CO desorption from a catalytic surface: elucidation of the role of steps by velocity-selected residence time measurements

Spiers Memorial Lecture: New directions in molecular scattering

The field of molecular scattering is reviewed as it pertains to gas-gas as well as gas-surface chemical reaction dynamics. We emphasize the importance of collaboration of experiment and theory, from which new directions of research are being pursued on increasingly complex problems. We review both experimental and theoretical advances that provide the modern toolbox available to molecular-scattering studies. We distinguish between two classes of work. The first involves simple systems and uses experiment to validate theory so that from the validated theory, one may learn far more than could ever be measured in the laboratory. The second class involves problems of great complexity that would be difficult or impossible to understand without a partnership of experiment and theory. Key topics covered in this review include crossed-beams reactive scattering and scattering at extremely low energies, where quantum effects dominate. They also include scattering from surfaces, reactive scattering and kinetics at surfaces, and scattering work done at liquid surfaces. The review closes with thoughts on future promising directions of research.

Time-resolved surface reaction kinetics in the pressure gap

We extend the use of our recently developed Near-Ambient Pressure Velocity Map Imaging (NAP-VMI) technique to study the kinetics and dynamics of catalytic reactions in the pressure gap. As an example, we show that NAP-VMI combined with molecular beam surface scattering allows the direct measurement of time- and velocity-resolved kinetics of the scattering and oxidation of CO on the Pd(110) surface with oxygen pressures at the surface up to 1 × 10-5 mbar, where different metastable surface structures form. Our results show that the c(2 × 4) oxide structure formed at low O2 pressure is highly active for CO oxidation. The velocity distribution of the CO2 products shows the presence of two reaction channels, which we attribute to reactions starting from two distinct but rapidly interconverting CO binding sites. The effective CO oxidation reaction activation energy is Er = (1.0 ± 0.13) eV. The CO2 production is suppressed at higher O2 pressure due to the number of antiphase domain boundaries increasing, and the missing row sites are filled by O-atoms at O2 pressures approaching 1 × 10-6 mbar. Filling of these sites by O-atoms reduces the CO surface lifetime, meaning the surface oxide is inactive for CO oxidation. We briefly outline further developments planned for the NAP-VMI and its application to other types of experiments.

Nonthermal Plasma Activation of Adsorbates: The Case of CO on Pt

Nonthermal plasmas provide a unique approach to electrically driven heterogeneous catalytic processes. Despite much interest from the community, fundamental activation pathways in these processes remain poorly understood. Here, we investigate how exposure to a nonthermal plasma sustained in an argon nonreactive atmosphere affects the desorption of carbon monoxide (CO) from platinum nanoparticles. Temperature-programmed desorption measurements indicate that the plasma reduces the effective binding energy (BE) of CO to Pt surfaces by as much as ∼0.3 eV, with the reduction in the BE scaling linearly with the plasma density. We find that the effective CO BE is most strongly reduced for under-coordinated sites (steps and edges) compared to well-coordinated sites (terraces). Density functional theory calculations suggest that this is due to plasma-induced charging and electric fields at the catalyst surface, which preferentially affect under-coordinated sites. This study provides direct experimental evidence of plasma-induced nonthermal activation of the adsorbate-catalyst couple.

A theory of phonon-induced friction on molecular adsorbates

In this manuscript, we provide a general theory for how surface phonons couple to molecular adsorbates. Our theory maps the extended dynamics of a surface's atomic vibrational motions to a generalized Langevin equation, and by doing so captures these dynamics in a single quantity: the non-Markovian friction. The different frequency components of this friction are the phonon modes of the surface slab weighted by their coupling to the adsorbate degrees of freedom. Using this formalism, we demonstrate that physisorbed species couple primarily to acoustic phonons while chemisorbed species couple to dispersionless local vibrations. We subsequently derive equations for phonon-adjusted reaction rates using transition state theory and demonstrate that these corrections improve agreement with experimental results for CO desorption rates from Pt(111).

Bond Selective Photochemistry at Metal Nanoparticle Surfaces: CO Desorption from Pt and Pd

The use of visible photon fluxes to influence catalytic reactions on metal nanoparticle surfaces has attracted attention based on observations of reaction mechanisms and selectivity not observed under equilibrium heating. These observations suggest that photon fluxes can selectively impact the rates of certain elementary steps, creating nonequilibrium energy distributions among various reaction pathways. However, quantitative studies validating these hypotheses on metal nanoparticle surfaces are lacking. We examine the influence of continuous wave visible photon fluxes on the CO desorption rates from 1 to 2 nm diameter Pt and Pd nanoparticle surfaces supported on γ-Al2O3. Temperature-programmed desorption measurements quantified via diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy demonstrate that visible photon fluxes significantly enhanced the rate of CO desorption from Pt nanoparticles in a wavelength-dependent manner. 440 nm photons most efficiently promoted CO desorption from Pt nanoparticle surfaces, aligning with the excitation energy for the interfacial electronic transition within the Pt-CO bond. Conversely, visible photon fluxes had no measurable influence on CO desorption rates from Pd nanoparticle surfaces after accounting for photon-induced heating. Density functional theory calculations demonstrate that the Pt-CO bond exhibits a narrower LUMO resonance, stronger coupling between the photoexcitation and forces induced on the metal-C bond, and vibrational energy dissipation that more effectively couples to desorption as compared to Pd-CO. These results demonstrate the specificity photons provide in facilitating chemical reactions on metal nanoparticle surfaces and substantiate the idea that photon fluxes can steer processes and outcomes of catalytic reactions in ways not achievable by equilibrium heating.

Unraveling CO adsorption behaviors and its poisoning effects on ZrCo surface

Theoretical calculations are performed to elucidate the adsorption behaviors and poisoning effects of CO gas on the ZrCo surface, which drastically limits its application in hydrogen isotopic storage. Specifically, the ionic Zr-Co bond on the surface leads to unique CO adsorption structures on different sites. The CO molecule tends to prefer a tilted adsorption configuration on the Co-Co bridge site. The electronic structures, charge distributions, and bonding characteristics are further explored to study the CO adsorption properties, which obey the electron density donation and back-donation mechanism. For different CO coverages, the stepwise adsorption energies of CO increase with the increasing of coverage, reaching the saturated coverage at nCO = 11. Then, the effects of temperature and partial pressure on CO coverage are evaluated using atomic thermodynamics. The computed phase diagram shows that the ZrCo(110) surface has a stable coverage of nCO = 6 at ambient temperature under ultrahigh vacuum conditions. The pre-adsorbed CO molecules lead to the charge redistribution and the d-band center downshift on the surface, which significantly affect hydrogen adsorption and dissociation. Our results provide insights into the poisoning mechanisms of the impurity gas on ZrCo alloys, which can be beneficial for designing high-performance ZrCo-based alloys with improved poisoning tolerance.

First-principles surface reaction rates by ring polymer molecular dynamics and neural network potential: role of anharmonicity and lattice motion

Elementary gas-surface processes are essential steps in heterogeneous catalysis. A predictive understanding of catalytic mechanisms remains challenging due largely to difficulties in accurately characterizing the kinetics of such steps. Experimentally, thermal rates for elementary surface reactions can now be measured using a novel velocity imaging technique, providing a stringent testing ground for ab initio rate theories. Here, we propose to combine ring polymer molecular dynamics (RPMD) rate theory with state-of-the-art first-principles-determined neural network potential to calculate surface reaction rates. Taking NO desorption from Pd(111) as an example, we show that the harmonic approximation and the neglect of lattice motion in the commonly-used transition state theory overestimates and underestimates the entropy change during the desorption process, respectively, leading to opposite errors in rate coefficient predictions and artificial error cancellations. Including anharmonicity and lattice motion, our results reveal a generally neglected surface entropy change due to significant local structural change during desorption and obtain the right answer for the right reasons. Although quantum effects are found to be less important in this system, the proposed approach establishes a more reliable theoretical benchmark for accurately predicting the kinetics of elementary gas-surface processes.

Adsorption and Absorption Energies of Hydrogen with Palladium

Thermal recombinative desorption rates of HD on Pd(111) and Pd(332) are reported from transient kinetic experiments performed between 523 and 1023 K. A detailed kinetic model accurately describes the competition between recombination of surface-adsorbed hydrogen and deuterium atoms and their diffusion into the bulk. By fitting the model to observed rates, we derive the dissociative adsorption energies (E _0, ads ^H₂ = 0.98 eV; E _0, ads ^D₂ = 1.00 eV; E _0, ads ^HD = 0.99 eV) as well as the classical dissociative binding energy ϵ_ads = 1.02 ± 0.03 eV, which provides a benchmark for electronic structure theory. In a similar way, we obtain the classical energy required to move an H or D atom from the surface to the bulk (ϵ_sb = 0.46 ± 0.01 eV) and the isotope specific energies, E _0, sb ^H = 0.41 eV and E _0, sb ^D = 0.43 eV. Detailed insights into the process of transient bulk diffusion are obtained from kinetic Monte Carlo simulations.

Two-Dimensional Ultrathin Silica Films

Two-dimensional (2D) ultrathin silica films have the potential to reach technological importance in electronics and catalysis. Several well-defined 2D-silica structures have been synthesized so far. The silica bilayer represents a 2D material with SiO₂ stoichiometry. It consists of precisely two layers of tetrahedral [SiO₄] building blocks, corner connected via oxygen bridges, thus forming a self-saturated silicon dioxide sheet with a thickness of ∼0.5 nm. Inspired by recent successful preparations and characterizations of these 2D-silica model systems, scientists now can forge novel concepts for realistic systems, particularly by atomic-scale studies with the most powerful and advanced surface science techniques and density functional theory calculations. This Review provides a solid introduction to these recent developments, breakthroughs, and implications on ultrathin 2D-silica films, including their atomic/electronic structures, chemical modifications, atom/molecule adsorptions, and catalytic reactivity properties, which can help to stimulate further investigations and understandings of these fundamentally important 2D materials.

The Barrier for CO2 Functionalization to Formate on Hydrogenated Pt

Understanding heterogeneous catalysis is based on knowing the energetic stability of adsorbed reactants, intermediates, and products as well as the energetic barriers separating them. We report an experimental determination of the barrier to CO₂ functionalization to form bidentate formate on a hydrogenated Pt surface and the corresponding reaction energy. This determination was possible using velocity resolved kinetics, which simultaneously provides information about both the dynamics and rates of surface chemical reactions. In these experiments, a pulse of isotopically labeled formic acid (DCOOH) doses the Pt surface rapidly forming bidentate formate (DCO*O*). We then record the (much slower) rate of decomposition of DCO*O* to form adsorbed D* and gas phase CO₂. We establish the reaction mechanism by dosing with O₂ to form adsorbed O*, which efficiently converts H* or D* to gas phase water. H₂O is formed immediately reflecting rapid loss of the acidic proton associated with formation of formate, while D₂O formation proceeds more slowly and on the same time scale as the CO₂ production. The temperature dependence of the reaction rate yields an activation energy that reflects the energy of the transition state with respect to DCO*O*. The derived heat of formation for DCO*O* on Pt(111) agrees well with results of microcalorimetry. The maximum release of translational energy of the formed CO₂ provides a measure of the energy of the transition state with respect to the products and the barrier to the reverse process, functionalization of CO₂. The comparison between the results on Pt(111) and Pt(332) shows that the barrier for CO₂ functionalization is reduced by the presence of steps. The approach taken here could provide a method to optimize catalysts for CO₂ functionalization.

NO Binding Energies to and Diffusion Barrier on Pd Obtained with Velocity-Resolved Kinetics

We report nitric oxide (NO) desorption rates from Pd(111) and Pd(332) surfaces measured with velocity-resolved kinetics. The desorption rates at the surface temperatures from 620 to 800 K span more than 3 orders of magnitude, and competing processes, like dissociation, are absent. Applying transition state theory (TST) to model experimental data leads to the NO binding energy E ₀ = 1.766 ± 0.024 eV and diffusion barrier D _T = 0.29 ± 0.11 eV on the (111) terrace and the stabilization energy for (110)-steps ΔE _ST = 0.060_-0.030 ^+0.015 eV. These parameters provide valuable benchmarks for theory.

Measuring Transient Reaction Rates from Nonstationary Catalysts

Up to now, methods for measuring rates of reactions on catalysts required long measurement times involving signal averaging over many experiments. This imposed a requirement that the catalyst return to its original state at the end of each experiment—a complete reversibility requirement. For real catalysts, fulfilling the reversibility requirement is often impossible—catalysts under reaction conditions may change their chemical composition and structure as they become activated or while they are being poisoned through use. It is therefore desirable to develop high-speed methods where transient rates can be quickly measured while catalysts are changing. In this work, we present velocity-resolved kinetics using high-repetition-rate pulsed laser ionization and high-speed ion imaging detection. The reaction is initiated by a single molecular beam pulse incident at the surface, and the product formation rate is observed by a sequence of pulses produced by a high-repetition-rate laser. Ion imaging provides the desorbing product flux (reaction rate) as a function of reaction time for each laser pulse. We demonstrate the principle of this approach by rate measurements on two simple reactions: CO desorption from and CO oxidation on the 332 facet of Pd. This approach overcomes the time-consuming scanning of the delay between CO and laser pulses needed in past experiments and delivers a data acquisition rate that is 10–1000 times higher. We are able to record kinetic traces of CO₂ formation while a CO beam titrates oxygen atoms from an O-saturated surface. This approach also allows measurements of reaction rates under diffusion-controlled conditions.

Following the microscopic pathway to adsorption through chemisorption and physisorption wells

Adsorption involves molecules colliding at the surface of a solid and losing their incidence energy by traversing a dynamical pathway to equilibrium. The interactions responsible for energy loss generally include both chemical bond formation (chemisorption) and nonbonding interactions (physisorption). In this work, we present experiments that revealed a quantitative energy landscape and the microscopic pathways underlying a molecule’s equilibration with a surface in a prototypical system: CO adsorption on Au(111). Although the minimum energy state was physisorbed, initial capture of the gas-phase molecule, dosed with an energetic molecular beam, was into a metastable chemisorption state. Subsequent thermal decay of the chemisorbed state led molecules to the physisorption minimum. We found, through detailed balance, that thermal adsorption into both binding states was important at all temperatures.

Fundamental mechanisms for molecular energy conversion and chemical reactions at surfaces

The dream of theoretical surface chemistry is to predict the outcome of reactions in order to find the ideal catalyst for a certain application. Having a working ab initio theory in hand would not only enable these predictions but also provide insights into the mechanisms of surface reactions. The development of theoretical models can be assisted by experimental studies providing benchmark data. Though for some reactions a quantitative agreement between experimental observations and theoretical calculations has been achieved, theoretical surface chemistry is in general still far away from gaining predictive power. Here we review recent experimental developments towards the understanding of surface reactions. It is demonstrated how quantum-state resolved scattering experiments on reactive and nonreactive systems can be used to test front-running theoretical approaches. Two challenges for describing dynamics at surfaces are addressed: nonadiabaticity in diatomic molecule surface scattering and the increasing system size when observing and describing the dynamics of polyatomic molecules at surfaces. Finally recent experimental studies on reactive systems are presented. It is shown how elementary steps in a complex surface reaction can be revealed experimentally.

Origin of Thermal and Hyperthermal CO2 from CO Oxidation on Pt Surfaces: The Role of Post-Transition-State Dynamics, Active Sites, and Chemisorbed CO2

The post-transition-state dynamics in CO oxidation on Pt surfaces are investigated using DFT-based ab initio molecular dynamics simulations. While the initial CO₂ formed on a terrace site on Pt(111) desorbs directly, it is temporarily trapped in a chemisorption well on a Pt(332) step site. These two reaction channels thus produce CO₂ with hyperthermal and thermal velocities with drastically different angular distributions, in agreement with recent experiments (Nature, 2018, 558, 280-283). The chemisorbed CO₂ is formed by electron transfer from the metal to the adsorbate, resulting in a bent geometry. While chemisorbed CO₂ on Pt(111) is unstable, it is stable by 0.2 eV on a Pt(332) step site. This helps explain why newly formed CO₂ produced at step sites desorbs with far lower translational energies than those formed at terraces. This work shows that steps and other defects could be potentially important in finding optimal conditions for the chemical activation and dissociation of CO₂ .

Electron transfer mediates vibrational relaxation of CO in collisions with Ag(111)

We report vibrational relaxation probabilities for CO(v = 17) scattered from Ag(111) and compare our results to studies on other molecule–surface systems, which indicates a clear dependence of the relaxation probability on the work function of the surface and the electron binding energy of the molecule.

Ion and velocity map imaging for surface dynamics and kinetics

We describe a new instrument that uses ion imaging to study molecular beam-surface scattering and surface desorption kinetics, allowing independent determination of both residence times on the surface and scattering velocities of desorbing molecules. This instrument thus provides the capability to derive true kinetic traces, i.e., product flux versus residence time, and allows dramatically accelerated data acquisition compared to previous molecular beam kinetics methods. The experiment exploits non-resonant multiphoton ionization in the near-IR using a powerful 150-fs laser pulse, making detection more general than previous experiments using resonance enhanced multiphoton ionization. We demonstrate the capabilities of the new instrument by examining the desorption kinetics of CO on Pd(111) and Pt(111) and obtain both pre-exponential factors and activation energies of desorption. We also show that the new approach is compatible with velocity map imaging.

Efficient electron-promoted desorption of benzene from water ice surfaces

We study the desorption of benzene from solid water surfaces during irradiation of ultrathin solid films with low energy electrons.

Steps or Terraces? Dynamics of Aromatic Hydrocarbons Adsorbed at Vicinal Metal Surfaces

The study of how molecules adsorb, diffuse, interact, and desorb from imperfect surfaces is essential for a complete understanding of elementary surface processes under relevant pressure and temperature conditions. Here we use first-principles calculations to study the adsorption of benzene and naphthalene on a vicinal Cu(443) surface with the aim to gain insight into the behavior of aromatic hydrocarbons on realistic surfaces at a finite temperature. Upon strong adsorption at step edges at a low temperature, the molecules then migrate from the step to the (111) terraces, where they can freely diffuse parallel to the step edge. This migration happens at temperatures well below the onset of desorption, suggesting a more complex dynamical picture than previously proposed from temperature-programed desorption studies. The increase of the adsorption strength observed in experiments for Cu(443) when compared to Cu(111) is explained by a stronger long-range van der Waals attraction between the hydrocarbons and the step edges of the Cu(443) surface. Our calculations highlight the need for time-resolved experimental studies to fully understand the dynamics of molecular layers on surfaces.

Face the Edges: Catalytic Active Sites of Nanomaterials

Edges are special sites in nanomaterials. The atoms residing on the edges have different environments compared to those in other parts of a nanomaterial and, therefore, they may have different properties. Here, recent progress in nanomaterial fields is summarized from the viewpoint of the edges. Typically, edge sites in MoS2 or metals, other than surface atoms, can perform as active centers for catalytic reactions, so the method to enhance performance lies in the optimization of the edge structures. The edges of multicomponent interfaces present even more possibilities to enhance the activities of nanomaterials. Nanoframes and ultrathin nanowires have similarities to conventional edges of nanoparticles, the application of which as catalysts can help to reduce the use of costly materials. Looking beyond this, the edge structures of graphene are also essential for their properties. In short, the edge structure can influence many properties of materials.