Enzyme Architecture: Breaking Down the Catalytic Cage that Activates Orotidine 5'-Monophosphate Decarboxylase for Catalysis

Utilization of Cofactor Binding Energy for Enzyme Catalysis: Formate Dehydrogenase-Catalyzed Reactions of the Whole NAD Cofactor and Cofactor Pieces

The pressure to optimize enzymatic rate accelerations has driven the evolution of the induced-fit mechanism for enzyme catalysts where the binding interactions of nonreacting phosphodianion or adenosyl substrate pieces drive enzyme conformational changes to form protein substrate cages that are activated for catalysis. We report the results of experiments to test the hypothesis that utilization of the binding energy of the adenosine 5'-diphosphate ribose (ADP-ribose) fragment of the NAD cofactor to drive a protein conformational change activates Candida boidinii formate dehydrogenase (CbFDH) for catalysis of hydride transfer from formate to NAD+. The ADP-ribose fragment provides a >14 kcal/mol stabilization of the transition state for CbFDH-catalyzed hydride transfer from formate to NAD+. This is larger than the ca. 6 kcal/mol stabilization of the ground-state Michaelis complex between CbFDH and NAD+ (KNAD = 0.032 mM). The ADP, AMP, and ribose 5'-phosphate fragments of NAD+ activate CbFDH for catalysis of hydride transfer from formate to nicotinamide riboside (NR). At a 1.0 M standard state, these activators stabilize the hydride transfer transition states by ≈5.5 (ADP), 5.5 (AMP), and 4.4 (ribose 5'-phosphate) kcal/mol. We propose that activation by these cofactor fragments is partly or entirely due to the ion-pair interaction between the guanidino side chain cation of R174 and the activator phosphate anion. This substitutes for the interaction between the α-adenosyl pyrophosphate anion of the whole NAD+ cofactor that holds CbFDH in the catalytically active closed conformation.

Kinetics and mechanism for enzyme-catalyzed reactions of substrate pieces

The most important difference between enzyme and small molecule catalysts is that only enzymes utilize the large intrinsic binding energies of nonreacting portions of the substrate in stabilization of the transition state for the catalyzed reaction. A general protocol is described to determine the intrinsic phosphodianion binding energy for enzymatic catalysis of reactions of phosphate monoester substrates, and the intrinsic phosphite dianion binding energy in activation of enzymes for catalysis of phosphodianion truncated substrates, from the kinetic parameters for enzyme-catalyzed reactions of whole and truncated substrates. The enzyme-catalyzed reactions so-far documented that utilize dianion binding interactions for enzyme activation; and, their phosphodianion truncated substrates are summarized. A model for the utilization of dianion binding interactions for enzyme activation is described. The methods for the determination of the kinetic parameters for enzyme-catalyzed reactions of whole and truncated substrates, from initial velocity data, are described and illustrated by graphical plots of kinetic data. The results of studies on the effect of site-directed amino acid substitutions at orotidine 5'-monophosphate decarboxylase, triosephosphate isomerase, and glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase provide strong support for the proposal that these enzymes utilize binding interactions with the substrate phosphodianion to hold the protein catalysts in reactive closed conformations.

Enabling Role of Ligand-Driven Conformational Changes in Enzyme Evolution

Many enzymes that show a large specificity in binding the enzymatic transition state with a higher affinity than the substrate utilize substrate binding energy to drive protein conformational changes to form caged substrate complexes. These protein cages provide strong stabilization of enzymatic transition states. Using part of the substrate binding energy to drive the protein conformational change avoids a similar strong stabilization of the Michaelis complex and irreversible ligand binding. A seminal step in the development of modern enzyme catalysts was the evolution of enzymes that couple substrate binding to a conformational change. These include enzymes that function in glycolysis (triosephosphate isomerase), the biosynthesis of lipids (glycerol phosphate dehydrogenase), the hexose monophosphate shunt (6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase), and the mevalonate pathway (isopentenyl diphosphate isomerase), catalyze the final step in the biosynthesis of pyrimidine nucleotides (orotidine monophosphate decarboxylase), and regulate the cellular levels of adenine nucleotides (adenylate kinase). The evolution of enzymes that undergo ligand-driven conformational changes to form active protein-substrate cages is proposed to proceed by selection of variants, in which the selected side chain substitutions destabilize a second protein conformer that shows compensating enhanced binding interactions with the substrate. The advantages inherent to enzymes that incorporate a conformational change into the catalytic cycle provide a strong driving force for the evolution of flexible protein folds such as the TIM barrel. The appearance of these folds represented a watershed event in enzyme evolution that enabled the rapid propagation of enzyme activities within enzyme superfamilies.

Essential Functional Interplay of the Catalytic Groups in Acid Phosphatase

The cooperative interplay between the functional devices of a preorganized active site is fundamental to enzyme catalysis. An in-depth understanding of this phenomenon is central to elucidating the remarkable efficiency of natural enzymes and provides an essential benchmark for enzyme design and engineering. Here, we study the functional interconnectedness of the catalytic nucleophile (His18) in an acid phosphatase by analyzing the consequences of its replacement with aspartate. We present crystallographic, biochemical, and computational evidence for a conserved mechanistic pathway via a phospho-enzyme intermediate on Asp18. Linear free-energy relationships for phosphoryl transfer from phosphomonoester substrates to His18/Asp18 provide evidence for the cooperative interplay between the nucleophilic and general-acid catalytic groups in the wild-type enzyme, and its substantial loss in the H18D variant. As an isolated factor of phosphatase efficiency, the advantage of a histidine compared to an aspartate nucleophile is ∼10⁴-fold. Cooperativity with the catalytic acid adds ≥10²-fold to that advantage. Empirical valence bond simulations of phosphoryl transfer from glucose 1-phosphate to His and Asp in the enzyme explain the loss of activity of the Asp18 enzyme through a combination of impaired substrate positioning in the Michaelis complex, as well as a shift from early to late protonation of the leaving group in the H18D variant. The evidence presented furthermore suggests that the cooperative nature of catalysis distinguishes the enzymatic reaction from the corresponding reaction in solution and is enabled by the electrostatic preorganization of the active site. Our results reveal sophisticated discrimination in multifunctional catalysis of a highly proficient phosphatase active site.

Protein-Ribofuranosyl Interactions Activate Orotidine 5'-Monophosphate Decarboxylase for Catalysis

The role of a global, substrate-driven, enzyme conformational change in enabling the extraordinarily large rate acceleration for orotidine 5'-monophosphate decarboxylase (OMPDC)-catalyzed decarboxylation of orotidine 5'-monophosphate (OMP) is examined in experiments that focus on the interactions between OMPDC and the ribosyl hydroxyl groups of OMP. The D37 and T100' side chains of OMPDC interact, respectively, with the C-3' and C-2' hydroxyl groups of enzyme-bound OMP. D37G and T100'A substitutions result in 1.4 kcal/mol increases in the activation barrier ΔG^⧧ for catalysis of decarboxylation of the phosphodianion-truncated substrate 1-(β-d-erythrofuranosyl)orotic acid (EO) but result in larger 2.1-2.9 kcal/mol increases in ΔG^⧧ for decarboxylation of OMP and for phosphite dianion-activated decarboxylation of EO. This shows that these substitutions reduce transition-state stabilization by the Q215, Y217, and R235 side chains at the dianion binding site. The D37G and T100'A substitutions result in <1.0 kcal/mol increases in ΔG^⧧ for activation of OMPDC-catalyzed decarboxylation of the phosphoribofuranosyl-truncated substrate FO by phosphite dianions. Experiments to probe the effect of D37 and T100' substitutions on the kinetic parameters for d-glycerol 3-phosphate and d-erythritol 4-phosphate activators of OMPDC-catalyzed decarboxylation of FO show that ΔG^⧧ for sugar phosphate-activated reactions is increased by ca. 2.5 kcal/mol for each -OH interaction eliminated by D37G or T100'A substitutions. We conclude that the interactions between the D37 and T100' side chains and ribosyl or ribosyl-like hydroxyl groups are utilized to activate OMPDC for catalysis of decarboxylation of OMP, EO, and FO.

Mechanisms of ligand binding

Many processes in chemistry and biology involve interactions of a ligand with its molecular target. Interest in the mechanism governing such interactions has dominated theoretical and experimental analysis for over a century. The interpretation of molecular recognition has evolved from a simple rigid body association of the ligand with its target to appreciation of the key role played by conformational transitions. Two conceptually distinct descriptions have had a profound impact on our understanding of mechanisms of ligand binding. The first description, referred to as induced fit, assumes that conformational changes follow the initial binding step to optimize the complex between the ligand and its target. The second description, referred to as conformational selection, assumes that the free target exists in multiple conformations in equilibrium and that the ligand selects the optimal one for binding. Both descriptions can be merged into more complex reaction schemes that better describe the functional repertoire of macromolecular systems. This review deals with basic mechanisms of ligand binding, with special emphasis on induced fit, conformational selection, and their mathematical foundations to provide rigorous context for the analysis and interpretation of experimental data. We show that conformational selection is a surprisingly versatile mechanism that includes induced fit as a mathematical special case and even captures kinetic properties of more complex reaction schemes. These features make conformational selection a dominant mechanism of molecular recognition in biology, consistent with the rich conformational landscape accessible to biological macromolecules being unraveled by structural biology.

Orotidine 5'-Monophosphate Decarboxylase: The Operation of Active Site Chains Within and Across Protein Subunits

The D37 and T100′ side chains of orotidine 5′-monophosphate decarboxylase (OMPDC) interact with the C-3′ and C-2′ ribosyl hydroxyl groups, respectively, of the bound substrate. We compare the intra-subunit interactions of D37 with the inter-subunit interactions of T100′ by determining the effects of the D37G, D37A, T100′G, and T100′A substitutions on the following: (a) k_cat and k_cat/K_m values for the OMPDC-catalyzed decarboxylations of OMP and 5-fluoroorotidine 5′-monophosphate (FOMP) and (b) the stability of dimeric OMPDC relative to the monomer. The D37G and T100′A substitutions resulted in 2 kcal mol^–1 increases in ΔG^† for k_cat/K_m for the decarboxylation of OMP, while the D37A and T100′G substitutions resulted in larger 4 and 5 kcal mol^–1 increases, respectively, in ΔG^†. The D37G and T100′A substitutions both resulted in smaller 2 kcal mol^–1 decreases in ΔG^† for the decarboxylation of FOMP compared to that of OMP. These results show that the D37G and T100′A substitutions affect the barrier to the chemical decarboxylation step while the D37A and T100′G substitutions also affect the barrier to a slow, ligand-driven enzyme conformational change. Substrate binding induces the movement of an α-helix (G′98–S′106) toward the substrate C-2′ ribosyl hydroxy bound at the main subunit. The T100′G substitution destabilizes the enzyme dimer by 3.5 kcal mol^–1 compared to the monomer, which is consistent with the known destabilization of α-helices by the internal Gly side chains [Serrano, L., et al. (1992) Nature, 356, 453–455]. We propose that the T100′G substitution weakens the α-helical contacts at the dimer interface, which results in a decrease in the dimer stability and an increase in the barrier to the ligand-driven conformational change.

Role of the Carboxylate in Enzyme-Catalyzed Decarboxylation of Orotidine 5'-Monophosphate: Transition State Stabilization Dominates Over Ground State Destabilization

Kinetic parameters k_ex (s^–1) and k_ex/K_d (M^–1 s^–1) are reported for exchange for deuterium in D₂O of the C-6 hydrogen of 5-fluororotidine 5′-monophosphate (FUMP) catalyzed by the Q215A, Y217F, and Q215A/Y217F variants of yeast orotidine 5′-monophosphate decarboxylase (ScOMPDC) at pD 8.1, and by the Q215A variant at pD 7.1–9.3. The pD rate profiles for wildtype ScOMPDC and the Q215A variant are identical, except for a 2.5 log unit downward displacement in the profile for the Q215A variant. The Q215A, Y217F and Q215A/Y217F substitutions cause 1.3–2.0 kcal/mol larger increases in the activation barrier for wildtype ScOMPDC-catalyzed deuterium exchange compared with decarboxylation, because of the stronger apparent side chain interaction with the transition state for the deuterium exchange reaction. The stabilization of the transition state for the OMPDC-catalyzed deuterium exchange reaction of FUMP is ca. 19 kcal/mol smaller than the transition state for decarboxylation of OMP, and ca. 8 kcal/mol smaller than for OMPDC-catalyzed deprotonation of FUMP to form the vinyl carbanion intermediate common to OMPDC-catalyzed reactions OMP/FOMP and UMP/FUMP. We propose that ScOMPDC shows similar stabilizing interactions with the common portions of decarboxylation and deprotonation transition states that lead to formation of this vinyl carbanion intermediate, and that there is a large ca. (19–8) = 11 kcal/mol stabilization of the former transition state from interactions with the nascent CO₂ of product. The effects of Q215A and Y217F substitutions on k_cat/K_m for decarboxylation of OMP are expressed mainly as an increase in K_m for the reactions catalyzed by the variant enzymes, while the effects on k_ex/K_d for deuterium exchange are expressed mainly as an increase in k_ex. This shows that the Q215 and Y217 side chains stabilize the Michaelis complex to OMP for the decarboxylation reaction, compared with the complex to FUMP for the deuterium exchange reaction. These results provide strong support for the conclusion that interactions which stabilize the transition state for ScOMPDC-catalyzed decarboxylation at a nonpolar enzyme active site dominate over interactions that destabilize the ground-state Michaelis complex.

Double-mutant cycles: new directions and applications

Double-mutant cycle (DMC) analysis is a powerful approach for detecting and quantifying the energetics of both direct and long-range interactions in proteins and other chemical systems. It can also be used to unravel higher-order interactions (e.g. three-body effects) that lead to cooperativity in protein folding and function. In this review, we describe new applications of DMC analysis based on advances in native mass spectrometry and high-throughput methods such as next generation sequencing and protein complementation assays. These developments have facilitated carrying out high-throughput DMC analysis, which can be used to characterize increasingly higher-order interactions and very large interaction networks in proteins. Such studies have provided insights into the extent of cooperativity (epistasis) in protein structures. High-throughput DMC studies have also been used to validate correlated mutation analysis and can provide restraints for protein docking.

Protein Flexibility and Stiffness Enable Efficient Enzymatic Catalysis

The enormous rate accelerations observed for many enzyme catalysts are due to strong stabilizing interactions between the protein and reaction transition state. The defining property of these catalysts is their specificity for binding the transition state with a much higher affinity than substrate. Experimental results are presented which show that the phosphodianion-binding energy of phosphate monoester substrates is used to drive conversion of their protein catalysts from flexible and entropically rich ground states to stiff and catalytically active Michaelis complexes. These results are generalized to other enzyme-catalyzed reactions. The existence of many enzymes in flexible, entropically rich, and inactive ground states provides a mechanism for utilization of ligand-binding energy to mold these catalysts into stiff and active forms. This reduces the substrate-binding energy expressed at the Michaelis complex, while enabling the full and specific expression of large transition-state binding energies. Evidence is presented that the complexity of enzyme conformational changes increases with increases in the enzymatic rate acceleration. The requirement that a large fraction of the total substrate-binding energy be utilized to drive conformational changes of floppy enzymes is proposed to favor the selection and evolution of protein folds with multiple flexible unstructured loops, such as the TIM-barrel fold. The effect of protein motions on the kinetic parameters for enzymes that undergo ligand-driven conformational changes is considered. The results of computational studies to model the complex ligand-driven conformational change in catalysis by triosephosphate isomerase are presented.