Chemical Modification of Cysteine Mutants of Subtilisin Bacillus lentus Can Create Better Catalysts Than the Wild-Type Enzyme

α-Vinyl azide–cysteine click coupling reaction enabled bioorthogonal peptide/protein modification

α-Alkyl and α-aryl vinyl azides were found to be able to couple with cysteine-derived alkyl thiols chemoselectively under mild conditions, providing the corresponding β-ketosulfides with simultaneous extrusion of N2 and ammonia.

Glycosyl disulfides: importance, synthesis and application to chemical and biological systems

This review explores methodologies for the preparation of glycosyl disulfides, their utility as intermediates in carbohydrate synthesis, and evaluates their biological impact in glycoscience and beyond.

Carbonic anhydrase modification for carbon management

Carbonic anhydrase modification (chemical and biological) is an attractive strategy for its diverse application to accelerate the absorption of CO₂ from a flue gas with improved activity and stability. This article reports various possibilities of CA modification using metal-ligand homologous chemistry, cross-linking agents, and residue- and group-specific and genetic modifications, and assesses their role in carbon management. Chemically modified carbonic anhydrase is able to improve the absorption of carbon dioxide from a gas stream into mediation compounds with enhanced sequestration and mineral formation. Genetically modified CA polypeptide can also increase carbon dioxide conversion. Chemical modification of CA can be categorized in terms of (i) residue-specific modification (involves protein-ligand interaction in terms of substitution/addition) and group-specific modifications (based on the functional groups of the target CA). For every sustainable change, there should be no/limited toxic or immunological response. In this review, several CA modification pathways and biocompatibility rules are proposed as a theoretical support for emerging research in this area.

Concepts of Catalysis in Site-Selective Protein Modifications

The manipulation and modulation of biomolecules has the potential to herald new modes of Biology and Medicine through chemical “editing”. Key to the success of such processes will be the selectivities, reactivities and efficiencies that may be brought to bear in bond-formation and bond-cleavage in a benign manner. In this Perspective, we use select examples, primarily from our own research, to examine the current opportunities, limitations and the particular potential of metal-mediated processes as exemplars of possible alternative catalytic modes and manifolds to those already found in nature.

Selective chemical protein modification

Chemical modification of proteins is an important tool for probing natural systems, creating therapeutic conjugates and generating novel protein constructs. Site-selective reactions require exquisite control over both chemo- and regioselectivity, under ambient, aqueous conditions. There are now various methods for achieving selective modification of both natural and unnatural amino acids--each with merits and limitations--providing a 'toolkit' that until 20 years ago was largely limited to reactions at nucleophilic cysteine and lysine residues. If applied in a biologically benign manner, this chemistry could form the basis of true Synthetic Biology.

A "tag-and-modify" approach to site-selective protein modification

Covalent modification can expand a protein's functional capacity. Fluorescent or radioactive labeling, for instance, allows imaging of a protein in real time. Labeling with an affinity probe enables isolation of target proteins and other interacting molecules. At the other end of this functional spectrum, protein structures can be naturally altered by enzymatic action. Protein-protein interactions, genetic regulation, and a range of cellular processes are under the purview of these post-translational modifications. The ability of protein chemists to install these covalent additions selectively has been critical for elucidating their roles in biology. Frequently the transformations must be applied in a site-specific manner, which demands the most selective chemistry. In this Account, we discuss the development and application of such chemistry in our laboratory. A centerpiece of our strategy is a "tag-and-modify" approach, which entails sequential installation of a uniquely reactive chemical group into the protein (the "tag") and the selective or specific modification of this group. The chemical tag can be a natural or unnatural amino acid residue. Of the natural residues, cysteine is the most widely used as a tag. Early work in our program focused on selective disulfide formation in the synthesis of glycoproteins. For certain applications, the susceptibility of disulfides to reduction was a limitation and prompted the development of several methods for the synthesis of more stable thioether modifications. The desulfurization of disulfides and conjugate addition to dehydroalanine are two routes to these modifications. The dehydroalanine tag has since proven useful as a general precursor to many modifications after conjugate addition of various nucleophiles; phosphorylated, glycosylated, peptidylated, prenylated, and even mimics of methylated and acetylated lysine-containing proteins are all accessible from dehydroalanine. While cysteine is a useful tag for selective modification, unnatural residues present the opportunity for bio-orthogonal chemistry. Azide-, arylhalide-, alkyne-, and alkene-containing amino acids can be incorporated into proteins genetically and can be specifically modified through various transformations. These transformations often rely on metal catalysis. The Cu-catalyzed azide-alkyne addition, Ru-catalyzed olefin metathesis, and Pd-catalyzed cross-coupling are examples of such transformations. In the course of adapting these reactions to protein modification, we learned much about the behavior of these reactions in water, and in some cases entirely new catalysts were developed. Through a combination of these bio-orthogonal transformations from the panel of tag-and-modify reactions, multiple and distinct modifications can be installed on protein surfaces. Multiple modifications are common in natural systems, and synthetic access to these proteins has enabled study of their biological role. Throughout these investigations, much has been learned in chemistry and biology. The demands of selective protein modification have revealed many aspects of reaction mechanisms, which in turn have guided the design of reagents and catalysts that allow their successful deployment in water and in biological milieu. With this ability to modify proteins, it is now possible to interrogate biological systems with precision that was not previously possible.

Sugars and proteins: New strategies in synthetic biology

The development of novel methodology for bond-forming processes that are compatible with biomolecules allows the assembly, alteration, or modification of proteins. Such synthetic proteins allow precise insight and investigation of function in a manner that has the potential for almost unlimited diversity.

Unique Regulation of the Active site of the Serine Esterase S-Formylglutathione Hydrolase

S-Formylglutathione hydrolases (SFGHs) are highly conserved thioesterases present in prokaryotes and eukaryotes, and form part of the formaldehyde detoxification pathway, as well as functioning as xenobiotic-hydrolysing carboxyesterases. As defined by their sensitivity to covalent modification, SFGHs behave as cysteine hydrolases, being inactivated by thiol alkylating agents, while being insensitive to inhibition by organophosphates such as paraoxon. As such, the enzyme has been classified as an esterase D in animals, plants and microbes. While SFGHs do contain a conserved cysteine residue that has been implicated in catalysis, sequence analysis also reveals the classic catalytic triad of a serine hydrolase. Using a combination of selective protein modification and X-ray crystallography, AtSFGH from Arabidopsis thaliana has been shown to be a serine hydrolase rather than a cysteine hydrolase. Uniquely, the conserved reactive cysteine (Cys59) previously implicated in catalysis lies in close proximity to the serine hydrolase triad, serving a gate-keeping function in comprehensively regulating access to the active site. Thus, any covalent modification of Cys59 inhibited all hydrolase activities of the enzyme. When isolated from Escherichia coli, a major proportion of recombinant AtSFGH was recovered with the Cys59 forming a mixed disulfide with glutathione. Reversible disulfide formation with glutathione could be demonstrated to regulate hydrolase activity in vitro. The importance of Cys59 in regulating AtSFGH in planta was demonstrated in transient expression assays in Arabidopsis protoplasts. As determined by fluorescence microscopy, the Cys59Ser mutant enzyme was shown to rapidly hydrolyse 4-methylumbelliferyl acetate in paraoxon-treated cells, while the native enzyme was found to be inactive. Our results clarify the classification of AtSFGHs as hydrolases and suggest that the regulatory and conserved cysteine provides an unusual redox-sensitive regulation to an enzyme functioning in both primary and xenobiotic metabolism in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Selective reduction and chemical modification of oxidized lipase cysteine mutants

Thirteen single-cysteine mutants of the 33 kDa fungal triacylglycerol lipase Thermomyces (formerly Humicola) lanuginosa lipase (TLL, EC 3.1.1.3) were produced and characterized for the purpose of site-directed chemical modification with spectroscopic reporter groups. All cysteine mutants were found to be predominantly blocked by oxidation to disulfides with endogenous cysteine during production. The fraction of lipase molecules with free sulfhydryl groups was analyzed by labeling with N-biotinylaminoethyl methanethiosulfonate, followed by a novel dot-blot method based on biotin-streptavidin interactions. A non-invasive method for the reduction of the introduced cysteine was elaborated for this protein containing three native disulfide bridges. The site-specifically reduced TLL mutants were then labeled with the sulfhydryl-specific reagents 2-(5-dimethylaminonaphth-1-ylsulfonamido)ethyl methanethiosulfonate or (1-oxyl-2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-Δ3-pyrroline-3-methyl) methanethiosulfonate, and studied by fluorescence and electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy.Key words: lipase, cysteine mutant, selective reduction, chemical modification, methanethiosulfonate.

Covalent modification of subtilisin Bacillus lentus cysteine mutants with enantiomerically pure chiral auxiliaries causes remarkable changes in activity

Methanethiosulfonate reagents may be used to introduce virtually unlimited structural modifications in enzymes via reaction with the thiol group of cysteine. The covalent coupling of enantiomerically pure (R) and (S) chiral auxiliary methanethiosulfonate ligands to cysteine mutants of subtilisin Bacillus lentus induces spectacular changes in catalytic activity between diastereomeric enzymes. Amidase and esterase kinetic assays using a low substrate approximation were used to establish kcat/KM values for the chemically modified mutants, and up to 3-fold differences in activity were found between diastereomeric enzymes. Changing the length of the carbon chain linking the phenyl or benzyl oxazolidinone ligand to the mutant N62C by a methylene unit reverses which diastereomeric enzyme is more active. Similarly, changing from a phenyl to benzyl oxazolidinone ligand at S166C reverses which diastereomeric enzyme is more active. Chiral modifications at S166C and L217C give CMMs having both high esterase kcat/KM's and high esterase to amidase ratios with large differences between diastereomeric enzymes.

Controlled site-selective protein glycosylation for precise glycan structure-catalytic activity relationships

Glycoproteins occur naturally as complex mixtures of differently glycosylated forms which are difficult to separate. To explore their individual properties, there is a need for homogeneous sources of carbohydrate-protein conjugates and this has recently prompted us to develop a novel method for the site-selective glycosylation of proteins. The potential of the method was illustrated by site-selective glycosylations of subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL) as a model protein. A representative library of mono- and disaccharide MTS reagents were synthesized from their parent carbohydrates and used to modify cysteine mutants of SBL at positions 62 in the S2 site, 156 and 166 in the S1 site and 217 in the S1' site. These were the first examples of preparations of homogeneous neoglycoproteins in which both the site of glycosylation and structure of the introduced glycan were predetermined. The scope of this versatile method was expanded further through the combined use of peracetylated MTS reagents and careful pH adjustment to introduce glycans containing different numbers of acetate groups. This method provides a highly controlled and versatile route that is virtually unlimited in the scope of the sites and glycans that may be conjugated, and opens up hitherto inaccessible opportunities for the systematic determination of the properties of glycosylated proteins. This potential has been clearly demonstrated by the determination of detailed glycan structure-hydrolytic activity relationships for SBL. The 48 glycosylated CMMs formed display kcat/KM values that range from 1.1-fold higher than WT to 7-fold lower than WT. The anomeric stereochemistry of the glycans introduced modulates changes in kcat/KM upon acetylation. At positions 62 and 217 acetylation enhances the activity of alpha-glycosylated CMMs but decreases that of beta-glycosylated. This trend is reversed at position 166 where, in contrast, acetylation enhances the kcat/KMs of beta-glycosylated CMMs but decreases those of alpha-glycosylated. Consistent with its surface exposed nature changes at position 156 are more modest, but still allow control of activity, particularly through glycosylation with disaccharide lactose.

Benzophenone boronic acid photoaffinity labeling of subtilisin CMMs to probe altered specificity

A transition state analogue inhibitor, boronic acid benzophenone (BBP) photoprobe, was used to study the differences in the topology of the S1 pocket of chemically modified mutant enzymes (CMMs). The BBP proved to be an effective competitive inhibitor and a revealing active site directed photoprobe of the CMMs of the serine protease subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL) which were chemically modified with the hydrophobic, negatively charged and positively charged moieties at the S1 pocket S166C residue. As expected, in all cases BBP bound best to WT-SBL. BBP binding to S166C-SCH2C6H5 and S166C-CH2-c-C6H11, with their large hydrophobic side chains, was reduced by 86-fold and 9-fold, respectively, compared to WT. Relative to WT, BBP binding to the charged CMMs, S166C-S-CH2CH2SO3- or S166C-S-CH2CH2NH3+, was reduced 170-fold and 4-fold respectively. Photolysis of the WT-SBL-BBP enzyme inhibitor (EI) complex, inactivated the enzyme and effected the formation of a covalent crosslink between WT and BBP. The crosslink was identified at Gly127 by peptide mapping analysis and Edman sequencing. Gly127 is located in the S1 hydrophobic pocket of SBL and its modification thus established binding of the benzophenone moiety in S1. Photolysis of the EI complex of S166C-SCH2C6H5, S166C-S-CH2CH2SO3-, or S166C-S-CH2CH2NH3+ and BBP under the same conditions did not inactivate these enzymes, nor effect the formation of a crosslink. These results corroborated the kinetic evidence that the active site topology of these CMMs is dramatically altered from that of WT. In contrast, while photolysis of the S166C-CH2-c-C6H11-BBP EI complex only inactivated 50% of the enzyme after 12 h, it still effected the formation of a covalent crosslink between the CMM and BBP, again at Gly127. However, this photolytic reaction was less efficient than with WT, demonstrating that the S1 pocket of S166C-CH2-c-C6H11 is significantly restricted compared to WT, but not as completely as for the other CMMs.

Altering the specificity of subtilisin Bacillus lentus through the introduction of positive charge at single amino acid sites

The use of methanethiosulfonates as thiol-specific modifying reagents in the strategy of combined site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification allows virtually unlimited opportunities for creating new protein surface environments. As a consequence of our interest in electrostatic manipulation as a means of tailoring enzyme activity and specificity, we have recently adopted this approach for the controlled incorporation of multiple negative charges at single sites in the representative serine protease, subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL). We now describe the use of this strategy to introduce multiple positive charges. A series of mono-, di- and triammonium methanethiosulfonates were synthesized and used to modify cysteine mutants of SBL at positions 62 in the S2 site, 156 and 166 in the S1 site and 217 in the S1' site. Kinetic parameters for these chemically modified mutants (CMM) enzymes were determined at pH 8.6. The presence of up to three positive charges in the S1, S1' and S2 subsites of SBL resulted in up to 77-fold lowered activity, possibly due to interference with the histidinium ion formed in the transition state of the hydrolytic reactions catalyzed.

The controlled introduction of multiple negative charge at single amino acid sites in subtilisin Bacillus lentus

The use of methanethiosulfonates as thiol-specific modifying reagents in the strategy of combined site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification allows virtually unlimited opportunities for creating new protein surface environments. As a consequence of our interest in electrostatic manipulation as a means of tailoring enzyme activity and specificity, we have adopted this approach for the controlled incorporation of multiple negative charges at single sites in the representative serine protease, subtilisin Bacillus lentus (SBL). A series of mono-, di- and triacidic acid methanethiosulfonates were synthesized and used to modify cysteine mutants of SBL at positions 62 in the S2 site, 156 and 166 in the S1 site and 217 in the S1' site. Kinetic parameters for these chemically modified mutant (CMM) enzymes were determined at pH 8.6 under conditions which ensured complete ionization of the unnatural amino acid side-chains introduced. The presence of up to three negative charges in the S1, S1' and S2 subsites of SBL resulted in up to 11-fold lowered activity, possibly due to interference with oxyanion stabilization of the transition state of the hydrolytic reactions catalyzed. Each unit increase in negative charge resulted in a raising of K(M) and a reduction of k(cat). However, no upper limit was observed for increases in K(M), whereas decreases in k(cat) reached a limiting value. Comparison with sterically similar but uncharged CMMs revealed that electrostatic effects of negative charges at positions 62, 156 and 217 are detrimental, but are beneficial at position 166. These results indicate that the ground-state binding of SBL to the standard substrate, Suc-AAPF-pNA, to SBL is reduced, but without drastic attenuation of catalytic efficiency, and show that SBL tolerates high levels of charge at single sites.

Chemical modification of enzymes for enhanced functionality

The explosion in commercial and synthetic applications of enzymes has stimulated much of the interest in enhancing enzyme functionality and stability. Covalent chemical modification, the original method available for altering protein properties, has now re-emerged as a powerful complementary approach to site-directed mutagenesis and directed evolution for tailoring proteins and enzymes. Glutaraldehyde crosslinking of enzyme crystals and polyethylene glycol (PEG) modification of enzyme surface amino groups are practical methods to enhance biocatalyst stability. Whereas crosslinking of enzyme crystals generates easily recoverable insoluble biocatalysts, PEGylation increases solubility in organic solvents. Chemical modification has been exploited for the incorporation of cofactors onto protein templates and for atom replacement in order to generate new functionality, such as the conversion of a hydrolase into a peroxidase. Despite the breadth of applicability of chemically modified enzymes, a difficulty that has previously impeded their implementation is the lack of chemo- or regio-specificity of chemical modifications, which can yield heterogeneous and irreproducible product mixtures. This challenge has recently been addressed by the introduction of a unique position for modification by a site-directed mutation that can subsequently be chemically modified to introduce an unnatural amino acid sidechain in a highly chemo- and regio-specific manner.

Probing the altered specificity and catalytic properties of mutant subtilisin chemically modified at position S156C and S166C in the S1 pocket

A series of chemically modified mutants (CMMs) of subtilisin B. lentus (SBL) were generated employing the combination of site-directed mutagenesis and chemical modification. This strategy entails the mutation of a selected active site residue to cysteine and its subsequent modification with a methanethiosulfonate reagent CH3SO2S-R, where R may be infinitely variable. The present study was undertaken to evaluate the changes in specificity and pH-activity profiles that could be induced by modification of S156C and S166C in the S1 pocket of SBL with a representative range of side chain modifications, namely R=-CH3, -CH2C6H5, -CH2CH2NH3+ and CH2CH2SO3 . The side chain of S156C is surface exposed and well solvated while that of S166C points into the pocket. Kinetic evaluation of the CMMs with suc-AAPF-pNA as substrate showed that the kcat/K(M)s changed very little for the S156C CMMs, but varied by up to 11-fold for the S166C CMMs. pH-Activity profiles were also determined, and showed that a negatively or positively charged side chain modification increased or decreased respectively, the pKa of the catalytic triad histidine for both modification sites but with more dramatic changes for the interior pointing S166C than for the solvent exposed S156C site. As an additional probe of altered specificity, inhibition of the CMMs by a representative series of 5 boronic acid transition state analogue inhibitors was determined. The K(I)s observed ranged from a 3.5-fold improvement over the WT value, to a 12-fold decrease in binding. Overall, greater variability in all the parameters measured, activity, pKa, and boronic acid binding resulted from modification at the inward pointing 166 site than at the solvent-exposed 156 site.

A combinatorial approach to chemical modification of subtilisin Bacillus lentus

The reaction between methanethiosulfonate reagents and cysteine mutants of subtilisin is quantitative and can be used to prepare chemically modified mutant enzymes (CMMs) with novel properties. The virtually unrestricted structural variations possible for CMMs presents a preparative and screening challenge. To address this, a rapid combinatorial method for preparing and screening the activities of CMMs has been developed.

Improving hydrolases for organic synthesis

Improving hydrolases by site-directed mutagenesis continues to be important, but an alternative method - directed evolution - also gains favor. Directed evolution combines random mutagenesis with screening or selection for the desired property. Directed evolution is especially useful for cases like solvent tolerance or thermostability where current theories are inadequate to predict which structural changes will give improvement. Researchers have also recently made significant progress on several practical problems: how to maintain the high activity of proteases and lipases in nonpolar organic solvents, how to resolve amines, and how to efficiently recycle the unwanted enantiomer in kinetic resolutions. Besides the lipases and proteases, researchers are also developing new hydrolases, notably dehalogenases and epoxide hydrolases.