High-Resolution in Vivo Footprinting of a Protein−DNA Complex Using γ-Radiation

The molecular structure of long non-coding RNAs: emerging patterns and functional implications

Long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs) are recently-discovered transcripts that regulate vital cellular processes and are crucially connected to diseases. Despite their unprecedented molecular complexity, it is emerging that lncRNAs possess distinct structural motifs. Remarkably, the 3D shape and topology of full-length, native lncRNAs have been visualized for the first time in the last year. These studies reveal that lncRNA structures dictate lncRNA functions. Here, we review experimentally determined lncRNA structures and emphasize that lncRNA structural characterization requires synergistic integration of computational, biochemical and biophysical approaches. Based on these emerging paradigms, we discuss how to overcome the challenges posed by the complex molecular architecture of lncRNAs, with the goal of obtaining a detailed understanding of lncRNA functions and molecular mechanisms in the future.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Protein Footprinting for Higher-Order Structure Analysis: Fundamentals and Applications

Proteins adopt different higher-order structures (HOS) to enable their unique biological functions. Understanding the complexities of protein higher-order structures and dynamics requires integrated approaches, where mass spectrometry (MS) is now positioned to play a key role. One of those approaches is protein footprinting. Although the initial demonstration of footprinting was for the HOS determination of protein/nucleic acid binding, the concept was later adapted to MS-based protein HOS analysis, through which different covalent labeling approaches "mark" the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) of proteins to reflect protein HOS. Hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX), where deuterium in D2O replaces hydrogen of the backbone amides, is the most common example of footprinting. Its advantage is that the footprint reflects SASA and hydrogen bonding, whereas one drawback is the labeling is reversible. Another example of footprinting is slow irreversible labeling of functional groups on amino acid side chains by targeted reagents with high specificity, probing structural changes at selected sites. A third footprinting approach is by reactions with fast, irreversible labeling species that are highly reactive and footprint broadly several amino acid residue side chains on the time scale of submilliseconds. All of these covalent labeling approaches combine to constitute a problem-solving toolbox that enables mass spectrometry as a valuable tool for HOS elucidation. As there has been a growing need for MS-based protein footprinting in both academia and industry owing to its high throughput capability, prompt availability, and high spatial resolution, we present a summary of the history, descriptions, principles, mechanisms, and applications of these covalent labeling approaches. Moreover, their applications are highlighted according to the biological questions they can answer. This review is intended as a tutorial for MS-based protein HOS elucidation and as a reference for investigators seeking a MS-based tool to address structural questions in protein science.

Development of Container Free Sample Exposure for Synchrotron X-ray Footprinting

The method of X-ray footprinting and mass spectrometry (XFMS) on large protein assemblies and membrane protein samples requires high flux density to overcome the hydroxyl radical scavenging reactions produced by the buffer constituents and the total protein content. Previously, we successfully developed microsecond XFMS using microfluidic capillary flow and a microfocused broadband X-ray source at the Advanced Light Source synchrotron beamlines, but the excessive radiation damage incurred when using capillaries prevented the full usage of a high-flux density beam. Here we present another significant advance for the XFMS method: the instrumentation of a liquid injection jet to deliver container free samples to the X-ray beam. Our preliminary experiments with a liquid jet at a bending magnet X-ray beamline demonstrate the feasibility of the approach and show a significant improvement in the effective dose for both the Alexa fluorescence assay and protein samples compared to conventional capillary flow methods. The combination of precisely controlled high dose delivery, shorter exposure times, and elimination of radiation damage due to capillary effects significantly increases the signal quality of the hydroxyl radical modification products and the dose-response data. This new approach is the first application of container free sample handling for XFMS and opens up the method for even further advances, such as high-quality microsecond time-resolved XFMS studies.

Analyzing the structure of macromolecules in their native cellular environment using hydroxyl radical footprinting

Hydroxyl radical footprinting (HRF) has been successfully used to study the structure of both nucleic acids and proteins in live cells.

Protein Footprinting Comes of Age: Mass Spectrometry for Biophysical Structure Assessment

Protein footprinting mediated by mass spectrometry has evolved over the last 30 years from proof of concept to commonplace biophysics tool, with unique capabilities for assessing structure and dynamics of purified proteins in physiological states in solution. This review outlines the history and current capabilities of two major methods of protein footprinting: reversible hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) and hydroxyl radical footprinting (HRF), an irreversible covalent labeling approach. Technological advances in both approaches now permit high-resolution assessments of protein structure including secondary and tertiary structure stability mediated by backbone interactions (measured via HDX) and solvent accessibility of side chains (measured via HRF). Applications across many academic fields and in biotechnology drug development are illustrated including: detection of protein interfaces, identification of ligand/drug binding sites, and monitoring dynamics of protein conformational changes along with future prospects for advancement of protein footprinting in structural biology and biophysics research.

Mechanistic Studies on RNA Strand Scission from a C2'-Radical

The C2'-carbon-hydrogen bond in ribonucleotides is significantly weaker than other carbohydrate carbon-hydrogen bonds in RNA or DNA. Independent generation of the C2'-uridine radical (1) in RNA oligonucleotides via Norrish type I photocleavage of a ketone-substituted nucleotide yields direct strand breaks via cleavage of the β-phosphate. The reactivity of 1 in different sequences and under a variety of conditions suggests that the rate constant for strand scission is significantly greater than 10⁶ s^-1 at pH 7.2. The initially formed C2'-radical (1) is not trapped under a variety of conditions, consistent with computational studies ( Chem.-Eur. J. 2009 , 15 , 2394 ) that suggest that the barrier to strand scission is very low and that synchronous proton transfer from the 2'-hydroxyl to the departing phosphate group facilitates cleavage. The C2'-radical could be a significant contributor to RNA strand scission by the hydroxyl radical, particularly under anaerobic conditions where 1 can be produced from nucleobase radicals.

Oxidative footprinting in the study of structure and function of membrane proteins: current state and perspectives

Membrane proteins, such as receptors, transporters and ion channels, control the vast majority of cellular signalling and metabolite exchange processes and thus are becoming key pharmacological targets. Obtaining structural information by usage of traditional structural biology techniques is limited by the requirements for the protein samples to be highly pure and stable when handled in high concentrations and in non-native buffer systems, which is often difficult to achieve for membrane targets. Hence, there is a growing requirement for the use of hybrid, integrative approaches to study the dynamic and functional aspects of membrane proteins in physiologically relevant conditions. In recent years, significant progress has been made in the field of oxidative labelling techniques and in particular the X-ray radiolytic footprinting in combination with mass spectrometry (MS) (XF-MS), which provide residue-specific information on the solvent accessibility of proteins. In combination with both low- and high-resolution data from other structural biology approaches, it is capable of providing valuable insights into dynamics of membrane proteins, which have been difficult to obtain by other structural techniques, proving a highly complementary technique to address structure and function of membrane targets. XF-MS has demonstrated a unique capability for identification of structural waters and conformational changes in proteins at both a high degree of spatial and a high degree of temporal resolution. Here, we provide a perspective on the place of XF-MS among other structural biology methods and showcase some of the latest developments in its usage for studying water-mediated transmembrane (TM) signalling, ion transport and ligand-induced allosteric conformational changes in membrane proteins.

Probing the structure of ribosome assembly intermediates in vivo using DMS and hydroxyl radical footprinting

The assembly of the Escherichia coli ribosome has been widely studied and characterized in vitro. Despite this, ribosome biogenesis in living cells is only partly understood because assembly is coupled with transcription, modification and processing of the pre-ribosomal RNA. We present a method for footprinting and isolating pre-rRNA as it is synthesized in E. coli cells. Pre-rRNA synthesis is synchronized by starvation, followed by nutrient upshift. RNA synthesized during outgrowth is metabolically labeled to facilitate isolation of recent transcripts. Combining this technique with two in vivo RNA probing methods, hydroxyl radical and DMS footprinting, allows the structure of nascent RNA to be probed over time. Together, these can be used to determine changes in the structures of ribosome assembly intermediates as they fold in vivo.

Rapid deamination of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer photoproducts at TCG sites in a translationally and rotationally positioned nucleosome in vivo

Sunlight-induced C to T mutation hot spots in skin cancers occur primarily at methylated CpG sites that coincide with sites of UV-induced cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) formation. The C and 5-methyl-C in CPDs are not stable and deaminate to U and T, respectively, which leads to the insertion of A by the DNA damage bypass polymerase η, thereby defining a probable mechanism for the origin of UV-induced C to T mutations. Deamination rates for T(m)CG CPDs have been found to vary 12-fold with rotational position in a nucleosome in vitro. To determine the influence of nucleosome structure on deamination rates in vivo, we determined the deamination rates of CPDs at TCG sites in a stably positioned nucleosome within the FOS promoter in HeLa cells. A procedure for in vivo hydroxyl radical footprinting with Fe-EDTA was developed, and, together with results from a cytosine methylation protection assay, we determined the translational and rotational positions of the TCG sites. Consistent with the in vitro observations, deamination was slower for one CPD located at an intermediate rotational position compared with two other sites located at outside positions, and all were much faster than for CPDs at non-TCG sites. Photoproduct formation was also highly suppressed at one site, possibly due to its interaction with a histone tail. Thus, it was shown that CPDs of TCG sites deaminate the fastest in vivo and that nucleosomes can modulate both their formation and deamination, which could contribute to the UV mutation hot spots and cold spots.

Rapid RNA strand scission following C2'-hydrogen atom abstraction

C2'-Nucleotide radicals have been proposed as key intermediates in direct strand break formation in RNA exposed to ionizing radiation. Uridin-2'-yl radical (1) was independently generated in single- and double-stranded RNA via photolysis of a ketone precursor. Direct stand breaks result from heterolytic cleavage of the adjacent C3'-carbon-oxygen bond. Trapping of 1 by O2 or β-mercaptoethanol (1 M) does not compete with strand scission, indicating that phosphate elimination is >10(6) s(-1). Uracil loss also does not compete with strand scission. When considered in conjunction with reports that nucleobase radicals produce 1, this chemistry explains why RNA is significantly more susceptible to strand scission by ionizing radiation (hydroxyl radical) than is DNA.

Oxidative protein labeling with analysis by mass spectrometry for the study of structure, folding, and dynamics

SIGNIFICANCE

Analytical approaches that can provide insights into the mechanistic processes underlying protein folding and dynamics are few since the target analytes-high-energy structural intermediates-are short lived and often difficult to distinguish from coexisting structures. Folding "intermediates" can be populated at equilibrium using weakly denaturing solvents, but it is not clear that these species are identical to those that are transiently populated during folding under "native" conditions. Oxidative labeling with mass spectrometric analysis is a powerful alternative for structural characterization of proteins and transient protein species based on solvent exposure at specific sites.

RECENT ADVANCES

Oxidative labeling is increasingly used with exceedingly short (μs) labeling pulses, both to minimize the occurrence of artifactual structural changes due to the incorporation of label and to detect short-lived species. The recent introduction of facile photolytic approaches for producing reactive oxygen species is an important technological advance that will enable more widespread adoption of the technique.

CRITICAL ISSUES

The most common critique of oxidative labeling data is that even with brief labeling pulses, covalent modification of the protein may cause significant artifactual structural changes.

FUTURE DIRECTIONS

While the oxidative labeling with the analysis by mass spectrometry is mature enough that most basic methodological issues have been addressed, a complete systematic understanding of side chain reactivity in the context of intact proteins is an avenue for future work. Specifically, there remain issues around the impact of primary sequence and side chain interactions on the reactivity of "solvent-exposed" residues. Due to its analytical power, wide range of applications, and relative ease of implementation, oxidative labeling is an increasingly important technique in the bioanalytical toolbox.

In vivo X-ray footprinting of pre-30S ribosomes reveals chaperone-dependent remodeling of late assembly intermediates

Assembly of 30S ribosomal subunits from their protein and RNA components requires extensive refolding of the 16S rRNA and is assisted by 10-20 assembly factors in bacteria. We probed the structures of 30S assembly intermediates in E. coli cells, using a synchrotron X-ray beam to generate hydroxyl radical in the cytoplasm. Widespread differences between mature and pre-30S complexes in the absence of assembly factors RbfA and RimM revealed global reorganization of RNA-protein interactions prior to maturation of the 16S rRNA and showed how RimM reduces misfolding of the 16S 3' domain during transcription in vivo. Quantitative (14)N/(15)N mass spectrometry of affinity-purified pre-30S complexes confirmed the absence of tertiary assembly proteins and showed that N-terminal acetylation of proteins S18 and S5 correlates with correct folding of the platform and central pseudoknot. Our results indicate that cellular factors delay specific RNA folding steps to ensure the quality of assembly.

DNA of a circular minichromosome linearized by restriction enzymes or other reagents is resistant to further cleavage: an influence of chromatin topology on the accessibility of DNA

The accessibility of DNA in chromatin is an essential factor in regulating its activities. We studied the accessibility of the DNA in a ∼170 kb circular minichromosome to DNA-cleaving reagents using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and fibre-fluorescence in situ hybridization on combed DNA molecules. Only one of several potential sites in the minichromosome DNA was accessible to restriction enzymes in permeabilized cells, and in growing cells only a single site at an essentially random position was cut by poisoned topoisomerase II, neocarzinostatin and γ-radiation, which have multiple potential cleavage sites; further sites were then inaccessible in the linearized minichromosomes. Sequential exposure to combinations of these reagents also resulted in cleavage at only a single site. Minichromosome DNA containing single-strand breaks created by a nicking endonuclease to relax any unconstrained superhelicity was also cut at only a single position by a restriction enzyme. Further sites became accessible after ≥95% of histones H2A, H2B and H1, and most non-histone proteins were extracted. These observations suggest that a global rearrangement of the three-dimensional packing and interactions of nucleosomes occurs when a circular minichromosome is linearized and results in its DNA becoming inaccessible to probes.

Modeling of the DNA-binding site of yeast Pms1 by mass spectrometry

Mismatch repair (MMR) corrects replication errors that would otherwise lead to mutations and, potentially, various forms of cancer. Among several proteins required for eukaryotic MMR, MutLα is a heterodimer comprised of Mlh1 and Pms1. The two proteins dimerize along their C-terminal domains (CTDs), and the CTD of Pms1 houses a latent endonuclease that is required for MMR. The highly conserved N-terminal domains (NTDs) independently bind DNA and possess ATPase active sites. Here we use two protein footprinting techniques, limited proteolysis and oxidative surface mapping, coupled with mass spectrometry to identify amino acids involved along the DNA-binding surface of the Pms1-NTD. Limited proteolysis experiments elucidated several basic residues that were protected in the presence of DNA, while oxidative surface mapping revealed one residue that is uniquely protected from oxidation. Furthermore, additional amino acids distributed throughout the Pms1-NTD were protected from oxidation either in the presence of a non-hydrolyzable analog of ATP or DNA, indicating that each ligand stabilizes the protein in a similar conformation. Based on the recently published X-ray crystal structure of yeast Pms1-NTD, a model of the Pms1-NTD/DNA complex was generated using the mass spectrometric data as constraints. The proposed model defines the DNA-binding interface along a positively charged groove of the Pms1-NTD and complements prior mutagenesis studies of Escherichia coli and eukaryotic MutL.

A new trick (hydroxyl radical generation) for an old vitamin (B12)

Photolysis of hydroxocobalamin in the presence of plasmid DNA (pBR322) results in DNA cleavage. Temporal control of hydroxyl radical production and DNA strand scission by hydroxocobalamin was demonstrated using a 2-deoxyribose assay and a plasmid relaxation assay, respectively. The light-driven hydroxocobalamin-mediated catalytic formation of hydroxyl radicals was demonstrated using radical scavenging studies of DNA cleavage and via recycling of a hydroxocobalamin-resin conjugate several times without loss of efficacy.

Mass spectrometry combined with oxidative labeling for exploring protein structure and folding

This review discusses various mass spectrometry (MS)-based approaches for exploring structural aspects of proteins in solution. Electrospray ionization (ESI)-MS, in particular, has found fascinating applications in this area. For example, when used in conjunction with solution-phase hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX), ESI-MS is a highly sensitive tool for probing conformational dynamics. The main focus of this article is a technique that is complementary to HDX, that is, the covalent labeling of proteins by hydroxyl radicals. The reactivity of individual amino acid side chains with *OH is strongly affected by their degree of solvent exposure. Thus, analysis of the oxidative labeling pattern by peptide mapping and tandem mass spectrometry provides detailed structural information. A convenient method for *OH production is the photolysis of H(2)O(2) by a pulsed UV laser, resulting in oxidative labeling on the microsecond time scale. Selected examples demonstrate the use of this technique for structural studies on membrane proteins, and the combination with rapid mixing devices for characterizing the properties of short-lived protein (un)folding intermediates.

Structural analysis of RNA in living cells by in vivo synchrotron X-ray footprinting

Chemical footprinting methods are widely used to probe the solution structures of nucleic acids and their complexes. Among the many available modifying reagents, hydroxyl radical is exceptional in its ability to provide nucleotide-level information on the solvent accessibility of the nucleic acid backbone. Until recently, hydroxyl radical footprinting has been limited to in vitro experiments. We describe the use of synchrotron X-radiation to generate hydroxyl radicals within cells for effective footprinting of RNA-protein complexes in vivo. This technique gives results that are consistent with in vitro footprinting experiments, with differences reflecting apparent structural changes to the RNA in vivo.

In vivo cloning of artificial DNA nanostructures

Mimicking nature is both a key goal and a difficult challenge for the scientific enterprise. DNA, well known as the genetic-information carrier in nature, can be replicated efficiently in living cells. Today, despite the dramatic evolution of DNA nanotechnology, a versatile method that replicates artificial DNA nanostructures with complex secondary structures remains an appealing target. Previous success in replicating DNA nanostructures enzymatically in vitro suggests that a possible solution could be cloning these nanostructures by using viruses. Here, we report a system where a single-stranded DNA nanostructure (Holliday junction or paranemic cross-over DNA) is inserted into a phagemid, transformed into XL1-Blue cells and amplified in vivo in the presence of helper phages. High copy numbers of cloned nanostructures can be obtained readily by using standard molecular biology techniques. Correct replication is verified by a number of assays including nondenaturing PAGE, Ferguson analysis, endonuclease VII digestion, and hydroxyl radical autofootprinting. The simplicity, efficiency, and fidelity of nature are fully reflected in this system. UV-induced psoralen cross-linking is used to probe the secondary structure of the inserted junction in infected cells. Our data suggest the possible formation of the immobile four-arm junction in vivo.

Time-resolved footprinting for the study of the structural dynamics of DNA–protein interactions

Transcription is often regulated at the level of initiation by the presence of transcription factors or nucleoid proteins or by changing concentrations of metabolites. These can influence the kinetic properties and/or structures of the intermediate RNA polymerase–DNA complexes in the pathway. Time-resolved footprinting techniques combine the high temporal resolution of a stopped-flow apparatus with the specific structural information obtained by the probing agent. Combined with a careful quantitative analysis of the evolution of the signals, this approach allows for the identification and kinetic and structural characterization of the intermediates in the pathway of DNA sequence recognition by a protein, such as a transcription factor or RNA polymerase. The combination of different probing agents is especially powerful in revealing different aspects of the conformational changes taking place at the protein–DNA interface. For example, hydroxyl radical footprinting, owing to their small size, provides a map of the solvent-accessible surface of the DNA backbone at a single nucleotide resolution; modification of the bases using potassium permanganate can reveal the accessibility of the bases when the double helix is distorted or melted; cross-linking experiments report on the formation of specific amino acid–DNA contacts, and DNase I footprinting results in a strong signal-to-noise ratio from DNA protection at the binding site and hypersensitivity at curved or kinked DNA sites. Recent developments in protein footprinting allow for the direct characterization of conformational changes of the proteins in the complex.

Following molecular transitions with single residue spatial and millisecond time resolution

"Footprinting" describes assays in which ligand binding or structure formation protects polymers such as nucleic acids and proteins from either cleavage or modification; footprinting allows the accessibility of individual residues to be mapped in solution. Equilibrium and time-dependent footprinting links site-specific structural information with thermodynamic and kinetic transitions, respectively. The hydroxyl radical (*OH) is a uniquely insightful footprinting probe by virtue of it being among the most reactive chemical oxidants; it reports the solvent accessibility of reactive sites on macromolecules with as fine as a single residue resolution. A novel method of millisecond time-resolved *OH footprinting is presented based on the Fenton reaction, Fe(II) + H(2)O(2) --> Fe(III) + *OH + OH(-). It is implemented using a standard three-syringe quench-flow mixer. The utility of this method is demonstrated by its application to the studies on RNA folding. Its applicability to a broad range of biological questions involving the function of DNA, RNA, and proteins is discussed.

Effects of Protein Concentration on the Extent of γ-Ray-Mediated Oxidative Labeling Studied by Electrospray Mass Spectrometry

Exposure of aqueous protein solutions to gamma-rays results in the formation of *OH radicals that readily react with solvent-exposed amino acid side chains. The incorporation of oxygen leads to peak progressions with a spacing of 16 Da in the mass distribution of the polypeptide chain. Unlike some other oxidative labeling strategies, these radiolysis experiments do not require solution additives that could interfere with the analysis or that might cause secondary oxidation processes. Using myoglobin as a model system, we demonstrate that the level of oxidative labeling depends critically on the protein concentration. If ignored, this effect may lead to ambiguities in the interpretation of experiments employing *OH labeling for monitoring solvent-accessible surface areas, protein folding, and protein-protein interactions. We present a simple analysis that allows oxidation to be interpreted as a process with exponential kinetics, characterized by an apparent rate constant of the form kapp=kRAD/([P]tot+B), where kRAD is the primary rate of hydroxyl radical production, B is a constant, and [P]tot is the total protein concentration. While oxidative labeling may trigger some changes in protein conformation, it is found that the magnitude of this effect is surprisingly small, a result that is consistent with observations previously made by others.

RADIOLYTIC PROTEIN FOOTPRINTING WITH MASS SPECTROMETRY TO PROBE THE STRUCTURE OF MACROMOLECULAR COMPLEXES

Structural proteomics approaches using mass spectrometry are increasingly used in biology to examine the composition and structure of macromolecules. Hydroxyl radical-mediated protein footprinting using mass spectrometry has recently been developed to define structure, assembly, and conformational changes of macromolecules in solution based on measurements of reactivity of amino acid side chain groups with covalent modification reagents. Accurate measurements of side chain reactivity are achieved using quantitative liquid-chromatography-coupled mass spectrometry, whereas the side chain modification sites are identified using tandem mass spectrometry. In addition, the use of footprinting data in conjunction with computational modeling approaches is a powerful new method for testing and refining structural models of macromolecules and their complexes. In this review, we discuss the basic chemistry of hydroxyl radical reactions with peptides and proteins, highlight various approaches to map protein structure using radical oxidation methods, and describe state-of-the-art approaches to combine computational and footprinting data.

Selective targeting of DNA for cleavage within DNA–histone assemblies by a spermine–[CpW(CO)3Ph]2 conjugate

In contrast to the histone-modifying action of other complexes of the type CpML(n)R, the compound obtained by linking the phenyl rings of two CpW(CO)(3)Ph moieties to the DNA-binding agent spermine selectively cleaves DNA in DNA-histone assemblies.

Identification by integrated computer modeling and light scattering studies of an electrostatic serum albumin-hyaluronic acid binding site

Dynamic light scattering and turbidimetry, carried out on solutions of hyaluronic acid (HA) and bovine or human serum albumin (SA) at fixed ionic strength (I), revealed a critical pH corresponding to the onset of HA-SA soluble complex formation. Subsequent reduction of pH below pH(c), corresponding to an increase in protein net positive charge, results in phase separation of the complex. The sensitivity of pH(c) to I indicated the primacy of electrostatic interactions in this process. Since pH(c) was always above the pK(a) of HA, these effects could be attributed to the influence of protein charge. The electrostatic potential around HSA was modeled using DelPhi (MSI) under pH, I conditions corresponding to incipient binding, phase separation, and noninteraction. At all incipient binding conditions (i.e., pH(c), at varying I), an identical region of positive potential 5 A from the protein van der Waals surface appeared. This unique domain intensified with a decrease in pH or I (corresponding to stronger binding), and diminished with an increase in pH or I (i.e., at noninteracting conditions). The size and low curvature of this domain could readily accommodate a 12 nm (decamer) sequence of HA. Simple electrostatic considerations indicate an electrostatic binding energy for the formation of this complex of ca. 1 kT, consistent with the condition of incipient complex formation. We suggest that such weak electrostatic binding may characterize nonspecific interactions for other protein-gylcosaminoglycan pairs.