A Functional Model of [Fe]-Hydrogenase

Molecular Dihydrogen Activation by (C5Me5)M/N (M=Rh, Ir) Transition Metal Frustrated Lewis Pairs: Reversible Proton Migration to, and Proton Abstraction from, the C5Me5 Ligand

The masked transition-metal frustrated Lewis pairs [Cp*M(κ3N,N',N''-L)][SbF6] (Cp*=η5-C5Me5; M=Ir, 1, Rh, 2; HL=pyridinyl-amidine ligand) reversibly activate H2 under mild conditions rendering the hydrido derivatives [Cp*MH(κ2N,N'-HL)][SbF6] observed as a mixture of the E and Z isomers at the amidine C=N bond (M=Ir, 3Z, 3E; M=Rh, 4Z, 4E). DFT calculations indicate that the formation of the E isomers follows a Grotthuss type mechanism in the presence of water. A mixture of Rh(I) isomers of formula [(Cp*H)Rh(κ2N,N'-HL)][SbF6] (5 a-d) is obtained by reductive elimination of Cp*H from 4. The formation of 5 a-d was elucidated by means of DFT calculations. Finally, when 2 reacts with D2, the Cp* and Cp*H ligands of the resulting rhodium complexes 4 and 5, respectively, are deuterated as a result of a reversible hydrogen abstraction from the Cp* ligand and D2 activation at rhodium.

trans-Di-bromido-tetra-kis-(5-methyl-1H-pyrazole-κN2)manganese(II)

The title compound, trans-di-bromido-tetra-kis-(5-methyl-1H-pyrazole-κN 2)manganese(II), [MnBr2(C4H6N2)4] or [Mn(3-MePzH)4Br2] (1) crystallizes in the triclinic P space group with the cell parameters a = 7.6288 (3), b = 8.7530 (4), c = 9.3794 (4) Å and α = 90.707 (4), β = 106.138 (4), γ = 114.285 (5)°, V = 542.62 (5) Å3, T = 120 K. The asymmetric unit contains only half the mol-ecule with the manganese atom is situated on a crystallographic inversion center. The 3-MePzH ligands are present in an AABB type manner with two methyl groups pointing up and the other two down. The supra-molecular architecture is characterized by several inter-molecular C-H⋯N, N-H⋯Br, and C-H⋯π inter-actions. Earlier, a polymorphic structure of [Mn(3-MePzH)4Br2] (2) with a similar geometry and also an AABB arrangement for the pyrazole ligands was described [Reedijk et al. (1971 ▸). Inorg. Chem. 10, 2594-2599; a = 8.802 (6), b = 9.695 (5), c = 7.613 (8) Å and α = 105.12 (4), β = 114.98 (4), γ = 92.90 (3)°, V = 558.826 (5) Å3, T = 295 K]. A varying supra-molecular pattern was reported, with the structure of 1 featuring a herringbone type pattern while that of structure 2 shows a pillared network type of arrangement along the a axis. A nickel complex [Ni(3-MePzH)4Br2] isomorphic to 1 and the analogous chloro derivatives of FeII, CoII and CuII are also known.

Polynuclear Iron(II) Pyridonates: Synthesis and Reactivity of Fe4 and Fe5 Clusters

The combination of pyridonate ligands with transition metal ions enables the synthesis of an especially rich set of diverse coordination compounds involving various κ- and μ-bonding modes and higher nuclearities. With iron(II) ions, this chemical space is rather poorly explored beyond some biomimetic models of the pyridone iron-containing hydrogenase. Here, the topologically new Fe₅ and Fe₄ clusters, Fe₅(L^H)₆[N(SiMe₃)₂]₄ (1) and Fe₄(L^Me)₆[N(SiMe₃)₂]₂ (2), were synthesized (L^H = 2-pyridonate; L^Me = 6-methyl-2-pyridonate). Complex 1 contained an unprecedented diamondoid Fe@Fe₄ tetrahedron with a central-to-peripheral Fe-Fe distance of ∼3.1 Å. The crystal structure of complex 2 displayed an Fe₄O₆ butterfly motif containing a planar Fe₄ arrangement. Mössbauer spectroscopy confirmed the high-spin ferrous character of all iron ions. SQUID magnetometry reveals that the Fe(II) ions are involved in weak magnetic exchange coupling across the pyridonate bridges that results in antiferromagnetic interactions. The Fe₄ cluster exhibits slow relaxation of magnetization under an applied magnetic field with an effective energy barrier of 38.5 K, rarely observed among the very rare examples of Fe(II) cluster-based single-molecule magnets. Studies of protolytic substitution of the amido ligands demonstrated the lability of the diamondoid Fe₅ core in 1 and the stability of the Fe₄ rhomboid in 2.

Biomimetic models of [Fe]-hydrogenase featuring a 2-acylphenylthiomethyl-6-R-pyridine (R = H or OMe) ligand

A new flexible pyridine ligand (FPL)-based method is developed, by which two novel biomimetic models of [Fe]-H2ase are prepared and their enzyme-like H2/D2 activation functions are studied.

Demethylation of Artificial Hydrogenase Agent for Prolonged CO Release and Enhanced Anti-Tau Aggregation Activity

Carbon Monoxide (CO) plays an important role in signaling in the cells, making its use as a therapeutic tool highly intriguing. Reduced burst emissions are important to avoid the cytotoxicity...

Scaffold-based [Fe]-hydrogenase model: H2 activation initiates Fe(0)-hydride extrusion and non-biomimetic hydride transfer

We report the synthesis and reactivity of a model of [Fe]-hydrogenase derived from an anthracene-based scaffold that includes the endogenous, organometallic acyl(methylene) donor. In comparison to other non-scaffolded acyl-containing complexes, the complex described herein retains molecularly well-defined chemistry upon addition of multiple equivalents of exogenous base. Clean deprotonation of the acyl(methylene) C–H bond with a phenolate base results in the formation of a dimeric motif that contains a new Fe–C(methine) bond resulting from coordination of the deprotonated methylene unit to an adjacent iron center. This effective second carbanion in the ligand framework was demonstrated to drive heterolytic H₂ activation across the Fe(ii) center. However, this process results in reductive elimination and liberation of the ligand to extrude a lower-valent Fe–carbonyl complex. Through a series of isotopic labelling experiments, structural characterization (XRD, XAS), and spectroscopic characterization (IR, NMR, EXAFS), a mechanistic pathway is presented for H₂/hydride-induced loss of the organometallic acyl unit (i.e. pyCH₂–C Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019 ]]> O → pyCH₃+C Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019 ]]> O). The known reduced hydride species [HFe(CO)₄]⁻ and [HFe₃(CO)₁₁]⁻ have been observed as products by ¹H/²H NMR and IR spectroscopies, as well as independent syntheses of PNP[HFe(CO)₄]. The former species (i.e. [HFe(CO)₄]⁻) is deduced to be the actual hydride transfer agent in the hydride transfer reaction (nominally catalyzed by the title compound) to a biomimetic substrate ([^TolIm](BAr^F) = fluorinated imidazolium as hydride acceptor). This work provides mechanistic insight into the reasons for lack of functional biomimetic behavior (hydride transfer) in acyl(methylene)pyridine based mimics of [Fe]-hydrogenase.

We report the synthesis and reactivity of a model of [Fe]-hydrogenase derived from an anthracene-based scaffold that includes the endogenous, organometallic acyl(methylene) donor.

Diversifying Metal-Ligand Cooperative Catalysis in Semi-Synthetic [Mn]-Hydrogenases

The reconstitution of [Mn]-hydrogenases using a series of MnI complexes is described. These complexes are designed to have an internal base or pro-base that may participate in metal-ligand cooperative catalysis or have no internal base or pro-base. Only MnI complexes with an internal base or pro-base are active for H2 activation; only [Mn]-hydrogenases incorporating such complexes are active for hydrogenase reactions. These results confirm the essential role of metal-ligand cooperation for H2 activation by the MnI complexes alone and by [Mn]-hydrogenases. Owing to the nature and position of the internal base or pro-base, the mode of metal-ligand cooperation in two active [Mn]-hydrogenases is different from that of the native [Fe]-hydrogenase. One [Mn]-hydrogenase has the highest specific activity of semi-synthetic [Mn]- and [Fe]-hydrogenases. This work demonstrates reconstitution of active artificial hydrogenases using synthetic complexes differing greatly from the native active site.

Deuteration mechanistic studies of hydrogenase mimics

The role of deuterium in disentangling key steps of the mechanisms of H₂ activation by mimics of hydrogenases is presented. These studies have allowed to a better understanding of the mode of action of the natural enzymes and their mimics.

Mononuclear Mn complexes featuring N,S-/N,N-donor and 1,3,5-triaza-7-phosphaadamantane ligands: synthesis and electrocatalytic properties

Mononuclear Mn(i) carbonyl complexes incorporating 2-mercaptobenzothiazole or 2-mercaptobenzimidazole and phosphaadamantane ligands were evaluated as electrocatalysts for the HER both in acetonitrile and acetonitrile/water.

Crystal Structures of [Fe]-Hydrogenase from Methanolacinia paynteri Suggest a Path of the FeGP-Cofactor Incorporation Process

[Fe]-hydrogenase (Hmd) catalyzes the reversible heterolytic cleavage of H2, and hydride transfer to methenyl-tetrahydromethanopterin (methenyl-H4MPT+). The iron-guanylylpyridinol (FeGP) cofactor, the prosthetic group of Hmd, can be extracted from the holoenzyme and inserted back into the protein. Here, we report the crystal structure of an asymmetric homodimer of Hmd from Methanolacinia paynteri (pHmd), which was composed of one monomer in the open conformation with the FeGP cofactor (holo-form) and a second monomer in the closed conformation without the cofactor (apo-form). In addition, we report the symmetric pHmd-homodimer structure in complex with guanosine monophosphate (GMP) or guanylylpyridinol (GP), in which each ligand was bound to the protein, where the GMP moiety of the FeGP-cofactor is bound in the holo-form. Binding of GMP and GP modified the local protein structure but did not induce the open conformation. The amino-group of the Lys150 appears to interact with the 2-hydroxy group of pyridinol ring in the pHmd–GP complex, which is not the case in the structure of the pHmd–FeGP complex. Lys150Ala mutation decreased the reconstitution rate of the active enzyme with the FeGP cofactor at the physiological pH. These results suggest that Lys150 might be involved in the FeGP-cofactor incorporation into the Hmd protein in vivo.

Membrane Inlet Mass Spectrometry: A Powerful Tool for Algal Research

Since the first great oxygenation event, photosynthetic microorganisms have continuously shaped the Earth's atmosphere. Studying biological mechanisms involved in the interaction between microalgae and cyanobacteria with the Earth's atmosphere requires the monitoring of gas exchange. Membrane inlet mass spectrometry (MIMS) has been developed in the early 1960s to study gas exchange mechanisms of photosynthetic cells. It has since played an important role in investigating various cellular processes that involve gaseous compounds (O2, CO2, NO, or H2) and in characterizing enzymatic activities in vitro or in vivo. With the development of affordable mass spectrometers, MIMS is gaining wide popularity and is now used by an increasing number of laboratories. However, it still requires an important theory and practical considerations to be used. Here, we provide a practical guide describing the current technical basis of a MIMS setup and the general principles of data processing. We further review how MIMS can be used to study various aspects of algal research and discuss how MIMS will be useful in addressing future scientific challenges.

Scaffold-Based Functional Models of [Fe]-Hydrogenase (Hmd): Building the Bridge between Biological Structure and Molecular Function

The well-known dinuclear [FeFe] and [NiFe] hydrogenase enzymes are redox-based proton reduction and H₂ oxidation catalysts. In comparison, the structural and functional aspects of the mononuclear nonredox hydrogenase, known as [Fe]-hydrogenase or Hmd, have been less explored because of the relatively recent crystallographic elucidation of the enzyme active site. Additionally, the synthetic challenges posed by the highly substituted and asymmetric coordination environment of the iron guanylylpyridinol (FeGP) cofactor have hampered functional biomimetic modeling studies to a large extent. The active site contains an octahedral low-spin Fe(II) center with the following coordination motifs: a bidentate acyl-pyridone moiety (C,N) and cysteinyl-S in a facial arrangement; two cis carbonyl ligands; and a H₂O/H₂ binding site. In [Fe]-hydrogenase, heterolytic H₂ activation putatively by the pendant pyridone/pyridonate-O base serving as a proton acceptor. Following H₂ cleavage, an intermediate Fe-H species is thought to stereoselectively transfer a hydride to the substrate methenyl-H₄MPT⁺, thus forming methylene-H₄MPT. In the past decade, chemists, inspired by the elegant organometallic chemistry inherent to the FeGP cofactor, have synthesized a number of faithful structural models. However, functional systems are still relatively limited and often rely on abiological ligands or metal centers that obfuscate a direct correlation to nature's design.Our group has developed a bioinspired suite of synthetic analogues of Hmd to better understand the effects of structure on the stability and functionality of the Hmd active site, with a special emphasis on using a scaffold-based ligand design. This systematic approach has contributed to a deeper understanding of the unique ligand array of [Fe]-hydrogenase in nature and has ultimately resulted in the first functional synthetic models without the aid of abiological ligands. This Account reviews the reactivity of the functional anthracene-scaffolded synthetic models developed by our group in the context of current mechanistic understanding drawn from both protein crystallography and computational studies. Furthermore, we introduce a novel thermodynamic framework to place the reactivity of our model systems in context and provide an outlook on the future study of [Fe]-hydrogenase synthetic models through both a structural and functional lens.

Biomimetic Hydrogenation Catalyzed by a Manganese Model of [Fe]-Hydrogenase

[Fe]-hydrogenase is an efficient biological hydrogenation catalyst. Despite intense research, Fe complexes mimicking the active site of [Fe]-hydrogenase have not achieved turnovers in hydrogenation reactions. Herein, we describe the design and development of a manganese(I) mimic of [Fe]-hydrogenase. This complex exhibits the highest activity and broadest scope in catalytic hydrogenation among known mimics. Thanks to its biomimetic nature, the complex exhibits unique activity in the hydrogenation of compounds analogous to methenyl-H₄ MPT⁺ , the natural substrate of [Fe]-hydrogenase. This activity enables asymmetric relay hydrogenation of benzoxazinones and benzoxazines, involving the hydrogenation of a chiral hydride transfer agent using our catalyst coupled to Lewis acid-catalyzed hydride transfer from this agent to the substrates.

Methanogenesis involves direct hydride transfer from H2 to an organic substrate

Certain anaerobic microorganisms evolved a mechanism to use H₂ as a reductant in their energy metabolisms. For these purposes, the microorganisms developed H₂-activating enzymes, which are aspirational catalysts in a sustainable hydrogen economy. In the case of the hydrogenotrophic pathway performed by methanogenic archaea, 8e^- are extracted from 4H₂ and used as reducing equivalents to convert CO₂ into CH₄. Under standard cultivation conditions, these archaea express [NiFe]-hydrogenases, which are Ni-dependent and Fe-dependent enzymes and heterolytically cleave H₂ into 2H⁺ and 2e^-, the latter being supplied into the central metabolism. Under Ni-limiting conditions, F₄₂₀-reducing [NiFe]-hydrogenases are downregulated and their functions are predominantly taken over by an upregulated [Fe]-hydrogenase. Unique in biology, this Fe-dependent hydrogenase cleaves H₂ and directly transfers H^- to an imidazolium-containing substrate. [Fe]-hydrogenase activates H₂ at an Fe cofactor ligated by two CO molecules, an acyl group, a pyridinol N atom and a cysteine thiolate as the central constituent. This Fe centre has inspired chemists to not only design synthetic mimics to catalytically cleave H₂ in solution but also for incorporation into apo-[Fe]-hydrogenase to give semi-synthetic proteins. This Perspective describes the enzymes involved in hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis, with a focus on those performing the reduction steps. Of these, we describe [Fe]-hydrogenases in detail and cover recent progress in their synthetic modelling.

Synthesis, characterization, and some properties of two types of new [Fe]-H2ase models containing a 4-phosphatopyridine or a 4-phosphatoguanosinepyridine moiety

The novel [Fe]-H₂ase active site framework-containing model 6 was first prepared and structurally characterized.

CNS and CNP Iron(II) Mono-Iron Hydrogenase (Hmd) Mimics: Role of Deprotonated Methylene(acyl) and the trans-Acyl Site in H2 Heterolysis

We report syntheses and H₂ activation involving model complexes of mono-iron hydrogenase (Hmd) derived from acyl-containing pincer ligand precursors bearing thioether (CNS^Pre) or phosphine (CNP^Pre) donor sets. Both complexes feature pseudo-octahedral iron(II) dicarbonyl units. While the CNS pincer adopts the expected mer-CNS (pincer) geometry, the CNP ligand unexpectedly adopts the fac-CNP coordination geometry. Both complexes exhibit surprisingly acidic methylene C-H bond (reversibly de/protonated by a bulky phenolate), which affords a putative dearomatized pyridinate-bound intermediate. Such base treatment of Fe-CNS also results in deligation of the thioether sulfur donor, generating an open coordination site trans from the acyl unit. In contrast, Fe-CNP maintains a CO ligand trans from the acyl site both in the parent and dearomatized complexes (the -PPh₂ donor is cis to acyl). The dearomatized mer-Fe-CNS was competent for H₂ activation (5 atm D_2(g) plus phenolate as base), which is attributed to both the basic site on the ligand framework and the open coordination site trans to the acyl donor. In contrast, the dearomatized fac-Fe-CNP was not competent for H₂ activation, which is ascribed to the blocked coordination site trans from acyl (occupied by CO ligand). These results highlight the importance of both (i) the open coordination site trans to the organometallic acyl donor and (ii) a pendant base in the enzyme active site.

A catalytically active [Mn]-hydrogenase incorporating a non-native metal cofactor

Nature carefully selects specific metal ions for incorporation into the enzymes that catalyze the chemical reactions necessary for life. Hydrogenases, enzymes that activate molecular H₂, exclusively utilize Ni and Fe in [NiFe]-, [FeFe]-, and [Fe]-hydrogeanses. However, other transition metals are known to activate or catalyze the production of hydrogen in synthetic systems. Here, we report the development of a biomimetic model complex of [Fe]-hydrogenase that incorporates a Mn, as opposed to a Fe, metal center. This Mn complex is able to heterolytically cleave H₂ as well as catalyze hydrogenation reactions. Incorporation of the model into an apoenzyme of [Fe]-hydrogenase results in a [Mn]-hydrogenase with enhanced occupancy-normalized activity over an analogous semi-synthetic [Fe]-hydrogenase. These findings represent the first instance of a non-native metal hydrogenase showing catalytic functionality and demonstrate that hydrogenases based on a manganese active site are viable.

Embedding a Ruthenium-Based Structural Mimic of the [Fe]-Hydrogenase Cofactor into Papain

We describe the synthesis of the ruthenacyclic carbamoyl complexes [Ru(2-NHC(O)C₅H₃NMe)(CO)₂( o,o-Me₂-C₆H₃S)(L)] (L = H₂O or MeCN), which have a labile water or acetonitrile ligand at their sixth coordination sites. Steric bulk around the ruthenium center is essential in preventing isomerization and dimerization, and embedding within papain can be achieved via coordination of its sole free cysteine residue. The observed chemistry parallels that of the natural [Fe]-hydrogenase.

Structural Mimics of the [Fe]-Hydrogenase: A Complete Set for Group VIII Metals

A set of structural mimics of the [Fe]-hydrogenase active site comprising all the group VIII metals, viz., [M(2-NHC(O)C₅H₄N)(CO)₂(2-S-C₅H₄N)], has been synthesized. They exist as a mixture of isomers in solution, and the relative stability of the isomers depends on the nature of the metal and the substituent at the 6-position of the pyridine ligand.

Dioxygen Sensitivity of [Fe]-Hydrogenase in the Presence of Reducing Substrates

Mono-iron hydrogenase ([Fe]-hydrogenase) reversibly catalyzes the transfer of a hydride ion from H₂ to methenyltetrahydromethanopterin (methenyl-H₄ MPT⁺ ) to form methylene-H₄ MPT. Its iron guanylylpyridinol (FeGP) cofactor plays a key role in H₂ activation. Evidence is presented for O₂ sensitivity of [Fe]-hydrogenase under turnover conditions in the presence of reducing substrates, methylene-H₄ MPT or methenyl-H₄ MPT⁺ /H₂ . Only then, H₂ O₂ is generated, which decomposes the FeGP cofactor; as demonstrated by spectroscopic analyses and the crystal structure of the deactivated enzyme. O₂ reduction to H₂ O₂ requires a reductant, which can be a catalytic intermediate transiently formed during the [Fe]-hydrogenase reaction. The most probable candidate is an iron hydride species; its presence has already been predicted by theoretical studies of the catalytic reaction. The findings support predictions because the same type of reduction reaction is described for ruthenium hydride complexes that hydrogenate polar compounds.

Frustration across the periodic table: heterolytic cleavage of dihydrogen by metal complexes

This perspective examines frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) in the context of heterolytic cleavage of H2 by transition metal complexes, with an emphasis on molecular complexes bearing an intramolecular Lewis base. FLPs have traditionally been associated with main group compounds, yet many reactions of transition metal complexes support a broader classification of FLPs that includes certain types of transition metal complexes with reactivity resembling main group-based FLPs. This article surveys transition metal complexes that heterolytically cleave H2, which vary in the degree that the Lewis pairs within these systems interact. Many of the examples include complexes bearing a pendant amine functioning as the base with the metal functioning as the hydride acceptor. Consideration of transition metal compounds in the context of FLPs can inspire new innovations and improvements in transition metal catalysis.This article is part of the themed issue 'Frustrated Lewis pair chemistry'.

Synthesis, Reactivity, and Catalytic Transfer Hydrogenation Activity of Ruthenium Complexes Bearing NNN Tridentate Ligands: Influence of the Secondary Coordination Sphere

By the introduction of -OH group(s) into different position(s) of 6-(pyridin-2-ylmethyl)-2,2'-bipyridine, several NNN-type ligands were synthesized and then introduced to ruthenium (Ru) centers by reactions with RuCl2(PPh3)3. In the presence of PPh3 or CO, these ruthenium complexes reacted with NH4PF6 in CH2Cl2 or CH3OH to give a series of ionic products 5-9. The reaction of Ru(L2)(PPh3)Cl2 (2) with CO generated a neutral complex [Ru(L2)(CO)Cl2] (10). In the presence of CH3ONa, 10 was further converted into complex [Ru(L2)(HOCH3)(CO)Cl] (11), in which there was a methanol molecule coordinating with ruthenium, as suggested by density functional theory calculations. The catalytic transfer hydrogenation activity of all of these new bifunctional metal-ligand complexes was tested. Dichloride complex 2 exhibits best activity, whereas carbonyl complexes 10 and 11 are efficient for selectively reducing 5-hexen-2-one, suggesting different hydrogenation mechanisms. The results reveal the dramatic influence for the reactivity and catalytic activity of the secondary coordination sphere in transition metal complexes.

Reversible Hydride Transfer to N,N'-Diarylimidazolinium Cations from Hydrogen Catalyzed by Transition Metal Complexes Mimicking the Reaction of [Fe]-Hydrogenase

[Fe]-hydrogenase is a key enzyme involved in methanogenesis and facilitates reversible hydride transfer from H₂ to N⁵,N¹⁰-methenyltetrahydromethanopterin (CH-H₄MPT⁺). In this study, a reaction system was developed to model the enzymatic function of [Fe]-hydrogenase by using N,N'-diphenylimidazolinium cation (1⁺) as a structurally related alternative to CH-H₄MPT⁺. In connection with the enzymatic mechanism via heterolytic cleavage of H₂ at the single metal active site, several transition metal complex catalysts capable of such activation were utilized in the model system. Reduction of 1[BF₄] to N,N'-diphenylimidazolidine (2) was achieved under 1 atm H₂ at ambient temperature in the presence of an equimolar amount of NEt₃ as a proton acceptor. The proposed catalytic pathways involved the generation of active hydride complexes and subsequent intermolecular hydride transfer to 1⁺. The reverse reaction was accomplished by treatment of 2 with HNMe₂Ph⁺ as the proton source, where [(η⁵-C₅Me₅)Ir{(p-MeC₆H₄SO₂)NCHPhCHPhNH}] was found to catalyze the formation of 1⁺ and H₂ with high efficiency. These results are consistent with the fact that use of 2,6-lutidine in the forward reaction or 2,6-lutidinium in the reverse reaction resulted in incomplete conversion. By combining these reactions using the above Ir amido catalyst, the reversible hydride transfer interconverting 1⁺/H₂ and 2/H⁺ was performed successfully. This system demonstrated the hydride-accepting and hydride-donating modes of biologically relevant N-heterocycles coupled with proton concentration. The influence of substituents on the forward and reverse reactivities was examined for the derivatives of 1⁺ and 2 bearing one para-substituted N-phenyl group.