Very Large Cooperative Effects in Heterobimetallic Titanium-Chromium Catalysts for Ethylene Polymerization/Copolymerization

Understanding Cooperativity in Homo- and Heterometallic Complexes: From Basic Concepts to Design

Cooperative effects have attracted considerable attention in recent years. These effects are ubiquitous in chemistry and biology and can govern interactions of proteins with other biomolecules, mechanisms of supramolecular recognition and polymerization, catalysis, assembly of compounds on surfaces, and physical properties such as magnetic, electronic or optical properties, e. g. Consequently, the understanding of cooperative effects can lead to a structure-property relation that can pave the way to future applications in various research areas; however, with regard to cooperative effects in homo- and heterometallic complexes, we still are at the beginning of understanding. Nevertheless, concepts to describe cooperativity of metal centers as well as methodologies to investigate and model these effects have emerged over the last years. This concept article gives an overview of these existing concepts, approaches, and strategies to understand cooperative effects in homo- and heterometallic complexes. Special emphasis is put on concepts to define cooperative effects, their quantification, as well as methods to investigate cooperative effects.

Welcoming Neighbour or Inhospitable Host? Selective Second Metal Binding in 5- and 6-Phospha-Substituted Bpy Ligands

The controlled formation of mixed-metal bimetallics was realised through use of a fac-[Re(CO)3(N,N'-bpy-P)Cl] complex bearing an exogenous 2,4,6-trioxa-1,3,5,7-tetramethyl-8-phosphaadamantane donor at the 5-position of the bpy. The introduction of gold, silver, and rhodium with appropriate secondary ligands was readily achieved from established starting materials. Restricted rotation about the C(bpy)-P bond was observed in several of the bimetallic complexes and correlated with the relative steric bulk of the second metal moiety. Related chemistry with the 6-substituted derivative proved more limited in scope with only the bimetallic Re/Au complex being isolated.

Cooperative activation of carbon-hydrogen bonds by heterobimetallic systems

The direct activation of C-H bonds has been a rich and active field of organometallic chemistry for many years. Recently, incredible progress has been made and important mechanistic insights have accelerated research. In particular, the use of heterobimetallic complexes to heterolytically activate C-H bonds across the two metal centers has seen a recent surge in interest. This perspective article aims to orient the reader in this fast moving field, highlight recent progress, give design considerations for further research and provide an optimistic outlook on the future of catalytic C-H functionalization with heterobimetallic complexes.

Coplanar binuclear group 4 post-metallocene complexes supported by chelating μ-(σ2-aryl) ligands: characterisation and olefin polymerisation catalysis

The report concerns expansion of the previously developed M-[O,N,C] [pyridine-2-phenolate-6-(σ-aryl)] catalyst system into rigid, coplanar bimetallic assemblies, which afford metal-metal distances that are predetermined yet amenable for cooperativity, as well as locked-in "syn" orientation of binding sites that offer the same direction of access for substrates. The binuclear complexes are generated in a regioselective manner to yield para hydrogen atoms (not ortho) at the central μ-aryl moiety, and have been characterised by multinuclear NMR spectroscopy. The "anti" (showing opposite directions of access) and mononuclear analogues have also been prepared for comparison purposes. Six syn-type bimetallic derivatives of Ti, Zr and Hf have been characterised by X-ray crystallography, to reveal metal-metal separations of 6.3-6.7 Å. For ethylene and ethylene/1-octene polymerisation reactions in conjunction with trityl borate, the syn-Ti2 catalysts display superior efficiencies and produced polymers with higher Mw values than for the anti and mono-Ti congeners, thus indicating the possibility of favourable enchainment interactions and cooperative reactivity.

Catalysis of Synergistic Reactions by Host-Guest Assemblies: Reductive Carbonylation of Nitrobenzenes

Numerous chemical transformations require two or more catalytically active sites that act in a concerted manner; nevertheless, designing heterogeneous catalysts with such multiple functionalities remains an overwhelming challenge. Herein, it is shown that by the integration of acidic flexible polymers and Pd-metallated covalent organic framework (COF) hosts, the merits of both catalytically active sites can be utilized to realize heterogeneous synergistic catalysis that are active in the conversion of nitrobenzenes to carbamates via reductive carbonylation. The concentrated catalytically active species in the nanospace force two catalytic components into proximity, thereby enhancing the cooperativity between the acidic species and Pd species to facilitate synergistic catalysis. The resulting host-guest assemblies constitute more efficient systems than the corresponding physical mixtures and the homogeneous counterparts. Furthermore, this system enables easy access to a family of important derivatives such as herbicides and polyurethane monomers and can be integrated with other COFs, showing promising results. This study utilizes host-guest assembly as a versatile tool for the fabrication of multifunctional catalysts with enhanced cooperativity between different catalytic species.

Added Complexity!-Mechanistic Aspects of Heterobimetallic Complexes for Application in Homogeneous Catalysis

Inspired by multimetallic assemblies and their role in enzyme catalysis, chemists have developed a plethora of heterobimetallic complexes for application in homogeneous catalysis. Starting with small heterobimetallic complexes with σ-donating and π-accepting ligands, such as N-heterocyclic carbene and carbonyl ligands, more and more complex systems have been developed over the past two decades. These systems can show a significant increase in catalytic activity compared with their monometallic counterparts. This increase can be attributed to new reaction pathways enabled by the presence of a second metal center in the active catalyst. This review focuses on mechanistic aspects of heterobimetallic complexes in homogeneous catalysis. Depending on the type of interaction of the second metal with the substrates, heterobimetallic complexes can be subdivided into four classes. Each of these classes is illustrated with multiple examples, showcasing the versatility of both, the types of interactions possible, and the reactions accessible.

Dinuclear Group 4 Metal Complexes Bearing Anthracene-Bridged Bifunctional Amido-Ether Ligands: Remarkable Metal Effect and Cooperativity toward Ethylene/1-Octene Copolymerization

Two types of bifunctional amido-ether ligands (syn-L and anti-L) with the rigid anthracene skeleton were designed to support dinuclear group 4 metal complexes. All organic ligands and organometallic complexes (syn-M₂ and anti-M₂; M = Hf, Zr, and Ti) were fully characterized by ¹H and ¹³C NMR spectroscopies and elemental analyses. The anti-Hf₂ complex showed two confirmations at room temperature with C₂-symmetry or S₂-symmetry that can inter-exchange, as indicated by VT NMR, while only a C₂-symmetric isomer was observed for syn-Hf₂ complex at room temperature. However, for Zr and Ti analogues, both syn and anti complexes exhibited only one conformation at room temperature. The molecular structures of complexes syn-Hf₂, anti-Hf₂, and syn-Ti₂ in the solid state were further determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, revealing the distances between two metal centers in syn-M₂ from 7.138 Å (syn-Ti₂) to 7.321 Å (syn-Hf₂) but a much farther separation in anti-M₂ (8.807 Å in C₂-symmetric anti-Hf₂). The mononuclear complex (2-CH₃O-C₆H₄-N-C₁₄H₉)Zr(NMe₂)₃ (mono-Zr₁) was also prepared for control experiments. In the presence of alkyl aluminum (AlEt₃) as the alkylating agent and trityl borate ([Ph₃C][B(C₆F₅)₄]) as the co-catalyst, all metal complexes were tested for copolymerization of ethylene with 1-octene at high temperature (130 °C). The preliminary polymerization results revealed that the activity was highly dependent upon the nature of metal centers, and syn-Zr₂ showed the highest activity of 9600 kg(PE)·mol^-1 (Zr)·h^-1, which was about 17- and 2.2-fold higher than those of syn-Hf₂ and syn-Ti₂, respectively. Benefitting from both steric proximity and electronical interaction of two metal centers, syn-Zr₂ exhibited significant cooperativity in comparison to anti-Zr₂ and mono-Zr₁, with regard to activity and molecular weight and 1-octene incorporation of resultant copolymers.

Structural evolution of iminopyridine support for nickel/palladium catalysts in ethylene (oligo)polymerization

The interest in the late transition metal catalyst based design of new architectures of polyethylene (PE) has continuously been increasing over the last few years. The structure of these catalysts is predominantly important in controlling the morphological and architectural properties of the resulting polyethylene. Particularly, iminopyridine is a versatile bidentate support for Ni and Pd catalysts in ethylene (oligo)polymerization providing a wide variety of products ranging from volatile oligomers to ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene. Extensive structural modifications have been induced in the iminopyridine ligand through steric and electronic substitution, tuning the catalyst behavior in terms of activity and properties of the resulting polymer. Carbocyclic-fused iminopyridine and N-oxide iminopyridine are the new state of the art iminopyridine ligand designs. In this review, we aim to summarize all the developments in mononuclear iminopyridine-nickel and -palladium catalysts for ethylene (oligo)polymerization since the first report published in 1999 to present, focusing on the correlation among the pre-catalyst, co-catalyst type, thermal stability and polymer/oligomer structure. For comparison, the structural variations in the binuclear iminopyridine-nickel catalysts are also described. The detailed comparison of the structural variations in these catalysts with respect to their polymerization performance will give deep understanding in the development of new efficient catalyst designs.

Sidechain Metallopolymers with Precisely Controlled Structures: Synthesis and Application in Catalysis

Inspired by the cooperative multi-metallic activation in metalloenzyme catalysis, artificial enzymes as multi-metallic catalysts have been developed for improved kinetics and higher selectivity. Previous models about multi-metallic catalysts, such as cross-linked polymer-supported catalysts, failed to precisely control the number and location of their active sites, leading to low activity and selectivity. In recent years, metallopolymers with metals in the sidechain, also named as sidechain metallopolymers (SMPs), have attracted much attention because of their combination of the catalytic, magnetic, and electronic properties of metals with desirable mechanical and processing properties of polymeric backbones. Living and controlled polymerization techniques provide access to SMPs with precisely controlled structures, for example, controlled degree of polymerization (DP) and molecular weight dispersity (Đ), which may have excellent performance as multi-metallic catalysts in a variety of catalytic reactions. This review will cover the recent advances about SMPs, especially on their synthesis and application in catalysis. These tailor-made SMPs with metallic catalytic centers can precisely control the number and location of their active sites, exhibiting high catalytic efficiency.

Modular Organoboron Catalysts Enable Transformations with Unprecedented Reactivity

ConspectusElectron-deficient boron-based catalysts with metal-free but metallomimetic characteristics provide a versatile platform for chemical transformations. However, their catalytic performance is usually lower than that of the corresponding metal-based catalysts. Furthermore, many elaborate organoboron compounds are produced via time-consuming multistep syntheses with low yields, presenting a formidable challenge for large-scale applications of these catalysts. Given this context, the development of organoboron catalysts with the combined advantages of high efficiency and easy preparation is of critical importance.Therefore, we envisioned that the construction of a dynamic Lewis multicore system (DLMCS) by integrating the Lewis acidic boron center(s) and a Lewis basic ammonium salt in one molecule would be particularly efficient for on-demand applications because of the intramolecular synergistic effect. This Account summarizes our recent efforts in developing modular organoboron catalysts with unprecedented activities for several chemical transformations. A series of mono-, di-, tri-, and tetranuclear organoboron catalysts was readily designed and prepared in nearly quantitative yields over two steps using commercially available feedstocks. Notably, these catalysts can be modularly tailored by fine control over the electrophilic property of the Lewis acidic boron center(s), electronic and steric effects of the electropositive ammonium cation, linker length between the boron center and the ammonium cation, the number of boron centers, and the nucleophilic anion. This modular design allows systematic manipulation of the reactivity and efficacy of the catalysts, thus optimizing suitable catalysts for versatile chemical transformations. These include the coupling of CO₂ and epoxides, copolymerization of CO₂ and epoxides, ring-opening polymerization (ROP) of epoxides, and ring-opening copolymerization (ROCOP) of epoxides and cyclic anhydrides.The utilization of mononuclear organoboron catalysts provided a turnover frequency of 11050 h^-1 for the CO₂/propylene oxide coupling reaction, an unprecedented efficiency of 5.0 kg of polymer/g of catalyst for the copolymerization of CO₂ and cyclohexene oxide, and a record-breaking catalytic efficiency of 7.4 kg of polymer/g of catalyst for the ROCOP of epoxides with cyclic anhydrides. A turnover number of 56500 was observed at a catalyst loading of 10 ppm for the ROP of epoxides using the dinuclear catalysts. The tetranuclear organoboron catalysts realized the previously intractable task of the copolymerization of CO₂ and epichlorohydrin, producing poly(chloropropylene carbonate) with the highest molecular weight of 36.5 kg/mol reported to date.Furthermore, the study revealed that the interaction between the dynamic Lewis multicore, that is, the intramolecular synergistic effect between the boron center(s) and the quaternary ammonium salt, plays a key role in mediating the catalytic activity and selectivity. This was based on investigations of the crystal structures of the catalysts, key intermediates, reaction kinetics, and density functional theory calculations. The modular tactics for the construction of organoboron catalysts presented in this Account should inspire more advanced catalyst designs.

Palladium Goes First: A Neutral Asymmetric Heteroditopic N,P Ligand Forming Pd-3d Heterobimetallic Complexes

A facile two-step synthesis of bis(1-methylhydrazinyl)pyrimidine from pyridine-2-carbaldehyde and 2-diphenylphosphanylbenzaldehyde gave access to the new asymmetric ligand 1. The phosphane selectively guides Pd^II into the softer tridentate N,N,P pocket, yielding monometallic complex 2. A second reaction with a 3d transition metal complex precursor (groups 7 to 12) fills the vacant N,N,N pocket and thus provides a variety of heterobimetallic complexes of the type Pd^II/M^II (M = Mn (3), Fe (4), Co (5), Ni (6), Cu (7), Zn (8)). Single-crystal X-ray diffraction studies were performed for all complexes. The assembly of μ₂-chlorido-bridged dimers was observed for complexes 5-7 in the solid state, while DOSY NMR experiments have shown that 5-7 are unbridged monomers in solution. As an exception, Fe^II prefers to form the homoleptic meridional complex [Fe{PdCl(1)}₂](OTf)₄ (4). The electrochemical behavior and the effective magnetic moment in solution were investigated for all complexes by cyclic voltammetry and Evans method, respectively. Experimental UV/vis results were interpreted by performing TD-DFT calculations on 1, 2, and 3.

Synthesis of Ethylene/1-Octene Copolymers with Ultrahigh Molecular Weights by Zr and Hf Complexes Bearing Bidentate NN Ligands with the Camphyl Linker

Ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) is a class of high-performance engineering plastics, exhibiting a unique set of properties and applications. Although many advances have been achieved in recent years, the synthesis of UHMWPE is still a great challenge. In this contribution, a series of zirconium and hafnium complexes, [2,6-(R1)2-4-R2-C6H2-N-C(camphyl)=C(camphyl)-N-2,6-(R1)2-4-R2-C6H2]MMe2(THF) (1-Zr: R1 = Me, R2 = H, M = Zr; 2-Zr: R1 = Me, R2 = Me, M = Zr; 1-Hf: R1 = Me, R2 = H, M = Hf; 2-Hf: R1 = Me, R2 = Me, M = Hf), bearing bidentate NN ligands with the bulky camphyl backbone were synthesized by the stoichiometric reactions of α-diimine ligands with MMe4 (M = Hf or Zr). All Zr and Hf metal complexes were analyzed using 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy, and the molecular structures of complexes 1-Zr and 1-Hf were determined by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, revealing that the original α-diimine ligand was selectively reduced into the ene-diamido form and generated an 1,3-diaza-2-metallocyclopentene ring in the metal complexes. Zr complexes 1-Zr and 2-Zr showed moderate activity (up to 388 kg(PE)·mol−1(M)·h−1), poor copolymerization ability, but unprecedented molecular weight capability toward ethylene/1-octene copolymerization. Therefore, copolymers with ultrahigh molecular weights (>600 or 337 × 104 g∙mol−1) were successfully synthesized by 1-Zr or 2-Zr, respectively, with the borate cocatalyst [Ph3C][B(C6F5)4]. Surprisingly, Hf complexes 1-Hf and 2-Hf showed negligible activity under otherwise identical conditions, revealing the great influence of metal centers on catalytic performances.

Cooperative Heterometallic Catalysts for Lactide Ring-Opening Polymerization: Combining Aluminum with Divalent Metals

While homometallic (salen)Al catalysts display excellent performance in lactide ring-opening polymerization (ROP), heterometallic (salen)Al complexes have yet to be reported. Herein, we describe four heterobimetallic (salen)Al catalysts and show that the choice of the heterometal is key. Cooperative Al/Mg and Al/Zn combinations improved the catalyst activity by a factor of up to 11 compared to the mono-Al analogue, whereas the mono-Mg and mono-Zn analogues were completely inactive. In contrast, Al/Li and Al/Ca heterocombinations stunted the polymerization rate. Kinetic and computational studies suggest that Al/Mg and Al/Zn cooperativity arises from the close intermetallic proximity facilitating chloride bridging (thus enhancing initiation), which promotes a rigid square pyramidal geometry around the Al center and further increases the available monomer coordination sites. This work also translates the use of ab initio molecular dynamics calculations to ROP, introducing a useful method of investigating catalyst flexibility and revealing that ligand strain and molecular rigidity can enhance heterometallic catalyst performance.

Heterometallic coordination polymers as heterogeneous electrocatalysts

Heterometallic coordination polymers have been rapidly developed as heterogeneous electrocatalysts. This review highlights the synthesis strategies of these polymers and the relationships between structures and electrocatalytic performances.

Custom-made polar monomers utilized in nickel and palladium promoted olefin copolymerization

In this review, the functions of custom-made polar monomers are insightfully emphasized in the preparation of functional polyolefins.

Computational Approach to Molecular Catalysis by 3d Transition Metals: Challenges and Opportunities

Computational chemistry provides a versatile toolbox for studying mechanistic details of catalytic reactions and holds promise to deliver practical strategies to enable the rational in silico catalyst design. The versatile reactivity and nontrivial electronic structure effects, common for systems based on 3d transition metals, introduce additional complexity that may represent a particular challenge to the standard computational strategies. In this review, we discuss the challenges and capabilities of modern electronic structure methods for studying the reaction mechanisms promoted by 3d transition metal molecular catalysts. Particular focus will be placed on the ways of addressing the multiconfigurational problem in electronic structure calculations and the role of expert bias in the practical utilization of the available methods. The development of density functionals designed to address transition metals is also discussed. Special emphasis is placed on the methods that account for solvation effects and the multicomponent nature of practical catalytic systems. This is followed by an overview of recent computational studies addressing the mechanistic complexity of catalytic processes by molecular catalysts based on 3d metals. Cases that involve noninnocent ligands, multicomponent reaction systems, metal-ligand and metal-metal cooperativity, as well as modeling complex catalytic systems such as metal-organic frameworks are presented. Conventionally, computational studies on catalytic mechanisms are heavily dependent on the chemical intuition and expert input of the researcher. Recent developments in advanced automated methods for reaction path analysis hold promise for eliminating such human-bias from computational catalysis studies. A brief overview of these approaches is presented in the final section of the review. The paper is closed with general concluding remarks.

Location matters: cooperativity of catalytic partners in porous organic polymers for enhanced CO2 transformation

Functionalities with corrected inter-site distance in porous materials enable them to work in a concerted manner.

Chromium complexes supported by the bidentate PN ligands: synthesis, characterization and application for ethylene polymerization

Chromium-based complexes are among the most important catalysts in the field of ethylene polymerization and oligomerization. Heterogeneous Cr Phillips catalysts account for more than one-third of the commercialized high density polyethylene (HDPE). In this contribution, chromium complexes, LCrCl3 (Cr1-Cr4: L = 2,6-R1-4-R2-C6H2-N[double bond, length as m-dash]CH-C6H4-2-PPh2; Cr1: R1 = H, R2 = H; Cr2: R1 = Me, R2 = H; Cr3: R1 = iPr, R2 = H; Cr4: R1 = Ph2CH, R2 = iPr), have been synthesized and characterized by elemental analysis, ESI and IR spectroscopy. The molecular structures of Cr3 and Cr4 are defined by X-ray diffraction, revealing a distorted octahedral geometry around the chromium center in both structures. In the presence of an aluminum cocatalyst, complexes Cr1-Cr4 show moderate to high activities toward ethylene polymerization. The nature of the catalysts and various reaction conditions, such as the nature and the amount of cocatalyst, reaction time and temperature, are investigated in detail. The results show that the title complexes have good thermal stability and the substituents on the ligands significantly affect the catalytic properties. Particularly, complex Cr4 can produce HDPE with a high molecular weight up to 68.3 × 104 g mol-1 due to the suppression of the chain transfer/termination by the introduction of bulky Ph2CH groups.