Engineering an [FeFe]-Hydrogenase: Do Accessory Clusters Influence O2 Resistance and Catalytic Bias?

Oxygen-resistant [FeFe]hydrogenases: new biocatalysis tools for clean energy and cascade reactions

The use of enzymes to generate hydrogen, instead of using rare metal catalysts, is an exciting area of study in modern biochemistry and biotechnology, as well as biocatalysis driven by sustainable hydrogen. Thus far, the oxygen sensitivity of the fastest hydrogen-producing/exploiting enzymes, [FeFe]hydrogenases, has hindered their practical application, thereby restricting innovations mainly to their [NiFe]-based, albeit slower, counterparts. Recent exploration of the biodiversity of clostridial hydrogen-producing enzymes has yielded the isolation of representatives from a relatively understudied group. These enzymes possess an inherent defense mechanism against oxygen-induced damage. This discovery unveils fresh opportunities for applications such as electrode interfacing, biofuel cells, immobilization, and entrapment for enhanced stability in practical uses. Furthermore, it suggests potential combinations with cascade reactions for CO2 conversion or cofactor regeneration, like NADPH, facilitating product separation in biotechnological processes. This work provides an overview of this new class of biocatalysts, incorporating unpublished protein engineering strategies to further investigate the dynamic mechanism of oxygen protection and to address crucial details remaining elusive such as still unidentified switching hot-spots and their effects. Variants with improved kcat as well as chimeric versions with promising features to attain gain-of-function variants and applications in various biotechnological processes are also presented.

Properties of the iron-sulfur cluster electron transfer relay in an [FeFe]-hydrogenase that is tuned for H2 oxidation catalysis

[FeFe]-hydrogenases catalyze the reversible oxidation of H2 from electrons and protons at an organometallic active site cofactor named the H-cluster. In addition to the H-cluster, most [FeFe]-hydrogenases possess accessory FeS cluster (F-cluster) relays that function in mediating electron transfer with catalysis. There is significant variation in the structural properties of F-cluster relays among the [FeFe]-hydrogenases; however, it is unknown how this variation relates to the electronic and thermodynamic properties, and thus the electron transfer properties, of enzymes. Clostridium pasteurianum [FeFe]-hydrogenase II (CpII) exhibits a large catalytic bias for H2 oxidation (compared to H2 production), making it a notable system for examining if F-cluster properties contribute to the overall function and efficiency of the enzyme. By applying a combination of multifrequency and potentiometric electron paramagnetic resonance, we resolved two electron paramagnetic resonance signals with distinct power- and temperature-dependent properties at g = 2.058 1.931 1.891 (F2.058) and g = 2.061 1.920 1.887 (F2.061), with assigned midpoint potentials of -140 ± 18 mV and -406 ± 12 mV versus normal hydrogen electrode, respectively. Spectral analysis revealed features consistent with spin-spin coupling between the two [4Fe-4S] F-clusters, and possible functional models are discussed that account for the contribution of coupling to the electron transfer landscape. The results signify the interplay of electronic coupling and free energy properties and parameters of the FeS clusters to the electron transfer mechanism through the relay and provide new insight as to how relays functionally complement the catalytic directionality of active sites to achieve highly efficient catalysis.

Outer-sphere effects on the O2 sensitivity, catalytic bias and catalytic reversibility of hydrogenases

The comparison of homologous metalloenzymes, in which the same inorganic active site is surrounded by a variable protein matrix, has demonstrated that residues that are remote from the active site may have a great influence on catalytic properties. In this review, we summarise recent findings on the diverse molecular mechanisms by which the protein matrix may define the oxygen tolerance, catalytic directionality and catalytic reversibility of hydrogenases, enzymes that catalyse the oxidation and evolution of H2. These mechanisms involve residues in the second coordination sphere of the active site metal ion, more distant residues affecting protein flexibility through their side chains, residues lining the gas channel and even accessory subunits. Such long-distance effects, which contribute to making enzymes efficient, robust and different from one another, are a source of wonder for biochemists and a challenge for synthetic bioinorganic chemists.

Combining a Commercial Mixer with a Wall-Tube Electrode Allows the Arbitrary Control of Concentrations in Protein Film Electrochemistry

Protein film electrochemistry is a technique in which an enzyme is immobilized on an electrode in a configuration that allows following the changes in turnover frequency as a response to changes in the experimental conditions. Insights into the reactivity of the enzyme can be obtained by quantitatively modeling such responses. As a consequence, the more the technique allows flexibility in changing conditions, the more useful it becomes. The most commonly used setup, based on the rotating disc electrode, allows easy stepwise increases in the concentration of nongaseous substrates, or exposure to constant concentration of dissolved gas, but does not permit to easily decrease the concentration of nongaseous substrates, or to change the concentration of dissolved gas in a stepwise fashion. To overcome the limitation by mass transport of the substrate toward the electrode when working with fast enzymes, we have designed another kind of electrochemical cell based on the wall-tube electrode (WTE). We demonstrate here that by using a system combining two syringe pumps, a commercial mixer, and the WTE, it is possible to change the concentration of species in a stepwise fashion in all directions, opening new possibilities to study redox enzymes. As a proof of concept, this device was applied to the study of the electrochemical response of the cytochrome c nitrite reductase of Desulfovibrio desulfuricans.

A Dynamic Water Channel Affects O2 Stability in [FeFe]-Hydrogenases

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are capable of reducing protons at a high rate. However, molecular oxygen (O2 ) induces the degradation of their catalytic cofactor, the H-cluster, which consists of a cubane [4Fe4S] subcluster (4FeH ) and a unique diiron moiety (2FeH ). Previous attempts to prevent O2 -induced damage have focused on enhancing the protein's sieving effect for O2 by blocking the hydrophobic gas channels that connect the protein surface and the 2FeH . In this study, we aimed to block an O2 diffusion pathway and shield 4FeH instead. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations identified a novel water channel (WH ) surrounding the H-cluster. As this hydrophilic path may be accessible for O2 molecules we applied site-directed mutagenesis targeting amino acids along WH in proximity to 4FeH to block O2 diffusion. Protein film electrochemistry experiments demonstrate increased O2 stabilities for variants G302S and S357T, and MD simulations based on high-resolution crystal structures confirmed an enhanced local sieving effect for O2 in the environment of the 4FeH in both cases. The results strongly suggest that, in wild type proteins, O2 diffuses from the 4FeH to the 2FeH . These results reveal new strategies for improving the O2 stability of [FeFe]-hydrogenases by focusing on the O2 diffusion network near the active site.

Probing Substrate Transport Effects on Enzymatic Hydrogen Catalysis: An Alternative Proton Transfer Pathway in Putatively Sensory [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases, metalloenzymes catalyzing proton/dihydrogen interconversion, have attracted intense attention due to their remarkable catalytic properties and (bio-)technological potential for a future hydrogen economy. In order to unravel the factors enabling their efficient catalysis, both their unique organometallic cofactors and protein structural features, i.e., "outer-coordination sphere" effects have been intensively studied. These structurally diverse enzymes are divided into distinct phylogenetic groups, denoted as Group A-D. Prototypical Group A hydrogenases display high turnover rates (104-105 s-1). Conversely, the sole characterized Group D representative, Thermoanaerobacter mathranii HydS (TamHydS), shows relatively low catalytic activity (specific activity 10-1 μmol H2 mg-1 min-1) and has been proposed to serve a H2-sensory function. The various groups of [FeFe] hydrogenase share the same catalytic cofactor, the H-cluster, and the structural factors causing the diverging reactivities of Group A and D remain to be elucidated. In the case of the highly active Group A enzymes, a well-defined proton transfer pathway (PTP) has been identified, which shuttles H+ between the enzyme surface and the active site. In Group D hydrogenases, this conserved pathway is absent. Here, we report on the identification of highly conserved amino acid residues in Group D hydrogenases that constitute a possible alternative PTP. We varied two proposed key amino acid residues of this pathway (E252 and E289, TamHydS numbering) via site-directed mutagenesis and analyzed the resulting variants via biochemical and spectroscopic methods. All variants displayed significantly decreased H2-evolution and -oxidation activities. Additionally, the variants showed two redox states that were not characterized previously. These findings provide initial evidence that these amino acid residues are central to the putative PTP of Group D [FeFe] hydrogenase. Since the identified residues are highly conserved in Group D exclusively, our results support the notion that the PTP is not universal for different phylogenetic groups in [FeFe] hydrogenases.

Post-acquisition correction of NMR spectra distorted by dynamic and static field inhomogeneity of cryogen-free magnets

Post-acquisition correction of NMR spectra is an important part of NMR spectroscopy that enables refined NMR spectra to be obtained, clean from undesirable out-phasing, broadening and noising. We describe analytical and numerical mathematical methods for post-acquisition correction of NMR spectra distorted by static and dynamic magnetic field inhomogeneity caused by imperfections of main superconducting coils and the cold head operation, typical for cryogen-free magnets. For the dynamic inhomogeneity, we apply a variant of the general reference deconvolution method, complemented with our mathematical analysis of spectral parameters. For the static inhomogeneity, we apply the method of a delayed Fourier transform, also supported with our analytical calculations. We verify our approach by correction processing of high-field experimental liquid-state 1H NMR spectra of water and ethanol as well as solid-state 13C MAS NMR spectra of adamantane and obtain good results for both static and dynamic field distortions. This work complements our previous work on instrumental suppression of dynamic distortions caused by the cold head operation. The results presented contribute well to the general field of processing NMR spectra and serve towards a more extensive use of cryogen-free magnets in high-resolution NMR spectroscopy.

Cryogen-free 400 MHz (9.4 T) solid state MAS NMR system with liquid state NMR potential

We show that the temporal magnetic field distortion generated by the Cold Head operation can be removed and high quality Solid-State Magic Angle Spinning NMR results can be obtained with a cryogen-free magnet. The compact design of the cryogen-free magnets allows for the probe to be inserted either from the bottom (as in most NMR systems) or, more conveniently, from the top. The magnetic field settling time can be made as short as an hour after a field ramp. Therefore, a single cryogen-free magnet can be used at different fixed fields. The magnetic field can be changed every day without compromising the measurement resolution.

Advances and challenges in photosynthetic hydrogen production

The vision to replace coal with hydrogen goes back to Jules Verne in 1874. However, sustainable hydrogen production remains challenging. The most elegant approach is to utilize photosynthesis for water splitting and to subsequently save solar energy as hydrogen. Cyanobacteria and green algae are unicellular photosynthetic organisms that contain hydrogenases and thereby possess the enzymatic equipment for photosynthetic hydrogen production. These features of cyanobacteria and algae have inspired artificial and semi-artificial in vitro techniques, that connect photoexcited materials or enzymes with hydrogenases or mimics of these for hydrogen production. These in vitro methods have on their part been models for the fusion of cyanobacterial and algal hydrogenases to photosynthetic photosystem I (PSI) in vivo, which recently succeeded as proofs of principle.

The Contribution of Proton-Donor pKa on Reactivity Profiles of [FeFe]-hydrogenases

The [FeFe]-hydrogenases are enzymes that catalyze the reversible activation of H₂ coupled to the reduction–oxidation of electron carriers. Members of the different taxonomic groups of [FeFe]-hydrogenases display a wide range of preference, or bias, for H₂ oxidation or H₂ production reactions, despite sharing a common catalytic cofactor, or H-cluster. Identifying the properties that control reactivity remains an active area of investigation, and models have emerged that include diversity in the catalytic site coordination environments and compositions of electron transfer chains. The kinetics of proton-coupled electron transfer at the H-cluster might be expected to be a point of control of reactivity. To test this hypothesis, systematic changes were made to the conserved cysteine residue that functions in proton exchange with the H-cluster in the three model enzymes: CaI, CpII, and CrHydA1. CaI and CpII both employ electron transfer accessory clusters but differ in bias, whereas CrHydA1 lacks accessory clusters having only the H-cluster. Changing from cysteine to either serine (more basic) or aspartate (more acidic) modifies the sidechain pKa and thus the barrier for the proton exchange step. The reaction rates for H₂ oxidation or H₂ evolution were surveyed and measured for model [FeFe]-hydrogenases, and the results show that the initial proton-transfer step in [FeFe]-hydrogenase is tightly coupled to the control of reactivity; a change from cysteine to more basic serine favored H₂ oxidation in all enzymes, whereas a change to more acidic aspartate caused a shift in preference toward H₂ evolution. Overall, the changes in reactivity profiles were profound, spanning 10⁵ in ratio of the H₂ oxidation-to-H₂ evolution rates. The fact that the change in reactivity follows a common trend implies that the effect of changing the proton-transfer residue pKa may also be framed as an effect on the scaling relationship between the H-cluster di(thiolmethyl)amine (DTMA) ligand pKa and E_m values of the H-cluster. Experimental observations that support this relationship, and how it relates to catalytic function in [FeFe]-hydrogenases, are discussed.

Second and Outer Coordination Sphere Effects in Nitrogenase, Hydrogenase, Formate Dehydrogenase, and CO Dehydrogenase

Gases like H₂, N₂, CO₂, and CO are increasingly recognized as critical feedstock in "green" energy conversion and as sources of nitrogen and carbon for the agricultural and chemical sectors. However, the industrial transformation of N₂, CO₂, and CO and the production of H₂ require significant energy input, which renders processes like steam reforming and the Haber-Bosch reaction economically and environmentally unviable. Nature, on the other hand, performs similar tasks efficiently at ambient temperature and pressure, exploiting gas-processing metalloenzymes (GPMs) that bind low-valent metal cofactors based on iron, nickel, molybdenum, tungsten, and sulfur. Such systems are studied to understand the biocatalytic principles of gas conversion including N₂ fixation by nitrogenase and H₂ production by hydrogenase as well as CO₂ and CO conversion by formate dehydrogenase, carbon monoxide dehydrogenase, and nitrogenase. In this review, we emphasize the importance of the cofactor/protein interface, discussing how second and outer coordination sphere effects determine, modulate, and optimize the catalytic activity of GPMs. These may comprise ionic interactions in the second coordination sphere that shape the electron density distribution across the cofactor, hydrogen bonding changes, and allosteric effects. In the outer coordination sphere, proton transfer and electron transfer are discussed, alongside the role of hydrophobic substrate channels and protein structural changes. Combining the information gained from structural biology, enzyme kinetics, and various spectroscopic techniques, we aim toward a comprehensive understanding of catalysis beyond the first coordination sphere.

Stability of the H-cluster under whole-cell conditions-formation of an Htrans-like state and its reactivity towards oxygen

Hydrogenases are metalloenzymes that catalyze the reversible oxidation of molecular hydrogen into protons and electrons. For this purpose, [FeFe]-hydrogenases utilize a hexanuclear iron cofactor, the H-cluster. This biologically unique cofactor provides the enzyme with outstanding catalytic activities, but it is also highly oxygen sensitive. Under in vitro conditions, oxygen stable forms of the H-cluster denoted H_trans and H_inact can be generated via treatment with sulfide under oxidizing conditions. Herein, we show that an H_trans-like species forms spontaneously under intracellular conditions on a time scale of hours, concurrent with the cells ceasing H₂ production. Addition of cysteine or sulfide during the maturation promotes the formation of this H-cluster state. Moreover, it is found that formation of the observed H_trans-like species is influenced by both steric factors and proton transfer, underscoring the importance of outer coordination sphere effects on H-cluster reactivity.

The oxygen-resistant [FeFe]-hydrogenase CbA5H harbors an unknown radical signal

[FeFe]-hydrogenases catalyze the reversible conversion of molecular hydrogen into protons and electrons with remarkable efficiency. However, their industrial applications are limited by their oxygen sensitivity. Recently, it was shown that the [FeFe]-hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinckii (CbA5H) is oxygen-resistant and can be reactivated after oxygen exposure. In this work, we used multifrequency continuous wave and pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to characterize the active center of CbA5H, the H-cluster. Under oxidizing conditions, the spectra were dominated by an additional and unprecedented radical species. The generation of this radical signal depends on the presence of an intact H-cluster and a complete proton transfer pathway including the bridging azadithiolate ligand. Selective ⁵⁷Fe enrichment combined with isotope-sensitive electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectroscopy revealed a spin density distribution that resembles an H-cluster state. Overall, we uncovered a radical species in CbA5H that is potentially involved in the redox sensing of CbA5H.

Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy revealed an unprecedented radical species in the oxygen-resistant [FeFe]-hydrogenase CbA5H. Analysis of the isotope-sensitive data suggests that it is related to the active site, the H-cluster.

Harnessing selenocysteine to enhance microbial cell factories for hydrogen production

Hydrogen is a clean, renewable energy source, that when combined with oxygen, produces heat and electricity with only water vapor as a biproduct. Furthermore, it has the highest energy content by weight of all known fuels. As a result, various strategies have engineered methods to produce hydrogen efficiently and in quantities that are of interest to the economy. To approach the notion of producing hydrogen from a biological perspective, we take our attention to hydrogenases which are naturally produced in microbes. These organisms have the machinery to produce hydrogen, which when cleverly engineered, could be useful in cell factories resulting in large production of hydrogen. Not all hydrogenases are efficient at hydrogen production, and those that are, tend to be oxygen sensitive. Therefore, we provide a new perspective on introducing selenocysteine, a highly reactive proteinogenic amino acid, as a strategy towards engineering hydrogenases with enhanced hydrogen production, or increased oxygen tolerance.

Reversible or Irreversible Catalysis of H+/H2 Conversion by FeFe Hydrogenases

Studies of molecular catalysts traditionally aim at understanding how a certain mechanism allows the reaction to be fast. A distinct question, which has only recently received attention in the case of bidirectional molecular catalysts, is how much thermodynamic driving force is required to achieve fast catalysis in either direction of the reaction. "Reversible" catalysts are bidirectional catalysts that work either way in response to even a small departure from equilibrium and thus do not waste input free energy as heat; conversely, "irreversible" catalysts require a large driving force to proceed at an appreciable rate [Fourmond et al. Nat. Rev. Chem. 2021, 5, 348-360]. Numerous mechanistic rationales for these contrasting behaviors have been proposed. To understand the determinants of catalytic (ir)reversibility, we examined the steady-state, direct electron transfer voltammetry of a particular FeFe hydrogenase, from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii, which is very unusual in that it irreversibly catalyzes H₂ oxidation and production: a large overpotential is required for the reaction to proceed in either direction [Land et al. Chem. Sci. 2020, 11, 12789-12801]. In contrast to previous hypotheses, we demonstrate that in this particular enzyme catalytic irreversibility can be explained without invoking slow interfacial electron transfer or variations in the mechanism: the observed kinetics is fully consistent with the same catalytic pathway being used in both directions of the reaction.

Recent advances in tuning redox properties of electron transfer centers in metalloenzymes catalyzing oxygen reduction reaction and H2 oxidation important for fuel cells design

Current fuel-cell catalysts for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) and H₂ oxidation use precious metals and, for ORR, require high overpotentials. In contrast, metalloenzymes perform their respective reaction at low overpotentials using earth-abundant metals, making metalloenzymes ideal candidates for inspiring electrocatalytic design. Critical to the success of these enzymes are redox-active metal centers surrounding the enzyme active sites that ensure fast electron transfer (ET) to or away from the active site, by tuning the catalytic potential of the reaction as observed in multicopper oxidases but also in dictating the catalytic bias of the reaction as realized in hydrogenases. This review summarizes recent advances in studying these ET centers in multicopper oxidases and heme-copper oxidases that perform ORR and hydrogenases in carrying out H₂ oxidation. Insights gained from understanding how the reduction potential of the ET centers effects reactivity at the active site in both the enzymes and their models are provided.

HydG, the "dangler" iron, and catalytic production of free CO and CN-: implications for [FeFe]-hydrogenase maturation

The organometallic H-cluster of the [FeFe]-hydrogenase consists of a [4Fe-4S] cubane bridged via a cysteinyl thiolate to a 2Fe subcluster ([2Fe]H) containing CO, CN-, and dithiomethylamine (DTMA) ligands. The H-cluster is synthesized by three dedicated maturation proteins: the radical SAM enzymes HydE and HydG synthesize the non-protein ligands, while the GTPase HydF serves as a scaffold for assembly of [2Fe]H prior to its delivery to the [FeFe]-hydrogenase containing the [4Fe-4S] cubane. HydG uses l-tyrosine as a substrate, cleaving it to produce p-cresol as well as the CO and CN- ligands to the H-cluster, although there is some question as to whether these are formed as free diatomics or as part of a [Fe(CO)2(CN)] synthon. Here we show that Clostridium acetobutylicum (C.a.) HydG catalyzes formation of multiple equivalents of free CO at rates comparable to those for CN- formation. Free CN- is also formed in excess molar equivalents over protein. A g = 8.9 EPR signal is observed for C.a. HydG reconstituted to load the 5th "dangler" iron of the auxiliary [4Fe-4S][FeCys] cluster and is assigned to this "dangler-loaded" cluster state. Free CO and CN- formation and the degree of activation of [FeFe]-hydrogenase all occur regardless of dangler loading, but are increased 10-35% in the dangler-loaded HydG; this indicates the dangler iron is not essential to this process but may affect relevant catalysis. During HydG turnover in the presence of myoglobin, the g = 8.9 signal remains unchanged, indicating that a [Fe(CO)2(CN)(Cys)] synthon is not formed at the dangler iron. Mutation of the only protein ligand to the dangler iron, H272, to alanine nearly completely abolishes both free CO formation and hydrogenase activation, however results show this is not due solely to the loss of the dangler iron. In experiments with wild type and H272A HydG, and with different degrees of dangler loading, we observe a consistent correlation between free CO/CN- formation and hydrogenase activation. Taken in full, our results point to free CO/CN-, but not an [Fe(CO)2(CN)(Cys)] synthon, as essential species in hydrogenase maturation.

Reversible catalysis

We describe as 'reversible' a bidirectional catalyst that allows a reaction to proceed at a significant rate in response to even a small departure from equilibrium, resulting in fast and energy-efficient chemical transformation. Examining the relation between reaction rate and thermodynamic driving force is the basis of electrochemical investigations of redox reactions, which can be catalysed by metallic surfaces and biological or synthetic molecular catalysts. This relation has also been discussed in the context of biological energy transduction, regarding the function of biological molecular machines that harness chemical reactions to do mechanical work. This Perspective describes mean-field kinetic modelling of these three types of systems - surface catalysts, molecular catalysts of redox reactions and molecular machines - with the goal of unifying concepts in these different fields. We emphasize that reversibility should be distinguished from other figures of merit, such as rate or directionality, before its design principles can be identified and used to engineer synthetic catalysts.

Reversible H2 Oxidation and Evolution by Hydrogenase Embedded in a Redox Polymer Film

Efficient electrocatalytic energy conversion requires the devices to function reversibly, i.e. deliver a significant current at minimal overpotential. Redox-active films can effectively embed and stabilise molecular electrocatalysts, but mediated electron transfer through the film typically makes the catalytic response irreversible. Here, we describe a redox-active film for bidirectional (oxidation or reduction) and reversible hydrogen conversion, consisting of [FeFe] hydrogenase embedded in a low-potential, 2,2’-viologen modified hydrogel. When this catalytic film served as the anode material in a H₂/O₂ biofuel cell, an open circuit voltage of 1.16 V was obtained - a benchmark value near the thermodynamic limit. The same film also acted as a highly energy efficient cathode material for H₂ evolution. We explained the catalytic properties using a kinetic model, which shows that reversibility can be achieved despite intermolecular electron transfer being slower than catalysis. This understanding of reversibility simplifies the design principles of highly efficient and stable bioelectrocatalytic films, advancing their implementation in energy conversion.

Artificial maturation of [FeFe] hydrogenase in a redox polymer film

We demonstrate that the insertion of the dinuclear active site of [FeFe] hydrogenase into the apo-enzyme can occur when the enzyme is embedded in a film of redox polymer, under conditions of mediated electron transfer. The maturation can be monitored by electrochemistry, and is as fast as under conditions of direct electron transfer. This new approach further clears the way to the implementation of hydrogenases in large scale real life processes.

A Beginner’s Guide to Thermodynamic Modelling of [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases, which are considered the most active naturally occurring catalysts for hydrogen oxidation and proton reduction, are extensively studied as models to learn the important features for efficient H2 conversion catalysis. Using infrared spectroscopy as a selective probe, the redox behaviour of the active site H-cluster is routinely modelled with thermodynamic schemes based on the Nernst equation for determining thermodynamic parameters, such as redox midpoint potentials and pKa values. Here, the thermodynamic models usually applied to [FeFe] hydrogenases are introduced and discussed in a pedagogic fashion and their applicability to additional metalloenzymes and molecular catalysts is also addressed.

Electrochemical Characterization of a Complex FeFe Hydrogenase, the Electron-Bifurcating Hnd From Desulfovibrio fructosovorans

Hnd, an FeFe hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio fructosovorans, is a tetrameric enzyme that can perform flavin-based electron bifurcation. It couples the oxidation of H₂ to both the exergonic reduction of NAD⁺ and the endergonic reduction of a ferredoxin. We previously showed that Hnd retains activity even when purified aerobically unlike other electron-bifurcating hydrogenases. In this study, we describe the purification of the enzyme under O₂-free atmosphere and its biochemical and electrochemical characterization. Despite its complexity due to its multimeric composition, Hnd can catalytically and directly exchange electrons with an electrode. We characterized the catalytic and inhibition properties of this electron-bifurcating hydrogenase using protein film electrochemistry of Hnd by purifying Hnd aerobically or anaerobically, then comparing the electrochemical properties of the enzyme purified under the two conditions via protein film electrochemistry. Hydrogenases are usually inactivated under oxidizing conditions in the absence of dioxygen and can then be reactivated, to some extent, under reducing conditions. We demonstrate that the kinetics of this high potential inactivation/reactivation for Hnd show original properties: it depends on the enzyme purification conditions and varies with time, suggesting the coexistence and the interconversion of two forms of the enzyme. We also show that Hnd catalytic properties (Km for H₂, diffusion and reaction at the active site of CO and O₂) are comparable to those of standard hydrogenases (those which cannot catalyze electron bifurcation). These results suggest that the presence of the additional subunits, needed for electron bifurcation, changes neither the catalytic behavior at the active site, nor the gas diffusion kinetics but induces unusual rates of high potential inactivation/reactivation.

Catalytic bias in oxidation-reduction catalysis

Cataytic bias refers to the propensity of a reaction catalyst to effect a different rate acceleration in one direction versus the other in a chemical reaction under non-equilibrium conditions. In biocatalysis, the inherent bias of an enzyme is often advantagous to augment the innate thermodynamics of a reaction to promote efficiency and fidelity in the coordination of catabolic and anabolic pathways. In industrial chemical catalysis a directional cataltyic bias is a sought after property in facilitating the engineering of systems that couple catalysis with harvest and storage of for example fine chemicals or energy compounds. Interestingly, there is little information about catalytic bias in biocatalysis likely in large part due to difficulties in developing tractible assays sensitive enough to study detailed kinetics. For oxidation-reduction reactions, colorimetric redox indicators exist in a range of reduction potentials to provide a mechanism to study both directions of reactions in a fairly facile manner. The current short review attempts to define catalytic bias conceptually and to develop model systems for defining the parameters that control catalytic bias in enzyme catalyzed oxidation-reduction catalysis.

Characterization of a putative sensory [FeFe]-hydrogenase provides new insight into the role of the active site architecture

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are known for their high rates of hydrogen turnover, and are intensively studied in the context of biotechnological applications. Evolution has generated a plethora of different subclasses with widely different characteristics. The M2e subclass is phylogenetically distinct from previously characterized members of this enzyme family and its biological role is unknown. It features significant differences in domain- and active site architecture, and is most closely related to the putative sensory [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Here we report the first comprehensive biochemical and spectroscopical characterization of an M2e enzyme, derived from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii. As compared to other [FeFe]-hydrogenases characterized to-date, this enzyme displays an increased H2 affinity, higher activation enthalpies for H+/H2 interconversion, and unusual reactivity towards known hydrogenase inhibitors. These properties are related to differences in active site architecture between the M2e [FeFe]-hydrogenase and "prototypical" [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Thus, this study provides new insight into the role of this subclass in hydrogen metabolism and the influence of the active site pocket on the chemistry of the H-cluster.

The roles of long-range proton-coupled electron transfer in the directionality and efficiency of [FeFe]-hydrogenases

As paradigms for proton-coupled electron transfer in enzymes and benchmarks for a fully renewable H₂ technology, [FeFe]-hydrogenases behave as highly reversible electrocatalysts when immobilized on an electrode, operating in both catalytic directions with minimal overpotential requirement. Using the [FeFe]-hydrogenases from Clostridium pasteurianum (CpI) and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1) we have conducted site-directed mutagenesis and protein film electrochemistry to determine how efficient catalysis depends on the long-range coupling of electron and proton transfer steps. Importantly, the electron and proton transfer pathways in [FeFe]-hydrogenases are well separated from each other in space. Variants with conservative substitutions (glutamate to aspartate) in either of two positions in the proton-transfer pathway retain significant activity and reveal the consequences of slowing down proton transfer for both catalytic directions over a wide range of pH and potential values. Proton reduction in the variants is impaired mainly by limiting the turnover rate, which drops sharply as the pH is raised, showing that proton capture from bulk solvent becomes critical. In contrast, hydrogen oxidation is affected in two ways: by limiting the turnover rate and by a large overpotential requirement that increases as the pH is raised, consistent with the accumulation of a reduced and protonated intermediate. A unique observation having fundamental significance is made under conditions where the variants still retain sufficient catalytic activity in both directions: An inflection appears as the catalytic current switches direction at the 2H⁺/H₂ thermodynamic potential, clearly signaling a departure from electrocatalytic reversibility as electron and proton transfers begin to be decoupled.

Investigation of the Unusual Ability of the [FeFe] Hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinckii to Access an O2-Protected State

[FeFe] hydrogenases are enzymes capable of producing and oxidizing H₂ at staggering submillisecond time scales. A major limitation in applying these enzymes for industrial hydrogen production is their irreversible inactivation by oxygen. Recently, an [FeFe] hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinckii (CbHydA1) was reported to regain its catalytic activity after exposure to oxygen. In this report, we have determined that artificially matured CbHydA1 is indeed oxygen tolerant in the absence of reducing agents and sulfides by means of reaching an O₂-protected state (H_inact). We were also able to generate the H_inact state anaerobically via both chemical and electrochemical oxidation. We use a combination of spectroscopy, electrochemistry, and density functional theory (DFT) to uncover intrinsic properties of the active center of CbHydA1, leading to its unprecedented oxygen tolerance. We have observed that reversible, low-potential oxidation of the active center leads to the protection against O₂-induced degradation. The transition between the active oxidized state (H_ox) and the H_inact state appears to proceed without any detectable intermediates. We found that the H_inact state is stable for more than 40 h in air, highlighting the remarkable resilience of CbHydA1 to oxygen. Using a combination of DFT and FTIR, we also provide a hypothesis for the chemical identity of the H_inact state. These results demonstrate that CbHydA1 has remarkable stability in the presence of oxygen, which will drive future efforts to engineer more robust catalysts for biofuel production.

The Solvent-Exposed Fe-S D-Cluster Contributes to Oxygen-Resistance in Desulfovibrio vulgaris Ni-Fe Carbon Monoxide Dehydrogenase

Ni-Fe CO-dehydrogenases (CODHs) catalyze the conversion between CO and CO₂ using a chain of Fe-S clusters to mediate long-range electron transfer. One of these clusters, the D-cluster, is surface-exposed and serves to transfer electrons between CODH and external redox partners. These enzymes tend to be extremely O₂-sensitive and are always manipulated under strictly anaerobic conditions. However, the CODH from Desulfovibrio vulgaris (Dv) appears unique: exposure to micromolar concentrations of O₂ on the minutes-time scale only reversibly inhibits the enzyme, and full activity is recovered after reduction. Here, we examine whether this unusual property of Dv CODH results from the nature of its D-cluster, which is a [2Fe-2S] cluster, instead of the [4Fe-4S] cluster observed in all other characterized CODHs. To this aim, we produced and characterized a Dv CODH variant where the [2Fe-2S] D-cluster is replaced with a [4Fe-4S] D-cluster through mutagenesis of the D-cluster-binding sequence motif. We determined the crystal structure of this CODH variant to 1.83-Å resolution and confirmed the incorporation of a [4Fe-4S] D-cluster. We show that upon long-term O₂-exposure, the [4Fe-4S] D-cluster degrades, whereas the [2Fe-2S] D-cluster remains intact. Crystal structures of the Dv CODH variant exposed to O₂ for increasing periods of time provide snapshots of [4Fe-4S] D-cluster degradation. We further show that the WT enzyme purified under aerobic conditions retains 30% activity relative to a fully anaerobic purification, compared to 10% for the variant, and the WT enzyme loses activity more slowly than the variant upon prolonged aerobic storage. The D-cluster is therefore a key site of irreversible oxidative damage in Dv CODH, and the presence of a [2Fe-2S] D-cluster contributes to the O₂-tolerance of this enzyme. Together, these results relate O₂-sensitivity with the details of the protein structure in this family of enzymes.

Opportunities toward hydrogen production biotechnologies

Hydrogen is already a major commodity and process intermediate for fertilizer production, petroleum processing, and chemical synthesis. It also offers unrealized potential for energy storage. While biological production offers an expandable and sustainable source, enthusiasm has been dampened by slow research progress. Also, the very low cost of natural gas (the major current hydrogen source) imposes severe economic challenges. This discussion describes process, metabolic, and protein engineering opportunities toward cost-effective biohydrogen production. Recent progress in hydrogenase engineering and photosynthetic bacterial research now suggests a favorable risk versus reward opportunity. Although the risks are still significant, successful technologies would provide important components in an integrated energy portfolio that enables global sustainability.

Tuning Catalytic Bias of Hydrogen Gas Producing Hydrogenases

Hydrogenases display a wide range of catalytic rates and biases in reversible hydrogen gas oxidation catalysis. The interactions of the iron-sulfur-containing catalytic site with the local protein environment are thought to contribute to differences in catalytic reactivity, but this has not been demonstrated. The microbe Clostridium pasteurianum produces three [FeFe]-hydrogenases that differ in "catalytic bias" by exerting a disproportionate rate acceleration in one direction or the other that spans a remarkable 6 orders of magnitude. The combination of high-resolution structural work, biochemical analyses, and computational modeling indicates that protein secondary interactions directly influence the relative stabilization/destabilization of different oxidation states of the active site metal cluster. This selective stabilization or destabilization of oxidation states can preferentially promote hydrogen oxidation or proton reduction and represents a simple yet elegant model by which a protein catalytic site can confer catalytic bias.

Loss of Specific Active-Site Iron Atoms in Oxygen-Exposed [FeFe]-Hydrogenase Determined by Detailed X-ray Structure Analyses

The [FeFe]-hydrogenases catalyze the uptake and evolution of hydrogen with unmatched speed at low overpotential. However, oxygen induces the degradation of the unique [6Fe-6S] cofactor within the active site, termed the H-cluster. We used X-ray structural analyses to determine possible modes of irreversible oxygen-driven inactivation. To this end, we exposed crystals of the [FeFe]-hydrogenase CpI from Clostridium pasteurianum to oxygen and quantitatively investigated the effects on the H-cluster structure over several time points using multiple data sets, while correlating it to decreases in enzyme activity. Our results reveal the loss of specific Fe atoms from both the diiron (2Fe_H) and the [4Fe-4S] subcluster (4Fe_H) of the H-cluster. Within the 2Fe_H, the Fe atom more distal to the 4Fe_H is strikingly more affected than the more proximal Fe atom. The 4Fe_H interconverts to a [2Fe-2S] cluster in parts of the population of active CpI^ADT, but not in crystals of the inactive apoCpI initially lacking the 2Fe_H. We thus propose two parallel processes: dissociation of the distal Fe atom and 4Fe_H interconversion. Both pathways appear to play major roles in the oxidative damage of [FeFe]-hydrogenases under electron-donor deprived conditions probed by our experimental setup.

Understanding and Design of Bidirectional and Reversible Catalysts of Multielectron, Multistep Reactions

Some enzymes, including those that are involved in the activation of small molecules such as H₂ or CO₂, can be wired to electrodes and function in either direction of the reaction depending on the electrochemical driving force and display a significant rate at very small deviations from the equilibrium potential. We call the former property "bidirectionality" and the latter "reversibility". This performance sets very high standards for chemists who aim at designing synthetic electrocatalysts. Only recently, in the particular case of the hydrogen production/evolution reaction, has it been possible to produce inorganic catalysts that function bidirectionally, with an even smaller number that also function reversibly. This raises the question of how to engineer such desirable properties in other synthetic catalysts. Here we introduce the kinetic modeling of bidirectional two-electron-redox reactions in the case of molecular catalysts and enzymes that are either attached to an electrode or diffusing in solution in the vicinity of an electrode. We emphasize that trying to discuss bidirectionality and reversibility in relation to a single redox potential leads to an impasse: the catalyst undergoes two redox transitions, and therefore two catalytic potentials must be defined, which may depart from the two potentials measured in the absence of catalysis. The difference between the two catalytic potentials defines the reversibility; the difference between their average value and the equilibrium potential defines the directionality (also called "preference", or "bias"). We describe how the sequence of events in the bidirectional catalytic cycle can be elucidated on the basis of the voltammetric responses. Further, we discuss the design principles of bidirectionality and reversibility in terms of thermodynamics and kinetics and conclude that neither bidirectionality nor reversibility requires that the catalytic energy landscape be flat. These theoretical findings are illustrated by previous results obtained with nickel diphosphine molecular catalysts and hydrogenases. In particular, analysis of the nickel catalysts highlights the fact that reversible catalysis can be achieved by catalysts that follow complex mechanisms with branched reaction pathways.

2nd PSL Chemical Biology Symposium (2019): At the Crossroads of Chemistry and Biology

Chemical Biology is the science of designing chemical tools to dissect and manipulate biology at different scales. It provides the fertile ground from which to address important problems of our society, such as human health and environment.

Highlights from the 54th EUCHEM Bürgenstock Conference on Stereochemistry, Brunnen, Switzerland, May 2019

Collapse

Overview of the Maturation Machinery of the H-Cluster of [FeFe]-Hydrogenases with a Focus on HydF

Hydrogen production in nature is performed by hydrogenases. Among them, [FeFe]-hydrogenases have a peculiar active site, named H-cluster, that is made of two parts, synthesized in different pathways. The cubane sub-cluster requires the normal iron-sulfur cluster maturation machinery. The [2Fe] sub-cluster instead requires a dedicated set of maturase proteins, HydE, HydF, and HydG that work to assemble the cluster and deliver it to the apo-hydrogenase. In particular, the delivery is performed by HydF. In this review, we will perform an overview of the latest knowledge on the maturation machinery of the H-cluster, focusing in particular on HydF.