Atom-by-Atom Evolution of the Same Ligand-Protected Au21, Au22, Au22Cd1, and Au24 Nanocluster Series

A concise guide to chemical reactions of atomically precise noble metal nanoclusters

Nanoparticles (NPs) with atomic precision, known as nanoclusters (NCs), are an emerging field in materials science in view of their fascinating structure-property relationships. Ultrasmall noble metal NPs have molecule-like properties that make them fundamentally unique compared with their plasmonic counterparts and bulk materials. In this review, we present a comprehensive account of the chemistry of monolayer-protected atomically precise noble metal nanoclusters with a focus on the chemical reactions, their diversity, associated kinetics, and implications. To begin with, we briefly review the history of the evolution of such precision materials. Then the review explores the diverse chemistry of noble metal nanoclusters, including ligand exchange reactions, ligand-induced structural transformations, and reactions with metal ions, metal thiolates, and halocarbons. Just as molecules do, these precision materials also undergo intercluster reactions in solution. Supramolecular forces between these systems facilitate the creation of well-defined hierarchical assemblies, composites, and hybrid materials. We conclude the review with a future perspective and scope of such chemistry.

Synthesis, structure anatomy, and catalytic properties of Ag14Cu2 nanoclusters co-protected by alkynyl and phosphine ligands

We report the synthesis, structure anatomy, and catalytic properties of Ag14Cu2(CCArF)14(PPh3)4 (CCArF: 3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenylacetylene) nanoclusters, denoted as Ag14Cu2. Ag14Cu2 has a robust electronic structure with two free valence electrons, and it has a distinctive absorbance feature. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD) disclosed that Ag14Cu2 possesses an octahedral Ag6 metal kernel capped by two Ag4Cu1(CCArF)7(PPh3)2 metal-ligand units. Remarkably, it exhibits excellent bifunctional catalytic performance for 4-nitrophenol reduction and the electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (eCO2RR). In 4-nitrophenol reduction, it adopts first-order reaction kinetics with a rate constant of 0.137 min-1, while in the eCO2RR, it shows a CO faradaic efficiency (FECO) of 83.71% and a high current density of 92.65 mA cm-2 at -1.6 V vs. RHE. Moreover, Ag14Cu2 showed robust long-term stability with no significant decay in current density and FECO over 10 h of continuous operation in the eCO2RR. This study not only enriches the potpourri of alkynyl-protected bimetallic AgCu nanoclusters, but also demonstrates the great potential of employing metal nanoclusters for bifunctional catalytic applications.

The role of metal accessibility on carbon dioxide electroreduction in atomically precise nanoclusters

Atomically precise nanoclusters (NCs) can be designed with high faradaic efficiency for the electrochemical reduction of CO2 to CO (FECO) and provide useful model systems for studying the metal-catalysed CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR). While size-dependent trends are commonly evoked, the effect of NC size on catalytic activity is often convoluted by other factors such as changes to surface structure, ligand density, and electronic structure, which makes it challenging to establish rigorous structure-property relationships. Herein, we report a detailed investigation of a series of NCs [AunAg46-n(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CR)24Cl4(PPh3)2, Au24Ag20(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CR)24Cl2, and Au43(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CR)20/Au42Ag1(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CR)20] with similar sizes and core structures but different ligand packing densities to investigate how the number of accessible metal sites impacts CO2RR activity and selectivity. We develop a simple method to determine the number of CO2-accessible sites for a given NC then use this to probe relationships between surface accessibility and CO2RR performance for atomically precise NC catalysts. Specifically, the NCs with the highest number of accessible metal sites [Au43(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CR)20 and Au42Ag1(C[triple bond, length as m-dash]CR)20] feature a FECO of >90% at -0.57 V vs. the reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE), while NCs with lower numbers of accessible metal sites have a reduced FECO. In addition, CO2RR studies performed on other Au-alkynyl NCs that span a wider range of sizes further support the relationship between FECO and the number of accessible metal sites, regardless of NC size. This work establishes a generalizable approach to evaluating the potential of atomically precise NCs for electrocatalysis.

Isostructural Nanocluster Manipulation Reveals Pivotal Role of One Surface Atom in Click Chemistry

Elucidating single-atom effects on the fundamental properties of nanoparticles is challenging because single-atom modifications are typically accompanied by appreciable changes to the overall particle's structure. Herein, we report the synthesis of a [Cu58 H20 PET36 (PPh3 )4 ]2+ (Cu58 ; PET: phenylethanethiolate; PPh3 : triphenylphosphine) nanocluster-an atomically precise nanoparticle-that can be transformed into the surface-defective analog [Cu57 H20 PET36 (PPh3 )4 ]+ (Cu57 ). Both nanoclusters are virtually identical, with five concentric metal shells, save for one missing surface copper atom in Cu57 . Remarkably, the loss of this single surface atom drastically alters the reactivity of the nanocluster. In contrast to Cu58 , Cu57 shows promising activity for click chemistry, particularly photoinduced [3+2] azide-alkyne cycloaddition (AAC), which is attributed to the active catalytic site in Cu57 after the removal of one surface copper atom. Our study not only presents a unique system for uncovering the effect of a single-surface atom modification on nanoparticle properties but also showcases single-atom surface modification as a powerful means for designing nanoparticle catalysts.

Recent developments in the investigation of driving forces for transforming coinage metal nanoclusters

Metal nanoclusters serve as an emerging class of modular nanomaterials. The transformation of metal nanoclusters has been fully reflected in their studies from every aspect, including the structural evolution analysis, physicochemical property regulation, and practical application promotion. In this review, we highlight the driving forces for transforming atomically precise metal nanoclusters and summarize the related transforming principles and fundamentals. Several driving forces for transforming nanoclusters are meticulously reviewed herein: ligand-exchange-induced transformations, metal-exchange-induced transformations, intercluster reactions, photochemical transformations, oxidation/reduction-induced transformations, and other factors (intrinsic instability, pH, temperature, and metal salts) triggering transformations. The exploitation of transforming principles to customize the preparations, structures, physicochemical properties, and practical applications of metal nanoclusters is also disclosed. At the end of this review, we provide our perspectives and highlight the challenges remaining for future research on the transformation of metal nanoclusters. Our intended audience is the broader scientific community interested in metal nanoclusters, and we believe that this review will provide researchers with a comprehensive synthetic toolbox and insights on the research fundamentals needed to realize more cluster-based nanomaterials with customized compositions, structures, and properties.

Cd Atom Goes into the Interior of Cluster Induced by Directional Consecutive Assembly of Tetrahedral Units on an Icosahedron Kernel

"Core sliding" in metal nanoclusters drives the reconstruction of external structural units and provides an ideal platform for mapping their precise transformation mechanism and evolution pathway. However, observing the movement behavior of metal atoms in experiments is still challenging because of the uncertain stability of intermediates. In this work, a series of Au-Cd alloy nanoclusters with continuously assembled kernels (one icosahedral building block assembled with 0 to 3 tetrahedral units) were constructed. As the assembly continued, it eventually led to the Cd atom doping into the inner positions of the clusters. Importantly, the Cd doped into the interior of the cluster exhibits a different behavior than the surface or external Cd atoms (dispersion doping vs localized occupy), which provides experimental evidence of the sliding behavior in the nanocluster kernel. Furthermore, density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that this sliding behavior in the inner sites of nanoclusters is an energetically favorable process. In addition, these Au-Cd nanoclusters exhibit tunable optical properties with different assembly patterns in their kernels.

Suppression of kernel vibrations by layer-by-layer ligand engineering boosts photoluminescence efficiency of gold nanoclusters

The restriction of structural vibration has assumed great importance in attaining bright emission of luminescent metal nanoclusters (NCs), where tremendous efforts are devoted to manipulating the surface landscape yet remain challenges for modulation of the structural vibration of the metal kernel. Here, we report efficient suppression of kernel vibration achieving enhancement in emission intensity, by rigidifying the surface of metal NCs and propagating as-developed strains into the metal core. Specifically, a layer-by-layer triple-ligands surface engineering is deployed to allow the solution-phase Au NCs with strong metal core-dictated fluorescence, up to the high absolute quantum yields of 90.3 ± 3.5%. The as-rigidified surface imposed by synergistic supramolecular interactions greatly influences the low-frequency acoustic vibration of the metal kernel, resulting in a subtle change in vibration frequency but a reduction in amplitude of oscillation. This scenario therewith impedes the non-radiative relaxation of electron dynamics, rendering the Au NCs with strong emission. The presented study exemplifies the linkage between surface chemistry and core-state emission of metal NCs, and proposes a strategy for brighter emitting metal NCs by regulating their interior metal core-involved motion.

Alloying and dealloying of Au18Cu32 nanoclusters at precise locations via controlling the electronegativity of substituent groups on thiol ligands

The doping site of metals in an alloy nanocluster plays a key role in determining the cluster properties. Herein, we found that alloying engineering was achieved by replacing Cu at specific positions in the second layer Cu₂₀ shell of the [Au18Cu32(SR-O)36]2- or [Au18Cu32(SR-F)36]3- (SR-O = -S-PhOMe; SR-F = -SC₆H₃^3,4F₂) nanocluster with Au to generate a core-shell [Au20.31Cu29.69(SR-O)36]2- protected by mercaptan ligands with electron-donating substituents, which could be stable obtained compared with the alloyed nanocluster with electron-withdrawing substituent ligands. Moreover, dealloying engineering was accomplished by an electron-withdrawing substituent ligand exchange strategy (i.e., [Au18Cu32(SR-F)36]2-). The abovementioned reaction was analyzed using single-crystal X-ray crystallography, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and monitored via time-dependent ultraviolet-visible absorption spectroscopy. This reversible and precise location of alloying and dealloying provides the possibility for studying the relationship between the structure and properties of nanoclusters at the atomic level.

Isomerism effects in relaxation dynamics of Au24(SR)16thiolate-protected gold nanoclusters

Understanding the excited state behavior of isomeric structures of thiolate-protected gold nanoclusters is still a challenging task. In this paper, based on grand unified model and ring model for describing thiolate-protected gold nanoclusters, we have predicted four isomers of Au₂₄(SR)₁₆nanoclusters. Density functional theory calculations show that the total energy of one of the predicted isomers is 0.1 eV lower in energy than previously crystallized isomer. The nonradiative relaxation dynamics simulations of Au₂₄(SH)₁₆isomers are performed to reveal the effects of structural isomerism on relaxation process of the lowest energy states, in which that most of the low-excited states consist of core states. In addition, crystallized isomer possesses the shorter e-h recombination time, whereas the most stable isomer has the longer recombination time, which may be attributed to the synergistic effect of nonadiabatic coupling and decoherence time. Our results could provide practical guidance to predict new gold nanoclusters for future experimental synthesis, and stimulate the exploration of atomic structures of same sized gold nanoclusters for photovoltaic and optoelectronic devices.

Superatomic Three-Center Bond in a Tri-Icosahedral Au36Ag2(SR)18 Cluster: Analogue of 3c-2e Bond in Molecules

Probing the nature of electronic stability for ligand-protected gold clusters is important in gold chemistry. A thermally stable Au₃₆Ag₂(SR)₁₈ nanocluster was synthesized recently. It has a D_3h tri-icosahedral [Au₃₀Ag₂]¹²⁺ core with 20 valence electrons, which does not follow the magic number of gold superatoms. Herein, we propose a superatomic three-center bond to unveil its electronic stability. The [Au₃₀Ag₂]¹²⁺ core is viewed as a union of three face-fused superatoms, and chemical bonding analysis suggests a three-superatom-center two-electron (3sc-2e) bond for the octet rule of each superatom, which mimics the bonding framework of the D_3h O₃^2- molecule. Moreover, a liganded tri-icosahedral [Au₂₇Pt₃Ag₂]¹¹⁺ core with 18 valence electrons is predicted, and three 2sc-2e bonds are formed between each of two superatoms to satisfy the octet rule (analogue of D_3h O₃), indicating the flexibility of superatomic bonding. Such a superatomic three-center bond extends the community of superatomic bonding and gives a new perspective for superatom assembling.

Atomically Precise Au42 Nanorods with Longitudinal Excitons for an Intense Photothermal Effect

Metallic-state gold nanorods are well known to exhibit strong longitudinal plasmon excitations in the near-infrared region (NIR) suitable for photothermal conversion. However, when the size decreases below ∼2 nm, Au nanostructures become nonmetallic, and whether the longitudinal excitation in plasmonic nanorods can be inherited is unknown. Here, we report atomically precise rod-shaped Au₄₂(SCH₂Ph)₃₂ with a hexagonal-close-packed Au₂₀ kernel of aspect ratio as high as 6.2, which exhibits an intense absorption at 815 nm with a high molar absorption coefficient of 1.4 × 10⁵ M^-1 cm^-1. Compared to other rod-shaped nanoclusters, Au₄₂ possesses a much more effective photothermal conversion with a large temperature increase of ∼27 °C within 5 min (λ_ex = 808 nm, 1 W cm^-2) at an ultralow concentration of 50 μg mL^-1 in toluene. Density functional theory calculations show that the NIR transition is mainly along the long axis of the Au₂₀ kernel in Au₄₂, i.e., a longitudinal excitonic oscillation, akin to the longitudinal plasmon in metallic-state nanorods. Transient absorption spectroscopy reveals that the fast decay in Au₄₂ is similar to that of shorter-aspect-ratio nanorods but is followed by an additional slow decay with a long lifetime of 2400 ns for the Au₄₂ nanorod. This work provides the first case that an intense longitudinal excitation is obtained in molecular-like nanorods, which can be used as photothermal converters and hold potential in biomedical therapy, photoacoustic imaging, and photocatalysis.

Atomic structure of a seed-sized gold nanoprism

The growth of nanoparticles along one or two directions leads to anisotropic nanoparticles, but the nucleation (i.e., the formation of small seeds of specific shape) has long been elusive. Here, we show the total structure of a seed-sized Au₅₆ nanoprism, in which the side Au{100} facets are surrounded by bridging thiolates, whereas the top/bottom {111} facets are capped by phosphine ligands at the corners and Br⁻ at the center. The bromide has been proved to be the key to effectively stabilize the Au{111} to fulfill a complete face-centered-cubic core. In femtosecond electron dynamics analysis, the non-evolution of transient absorption spectra of Au₅₆ is similar to that of larger-sized gold nanoclusters (n > 100), which is ascribed to the completeness of the prismatic Au₅₆ core and an effective electron relaxation pathway created by the stronger Au-Au bonds inside. This work provides some insights for the understanding of plasmonic nanoprism formation.

The formation pathway of shape-anisotropic nanoparticles is difficult to characterize and not well understood. The authors synthesize a prismatic-shaped Au₅₆ nanocluster as possible seed of a prismatic nanoparticle and characterize the structure and ligand bonding motifs, providing insight into the formation and surface protection mechanisms.

Master key to coinage metal nanoclusters treasure chest: 38-metal clusters

Atomically precise metal nanoclusters with specific chemical compositions have become a popular research topic due to their precise structures, attractive properties, and wide range of applications in various fields. Currently, among more than 100 reported metal nanoclusters with precise formulas, 38-atom coinage metal nanoclusters stand out due to their unique structural diversities, such as face-centered cubic (FCC) and body-centered cubic (BCC) arrangements. Among them, the formation of the metal cores includes vertex-sharing, face-fusion, and FCC cubes fusion. Due to their geometrical features, 38-atom coinage metal nanoclusters exhibit attractive properties, making them an ideal model for exploring structure-property relationships. Therefore, 38-atom coinage metal nanoclusters are a universal key to the treasure trove of nanoclusters, which can open almost all fields and are of great research significance. This paper focuses on the structure of 38-atom coinage metal nanoclusters and reviews the preparation and crystallization methods, excellent properties, and practical applications. Finally, future research prospects and development opportunities are provided.

Total Structure of Bimetallic Core-Shell [Au42 Cd40 (SR)52 ]2- Nanocluster and Its Implications

Bimetallic core-shell nanostructures hold great promise in elucidating the bimetallic synergism. However, it remains a challenge to construct atomically precise core-shell with high-valence active metals on the gold surface. In this work, we report the total structure of a [Au₄₂ Cd₄₀ (SR)₅₂ ]^2- core-shell nanocluster and multiple implications. Single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) reveals that the structure possesses a two-shelled Au₆ @Au₃₆ core and a closed cadmium shell of Cd₄₀ , and the core-shell structure is then protected by 52 thiolate (-SR) ligands. The composition of the nanocluster is further confirmed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). A catalytic test for styrene oxidation and a comparison with relevant nanoclusters reveal the surface effect on the catalytic activity and selectivity.

Correlating structural rules with electronic properties of ligand-protected alloy nanoclusters

Thiolate protected gold nanoclusters (TPNCs) are a unique class of nanomaterials finding applications in various fields, such as biomedicine, optics, and catalysis. The atomic precision of their structure, characterized through single crystal x-ray diffraction, enables the accurate investigation of their physicochemical properties through electronic structure calculations. Recent experimental efforts have led to the successful heterometal doping of TPNCs, potentially unlocking a large domain of bimetallic TPNCs for targeted applications. However, how TPNC size, bimetallic composition, and location of dopants influence electronic structure is unknown. To this end, we introduce novel structure-property relationships (SPRs) that predict electronic properties such as ionization potential (IP) and electron affinity (EA) of AgAu TPNCs based on physically relevant descriptors. The models are constructed by first generating a hypothetical AgAu TPNC dataset of 368 structures with sizes varying from 36 to 279 metal atoms. Using our dataset calculated with density functional theory (DFT), we employed systematic analyses to unravel size, composition, and, importantly, core-shell effects on TPNC EA and IP behavior. We develop generalized SPRs that are able to predict electronic properties across the AgAu TPNC materials space. The models leverage the same three fundamental descriptors (i.e., size, composition, and core-shell makeup) that do not require DFT calculations and rely only on simple atom counting, opening avenues for high throughput bimetallic TPNC screening for targeted applications. This work is a first step toward finely controlling TPNC electronic properties through heterometal doping using high throughput computational means.

[Cu36H10(PET)24(PPh3)6Cl2] Reveals Surface Vacancy Defects in Ligand-Stabilized Metal Nanoclusters

Precise identification and in-depth understanding of defects in nanomaterials can aid in rationally modulating defect-induced functionalities. However, few studies have explored vacancy defects in ligand-stabilized metal nanoclusters with well-defined structures, owing to the substantial challenge of synthesizing and isolating such defective metal nanoclusters. Herein, a novel defective copper hydride nanocluster, [Cu₃₆H₁₀(PET)₂₄(PPh₃)₆Cl₂] (Cu36; PET: phenylethanethiolate; PPh₃: triphenylphosphine), is successfully synthesized at the gram scale via a simple one-pot reduction method. Structural analysis reveals that Cu36 is a distorted half cubic nanocluster, evolved from the perfect Nichol's half cube. The two surface copper vacancies in Cu36 are found to be the principal imperfections, which result in some structural adjustments, including copper atom reconstruction near the vacancies as well as ligand modifications (e.g., substitution, migration, and exfoliation). Density functional theory calculations imply that the above-mentioned defects have a considerable influence on the electronic structure and properties. The modeling suggests that the formation of defective Cu36 rather than the perfect half cube is driven by the enlargement of the energy gap between the highest occupied molecular orbital and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital of the nanocluster. The structural evolution induced by the surface copper atom vacancies provides atomically precise insights into the defect-induced readjustment of the local structure and introduces new avenues for understanding the chemistry of defects in nanomaterials.

High photoluminescence from self-assembled Ag2Cl2(dppe)2 clusters through metallophilic interactions

Ligand protected metal nanoclusters (NCs) are an emerging class of functional materials with intriguing photophysical and chemical properties. The size and molecular structure play an important role in endowing NCs with characteristic optical and electronic properties. Modulation of these properties through the chemical reactivity of NCs is largely unexplored. Here, we report on the synthesis of self-assembled Ag₂Cl₂(dppe)₂ clusters through the ligand-exchange-induced transformation of [Pt₂Ag₂₃Cl₇(PPh₃)₁₀] NCs [(dppe): 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane; (PPh₃): triphenylphosphine]. The single crystal x-ray structure reveals that two Ag atoms are bridged by one dppe and two Cl ligands, forming a Ag₂Cl₂(dppe) cluster, which is subsequently self-assembled through dppe ligands to form [Ag₂Cl₂(dppe)₂]_n. Importantly, the Ag₂Cl₂(dppe)₂ cluster assembly exhibits high photoluminescence quantum yield: ∼18%, which is attributed to the metallophilic interactions and rigidification of the ligand shell. We hope that this work will motivate the exploitation of the chemical reactivity of NCs as a new path to attain cluster assemblies endowed with enhanced photophysical properties.

Role of Small Moiety of a Large Ligand: Tyrosine Templated Copper Nanoclusters

To explore the underlying formation mechanism of luminescent metal nanoclusters (NCs) using a small moiety such as amino acids (outside the milieu of a protein environment) as templates, herein we report blue-emitting copper nanoclusters (CuNCs) using l-tyrosine (l-Tyr) as a capping agent as well as a reducing agent. We also demonstrate the effect of an in situ fibrillation of Tyr on the luminescence and structural properties of NCs. Fluorescence studies along with microscopic imaging revealed the rapid formation of a dityrosine (di-Tyr) moiety in an alkaline medium followed by an aggregated "Tamarix dioica leaf"-like fibrillar pattern along with CuNCs. Our present investigation delineates the role played by π-π interactions in the formation of the fibrillar structures. We substantiated the fundamentals of using a small molecule of a large ligand that can serve as a template and also show how these NCs once formed destroy the fibrils of di-Tyr as a function of time.

Surface engineering of linearly fused Au13 units using diphosphine and Cd doping

Herein, surface engineering was delicately performed to assemble two new Au-Cd alloy nanoclusters, including [Cd2Au17(S-c-C6H11)12(DPPP)2](BPh4) and Cd2Au29(TBBT)17(DPPF)2. Both the Au13 (in Cd2Au17) and Au25 (in Cd2Au29) cores were covered by two identical Au2Cd(SR)6 motifs and two diphosphine ligands. In addition, their optical properties were explored to give clues on the kernel- and surface-dependent electronic structures.