Determination of the Molecular Structures of Ferric Enterobactin and Ferric Enantioenterobactin Using Racemic Crystallography

Conjugation to Native and Nonnative Triscatecholate Siderophores Enhances Delivery and Antibacterial Activity of a β-Lactam to Gram-Negative Bacterial Pathogens

Developing new antibiotics and delivery strategies is of critical importance for treating infections caused by Gram-negative bacterial pathogens. Hijacking bacterial iron uptake machinery, such as that of the siderophore enterobactin (Ent), represents one promising approach toward these goals. Here, we report a novel Ent-inspired siderophore-antibiotic conjugate (SAC) employing an alternative siderophore moiety as the delivery vector and demonstrate the potency of our SACs harboring the β-lactam antibiotic ampicillin (Amp) against multiple pathogenic Gram-negative bacterial strains. We establish the ability of N,N',N''-(nitrilotris(ethane-2,1-diyl))tris(2,3-dihydroxybenzamide) (TRENCAM, hereafter TC), a synthetic mimic of Ent, to facilitate drug delivery across the outer membrane (OM) of Gram-negative pathogens. Conjugation of Amp to a new monofunctionalized TC scaffold affords TC-Amp, which displays markedly enhanced antibacterial activity against the gastrointestinal pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (STm) compared with unmodified Amp. Bacterial uptake, antibiotic susceptibility, and microscopy studies with STm show that the TC moiety facilitates TC-Amp uptake by the OM receptors FepA and IroN and that the Amp warhead inhibits penicillin-binding proteins. Moreover, TC-Amp achieves targeted activity, selectively killing STm in the presence of a commensal lactobacillus. Remarkably, we uncover that TC-Amp and its Ent-based predecessor Ent-Amp achieve enhanced antibacterial activity against diverse Gram-negative ESKAPE pathogens that express Ent uptake machinery, including strains that possess intrinsic β-lactam resistance. TC-Amp and Ent-Amp exhibit potency comparable to that of the FDA-approved SAC cefiderocol against Gram-negative pathogens. These results demonstrate the effective application of native and appropriately designed nonnative siderophores as vectors for drug delivery across the OM of multiple Gram-negative bacterial pathogens.

Recognition of Actinides by Siderocalin

Plain simulations and enhanced sampling unveil a novel siderocalin (Scn) recognition mode for An-Ent (where An = actinides and Ent = enterobactin) complexes and identify a "seesaw" relationship between actinide affinity to Ent and Scn recognition to an An-Ent complex. Electrostatic interactions predominantly govern competitive binding in both processes. Additionally, hydrolysis-induced negative charge, water expulsion-driven entropy, and Ent's conformational adaptability collectively enhance high-affinity recognition.

Mining elements of siderophore chirality encoded in microbial genomes

The vast majority of bacteria require iron to grow. A significant iron acquisition strategy is the production of siderophores, which are secondary microbial metabolites synthesized to sequester iron(III). Siderophore structures encompass a variety of forms, of which highly modified peptidic siderophores are of interest herein. State-of-the-art genome mining tools, such as antiSMASH (antibiotics & Secondary Metabolite Analysis SHell), hold the potential to predict and discover new peptidic siderophores, including a combinatoric suite of triscatechol siderophores framed on a triserine-ester backbone of the general class, (DHB-^l/d CAA-^l Ser)₃ (CAA, cationic amino acid). Siderophores with ^l/d Arg, ^l/d Lys and ^l Orn, but not ^d Orn, were predicted in bacterial genomes. Fortuitously the ^d Orn siderophore was identified, yet its lack of prediction highlights the limitation of current genome mining tools. The full combinatoric suite of these siderophores, which form chiral iron(III) complexes, reveals stereospecific coordination chemistry encoded in microbial genomes. The chirality embedded in this suite of Fe(III)-siderophores raises the question of whether the relevant siderophore-mediated iron acquisition pathways are stereospecific and selective for ferric siderophore complexes of a defined configuration.

Advances in the Synthesis of Enterobactin, Artificial Analogues, and Enterobactin-Derived Antimicrobial Drug Conjugates and Imaging Tools for Infection Diagnosis

Iron is an essential growth factor for bacteria, but although highly abundant in nature, its bioavailability during infection in the human host or the environment is limited. Therefore, bacteria produce and secrete siderophores to ensure their supply of iron. The triscatecholate siderophore enterobactin and its glycosylated derivatives, the salmochelins, play a crucial role for iron acquisition in several bacteria. As these compounds can serve as carrier molecules for the design of antimicrobial siderophore drug conjugates as well as siderophore-derived tool compounds for the detection of infections with bacteria, their synthesis and the design of artificial analogues is of interest. In this review, we give an overview on the synthesis of enterobactin, biomimetic as well as totally artificial analogues, and related drug-conjugates covering up to 12/2021.

1 Introduction

2 Antibiotic Crisis and Sideromycins as Natural Templates for New Antimicrobial Drugs

3 Biosynthesis of Enterobactin, Salmochelins, and Microcins

4 Total Synthesis of Enterobactin and Salmochelins

5 Chemoenzymatic Semi-synthesis of Salmochelins and Microcin E492m Derivatives

6 Synthesis of Biomimetic Enterobactin Derivatives with Natural Tris-lactone Backbone

7 Synthesis of Artificial Enterobactin Derivatives without Tris-lactone Backbone

8 Conclusions

Ruckerbactin Produced by Yersinia ruckeri YRB Is a Diastereomer of the Siderophore Trivanchrobactin Produced by Vibrio campbellii DS40M4

The Gram-negative bacterium Yersinia ruckeri is the causative agent for enteric red mouth disease in salmonids. The genome of Y. ruckeri YRB contains a biosynthetic gene cluster encoding the biosynthesis of catechol siderophores that are diastereomeric with the known vanchrobactin class of siderophores, (DHBDArgLSer)(1-3). Ruckerbactin (1), produced by Y. ruckeri YRB, was found to be the linear tris-l-serine ester composed of l-arginine and 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid, (DHBLArgLSer)3. The biscatechol, (DHBLArgLSer)2 (2), and monocatechol, DHBLArgLSer (3), compounds were also isolated and characterized. The macrolactone of ruckerbactin was not detected. The presence of LArg in ruckerbactin makes it the diastereomer of trivanchrobactin with DArg. The electronic circular dichroism spectra of Fe(III)-ruckerbactin and Fe(III)-trivanchrobactin reveal the opposite enantiomeric configurations at the Fe(III) sites. Fe(III)-ruckerbactin adopts the Δ configuration, and Fe(III)-trivanchrobactin adopts the Λ configuration. Y. ruckeri YRB was also found to produce the antimicrobial agent holomycin (4).

Genomics-driven discovery of chiral triscatechol siderophores with enantiomeric Fe(iii) coordination

Ferric complexes of triscatechol siderophores may assume one of two enantiomeric configurations at the iron site. Chirality is known to be important in the iron uptake process, however an understanding of the molecular features directing stereospecific coordination remains ambiguous. Synthesis of the full suite of (DHB^L/DLys^L/DSer)₃ macrolactone diastereomers, which includes the siderophore cyclic trichrysobactin (CTC), enables the effects that the chirality of Lys and Ser residues exert on the configuration of the Fe(iii) complex to be defined. Computationally optimized geometries indicate that the Λ/Δ configurational preferences are set by steric interactions between the Lys sidechains and the peptide backbone. The ability of each (DHB^L/DLys^L/DSer)₃ diastereomer to form a stable Fe(iii) complex prompted a genomic search for biosynthetic gene clusters (BGCs) encoding the synthesis of these diastereomers in microbes. The genome of the plant pathogen Dickeya chrysanthemi EC16 was sequenced and the genes responsible for the biosynthesis of CTC were identified. A related but distinct BGC was identified in the genome of the opportunistic pathogen Yersinia frederiksenii ATCC 33641; isolation of the siderophore from Y. frederiksenii ATCC 33641, named frederiksenibactin (FSB), revealed the triscatechol oligoester, linear-(DHB^LLys^LSer)₃. Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy establishes that Fe(iii)-CTC and Fe(iii)-FSB are formed in opposite enantiomeric configuration, consistent with the results of the ferric complexes of the cyclic (DHB^L/DLys^L/DSer)₃ diastereomers.

Biomimetic enterobactin analogue mediates iron-uptake and cargo transport into E. coli and P. aeruginosa

The design, synthesis and biological evaluation of the artificial enterobactin analogue EntKL and several fluorophore-conjugates thereof are described. EntKL provides an attachment point for cargos such as fluorophores or antimicrobial payloads. Corresponding conjugates are recognized by outer membrane siderophore receptors of Gram-negative pathogens and retain the natural hydrolyzability of the tris-lactone backbone. Initial density-functional theory (DFT) calculations of the free energies of solvation (ΔG(sol)) and relaxed Fe-O force constants of the corresponding [Fe-EntKL]3- complexes indicated a similar iron binding constant compared to natural enterobactin (Ent). The synthesis of EntKL was achieved via an iterative assembly based on a 3-hydroxylysine building block over 14 steps with an overall yield of 3%. A series of growth recovery assays under iron-limiting conditions with Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa mutant strains that are defective in natural siderophore synthesis revealed a potent concentration-dependent growth promoting effect of EntKL similar to natural Ent. Additionally, four cargo-conjugates differing in molecular size were able to restore growth of E. coli indicating an uptake into the cytosol. P. aeruginosa displayed a stronger uptake promiscuity as six different cargo-conjugates were found to restore growth under iron-limiting conditions. Imaging studies utilizing BODIPYFL-conjugates, demonstrated the ability of EntKL to overcome the Gram-negative outer membrane permeability barrier and thus deliver molecular cargos via the bacterial iron transport machinery of E. coli and P. aeruginosa.

Function of Fimsbactin B as an Acinetobacter-Selective Antibiotic Delivery Vehicle

The ability of fimsbactin B, a natural siderophore of Acinetobacter baumannii, to function as an antibiotic delivery vehicle was investigated by synthesizing three structurally diversified fimsbactin B-cefaclor conjugates. Their antimicrobial activities were Acinetobacter-selective and up to 128-fold more potent than that of cefaclor alone. This activity enhancement originated from the fimsbactin-B-dependent active uptake of cefaclor. Thus, fimsbactin-B-based antibiotic delivery can be an effective approach in combating antibiotic-resistant Acinetobacter infections.

Molecular Evolution of Transition Metal Bioavailability at the Host-Pathogen Interface

The molecular evolution of the adaptive response at the host-pathogen interface has been frequently referred to as an 'arms race' between the host and bacterial pathogens. The innate immune system employs multiple strategies to starve microbes of metals. Pathogens, in turn, develop successful strategies to maintain access to bioavailable metal ions under conditions of extreme restriction of transition metals, or nutritional immunity. However, the processes by which evolution repurposes or re-engineers host and pathogen proteins to perform or refine new functions have been explored only recently. Here we review the molecular evolution of several human metalloproteins charged with restricting bacterial access to transition metals. These include the transition metal-chelating S100 proteins, natural resistance-associated macrophage protein-1 (NRAMP-1), transferrin, lactoferrin, and heme-binding proteins. We examine their coevolution with bacterial transition metal acquisition systems, involving siderophores and membrane-spanning metal importers, and the biological specificity of allosteric transcriptional regulatory proteins tasked with maintaining bacterial metallostasis. We also discuss the evolution of metallo-β-lactamases; this illustrates how rapid antibiotic-mediated evolution of a zinc metalloenzyme obligatorily occurs in the context of host-imposed nutritional immunity.

Formation of a tris(catecholato) iron(III) complex with a nature-inspired cyclic peptoid ligand

Siderophore-mimicking macrocyclic peptoids were synthesized. Peptoid 3 with intramolecular hydrogen bonds showed an optimally arranged primary coordination sphere leading to a stable catecholate-iron complex. The tris(catecholato) structure of 3-Fe(iii) was determined with UV-vis, fluorescence, and EPR spectroscopies and DFT calculations. The iron binding affinity was comparable to that of deferoxamine, with enhanced stability upon air exposure.

Enterobactin Deficiency in a Coliform Mastitis Isolate Decreases Its Fitness in a Murine Model: A Preliminary Host-Pathogen Interaction Study

Iron is an essential nutrient for bacterial growth. Therefore, bacteria have evolved chelation mechanisms to acquire iron for their survival. Enterobactin, a chelator with high affinity for ferric iron, is secreted by Escherichia coli and contributes to its improved bacterial fitness. In this preliminary study, we evaluated enterobactin deficiency both in vitro and in vivo in the context of E. coli mastitis. Firstly, we showed that expression of lipocalin 2, a protein produced by the host that is able to both bind and deplete enterobactin, is increased upon E. coli infection in the cow's mastitic mammary gland. Secondly, we demonstrated in vitro that enterobactin deficiency does not alter interleukin (IL)-8 expression in bovine mammary epithelial cells and its associated neutrophil recruitment. However, a significantly increased reactive oxygen species production of these neutrophils was observed. Thirdly, we showed there was no significant difference in bacterial in vitro growth between the enterobactin-deficient mutant and its wild-type counterpart. However, when further explored in a murine model for bovine mastitis, the enterobactin-deficient mutant vs. the wild-type strain revealed a significant reduction of the bacterial load and, consequently, a decrease in pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-1α,-1β,-4,-6, and-8). A reduced neutrophilic influx was also observed immunohistochemically. These findings therefore identify interference of the enterobactin iron-scavenging mechanism as a potential measure to decrease the fitness of E. coli in the mastitic mammary gland.

Iron Acquisition by Bacterial Pathogens: Beyond Tris-Catecholate Complexes

Sequestration of the essential nutrient iron from bacterial invaders that colonize the vertebrate host is a central feature of nutritional immunity and the "fight over transition metals" at the host-pathogen interface. The iron quota for many bacterial pathogens is large, as iron enzymes often make up a significant share of the metalloproteome. Iron enzymes play critical roles in respiration, energy metabolism, and other cellular processes by catalyzing a wide range of oxidation-reduction, electron transfer, and oxygen activation reactions. In this Concept article, we discuss recent insights into the diverse ways that bacterial pathogens acquire this essential nutrient, beyond the well-characterized tris-catecholate FeIII complexes, in competition and cooperation with significant host efforts to cripple these processes. We also discuss pathogen strategies to adapt their metabolism to less-than-optimal iron concentrations, and briefly speculate on what might be an integrated adaptive response to the concurrent limitation of both iron and zinc in the infected host.

A Unique Conformational Distortion Mechanism Drives Lipocalin 2 Binding to Bacterial Siderophores

Lcn2 is a host defense protein induced via the innate immune response to sequester iron-loaded bacterial siderophores. However, excess or prolonged elevation of Lcn2 levels can induce adverse cellular effects, including oxidative stress and inflammation. In this work, we use Hydrogen-Deuterium eXchange (HDX) and Isothermal Titration Calorimetry (ITC) to characterize the binding interaction between Lcn2 and siderophores enterobactin and 2,3-DHBA, in the presence and absence of iron. Our results indicate a rare "Type II" interaction in which binding of siderophores drives the protein conformational equilibrium toward an unfolded state. Linking our molecular model to cellular assays, we demonstrate that this "distorted binding mode" facilitates a deleterious cellular accumulation of reactive oxygen species that could represent the molecular origin of Lcn2 pathology. These results add important insights into mechanisms of Lcn2 action and have implications in Lcn2-mediated effects including inflammation.

Enterobactin-Specific Antibodies Induced by a Novel Enterobactin Conjugate Vaccine

Enterobactin (Ent)-mediated high-affinity iron acquisition is critical for Gram-negative bacteria to survive in the host. Given the bacteriostatic effect of lipocalin resulting from its potent Ent-binding ability, immune intervention directly targeting Ent is promising for iron-dependent pathogen control. Recently, an Ent conjugate vaccine was reported, but it still has several significant weaknesses. In this study, we sought to develop an innovative Ent conjugate vaccine that can induce a high level of antibodies directed against Ent and to provide solid evidence demonstrating siderophore-binding capacity of Ent-specific antibodies. Using a simple method, we successfully conjugated purified Ent to different carriers, including keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH), bovine serum albumin, and CmeC, a vaccine candidate for Campylobacter control. Subcutaneous immunization of rabbits with the KLH-Ent conjugate triggered a strong systemic IgG immune response with an up to 16,384-fold increase in IgG titer directed against whole conjugate and an up to 4,096-fold increase in the level of specific anti-Ent IgG. To evaluate the ability of Ent-specific IgG to bind to the Ent derivatives present in vivo, various Ent derivatives were chemically synthesized and a unique enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay method was developed. The Ent-specific IgG also displayed exceptional reactivity to ferric Ent, a linear trimer of Ent, and different salmochelins. Growth assays further demonstrated that the Ent-specific antibodies significantly inhibited Ent-dependent growth of Campylobacter spp. and Escherichia coli Collectively, this study reports an efficient method to prepare a new type of Ent conjugate vaccines for inducing a high level of Ent-specific antibodies, which can bind to various Ent derivatives and display lipocalin-like bacteriostatic features.IMPORTANCE Ent-mediated high-affinity iron acquisition is a universal and critical contributor for Gram-negative pathogens to survive and infect hosts. Published information has supported an innovative immune intervention strategy that directly targets Ent to starve pathogens by limiting the availability of iron to be utilized. Compared to a recently published Ent conjugate, there are three advantages of the vaccine described in this study: ease of preparation, induction of high titer of anti-Ent IgG, and the ability of Ent-specific antibodies to bind various Ent derivatives, including the salmochelins that help enteric pathogens evade sequestration of siderophores by host lipocalins. In addition, the Ent-specific antibodies were demonstrated to function similarly to lipocalin to interfere with the Ent-dependent growth of Campylobacter and E. coli under iron-restricted conditions. This study has significant potential for broader applications to prevent and control various Gram-negative infections in humans and animals.

Fimsbactin and Acinetobactin Compete for the Periplasmic Siderophore Binding Protein BauB in Pathogenic Acinetobacter baumannii

Environmental and pathogenic microbes produce siderophores as small iron-binding molecules to scavenge iron from natural environments. It is common for microbes to produce multiple siderophores to gain a competitive edge in mixed microbial environments. Strains of human pathogenic Acinetobacter baumannii produce up to three siderophores: acinetobactin, baumannoferrin, and fimsbactin. Production of acinetobactin and baumannoferrin is highly conserved among clinical isolates while fimsbactin production appears to be less common. Fimsbactin is structurally related to acinetobactin through the presence of catecholate and phenolate oxazoline metal-binding motifs, and both are derived from nonribosomal peptide assembly lines with similar catalytic domain orientations and identities. Here we report on the chemical, biochemical, and microbiological investigation of fimsbactin and acinetobactin alone and in combination. We show that fimsbactin forms a 1:1 complex with iron(III) that is thermodynamically more stable than the 2:1 acinetobactin ferric complex. Alone, both acinetobactin and fimsbactin stimulate A. baumannii growth, but in combination the two siderophores appear to compete and collectively inhibit bacterial growth. We show that fimsbactin directly competes with acinetobactin for binding the periplasmic siderophore-binding protein BauB suggesting a possible biochemical mechanism for the phenomenon where the buildup of apo-siderophores in the periplasm leads to iron starvation. We propose an updated model for siderophore utilization and competition in A. baumannii that frames the molecular, biochemical, and cellular interplay of multiple iron acquisition systems in a multidrug resistant Gram-negative human pathogen.

The folding equilibria of enterobactin enantiomers and their interaction with actinides

The helicity preference of Ent enantiomers was enhanced when binding with Fe³⁺ while disrupted when binding with actinides.

Use of a Compact Tripodal Tris(bipyridine) Ligand to Stabilize a Single-Metal-Centered Chirality: Stereoselective Coordination of Iron(II) and Ruthenium(II) on a Semirigid Hexapeptide Macrocycle

Fe(II)-coordinating hexapeptides containing three 2,2'-bipyridine moieties as side chains were designed and synthesized. A cyclic hexapeptide having three [(2,2'-bipyridin)-5-yl]-d-alanine (d-Bpa5) residues, in which d-Bpa5 and Gly are alternately arranged with 3-fold rotational symmetry, coordinated with Fe(II) to form a 1:1 octahedral Fe(II)-peptide complex with a single facial-Λ configuration of the metal-centered chirality. NMR spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations revealed that the Fe(II)-peptide complex has an apparent C₃-symmetric conformations on the NMR time scale, while the peptide backbone is subject to dynamic conformational exchange between three asymmetric β/γ conformations and one C₃-symmetric γ/γ/γ conformation. The semirigid cyclic hexapeptide preferentially arranged these conformations of the small octahedral Fe(II)-bipyridine complex, as well as the Ru(II) congener, to underpin the single configuration of the metal-centered chirality.