Mechanistic investigation of methylphosphonate synthase, a non-heme iron-dependent oxygenase

The functional importance of bacterial oxidative phosphonate pathways

Organophosphonates (Pns) are a unique class of natural products characterized by a highly stable C-P bond. Pns exhibit a wide array of interesting structures as well as useful bioactivities ranging from antibacterial to herbicidal. More structurally simple Pns are scavenged and catabolized by bacteria as a source of phosphorus. Despite their environmental and industrial importance, the pathways involved in the metabolism of Pns are far from being fully elucidated. Pathways that have been characterized often reveal unusual chemical transformations and new enzyme mechanisms. Among these, oxidative enzymes play an outstanding role during the biosynthesis and degradation of Pns. They are to a high extent responsible for the structural diversity of Pn secondary metabolites and for the break-down of both man-made and biogenic Pns. Here, we review our current understanding of the importance of oxidative enzymes for microbial Pn metabolism, discuss the underlying mechanistic principles, similarities, and differences between pathways. This review illustrates Pn biochemistry to involve a mix of classical redox biochemistry and unique oxidative reactions, including ring formations, rearrangements, and desaturations. Many of these reactions are mediated by specialized iron-dependent oxygenases and oxidases. Such enzymes are the key to both early pathway diversification and late-stage functionalization of complex Pns.

Global and seasonal variation of marine phosphonate metabolism

Marine microbial communities rely on dissolved organic phosphorus (DOP) remineralisation to meet phosphorus (P) requirements. We extensively surveyed the genomic and metagenomic distribution of genes directing phosphonate biosynthesis, substrate-specific catabolism of 2-aminoethylphosphonate (2-AEP, the most abundant phosphonate in the marine environment), and broad-specificity catabolism of phosphonates by the C-P lyase (including methylphosphonate, a major source of methane). We developed comprehensive enzyme databases by curating publicly available sequences and then screened metagenomes from TARA Oceans and Munida Microbial Observatory Time Series (MOTS) to assess spatial and seasonal variation in phosphonate metabolism pathways. Phosphonate cycling genes were encoded in diverse gene clusters by 35 marine bacterial and archaeal classes. More than 65% of marine phosphonate cycling genes mapped to Proteobacteria with production demonstrating wider taxonomic diversity than catabolism. Hydrolysis of 2-AEP was the dominant phosphonate catabolism strategy, enabling microbes to assimilate carbon and nitrogen alongside P. Genes for broad-specificity catabolism by the C-P lyase were far less widespread, though enriched in the extremely P-deplete environment of the Mediterranean Sea. Phosphonate cycling genes were abundant in marine metagenomes, particularly from the mesopelagic zone and winter sampling dates. Disparity between prevalence of substrate-specific and broad-specificity catabolism may be due to higher resource expenditure from the cell to build and retain the C-P lyase. This study is the most comprehensive metagenomic survey of marine microbial phosphonate cycling to date and provides curated databases for 14 genes involved in phosphonate cycling.

Fenton-Derived OH Radicals Enable the MPnS Enzyme to Convert 2-Hydroxyethylphosphonate to Methylphosphonate: Insights from Ab Initio QM/MM MD Simulations

The mechanism for dioxygen activation represents one of the core issues in metalloenzymes. In most cases, the activation of the O₂ molecule requires additional electrons from an external reducant. However, nonheme hydroxyethylphosphonate dioxygenase (HEPD) and methylphosphonate synthase (MPnS) are exceptional C-H oxygenases. Both enzymes do not utilize reductants, rather they employ directly iron(III)-superoxide species to initiate H-abstraction reactions and lead thereby to catalysis of the C-C cleavage in 2-hydroxyethylphosphonate (2-HEP). Using the recently characterized MPnS structure and QM(B3LYP)/MM-based metadynamics simulations, we deciphered the chemical mechanism for MPnS. Our simulations demonstrate O₂ activation in MPnS is mediated by an adjacent Lysine residue (Lys28) in the active site, leading to an unusual H ₂ O ₂ intermediate in the reductant-independent nonheme MPnS enzyme. Furthermore, the so-generated H ₂ O ₂ intermediate is subsequently employed in a Fenton-type reaction, leading to a locked •OH radical that spontaneously attaches to the substrate carbonyl group. Meanwhile, the proton from the Fe(III)-OH is shuttled back to the deprotonated Lys28, affording the Fe(IV)-oxo species that is identified by experiment in HEPD. Thus, our calculations demonstrate an unusual proton-shuttle mechanism for O ₂ activation in metalloenzymes.

A role for phosphorus redox in emerging and modern biochemistry

Phosphorus is a major biogeochemical element controlling growth in many ecosystems. It has presumably been an important element since the onset of life. In most chemical and biochemical considerations, phosphorus is synonymous with phosphates, a pentavalent oxidation state that includes the phosphate backbone of DNA and RNA, as well as major metabolites such as ATP. However, redox processing of phosphates to phosphites and phosphonates, and to even lower oxidation states provides a work-around to many of the problems of prebiotic chemistry, including phosphorus's low solubility and poor reactivity. In addition, modern phosphorus cycling has increasingly identified reduced P compounds as playing a role, sometimes significant, in biogeochemical processes. This suggests that phosphorus is not redox-insensitive and reduced P compounds should be considered as part of the phosphorus biogeochemical cycle.

Structural basis for methylphosphonate biosynthesis

Methylphosphonate synthase (MPnS) produces methylphosphonate, a metabolic precursor to methane in the upper ocean. Here, we determine a 2.35-angstrom resolution structure of MPnS and discover that it has an unusual 2-histidine-1-glutamine iron-coordinating triad. We further solve the structure of a related enzyme, hydroxyethylphosphonate dioxygenase from Streptomyces albus (SaHEPD), and find that it displays the same motif. SaHEPD can be converted into an MPnS by mutation of glutamine-adjacent residues, identifying the molecular requirements for methylphosphonate synthesis. Using these sequence markers, we find numerous putative MPnSs in marine microbiomes and confirm that MPnS is present in the abundant Pelagibacter ubique. The ubiquity of MPnS-containing microbes supports the proposal that methylphosphonate is a source of methane in the upper, aerobic ocean, where phosphorus-starved microbes catabolize methylphosphonate for its phosphorus.

Beyond ferryl-mediated hydroxylation: 40 years of the rebound mechanism and C-H activation

Since our initial report in 1976, the oxygen rebound mechanism has become the consensus mechanistic feature for an expanding variety of enzymatic C-H functionalization reactions and small molecule biomimetic catalysts. For both the biotransformations and models, an initial hydrogen atom abstraction from the substrate (R-H) by high-valent iron-oxo species (Feⁿ=O) generates a substrate radical and a reduced iron hydroxide, [Fe^n-1-OH ·R]. This caged radical pair then evolves on a complicated energy landscape through a number of reaction pathways, such as oxygen rebound to form R-OH, rebound to a non-oxygen atom affording R-X, electron transfer of the incipient radical to yield a carbocation, R⁺, desaturation to form olefins, and radical cage escape. These various flavors of the rebound process, often in competition with each other, give rise to the wide range of C-H functionalization reactions performed by iron-containing oxygenases. In this review, we first recount the history of radical rebound mechanisms, their general features, and key intermediates involved. We will discuss in detail the factors that affect the behavior of the initial caged radical pair and the lifetimes of the incipient substrate radicals. Several representative examples of enzymatic C-H transformations are selected to illustrate how the behaviors of the radical pair [Fe^n-1-OH ·R] determine the eventual reaction outcome. Finally, we discuss the powerful potential of "radical rebound" processes as a general paradigm for developing novel C-H functionalization reactions with synthetic, biomimetic catalysts. We envision that new chemistry will continue to arise by bridging enzymatic "radical rebound" with synthetic organic chemistry.

Phosphonate Biochemistry

Organophosphonic acids are unique as natural products in terms of stability and mimicry. The C-P bond that defines these compounds resists hydrolytic cleavage, while the phosphonyl group is a versatile mimic of transition-states, intermediates, and primary metabolites. This versatility may explain why a variety of organisms have extensively explored the use organophosphonic acids as bioactive secondary metabolites. Several of these compounds, such as fosfomycin and bialaphos, figure prominently in human health and agriculture. The enzyme reactions that create these molecules are an interesting mix of chemistry that has been adopted from primary metabolism as well as those with no chemical precedent. Additionally, the phosphonate moiety represents a source of inorganic phosphate to microorganisms that live in environments that lack this nutrient; thus, unusual enzyme reactions have also evolved to cleave the C-P bond. This review is a comprehensive summary of the occurrence and function of organophosphonic acids natural products along with the mechanisms of the enzymes that synthesize and catabolize these molecules.

Go it alone: four-electron oxidations by mononuclear non-heme iron enzymes

This review discusses the current mechanistic understanding of a group of mononuclear non-heme iron-dependent enzymes that catalyze four-electron oxidation of their organic substrates without the use of any cofactors or cosubstrates. One set of enzymes acts on α-ketoacid-containing substrates, coupling decarboxylation to oxygen activation. This group includes 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase, 4-hydroxymandelate synthase, and CloR involved in clorobiocin biosynthesis. A second set of enzymes acts on substrates containing a thiol group that coordinates to the iron. This group is comprised of isopenicillin N synthase, thiol dioxygenases, and enzymes involved in the biosynthesis of ergothioneine and ovothiol. The final group of enzymes includes HEPD and MPnS that both carry out the oxidative cleavage of the carbon-carbon bond of 2-hydroxyethylphosphonate but generate different products. Commonalities amongst many of these enzymes are discussed and include the initial substrate oxidation by a ferric-superoxo-intermediate and a second oxidation by a ferryl species.

Mechanistic Investigation of a Non-Heme Iron Enzyme Catalyzed Epoxidation in (-)-4'-Methoxycyclopenin Biosynthesis

Mechanisms have been proposed for α-KG-dependent non-heme iron enzyme catalyzed oxygen atom insertion into an olefinic moiety in various natural products, but they have not been examined in detail. Using a combination of methods including transient kinetics, Mössbauer spectroscopy, and mass spectrometry, we demonstrate that AsqJ-catalyzed (-)-4'-methoxycyclopenin formation uses a high-spin Fe(IV)-oxo intermediate to carry out epoxidation. Furthermore, product analysis on (16)O/(18)O isotope incorporation from the reactions using the native substrate, 4'-methoxydehydrocyclopeptin, and a mechanistic probe, dehydrocyclopeptin, reveals evidence supporting oxo↔hydroxo tautomerism of the Fe(IV)-oxo species in the non-heme iron enzyme catalysis.

Oxygen-18 Kinetic Isotope Effects of Nonheme Iron Enzymes HEPD and MPnS Support Iron(III) Superoxide as the Hydrogen Abstraction Species

Nonheme iron oxygenases that carry out four-electron oxidations of substrate have been proposed to employ iron(III) superoxide species to initiate this reaction [Paria, S.; Que, L.; Paine, T. K. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed.2011, 50, 11129]. Here we report experimental evidence in support of this proposal. ¹⁸O KIEs were measured for two recently discovered mononuclear nonheme iron oxygenases: hydroxyethylphosphonate dioxygenase (HEPD) and methylphosphonate synthase (MPnS). Competitive ¹⁸O KIEs measured with deuterated substrates are larger than those measured with unlabeled substrates, which indicates that C–H cleavage must occur before an irreversible reductive step at molecular oxygen. A similar observation was previously used to implicate copper(II) superoxide in the H-abstraction reactions catalyzed by dopamine β-monooxygenase [Tian, G. C.; Klinman, J. P. J. Am. Chem. Soc.1993, 115, 8891] and peptidylglycine α-hydroxylating monooxygenase [Francisco, W. A.; Blackburn, N. J.; Klinman, J. P. Biochemistry2003, 42, 1813].

A common late-stage intermediate in catalysis by 2-hydroxyethyl-phosphonate dioxygenase and methylphosphonate synthase

2-Hydroxyethylphosphonate dioxygenase (HEPD) and methylphosphonate synthase (MPnS) are nonheme iron oxygenases that both catalyze the carbon-carbon bond cleavage of 2-hydroxyethylphosphonate but generate different products. Substrate labeling experiments led to a mechanistic hypothesis in which the fate of a common intermediate determined product identity. We report here the generation of a bifunctional mutant of HEPD (E176H) that exhibits the activity of both HEPD and MPnS. The product distribution of the mutant is sensitive to a substrate isotope effect, consistent with an isotope-sensitive branching mechanism involving a common intermediate. The X-ray structure of the mutant was determined and suggested that the introduced histidine does not coordinate the active site metal, unlike the iron-binding glutamate it replaced.

Phosphonate biosynthesis and catabolism: a treasure trove of unusual enzymology

Natural product biosynthesis has proven a fertile ground for the discovery of novel chemistry. Herein we review the progress made in elucidating the biosynthetic pathways of phosphonate and phosphinate natural products such as the antibacterial compounds dehydrophos and fosfomycin, the herbicidal phosphinothricin-containing peptides, and the antimalarial compound FR-900098. In each case, investigation of the pathway has yielded unusual, and often unprecedented, biochemistry. Likewise, recent investigations have uncovered novel ways to cleave the CP bond to yield phosphate under phosphorus starvation conditions. These include the discovery of novel oxidative cleavage of the CP bond catalyzed by PhnY and PhnZ as well as phosphonohydrolases that liberate phosphate from phosphonoacetate. Perhaps the crown jewel of phosphonate catabolism has been the recent resolution of the longstanding problem of the C-P lyase responsible for reductively cleaving the CP bond of a number of different phosphonates to release phosphate. Taken together, the strides made on both metabolic and catabolic fronts illustrate an array of fascinating biochemistry.