a result of the low rotational barrier of the o-aminophenyl pickets adjacent to the bipyrrole moiety. Atropisomer enrichment of TAPC was required for the preparation of picket fence, triazacyclononane-capped, and trisimidazole-alphaalphaalpha-corroles. A racemic alpha(2)beta model of cis-A(2)B geometry was also obtained by linking two cis anilines with a short strap and inserting an imidazole tail on the opposite face of TAPC.

Appending a tris-imidazole ligand with a Tyr 244 mimic on the distal face of bromoacetamidoporphyrin

[structure: see text] Bromoacetamidoporphyrin is a convenient synthon for the attachment of distal superstructures at room temperature in good yields. New models are presented that contain a tris-imidazole distal ligand set bound to the porphyrin in either a binary or trinary fashion. More importantly, one distal imidazole is cross-linked to a phenol mimicking Tyr(244), making this model the closest structural analogue yet reported of the metal free cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) active site.

Synthesis of cytochrome c oxidase models bearing a Tyr244 mimic

A close structural analogue of the metal-free cytochrome c oxidase active site has been synthesized. This model has a proximal imidazole tail and three distal imidazole pickets attached to a porphyrin. One distal imidazole is cross-linked to a phenol, mimicking Tyr(244). The strategy behind the successful synthesis of this regioisomerically pure model involved discovering the best sequence to introduce the phenol-substituted imidazole and employing a fluorinated substituent.

Effect of electron availability on selectivity of O2 reduction by synthetic monometallic Fe porphyrins

Herein we report that biomimetic analogues of cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) couple reduction of O(2) to oxidation of a single-electron carrier, Ru(NH(3))(6)(2+), under steady-state catalytic turnover. Higher Ru(II) concentrations favor the 4-electron vs 2-electron O(2) reduction pathway. Our data indicate that the capacity of electrode-adsorbed Fe-only porphyrins to catalyze reduction of O(2) to H(2)O is due to high availability of electrons and is eliminated under the biologically relevant slow electron delivery.

Spectroscopic evidence for a heme-superoxide/Cu(I) intermediate in a functional model of cytochrome c oxidase

A superstructured tetraphenylporphyrin with a covalently attached proximal imidazole axial base and three distal imidazole pickets has been developed as a model for the active site of terminal oxidases such as cytochrome c oxidase. The oxygen adduct of the Fe-only heme (at low temperature) has a diamagnetic NMR and is EPR silent, which taken together with a resonance Raman oxygen isotope sensitive band (nuFe-O) at 575/554 cm-1 (16O2/18O2) indicates formation of a six-coordinate heme-superoxide complex. Unexpectedly, the Fe/Cu complex, where the copper is in a trisimidazole environment approximately 5 A above the heme plane, displays similar characteristics: a diamagnetic NMR, EPR silence, and nuFe-O at 570/544 cm-1. This indicates the dioxygen adduct of this Fe/Cu system is also a superoxide. This contrasts with previously characterized partially reduced dioxygen intermediates of binuclear heme/copper complexes that form Fe/Cu mu-peroxo complexes.

Water-soluble polymer-bound biomimetic analogues of cytochrome C oxidase catalyze 4e- reduction of O2 to water

Activity toward catalytic O(2) reduction by polyacrylic acid (PAA) and polyvinylpyridine (PVP) polymers containing functional analogues of the O(2)-reducing site of cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) has been studied in solution and on the electrode surface. Pronounced effects of the porphyrin microenvironment on the selectivity and turnover frequency of the catalysts were observed.

Functional analogues of the dioxygen reduction site in cytochrome oxidase: mechanistic aspects and possible effects of Cu(B)

Catalytic reduction of O(2) and H(2)O(2) by new synthetic analogues of the heme/Cu site in cytochrome c and ubiquinol oxidases has been studied in aqueous buffers. Among the synthetic porphyrins yet reported, those employed in this study most faithfully mimic the immediate coordination environment of the Fe/Cu core. Under physiologically relevant conditions, these biomimetic catalysts reproduce key aspects of the O(2) and H(2)O(2) chemistry of the enzyme. When deposited on an electrode surface, they catalyze the selective reduction of O(2) to H(2)O at potentials comparable to the midpoint potential of cytochrome c. The pH dependence of the half-wave potentials and other data are consistent with O-O bond activation at these centers proceeding via a slow generation of a formally ferric-hydroperoxo intermediate, followed by its rapid reduction to the level of water. This kinetics is analogous to that proposed for the O-O reduction step at the heme/Cu site. It minimizes the steady-state concentration of the catalytic intermediate whose decomposition would release free H(2)O(2). The maximum catalytic rate constants of O(2) reduction by the ferrous catalyst and of H(2)O(2) reduction by both ferric and ferrous catalysts are comparable to those reported for cytochrome oxidase. The oxidized catalyst also displays catalase activity. Comparison of the catalytic properties of the biomimetic complexes in the FeCu and Cu-free forms indicates that, in the regime of rapid electron flux, Cu does not significantly affect the turnover frequency or the stability of the catalysts, but it suppresses superoxide-releasing autoxidation of an O(2)-catalyst adduct. The distal Cu also accelerates O(2) binding and minimizes O-O bond homolysis in the reduction of H(2)O(2).

Electrochemical metalloporphyrin-catalyzed reduction of chlorite

We measured the redox stoichiometry and rate constants for the electrochemical reduction of ClO(2)(-) at pH 7, catalyzed by a series of metalloporphyrins of Mn, Fe, and Co with different proximal and distal environments. A clean four-electron reduction was observed. The catalytic activity correlates well with that observed in reduction of H(2)O(2). The axial imidazole and/or a redox-active distal metal (Cu or Co) increases the turnover frequency in several compounds. The metalloporphyrins were inert to ClO(x)(-) (x = 3,4) and IO(3)(-) but catalyzed facile two-electron reduction of IO(4)(-); six-electron reduction of BrO(3)(-) was also observed.