Engineering Optically Switchable Transistors with Improved Performance by Controlling Interactions of Diarylethenes in Polymer Matrices

Photophore-Anchored Molecular Switch for High-Performance Nonvolatile Organic Memory Transistor

Over the past decade, molecular-switch-embedded memory devices, particularly field-effect transistors (FETs), have gained significant interest. Molecular switches are integrated to regulate the resistance or current levels in FETs. Despite substantial efforts, realizing large memory window with a long retention time, a critical factor in memory device functionality, remains a challenge. This is due to the inability of an isomeric state of a molecular switch to serve as a stable deep trap state within the semiconductor layer. Herein, the study addresses this limitation by introducing chemical bonding between molecular switch and conjugated polymeric semiconductor, facilitating closed isomer of diarylethene (DAE) to operate as a morphologically stable deep trap state. Azide- and diazirine-anchored DAEs are synthesized, which form chemical bonds to the polymer through photocrosslinking, thereby implementing permanent and controllable trapping states nearby conjugated backbone of polymer semiconductor. Consequently, when diazirine-anchored DAE is blended with F8T2 and subjected to photocrosslinking, the resulting organic FETs exhibit remarkable memory performance, including a memory window of 22 V with a retention time over 106 s, a high photoprogrammable on/off ratio over 103, and a high operational stability over 100 photocycles. Further, photophore-anchored DAEs can achieve precise patterning, which enables meticulous control over the semiconductor layer structure.

Phototunable and Photopatternable Polymer Semiconductors

ConspectusIn recent decades, there has been rapid development in the field of polymer semiconductors, particularly those based on conjugated donor-acceptor (D-A) polymers exhibiting high charge mobilities. Furthermore, the application of polymer semiconductors has been successfully extended to a wide range of functional devices, including sensors, photodetectors, radio frequency identification (RFID) tags, electronic paper, skin electronics, and artificial synapses. Over the past few years, there has been a growing focus on stimuli-responsive polymer semiconductors, which have the potential to impart additional functionalities to conventional field-effect transistors, garnering increased attention within the research community. In this context, phototunable polymer semiconductors have received significant attention due to their ability to utilize light as an external stimulus, enabling remote control of device performance with high spatiotemporal resolution. Meanwhile, integration of field-effect transistors with polymer semiconductors can enable the realization of complex functions. To achieve this, precise and controllable patterning of polymer semiconductors becomes essential. In this Account, we discuss our research findings in the context of phototunable and photopatternable polymer semiconductors. These developments encompass the following key aspects: (i) polymer semiconductors, such as poly(diketopyrrolopyrrole-quaterthiophene) (PDPP4T), exhibit phototunability when blended with the photochromic compound hexaarylbiimidazole (HABI). The photo/thermal-responsive field-effect transistors (FETs) can be fabricated using blending thin films. Remarkably, these photo/thermal-responsive transistors can function as photonically programmable and thermally erasable nonvolatile memory devices. (ii) By incorporating photoswitchable groups like azo and spiropyran into the side chains of conjugated D-A polymers, we can create phototunable polymer semiconductors. The reversible isomerization of azo and spiropyran groups significantly influences the charge transport properties of these polymer semiconductors. Consequently, the performance of the resulting FETs can be reversibly tuned through UV/visible or near-infrared light (NIR) irradiation. Notably, the incorporation of two distinct azo groups into the side chains leads to polymer semiconductors with tristable semiconducting states, offering the ability to logically control device performance using light irradiation at three different wavelengths. (iii) Photopatterning of p-type, n-type, and ambipolar semiconductors featuring alkyl side chains can be achieved using a diazirine-based, four-armed photo-cross-linker (4CNN) with a loading concentration of no more than 3% (w/w). Furthermore, the semiconducting performances of FETs with patterned thin films were found to be satisfactorily uniform. Importantly, the cross-linked thin films are robust and show good resistance to organic solvents, which is useful for fabricating all-solution processable multilayer electronic devices. (iv) The introduction of azide groups into the side chains of conjugated polymers results in a single-component semiconducting photoresist. The presence of azide groups renders the side chains with photo-cross-linking ability, enabling the successful formation of uniform patterns, even as small as 5 μm, under UV light irradiation. Benefiting from the single component feature, field-effect transistors with individual patterned thin films display satisfactorily uniform performances. Moreover, this semiconducting photoresist has proven effective for efficiently photopatterning other polymer semiconductors, demonstrating its versatility.

Organic multilevel (opto)electronic memories towards neuromorphic applications

In the past decades, neuromorphic computing has attracted the interest of the scientific community due to its potential to circumvent the von Neumann bottleneck. Organic materials, owing to their fine tunablility and their ability to be used in multilevel memories, represent a promising class of materials to fabricate neuromorphic devices with the key requirement of operation with synaptic weight. In this review, recent studies of organic multilevel memory are presented. The operating principles and the latest achievements obtained with devices exploiting the main approaches to reach multilevel operation are discussed, with emphasis on organic devices using floating gates, ferroelectric materials, polymer electrets and photochromic molecules. The latest results obtained using organic multilevel memories for neuromorphic circuits are explored and the major advantages and drawbacks of the use of organic materials for neuromorphic applications are discussed.

Photoswitchable semiconducting polymer dots for pattern encoding and superresolution imaging

Two photoswitchable semiconducting polymers were synthesized by covalently incorporating photochromic dithienylethene (DTE) into the main chains. Small size polymer dots (Pdots) were prepared and showed dynamic photoswitching upon alternate light irradiation. By virtue of the tunable photoswitching properties, effective pattern encoding and superresolution imaging with a resolution of up to about 30 nm were achieved.

Molecular-Switch-Embedded Solution-Processed Semiconductors

Recent improvements in the performance of solution-processed semiconductor materials and optoelectronic devices have shifted research interest to the diversification/advancement of their functionality. Embedding a molecular switch capable of transition between two or more metastable isomers by light stimuli is one of the most straightforward and widely accepted methods to potentially realize the multifunctionality of optoelectronic devices. A molecular switch embedded in a semiconductor can effectively control various parameters such as trap-level, dielectric constant, electrical resistance, charge mobility, and charge polarity, which can be utilized in photoprogrammable devices including transistors, memory, and diodes. This review classifies the mechanism of each optoelectronic transition driven by molecular switches regardless of the type of semiconductor material or molecular switch or device. In addition, the basic characteristics of molecular switches and the persisting technical/scientific issues corresponding to each mechanism are discussed to help researchers. Finally, interesting yet infrequently reported applications of molecular switches and their mechanisms are also described.

Excited-state resonance Raman spectroscopy probes the sequential two-photon excitation mechanism of a photochromic molecular switch

Some diarylethene molecular switches have a low quantum yield for cycloreversion when excited by a single photon, but react more efficiently following sequential two-photon excitation. The increase in reaction efficiency depends on both the relative time delay and the wavelength of the second photon. This paper examines the wavelength-dependent mechanism for sequential excitation using excited-state resonance Raman spectroscopy to probe the ultrafast (sub-30 fs) dynamics on the upper electronic state following secondary excitation. The approach uses femtosecond stimulated Raman scattering (FSRS) to measure the time-gated, excited-state resonance Raman spectrum in resonance with two different excited-state absorption bands. The relative intensities of the Raman bands reveal the initial dynamics in the higher-lying states, S_n, by providing information on the relative gradients of the potential energy surfaces that are accessed via secondary excitation. The excited-state resonance Raman spectra reveal specific modes that become enhanced depending on the Raman excitation wavelength, 750 or 400 nm. Many of the modes that become enhanced in the 750 nm FSRS spectrum are assigned as vibrational motions localized on the central cyclohexadiene ring. Many of the modes that become enhanced in the 400 nm FSRS spectrum are assigned as motions along the conjugated backbone and peripheral phenyl rings. These observations are consistent with earlier measurements that showed higher efficiency following secondary excitation into the lower excited-state absorption band and illustrate a powerful new way to probe the ultrafast dynamics of higher-lying excited states immediately following sequential two-photon excitation.

A Molecular-Switch-Embedded Organic Photodiode for Capturing Images against Strong Backlight

When the intensity of the incident light increases, the photocurrents of organic photodiodes (OPDs) exhibit relatively early saturation, due to which OPDs cannot easily detect objects against strong backlights, such as sunlight. In this study, this problem is addressed by introducing a light-intensity-dependent transition of the operation mode, such that the operation mode of the OPD autonomously changes to overcome early photocurrent saturation as the incident light intensity passes the threshold intensity. The photoactive layer is doped with a strategically designed and synthesized molecular switch, 1,2-bis-(2-methyl-5-(4-cyanobiphenyl)-3-thienyl)tetrafluorobenzene (DAB). The proposed OPD exhibits a typical OPD performance with an external quantum efficiency (EQE) of <100% and a photomultiplication behavior with an EQE of >100% under low-intensity and high-intensity light illuminations, respectively, thereby resulting in an extension of the photoresponse linearity to a light intensity of 434 mW cm^-2 . This unique and reversible transition of the operation mode can be explained by the unbalanced quantum yield of photocyclization/photocycloreversion of the molecular switch. The details of the operation mechanism are discussed in conjunction with various photophysical analyses. Furthermore, they establish a prototype image sensor with an array of molecular-switch-embedded OPD pixels to demonstrate their extremely high sensitivity against strong light illumination.

Future-Oriented Advanced Diarylethene Photoswitches: From Molecular Design to Spontaneous Assembly Systems

Diarylethene (DAE) photoswitch is a new and promising family of photochromic molecules and has shown superior performance as a smart trigger in stimulus-responsive materials. During the past few decades, the DAE family has achieved a leap from simple molecules to functional molecules and developed toward validity as a universal switching building block. In recent years, the introduction of DAE into an assembly system has been an attractive strategy that enables the photochromic behavior of the building blocks to be manifested at the level of the entire system, beyond the DAE unit itself. This assembly-based strategy will bring many unexpected results that promote the design and manufacture of a new generation of advanced materials. Here, recent advances in the design and fabrication of diarylethene as a trigger in materials science, chemistry, and biomedicine are reviewed.

Photocontrolled multiple-state photochromic benzo[b]phosphole thieno[3,2-b]phosphole-containing alkynylgold(I) complex via selective light irradiation

Photochromic materials have drawn growing attention because using light as a stimulus has been regarded as a convenient and environmental-friendly way to control properties of smart materials. While photoresponsive systems that are capable of showing multiple-state photochromism are attractive, the development of materials with such capabilities has remained a challenging task. Here we show that a benzo[b]phosphole thieno[3,2‑b]phosphole-containing alkynylgold(I) complex features multiple photoinduced color changes, in which the gold(I) metal center plays an important role in separating two photoactive units that leads to the suppression of intramolecular quenching processes of the excited states. More importantly, the exclusive photochemical reactivity of the thieno[3,2‑b]phosphole moiety of the gold(I) complex can be initiated upon photoirradiation of visible light. Stepwise photochromism of the gold(I) complex has been made possible, offering an effective strategy for the construction of multiple-state photochromic materials with multiple photocontrolled states to enhance the storage capacity of potential optical memory devices.

Photofluorochromic water-dispersible nanoparticles for single-photon-absorption upconversion cell imaging

Photofluorochromic diarylethene (DAE) molecules have been widely investigated due to their excellent fatigue resistance and thermal stability. However, the poor water solubility of DAEs limits their biological applications to some extent. Herein, we reported two kinds of water-dispersible DAE nanoparticles (DAEI-NPs and DAEB-NPs), in which DAE molecules were stabilized by the amphiphilic polymer DSPE-mPEG2000 using the nanoprecipitation approach. The fabricated nanoparticles retain well-controlled luminescence and fluorescence photoswitching properties in aqueous solution, which could be reversibly switched on and off under the alternating irradiation of ultraviolet (UV) and visible light. In addition, the closed-ring isomers of DAEB-NPs performed hot-band-absorption-based photon upconversion when excited by a 593.5 nm laser. Bearing excellent photophysical properties and low cytotoxicity, DAEB-NPs were applicable for upconversion cell imaging without high-excitation power density and free from oxygen removal. Additionally, the imaging process could be switched on by regulating the photofluorochromic nanoparticles.

Challenges for Incorporating Optical Switchability in Organic-Based Electronic Devices

Transistors operate by controlling the current flowing from a source to a drain electrode via a third electrode (gate), thus giving access to a binary treatment (ON/OFF or 0/1) of the signal currently exploited in microelectronics. Introducing a second independent lever to modulate the current would allow for more complex logic functions amenable to a single electronic component and hence to new opportunities for advanced electrical signal processing. One avenue is to add this second dimension with light by incorporating photochromic molecules in current organic-based electronic devices. In this Spotlight, we describe different concepts that have been implemented in organic thin films and in molecular junctions as well as some pitfalls that have been highlighted thanks to theoretical modeling.

Photocontrollable Modulation of Frontier Molecular Orbital Energy Levels of Cyclopentenone-Based Diarylethenes

Photoswitchable diarylethenes provide a unique opportunity to optically modulate frontier molecular orbital energy levels, thereby opening an avenue for the design of electronic devices such as photocontrollable organic field-effect transistors (OFETs). In the present work, the absolute position of the frontier orbital levels of nonsymmetrical diarylethenes based on a cyclopentenone bridge has been studied using cyclic voltammetry and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. It has been shown that varying heteroaromatic substituents make it possible to change the absolute positions of the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of both diarylethene photoisomers. The data obtained are used to refine the operation mechanism of the previously developed OFET devices, employing the cyclopentenone-derived diarylethenes at the dielectric/semiconductor interface.

Multiresponsive Nonvolatile Memories Based on Optically Switchable Ferroelectric Organic Field-Effect Transistors

Organic transistors are key elements for flexible, wearable, and biocompatible logic applications. Multiresponsivity is highly sought-after in organic electronics to enable sophisticated operations and functions. Such a challenge can be pursued by integrating more components in a single device, each one responding to a specific external stimulus. Here, the first multiresponsive organic device based on a photochromic-ferroelectric organic field-effect transistor, which is capable of operating as nonvolatile memory with 11 bit memory storage capacity in a single device, is reported. The memory elements can be written and erased independently by means of light or an electric field, with accurate control over the readout signal, excellent repeatability, fast response, and high retention time. Such a proof of concept paves the way toward enhanced functional complexity in optoelectronics via the interfacing of multiple components in a single device, in a fully integrated low-cost technology compatible with flexible substrates.

Simultaneous Incorporation of Two Types of Azo-Groups in the Side Chains of a Conjugated D-A Polymer for Logic Control of the Semiconducting Performance by Light Irradiation

A new design strategy for photoresponsive semiconducting polymer with tri-stable semiconducting states is reported by simultaneous incorporation of tetra-ortho-methoxy-substituted azobenzene (mAzo) and arylazopyrazole (pAzo) in the side chains. The trans-to-cis transformations for mAzo and pAzo groups can sequentially occur within the polymer thin film after sequential 560 and 365 nm light irradiation. Remarkably, the trans-cis isomerization of mAzo and pAzo groups can modulate the thin film crystallinity. Accordingly, the performances of the resulting field-effect transistors (FETs) can be reversibly modulated, leading to tri-stable semiconducting states after sequential 560, 365, and 470 nm light irradiation. Therefore, the device performance can be logically controlled by light irradiation at three different wavelengths. In addition, with light irradiation and device current as the input and output signals, the three-value logic gate by using single FET device can be successfully mimicked.

Photoswitchable Metal-Organic Framework Thin Films: From Spectroscopy to Remote-Controllable Membrane Separation and Switchable Conduction

The preparation of functional materials from photoswitchable molecules where the molecular changes multiply to macroscopic effects presents a great challenge in material science. An attractive approach is the incorporation of the photoswitches in nanoporous, crystalline metal-organic frameworks, MOFs, often showing remote-controllable chemical and physical properties. Because of the short light-penetration depth, thin MOF films are particularly interesting, allowing the entire illumination of the material. In the present progress report, we review and discuss the status of photoswitchable MOF films. These films may serve as model systems for quantifying the isomer switching yield by infrared and UV-vis spectroscopy as well as for uptake experiments exploring the switching effects on the host-guest interaction, especially on guest adsorption and diffusion. In addition, the straightforward device integration facilitates various experiments. In this way, unique features were demonstrated, such as photoswitchable membrane separation with continuously tunable selectivity, light-switchable proton conductivity of the guests in the pores, and remote-controllable electronic conduction.

Molecular Photoswitching in Confined Spaces

In nature, light is harvested by photoactive proteins to drive a range of biological processes, including photosynthesis, phototaxis, vision, and ultimately life. Bacteriorhodopsin, for example, is a protein embedded within archaeal cell membranes that binds the chromophore retinal within its hydrophobic pocket. Exposure to light triggers regioselective photoisomerization of the confined retinal, which in turn initiates a cascade of conformational changes within the protein, triggering proton flux against the concentration gradient, providing the microorganisms with the energy to live. We are inspired by these functions in nature to harness light energy using synthetic photoswitches under confinement. Like retinal, synthetic photoswitches require some degree of conformational flexibility to isomerize. In nature, the conformational change associated with retinal isomerization is accommodated by the structural flexibility of the opsin host, yet it results in steric communication between the chromophore and the protein. Similarly, we strive to design systems wherein isomerization of confined photoswitches results in steric communication between a photoswitch and its confining environment. To achieve this aim, a balance must be struck between molecular crowding and conformational freedom under confinement: too much crowding prevents switching, whereas too much freedom resembles switching of isolated molecules in solution, preventing communication.

In this Account, we discuss five classes of synthetic light-switchable compounds—diarylethenes, anthracenes, azobenzenes, spiropyrans, and donor–acceptor Stenhouse adducts—comparing their behaviors under confinement and in solution. The environments employed to confine these photoswitches are diverse, ranging from planar surfaces to nanosized cavities within coordination cages, nanoporous frameworks, and nanoparticle aggregates. The trends that emerge are primarily dependent on the nature of the photoswitch and not on the material used for confinement. In general, we find that photoswitches requiring less conformational freedom for switching are, as expected, more straightforward to isomerize reversibly under confinement. Because these compounds undergo only small structural changes upon isomerization, however, switching does not propagate into communication with their environment. Conversely, photoswitches that require more conformational freedom are more challenging to switch under confinement but also can influence system-wide behavior.

Although we are primarily interested in the effects of geometric constraints on photoswitching under confinement, additional effects inevitably emerge when a compound is removed from solution and placed within a new, more crowded environment. For instance, we have found that compounds that convert to zwitterionic isomers upon light irradiation often experience stabilization of these forms under confinement. This effect results from the mutual stabilization of zwitterions that are brought into close proximity on surfaces or within cavities. Furthermore, photoswitches can experience preorganization under confinement, influencing the selectivity and efficiency of their photoreactions. Because intermolecular interactions arising from confinement cannot be considered independently from the effects of geometric constraints, we describe all confinement effects concurrently throughout this Account.

Improving Fatigue Resistance of Dihydropyrene by Encapsulation within a Coordination Cage

Photochromic molecules undergo reversible isomerization upon irradiation with light at different wavelengths, a process that can alter their physical and chemical properties. For instance, dihydropyrene (DHP) is a deep-colored compound that isomerizes to light-brown cyclophanediene (CPD) upon irradiation with visible light. CPD can then isomerize back to DHP upon irradiation with UV light or thermally in the dark. Conversion between DHP and CPD is thought to proceed via a biradical intermediate; bimolecular events involving this unstable intermediate thus result in rapid decomposition and poor cycling performance. Here, we show that the reversible isomerization of DHP can be stabilized upon confinement within a Pd^II₆L₄ coordination cage. By protecting this reactive intermediate using the cage, each isomerization reaction proceeds to higher yield, which significantly decreases the fatigue experienced by the system upon repeated photocycling. Although molecular confinement is known to help stabilize reactive species, this effect is not typically employed to protect reactive intermediates and thus improve reaction yields. We envisage that performing reactions under confinement will not only improve the cyclic performance of photochromic molecules, but may also increase the amount of product obtainable from traditionally low-yielding organic reactions.