Structural Properties and Catalytic Implications of the SPASM Domain Iron-Sulfur Clusters in Methylorubrum extorquens PqqE

Structural features and substrate engagement in peptide-modifying radical SAM enzymes

In recent years, the biological significance of ribosomally synthesized, post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs) and the intriguing chemistry catalyzed by their tailoring enzymes has garnered significant attention. A subgroup of bacterial radical S-adenosylmethionine (rSAM) enzymes can activate C-H bonds in peptides, which leads to the production of a diverse range of RiPPs. The remarkable ability of these enzymes to facilitate various chemical processes, to generate and harbor high-energy radical species, and to accommodate large substrates with a high degree of flexibility is truly intriguing. The wide substrate scope and diversity of the chemistry performed by rSAM enzymes raise one question: how does the protein environment facilitate these distinct chemical conversions while sharing a similar structural fold? In this review, we discuss recent advances in the field of RiPP-rSAM enzymes, with a particular emphasis on domain architectures and substrate engagements identified by biophysical and structural characterizations. We provide readers with a comparative analysis of six examples of RiPP-rSAM enzymes with experimentally characterized structures. Linking the structural elements and the nature of rSAM-catalyzed RiPP production will provide insight into the functional engineering of enzyme activity to harness their catalytic power in broader applications.

Structural and mechanistic basis for RiPP epimerization by a radical SAM enzyme

D-Amino acid residues, found in countless peptides and natural products including ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs), are critical for the bioactivity of several antibiotics and toxins. Recently, radical S-adenosyl-L-methionine (SAM) enzymes have emerged as the only biocatalysts capable of installing direct and irreversible epimerization in RiPPs. However, the mechanism underpinning this biochemical process is ill-understood and the structural basis for this post-translational modification remains unknown. Here we report an atomic-resolution crystal structure of a RiPP-modifying radical SAM enzyme in complex with its substrate properly positioned in the active site. Crystallographic snapshots, size-exclusion chromatography-small-angle x-ray scattering, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy and biochemical analyses reveal how epimerizations are installed in RiPPs and support an unprecedented enzyme mechanism for peptide epimerization. Collectively, our study brings unique perspectives on how radical SAM enzymes interact with RiPPs and catalyze post-translational modifications in natural products.

Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry Identifies Local and Long-Distance Interactions within the Multicomponent Radical SAM Enzyme, PqqE

Interactions among proteins and peptides are essential for many biological activities including the tailoring of peptide substrates to produce natural products. The first step in the production of the bacterial redox cofactor pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ) from its peptide precursor is catalyzed by a radical SAM (rSAM) enzyme, PqqE. We describe the use of hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to characterize the structure and conformational dynamics in the protein-protein and protein-peptide complexes necessary for PqqE function. HDX-MS-identified hotspots can be discerned in binary and ternary complex structures composed of the peptide PqqA, the peptide-binding chaperone PqqD, and PqqE. Structural conclusions are supported by size-exclusion chromatography coupled to small-angle X-ray scattering (SEC-SAXS). HDX-MS further identifies reciprocal changes upon the binding of substrate peptide and S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) to the PqqE/PqqD complex: long-range conformational alterations have been detected upon the formation of a quaternary complex composed of PqqA/PqqD/PqqE and SAM, spanning nearly 40 Å, from the PqqA binding site in PqqD to the PqqE active site Fe4S4. Interactions among the various regions are concluded to arise from both direct contact and distal communication. The described experimental approach can be readily applied to the investigation of protein conformational communication among a large family of peptide-modifying rSAM enzymes.

Microbial synthesis of pyrroloquinoline quinone

Pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ) is a peptide-modified natural product. PQQ has important physiological functions such as anti-oxidation, anti-aging, and immunity enhancement. However, due to the lack of in-depth understanding of PQQ biosynthesis and regulation, inefficient PQQ production level limits its wide application. Accordingly, there is still an urgent need to develop high-yielding strains for synthesis of PQQ. This paper reviewed the research and development trends on the PQQ biosynthetic pathways, catalytic reaction mechanism of key enzymes, and the selection of high-yielding strains, which also prospects for the future construction of PQQ biosynthetic microbial cell factories.

The new epoch of structural insights into radical SAM enzymology

The Radical SAM (RS) superfamily of enzymes catalyzes a wide array of enzymatic reactions. The majority of these enzymes employ an electron from a reduced [4Fe-4S]+1 cluster to facilitate the reductive cleavage of S-adenosyl-l-methionine, thereby producing a highly reactive 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical (5'-dA⋅) and l-methionine. Typically, RS enzymes use this 5'-dA⋅ to extract a hydrogen atom from the target substrate, starting the cascade of an expansive and impressive variety of chemical transformations. While a great deal of understanding has been gleaned for 5'-dA⋅ formation, because of the chemical diversity within this superfamily, the subsequent chemical transformations have only been fully elucidated in a few examples. In addition, with the advent of new sequencing technology, the size of this family now surpasses 700,000 members, with the number of uncharacterized enzymes and domains also rapidly expanding. In this review, we outline the history of RS enzyme characterization in what we term "epochs" based on advances in technology designed for stably producing these enzymes in an active state. We propose that the state of the field has entered the fourth epoch, which we argue should commence with a protein structure initiative focused solely on RS enzymes to properly tackle this unique superfamily and uncover more novel chemical transformations that likely exist.

The Radical SAM Heme Synthase AhbD from Methanosarcina barkeri Contains Two Auxiliary [4Fe-4S] Clusters

In archaea and sulfate-reducing bacteria, heme is synthesized via the siroheme-dependent pathway. The last step of this route is catalyzed by the Radical SAM enzyme AhbD and consists of the conversion of iron-coproporphyrin III into heme. AhbD belongs to the subfamily of Radical SAM enzymes containing a SPASM/Twitch domain carrying either one or two auxiliary iron-sulfur clusters in addition to the characteristic Radical SAM cluster. In previous studies, AhbD was reported to contain one auxiliary [4Fe-4S] cluster. In this study, the amino acid sequence motifs containing conserved cysteine residues in AhbD proteins from different archaea and sulfate-reducing bacteria were reanalyzed. Amino acid sequence alignments and computational structural models of AhbD suggested that a subset of AhbD proteins possesses the full SPASM motif and might contain two auxiliary iron-sulfur clusters (AuxI and AuxII). Therefore, the cluster content of AhbD from Methanosarcina barkeri was studied using enzyme variants lacking individual clusters. The purified enzymes were analyzed using UV/Visible absorption and EPR spectroscopy as well as iron/sulfide determinations showing that AhbD from M. barkeri contains two auxiliary [4Fe-4S] clusters. Heme synthase activity assays suggested that the AuxI cluster might be involved in binding the reaction intermediate and both clusters potentially participate in electron transfer.

Reactivity and mechanism in chemical and synthetic biology

Physical organic chemistry and mechanistic thinking provide a strong intellectual framework for understanding the chemical logic of evolvable informational macromolecules and metabolic transformations in living organisms. These concepts have also led to numerous successes in designing and applying tools to delineate biological function in health and disease, chemical ecology and possible alternative chemistries employed by extraterrestrial life. A symposium at the 2020 Pacifichem meeting was scheduled in December 2020 to discuss designing and exploiting expanded genetic alphabets, methods to understand the biosynthesis of natural products and re-engineering primary metabolism in bacteria. The COVID-19 pandemic led to postponement of in-person discussions, with the symposium eventually being held on 20-21 December 2021 as an online event. This issue is a written record of work presented on biosynthetic pathways and enzyme catalysis, engineering microorganisms with new metabolic capabilities, and the synthesis of non-canonical, nucleobases for medical applications and for studies of alternate chemistries for living organisms. The variety of opinion pieces, reviews and original research articles provide a starting point for innovations that clarify how complex biological systems emerge from the rules of chemical reactivity and mechanism. This article is part of the themed issue 'Reactivity and mechanism in chemical and synthetic biology'.

RaS-RiPPs in Streptococci and the Human Microbiome

Radical S-adenosylmethionine (RaS) enzymes have quickly advanced to one of the most abundant and versatile enzyme superfamilies known. Their chemistry is predicated upon reductive homolytic cleavage of a carbon–sulfur bond in cofactor S-adenosylmethionine forming an oxidizing carbon-based radical, which can initiate myriad radical transformations. An emerging role for RaS enzymes is their involvement in the biosynthesis of ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs), a natural product family that has become known as RaS-RiPPs. These metabolites are especially prevalent in human and mammalian microbiomes because the complex chemistry of RaS enzymes gives rise to correspondingly complex natural products with minimal cellular energy and genomic fingerprint, a feature that is advantageous in microbes with small, host-adapted genomes in competitive environments. Herein, we review the discovery and characterization of RaS-RiPPs from the human microbiome with a focus on streptococcal bacteria. We discuss the varied chemical modifications that RaS enzymes introduce onto their peptide substrates and the diverse natural products that they give rise to. The majority of RaS-RiPPs remain to be discovered, providing an intriguing avenue for future investigations at the intersection of metalloenzymology, chemical ecology, and the human microbiome.

Pyrroloquinoline Quinone Chemistry, Biology, and Biosynthesis

The widely distributed, essential redox factor pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ, methoxatin) (1) was discovered in the mid-1960s. The breadth and depth of its biological effects are steadily being revealed, and understanding its biosynthesis at the genomic level is a continuing process. In this review, aspects of the chemistry, biology, biosynthesis, and commercial production of 1 at the gene level, and some applications, are presented from discovery through to mid-2021.

HygY Is a Twitch Radical SAM Epimerase with Latent Dehydrogenase Activity Revealed upon Mutation of a Single Cysteine Residue

HygY is a SPASM/twitch radical SAM enzyme hypothesized to catalyze the C2'-epimerization of galacamine during the biosynthesis of hygromycin B. This activity is confirmed via biochemical and structural analysis of the derivatized reaction products using chemically synthesized deuterated substrate, high-resolution mass spectrometry and ¹H NMR. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of the reduced enzyme is consistent with ligation of two [Fe₄S₄] clusters characteristic of the twitch radical SAM subgroup. HygY catalyzed epimerization proceeds with incorporation of a single solvent Hydron into the talamine product facilitated by the catalytic cysteine-183 residue. Mutation of this cysteine to alanine converts HygY from a C2'-epimerase to an C2'-dehydrogenase with comparable activity. The SPASM/twitch radical SAM enzymes often serve as anaerobic oxidases making the redox-neutral epimerases in this class rather interesting. The discovery of latent dehydrogenase activity in a twitch epimerase may therefore offer new insights into the mechanistic features that distinguish oxidative versus redox-neutral SPASM/twitch enzymes and lead to the evolution of new enzyme activities.

Mechanism of Reduction of an Aminyl Radical Intermediate in the Radical SAM GTP 3',8-Cyclase MoaA

The diversity of the reactions catalyzed by radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzymes is achieved at least in part through the variety of mechanisms to quench their radical intermediates. In the SPASM-twitch family, the largest family of radical SAM enzymes, the radical quenching step is thought to involve an electron transfer to or from an auxiliary 4Fe-4S cluster in or adjacent to the active site. However, experimental demonstration of such functions remains limited. As a representative member of this family, MoaA has one radical SAM cluster ([4Fe-4S]_RS) and one auxiliary cluster ([4Fe-4S]_AUX), and catalyzes a unique 3',8-cyclization of GTP into 3',8-cyclo-7,8-dihydro-GTP (3',8-cH₂GTP) in the molybdenum cofactor (Moco) biosynthesis. Here, we report a mechanistic investigation of the radical quenching step in MoaA, a chemically challenging reduction of 3',8-cyclo-GTP-N7 aminyl radical. We first determined the reduction potentials of [4Fe-4S]_RS and [4Fe-4S]_AUX as -510 mV and -455 mV, respectively, using a combination of protein film voltammogram (PFV) and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. Subsequent Q-band EPR characterization of 5'-deoxyadenosine C4' radical (5'-dA-C4'•) trapped in the active site revealed isotropic exchange interaction (∼260 MHz) between 5'-dA-C4'• and [4Fe-4S]_AUX¹⁺, suggesting that [4Fe-4S]_AUX is in the reduced (1+) state during the catalysis. Together with density functional theory (DFT) calculation, we propose that the aminyl radical reduction proceeds through a proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET), where [4Fe-4S]_AUX serves as an electron donor and R17 residue acts as a proton donor. These results provide detailed mechanistic insights into the radical quenching step of radical SAM enzyme catalysis.

Characterizing SPASM/twitch Domain-Containing Radical SAM Enzymes by EPR Spectroscopy

Owing to their importance, diversity and abundance of generated paramagnetic species, radical S-adenosylmethionine (rSAM) enzymes have become popular targets for electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopic studies. In contrast to prototypic single-domain and thus single-[4Fe-4S]-containing rSAM enzymes, there is a large subfamily of rSAM enzymes with multiple domains and one or two additional iron-sulfur cluster(s) called the SPASM/twitch domain-containing rSAM enzymes. EPR spectroscopy is a powerful tool that allows for the observation of the iron-sulfur clusters as well as potentially trappable paramagnetic reaction intermediates. Here, we review continuous-wave and pulse EPR spectroscopic studies of SPASM/twitch domain-containing rSAM enzymes. Among these enzymes, we will review in greater depth four well-studied enzymes, BtrN, MoaA, PqqE, and SuiB. Towards establishing a functional consensus of the additional architecture in these enzymes, we describe the commonalities between these enzymes as observed by EPR spectroscopy.

Radical SAM Enzymes and Ribosomally-Synthesized and Post-translationally Modified Peptides: A Growing Importance in the Microbiomes

To face the current antibiotic resistance crisis, novel strategies are urgently required. Indeed, in the last 30 years, despite considerable efforts involving notably high-throughput screening and combinatorial libraries, only few antibiotics have been launched to the market. Natural products have markedly contributed to the discovery of novel antibiotics, chemistry and drug leads, with more than half anti-infective and anticancer drugs approved by the FDA being of natural origin or inspired by natural products. Among them, thanks to their modular structure and simple biosynthetic logic, ribosomally synthesized and posttranslationally modified peptides (RiPPs) are promising scaffolds. In addition, recent studies have highlighted the pivotal role of RiPPs in the human microbiota which remains an untapped source of natural products. In this review, we report on recent developments in radical SAM enzymology and how these unique biocatalysts have been shown to install complex and sometimes unprecedented posttranslational modifications in RiPPs with a special focus on microbiome derived enzymes.

Current Advancements in Sactipeptide Natural Products

Ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs) are a growing class of natural products that benefited from genome sequencing technology in the past two decades. RiPPs are widely distributed in nature and show diverse chemical structures and rich biological activities. Despite the various structural characteristic of RiPPs, they follow a common biosynthetic logic: a precursor peptide containing an N-terminal leader peptide and a C-terminal core peptide; in some cases,a follower peptide is after the core peptide. The precursor peptide undergoes a series of modification, transport, and cleavage steps to form a mature natural product with specific activities. Sactipeptides (Sulfur-to-alpha carbon thioether cross-linked peptides) belong to RiPPs that show various biological activities such as antibacterial, spermicidal and hemolytic properties. Their common hallmark is an intramolecular thioether bond that crosslinks the sulfur atom of a cysteine residue to the α-carbon of an acceptor amino acid, which is catalyzed by a rSAM enzyme. This review summarizes recent achievements concerning the discovery, distribution, structural elucidation, biosynthesis and application prospects of sactipeptides.

Biogenesis of the peptide-derived redox cofactor pyrroloquinoline quinone

Pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ) is a peptide-derived redox cofactor produced by prokaryotes that also plays beneficial roles in organisms from other kingdoms. We review recent developments on the pathway of PQQ biogenesis, focusing on the mechanisms of PqqE, PqqF/G, and PqqB. These advances may shed light on other, uncharacterized biosynthetic pathways.