A reappraisal, based on (31)P NMR, of the direct coordination of a metal ion with the phosphoryl oxygen at the cleavage site of a hammerhead ribozyme

Complex formation of cadmium with sugar residues, nucleobases, phosphates, nucleotides, and nucleic acids

Cadmium(II), commonly classified as a relatively soft metal ion, prefers indeed aromatic-nitrogen sites (e.g., N7 of purines) over oxygen sites (like sugar-hydroxyl groups). However, matters are not that simple, though it is true that the affinity of Cd(2+) towards ribose-hydroxyl groups is very small; yet, a correct orientation brought about by a suitable primary binding site and a reduced solvent polarity, as it is expected to occur in a folded nucleic acid, may facilitate metal ion-hydroxyl group binding very effectively. Cd(2+) prefers the guanine(N7) over the adenine(N7), mainly because of the steric hindrance of the (C6)NH(2) group in the adenine residue. This Cd(2+)-(N7) interaction in a guanine moiety leads to a significant acidification of the (N1)H meaning that the deprotonation reaction occurs now in the physiological pH range. N3 of the cytosine residue, together with the neighboring (C2)O, is also a remarkable Cd(2+) binding site, though replacement of (C2)O by (C2)S enhances the affinity towards Cd(2+) dramatically, giving in addition rise to the deprotonation of the (C4)NH(2) group. The phosphodiester bridge is only a weak binding site but the affinity increases further from the mono- to the di- and the triphosphate. The same also holds for the corresponding nucleotides. Complex stability of the pyrimidine-nucleotides is solely determined by the coordination tendency of the phosphate group(s), whereas in the case of purine-nucleotides macrochelate formation takes place by the interaction of the phosphate-coordinated Cd(2+) with N7. The extents of the formation degrees of these chelates are summarized and the effect of a non-bridging sulfur atom in a thiophosphate group (versus a normal phosphate group) is considered. Mixed ligand complexes containing a nucleotide and a further mono- or bidentate ligand are covered and it is concluded that in these species N7 is released from the coordination sphere of Cd(2+). In the case that the other ligand contains an aromatic residue (e.g., 2,2'-bipyridine or the indole ring of tryptophanate) intramolecular stack formation takes place. With buffers like Tris or Bistris mixed ligand complexes are formed. Cd(2+) coordination to dinucleotides and to dinucleoside monophosphates provides some insights regarding the interaction between Cd(2+) and nucleic acids. Cd(2+) binding to oligonucleotides follows the principles of coordination to its units. The available crystal studies reveal that N7 of purines is the prominent binding site followed by phosphate oxygens and other heteroatoms in nucleic acids. Due to its high thiophilicity, Cd(2+) is regularly used in so-called thiorescue experiments, which lead to the identification of a direct involvement of divalent metal ions in ribozyme catalysis.

Ground-state coordination of a catalytic metal to the scissile phosphate of a tertiary-stabilized Hammerhead ribozyme

Although the Hammerhead ribozyme (HHRz) has long been used as a model system in the field of ribozyme enzymology, several details of its mechanism are still not well understood. In particular, significant questions remain concerning the disposition and role of catalytic metals in the HHRz. Previous metal-rescue experiments using a "minimal" HHRz resulted in prediction of a catalytic metal that is bound in the A9/G10.1 site in the ground state of the reaction and that bridges to the scissile phosphate further along the reaction pathway. "Native" or extended HHRz constructs contain tertiary contacts that stabilize a more compact structure at moderate ionic strength. We performed Cd(2+) rescue experiments on an extended HHRz from Schistosoma mansoni using stereo-pure scissile phosphorothioate-substituted substrates in order to determine whether a metal ion makes contact with the scissile phosphate in the ground state or further along the reaction coordinate. Inhibition in Ca(2+)/Mg(2+) and rescue by thiophilic Cd(2+) was specific for the R(p)-S stereoisomer of the scissile phosphate. The affinity of the rescuing Cd(2+), measured in two different ionic strength backgrounds, increased fourfold to 17-fold when the pro-R(p) oxygen is replaced by sulfur. These data support a model in which the rescuing metal ion makes a ground-state interaction with the scissile phosphate in the native HHRz. The resulting model for Mg(2+) activation in the HHRz places a metal ion in contact with the scissile phosphate, where it may provide ground-state electrostatic activation of the substrate.

The identity of the nucleophile substitution may influence metal interactions with the cleavage site of the minimal hammerhead ribozyme

Potential metal interactions with the cleavage site of a minimal hammerhead ribozyme (mHHRz) were probed using (31)P NMR-detected Cd(2+) titration studies of HHRz constructs containing a phosphorothioate (PS) modification at the cleavage site. The mHHRz nucleophile position was replaced by either a 2'-F or a 2'-NH(2) in order to block cleavage activity during the study. The 2'-F/PS cleavage site mHHRz construct, in which the 2'-F should closely imitate the atom size and electronegativity of a 2'-OH, demonstrates low levels of metal ion association (<1 ppm (31)P chemical shift changes). This observation indicates that having an atom size and electrostatic properties that are similar to the 2'-OH are not the governing factors in allowing metal interactions with the scissile phosphate of the mHHRz. With a 2'-NH(2) substitution, a large upfield change in (31)P NMR chemical shift of the phosphorothioate peak (Delta approximately 3 ppm with 6 equiv of added Cd(2+)) indicates observable Cd(2+) interactions with the substituted site. Since a 2'-NH(2), but not a 2'-F, can serve as a metal ligand, these data suggest that a metal ion interaction with the HHRz cleavage site may include both the scissile phosphate and the 2' nucleophile. Control samples in which the 2'-NH(2)/PS unit is placed either next to the mHHRz cleavage site (at U16.1), in a duplex, or in a (am)U(PS)U dinucleotide show much weaker interactions with Cd(2+). Results with these control samples indicate that simply the presence of a 2'-NH(2)/PS unit does not create a strong metal binding site, reinforcing the possibility that the 2'-NH(2)-moderated Cd-PS interaction is specific to the mHHRz cleavage site. Upfield chemical shifts of both (31)P and H-2' (1)H resonances in (am)U(PS)U are observed with addition of Cd(2+), consistent with the predicted metal coordination to both 2'-NH(2) and phosphorothioate ligands. These data suggest that metal ion association with the HHRz cleavage site may include an interaction with the 2'-OH nucleophile.

Probing general acid catalysis in the hammerhead ribozyme

Recent crystallographic and computational studies have provided fresh insights into the catalytic mechanism of the RNA-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme. Based on these findings, specific ribozyme functional groups have been hypothesized to act directly as the general acid and base catalysts, although the catalytic role of divalent metal cations (M(2+)) remains uncertain. We now report a functional characterization of the general acid catalysis mechanism and the role of an M(2+) cofactor therein, for the S. mansoni hammerhead (an "extended" hammerhead ribozyme). We have compared hammerhead cleavage of substrates with natural (ribo-phosphodiester) versus bridging-5'-phosphorothioate scissile linkages, in the contexts of active site mutations and M(2+) substitution. Cleavage of the natural substrate is inhibited by modification of the G8 2'-OH ribozyme residue and depends strongly upon the presence and identity of an M(2+) cofactor; in contrast, cleavage of the bridging-phosphorothioate substrate is conspicuously insensitive to any of these factors. These results imply that (1) both an M(2+) cofactor and the G8 2'-OH play crucial roles in hammerhead general acid catalysis and (2) the M(2+) cofactor does not contribute to general acid catalysis via Lewis acid stabilization of the leaving group. General acid pK(a) perturbation was also demonstrated for both M(2+) substitution and G8 2'-OH modification, which suggests transition state M(2+) coordination of the G8 2'-OH, to lower its pK(a) and improve its ability to transfer a proton to the leaving group. We also report a simple method for synthesizing radiolabeled bridging-5'-phosphorothioate substrates.

Coupling of fast and slow modes in the reaction pathway of the minimal hammerhead ribozyme cleavage

By employing classical molecular dynamics, correlation analysis of coupling between slow and fast dynamical modes, and free energy (umbrella) sampling using classical as well as mixed quantum mechanics molecular mechanics force fields, we uncover a possible pathway for phosphoryl transfer in the self-cleaving reaction of the minimal hammerhead ribozyme. The significance of this pathway is that it initiates from the minimal hammerhead crystal structure and describes the reaction landscape as a conformational rearrangement followed by a covalent transformation. The delineated mechanism is catalyzed by two metal (Mg(2+)) ions, proceeds via an in-line-attack by CYT 17 O2' on the scissile phosphorous (ADE 1.1 P), and is therefore consistent with the experimentally observed inversion configuration. According to the delineated mechanism, the coupling between slow modes involving the hammerhead backbone with fast modes in the cleavage site appears to be crucial for setting up the in-line nucleophilic attack.

Mapping of the functional phosphate groups in the catalytic core of deoxyribozyme 10-23

The RNA phosphodiester bond cleavage activity of a series of 16 thio-deoxyribozymes 10-23, containing a P-stereorandom single phosphorothioate linkage in predetermined positions of the catalytic core from P1 to P16, was evaluated under single-turnover conditions in the presence of either 3 mM Mg(2+) or 3 mM Mn(2+). A metal-specificity switch approach permitted the identification of nonbridging phosphate oxygens (proR(P) or proS(P)) located at seven positions of the core (P2, P4 and P9-13) involved in direct coordination with a divalent metal ion(s). By contrast, phosphorothioates at positions P3, P6, P7 and P14-16 displayed no functional relevance in the deoxyribozyme-mediated catalysis. Interestingly, phosphorothioate modifications at positions P1 or P8 enhanced the catalytic efficiency of the enzyme. Among the tested deoxyribozymes, thio-substitution at position P5 had the largest deleterious effect on the catalytic rate in the presence of Mg(2+), and this was reversed in the presence of Mn(2+). Further experiments with thio-deoxyribozymes of stereodefined P-chirality suggested direct involvement of both oxygens of the P5 phosphate and the proR(P) oxygen at P9 in the metal ion coordination. In addition, it was found that the oxygen atom at C6 of G(6) contributes to metal ion binding and that this interaction is essential for 10-23 deoxyribozyme catalytic activity.

NMR spectroscopic study of a DNA duplex with mercury-mediated T-T base pairs

Recently, we reported that T-T mismatches can specifically recognize Hg(II) (T-Hg(II)-T pair formation). In order to understand the properties of the T-Hg(II)-T pair, we recorded NMR spectra for a DNA duplex, d(CGCGTTGTCC).d(GGACTTCGCG), with two successive T-T mismatches (Hg (II)-binding sites). We assigned 1H resonances for mercury-free and di-mercurated duplexes, and performed titration experiments with Hg(II) by using 1D 1H NMR spectra. Because of the above mentioned assignments, we could confirm the existence of mono-mercurated species, because individual components gave independent NMR signals in the titration spectra.

Enantioselective MSPV Reduction of Ketimines Using 2-Propanol and (BINOL)AlIII

[reaction: see text] A highly enantioselective Meerwein-Schmidt-Ponndorf-Verley (MSPV) reduction of N-phosphinoyl ketimines by (BINOL)Al(III)/2-propanol is reported. Yields ranging between 79 and 85% with high enantiomeric excesses (93-98%) are observed for a wide range of structurally diverse ketimines. A [2.0.4] bicyclic chelation model is proposed to account for this high selectivity.

Architecture of a Diels-Alderase ribozyme with a preformed catalytic pocket

Artificial ribozymes catalyze a variety of chemical reactions. Their structures and reaction mechanisms are largely unknown. We have analyzed a ribozyme catalyzing Diels-Alder cycloaddition reactions by comprehensive mutation analysis and a variety of probing techniques. New tertiary interactions involving base pairs between nucleotides of the 5' terminus and a large internal loop forming a pseudoknot fold were identified. The probing data indicate a preformed tertiary structure that shows no major changes on substrate or product binding. Based on these observations, a molecular architecture featuring a Y-shaped arrangement is proposed. The tertiary structure is formed in a rather unusual way; that is, the opposite sides of the asymmetric internal loop are clamped by the four 5'-terminal nucleotides, forming two adjacent two base-pair helices. It is proposed that the catalytic pocket is formed by a wedge within one of these helices.

Detection of RNA nucleobase metalation by NMR spectroscopy

Nucleic acids possess several metal cation recognition sites, including phosphates, nucleobases and possibly riboses. This article focuses on the detection of nucleobase-metal interactions by NMR spectroscopy.

NMR-Based Reappraisal of the Coordination of a Metal Ion at the Pro-Rp Oxygen of the A9/G10.1 Site in a Hammerhead Ribozyme

In the identification of a metal-binding site within enzymes, kinetic analyses based on thio-effects and Cd(2+)-rescues are widely used. In those analyses, kinetic studies using a phosphorothioate have been discussed on the premise that the substitution by a sulfur atom does not change the conformation of a ribozyme. However, our present NMR structural analysis demonstrates the change of the conformation at the metal-binding site by Rp-sulfur but not by Sp-sulfur substitution and warns against incautious interpretations of thio-effects and rescue phenomena in kinetic studies using a phosphorothioate. Our analysis further demonstrates that, in solution, a Cd(2+) ion can interact with an Rp-phosphorothioate (in support of the controversial McKay's structure, Nature 1994, 372, 68-74) and with an Sp-phosphorothioate (in support of the controversial Scott's structure, Cell 1995, 81, 991-1002) at the metal-binding A9/G10.1 site and that, in the former case, the bound Cd(2+) ion can return the ribozyme to an active conformation and rescue its enzymatic activity.

Analysis on a Cooperative Pathway Involving Multiple Cations in Hammerhead Reactions

The hammerhead ribozyme reaction is more complex than might have been expected, perhaps because of the flexibility of RNA, which would have enhanced the potential of RNA during evolution of and in the RNA world. Divalent Mg(2+) ions can increase the rate of the ribozyme-catalyzed reaction by approximately 10(9)-fold as compared to the background rate under standard conditions. However, the role of Mg(2+) ions is controversial since the reaction can proceed in the presence of high concentrations of monovalent ions, such as Li(+), Na(+), and NH(4)(+) ions, in the absence of divalent ions. We thus carried out ribozyme reactions under various conditions, and we obtained parameters that explain the experimental data. On the basis of the analysis, we propose a new pathway in the hammerhead ribozyme reaction in which divalent metal ions and monovalent ions act cooperatively.

Differential Binding of Mg2+, Zn2+, and Cd2+at Two Sites in a Hammerhead Ribozyme Motif, Determined by15N NMR

A decamer duplex model of Domain II of the hammerhead ribozyme was synthesized with [8-13C-1,7,NH2-15N3]-guanosine at the known metal binding site, G10.1 and, for comparison, [2-13C-1,7,NH2-15N3]-guanosine at G16.2. The 15N NMR chemical shifts of the labeled N7s monitored during addition of Mg2+, Cd2+, and Zn2+ showed the same preference for binding at G10.1 over G16.2 for each metal. These results demonstrate that 15N labeling can be used to evaluate the binding of different metals, including Mg2+, to a given nitrogen, as well as to compare the binding potential of different sites.

Nature of the Chemical Bond Formed with the Structural Metal Ion at the A9/G10.1 Motif Derived from Hammerhead Ribozymes

We have studied the interaction between metal ions and the metal ion-binding motif in hammerhead ribozymes, as well as the functions of the metal ion at the motif, with heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. In this study, we employed model RNA systems which mimic the metal ion-binding motif and the altered motif. In Co(NH3)6(III) titrations, we observed large 1H and 31P chemical shift perturbations for the motif and found that outer-sphere complexation of Co(NH3)6(III) is possible for this motif. From the reinvestigation of our previous 15N chemical shift data for Cd(II) binding, in comparison with those of organometallic compounds, we conclude that Cd(II) can form an inner-sphere complex with the nucleobase in the motif. Therefore, the A9/G10.1 site was found to accept both inner-sphere and outer-sphere complexations. The Mg(II) titration for a slightly different motif from the A9/G10.1 site (G10.1-C11.1 to A10.1-U11.1) revealed that its affinity to Mg(II) was drastically reduced, although the ribozyme with this altered motif is known to retain enzymatic activities. This observation suggests that the metal ion at these motifs is not a catalytic center of hammerhead ribozymes.

Metal ion binding to catalytic RNA molecules

Cations play critical roles in ribozyme structure and catalysis. Unraveling the contributions of cations as catalytic cofactors is a complex process, due to their role in inducing RNA folding and their potential ability to influence chemical reactions. Recent studies have made progress in separating these roles by directly comparing ion-induced folding with ribozyme activity. In addition, spectroscopic studies have allowed some ribozyme metal sites to be directly observed in solution, providing binding affinities and ligand information. The emerging picture suggests that important cation sites can be classified according to their affinities and properties, and can be located within the ribozyme structure. At moderate ionic strengths, a common theme is emerging for some ribozymes of structural sites that have relatively high metal ion affinities and a second type of metal site with weaker affinity that is responsible for catalysis or structural fine-tuning. In the larger ribozymes, apparent clusters of metal-sensitive positions are observed.