Chiral Guest Binding as a Probe of Macrocycle Dynamics and Tautomerism in a Conjugated Tetrapyrrole

NMR lineshape analysis using analytical solutions of multi-state chemical exchange with applications to kinetics of host-guest systems

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) lineshape analysis is a powerful tool for the study of chemical kinetics. Here we provide techniques for analysis of the relationship between experimentally observed spin kinetics (transitions between different environments [Formula: see text]) and corresponding chemical kinetics (transitions between distinct chemical species; e.g., free host and complexed host molecule). The advantages of using analytical solutions for two-, three- or generally N-state exchange lineshapes (without J-coupling) over the widely used numerical calculation for NMR spectral fitting are presented. Several aspects of exchange kinetics including the generalization of coalescence conditions in two-state exchange, the possibility of multiple processes between two states, and differences between equilibrium and steady-state modes are discussed. 'Reduced equivalent schemes' are introduced for spin kinetics containing fast-exchanging states, effectively reducing the number of exchanging states. The theoretical results have been used to analyze a host-guest system containing an oxoporphyrinogen complexed with camphorsulfonic acid and several other literature examples, including isomerization, protein kinetics, or enzymatic reactions. The theoretical treatment and experimental examples present an expansion of the systematic approach to rigorous analyses of systems with rich chemical kinetics through NMR lineshape analysis.

Importance of molecular symmetry for enantiomeric excess recognition by NMR

Recently prochiral solvating agents (pro-CSA) came under the spotlight for the detection of enantiopurity by NMR. Chemical shift non-equivalency in achiral hosts introduced by the presence of chiral guests yields observable resonance signal splitting (Δδ) correlating to the enantiomeric excess (e.e.). In this work, symmetry is our lens to explain porphyrin-based supramolecular receptor activity in a chiral environment. Based on extensive NMR analyses of the atropisomeric receptors, the host symmetry is shown to be affected by porphyrin nonplanarity and further desymmetrized in the presence of a chiral guest. As such, the exposed porphyrin inner core (N-H), with its strong hydrogen bond abilities, for the first time, has been exploited in enantiomeric composition analysis. Our approach in e.e. detection by N-H signals appearing in a previously underutilized region of the spectrum (below 0 ppm) shows chemical shift splitting (Δδ) three times more sensitive to enantiomeric compositions than previously reported systems.

Analyte Interactions with Oxoporphyrinogen Derivatives: Computational Aspects

Abstract:

The binding of anions by highly-coloured chromophore compounds is of interest from the point-of-view of the development of optical sensors for analyte species. In this review, we have summarised our work on the interactions between oxoporphyrinogen type host compounds and different analyte species using computational methods. The origin of our interest in sensing using oxoporphyrinogens stems from an initial finding involving anion-host interactions involving a conjugated oxoporphyrinogen molecule. This review starts from that point, introducing some additional exemplary anion binding data, which is then elaborated to include descriptions of our synthesis work towards multitopic and ion pair interactions. In all the projects, we have consulted computational data on host structure and host-guest complexes in order to obtain information about the interactions occurring during complexation. Density functional theory and molecular dynamics simulations have been extensively used for these purposes. Oxoporphyrinogens are highly colored synthetically flexible compounds whose interactions with anions, ion pairs, and other species have been modelled using computational methods.

Molecular rotor based on an oxidized resorcinarene

Rate of rotation of substituents in a molecular single stator-double rotor based on an oxidized resorcinarene with unsaturated hemiquinonoid groups at its meso positions (i.e., a fuchsonarene) has been controlled according to solvent polarity and acidity.

Syntheses of thiophene appended N-confused phlorin isomers

A doubly confused thiapentapyrrane NSP-5 was synthesized by acid-catalysed condensation. Subsequent oxidation with DDQ did not afford the expected thiasapphyrin-like product. Instead, two tetrapyrrolic macrocycles, i.e. neo-N-confused phlorin (1) and N-confused phlorin-II (2) were obtained in the yields of 14% and 18%, respectively. The compounds were characterized by NMR, HRMS, and X-ray diffraction analyses. Single crystal structures clearly reveal that the thienyl units are not embedded into the macrocycles, but appended as meso-substituents, and the C[Formula: see text]-N and C[Formula: see text]-C[Formula: see text] cyclization modes can be clearly revealed by the crystal structures of 1 and 2, respectively. The observation that the thienyl unit is not involved in oxidative cyclization may be related to the relatively low reactivity of the thiophene moiety compared with the more electron-rich pyrrole unit. These results indicate that oxidative cyclization of linear thiaoligopyrranes containing terminal thiophene units may be developed as an effective approach for synthesizing nonconjugated macrocycles like phlorin analogues.

Estimation of Enantiomeric Excess Based on Rapid Host–Guest Exchange

Chiral molecules possess enantiomers that have non-superimposable chemical structures but exhibit identical nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra. This feature prevents the use of NMR spectroscopic methods for the determination of enantiomeric excesses (ee) of chiral molecules, using simple mixtures of their enantiomers. Recently, however, it was reported that the addition of a symmetrical prochiral molecule (a reporter or host) into a solution of chiral analyte can lead to estimation of ee through interactions involving rapid exchange of the chiral analyte (guest) in the formed host–guest complex. This is due to the ee-dependent splitting of NMR resonances of the prochiral host molecule based on averaging the chemical shift non-equivalency caused by the presence of a chiral guest. The mechanism is not dependent on diastereomer formation, and 1:1 host–guest complexes can also show ee-dependent NMR peak splitting. Prochiral molecules capable of ee sensing using the NMR technique are now referred to as so-called prochiral solvating agents (pro-CSAs). pro-CSAs represent a family of reagents distinct from the commonly used NMR chiral derivatizing reagents (where chiral auxiliaries are used to derivatize enantiomers to diastereomers) or chiral solvating agents (where chiral auxiliaries interact in an asymmetric manner with analyte enantiomers). pro-CSA methods are unique since neither pro-CSA nor NMR contains chiral factors, making the technique neutral with respect to chirality. Here, we review our recent work on this matter involving several different nominally achiral receptor molecules whose unique guest binding properties and solution characteristics (especially with regard to NMR spectroscopy) allow for the estimation of ee in the corresponding chiral guests.

Dynamics of Meso-Chiral Interconversion in a Butterfly-Shape Overcrowded Alkene Rotor Tunable by Solvent Properties

Elucidation of dynamics of molecular rotational motion is an essential part and challenging area of research. We demonstrate reversible diastereomeric interconversion of a molecular rotor composed of overcrowded butterfly-shape alkene (FDF). Its inherent dual rotatory motion (two rotors, one stator) with interconversion between two diastereomers, chiral trans-FDF and meso cis-FDF forms, has been examined in detail upon varying temperatures and solvents. The free energy profile of 180° revolution of one rotor part has a bimodal shape with unevenly positioned maxima (transition states). FDF in aromatic solvents adopts preferentially meso cis-conformation, while in non-aromatic solvents a chiral trans-conformation is more abundant owing to the solvent interactions with peripheral hexyl chains (solvophobic effect). Moderate correlations between the trans-FDF/cis-FDF ratio and solvent parameters, such as refractive index, polarizability, and viscosity were found.

Enantiomeric Excess Dependent Splitting of NMR Signal through Dynamic Chiral Inversion and Coligand Exchange in a Coordination Complex

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy cannot be used to discriminate enantiomers, and NMR resonances of enantiomeric mixtures are generally not affected by enantiomeric excess (ee). Here, we report that a coordination complex (L·2Zn·3C), where L is a salen-like prochiral ligand and C is an exchangeable acetate coligand, exhibits symmetrical splitting of one of the ¹H NMR resonances of L with the degree of splitting linearly proportional to ee of the chiral guest coligand C, 2-phenoxypropionic acid. Despite the well-defined chirality in the crystal structure of L·2Zn·3C, concurrent fast chiral inversion and coligand exchange in solution renders L·2Zn·3C the primary example of prochiral solvating agent (pro-CSA) based on a coordination complex. Notably, the NMR resonances remain split even in dilute solution due to the lack of chiral guest dissociation in the coligand exchange system. This work provides new insights into chiral transfer events in metal-ligand complexes.

Optically Pure Aziridin-2-yl Methanols as Readily Available 1H NMR Sensors for Enantiodiscrimination of α-Racemic Carboxylic Acids Containing Tertiary or Quaternary Stereogenic Centers

Enantiopure aziridin-2-yl methanols 3–7 are used as highly effective sensors for enantiodiscrimination of α-racemic carboxylic acids containing tertiary or quaternary stereogenic centers. A linear correlation between theoretical and observed % ee values for CSA-3 and enantiomerically enriched samples of mandelic acid has been observed, indicating the possible application of these compounds in the ee determination. The free NH and OH groups in 3–7 ensure good recognition.

meso-Tetraphenylporphine as a prochiral solvating agent (pro-CSA): A physicochemical study

Meso-tetraphenylporphine (TPP) can be used as a prochiral chiral solvating agent (pro-CSA) for NMR detection of enantiomeric excess (ee) of chiral organic acids, in this study 2-phenoxypropionic acid (PPA). The pro-CSA sensing mechanism is unique in that it does not depend on formation of diastereomers. Here we discuss the factors affecting construction of the calibration curves ([Formula: see text] observed linearity between induced chemical shift non-equivalency and ee) including temperature, guest exchange rate and binding strength. We have employed various NMR techniques including variable temperature NMR, titration experiments and analyses of NMR spectral line shapes. It is confirmed that optimization of ee sensing conditions is required for each TPP/acid guest pair. For the TPP/PPA host–guest system, an optimum operating temperature is -32[Formula: see text] C with an acceptable range from -28[Formula: see text] C to -50[Formula: see text] C. The upper bound is due to complete diprotonation of TPP by PPA and the lower bound is due to the limit of PPA guest exchange rate at TPP’s binding site [Formula: see text] s[Formula: see text]. These findings, typical for porphyrin-type diprotonated pro-CSAs, yields valuable insight for design of the next generation of ee sensing molecules.

Increasing the complexity of oxoporphyrinogen colorimetric sensing chromophores: N-alkylation and β-substitution

Meso-5,10,15,20-tetrakis-3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-oxocyclohexadienylideneporphyrinogen, OxP, is a versatile, highly colored chromophore derived from meso-5,10,15,20-tetrakis(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)porphyrin. It exhibits a wide range of chromogenic responses to solvents (solvatochromism), anions and acidic media (halochromism) making it potentially useful as an analytical reagent. The chromogenic responses of OxP can be modulated by varying its chemical structure, and this is reviewed here based on the introduction of substituents at central nitrogen atoms or pyrrolic [Formula: see text]-positions. OxP and its N-alkylated derivates Bn2OxP and Bn4OxP have been used to estimate acidity in non-polar solvents. Bn2OxP can also be used to determine enantiomeric excesses of chiral substances. N-alkylation has also been used to introduce higher functional groups such as porphyrins to prepare self-assembling systems. [Formula: see text]-Substitution has been used to introduce selectivity of anion interactions including towards basic anions (fluoride, cyanide) and polyoxoanions (nitrate, perchlorate, etc.). These aspects make OxP a highly adaptable tetrapyrrole molecule for sensing and other applications.

Shape-Persistent π-Conjugated Macrocycles with Aggregation-Induced Emission Property: Synthesis, Mechanofluorochromism, and Mercury(II) Detection

Shape-persistent conjugated macrocycles are fundamentally important because of their unique structure and properties. Herein, a series of π-conjugated macrocycles with a shape-persistent architecture, an adaptive backbone, and aggregation-induced emission (AIE) properties are synthesized via oxidative coupling of acetylene-terminated tetraphenylethylene precursor with a half-ring topology and following transformation from butadiynylene linkers into thienylene ones. Characterization by NMR spectroscopy and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry provided unambiguous proofs for the macrocyclic structures. In particular, the free rotation of aromatic rings in the rigid macrocyclic backbone was validated by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy, variable-temperature NMR measurements, and theoretical calculations. Moreover, these shape-persistent macrocyclic chromophores all exhibited obvious AIE phenomena and remarkable mechanofluorochromism behaviors with a red-shifted luminescence upon grinding and blue-shifted emission after solvent annealing. Also, the introduction of S atoms into the macrocyclic frameworks endowed the macrocyclic luminogen the capability to selectively detect mecury(II) ions in aqueous media among other metal ions.

Structural Modulation of Chromic Response: Effects of Binding-Site Blocking in a Conjugated Calix[4]pyrrole Chromophore

Herein, we modulate the chromic response of a highly colored tetrapyrrole macrocycle, namely, tetrakis(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-oxocyclohexadien-2,5-yl)porphyrinogen (OxP) by structural modification. N-Benzylation at the macrocyclic nitrogen atoms leads to stepwise elimination of the two calix[4]pyrrole-type binding sites of OxP and serial variation of the chromic properties of the products, double N-benzylated Bz₂OxP and tetra N-benzylated Bz₄OxP. The halochromic (response to acidity) and solvatochromic (response to solvent polarity) properties were studied by using UV/Vis spectroscopy and NMR spectroscopy in nonpolar organic solvents. Titration experiments were used to generate binding isotherms to elucidate their binding properties with difluoroacetic acid. Differences in the halochromic properties of the compounds allowed construction of a colorimetric scale of acidity in nonpolar solvents, as the compounds in the series OxP, Bz₂OxP, and Bz₄OxP are increasingly difficult to protonate but maintain their propensity to change color upon protonation. The concurrent effects of binding-site blocking and modulation of acidity sensitivity are important new aspects for the development of colorimetric indicators.

The effect of a highly twisted CC double bond on the electronic structures of 9,9′-bifluorenylidene derivatives in the ground and excited states

A highly twisted CC double bond elicits changes in the physicochemical properties of π-systems.

Synthesis and anion binding properties of porphyrins and related compounds

Over the last two decades the preparation of pyrrole-based receptors for anion recognition has attracted considerable attention. In this regard porphyrins, phthalocyanines and expanded porphyrins have been used as strong and selective receptors while the combination of those with different techniques and materials can boost their applicability in different applications as chemosensors and extracting systems. Improvements in the field, including the synthesis of this kind of compounds, can contribute to the development of efficient, cheap, and easy-to-prepare anion receptors. Extensive efforts have been made to improve the affinity and selectivity of these compounds and the continuous expansion of related research makes this chemistry even more promising. In this review, we summarize the most recent developments in anion binding studies while outlining the strategies that may be used to synthesize and functionalize these type of macrocycles.

Anion binding, electrochemistry and solvatochromism of β-brominated oxoporphyrinogens

Effects of macrocycle bromination on the structural, electrochemical and anion binding properties of 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(3,5-di-t-butyl-4-oxo-cyclohexa-2,5-dienylidene)porphyrinogen, OxP, are reported. Bromination of 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(3,5-di-t-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)-porphinatocopper(II), [T(DtBHP)P]Cu(II) yielded β-Br8OxP, which was N-alkylated to β-Br8OxPBz2 and β-Br8OxPBz4 (where Bz = 4-bromobenzyl). β-Br8OxPBz2 crystallizes in orthorhombic space group Pccn [a = 23.5535(17) Å, b = 19.3587(14) Å c = 20.9760(15) Å, V = 9564.3(12) Å3]. It has a calix[4]pyrrole-like structure with a saddle conformation and two molecules of methanol occupy a central binding site made up of the non-alkylated pyrrole N–H groups. Computational and electrochemical studies revealed widening HOMO–LUMO band gaps for the brominated compounds over the non-brominated analogues consistent with the observed hypsochromic shifts in electronic absorption spectra. Solvatochromic and chromogenic effects on anion binding were both observed for β-Br8OxP and β-Br8OxPBz2 with binding affinities of anions being greater than those observed for the corresponding OxP and OxPBz2. Colorimetric sensor studies suggest that the OxP compounds reported here are possible candidates for use in the design of optoelectronic noses for detection of anions and anionic analyte species of biological interest.

Nanoarchitectonics for Dynamic Functional Materials from Atomic-/Molecular-Level Manipulation to Macroscopic Action

Objects in all dimensions are subject to translational dynamism and dynamic mutual interactions, and the ability to exert control over these events is one of the keys to the synthesis of functional materials. For the development of materials with truly dynamic functionalities, a paradigm shift from "nanotechnology" to "nanoarchitectonics" is proposed, with the aim of design and preparation of functional materials through dynamic harmonization of atomic-/molecular-level manipulation and control, chemical nanofabrication, self-organization, and field-controlled organization. Here, various examples of dynamic functional materials are presented from the atom/molecular-level to macroscopic dimensions. These systems, including atomic switches, molecular machines, molecular shuttles, motional crystals, metal-organic frameworks, layered assemblies, gels, supramolecular assemblies of biomaterials, DNA origami, hollow silica capsules, and mesoporous materials, are described according to their various dynamic functions, which include short-term plasticity, long-term potentiation, molecular manipulation, switchable catalysis, self-healing properties, supramolecular chirality, morphological control, drug storage and release, light-harvesting, mechanochemical transduction, molecular tuning molecular recognition, hand-operated nanotechnology.

Enantiodiscrimination of carboxylic acids using the diphenylprolinol NMR chiral solvating agents

Enantiopure diphenylprolinols have been developed as effective and practical NMR chiral solvating agents for the enantiodiscrimination of diverse α-carboxylic acids.

Right handed chiral superstructures from achiral molecules: self-assembly with a twist

The induction and development of chiral supramolecular structures from hierarchical self-assembly of achiral compounds is closely related to the evolution of life and the chiral amplification found in nature. Here we show that the combination of achiral tetraphenylethene (TPE) an AIE-active luminophore bearing four long alkyl chains via amide linkage allows the entire process of induction and control of supramolecular chirality into well-defined uniform right-handed twisted superstructures via solvent composition and polarity, i.e. solvophobic effect. We showed that the degree of twist and the pitch of the ribbons can be controlled to one-handed helical structure via solvophobic effects. The twisted superstructure assembly was visualised by scanning electron microscope (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), furthermore, circular dichroism (CD) confirms used to determine controlled right-handed assembly. This controlled assembly of an AIE-active molecule can be of practical value; for example, as templates for helical crystallisation, catalysis and a chiral mechanochromic luminescent superstructure formation.

Strong circularly polarized luminescence from the supramolecular gels of an achiral gelator: tunable intensity and handedness

Although the importance of circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) materials has been widely recognized, the CPL responses of supramolecular gels are still rarely studied. Moreover, developing CPL materials based on supramolecular gels is of great significance, due to their special advantages and important applications. Herein, we report the first circularly polarized supramolecular gels self-assembled exclusively from a simple achiral C3-symmetric molecule. Most importantly, the excellent tunability of these novel CPL materials, which benefits from achiral molecular building blocks as well as the nature of supramolecular gels, has been investigated. Thus, the CPL intensity of these supramolecular gels is easily enhanced by mechanical stirring or doping chiral amines. The handedness of CPL signals is controlled by the chirality of organic amines.

Computational Study of Proton Transfer in Tautomers of 3- and 5-Hydroxypyrazole Assisted by Water

The tautomerism of 3- and 5-hydroxypyrazole is studied at the B3LYP, CCSD and G3B3 computational levels, including the gas phase, PCM-water effects, and proton transfer assisted by water molecules. To understand the propensity of tautomerization, hydrogen-bond acidity and basicity of neutral species is approached by means of correlations between donor/acceptor ability and H-bond interaction energies. Tautomerism processes are highly dependent on the solvent environment, and a significant reduction of the transition barriers upon solvation is seen. In addition, the inclusion of a single water molecule to assist proton transfer decreases the barriers between tautomers. Although the second water molecule further reduces those barriers, its effect is less appreciable than the first one. Neutral species present more stable minima than anionic and cationic species, but relatively similar transition barriers to anionic tautomers.

Chiral sensing by nonchiral tetrapyrroles

Enantiomeric excess (ee) is a measure of the purity of an enantiomer of a chiral compound with respect to the presence of the complementary enantiomer. It is an important aspect of chemistry, especially in the fields of pharmaceuticals and asymmetric catalysis. Existing methods for determination of enantiomeric excesses using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy mostly rely on special chiral reagents (auxiliaries) that form two or more diastereomeric complexes with a chiral compound. As a result of this, the NMR spectrum of each enantiomer is different, allowing the determination of enantiomeric excess. In this Account, we describe a molecular design process that has allowed us to prepare prochiral solvating agents for NMR determination of ee of a wide variety of analyte types. At the outset of this work, we initially encountered the phenomenon of NMR peak splitting in the oxoporphyrinogen (OxP) host component of a supramolecular host-guest complex, where the extent of the splitting is apparently proportional to the guests' ee. Upon closer examination of the mechanism of action, it was found that several complicating factors, including prototropic tautomerism, macrocyclic inversion (ring-flipping), and 1:2 host-guest stoichiometry, obstruct potential applications of OxP as a chiral solvating agent. By considering the molecular conformation of the OxP host, a saddle-shaped calix[4]pyrrole, we moved to study the tetraphenylporphyrin (TPP) dication since it has a similar form, and it was found that it could also be used to probe ee. However, although TPP does not suffer from disadvantageous tautomeric processes, it is still subject to macrocyclic inversion and has the additional serious disadvantage of operating for ee sensing only at depressed temperatures. The intrinsic disadvantages of the OxP and TPP systems were finally overcome by covalently modifying the OxP chromophore by regioselective N-alkylation at one face of the molecule. This procedure yields a host Bz2OxP that undergoes 1:1 host-guest interactions, cannot be protonated (and so does not suffer drawbacks due to tautomeric processes), and can interact solely through hydrogen bonding with a much wider range of analyte types, including acids, esters, amines (including amino acid derivatives), and ketones, for the determination of their ee at room temperature. Chiral sensing, in this case, can be understood by considering the breakdown of the host's symmetry when it interacts with a chiral guest under fast exchange. Furthermore, chirality discrimination (i.e., which is the major enantiomer in a sample) can be performed by addition of a small amount of one of the known enantiomers. Adaptation of a symmetrical molecule for ee sensing presents certain intrinsic advantages, including identical binding constants of each enantiomer. Our results indicate that other symmetrical molecules might also be useful as NMR probes of enantiopurity. These systems could provide insights into important chirality principles such as majority rule, intermolecular chirality transfer, and asymmetric reactions. The Bz2OxP system is also of note from the point of view that it does not rely on the formation of diastereomers.

Switching of inherent chirality driven by self-assembly

Dynamic chirality of iminoresorcin[4]arenes that originates from keto–enol tautomerisation was switched by non-covalent interactions with achiral molecules.

Bioinspired nanoarchitectonics as emerging drug delivery systems

Bioinspired nanoarchitectonics opens a new era for designing drug delivery systems.