Redox-Modulated Stepwise Photochromism in a Ruthenium Complex with Dual Dithienylethene-Acetylides

Amplified photomodulation of a bis(dithienylethene)-substituted phosphine

Phosphine ligands play a crucial role in homogeneous catalysis, allowing fine-tuning of the catalytic activity of various metals by modifying their structure. An ultimate challenge in this field is to reach controlled modulation of catalysis in situ, for which the development of phosphines capable of photoswitching between states with differential electronic properties has been proposed. To magnify this light-induced behavior, in this work we describe a novel phosphine ligand incorporating two dithienylethene photoswitchable moieties tethered to the same phosphorus atom. Double photoisomerization was observed for this ligand, which remains unhindered upon gold(I) complexation. As a result, the preparation of a fully ring-closed phosphine isomer was accomplished, for which amplified variation of phosphorus electron density was verified both experimentally and by computational calculations. Accordingly, the presented molecular design based on multiphotochromic phosphines could open new ways for preparing enhanced photoswitchable catalytic systems.

Kinetic Analysis of the Photochemical Paths in Asymmetric Diarylethene Dimer

An asymmetric diarylethene dimer composed of 2- and 3-thienylethene units linked by m-phenylene developed various colors upon UV irradiation via an independent photochromic reaction on each unit. The change in contents and the other photoresponses of the photogenerated four isomers were analyzed using quantum yield for all the possible photochemical paths, i. e., photoisomerization, fluorescence, energy transfer, and the other non-radiative paths. Almost all the rate constants of photochemical paths were calculated using measurable quantum yields and lifetimes. It was found that a significant contribution on photoresponse was the competition between photoisomerization and intramolecular energy transfer. The clear difference was observed in the photoresponses of the dimer and the 1 : 1 mixture solution of the model compounds. The m-phenylene spacer appropriately regulated the rate of energy transfer in the asymmetric dimer, and the spacer enabled isolation of the excited state of the dimer, making the above quantitative analysis possible.

Multistate Switching of Some Ruthenium Alkynyl and Vinyl Spiropyran Complexes

To study the switching properties of photochromes, we undertook the synthesis and characterization of several ruthenium organometallic complexes of the type [Ru(Cp*)(dppe)(C≡C-SP)] or [Ru(CO)(dppe)(PPh3)Cl(CH═CH-SP)], where SP = spiropyran. The spectroscopic and electrochemical properties of the complexes were determined by careful cyclic voltammetric and spectroelectrochemical experiments. Whereas the mononuclear alkynyl ruthenium complexes undergo one-electron oxidations localized over the metal alkynyl moiety, the oxidation of the mononuclear vinyl ruthenium complexes is centered on the indoline moiety of the spiropyran. Through these studies, we demonstrate access to several stable redox states, in addition to switching states attained via acidochromism and/or photoisomerization.

Ytterbium(III) Complex with Photochromic Ruthenium(II) Acetylide Ligand: All Visible Light Photoswitching of NIR Luminescence

We report a ruthenium(II) bisacetylide complex bearing a photochromic dithienylethene (DTE) acetylide arm and a coordinating bipyridyl on the trans acetylide unit. Its coordination with Yb(TTA)₃ centers (TTA = 2-thenoyltrifluoroacetonate) produces a bimetallic complex in which the dithienylethene isomerization is triggered by both ultraviolet (UV) light absorbed by the DTE unit and 450 nm excitation in a transition of the organometallic moiety. The redox behavior arising from the ruthenium(II) bisacetylide system is fully investigated by cyclic voltammetry and spectroelectrochemistry, revealing a lack of stability of the DTE-closed oxidized state preventing effective redox luminescence switching. On the other hand, the photoswitching of ytterbium(III) near-infrared (NIR) emission triggered by the photochromic reaction is fully operational. The electronic structure of this complex in its different states characterized by strong electronic coupling between the DTE and the ruthenium(II)-based moieties leading to metal-assisted photochromic behavior were rationalized with the help of time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations.

Metal-Photoswitch Friendship: From Photochromic Complexes to Functional Materials

Cooperative metal-photoswitch interfaces comprise an application-driven field which is based on strategic coupling of metal cations and organic photochromic molecules to advance the behavior of both components, resulting in dynamic molecular and material properties controlled through external stimuli. In this Perspective, we highlight the ways in which metal-photoswitch interplay can be utilized as a tool to modulate a system's physicochemical properties and performance in a variety of structural motifs, including discrete molecular complexes or cages, as well as periodic structures such as metal-organic frameworks. This Perspective starts with photochromic molecular complexes as the smallest subunit in which metal-photoswitch interactions can occur, and progresses toward functional materials. In particular, we explore the role of the metal-photoswitch relationship for gaining fundamental knowledge of switchable electronic and magnetic properties, as well as in the design of stimuli-responsive sensors, optically gated memory devices, catalysts, and photodynamic therapeutic agents. The abundance of stimuli-responsive systems in the natural world only foreshadows the creative directions that will uncover the full potential of metal-photoswitch interactions in the coming years.

Photocontrolled multiple-state photochromic benzo[b]phosphole thieno[3,2-b]phosphole-containing alkynylgold(I) complex via selective light irradiation

Photochromic materials have drawn growing attention because using light as a stimulus has been regarded as a convenient and environmental-friendly way to control properties of smart materials. While photoresponsive systems that are capable of showing multiple-state photochromism are attractive, the development of materials with such capabilities has remained a challenging task. Here we show that a benzo[b]phosphole thieno[3,2‑b]phosphole-containing alkynylgold(I) complex features multiple photoinduced color changes, in which the gold(I) metal center plays an important role in separating two photoactive units that leads to the suppression of intramolecular quenching processes of the excited states. More importantly, the exclusive photochemical reactivity of the thieno[3,2‑b]phosphole moiety of the gold(I) complex can be initiated upon photoirradiation of visible light. Stepwise photochromism of the gold(I) complex has been made possible, offering an effective strategy for the construction of multiple-state photochromic materials with multiple photocontrolled states to enhance the storage capacity of potential optical memory devices.

Metal complexes bearing photochromic ligands: photocontrol of functions and processes

Metal complexes associated with photochromic molecules are attractive platforms to achieve smart light-switching materials with innovative and exciting properties due to specific optical, electronic, magnetic or catalytic features of metal complexes and by perturbing the excited-state properties of both components to generate new reactivity and photochemical properties. In this overview, we focus on selected achievements in key domains dealing with optical, redox, magnetic properties, as well as application in catalysis or supramolecular chemistry. We also try to point out scientific challenges that are still faced for future developments and applications.

Light-Triggered Metal Coordination Dynamics in Photoswitchable Dithienylethene-Ferrocene System

The C₂-symmetric photochromic molecule 3, containing dithienylethene (DTE) and ferrocene units connected by an alkyne bridge, represents a unique probe where a metal (Hg²⁺) binds with the central DTE moiety. Both photoisomerized states of 3 (open, 3o; closed, 3c) are found to interact with Hg²⁺ ion by the S atoms of the DTE core; however, the binding constants (from a UV-vis study) and DFT calculations suggest that the open isomer (3o) binds with the metal ion more strongly than that of the closed isomer (3c). Notably, the course of metal binding does not perturb the inherent photoisomerization properties of the DTE core and the photoswitchability persists even in the metal-coordinated form of 3, however, with a comparatively slower rate. The quantum yields for photocyclization (Φ_o→c) and photocycloreversion (Φ_c→o) in the free form are 0.56 and 0.007, respectively, whereas the photocyclization quantum yield in the Hg²⁺ complexed species is 0.068, 8.2 times lower than the photocyclization quantum yield (Φ_o→c) of free 3o. Thus, the rate of photoisomerization can be modulated by a suitable metal coordination to the DTE core. The dynamics of photoswitchability in the metal-coordinated form of DTE has been explored by experimental means (UV-vis and electrochemical studies) as well as quantum chemical calculations.

Photoisomerization of PtII Complexes Containing Two Different Photochromic Chromophores: Boron Chromophore versus Dithienylethene Chromophore

In order to examine competitive photoisomerization, a series of novel photochromic Pt^II molecules that contain both dithienylethene (DTE) and B(ppy)Mes₂ units (ppy=2-phenylpyridine, Mes=mesityl) were successfully synthesized and fully structurally characterized. Their photochromic properties were examined by UV/Vis, emission and NMR spectroscopy. It was found that the DTE unit in all three compounds is the preferred photoisomerization site, exhibiting reversible photochromism with irradiation. The B(ppy)Mes₂ unit does not undergo photoisomerization in these molecules, but likely enhances the photoisomerization quantum efficiency of the DTE moiety through the antenna effect. Extended irradiation with UV light leads to the rearrangement of the ring-closed isomers of DTE. TD-DFT computational studies indicate that the DTE photocyclization proceeds via a triplet pathway through an efficient energy transfer process.

Symmetric and nonsymmetric bis-hemithioindigos – precise visible light controlled shape-shifters

A series of bis-hemithioindigo photoswitches with different molecular setups are presented allowing precise manipulation of molecular shapes with visible light.

Photochemical reactions of metal complexes in the solid state

This perspective focusses on the solid-state reactivity and structural transformation driven by photochemical methods in discrete metal complexes, organometallic compounds, metallo-macrocycles and cages. Changes in the metal-metal bond distances, racemization of chiral centres, fusion of cages, formation of coordination polymers, expected [2 + 2] and [4 + 4] cycloaddition products, unusual phenyl-olefin dimerization, and linkage isomerization of -SO₂, -NO & -NO₂ ligands cause the structural transformations. Of these, [2 + 2] photo-cycloaddition reactions have been widely studied and the photoreactions are made possible by various supramolecular interactions including hydrogen bonds, metallophilic, ππ and C-Hπ interactions, ligand design and metallic clips to bring the reactive functional groups closely into correct orientation close to the transition state. These photoreactions are often accompanied by crystal bending, mechanical motion, and changes in the magnetic and photoluminescence properties. In several cases, the single crystals have been preserved at the end of the reactions, which are known as single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) reactions.

Is energy transfer limiting multiphotochromism? answers from ab initio quantifications

Dithienylethenes (DTEs) can be assembled to form supramolecular multiphotochromic systems that are highly functional molecular architectures of potential interest for building complex optoelectronic devices. Yet even simple DTE dimers relying on an organic linker may suffer from a partial photoactivity, i.e., only one of the two switches does isomerise. Experimentally, this limited photochromism has been attributed to an excited state energy transfer (EET) between the two DTEs of the multimer; this EET taking place instead of the desired photoinduced cyclisation of the DTE. However, no clear evidences of this phenomenon have been provided so far. In this work we propose the first rationalisation of this potential parasite photoinduced event using a computational approach based on Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory (TD-DFT) for the calculation of the electronic coupling in DTE dimers. Besides quantifying EET in several systems, we dissect the role of through-bond and through-space mechanisms on this process and clarify their dependence on both the nature and length of the bridge separating the two photochromes. The theoretical data obtained in this framework are in full agreement with the experimental outcomes and pave the way toward a molecular design of coupled, yet fully functionals, DTE-based multiswitches.

Coordination Compounds with Photochromic Ligands: Ready Tunability and Visible Light-Sensitized Photochromism

Photochromic compounds are well-known for their promising applications in many areas. In this context, many different photochromic families have been developed. As the early study of these photochromic compounds was mainly focused on the organic system, their photochromic reactivity was mainly derived from the singlet excited state. We hypothesized that the incorporation of the photochromic ligand to the transition metal complex and coordination complex systems would not only render the triplet state of the organic photochromic system more readily accessible due to the large spin-orbit coupling of the heavy metal center but also would lead to ready extension of the excitation wavelength to less destructive longer wavelength low-energy excitation. On the other hand, the long-lived triplet excited states of the metal complexes are also suitable for energy or electron transfer processes, which should lead to new photochromic behavior and photoswitchable functional properties. Through the incorporation of the stilbene-, azo-, spirooxazine-, and dithienylethene-containing ligands to transition metal complex systems with heavy metal centers and suitable excited states, triplet state photosensitized photochromism has been achieved. With the triplet state photosensitization, the photochromism of these compounds could be extended from the high energy UV region to the visible region. In the development of dithienylethene-containing ligands, we have adopted an alternative strategy, which involves the incorporation of nitrogen and sulfur heterocycles that directly form part of the dithienylethene framework as ligands to exert a much stronger perturbation and influence on the excited state properties of the photochromic unit by the metal center. On the basis of the new design, wide ranges of dithienylethene-containing ligands, including phenanthrolines, 2-pyridylimidazoles, N-pyridylimidazol-2-ylidenes, cyclometalating thienylpyridines, β-diketonates, and β-ketoiminates have been designed and incorporated into various coordination systems. Apart from the photosensitization, tuning of the closed form absorption and photochromic behavior based on the perturbation of the metal center, coordination-assisted planarization, modification of the ancillary ligands and introduction of various electronic excited states derived from the coordination system have been successfully demonstrated. This strategy can be used for developing NIR photochromic dithienylethenes. With the above effects observed upon the coordination to different transition metal centers and central atoms, this strategy offers a simple and effective way for the modification of the photochromic characteristics. Moreover, the emission and other functional properties of the coordination systems could also be photoswitched by the photochromic reactions.

Stepwise photochromism of bisnaphthopyrans exhibiting an excitation intensity-dependent color change

The bisnaphthopyran derivatives composed of two naphthopyran units exhibit a nonlinear color change depending on the excitation light intensity.

High quantum yield and unusual photoluminescence behaviour in tetrahedral manganese(ii) based on hybrid compounds

High quantum yields and unusual luminescence characteristics were successfully achieved by regulating the organic cations in tetrahedral manganese(ii) complexes.

Redox-driven porphyrin based systems for new luminescent molecular switches

This work explores the possibility of controlling the fluorescence of porphyrins via oxidation of a ruthenium acetylide unit. The modulation depends on the nature of the porphyrin unit(s).

Multiphotochromism in an Asymmetric Ruthenium Complex with Two Different Dithienylethenes

An asymmetric bis(dithienylethene-acetylide) ruthenium(II) complex trans-Ru(dppe)₂(L1o)(L2o) (1oo) incorporating two different dithienylethene-acetylides (L1o and L2o) was designed to modulate multistate photochromism in view of the well separated ring-closing absorption bands between L1o and L2o. Upon irradiation with appropriate wavelengths of light, complex 1 undergoes stepwise photocyclization and selective photocycloreversion to afford four states (1oo, 1co, 1oc, and 1cc). As a contrast, symmetric complexes trans-Ru(dppe)₂(L1o)₂ (2oo) and trans-Ru(dppe)₂(L2o)₂ (3oo) with two identical dithienylethene-acetylides were synthesized, and the corresponding photochromic behavior was investigated. The photochromic properties of the oxidized species (1oo⁺/1co⁺/1oc⁺/1cc⁺, 2oo⁺/2co⁺/2cc⁺, and 3oo⁺/3co⁺/3cc⁺) were also investigated. The ring-closing absorption bands of one-electron oxidized species 1oo⁺, 2oo⁺, and 3oo⁺ show obvious blue shifts relative to those of 1oo, 2oo, and 3oo, respectively. The ring-closing absorption bands in both neutral and oxidized species grow progressively following oo → oc/co → cc and oo⁺ → oc⁺/co⁺ → cc⁺. As revealed by spectroscopic, electrochemical, and computational studies, complex 1 displays eight switchable states through stepwise photocyclization, selective cycloreversion, and a reversible redox process.

An unprecedented photochromic system with cis-oriented dithienyl-dithiolenes supported by metal chelation

4,5-Bis(2-methyl-5-phenylthiophen-3-yl)-1,3-dithiol-2-one (L1o) was elaborately designed to afford dithienyl-dithiolene as a new photochromic ligand. We describe herein the preparation and characterization of unprecedented photochromic dithienyl-dithiolene complexes with cis-orientation of dithienylethene (DTE) stabilized by metal chelation instead of conventional cyclopentene. The treatment of L1o with sodium methoxide in methanol afforded a disodium salt of dithiolate dianion, which reacts with M(dppe)Cl₂ (dppe = 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane, M = Ni, Pd) to give neutral compounds M(dppe)(dithiolate) as established by X-ray crystallography. The reaction of L1o with NiCl₂ in the presence of sodium methoxide allows the isolation of an anionic nickel(ii) bis(dithienyl-dithiolene) complex with photochemical inertness. In contrast, the corresponding reaction with ZnCl₂ afforded a dianionic zinc(ii) complex chelated by two dianionic dithienyl-dithiolenes, which displays stepwise photocyclization upon irradiation with UV light at 312 nm as demonstrated experimentally and theoretically. Only when dithienyl-dithiolene behaves as a dicationic ligand instead of neutral or monoanionic species, it is possible to achieve reversible photochromism in the corresponding metal complexes.

Spectroscopic and electrochemical properties of ruthenium complexes with photochromic triarylamine–dithienylethene–acetylide ligands

The charge delocalization along the molecular backbone shows a progressive increase following stepwise photocyclization in the inorganic–organic mixed-valence system.

Designing efficient photochromic dithienylethene dyads

Aiming at designing more efficient multiphotochromes, we investigate with the help of ab initio tools the impact of the substitution on a series of dimers constituted of two dithienylethene (DTE) moieties, strongly coupled to each other through an ethynyl linker. The electronic structure and the optical properties of a large panel of compounds, substituted on different positions by various types of electroactive groups, have been compared with the aim of designing a dyad in which the three possible isomers (open-open, closed-open, closed-closed) can be reached. We show that appending the reactive carbons atoms of the DTE core with electroactive groups on one of the two photochromes allows cyclisation to be induced on a specific moiety, which leads to the formation of the desired closed-open isomer. Substituting the lateral positions of the thiophene rings provides further control of the topology of the frontier molecular orbitals, so that the electronic transition inducing the second ring closure stands out in the spectrum of the intermediate isomer.

Substituent effects on the properties of photochromic hybrid diarylethenes with a naphthalene moiety

Four new unsymmetrical photochromic diarylethenes bearing both naphthalene and thiophene moieties were synthesized, and the structures of two diarylethenes were determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. The naphthalene ring was connected directly to the central perfluorocyclopentene ring as an aryl moiety and available to participate in photoisomerization reaction. All the diarylethenes exhibited favorable photochromism and functioned as fluorescence switches in both solution and poly(methyl methacrylate) films. The electron-withdrawing substituent significantly shifted the absorption maxima to a longer wavelength and evidently suppressed the cycloreversion quantum yield, whereas the electron-donating substituents enhanced the fluorescence quantum yield of diarylethenes with a naphthalene moiety. Furthermore, cyclic voltammograms suggested that the oxidation onsets and band-gaps of the open-ring isomers were much bigger than those of the closed-ring isomers. The results indicated that the substituents at the 5-position of thiophene ring could availably modulate their optical and electrochemical behaviors.

Two heteroleptic Ir(iii)–bisthienylethene compounds: syntheses, structures and aggregation-induced luminescence

Bisthienylethene hnbdtiH and its heteroleptic complexes [Ir(dfppy)₂(hnbdti)]·2CH₃OH (1) and [Ir(ppy)₂(hnbdti)]·CH₃OH (2) were synthesized and characterized by crystal structures. Aggregation-induced phosphorescence emission was observed in 1.

Heteroleptic Ir(iii) complexes based on 2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)-pyridine and bisthienylethene: structures, luminescence and photochromic properties

Bisthienylethenes L1H and L2H, and their Ir(iii) complexes have been synthesized. Their crystal structures, luminescences and photochromisms have been studied.

Multiphotochromic molecular systems

We review molecular compounds encompassing several photochromic units with a focus on their functionalities.

Switching of the triplet excited state of styryl 2,6-diiodo-bodipy and its application in acid-activatable singlet oxygen photosensitizing

IodoBodipy-styrylBodipy dyads triplet photosensitizers were prepared (B-1 and B-2) which contain acid-responsive moiety. Both compounds show broadband visible light absorption, due to the resonance energy transfer (RET) between the two different visible light-harvesting Bodipy units. The photophysical properties of the dyads were studied with steady-state and nanosecond time-resolved transient absorption spectroscopy. The production of triplet excited state is switched ON or OFF by protonation/deprotonation of the amino group in the dyads. In the neutral form, the excited state is short-lived (<10 ns) and no singlet oxygen ((1)O2) photosensitizing was observed. Upon protonation, a long-lived triplet excited state was observed (τT = 3.1 μs) and the (1)O2 quantum yield (ΦΔ) is up to 73.8%. The energy levels of the components of the dyads were changed upon protonation and this energy level tuning exerts significant influence on the triplet state property of the dyad. Acid-activated shuffling of the localization of the triplet excited state between two components of a dyad was observed. Furthermore, we observed a rare example that a chromophore giving shorter absorption wavelength is acting as the singlet energy acceptor in RET. The experimental results were rationalized by density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT) calculations.