Structures and aggregation states of fluoromethyllithium and chloromethyllithium carbenoids in the gas phase and in ethereal solvent

Taming Metal/Fluorine Carbenoids

Although Li/Cl carbenoids are versatile reagents in organic synthesis, the controlled handling of the extremely reactive and labile M/F carbenoids remains a challenge. We now show that even these compounds can be stabilized and isolated in solid state, as well as in solution. Particularly the sodium and potassium compounds exhibit a remarkable stability, thus allowing the first isolation of a room-temperature-stable fluorine carbenoid. Spectroscopic, as well as DFT studies confirmed the pronounced carbenoid character, showing M-F-C interactions with elongated C-F bonds. The different stabilities of the carbenoids was found to originate from the different strength of the M-F interaction. Hence, the lithium compounds are considerably more reactive than their heavier congeners. Reactivity studies showed that the nature of the metal also influences the reactivity, resulting in different selectivity in the addition to thioketones.

Stability and reactivity control of carbenoids: recent advances and perspectives

Metal carbenoids such as lithium or Simmons-Smith-type reagents are widely used in organic synthesis, particularly in cyclopropanation and homologation reactions. These reagents are often highly reactive and thermally labile, thus limiting their isolation and hampering the development of new synthetic applications. Recent years however, have shown that by means of systematic stabilization a control of reactivity and the development of new applications is possible. This feature article documents recent developments in the control of carbenoid reactivity and stability and highlights structural and electronic properties as well as applications in main group element and transition metal chemistry.

First substoichiometric version of the catalytic enantioselective addition of an alkyllithium to an aldehyde

A substoichiometric enantioselective version of the extremely fast nucleophilic addition of Alk-Li to RCHO is made possible thanks to a thorough analysis of the aggregation phenomena involved in the reaction: calculated quantities of LiCl must be added to the medium at the right time to keep the catalytic cycle running.

Mechanism of lithium diisopropylamide-mediated substitution of 2,6-difluoropyridine

Treatment of 2,6-difluoropyridine with lithium diisopropylamide in THF solution at -78 degrees C effects ortholithiation quantitatively. Warming the solution to 0 degrees C converts the aryllithium to 2-fluoro-6-(diisopropylamino)pyridine. Rate studies reveal evidence of a reversal of the ortholithiation and a subsequent 1,2-addition via two monomer-based pathways of stoichiometries [ArH*i-Pr(2)NLi(THF)](double dagger) and [ArH*i-Pr(2)NLi(THF)(3)](double dagger). Computational studies fill in the structural details and provide evidence of a direct substitution without the intermediacy of a Meisenheimer complex.

A computational study of lithium ketone enolate aggregation in the gas phase and in THF solution

The aggregation state of several lithium enolates were calculated in the gas phase and in THF solution by the B3LYP DFT and MP2 methods. The gas phase free energies of aggregate formation were underestimated by the DFT calculations, compared to those obtained by the G3MP2 method, although DFT did correctly predict the hexamer to be the major gas phase species. The DFT calculations correctly predicted the tetramer to be the major species in THF, while MP2 underestimated the stability of the tetramer relative to the dimer.

On the mechanism and stereochemistry of chiral lithium-carbenoid-promoted cyclopropanation reactions

An investigation into the mechanism and stereochemistry of chiral lithium-carbenoid-promoted cyclopropanation reactions by using density functional theory (DFT) methods is reported. Previous work suggested that this type of cyclopropanation reaction may proceed by competition between a methylene-transfer mechanism and a carbometalation mechanism. In this paper, it is demonstrated that the intramolecular cyclopropanation reactions promoted by chiral carbenoids 1 and 2 proceed by the methylene-transfer mechanism. The carbometalation mechanism was found to have a much higher reaction barrier and does not appear to compete with the methylene-transfer mechanism. The Lewis base group does not enhance the carbometalation pathway enough to compete with the methylene-transfer pathway. The present computational results are consistent with experimental observations for these cyclopropanation reactions. The factors governing the stereochemistry of the intramolecular cyclopropanation reaction by the methylene-transfer mechanism were examined to help elucidate the origin of the stereoselectivity observed in experiments. Both the directing group and the configuration at the C(1) centre were found to play a key role in the stereochemistry. Carbenoid 1 has a chiral C(1) centre of R configuration. The Lewis base group directs the cyclization of carbenoid 1 to form a single product. In contrast, the Lewis base group cannot direct the cyclization of carbenoid 2 to furnish a stereoselective product due to the S configuration of the chiral C(1) centre in carbenoid 2. This relationship of the stereochemistry to the chiral character of the carbenoid has implications for the design of new efficient carbenoid reagents for stereoselective cyclopropanation.

Aggregation of Alkyllithiums in Tetrahydrofuran

Density functional theory was used to examine the solvation number and aggregation state of several alkyllithium compounds in clusters with tetrahydrofuran molecules coordinated to each lithium atom. We then made the microsolvation approximation and approximated the bulk free energy of solvation by the free energy of clustering with solvent molecules in the gas phase. The trends in the computed results are in reasonable agreement with the available experimental data.

Methylene Transfer or Carbometalation? A Theoretical Study to Determine the Mechanism of Lithium Carbenoid-Promoted Cyclopropanation Reactions in Aggregation and Solvation States

Density functional theory calculations for the lithium carbenoid-promoted cyclopropanations in aggregation and solvation states are presented in order to investigate the controversy of the mechanistic dichotomy, that is, the methylene-transfer mechanism and the carbometalation mechanism. The methylene-transfer mechanism represents the reaction reality, whereas the carbometalation pathway does not appear to compete significantly with the methylene-transfer pathway and should be ruled out as a major factor. A simple model calculation for monomeric lithium carbenoid-promoted cyclopropanations with ethylene in the gas phase is not sufficient to reflect the reaction conditions accurately or to determine the reaction mechanism since its result is inconsistent with the experimental facts. The aggregated lithium carbenoids are the most probable reactive species in the reaction system. The calculated reaction barriers of the methylene-transfer pathways are 10.1 and 8.0 kcal/mol for the dimeric (LiCH2F)2 and tetrameric (LiCH2F)4 species, respectively, compared with the reaction barrier of 16.0 kcal/mol for the monomeric LiCH2F species. In contrast, the reaction barriers of the carbometalation pathways are 26.8 kcal/mol for the dimeric (LiCH2F)2 and 33.9 kcal/mol for the tetrameric (LiCH2F)4 species, compared with the reaction barrier of 12.5 kcal/mol for the monomeric LiCH2F species. The effects of solvation were investigated by explicit coordination of the solvent molecules to the lithium centers. This solvation effect is found to enhance the methylene-transfer pathway, while it is found to impede the carbometalation pathway instead. The combined effects of the aggregation and solvation lead to barriers to reaction in the range of 7.2-9.0 kcal/mol for lithium carbenoid-promoted cyclopropanation reactions along the methylene-transfer pathway. Our computational results are in good agreement with the experimental observations.

Unexpected Four-Membered over Six-Membered Ring Formation during the Synthesis of Azaheterocyclic Phosphonates: Experimental and Theoretical Evaluation

The cyclization of functionalized aminophosphonates is studied on both experimental and theoretical grounds. In a recently described route to phosphono-beta-lactams [Stevens C. V.; Vekemans, W.; Moonen, K.; Rammeloo, T. Tetrahedron Lett. 2003, 44, 1619], it was found that starting from an ambident allylic anion only four-membered rings were formed without any trace of six-membered lactams. New anion trapping experiments revealed that the gamma-anion is highly reactive in intermolecular reactions. Ab initio calculations predict higher reaction barriers for the gamma-anion due to restricted rotation about the C-N bond and due to highly strained transition states during ring closure. The sodium or lithium counterion, explicit dimethyl ether solvent molecules, and bulk solvent effects were properly taken into account at various levels of theory.

Theoretical Study on the Lithium−Halogen Exchange Reaction of 1,1-Dihaloalkenes with Methyllithium and the Nucleophilic Substitution Reaction of the Resulting α-Halo Alkenyllithiums

Transition structures for the lithium-bromine exchange reaction of 1,1-dibromoalkenes with methyllithium have been located by both the B3LYP and the MP2 levels of theory with the 6-31+G basis set. The reaction with methyllithium dimer gave similar results with lower activation energies. These calculations predict both the kinetic and the thermodynamic stereoselectivity correctly. That is, the sterically more constrained bromine atom of 1,1-dibromoalkenes was predominantly reacted with alkyllithium (dimer) in the kinetic condition. The intramolecular substitution reaction of 4,4-dibromo-3-methyl-3-pentenol in the presence of methyllithium has been investigated. After deprotonation of the alcohol and the lithium-bromine exchange reaction, the intramolecular substitution reaction occurs to give dihydrofuran in a concerted manner. The intermolecular substitution of alpha-chloro alkenyllithium with methyllithium was also studied for comparison. The formation of the indene derivative from 3-(o-bromophenyl)-1,1-dibromo-1-propene in the presence of methyllithium occurs in a similar manner. The lithium-bromine exchange reaction of bromobenzene with methyllithium occurs in an S(N)2 mechanism and the solvent plays an important role.

On the Existence of Uncharged Molecules with a Pyramidally Coordinated Carbon: The Cases of Pentacyclo[4.3.0.02,9.03,8.07,9]non-4-ene and Heptacyclo- [7.6.0.01,5.05,15.06,14.010,14.010,15]pentadecane

[reaction: see text] B3LYP/6-31G(d) and MP2 calculations predict interactions between the divalent carbon and one double bond in tricyclo[3.2.2.0(2,4)]nona-6,8-dien-3-ylidene (3). Carbene 3 easily forms the more stable 4, a species with a pyramidal geometry. Moreover, the kinetic stability of 4 has been investigated, and some of its decay products are described. Interestingly, 3,3-dibromotricyclo[3.2.2.0(2,4)]nona-6,8-diene (1), the precursor of carbenoid 3, has already been reported and shown to undergo a formal dimerization to give 2. In addition, 15, a compound structurally related to 4, is expected to have a substantially greater stability toward further rearrangement.

A computational study of mixed aggregates of chloromethyllithium with lithium dialkylamides

DFT calculations were performed to examine the possible formation of mixed aggregates between chloromethyllithium carbenoids and lithium dimethylamide (LiDMA). In the gas phase mixed aggregates were readily formed and consisted of mixed dimers, mixed trimers, and mixed tetramers. THF solvation disfavored the formation of mixed tetramers and resulted in less exergonic free energies of mixed dimer and mixed trimer formation.

A Computational Study of Oxiranyllithium

[reaction: see text] Computational methods were used to determine the structure, bonding, and aggregation states of oxiranyllithium in the gas phase and in THF solution, at 200 and 298 K. THF solvation was modeled by microsolvation with explicit THF ligands, forming a supermolecule that includes the oxiranyllithium aggregate and its first solvation shell. Because oxiranyllithium has a chiral center, two diastereomeric dimers were formed, the RR and the RS, along with their enantiomers. Similarly, three diastereomers of the tetramer were formed, the RRRR, RRRS, and RRSS and their enantiomers. Oxiranyllithium was found to exist predominantly as the tetramer in the gas phase, while the dimer was the dominant species in THF solution. The relative concentrations of the different stereoisomers were calculated from equilibrium constants.

Computational Strategies for Evaluating Barrier Heights for Gas-Phase Reactions of Lithium Enolates

Gas-phase activation energies were calculated for three lithium enolate reactions by using several different ab initio and density functional theory (DFT) methods to determine which levels of theory generate acceptable results. The reactions included an aldol-type addition of an enolate to an aldehyde, a proton transfer from an alcohol to a lithium enolate, and an S(N)2 reaction of an enolate with chloromethane. For each reaction, the calculations were performed for both the monomeric and dimeric forms of the lithium enolate. It was found that transition state geometry optimization with B3LYP followed by single point MP2 calculations generally provided acceptable results compared to higher level ab initio methods.

Structure, Bonding, and Solvation of Lithium Vinylcarbenoids

[reaction: see text] Molecular modeling was used to determine the structure of lithium vinylcarbenoids in the gas phase and in THF solution. Solvent effects were modeled by microsolvation with explicit THF ligands on each of the lithium atoms. The carbenoid geometries are dependent on the heteroatom and on solvation. The calculations predict 1-chlorovinyllithium and 1-bromovinyllithium to be a mixture of monomer and dimer at 200 K and mostly monomer at higher temperatures, whereas the 1-fluoro-, 1-methoxy-, and 1-dimethylaminovinyllithium are predicted to be dimeric in solution.

Structure, Bonding, and Solvation of Dilithiodiamines

Computational methods were used to determine the structure of dilithiodiamines and the effects of solvation by ethereal solvents. Solvation was examined by the use of microsolvation with explicit dimethyl ether or THF ligands and by the combined use of microsolvation and the IEFPCM continuum solvent model. It was determined that each of the compounds studied exists exclusively as a bridged intramolecular dimer, both in the gas phase and in solution. Thermodynamic properties were calculated at 200 and 298 K to estimate the effect of temperature on the cyclization energies. Infrared spectroscopy was used to confirm the proposed intramolecular dimer structures.

Solvent effects on the aggregation state of lithium dialkylaminoborohydrides

DFT calculations were performed to determine the effects of ethereal solvents on the aggregation state of lithium dialkylaminoborohydrides (LABs). The calculations included dimerization energies in the gas phase, with continuum solvation only, microsolvation with coordinating ethereal ligands, and a combination of the microsolvation and continuum models. The continuum model alone overestimates the stability of the dimers, apparently due to the lack of steric effects from the coordinating ethereal ligands. The use of the combined microsolvation and continuum solvation models predicts lithium dimethylaminoborohydride to be a mixture of monomer and dimer in THF, and more sterically hindered lithium aminoborohydrides to exist primarily as monomers. The kinetics of amination of 1-chlorodecane by lithium dimethylaminoborohydride showed no detectable change in reaction rate with time, suggesting that the LAB reagent may exist primarily as a monomer in THF.