Determining Membrane Protein-Lipid Binding Thermodynamics Using Native Mass Spectrometry

Insights into the Main Protease of SARS-CoV-2: Thermodynamic Analysis, Structural Characterization, and the Impact of Inhibitors

The main protease (Mpro) of SARS-CoV-2 is an essential enzyme for coronaviral maturation and is the target of Paxlovid, which is currently the standard-of-care treatment for COVID-19. There remains a need to identify new inhibitors of Mpro as viral resistance to Paxlovid emerges. Here, we report the use of native mass spectrometry coupled with 193 nm ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) and integrated with other biophysical tools to structurally characterize Mpro and its interactions with potential covalent inhibitors. The overall energy landscape was obtained using variable temperature nanoelectrospray ionization (vT-nESI), thus providing quantitative evaluation of inhibitor binding on the stability of Mpro. Thermodynamic parameters extracted from van't Hoff plots revealed that the dimeric complexes containing each inhibitor showed enhanced stability through increased melting temperatures as well as overall lower average charge states, giving insight into the basis for inhibition mechanisms.

Native Mass Spectrometry Reveals Binding Interactions of SARS-CoV-2 PLpro with Inhibitors and Cellular Targets

Here we used native mass spectrometry (native MS) to probe a SARS-CoV protease, PLpro, which plays critical roles in coronavirus disease by affecting viral protein production and antagonizing host antiviral responses. Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) and variable temperature electrospray ionization (vT ESI) were used to localize binding sites of PLpro inhibitors and revealed the stabilizing effects of inhibitors on protein tertiary structure. We compared PLpro from SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 in terms of inhibitor and ISG15 interactions to discern possible differences in protease function. A PLpro mutant lacking a single cysteine was used to localize inhibitor binding, and thermodynamic measurements revealed that inhibitor PR-619 stabilized the folded PLpro structure. These results will inform further development of PLpro as a therapeutic target against SARS-CoV-2 and other emerging coronaviruses.

Elucidating the role of lipid interactions in stabilizing the membrane protein KcsA

The significant effects of lipid binding on the functionality of potassium channel KcsA have been validated by brilliant studies. However, the specific interactions between lipids and KcsA, such as binding parameters for each binding event, have not been fully elucidated. In this study, we employed native mass spectrometry to investigate the binding of lipids to KcsA and their effects on the channel. The tetrameric structure of KcsA remains intact even in the absence of lipid binding. However, the subunit architecture of the E71A mutant, which is constantly open at low pH, relies on tightly associated copurified lipids. Furthermore, we observed that lipids exhibit weak binding to KcsA at high pH when the channel is at a closed/inactivation state in the absence of permeant cation K+. This feeble interaction potentially facilitates the association of K+ ions, leading to the transition of the channel to a resting closed/open state. Interestingly, both anionic and zwitterionic lipids strongly bind to KcsA at low pH when the channel is in an open/inactivation state. We also investigated the binding patterns of KcsA with natural lipids derived from E. coli and Streptomyces lividans. Interestingly, lipids from E. coli exhibited much stronger binding affinity compared to the lipids from S. lividans. Among the natural lipids from S. lividans, free fatty acids and triacylglycerols demonstrated the tightest binding to KcsA, whereas no detectable binding events were observed with natural phosphatidic acid lipids. These findings suggest that the lipid association pattern in S. lividans, the natural host for KcsA, warrants further investigation. In conclusion, our study sheds light on the role of lipids in stabilizing KcsA and highlights the importance of specific lipid-protein interactions in modulating its conformational states.

Native MS-guided lipidomics to define endogenous lipid microenvironments of eukaryotic receptors and transporters

The mammalian membrane is composed of various eukaryotic lipids interacting with extensively post-translationally modified proteins. Probing interactions between these mammalian membrane proteins and their diverse and heterogeneous lipid cohort remains challenging. Recently, native mass spectrometry (MS) combined with bottom-up 'omics' approaches has provided valuable information to relate structural and functional lipids to membrane protein assemblies in eukaryotic membranes. Here we provide a step-by-step protocol to identify and provide relative quantification for endogenous lipids bound to mammalian membrane proteins and their complexes. Using native MS to guide our lipidomics strategies, we describe the necessary sample preparation steps, followed by native MS data acquisition, tailored lipidomics and data interpretation. We also highlight considerations for the integration of different levels of information from native MS and lipidomics and how to deal with the various challenges that arise during the experiments. This protocol begins with the preparation of membrane proteins from mammalian cells and tissues for native MS. The results enable not only direct assessment of copurified endogenous lipids but also determination of the apparent affinities of specific lipids. Detailed sample preparation for lipidomics analysis is also covered, along with comprehensive settings for liquid chromatography-MS analysis. This protocol is suitable for the identification and quantification of endogenous lipids, including fatty acids, sterols, glycerolipids, phospholipids and glycolipids and can be used to interrogate proteins from recombinant sources to native membranes.

Enhanced Declustering Enables Native Top-Down Analysis of Membrane Protein Complexes using Ion-Mobility Time-Aligned Fragmentation

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is proving to be a disruptive technique for studying the interactions of proteins, necessary for understanding the functional roles of these biomolecules. Recent research is expanding the application of native MS towards membrane proteins directly from isolated membrane preparations or from purified detergent micelles. The former results in complex spectra comprising several heterogeneous protein complexes; the latter enables therapeutic protein targets to be screened against multiplexed preparations of compound libraries. In both cases, the resulting spectra are increasingly complex to assign/interpret, and the key to these new directions of native MS research is the ability to perform native top-down analysis, which allows unambiguous peak assignment. To achieve this, detergent removal is necessary prior to MS analyzers, which allow selection of specific m/z values, representing the parent ion for downstream activation. Here, we describe a novel, enhanced declustering (ED) device installed into the first pumping region of a cyclic IMS-enabled mass spectrometry platform. The device enables declustering of ions prior to the quadrupole by imparting collisional activation through an oscillating electric field applied between two parallel plates. The positioning of the device enables liberation of membrane protein ions from detergent micelles. Quadrupole selection can now be utilized to isolate protein-ligand complexes, and downstream collision cells enable the dissociation and identification of binding partners. We demonstrate that ion mobility (IM) significantly aids in the assignment of top-down spectra, aligning fragments to their corresponding parent ions by means of IM drift time. Using this approach, we were able to confidently assign and identify a novel hit compound against PfMATE, obtained from multiplexed ligand libraries.

Investigating Lipid Transporter Protein and Lipid Interactions Using Variable Temperature Electrospray Ionization, Ultraviolet Photodissociation Mass Spectrometry, and Collision Cross Section Analysis

Gram-negative bacteria develop and exhibit resistance to antibiotics, owing to their highly asymmetric outer membrane maintained by a group of six proteins comprising the Mla (maintenance of lipid asymmetry) pathway. Here, we investigate the lipid binding preferences of one Mla protein, MlaC, which transports lipids through the periplasm. We used ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) to identify and characterize modifications of lipids endogenously bound to MlaC expressed in three different bacteria strains. UVPD was also used to localize lipid binding to MlaC residues 130-140, consistent with the crystal structure reported for lipid-bound MlaC. The impact of removing the bound lipid from MlaC on its structure was monitored based on collision cross section measurements, revealing that the protein unfolded prior to release of the lipid. The lipid selectivity of MlaC was evaluated based on titrimetric experiments, indicating that MlaC-bound lipids in various classes (sphingolipids, glycerophospholipids, and fatty acids) as long as they possessed no more than two acyl chains.

Native mass spectrometry and structural studies reveal modulation of MsbA-nucleotide interactions by lipids

The ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter, MsbA, plays a pivotal role in lipopolysaccharide (LPS) biogenesis by facilitating the transport of the LPS precursor lipooligosaccharide (LOS) from the cytoplasmic to the periplasmic leaflet of the inner membrane. Despite multiple studies shedding light on MsbA, the role of lipids in modulating MsbA-nucleotide interactions remains poorly understood. Here we use native mass spectrometry (MS) to investigate and resolve nucleotide and lipid binding to MsbA, demonstrating that the transporter has a higher affinity for adenosine 5'-diphosphate (ADP). Moreover, native MS shows the LPS-precursor 3-deoxy-D-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid (Kdo)2-lipid A (KDL) can tune the selectivity of MsbA for adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) over ADP. Guided by these studies, four open, inward-facing structures of MsbA are determined that vary in their openness. We also report a 2.7 Å-resolution structure of MsbA in an open, outward-facing conformation that is not only bound to KDL at the exterior site, but with the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) adopting a distinct nucleotide-free structure. The results obtained from this study offer valuable insight and snapshots of MsbA during the transport cycle.

TREK2 Lipid Binding Preferences Revealed by Native Mass Spectrometry

TREK2, a two-pore domain potassium channel, is recognized for its regulation by various stimuli, including lipids. While previous members of the TREK subfamily, TREK1 and TRAAK, have been investigated to elucidate their lipid affinity and selectivity, TREK2 has not been similarly studied in this regard. Our findings indicate that while TRAAK and TREK2 exhibit similarities in terms of electrostatics and share an overall structural resemblance, there are notable distinctions in their interaction with lipids. Specifically, SAPI(4,5)P2,1-stearoyl-2-arachidonoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-myo-inositol-4',5'-bisphosphate) exhibits a strong affinity for TREK2, surpassing that of dOPI(4,5)P2,1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-myo-inositol-4',5'-bisphosphate), which differs in its acyl chains. TREK2 displays lipid binding preferences not only for the headgroup of lipids but also toward the acyl chains. Functional studies draw a correlation for lipid binding affinity and activity of the channel. These findings provide important insight into elucidating the molecular prerequisites for specific lipid binding to TREK2 important for function.

Native mass spectrometry of membrane protein-lipid interactions in different detergent environments

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is revealing the role of specific lipids in modulating membrane protein structure and function. Membrane proteins solubilized in detergents are often introduced into the mass spectrometer; however, commonly used detergents for structural studies, such as dodecylmaltoside, tend to generate highly charged ions, leading to protein unfolding, thereby diminishing their utility for characterizing protein-lipid interactions. Thus, there is a critical need to develop approaches to investigate protein-lipid interactions in different detergents. Here, we demonstrate how charge-reducing molecules, such as spermine and trimethylamine-N-oxide, enable characterization of lipid binding to the bacterial water channel (AqpZ) and ammonia channel (AmtB) in complex with regulatory protein GlnK in different detergent environments. We find protein-lipid interactions are not only protein-dependent but can also be influenced by the detergent and type of charge-reducing molecule. AqpZ-lipid interactions are enhanced in LDAO (n-dodecyl-N,N-dimethylamine-N-oxide), whereas the interaction of AmtB-GlnK with lipids is comparable among different detergents. A fluorescent lipid binding assay also shows detergent dependence for AqpZ-lipid interactions, consistent with results from native MS. Taken together, native MS will play a pivotal role in establishing optimal experimental parameters that will be invaluable for various applications, such as drug discovery, as well as biochemical and structural investigations.

Simultaneous Native Mass Spectrometry Analysis of Single and Double Mutants To Probe Lipid Binding to Membrane Proteins

Lipids are critical modulators of membrane protein structure and function. However, it is challenging to investigate the thermodynamics of protein-lipid interactions because lipids can simultaneously bind membrane proteins at different sites with different specificities. Here, we developed a native mass spectrometry (MS) approach using single and double mutants to measure the relative energetic contributions of specific residues on Aquaporin Z (AqpZ) toward cardiolipin (CL) binding. We first mutated potential lipid-binding residues on AqpZ, and mixed mutant and wild-type proteins together with CL. By using native MS to simultaneously resolve lipid binding to the mutant and wild-type proteins in a single spectrum, we directly determined the relative affinities of CL binding, thereby revealing the relative Gibbs free energy change for lipid binding caused by the mutation. Comparing different mutants revealed that W14 contributes to the tightest CL binding site, with R224 contributing to a lower affinity site. Using double mutant cycling, we investigated the synergy between W14 and R224 sites on CL binding. Overall, this novel native MS approach provides unique insights into the binding of lipids to specific sites on membrane proteins.

A non-FRET DNA reporter that changes fluorescence colour upon nuclease digestion

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) reporters are commonly used in the final stages of nucleic acid amplification tests to indicate the presence of nucleic acid targets, where fluorescence is restored by nucleases that cleave the FRET reporters. However, the need for dual labelling and purification during manufacturing contributes to the high cost of FRET reporters. Here we demonstrate a low-cost silver nanocluster reporter that does not rely on FRET as the on/off switching mechanism, but rather on a cluster transformation process that leads to fluorescence color change upon nuclease digestion. Notably, a 90 nm red shift in emission is observed upon reporter cleavage, a result unattainable by a simple donor-quencher FRET reporter. Electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry results suggest that the stoichiometric change of the silver nanoclusters from Ag13 (in the intact DNA host) to Ag10 (in the fragments) is probably responsible for the emission colour change observed after reporter digestion. Our results demonstrate that DNA-templated silver nanocluster probes can be versatile reporters for detecting nuclease activities and provide insights into the interactions between nucleases and metallo-DNA nanomaterials.

Dynamic framework for large-scale modeling of membranes and peripheral proteins

In this chapter, we present a novel computational framework to study the dynamic behavior of extensive membrane systems, potentially in interaction with peripheral proteins, as an alternative to conventional simulation methods. The framework effectively describes the complex dynamics in protein-membrane systems in a mesoscopic particle-based setup. Furthermore, leveraging the hydrodynamic coupling between the membrane and its surrounding solvent, the coarse-grained model grounds its dynamics in macroscopic kinetic properties such as viscosity and diffusion coefficients, marrying the advantages of continuum- and particle-based approaches. We introduce the theoretical background and the parameter-space optimization method in a step-by-step fashion, present the hydrodynamic coupling method in detail, and demonstrate the application of the model at each stage through illuminating examples. We believe this modeling framework to hold great potential for simulating membrane and protein systems at biological spatiotemporal scales, and offer substantial flexibility for further development and parametrization.

Phospholipids Differentially Regulate Ca2+ Binding to Synaptotagmin-1

Synaptotagmin-1 (Syt-1) is a calcium sensing protein that is resident in synaptic vesicles. It is well established that Syt-1 is essential for fast and synchronous neurotransmitter release. However, the role of Ca2+ and phospholipid binding in the function of Syt-1, and ultimately in neurotransmitter release, is unclear. Here, we investigate the binding of Ca2+ to Syt-1, first in the absence of lipids, using native mass spectrometry to evaluate individual binding affinities. Syt-1 binds to one Ca2+ with a KD ∼ 45 μM. Each subsequent binding affinity (n ≥ 2) is successively unfavorable. Given that Syt-1 has been reported to bind anionic phospholipids to modulate the Ca2+ binding affinity, we explored the extent that Ca2+ binding was mediated by selected anionic phospholipid binding. We found that phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PI(4,5)P2) and dioleoylphosphatidylserine (DOPS) positively modulated Ca2+ binding. However, the extent of Syt-1 binding to phosphatidylinositol 3,5-bisphosphate (PI(3,5)P2) was reduced with increasing [Ca2+]. Overall, we find that specific lipids differentially modulate Ca2+ binding. Given that these lipids are enriched in different subcellular compartments and therefore may interact with Syt-1 at different stages of the synaptic vesicle cycle, we propose a regulatory mechanism involving Syt-1, Ca2+, and anionic phospholipids that may also control some aspects of vesicular exocytosis.

Overcoming aggregation with laser heated nanoelectrospray mass spectrometry: thermal stability and pathways for loss of bicarbonate from carbonic anhydrase II

Variable temperature electrospray mass spectrometry is useful for multiplexed measurements of the thermal stabilities of biomolecules, but the ionization process can be disrupted by aggregation-prone proteins/complexes that have irreversible unfolding transitions. Resistively heating solutions containing a mixture of bovine carbonic anhydrase II (BCAII), a CO2 fixing enzyme involved in many biochemical pathways, and cytochrome c leads to complete loss of carbonic anhydrase signal and a significant reduction in cytochrome c signal above ∼72 °C due to aggregation. In contrast, when the tips of borosilicate glass nanoelectrospray emitters are heated with a laser, complete thermal denaturation curves for both proteins are obtained in <1 minute. The simultaneous measurements of the melting temperature of BCAII and BCAII bound to bicarbonate reveal that the bicarbonate stabilizes the folded form of this protein by ∼6.4 °C. Moreover, the temperature dependences of different bicarbonate loss pathways are obtained. Although protein analytes are directly heated by the laser for only 140 ms, heat conduction further up the emitter leads to a total analyte heating time of ∼41 s. Pulsed laser heating experiments could reduce this time to ∼0.5 s for protein aggregation that occurs on a faster time scale. Laser heating provides a powerful method for studying the detailed mechanisms of cofactor/ligand loss with increasing temperature and promises a new tool for studying the effect of ligands, drugs, growth conditions, buffer additives, or other treatments on the stabilities of aggregation-prone biomolecules.

The density-threshold affinity: Calculating lipid binding affinities from unbiased coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations

Many membrane proteins are sensitive to their local lipid environment. As structural methods for membrane proteins have improved, there is growing evidence of direct, specific binding of lipids to protein surfaces. Unfortunately the workhorse of understanding protein-small molecule interactions, the binding affinity for a given site, is experimentally inaccessible for these systems. Coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations can be used to bridge this gap, and are relatively straightforward to learn. Such simulations allow users to observe spontaneous binding of lipids to membrane proteins and quantify localized densities of individual lipids or lipid fragments. In this chapter we outline a protocol for extracting binding affinities from these localized distributions, known as the "density threshold affinity." The density threshold affinity uses an adaptive and flexible definition of site occupancy that alleviates the need to distinguish between "bound'' lipids and bulk lipids that are simply diffusing through the site. Furthermore, the method allows "bead-level" resolution that is suitable for the case where lipids share binding sites, and circumvents ambiguities about a relevant reference state. This approach provides a convenient and straightforward method for comparing affinities of a single lipid species for multiple sites, multiple lipids for a single site, and/or a single lipid species modeled using multiple forcefields.

Effects of Nano-Electrospray Ionization Emitter Position on Unintentional In-Source Activation of Peptide and Protein Ions

Native ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) typically introduces protein ions into the gas phase through nano-electrospray ionization (nESI). Many nESI setups have mobile stages for tuning the ion signal and extent of co-solute and salt adduction. However, tuning the position of the emitter capillary in nESI can have unintended downstream consequences for collision-induced unfolding or collision-induced dissociation (CIU/D) experiments. Here, we show that relatively small variations in the nESI emitter position can shift the midpoint (commonly called the "CID50" or "CIU50") potential of CID breakdown curves and CIU transitions by as much as 8 V on commercial instruments. A spatial "map" of the shift in CID50 for the loss of heme from holomyoglobin onto the emitter position on a Waters Synapt G2-Si mass spectrometer shows that emitter positions closer to the instrument inlet can result in significantly greater in-source activation, whereas different effects are found on an Agilent 6545XT instrument for the ions studied. A similar effect is observed for CID of the singly protonated leucine enkephalin peptide and Shiga toxin 1 subunit B homopentamer on the Waters Synapt G2-Si instrument. In-source activation effects on a Waters Synapt G2-Si are also investigated by examining the RMSD between CIU fingerprints acquired at different emitter positions and the shifts in CIU50 for structural transitions of bovine serum albumin and NIST monoclonal antibody.

Identification of Ligands for Ion Channels: TRPM2

Transient receptor potential melastatin 2 (TRPM2) is a calcium-permeable, nonselective cation channel with a widespread distribution throughout the body. It is involved in many pathological and physiological processes, making it a potential therapeutic target for various diseases, including Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, and cancers. New analytical techniques are beneficial for gaining a deeper understanding of its involvement in disease pathogenesis and for advancing the drug discovery for TRPM2-related diseases. In this work, we present the application of collision-induced affinity selection mass spectrometry (CIAS-MS) for the direct identification of ligands binding to TRPM2. CIAS-MS circumvents the need for high mass detection typically associated with mass spectrometry of large membrane proteins. Instead, it focuses on the detection of small molecules dissociated from the ligand-protein-detergent complexes. This affinity selection approach consolidates all affinity selection steps within the mass spectrometer, resulting in a streamlined process. We showed the direct identification of a known TRPM2 ligand dissociated from the protein-ligand complex. We demonstrated that CIAS-MS can identify binding ligands from complex mixtures of compounds and screened a compound library against TRPM2. We investigated the impact of voltage increments and ligand concentrations on the dissociation behavior of the binding ligand, revealing a dose-dependent relationship.

Double and triple thermodynamic mutant cycles reveal the basis for specific MsbA-lipid interactions

Structural and functional studies of the ATP-binding cassette transporter MsbA have revealed two distinct lipopolysaccharide (LPS) binding sites: one located in the central cavity and the other at a membrane-facing, exterior site. Although these binding sites are known to be important for MsbA function, the thermodynamic basis for these specific MsbA-LPS interactions is not well understood. Here, we use native mass spectrometry to determine the thermodynamics of MsbA interacting with the LPS-precursor 3-deoxy-D-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid (Kdo)2-lipid A (KDL). The binding of KDL is solely driven by entropy, despite the transporter adopting an inward-facing conformation or trapped in an outward-facing conformation with adenosine 5'-diphosphate and vanadate. An extension of the mutant cycle approach is employed to probe basic residues that interact with KDL. We find the molecular recognition of KDL is driven by a positive coupling entropy (as large as -100 kJ/mol at 298 K) that outweighs unfavorable coupling enthalpy. These findings indicate that alterations in solvent reorganization and conformational entropy can contribute significantly to the free energy of protein-lipid association. The results presented herein showcase the advantage of native MS to obtain thermodynamic insight into protein-lipid interactions that would otherwise be intractable using traditional approaches, and this enabling technology will be instrumental in the life sciences and drug discovery.

Biophysical Characterization of RAS-SOS Complexes by Native Mass Spectrometry

RAS is regulated by specific guanine nucleotide exchange factors, such as Son of Sevenless (SOS), that activates RAS by facilitating the exchange of inactive, GDP-bound RAS with GTP. The catalytic activity of SOS is known to be allosterically modulated by an active, GTP-bound RAS. However, it remains poorly understood how oncogenic RAS mutants interact with SOS and modulate its activity. In this chapter, we describe the application of native mass spectrometry (MS) to monitor the assembly of the catalytic domain of SOS (SOScat) with RAS and cancer-associated mutants. Results from this approach have led to the discovery of different molecular assemblies and distinct conformers of SOScat engaging KRAS. It was also found that KRASG13D exhibits high affinity for SOScat and is a potent allosteric modulator of its SOScat activity. KRASG13D-GTP can allosterically increase the nucleotide exchange rate of KRAS at the active site by more than twofold compared to the wild-type protein. Furthermore, small-molecule RAS•SOS disruptors fail to dissociate KRASG13D•SOScat complexes, underscoring the need for more potent disruptors targeting oncogenic RAS mutants. Taken together, native MS will be instrumental in better understanding the interaction between oncogenic RAS mutants and SOS, which is of crucial importance for development of improved therapeutics.

Native mass spectrometry of proteoliposomes containing integral and peripheral membrane proteins

Cellular membranes are critical to the function of membrane proteins, whether they are associated (peripheral) or embedded (integral) within the bilayer. While detergents have contributed to our understanding of membrane protein structure and function, there remains challenges in characterizing protein-lipid interactions within the context of an intact membrane. Here, we developed a method to prepare proteoliposomes for native mass spectrometry (MS) studies. We first use native MS to detect the encapsulation of soluble proteins within liposomes. We then find the peripheral Gβ1γ2 complex associated with the membrane can be ejected and analyzed using native MS. Four different integral membrane proteins (AmtB, AqpZ, TRAAK, and TREK2), all of which have previously been characterized in detergent, eject from the proteoliposomes as intact complexes bound to lipids that have been shown to tightly associate in detergent, drawing a correlation between the two approaches. We also show the utility of more complex lipid environments, such as a brain polar lipid extract, and show TRAAK ejects from liposomes of this extract bound to lipids. These findings underscore the capability to eject protein complexes from membranes bound to both lipids and metal ions, and this approach will be instrumental in the identification of key protein-lipid interactions.

SIMULTANEOUS NATIVE MASS SPECTROMETRY ANALYSIS OF SINGLE AND DOUBLE MUTANTS TO PROBE LIPID BINDING TO MEMBRANE PROTEINS

Lipids are critical modulators of membrane protein structure and function. However, it is challenging to investigate the thermodynamics of protein-lipid interactions because lipids can simultaneously bind membrane proteins at different sites with different specificities. Here, we developed a native mass spectrometry (MS) approach using single and double mutants to measure the relative energetic contributions of specific residues on Aquaporin Z (AqpZ) toward cardiolipin (CL) binding. We first mutated potential lipid-binding residues on AqpZ, and mixed mutant and wild-type proteins together with CL. By using native MS to simultaneously resolve lipid binding to the mutant and wild-type proteins in a single spectrum, we directly determined the relative affinities of CL binding, thereby revealing the relative Gibbs free energy change for lipid binding caused by the mutation. Comparing different mutants revealed that the W14 contributes to the tightest CL binding site, with R224 contributing to a lower affinity site. Using double mutant cycling, we investigated the synergy between W14 and R224 sites on CL binding. Overall, this novel native MS approach provides unique insights into lipid binding to specific sites on membrane proteins.

A Critical Evaluation of Detergent Exchange Methodologies for Membrane Protein Native Mass Spectrometry

Membrane proteins (MPs) play many critical roles in cellular physiology and constitute the majority of current pharmaceutical targets. However, MPs are comparatively understudied relative to soluble proteins due to the challenges associated with their solubilization in membrane mimetics. Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as a useful technique to probe the structures of MPs. Typically, nMS studies using MPs have employed detergent micelles to solubilize the MP. Oftentimes, the detergent micelle that the MP was purified in will be exchanged into another detergent prior to analysis by nMS. While methodologies for performing detergent exchange have been extensively described in prior reports, the effectiveness of these protocols remains understudied. Here, we present a critical analysis of detergent exchange efficacy using several model transmembrane proteins and a variety of commonly used detergents, evaluating the completeness of the exchange using a battery of existing protocols. Our data include results for octyl glucoside (OG), octaethylene glycol monododecyl ether (C12E8), and tetraethylene glycol monooctyl ether (C8E4), and these data demonstrate that existing protocols are insufficient and yield incomplete exchange for the proteins under the conditions probed here. In some cases, our data indicate that up to 99% of the measured detergent corresponds to the original pre-exchange detergent rather than the desired post-exchange detergent. We conclude by discussing the need for new detergent exchange methodologies alongside improved exchange yield expectations for studying the potential influence of detergents on MP structures.

Development of an Automated, High-Throughput Methodology for Native Mass Spectrometry and Collision-Induced Unfolding

Native ion mobility mass spectrometry (nIM-MS) has emerged as a useful technology for the rapid evaluation of biomolecular structures. When combined with collisional activation in a collision-induced unfolding (CIU) experiment, nIM-MS experimentation can be leveraged to gain greater insight into biomolecular conformation and stability. However, nIM-MS and CIU remain throughput limited due to nonautomated sample preparation and introduction. Here, we explore the use of a RapidFire robotic sample handling system to develop an automated, high-throughput methodology for nMS and CIU. We describe native RapidFire-MS (nRapidFire-MS) capable of performing online desalting and sample introduction in as little as 10 s per sample. When combined with CIU, our nRapidFire-MS approach can be used to collect CIU fingerprints in 30 s following desalting by using size exclusion chromatography cartridges. When compared to nMS and CIU data collected using standard approaches, ion signals recorded by nRapidFire-MS exhibit identical ion collision cross sections, indicating that the same conformational populations are tracked by the two approaches. Our data further suggest that nRapidFire-MS can be extended to study a variety of biomolecular classes, including proteins and protein complexes ranging from 5 to 300 kDa and oligonucleotides. Furthermore, nRapidFire-MS data acquired for biotherapeutics suggest that nRapidFire-MS has the potential to enable high-throughput nMS analyses of biopharmaceutical samples. We conclude by discussing the potential of nRapidFire-MS for enabling the development of future CIU assays capable of catalyzing breakthroughs in protein engineering, inhibitor discovery, and formulation development for biotherapeutics.

Cardiolipin Regulates the Activity of the Mitochondrial ABC Transporter ABCB10

The ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter ABCB10 resides in the inner membrane of mitochondria and is implicated in erythropoiesis. Mitochondria from different cell types share some specific characteristics, one of which is the high abundance of cardiolipin. Although previous studies have provided insight into ABCB10, the affinity and selectivity of this transporter toward lipids, particularly those found in the mitochondria, remain poorly understood. Here, native mass spectrometry is used to directly monitor the binding events of lipids to human ABCB10. The results reveal that ABCB10 binds avidly to cardiolipin with an affinity significantly higher than that of other phospholipids. The first three binding events of cardiolipin display positive cooperativity, which is suggestive of specific cardiolipin-binding sites on ABCB10. Phosphatidic acid is the second-best binder of the lipids investigated. The bulk lipids, phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine, display the weakest binding affinity for ABCB10. Other lipids bind ABCB10 with a similar affinity. Functional assays show that cardiolipin regulates the ATPase activity of ABCB10 in a dose-dependent fashion. ATPase activity of ABCB10 was also impacted in the presence of other lipids but to a lesser extent than cardiolipin. Taken together, ABCB10 has a high binding affinity for cardiolipin, and this lipid also regulates the ATPase activity of the transporter.

Double and triple thermodynamic mutant cycles reveal the basis for specific MsbA-lipid interactions

Structural and functional studies of the ATP-binding cassette transporter MsbA have revealed two distinct lipopolysaccharide (LPS) binding sites: one located in the central cavity and the other at a membrane-facing, exterior site. Although these binding sites are known to be important for MsbA function, the thermodynamic basis for these specific MsbA-LPS interactions is not well understood. Here, we use native mass spectrometry to determine the thermodynamics of MsbA interacting with the LPS-precursor 3-deoxy-D-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid (Kdo)2-lipid A (KDL). The binding of KDL is solely driven by entropy, despite the transporter adopting an inward-facing conformation or trapped in an outward-facing conformation with adenosine 5'-diphosphate and vanadate. An extension of the mutant cycle approach is employed to probe basic residues that interact with KDL. We find the molecular recognition of KDL is driven by a positive coupling entropy (as large as -100 kJ/mol at 298K) that outweighs unfavorable coupling enthalpy. These findings indicate that alterations in solvent reorganization and conformational entropy can contribute significantly to the free energy of protein-lipid association. The results presented herein showcase the advantage of native MS to obtain thermodynamic insight into protein-lipid interactions that would otherwise be intractable using traditional approaches, and this enabling technology will be instrumental in the life sciences and drug discovery.

Identifying Membrane Protein-Lipid Interactions with Lipidomic Lipid Exchange-Mass Spectrometry

Lipids can play important roles in modulating membrane protein structure and function. However, it is challenging to identify natural lipids bound to membrane proteins in complex bilayers. Here, we developed lipidomic lipid exchange-mass spectrometry (LX-MS) to study the lipid affinity for membrane proteins on a lipidomic scale. We first mix membrane protein nanodiscs with empty nanodiscs that have no embedded membrane proteins. After allowing lipids to passively exchange between the two populations, we separate the two types of nanodiscs and perform lipidomic analysis on each with liquid chromatography and MS. Enrichment of lipids in the membrane protein nanodiscs reveals the affinity of individual lipids for binding the target membrane protein. We apply this approach to study three membrane proteins. With the Escherichia coli ammonium transporter AmtB and aquaporin AqpZ in nanodiscs with E. coli polar lipid extracts, we detected binding of cardiolipin and phosphatidyl-glycerol lipids to the proteins. With the acetylcholine receptor in nanodiscs with brain polar lipid extracts, we discovered a complex set of lipid interactions that depended on the head group and tail composition. Overall, lipidomic LX-MS provides a detailed understanding of the lipid-binding affinity and thermodynamics for membrane proteins in complex bilayers and provides a unique perspective on the chemical environment surrounding membrane proteins.

The solute carrier SPNS2 recruits PI(4,5)P2 to synergistically regulate transport of sphingosine-1-phosphate

Solute carrier spinster homolog 2 (SPNS2), one of only four known major facilitator superfamily (MFS) lysolipid transporters in humans, exports sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P) across cell membranes. Here, we explore the synergistic effects of lipid binding and conformational dynamics on SPNS2's transport mechanism. Using mass spectrometry, we discovered that SPNS2 interacts preferentially with PI(4,5)P2. Together with functional studies and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we identified potential PI(4,5)P2 binding sites. Mutagenesis of proposed lipid binding sites and inhibition of PI(4,5)P2 synthesis reduce S1P transport, whereas the absence of the N terminus renders the transporter essentially inactive. Probing the conformational dynamics of SPNS2, we show how synergistic binding of PI(4,5)P2 and S1P facilitates transport, increases dynamics of the extracellular gate, and stabilizes the intracellular gate. Given that SPNS2 transports a key signaling lipid, our results have implications for therapeutic targeting and also illustrate a regulatory mechanism for MFS transporters.

Dissecting the Thermodynamics of ATP Binding to GroEL One Nucleotide at a Time

Variable-temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) native mass spectrometry (nMS) is used to determine the thermodynamics for stepwise binding of up to 14 ATP molecules to the 801 kDa GroEL tetradecamer chaperonin complex. Detailed analysis reveals strong enthalpy-entropy compensation (EEC) for the ATP binding events leading to formation of GroEL-ATP₇ and GroEL-ATP₁₄ complexes. The observed variations in EEC and stepwise free energy changes of specific ATP binding are consistent with the well-established nested cooperativity model describing GroEL-ATP interactions, viz., intraring positive cooperativity and inter-ring negative cooperativity (Dyachenko A.; Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.2013, 110, 7235-7239). Entropy-driven ATP binding is to be expected for ligand-induced conformational changes of the GroEL tetradecamer, though the magnitude of the entropy change suggests that reorganization of GroEL-hydrating water molecules and/or expulsion of water from the GroEL cavity may also play key roles. The capability for determining complete thermodynamic signatures (ΔG, ΔH, and -TΔS) for individual ligand binding reactions for the large, nearly megadalton GroEL complex expands our fundamental view of chaperonin functional chemistry. Moreover, this work and related studies of protein-ligand interactions illustrate important new capabilities of vT-ESI-nMS for thermodynamic studies of protein interactions with ligands and other molecules such as proteins and drugs.

Optimization of a Digital Mass Filter for the Isolation of Intact Protein Complexes in Stability Zone 1,1

Digital mass filters are advantageous for the analysis of large molecules due to the ability to perform ion isolation of high-m/z ions without the generation of very high radio frequency (RF) and DC voltages. Experimentally determined Mathieu stability diagrams of stability zone 1,1 for capacitively coupled digital waveforms show a voltage offset between the quadrupole rod pairs is introduced by the capacitors which is dependent on the voltage magnitude of the waveform and the duty cycle. This changes the ion's a value from a = 0 to a < 0. These effects are illustrated for isolation for single-charge states for various protein complexes up to 800 kDa (GroEL) for stability zone 1,1. Isolation resolving power (m/Δm) of approximately 280 was achieved for an ion of m/z 12,315 (z = 65+ for 800.5 kDa GroEL D398A), which corresponds to an m/z window of 44.

Regulation of membrane protein structure and function by their lipid nano-environment

Transmembrane proteins comprise ~30% of the mammalian proteome, mediating metabolism, signalling, transport and many other functions required for cellular life. The microenvironment of integral membrane proteins (IMPs) is intrinsically different from that of cytoplasmic proteins, with IMPs solvated by a compositionally and biophysically complex lipid matrix. These solvating lipids affect protein structure and function in a variety of ways, from stereospecific, high-affinity protein-lipid interactions to modulation by bulk membrane properties. Specific examples of functional modulation of IMPs by their solvating membranes have been reported for various transporters, channels and signal receptors; however, generalizable mechanistic principles governing IMP regulation by lipid environments are neither widely appreciated nor completely understood. Here, we review recent insights into the inter-relationships between complex lipidomes of mammalian membranes, the membrane physicochemical properties resulting from such lipid collectives, and the regulation of IMPs by either or both. The recent proliferation of high-resolution methods to study such lipid-protein interactions has led to generalizable insights, which we synthesize into a general framework termed the 'functional paralipidome' to understand the mutual regulation between membrane proteins and their surrounding lipid microenvironments.

Mechanistic Insights into IscU Conformation Regulation for Fe-S Cluster Biogenesis Revealed by Variable Temperature Electrospray Ionization Native Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster (ISC) cofactors are required for the function of many critical cellular processes. In the ISC Fe-S cluster biosynthetic pathway, IscU assembles Fe-S cluster intermediates from iron, electrons, and inorganic sulfur, which is provided by the cysteine desulfurase enzyme IscS. IscU also binds to Zn, which mimics and competes for binding with the Fe-S cluster. Crystallographic and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic studies reveal that IscU is a metamorphic protein that exists in multiple conformational states, which include at least a structured form and a disordered form. The structured form of IscU is favored by metal binding and is stable in a narrow temperature range, undergoing both cold and hot denaturation. Interestingly, the form of IscU that binds IscS and functions in Fe-S cluster assembly remains controversial. Here, results from variable temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) native ion mobility mass spectrometry (nIM-MS) establish that IscU exists in structured, intermediate, and disordered forms that rearrange to more extended conformations at higher temperatures. A comparison of Zn-IscU and apo-IscU reveals that Zn(II) binding attenuates the cold/heat denaturation of IscU, promotes refolding of IscU, favors the structured and intermediate conformations, and inhibits the disordered high charge states. Overall, these findings provide a structural rationalization for the role of Zn(II) in stabilizing IscU conformations and IscS in altering the IscU active site to prepare for Zn(II) release and cluster synthesis. This work highlights how vT-ESI-nIM-MS can be applied as a powerful tool in mechanistic enzymology by providing details of relationships among temperature, protein conformations, and ligand/protein binding.

Structural basis for lipid and copper regulation of the ABC transporter MsbA

A critical step in lipopolysaccharide (LPS) biogenesis involves flipping lipooligosaccharide, an LPS precursor, from the cytoplasmic to the periplasmic leaflet of the inner membrane, an operation carried out by the ATP-binding cassette transporter MsbA. Although LPS binding to the inner cavity of MsbA is well established, the selectivity of MsbA-lipid interactions at other site(s) remains poorly understood. Here we use native mass spectrometry (MS) to characterize MsbA-lipid interactions and guide structural studies. We show the transporter co-purifies with copper(II) and metal binding modulates protein-lipid interactions. A 2.15 Å resolution structure of an N-terminal region of MsbA in complex with copper(II) is presented, revealing a structure reminiscent of the GHK peptide, a high-affinity copper(II) chelator. Our results demonstrate conformation-dependent lipid binding affinities, particularly for the LPS-precursor, 3-deoxy-D-manno-oct-2-ulosonic acid (Kdo)2-lipid A (KDL). We report a 3.6 Å-resolution structure of MsbA trapped in an open, outward-facing conformation with adenosine 5'-diphosphate and vanadate, revealing a distinct KDL binding site, wherein the lipid forms extensive interactions with the transporter. Additional studies provide evidence that the exterior KDL binding site is conserved and a positive allosteric modulator of ATPase activity, serving as a feedforward activation mechanism to couple transporter activity with LPS biosynthesis.

Step toward Probing the Nonannular Belt of Membrane Proteins

Integral membrane proteins are embedded in the biological membrane, where they carry out numerous biological processes. Although lipids present in the membrane are crucial for membrane protein function, it remains difficult to characterize many lipid binding events to membrane proteins, such as those that form the annular belt. Here, we use native mass spectrometry along with the charge-reducing properties of trimethylamine N-oxide (TMAO) to characterize a large number of lipid binding events to the bacterial ammonia channel (AmtB). In the absence of TMAO, significant peak overlap between neighboring charge states is observed, resulting in erroneous abundances for different molecular species. With the addition of TMAO, the weighted average charge state (Z_avg) was decreased. In addition, the increased spacing between nearby charge states enabled a higher number of lipid binding species to be observed while minimizing mass spectral peak overlap. These conditions helped us to determine the equilibrium binding constants (K_d) for up to 16 lipid binding events. The binding constants for the first few lipid binding events display the highest affinity, whereas the binding constants for higher lipid binding events converge to a similar value. These findings suggest a transition from nonannular to annular lipid binding to AmtB.

Stability and Dissociation of Adeno-Associated Viral Capsids by Variable Temperature-Charge Detection-Mass Spectrometry

Adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors have emerged as gene therapy and vaccine delivery systems. Differential scanning fluorimetry or differential scanning calorimetry is commonly used to measure the thermal stability of AAVs, but these global methods are unable to distinguish the stabilities of different AAV subpopulations in the same sample. To address this challenge, we combined charge detection-mass spectrometry (CD-MS) with a variable temperature (VT) electrospray source that controls the temperature of the solution prior to electrospray. Using VT-CD-MS, we measured the thermal stabilities of empty and filled capsids. We found that filled AAVs ejected their cargo first and formed intermediate empty capsids before completely dissociating. Finally, we observed that pH stress caused a major decrease in thermal stability. This new approach better characterizes the thermal dissociation of AAVs, providing the simultaneous measurement of the stabilities and dissociation pathways of different subpopulations.

Structural mass spectrometry of membrane proteins

The analysis of proteins and protein complexes by mass spectrometry (MS) has come a long way since the invention of electrospray ionization (ESI) in the mid 80s. Originally used to characterize small soluble polypeptide chains, MS has progressively evolved over the past 3 decades towards the analysis of samples of ever increasing heterogeneity and complexity, while the instruments have become more and more sensitive and resolutive. The proofs of concepts and first examples of most structural MS methods appeared in the early 90s. However, their application to membrane proteins, key targets in the biopharma industry, is more recent. Nowadays, a wealth of information can be gathered from such MS-based methods, on all aspects of membrane protein structure: sequencing (and more precisely proteoform characterization), but also stoichiometry, non-covalent ligand binding (metals, drug, lipids, carbohydrates), conformations, dynamics and distance restraints for modelling. In this review, we present the concept and some historical and more recent applications on membrane proteins, for the major structural MS methods.

Quantifying Biomolecular Interactions Using Slow Mixing Mode (SLOMO) Nanoflow ESI-MS

Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is a powerful label-free assay for detecting noncovalent biomolecular complexes in vitro and is increasingly used to quantify binding thermochemistry. A common assumption made in ESI-MS affinity measurements is that the relative ion signals of free and bound species quantitatively reflect their relative concentrations in solution. However, this is valid only when the interacting species and their complexes have similar ESI-MS response factors (RFs). For many biomolecular complexes, such as protein-protein interactions, this condition is not satisfied. Existing strategies to correct for nonuniform RFs are generally incompatible with static nanoflow ESI (nanoESI) sources, which are typically used for biomolecular interaction studies, thereby significantly limiting the utility of ESI-MS. Here, we introduce slow mixing mode (SLOMO) nanoESI-MS, a direct technique that allows both the RF and affinity (K _d) for a biomolecular interaction to be determined from a single measurement using static nanoESI. The approach relies on the continuous monitoring of interacting species and their complexes under nonhomogeneous solution conditions. Changes in ion signals of free and bound species as the system approaches or moves away from a steady-state condition allow the relative RFs of the free and bound species to be determined. Combining the relative RF and the relative abundances measured under equilibrium conditions enables the K _d to be calculated. The reliability of SLOMO and its ease of use is demonstrated through affinity measurements performed on peptide-antibiotic, protease-protein inhibitor, and protein oligomerization systems. Finally, affinities measured for the binding of human and bacterial lectins to a nanobody, a viral glycoprotein, and glycolipids displayed within a model membrane highlight the tremendous power and versatility of SLOMO for accurately quantifying a wide range of biomolecular interactions important to human health and disease.

Separation and Collision Cross Section Measurements of Protein Complexes Afforded by a Modular Drift Tube Coupled to an Orbitrap Mass Spectrometer

New developments in analytical technologies and biophysical methods have advanced the characterization of increasingly complex biomolecular assemblies using native mass spectrometry (MS). Ion mobility methods, in particular, have enabled a new dimension of structural information and analysis of proteins, allowing separation of conformations and providing size and shape insights based on collision cross sections (CCSs). Based on the concepts of absorption-mode Fourier transform (aFT) multiplexing ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), here, a modular drift tube design proves capable of separating native-like proteins up to 148 kDa with resolution up to 45. Coupled with high-resolution Orbitrap MS, binding of small ligands and cofactors can be resolved in the mass domain and correlated to changes in structural heterogeneity observed in the ion-neutral CCS distributions. We also demonstrate the ability to rapidly determine accurate CCSs for proteins with 1-min aFT-IMS-MS sweeps without the need for calibrants or correction factors.

Native top-down mass spectrometry for higher-order structural characterization of proteins and complexes

Progress in structural biology research has led to a high demand for powerful and yet complementary analytical tools for structural characterization of proteins and protein complexes. This demand has significantly increased interest in native mass spectrometry (nMS), particularly native top-down mass spectrometry (nTDMS) in the past decade. This review highlights recent advances in nTDMS for structural research of biological assemblies, with a particular focus on the extra multi-layers of information enabled by TDMS. We include a short introduction of sample preparation and ionization to nMS, tandem fragmentation techniques as well as mass analyzers and software/analysis pipelines used for nTDMS. We highlight unique structural information offered by nTDMS and examples of its broad range of applications in proteins, protein-ligand interactions (metal, cofactor/drug, DNA/RNA, and protein), therapeutic antibodies and antigen-antibody complexes, membrane proteins, macromolecular machineries (ribosome, nucleosome, proteosome, and viruses), to endogenous protein complexes. The challenges, potential, along with perspectives of nTDMS methods for the analysis of proteins and protein assemblies in recombinant and biological samples are discussed.

Native Mass Spectrometry at the Convergence of Structural Biology and Compositional Proteomics

ConspectusBiology is driven by a vast set of molecular interactions that evolved over billions of years. Just as covalent modifications like acetylations and phosphorylations can change a protein's function, so too can noncovalent interactions with metals, small molecules, and other proteins. However, much of the language of protein-level biology is left either undiscovered or inferred, as traditional methods used in the field of proteomics use conditions that dissociate noncovalent interactions and denature proteins.Just in the past few years, mass spectrometry (MS) has evolved the capacity to preserve and subsequently characterize the complete composition of endogenous protein complexes. Using this "native" type of mass spectrometry, a complex can be activated to liberate some or all of its subunits, typically via collisions with neutral gas or solid surfaces and isolated before further characterization ("Native Top-Down MS," or nTDMS). The subunit mass, the parent ion mass, and the fragment ions of the activated subunits can be used to piece together the precise molecular composition of the parent complex. When performed en masse in discovery mode (i.e., "native proteomics"), the interactions of life─including protein modifications─will eventually be clarified and linked to dysfunction in human disease states.In this Account, we describe the current and future components of the native MS toolkit, covering the challenges the field faces to characterize ever larger bioassemblies. Each of the three pillars of native proteomics are addressed: (i) separations, (ii) top-down mass spectrometry, and (iii) integration with structural biology. Complexes such as endogenous nucleosomes can be targeted now using nTDMS, whereas virus particles, exosomes, and high-density lipoprotein particles will be tackled in the coming few years. The future work to adequately address the size and complexity of mega- to gigadalton complexes will include native separations, single ion mass spectrometry, and new data types. The use of nTDMS in discovery mode will incorporate native-compatible separation techniques to maximize the number of proteoforms in complexes identified. With a new wave of innovations, both targeted and discovery mode nTDMS will expand to include extremely scarce and exceedingly heterogeneous bioassemblies. Understanding the proteinaceous interactions of life and how they go wrong (e.g., misfolding, forming complexes in dysfunctional stoichiometries and configurations) will not only inform the development of life-restoring therapeutics but also deepen our understanding of life at the molecular level.

Native Mass Spectrometry: Recent Progress and Remaining Challenges

Native mass spectrometry (nMS) has emerged as an important tool in studying the structure and function of macromolecules and their complexes in the gas phase. In this review, we cover recent advances in nMS and related techniques including sample preparation, instrumentation, activation methods, and data analysis software. These advances have enabled nMS-based techniques to address a variety of challenging questions in structural biology. The second half of this review highlights recent applications of these technologies and surveys the classes of complexes that can be studied with nMS. Complementarity of nMS to existing structural biology techniques and current challenges in nMS are also addressed.

Approaches to Heterogeneity in Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is aimed at preserving and determining the native structure, composition, and stoichiometry of biomolecules and their complexes from solution after they are transferred into the gas phase. Major improvements in native MS instrumentation and experimental methods over the past few decades have led to a concomitant increase in the complexity and heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed, including protein-ligand complexes, protein complexes with multiple coexisting stoichiometries, and membrane protein-lipid assemblies. Heterogeneous features of these biomolecular samples can be important for understanding structure and function. However, sample heterogeneity can make assignment of ion mass, charge, composition, and structure very challenging due to the overlap of tens or even hundreds of peaks in the mass spectrum. In this review, we cover data analysis, experimental, and instrumental advances and strategies aimed at solving this problem, with an in-depth discussion of theoretical and practical aspects of the use of available deconvolution algorithms and tools. We also reflect upon current challenges and provide a view of the future of this exciting field.

Mass Spectrometry Methods for Measuring Protein Stability

Mass spectrometry is a central technology in the life sciences, providing our most comprehensive account of the molecular inventory of the cell. In parallel with developments in mass spectrometry technologies targeting such assessments of cellular composition, mass spectrometry tools have emerged as versatile probes of biomolecular stability. In this review, we cover recent advancements in this branch of mass spectrometry that target proteins, a centrally important class of macromolecules that accounts for most biochemical functions and drug targets. Our efforts cover tools such as hydrogen-deuterium exchange, chemical cross-linking, ion mobility, collision induced unfolding, and other techniques capable of stability assessments on a proteomic scale. In addition, we focus on a range of application areas where mass spectrometry-driven protein stability measurements have made notable impacts, including studies of membrane proteins, heat shock proteins, amyloidogenic proteins, and biotherapeutics. We conclude by briefly discussing the future of this vibrant and fast-moving area of research.

High-Resolution Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) involves the analysis and characterization of macromolecules, predominantly intact proteins and protein complexes, whereby as much as possible the native structural features of the analytes are retained. As such, native MS enables the study of secondary, tertiary, and even quaternary structure of proteins and other biomolecules. Native MS represents a relatively recent addition to the analytical toolbox of mass spectrometry and has over the past decade experienced immense growth, especially in enhancing sensitivity and resolving power but also in ease of use. With the advent of dedicated mass analyzers, sample preparation and separation approaches, targeted fragmentation techniques, and software solutions, the number of practitioners and novel applications has risen in both academia and industry. This review focuses on recent developments, particularly in high-resolution native MS, describing applications in the structural analysis of protein assemblies, proteoform profiling of─among others─biopharmaceuticals and plasma proteins, and quantitative and qualitative analysis of protein-ligand interactions, with the latter covering lipid, drug, and carbohydrate molecules, to name a few.

High-Throughput Native Mass Spectrometry Screening in Drug Discovery

The design of new therapeutic molecules can be significantly informed by studying protein-ligand interactions using biophysical approaches directly after purification of the protein-ligand complex. Well-established techniques utilized in drug discovery include isothermal titration calorimetry, surface plasmon resonance, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and structure-based drug discovery which mainly rely on protein crystallography and, more recently, cryo-electron microscopy. Protein-ligand complexes are dynamic, heterogeneous, and challenging systems that are best studied with several complementary techniques. Native mass spectrometry (MS) is a versatile method used to study proteins and their non-covalently driven assemblies in a native-like folded state, providing information on binding thermodynamics and stoichiometry as well as insights on ternary and quaternary protein structure. Here, we discuss the basic principles of native mass spectrometry, the field's recent progress, how native MS is integrated into a drug discovery pipeline, and its future developments in drug discovery.

Cupric Ions Selectively Modulate TRAAK-Phosphatidylserine Interactions

TRAAK and TREK2 are two-pore domain K⁺ (K2P) channels and are modulated by diverse factors including temperature, membrane stretching, and lipids, such as phosphatidic acid. In addition, copper and zinc, both of which are essential for life, are known to regulate TREK2 and a number of other ion channels. However, the role of ions in the association of lipids with integral membrane proteins is poorly understood. Here, we discover cupric ions selectively modulate the binding of phosphatidylserine (PS) to TRAAK but not TREK2. Other divalent cations (Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, and Zn²⁺) bind both channels but have no impact on binding PS and other lipids. Additionally, TRAAK binds more avidly to Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ than TREK2. In the presence of Cu²⁺, TRAAK binds similarly to PS with different acyl chains, indicating a crucial role of the serine headgroup in coordinating Cu²⁺. High-resolution native mass spectrometry (MS) enables the determination of equilibrium binding constants for distinct Cu²⁺-bound stoichiometries and uncovered the highest coupling factor corresponds to a 1:1 PS-to-Cu²⁺ ratio. Interestingly, the next three highest coupling factors had a ∼1.5:1 PS-to-Cu²⁺ ratio. Our findings bring forth the role of cupric ions as an essential cofactor in selective TRAAK-PS interactions.

Temperature Regulates Stability, Ligand Binding (Mg2+ and ATP), and Stoichiometry of GroEL-GroES Complexes

Chaperonins are nanomachines that harness ATP hydrolysis to power and catalyze protein folding, a chemical action that is directly linked to the maintenance of cell function through protein folding/refolding and assembly. GroEL and the GroEL-GroES complex are archetypal examples of such protein folding machines. Here, variable-temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) native mass spectrometry is used to delineate the effects of solution temperature and ATP concentrations on the stabilities of GroEL and GroEL-GroES complexes. The results show clear evidence for destabilization of both GroEL₁₄ and GroES₇ at temperatures of 50 and 45 °C, respectively, substantially below the previously reported melting temperature (T_m ∼ 70 °C). This destabilization is accompanied by temperature-dependent reaction products that have previously unreported stoichiometries, viz. GroEL₁₄-GroES_y-ATP_n, where y = 1, 2, 8 and n = 0, 1, 2, 8, that are also dependent on Mg²⁺ and ATP concentrations. Variable-temperature native mass spectrometry reveals new insights about the stability of GroEL in response to temperature effects: (i) temperature-dependent ATP binding to GroEL; (ii) effects of temperature as well as Mg²⁺ and ATP concentrations on the stoichiometry of the GroEL-GroES complex, with Mg²⁺ showing greater effects compared to ATP; and (iii) a change in the temperature-dependent stoichiometries of the GroEL-GroES complex (GroEL₁₄-GroES₇ vs GroEL₁₄-GroES₈) between 24 and 40 °C. The similarities between results obtained by using native MS and cryo-EM [Clare et al. An expanded protein folding cage in the GroEL-gp31 complex. J. Mol. Biol. 2006, 358, 905-911; Ranson et al. Allosteric signaling of ATP hydrolysis in GroEL-GroES complexes.Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 2006, 13, 147-152] underscore the utility of native MS for investigations of molecular machines as well as identification of key intermediates involved in the chaperonin-assisted protein folding cycle.

Untangling the complexity of membrane protein folding

Delineating the folding steps of helical-bundle membrane proteins has been a challenging task. Many questions remain unanswered, including the conformation and stability of the states populated during folding, the shape of the energy barriers between the states, and the role of lipids as a solvent in mediating the folding. Recently, theoretical frames have matured to a point that permits detailed dissection of the folding steps, and advances in experimental techniques at both single-molecule and ensemble levels enable selective modulation of specific steps for quantitative determination of the folding energy landscapes. We also discuss how lipid molecules would play an active role in shaping the folding energy landscape of membrane proteins, and how folding of multi-domain membrane proteins can be understood based on our current knowledge. We conclude this review by offering an outlook for emerging questions in the study of membrane protein folding.

Investigation of Protein-Lipid Interactions Using Native Mass Spectrometry

Integral membrane proteins are embedded in biological membranes where various lipids modulate their structure and function. There exists a critical need to elucidate how these lipids participate in the physiological and pathological processes associated with the membrane protein dysfunction. Native mass spectrometry (MS), combined with ion mobility spectrometry (IM), is emerging as a powerful tool to probe membrane protein complexes and their interactions with ligands, lipids, and other small molecules. Unlike other biophysical approaches, native IM-MS can resolve individual ligand/lipid binding events. We have developed a novel method using native MS, coupled with a temperature-control apparatus, to determine the thermodynamic parameters of individual ligand or lipid binding events to proteins. This approach has been validated using several soluble protein-ligand systems wherein MS results are compared with those acquired from conventional biophysical techniques, such as isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Using these principles, it is possible to elucidate the thermodynamics of individual lipid binding to integral membrane proteins. Herein, we use the ammonia channel (AmtB) from Escherichia coli as a model membrane protein. Remarkably, distinct thermodynamic signatures for AmtB binding to lipids with different headgroups and acyl chain configurations are observed. Additionally, using a mutant form of AmtB that abolishes a specific lipid binding site, distinct changes have been discovered in the thermodynamic signatures compared with the wild-type, implying that these signatures can identify key residues involved in specific lipid binding and potentially differentiate between specific lipid binding sites. This chapter provides procedures and findings associated with temperature-controlled native MS as a novel approach to interrogate membrane proteins and their interactions with lipids and other molecules.

Entropy in the Molecular Recognition of Membrane Protein-Lipid Interactions

Understanding the molecular driving forces that underlie membrane protein-lipid interactions requires the characterization of their binding thermodynamics. Here, we employ variable-temperature native mass spectrometry to determine the thermodynamics of lipid binding events to the human G-protein-gated inward rectifier potassium channel, Kir3.2. The channel displays distinct thermodynamic strategies to engage phosphatidylinositol (PI) and phosphorylated forms thereof. The addition of a 4'-phosphate to PI results in an increase in favorable entropy. PI with two or more phosphates exhibits more complex binding, where lipids appear to bind two nonidentical sites on Kir3.2. Remarkably, the interaction of 4,5-bisphosphate PI with Kir3.2 is solely driven by a large, favorable change in entropy. Installment of a 3'-phosphate to PI(4,5)P2 results in an altered thermodynamic strategy. The acyl chain of the lipid has a marked impact on binding thermodynamics and, in some cases, enthalpy becomes favorable.