CO-Bridged H-Cluster Intermediates in the Catalytic Mechanism of [FeFe]-Hydrogenase CaI

Oxygen sensitivity of [FeFe]-hydrogenase: a comparative study of active site mimics inside vs. outside the enzyme

[FeFe]-hydrogenase is nature's most efficient proton reducing and H2-oxidizing enzyme. However, biotechnological applications are hampered by the O2 sensitivity of this metalloenzyme, and the mechanism of aerobic deactivation is not well understood. Here, we explore the oxygen sensitivity of four mimics of the organometallic active site cofactor of [FeFe]-hydrogenase, [Fe2(adt)(CO)6-x(CN)x]x- and [Fe2(pdt)(CO)6-x(CN)x]x- (x = 1, 2) as well as the corresponding cofactor variants of the enzyme by means of infrared, Mössbauer, and NMR spectroscopy. Additionally, we describe a straightforward synthetic recipe for the active site precursor complex Fe2(adt)(CO)6. Our data indicate that the aminodithiolate (adt) complex, which is the synthetic precursor of the natural active site cofactor, is most oxygen sensitive. This observation highlights the significance of proton transfer in aerobic deactivation, and supported by DFT calculations facilitates an identification of the responsible reactive oxygen species (ROS). Moreover, we show that the ligand environment of the iron ions critically influences the reactivity with O2 and ROS like superoxide and H2O2 as the oxygen sensitivity increases with the exchange of ligands from CO to CN-. The trends in aerobic deactivation observed for the model complexes are in line with the respective enzyme variants. Based on experimental and computational data, a model for the initial reaction of [FeFe]-hydrogenase with O2 is developed. Our study underscores the relevance of model systems in understanding biocatalysis and validates their potential as important tools for elucidating the chemistry of oxygen-induced deactivation of [FeFe]-hydrogenase.

Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation-Mediated Photocatalytic Subcellular Hybrid System for Highly Efficient Hydrogen Production

Plant chloroplasts have a highly compartmentalized interior, essential for executing photocatalytic functions. However, the construction of a photocatalytic reaction compartment similar to chloroplasts in inorganic-biological hybrid systems (IBS) has not been reported. Drawing inspiration from the compartmentalized chloroplast and the phenomenon of liquid-liquid phase separation, herein, a new strategy is first developed for constructing a photocatalytic subcellular hybrid system through liquid-liquid phase separation technology in living cells. Photosensitizers and in vivo expressed hydrogenases are designed to coassemble within the cell to create subcellular compartments for synergetic photocatalysis. This compartmentalization facilitates efficient electron transfer and light energy utilization, resulting in highly effective H2 production. The subcellular compartments hybrid system (HM/IBSCS) exhibits a nearly 87-fold increase in H2 production compared to the bare bacteria/hybrid system. Furthermore, the intracellular compartments of the photocatalytic reactor enhance the system's stability obviously, with the bacteria maintaining approximately 81% of their H2 production activity even after undergoing five cycles of photocatalytic hydrogen production. The research brings forward visionary prospects for the field of semi-artificial photosynthesis, offering new possibilities for advancements in areas such as renewable energy, biomanufacturing, and genetic engineering.

Facile electrocatalytic proton reduction by a [Fe-Fe]-hydrogenase bio-inspired synthetic model bearing a terminal CN- ligand

An azadithiolate bridged CN- bound pentacarbonyl bis-iron complex, mimicking the active site of [Fe-Fe] H2ase is synthesized. The geometric and electronic structure of this complex is elucidated using a combination of EXAFS analysis, infrared and Mössbauer spectroscopy and DFT calculations. The electrochemical investigations show that complex 1 effectively reduces H+ to H2 between pH 0-3 at diffusion-controlled rates (1011 M-1 s-1) i.e. 108 s-1 at pH 3 with an overpotential of 140 mV. Electrochemical analysis and DFT calculations suggests that a CN- ligand increases the pKa of the cluster enabling hydrogen production from its Fe(i)-Fe(0) state at pHs much higher and overpotential much lower than its precursor bis-iron hexacarbonyl model which is active in its Fe(0)-Fe(0) state. The formation of a terminal Fe-H species, evidenced by spectroelectrochemistry in organic solvent, via a rate determining proton coupled electron transfer step and protonation of the adjacent azadithiolate, lowers the kinetic barrier leading to diffusion controlled rates of H2 evolution. The stereo-electronic factors enhance its catalytic rate by 3 order of magnitude relative to a bis-iron hexacarbonyl precursor at the same pH and potential.

Kinetic Modeling of the Reversible or Irreversible Electrochemical Responses of FeFe-Hydrogenases

The enzyme FeFe-hydrogenase catalyzes H2 evolution and oxidation at an active site that consists of a [4Fe-4S] cluster bridged to a [Fe2(CO)3(CN)2(azadithiolate)] subsite. Previous investigations of its mechanism were mostly conducted on a few "prototypical" FeFe-hydrogenases, such as that from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii(Cr HydA1), but atypical hydrogenases have recently been characterized in an effort to explore the diversity of this class of enzymes. We aim at understanding why prototypical hydrogenases are active in either direction of the reaction in response to a small deviation from equilibrium, whereas the homologous enzyme from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii (Tam HydS) shows activity only under conditions of very high driving force, a behavior that was referred to as "irreversible catalysis". We follow up on previous spectroscopic studies and recent developments in the kinetic modeling of bidirectional reactions to investigate and compare the catalytic cycles of Cr HydA1 and Tam HydS under conditions of direct electron transfer with an electrode. We compare the hypothetical catalytic cycles described in the literature, and we show that the observed changes in catalytic activity as a function of potential, pH, and H2 concentration can be explained with the assumption that the same catalytic mechanism applies. This helps us identify which variations in properties of the catalytic intermediates give rise to the distinct "reversible" or "irreversible" catalytic behaviors.

The Alga Uronema belkae Has Two Structural Types of [FeFe]-Hydrogenases with Different Biochemical Properties

Several species of microalgae can convert light energy into molecular hydrogen (H2) by employing enzymes of early phylogenetic origin, [FeFe]-hydrogenases, coupled to the photosynthetic electron transport chain. Bacterial [FeFe]-hydrogenases consist of a conserved domain that harbors the active site cofactor, the H-domain, and an additional domain that binds electron-conducting FeS clusters, the F-domain. In contrast, most algal hydrogenases characterized so far have a structurally reduced, so-termed M1-type architecture, which consists only of the H-domain that interacts directly with photosynthetic ferredoxin PetF as an electron donor. To date, only a few algal species are known to contain bacterial-type [FeFe]-hydrogenases, and no M1-type enzymes have been identified in these species. Here, we show that the chlorophycean alga Uronema belkae possesses both bacterial-type and algal-type [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Both hydrogenase genes are transcribed, and the cells produce H2 under hypoxic conditions. The biochemical analyses show that the two enzymes show features typical for each of the two [FeFe]-hydrogenase types. Most notable in the physiological context is that the bacterial-type hydrogenase does not interact with PetF proteins, suggesting that the two enzymes are integrated differently into the alga's metabolism.

Synthesis, Spectroscopy, and Structure of [FeRu(μ-dithiolate)(CN)2(CO)4]2

The salt [K(18-crown-6)]2[Ru(CN)2(CO)3] ([K(18-crown-6)]2[1]) was generated by the reaction of Ru(C2H4)(CO)4 with [K(18-crown-6)]CN. An initial thermal reaction gives [Ru(CN)(CO)4]-, which, upon ultraviolet (UV) irradiation, reacts with a second equiv of CN-. Protonation of [1]2- gave [HRu(CN)2(CO)3]- ([H1]-), which was isolated as a single isomer with mutually trans cyanide ligands. The complex cis,cis,cis-[Ru(pdt)(CN)2(CO)2]2- ([2]2-) was prepared by the UV-induced reaction of [1]2- with propanedithiol (pdtH2). The corresponding iron complex cis,cis,cis-[Fe(pdt)(CN)2(CO)2]2- ([3]2-) was prepared similarly. The pdt complexes [2]2- and [3]2- were treated with Fe(benzylideneacetone)(CO)3 to give, respectively, [RuFe (μ-pdt)(CN)2(CO)4]2- ([5]2-) and [Fe2(μ-pdt)(CN)2(CO)4]2- ([4]2-). The pathway from [3]2- to Fe2 complex [4]2- implicates intermetallic migration of CN-. In contrast, the formation of [5]2- leaves the Ru(CN)2(CO) center intact, as confirmed by X-ray crystallography. The structure of [5]2- features a "rotated" square-pyramidal Fe(CO)2(μ-CO) site. NMR measurements indicate that the octahedral Ru site is stereochemically rigid, whereas the Fe site dynamically undergoes turnstile rotation. 57Fe Mössbauer spectral parameters are very similar for rotated [5]2- and unrotated Fe2 complex [4]2-, indicating the insensitivity of that technique to both the geometry and the oxidation state of the Fe site. According to cyclic voltammetry, [5]2- oxidizes at E1/2 ∼ -0.8 V vs Fc+/0. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurements show that 1e- oxidation of [5]2- gives an S = 1/2 rhombic species, consistent with the formulation Ru(II)Fe(I), related to the Hox state of the [FeFe] hydrogenases. Density functional theory (DFT) studies reproduce the structure, 1H NMR shifts, and infrared (IR) spectra observed for [5]2-. Related homometallic complexes with both cyanides on a single metal are predicted to not adopt rotated structures. These data suggest that [5]2- is best described as Ru(II)Fe(0). This conclusion raises the possibility that for some reduced states of the [FeFe]-hydrogenases, the [2Fe]H site may be better described as Fe(II)Fe(0) than Fe(I)Fe(I).

The Contribution of Proton-Donor pKa on Reactivity Profiles of [FeFe]-hydrogenases

The [FeFe]-hydrogenases are enzymes that catalyze the reversible activation of H₂ coupled to the reduction–oxidation of electron carriers. Members of the different taxonomic groups of [FeFe]-hydrogenases display a wide range of preference, or bias, for H₂ oxidation or H₂ production reactions, despite sharing a common catalytic cofactor, or H-cluster. Identifying the properties that control reactivity remains an active area of investigation, and models have emerged that include diversity in the catalytic site coordination environments and compositions of electron transfer chains. The kinetics of proton-coupled electron transfer at the H-cluster might be expected to be a point of control of reactivity. To test this hypothesis, systematic changes were made to the conserved cysteine residue that functions in proton exchange with the H-cluster in the three model enzymes: CaI, CpII, and CrHydA1. CaI and CpII both employ electron transfer accessory clusters but differ in bias, whereas CrHydA1 lacks accessory clusters having only the H-cluster. Changing from cysteine to either serine (more basic) or aspartate (more acidic) modifies the sidechain pKa and thus the barrier for the proton exchange step. The reaction rates for H₂ oxidation or H₂ evolution were surveyed and measured for model [FeFe]-hydrogenases, and the results show that the initial proton-transfer step in [FeFe]-hydrogenase is tightly coupled to the control of reactivity; a change from cysteine to more basic serine favored H₂ oxidation in all enzymes, whereas a change to more acidic aspartate caused a shift in preference toward H₂ evolution. Overall, the changes in reactivity profiles were profound, spanning 10⁵ in ratio of the H₂ oxidation-to-H₂ evolution rates. The fact that the change in reactivity follows a common trend implies that the effect of changing the proton-transfer residue pKa may also be framed as an effect on the scaling relationship between the H-cluster di(thiolmethyl)amine (DTMA) ligand pKa and E_m values of the H-cluster. Experimental observations that support this relationship, and how it relates to catalytic function in [FeFe]-hydrogenases, are discussed.

Second and Outer Coordination Sphere Effects in Nitrogenase, Hydrogenase, Formate Dehydrogenase, and CO Dehydrogenase

Gases like H₂, N₂, CO₂, and CO are increasingly recognized as critical feedstock in "green" energy conversion and as sources of nitrogen and carbon for the agricultural and chemical sectors. However, the industrial transformation of N₂, CO₂, and CO and the production of H₂ require significant energy input, which renders processes like steam reforming and the Haber-Bosch reaction economically and environmentally unviable. Nature, on the other hand, performs similar tasks efficiently at ambient temperature and pressure, exploiting gas-processing metalloenzymes (GPMs) that bind low-valent metal cofactors based on iron, nickel, molybdenum, tungsten, and sulfur. Such systems are studied to understand the biocatalytic principles of gas conversion including N₂ fixation by nitrogenase and H₂ production by hydrogenase as well as CO₂ and CO conversion by formate dehydrogenase, carbon monoxide dehydrogenase, and nitrogenase. In this review, we emphasize the importance of the cofactor/protein interface, discussing how second and outer coordination sphere effects determine, modulate, and optimize the catalytic activity of GPMs. These may comprise ionic interactions in the second coordination sphere that shape the electron density distribution across the cofactor, hydrogen bonding changes, and allosteric effects. In the outer coordination sphere, proton transfer and electron transfer are discussed, alongside the role of hydrophobic substrate channels and protein structural changes. Combining the information gained from structural biology, enzyme kinetics, and various spectroscopic techniques, we aim toward a comprehensive understanding of catalysis beyond the first coordination sphere.

Time-Resolved Infrared Spectroscopy Reveals the pH-Independence of the First Electron Transfer Step in the [FeFe] Hydrogenase Catalytic Cycle

[FeFe] hydrogenases are highly active catalysts for hydrogen conversion. Their active site has two components: a [4Fe-4S] electron relay covalently attached to the H₂ binding site and a diiron cluster ligated by CO, CN^-, and 2-azapropane-1,3-dithiolate (ADT) ligands. Reduction of the [4Fe-4S] site was proposed to be coupled with protonation of one of its cysteine ligands. Here, we used time-resolved infrared (TRIR) spectroscopy on the [FeFe] hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1) containing a propane-1,3-dithiolate (PDT) ligand instead of the native ADT ligand. The PDT modification does not affect the electron transfer step to [4Fe-4S]_H but prevents the enzyme from proceeding further through the catalytic cycle. We show that the rate of the first electron transfer step is independent of the pH, supporting a simple electron transfer rather than a proton-coupled event. These results have important implications for our understanding of the catalytic mechanism of [FeFe] hydrogenases and highlight the utility of TRIR.

Bioinorganic Chemistry on Electrodes: Methods to Functional Modeling

One of the major goals of bioinorganic chemistry has been to mimic the function of elegant metalloenzymes. Such functional modeling has been difficult to attain in solution, in particular, for reactions that require multiple protons and multiple electrons (nH⁺/ne^-). Using a combination of heterogeneous electrochemistry, electrode and molecule design one may control both electron transfer (ET) and proton transfer (PT) of these nH⁺/ne^- reactions. Such control can allow functional modeling of hydrogenases (H⁺ + e^- → 1/2 H₂), cytochrome c oxidase (O₂ + 4 e^- + 4 H⁺ → 2 H₂O), monooxygenases (RR'CH₂ + O₂ + 2 e^- + 2 H⁺ → RR'CHOH + H₂O) and dioxygenases (S + O₂ → SO₂; S = organic substrate) in aqueous medium and at room temperatures. In addition, these heterogeneous constructs allow probing unnatural bioinspired reactions and estimation of the inner- and outer-sphere reorganization energy of small molecules and proteins.

Hydride state accumulation in native [FeFe]-hydrogenase with the physiological reductant H2 supports its catalytic relevance

Small molecules in solution may interfere with mechanistic investigations, as they can affect the stability of catalytic states and produce off-cycle states that can be mistaken for catalytically relevant species. Here we show that the hydride state (H_hyd), a proposed central intermediate in the catalytic cycle of [FeFe]-hydrogenase, can be formed in wild-type [FeFe]-hydrogenases treated with H₂ in absence of other, non-biological, reductants. Moreover, we reveal a new state with unclear role in catalysis induced by common low pH buffers.

Studies of enzymatic catalysis often rely on non-biological reagents, which may affect catalytic intermediates and produce off-cycle states. Here the influence of buffer and reductant on key intermediates of [FeFe]-hydrogenase are explored.

The Nonphysiological Reductant Sodium Dithionite and [FeFe] Hydrogenase: Influence on the Enzyme Mechanism

[FeFe] hydrogenases are highly active enzymes for interconverting protons and electrons with hydrogen (H₂). Their active site H-cluster is formed of a canonical [4Fe-4S] cluster ([4Fe-4S]_H) covalently attached to a unique [2Fe] subcluster ([2Fe]_H), where both sites are redox active. Heterolytic splitting and formation of H₂ takes place at [2Fe]_H, while [4Fe-4S]_H stores electrons. The detailed catalytic mechanism of these enzymes is under intense investigation, with two dominant models existing in the literature. In one model, an alternative form of the active oxidized state H_ox, named H_oxH, which forms at low pH in the presence of the nonphysiological reductant sodium dithionite (NaDT), is believed to play a crucial role. H_oxH was previously suggested to have a protonated [4Fe-4S]_H. Here, we show that H_oxH forms by simple addition of sodium sulfite (Na₂SO₃, the dominant oxidation product of NaDT) at low pH. The low pH requirement indicates that sulfur dioxide (SO₂) is the species involved. Spectroscopy supports binding at or near [4Fe-4S]_H, causing its redox potential to increase by ∼60 mV. This potential shift detunes the redox potentials of the subclusters of the H-cluster, lowering activity, as shown in protein film electrochemistry (PFE). Together, these results indicate that H_oxH and its one-electron reduced counterpart H_red'H are artifacts of using a nonphysiological reductant, and not crucial catalytic intermediates. We propose renaming these states as the "dithionite (DT) inhibited" states H_ox-DT_i and H_red-DT_i. The broader potential implications of using a nonphysiological reductant in spectroscopic and mechanistic studies of enzymes are highlighted.

Electrochemical control of [FeFe]-hydrogenase single crystals reveals complex redox populations at the catalytic site

Elucidating the distribution of intermediates at the active site of redox metalloenzymes is vital to understanding their highly efficient catalysis. Here we demonstrate that it is possible to generate, and detect, the key catalytic redox states of an [FeFe]-hydrogenase in a protein crystal. Individual crystals of the prototypical [FeFe]-hydrogenase I from Clostridium pasteurianum (CpI) are maintained under electrochemical control, allowing for precise tuning of the redox potential, while the crystal is simultaneously probed via Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) microspectroscopy. The high signal/noise spectra reveal potential-dependent variation in the distribution of redox states at the active site (H-cluster) according to state-specific vibrational bands from the endogeneous CO and CN- ligands. CpI crystals are shown to populate the same H-cluster states as those detected in solution, including the oxidised species Hox, the reduced species Hred/HredH+, the super-reduced HsredH+ and the hydride species Hhyd. The high sensitivity and precise redox control offered by this approach also facilitates the detection and characterisation of low abundance species that only accumulate within a narrow window of conditions, revealing new redox intermediates.

Vibrational Perturbation of the [FeFe] Hydrogenase H-Cluster Revealed by 13C2H-ADT Labeling

[FeFe] hydrogenases are highly active catalysts for the interconversion of molecular hydrogen with protons and electrons. Here, we use a combination of isotopic labeling, ⁵⁷Fe nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy (NRVS), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations to observe and characterize the vibrational modes involving motion of the 2-azapropane-1,3-dithiolate (ADT) ligand bridging the two iron sites in the [2Fe]_H subcluster. A -¹³C²H₂- ADT labeling in the synthetic diiron precursor of [2Fe]_H produced isotope effects observed throughout the NRVS spectrum. The two precursor isotopologues were then used to reconstitute the H-cluster of [FeFe] hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1), and NRVS was measured on samples poised in the catalytically crucial H_hyd state containing a terminal hydride at the distal Fe site. The ¹³C²H isotope effects were observed also in the H_hyd spectrum. DFT simulations of the spectra allowed identification of the ⁵⁷Fe normal modes coupled to the ADT ligand motions. Particularly, a variety of normal modes involve shortening of the distance between the distal Fe-H hydride and ADT N-H bridgehead hydrogen, which may be relevant to the formation of a transition state on the way to H₂ formation.

Site-selective protonation of the one-electron reduced cofactor in [FeFe]-hydrogenase

Hydrogenases are bidirectional redox enzymes that catalyze hydrogen turnover in archaea, bacteria, and algae. While all types of hydrogenase show H2 oxidation activity, [FeFe]-hydrogenases are excellent H2 evolution catalysts as well. Their active site cofactor comprises a [4Fe-4S] cluster covalently linked to a diiron site equipped with carbon monoxide and cyanide ligands. The active site niche is connected with the solvent by two distinct proton transfer pathways. To analyze the catalytic mechanism of [FeFe]-hydrogenase, we employ operando infrared spectroscopy and infrared spectro-electrochemistry. Titrating the pH under H2 oxidation or H2 evolution conditions reveals the influence of site-selective protonation on the equilibrium of reduced cofactor states. Governed by pKa differences across the active site niche and proton transfer pathways, we find that individual electrons are stabilized either at the [4Fe-4S] cluster (alkaline pH values) or at the diiron site (acidic pH values). This observation is discussed in the context of the complex interdependence of hydrogen turnover and bulk pH.

A Beginner’s Guide to Thermodynamic Modelling of [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases, which are considered the most active naturally occurring catalysts for hydrogen oxidation and proton reduction, are extensively studied as models to learn the important features for efficient H2 conversion catalysis. Using infrared spectroscopy as a selective probe, the redox behaviour of the active site H-cluster is routinely modelled with thermodynamic schemes based on the Nernst equation for determining thermodynamic parameters, such as redox midpoint potentials and pKa values. Here, the thermodynamic models usually applied to [FeFe] hydrogenases are introduced and discussed in a pedagogic fashion and their applicability to additional metalloenzymes and molecular catalysts is also addressed.

Proton Transfer Mechanisms in Bimetallic Hydrogenases

Hydrogenases are metalloenzymes that catalyze proton reduction and H₂ oxidation with outstanding efficiency. They are model systems for bioinorganic chemistry, including low-valent transition metals, hydride chemistry, and proton-coupled electron transfer. In this Account, we describe how photochemistry and infrared difference spectroscopy can be used to identify the dynamic hydrogen-bonding changes that facilitate proton transfer in [NiFe]- and [FeFe]-hydrogenase.[NiFe]-hydrogenase binds a heterobimetallic nickel/iron site embedded in the protein by four cysteine ligands. [FeFe]-hydrogenase carries a homobimetallic iron/iron site attached to the protein by only a single cysteine. Carbon monoxide and cyanide ligands in the active site facilitate detailed investigations of hydrogenase catalysis by infrared spectroscopy because of their strong signals and redox-dependent frequency shifts. We found that specific redox-state transitions in [NiFe]- and [FeFe]-hydrogenase can be triggered by visible light to record extremely sensitive "light-minus-dark" infrared difference spectra monitoring key amino acid residues. As these transitions are coupled to protonation changes, our data allowed investigation of dynamic hydrogen-bonding changes that go well beyond the resolution of protein crystallography.In [NiFe]-hydrogenase, photolysis of the bridging hydride ligand in the Ni-C state was followed by infrared difference spectroscopy. Our data clearly indicate the formation of a protonated cysteine residue as well as hydrogen-bonding changes involving a glutamic acid residue and a "dangling water" molecule. These findings are in excellent agreement with crystallographic analyses of [NiFe]-hydrogenase. In [FeFe]-hydrogenase, an external redox dye was used to accumulate the Hred state. Infrared difference spectra indicate hydrogen-bonding changes involving two glutamic acid residues and a conserved arginine residue. While crystallographic analyses of [FeFe]-hydrogenase in the oxidized state failed to explain the rapid proton transfer because of a breach in the succession of residues, our findings facilitated a precise molecular model of discontinued proton transfer.Comparing both systems, our data emphasize the role of the outer coordination sphere in bimetallic hydrogenases: we suggest that protonation of a nickel-ligating cysteine in [NiFe]-hydrogenase causes the notable preference toward H₂ oxidation. On the contrary, proton transfer in [FeFe]-hydrogenase involves an adjacent cysteine as a relay group, promoting both H₂ oxidation and proton reduction. These observations may guide the design of organometallic compounds that mimic the catalytic properties of hydrogenases.

Phosphine-substituted diiron complexes Fe2(μ-Rodt)(CO)6−n(PPh3)n (R = Ph, Me, H and n = 1, 2) featuring desymmetrized oxadithiolate bridges: structures, protonation, and electrocatalysis

The influence of desymmetrized dithiolates (Rodt) and phosphine coordination modes (PPh3) on the structural, protophilic, and electrocatalytic features of diiron complexes 4–6 and 7–9 is described.

[FeFe]-Hydrogenases: maturation and reactivity of enzymatic systems and overview of biomimetic models

[FeFe]-hydrogenases recieved increasing interest in the last decades. This review summarises important findings regarding their enzymatic reactivity as well as inorganic models applied as electro- and photochemical catalysts.

A quantum chemical approach for the mechanisms of redox-active metalloenzymes

During the past 20 years, quantum chemistry has grown to be a significant part in the investigation of mechanisms for redox-active enzymes. In our group we have developed an approach that has been applied to a large number of such systems. Hybrid density functional theory (hybrid DFT) has from the start of these investigations been the leading electronic structure tool. An understanding of how the method works in practice has significantly improved the accuracy and applicability. During the past ten years, it has been found that the results for redox enzymes mainly depend on the chosen fraction of exact exchange in the functional, and that a choice of 15% has worked best. The idea has therefore been to vary that fraction over a reasonable range and study the relative energy dependence. For modeling the enzymes, a cluster approach has been developed. In the present review the development of the method we used is described from its start in work on photosystem II, fifteen years ago. Examples from a few recent applications are described, where the metals have been iron, nickel, copper, cobalt or manganese. The results are in excellent agreement with available experiments, and a large number of new predictions have been made.

During the past 20 years, quantum chemistry has grown to be a significant part in the investigation of mechanisms for redox-active enzymes.

Biochemical and artificial pathways for the reduction of carbon dioxide, nitrite and the competing proton reduction: effect of 2nd sphere interactions in catalysis

Reduction of oxides and oxoanions of carbon and nitrogen are of great contemporary importance as they are crucial for a sustainable environment.

Energetics for Proton Reduction in FeFe Hydrogenase

The energetics for proton reduction in FeFe-hydrogenase has been reinvestigated by theoretical modeling, in light of recent experiments. Two different mechanisms have been considered. In the first one, the bridging hydride position was blocked by the enzyme, which is the mechanism that has been supported by a recent spectroscopic study by Cramer et al. A major difficulty in the present study to agree with experimental energetics was to find the right position for the added proton in the first reduction step. It was eventually found that the best position was as a terminal hydride on the distal iron, which has not been suggested in any of the recent, experimentally based mechanisms. The lowest transition state was surprisingly found to be a bond formation between a proton on a cysteine and the terminal hydride. This type of TS is similar to the one for heterolytic H₂ cleavage in NiFe hydrogenase. The second mechanism investigated here is not supported by the present calculations or the recent experiments by Cramer et al., but was still studied as an interesting comparison. In that mechanism, the formation of the bridging hydride was allowed. The H–H formation barrier is only 3.6 kcal/mol higher than for the first mechanism, but there are severe problems concerning the motion of the protons.

Temperature Dependence of Structural Dynamics at the Catalytic Cofactor of [FeFe]-hydrogenase

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are nature's blueprint for efficient hydrogen turnover. Understanding their enzymatic mechanism may improve technological H₂ fuel generation. The active-site cofactor (H-cluster) consists of a [4Fe-4S] cluster ([4Fe]_H), cysteine-linked to a diiron site ([2Fe]_H) carrying an azadithiolate (adt) group, terminal cyanide and carbon monoxide ligands, and a bridging carbon monoxide (μCO) in the oxidized protein (Hox). Recently, the debate on the structure of reduced H-cluster states was intensified by the assignment of new species under cryogenic conditions. We investigated temperature effects (4-280 K) in infrared (IR) and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) data of [FeFe]-hydrogenases using fit analyses and quantum-chemical calculations. IR data from our laboratory and literature sources were evaluated. At ambient temperatures, reduced H-cluster states with a bridging hydride (μH^-, in Hred and Hsred) or with an additional proton at [4Fe]_H (Hred') or at the distal iron of [2Fe]_H (Hhyd) prevail. At cryogenic temperatures, these species are largely replaced by states that hold a μCO, lack [4Fe]_H protonation, and bind an additional proton at the adt nitrogen (HredH⁺ and HsredH⁺). XAS revealed the atomic coordinate dispersion (i.e., the Debye-Waller parameter, 2σ²) of the iron-ligand bonds and Fe-Fe distances in the oxidized and reduced H-cluster. 2σ² showed a temperature dependence typical for the so-called protein-glass transition, with small changes below ∼200 K and a pronounced increase above this "breakpoint". This behavior is attributed to the freezing-out of larger-scale anharmonic motions of amino acid side chains and water species. We propose that protonation at [4Fe]_H as well as ligand rearrangement and μH^- binding at [2Fe]_H are impaired because of restricted molecular mobility at cryogenic temperatures so that protonation can be biased toward adt. We conclude that a H-cluster with a μCO, selective [4Fe]_H or [2Fe]_H protonation, and catalytic proton transfer via adt facilitates efficient H₂ conversion in [FeFe]-hydrogenase.

The Laser-Induced Potential Jump: A Method for Rapid Electron Injection into Oxidoreductase Enzymes

Oxidoreductase enzymes often perform technologically useful chemical transformations using abundant metal cofactors with high efficiency under ambient conditions. The understanding of the catalytic mechanism of these enzymes is, however, highly dependent on the availability of well-characterized and optimized time-resolved analytical techniques. We have developed an approach for rapidly injecting electrons into a catalytic system using a photoactivated nanomaterial in combination with a range of redox mediators to produce a potential jump in solution, which then initiates turnover via electron transfer (ET) to the catalyst. The ET events at the nanomaterial-mediator-catalyst interfaces are, however, highly sensitive to the experimental conditions such as photon flux, relative concentrations of system components, and pH. Here, we present a systematic optimization of these experimental parameters for a specific catalytic system, namely, [FeFe] hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1). The developed strategies can, however, be applied in the study of a wide variety of oxidoreductase enzymes. Our potential jump system consists of CdSe/CdS core-shell nanorods as a photosensitizer and a series of substituted bipyridinium salts as mediators with redox potentials in the range from -550 to -670 mV (vs SHE). With these components, we screened the effect of pH, mediator concentration, protein concentration, photosensitizer concentration, and photon flux on steady-state photoreduction and hydrogen production as well as ET and potential jump efficiency. By manipulating these experimental conditions, we show the potential of simple modifications to improve the tunability of the potential jump for application to study oxidoreductases.

Characterization of a putative sensory [FeFe]-hydrogenase provides new insight into the role of the active site architecture

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are known for their high rates of hydrogen turnover, and are intensively studied in the context of biotechnological applications. Evolution has generated a plethora of different subclasses with widely different characteristics. The M2e subclass is phylogenetically distinct from previously characterized members of this enzyme family and its biological role is unknown. It features significant differences in domain- and active site architecture, and is most closely related to the putative sensory [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Here we report the first comprehensive biochemical and spectroscopical characterization of an M2e enzyme, derived from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii. As compared to other [FeFe]-hydrogenases characterized to-date, this enzyme displays an increased H2 affinity, higher activation enthalpies for H+/H2 interconversion, and unusual reactivity towards known hydrogenase inhibitors. These properties are related to differences in active site architecture between the M2e [FeFe]-hydrogenase and "prototypical" [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Thus, this study provides new insight into the role of this subclass in hydrogen metabolism and the influence of the active site pocket on the chemistry of the H-cluster.

The roles of long-range proton-coupled electron transfer in the directionality and efficiency of [FeFe]-hydrogenases

As paradigms for proton-coupled electron transfer in enzymes and benchmarks for a fully renewable H₂ technology, [FeFe]-hydrogenases behave as highly reversible electrocatalysts when immobilized on an electrode, operating in both catalytic directions with minimal overpotential requirement. Using the [FeFe]-hydrogenases from Clostridium pasteurianum (CpI) and Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1) we have conducted site-directed mutagenesis and protein film electrochemistry to determine how efficient catalysis depends on the long-range coupling of electron and proton transfer steps. Importantly, the electron and proton transfer pathways in [FeFe]-hydrogenases are well separated from each other in space. Variants with conservative substitutions (glutamate to aspartate) in either of two positions in the proton-transfer pathway retain significant activity and reveal the consequences of slowing down proton transfer for both catalytic directions over a wide range of pH and potential values. Proton reduction in the variants is impaired mainly by limiting the turnover rate, which drops sharply as the pH is raised, showing that proton capture from bulk solvent becomes critical. In contrast, hydrogen oxidation is affected in two ways: by limiting the turnover rate and by a large overpotential requirement that increases as the pH is raised, consistent with the accumulation of a reduced and protonated intermediate. A unique observation having fundamental significance is made under conditions where the variants still retain sufficient catalytic activity in both directions: An inflection appears as the catalytic current switches direction at the 2H⁺/H₂ thermodynamic potential, clearly signaling a departure from electrocatalytic reversibility as electron and proton transfers begin to be decoupled.

Spectroscopic investigations under whole-cell conditions provide new insight into the metal hydride chemistry of [FeFe]-hydrogenase

Hydrogenases are among the fastest H₂ evolving catalysts known to date and have been extensively studied under in vitro conditions. Here, we report the first mechanistic investigation of an [FeFe]-hydrogenase under whole-cell conditions. Functional [FeFe]-hydrogenase from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is generated in genetically modified Escherichia coli cells by addition of a synthetic cofactor to the growth medium. The assembly and reactivity of the resulting semi-synthetic enzyme was monitored using whole-cell electron paramagnetic resonance and Fourier-transform Infrared difference spectroscopy as well as scattering scanning near-field optical microscopy. Through a combination of gas treatments, pH titrations, and isotope editing we were able to corroborate the formation of a number of proposed catalytic intermediates in living cells, supporting their physiological relevance. Moreover, a previously incompletely characterized catalytic intermediate is reported herein, attributed to the formation of a protonated metal hydride species.

Spectroscopic and Computational Evidence that [FeFe] Hydrogenases Operate Exclusively with CO-Bridged Intermediates

[FeFe] hydrogenases are extremely active H₂-converting enzymes. Their mechanism remains highly controversial, in particular, the nature of the one-electron and two-electron reduced intermediates called H_redH⁺ and H_sredH⁺. In one model, the H_redH⁺ and H_sredH⁺ states contain a semibridging CO, while in the other model, the bridging CO is replaced by a bridging hydride. Using low-temperature IR spectroscopy and nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy, together with density functional theory calculations, we show that the bridging CO is retained in the H_sredH⁺ and H_redH⁺ states in the [FeFe] hydrogenases from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and Desulfovibrio desulfuricans, respectively. Furthermore, there is no evidence for a bridging hydride in either state. These results agree with a model of the catalytic cycle in which the H_redH⁺ and H_sredH⁺ states are integral, catalytically competent components. We conclude that proton-coupled electron transfer between the two subclusters is crucial to catalysis and allows these enzymes to operate in a highly efficient and reversible manner.

Spectroscopic and biochemical insight into an electron-bifurcating [FeFe] hydrogenase

Abstract

The heterotrimeric electron-bifurcating [FeFe] hydrogenase (HydABC) from Thermotoga maritima (Tm) couples the endergonic reduction of protons (H⁺) by dihydronicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) (∆G⁰ ≈ 18 kJ mol⁻¹) to the exergonic reduction of H⁺ by reduced ferredoxin (Fd_red) (∆G⁰ ≈ − 16 kJ mol⁻¹). The specific mechanism by which HydABC functions is not understood. In the current study, we describe the biochemical and spectroscopic characterization of TmHydABC recombinantly produced in Escherichia coli and artificially maturated with a synthetic diiron cofactor. We found that TmHydABC catalyzed the hydrogen (H₂)-dependent reduction of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD⁺) in the presence of oxidized ferredoxin (Fd_ox) at a rate of  ≈17 μmol NADH min⁻¹ mg⁻¹. Our data suggest that only one flavin is present in the enzyme and is not likely to be the site of electron bifurcation. FTIR and EPR spectroscopy, as well as FTIR spectroelectrochemistry, demonstrated that the active site for H₂ conversion, the H-cluster, in TmHydABC behaves essentially the same as in prototypical [FeFe] hydrogenases, and is most likely also not the site of electron bifurcation. The implications of these results are discussed with respect to the current hypotheses on the electron bifurcation mechanism of [FeFe] hydrogenases. Overall, the results provide insight into the electron-bifurcating mechanism and present a well-defined system for further investigations of this fascinating class of [FeFe] hydrogenases.

Graphic abstract

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s00775-019-01747-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Tuning Catalytic Bias of Hydrogen Gas Producing Hydrogenases

Hydrogenases display a wide range of catalytic rates and biases in reversible hydrogen gas oxidation catalysis. The interactions of the iron-sulfur-containing catalytic site with the local protein environment are thought to contribute to differences in catalytic reactivity, but this has not been demonstrated. The microbe Clostridium pasteurianum produces three [FeFe]-hydrogenases that differ in "catalytic bias" by exerting a disproportionate rate acceleration in one direction or the other that spans a remarkable 6 orders of magnitude. The combination of high-resolution structural work, biochemical analyses, and computational modeling indicates that protein secondary interactions directly influence the relative stabilization/destabilization of different oxidation states of the active site metal cluster. This selective stabilization or destabilization of oxidation states can preferentially promote hydrogen oxidation or proton reduction and represents a simple yet elegant model by which a protein catalytic site can confer catalytic bias.

How [FeFe]-Hydrogenase Facilitates Bidirectional Proton Transfer

Hydrogenases are metalloenzymes that catalyze the conversion of protons and molecular hydrogen, H₂. [FeFe]-hydrogenases show particularly high rates of hydrogen turnover and have inspired numerous compounds for biomimetic H₂ production. Two decades of research on the active site cofactor of [FeFe]-hydrogenases have put forward multiple models of the catalytic proceedings. In comparison, our understanding of proton transfer is poor. Previously, residues were identified forming a hydrogen-bonding network between active site cofactor and bulk solvent; however, the exact mechanism of catalytic proton transfer remained inconclusive. Here, we employ in situ infrared difference spectroscopy on the [FeFe]-hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii evaluating dynamic changes in the hydrogen-bonding network upon photoreduction. While proton transfer appears to be impaired in the oxidized state (Hox), the presented data support continuous proton transfer in the reduced state (Hred). Our analysis allows for a direct, molecular unique assignment to individual amino acid residues. We found that transient protonation changes of glutamic acid residue E141 and, most notably, arginine R148 facilitate bidirectional proton transfer in [FeFe]-hydrogenases.

Differential Protonation at the Catalytic Six-Iron Cofactor of [FeFe]-Hydrogenases Revealed by 57Fe Nuclear Resonance X-ray Scattering and Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics Analyses

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are efficient biological hydrogen conversion catalysts and blueprints for technological fuel production. The relations between substrate interactions and electron/proton transfer events at their unique six-iron cofactor (H-cluster) need to be elucidated. The H-cluster comprises a four-iron cluster, [4Fe4S], linked to a diiron complex, [FeFe]. We combined ⁵⁷Fe-specific X-ray nuclear resonance scattering experiments (NFS, nuclear forward scattering; NRVS, nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy) with quantum-mechanics/molecular-mechanics computations to study the [FeFe]-hydrogenase HYDA1 from a green alga. Selective ⁵⁷Fe labeling at only [4Fe4S] or [FeFe], or at both subcomplexes was achieved by protein expression with a ⁵⁷Fe salt and in vitro maturation with a synthetic diiron site precursor containing ⁵⁷Fe. H-cluster states were populated under infrared spectroscopy control. NRVS spectral analyses facilitated assignment of the vibrational modes of the cofactor species. This approach revealed the H-cluster structure of the oxidized state (Hox) with a bridging carbon monoxide at [FeFe] and ligand rearrangement in the CO-inhibited state (Hox-CO). Protonation at a cysteine ligand of [4Fe4S] in the oxidized state occurring at low pH (HoxH) was indicated, in contrast to bridging hydride binding at [FeFe] in a one-electron reduced state (Hred). These findings are direct evidence for differential protonation either at the four-iron or diiron subcomplex of the H-cluster. NFS time-traces provided Mössbauer parameters such as the quadrupole splitting energy, which differ among cofactor states, thereby supporting selective protonation at either subcomplex. In combination with data for reduced states showing similar [4Fe4S] protonation as HoxH without (Hred') or with (Hhyd) a terminal hydride at [FeFe], our results imply that coordination geometry dynamics at the diiron site and proton-coupled electron transfer to either the four-iron or the diiron subcomplex discriminate catalytic and regulatory functions of [FeFe]-hydrogenases. We support a reaction cycle avoiding diiron site geometry changes during rapid H₂ turnover.

The Molecular Proceedings of Biological Hydrogen Turnover

Over the past two decades, the bioinorganic chemistry of hydrogenases has attracted much interest from basic and applied research. Hydrogenases are highly efficient metalloenzymes that catalyze the reversible reduction of protons to molecular hydrogen (H₂) in all domains of life. Their iron- and nickel-based cofactors represent promising blueprints for the design of biomimetic, synthetic catalysts. In this Account, we address the molecular proceedings of hydrogen turnover with [FeFe]-hydrogenases. The active site cofactor of [FeFe]-hydrogenases ("H-cluster") comprises a unique diiron complex linked to a [4Fe-4S] cluster via a single cysteine. Since it was discovered that a synthetic analogue of the diiron site can be incorporated into apoprotein in vitro to yield active enzyme, significant progress has been made toward a comprehensive understanding of hydrogenase catalysis. The diiron site carries three to four carbon monoxide (CO) and two cyanide (CN^-) ligands that give rise to intense infrared (IR) absorption bands. These bands are sensitive reporters of the electron density across the H-cluster, which can be addressed by infrared spectroscopy to follow redox and protonation changes at the cofactor. Synthetic variation of the metal-bridging dithiolate ligand at the diiron site, as well as site-directed mutagenesis of amino acids, provides access to the proton pathways toward the cofactor. Quantum chemical calculations are employed to specifically assign IR bands to vibrational modes of the diatomic ligands and yield refined H-cluster geometries. Here, we provide an overview of recent research on [FeFe]-hydrogenases with emphasis on experimental and computational IR studies. We describe advances in attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR FTIR) and protein film electrochemistry, as well as density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Key cofactor species are discussed in terms of molecular geometry, redox state, and protonation. Isotope editing is introduced as a tool to evaluate the cofactor geometry beyond the limits of protein crystallography. In particular, the role of proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) in the generation of catalytically relevant redox species is addressed. We propose that site-selective protonation of the H-cluster biases surplus electrons either to the [4Fe-4S] cluster or to the diiron site. Protonation of the [4Fe-4S] cluster prevents premature reduction at the diiron site and stabilizes a reactive, terminal hydride. The observed H-cluster species are assigned to rapid H₂ conversion or to reactions possibly involved in activity regulation and cellular H₂ sensing. In the catalytic cycle of [FeFe]-hydrogenases, an H-cluster geometry is preserved that features a bridging CO ligand. PCET levels the redox potential for two steps of sequential cofactor reduction. The concept of consecutive PCET at a geometrically inert cofactor with tight control of electron and proton localization may inspire the design of a novel generation of biomimetic catalysts for the production of H₂ as a fuel.