Entropically Driven Enhancement of Cleavage Activity of a DNA-Armed Hammerhead Ribozyme: Mechanism of Action of Hammerhead Ribozymes

Unraveling the Kinetics of the 10-23 RNA-Cleaving DNAzyme

DNA-based enzymes, or DNAzymes, are single-stranded DNA sequences with the ability to catalyze various chemical reactions, including the cleavage of the bond between two RNA nucleotides. Lately, an increasing interest has been observed in these RNA-cleaving DNAzymes in the biosensing and therapeutic fields for signal generation and the modulation of gene expression, respectively. Additionally, multiple efforts have been made to study the effects of the reaction environment and the sequence of the catalytic core on the conversion of the substrate into product. However, most of these studies have only reported alterations of the general reaction course, but only a few have focused on how each individual reaction step is affected. In this work, we present for the first time a mathematical model that describes and predicts the reaction of the 10-23 RNA-cleaving DNAzyme. Furthermore, the model has been employed to study the effect of temperature, magnesium cations and shorter substrate-binding arms of the DNAzyme on the different kinetic rate constants, broadening the range of conditions in which the model can be exploited. In conclusion, this work depicts the prospects of such mathematical models to study and anticipate the course of a reaction given a particular environment.

Analysis of the Conserved P9-G10.1 Metal-Binding Motif in Hammerhead Ribozymes with an Extra Nucleotide Inserted between A9 and G10.1 Residues

Hammerhead ribozymes (Rz) have catalytically important tandem G:A pairs in the core region, and we recently demonstrated that the P9-G10.1 motif (a sheared-type G:A pair with a guanine residue on the 3' side of the adenine residue) with several flanking base pairs is sufficient for capture of divalent cations, such as Mg(2+) and Cd(2+) ions that are important to maintain full activities (Tanaka et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2002, 124, 4595-4601; Tanaka et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126, 744-752). We also found that mutant hammerhead ribozymes that have an additional G residue inserted between A9 and G10.1 residues (the metal-binding P9-G10.1 motif) have significant catalytic activities. In this study, we demonstrate that the hammerhead ribozymes are capable of maintaining the catalytically competent structure even when the tandem, sheared-type G:A pairs were perturbed by an insertion of an additional nucleotide, whereas the chirality of the phosphorothioate at the P9 position significantly influenced the enzymatic activity for both the natural and G-inserted ribozymes.

Biologically important reactions catalyzed by RNA molecules

The last few years have seen a considerable increase in our understanding of catalysis by naturally occurring RNA molecules called ribozymes. The biological functions of RNA molecules depend upon their adoption of appropriate three-dimensional structures. The structure of RNA has a very important electrostatic component, which results from the presence of charged phosphodiester bonds. Metal ions are usually required to stabilize the folded structures and/or catalysis. Some ribozymes utilize metal ions as catalysts, whereas others use the ions to maintain appropriate three-dimensional structures. In the latter case, the correct folding of the RNA structures can perturb the pKa values of the nucleotide(s) within a catalytic pocket such that they act as general acid/bases catalysts.

Factors that contribute to efficient catalytic activity of a small Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme in relation to its RNA cleavage function

Recently, we found a small Ca(2+)-dependent deoxyribozyme (unmodified), d(GCCTGGCAG(1)G(2)C(3)T(4)A(5)C(6)A(7)A(8)C(9)G(10)A(11)GTCCCT), with cleavage activity for its RNA substrate, r(AGGGACA downward arrow UGCCAGGC) ( downward arrow denotes the RNA cleavage site), in the presence of Ca(2+) and developed a functional SPR sensor chip with this deoxyribozyme [Okumoto, Y., Ohmichi, T., and Sugimoto, N. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 2769-2773]. In the study presented here, to clarify the factors contributing to the efficient catalytic activity of the unmodified deoxyribozyme, RNA cleavage reactions were carried out using 24 mutant deoxyribozymes containing one unnatural DNA nucleotide, such as dI (2'-deoxyinosine), 7-deaza-dG, 2-aminopurine, 7-deaza-dA, 2-amino-dA, dm(5)C (5-methyl-2'-deoxycytosine), or d(P)C (5-propynyl-2'-deoxycytosine). The K(m) values (Michaelis constants) with the mutants that lacked N7 and O6 of G(1) and O6 of G(2) were 4.5 and 6.6 times that of the unmodified one, respectively. The k(cat) value (cleavage rate constant) with the mutants that lacked O6 of G(10) was 0.025 times that of the unmodified one. The results of UV melting curves, SPR kinetics, and CD spectra supported the quantitative idea that the catalytic activity of the unmodified form was achieved using Ca(2+). On the basis of these results, a preliminary model for two G(1) x A(8) and G(2) x A(7) mismatched base pairs such as G(anti) x A(anti) formed in the catalytic loop is proposed. The factor of 10 increase in the k(cat)/K(m) value of the mutant deoxyribozyme, which has C(9) substituted with d(P)C, suggests that the base stacking interaction between the substituted propynyl group in dC and the nearest-neighbor base grew stronger. Thus, substituting d(P)C for dC in the catalytic loop would be one of the best ways to increase the catalytic activity of the deoxyribozyme.

Metal ions and the stereochemistry of ribozyme reactions

Inversion of configuration at phosphorus during ribozyme-catalyzed cleavage of RNA is usually considered unequivocal proof of in-line attack, but the relevant pseudorotation diagram for formation of the 2('),3(')-cyclic phosphate shows that inversion is not inconsistent with adjacent attack as long as breakdown of the trigonal bipyramid is in-line. For the reaction to occur by adjacent attack, a normally unstable apical oxyanion in the trigonal bipyramidal intermediate would have to be stabilized. Density-functional calculations show that a metal ion such as magnesium could perform this stabilization. We conclude that the possibility of adjacent attack should not be too hastily dismissed in cases where the setup is closer to adjacent than to in-line geometry.

Detection of a proton-transfer process by kinetic solvent isotope effects in NH(4)(+)-mediated reactions catalyzed by a hammerhead ribozyme

Hammerhead ribozymes have been considered to be metalloenzymes. However, this proposal was recently questioned by the finding that the reaction proceeds in the presence of high concentrations of monovalent ions such as NH(4)(+) ions and in the absence of any divalent metal ions. Our present analysis based on solvent isotope effects indicates that (1) a proton transfer(s) occurs only in the NH(4)(+)-mediated reaction but not in metal-ion-mediated reactions such as Mg(2+)- and Li(+)-mediated reactions, (2) the catalyst that stabilizes the 5' leaving group in the NH(4)(+)-mediated reaction is different from that in the metal-ion-mediated HH ribozyme reactions, (3) an NH(4)(+) ion seems to act as a general acid catalyst, and (4) a nucleobase alone should not be the catalyst.

Allosterically controlled single-chained maxizymes with extremely high and specific activity

For the treatment of chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML), attempts have been made to design various ribozyme motifs that can specifically recognize and cleave BCR-ABL fusion mRNAs. In the case of L6 BCR-ABL b2a2 mRNA, it is difficult to cleave the abnormal mRNA specifically because the mRNA includes no sequences that can be cleaved efficiently by conventional hammerhead ribozymes near the BCR-ABL junction. We recently succeeded in designing a novel maxizyme, which specifically cleaves BCR-ABL fusion mRNA, as a result of the formation of a dimeric structure [Kuwabara, T.; et al. Mol. Cell 1998, 2, 617-627; Tanabe, T.; et al. Nature 2000, 406, 473-474]. Specifically, we tailored the maxizyme with molecular switching function: the maxizyme splices a cleavable GUC site, but only when it appears within a strand of mRNA that possesses the abnormal splice junction. We demonstrated that this approach is generalizable [Tanabe, T.; et al. Biomacromolecules 2000, 1, 108-117]. All the maxizymes designed in the past functioned as a result of the formation of a dimeric structure. Questions have been asked whether a similar molecular switching might be possible within a single molecule when two monomer units of the maxizyme were connected via a linker sequence. We found that an analogous conformational change could not be induced within a single molecule when two maxizyme units were simply connected via a nonregulatable linker sequence. However, an active conformation was achieved by the introduction of an antisense modulator within the linker sequence that adjusted the overall structure to the correct form. Results of studies in cultured cells suggested that the desired conformational change could indeed be induced within the modified single-chained maxizyme and such a construct caused apoptosis only in leukemic cells with the Philadelphia chromosome.

Comparison of metal-ion-dependent cleavages of RNA by a DNA enzyme and a hammerhead ribozyme

Joyce's DNA enzyme catalyzes cleavage of RNAs with almost the same efficiency as the hammerhead ribozyme. The cleavage activity of the DNA enzyme was pH dependent, and the logarithm of the cleavage rate increased linearly with pH from pH 6 to pH 9 with a slope of approximately unity. The existence of an apparent solvent isotope effect, with cleavage of RNA by the DNA enzyme in H(2)O being 4.3 times faster than cleavage in D(2)O, was in accord with the interpretation that, at a given pH, the concentration of the active species (deprotonated species) is 4.3 times higher in H(2)O than the concentration in D(2)O. This leads to the intrinsic isotope effect of unity, demonstrating that no proton transfer occurs in the transition state in reactions catalyzed by the DNA enzyme. Addition of La(3+) ions to the Mg(2+)-background reaction mixture inhibited the DNA enzyme-catalyzed reactions, suggesting the replacement of catalytically and/or structurally important Mg(2+) ions by La(3+) ions. Similar kinetic features of DNA enzyme mediated cleavage of RNA and of hammerhead ribozyme-mediated cleavage suggest that a very similar catalytic mechanism is used by the two types of enzyme, despite their different compositions.

A new and efficient DNA enzyme for the sequence-specific cleavage of RNA

A new DNA enzyme, the "Bipartite DNAzyme", suitable for the sequence-specific cleavage of RNA, was obtained from a random DNA library by in vitro selection. Only a single family of catalytic molecules emerged from the selection, and a 22 nucleotide consensus sequence common to all clones defined a putative catalytic core. The most abundant clone self-cleaved at a single internal ribonucleotide phosphodiester with a relatively fast k(obs) value of 1.7 min(-1), in 10 mM MgCl(2) at 23 degrees C. This DNAzyme ("Bipartite I") required divalent cations, with magnesium and manganese most optimally supporting cleavage. A reselection from a mutagenized DNAzyme pool for the ability to cleave at extended RNA substrates yielded an unchanged catalytic core sequence. From this re-selection a DNAzyme ("Bipartite II") capable of sequence-specifically cleaving extended stretches of RNA was derived. A rate versus pH analysis of the Bipartite II DNAzyme revealed a two-phase profile, similar to that reported for the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme, suggesting that the Bipartite II DNAzyme and the HDV ribozyme may share similar catalytic strategies. Multiple-turnover kinetics, measured in 30 mM MgCl(2), at 37 degrees C, with an HIV-1-derived RNA substrate, yielded a k(cat) value of approximately 1.4 min(-1) and a K(M) value of approximately 230 nM, which were of the same order as k(cat) and K(M )values measured for other ribozymes and DNAzymes in general use for RNA cleavage. The Bipartite DNAzyme therefore represents a new and potentially useful reagent, both for the processing of RNA transcripts in vitro and for mRNA ablation procedures in vivo.

Allosterically controllable maxizymes cleave mRNA with high efficiency and specificity

Ribozymes are small and versatile nucleic acids that can cleave RNA molecules at specific sites. However, because of the limited number of cleavable sequences on the target mRNA, in some cases conventional ribozymes do not have precise cleavage specificity. To overcome this problem, an allosteric version (a maxizyme) was developed that displayed activity and specificity in vivo. More than five custom-designed maxizymes have demonstrated sensor functions, which indicates that the technology might be broadly applicable in molecular biology and possibly in the clinic.

Effects of metal ions and catalytic loop sequences on the complex formation of a deoxyribozyme and its RNA substrate

A deoxyribozyme is a catalytic DNA that catalyzes a site-specific RNA cleavage activity and requires various divalent cations. Earlier we have reported that by downsizing the catalytic loop of a deoxyribozyme from 15-mer to 11-mer it resulted in a short and novel Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme. In this paper, we investigate the complex formation of deoxyribozymes with their RNA substrates by using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) in order to determine quantitatively the effect of Ca2+ or Mg2+ on the recognition step between a deoxyribozyme and its RNA substrate. The results indicate that both the association and dissociation rate constants (k(a) and k(d)) for the deoxyribozyme-RNA complex depends on metal ions as well as the loop size of the deoxyribozyme. Metal ions with high RNA cleavage activity induced an increase in k(a) and a decrease in k(d). On the basis of the results, we propose that Ca2+ ions may play a role in the rearrangement of the 11-mer catalytic loop of the short Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme.

Effects of cetyltrimethylammonium bromide on reactions catalyzed by maxizymes, a novel class of metalloenzymes

We demonstrated previously that some shortened forms of hammerhead ribozymes had high cleavage activity that was similar to that of the wild-type parental hammerhead ribozyme. Moreover, the active species appeared to form dimeric structures with a common stem II (in order to distinguish monomeric forms of conventional minizymes that have low activity from our novel dimers with high-level activity, the latter very active short ribozymes were designated 'maxizymes'). The dimers can be homodimeric (with two identical binding sequences) or heterodimeric (with two different binding sequences). In the case of heterodimers, they are in equilibrium with inactive homodimers. In this study, we investigated the effects of cationic detergent, cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), on reactions catalyzed by a variety of maxizymes. The slope of close to unity in profiles of pH versus rate demonstrated that the deprotonation was important in catalysis and that the rate-limiting chemical step was followed in these reactions. Addition of appropriate amounts of CTAB enhanced the activity of a variety of maxizymes. The activity of our least stable, least active maxizyme was enhanced 100-fold by CTAB. Thus, CTAB effectively enhanced the conversion of kinetically trapped inactive conformations to active forms. Moreover, we suggest that the activity and specificity of catalytic RNAs in vivo might be better estimated if their reactions are monitored in vitro in the presence of appropriate amounts of CTAB.

Extremely high and specific activity of DNA enzymes in cells with a Philadelphia chromosome

BACKGROUND

Chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) results from chromosome 22 translocations (the Philadelphia chromosome) that creates BCR-ABL fusion genes, which encode two abnormal mRNAs (b3a2 and b2a2). Various attempts to design antisense oligonucleotides that specifically cleave abnormal L6 BCR-ABL fusion mRNA have not been successful. Because b2a2 mRNA cannot be effectively cleaved by hammerhead ribozymes near the BCR-ABL junction, it has proved very difficult to engineer specific cleavage of this chimeric mRNA. Nonspecific effects associated with using antisense molecules make the use of such antisense molecules questionable.

RESULTS

The usefulness of DNA enzymes in specifically suppressing expression of L6 BCR-ABL mRNA in mammalian cells is demonstrated. Although the efficacy of DNA enzymes with natural linkages decreased 12 hours after transfection, partially modified DNA enzymes, with either phosphorothioate or 2'-O-methyl groups at both their 5' and 3' ends, remained active for much longer times in mammalian cells. Moreover, the DNA enzyme with only 2'-O-methyl modifications was also highly specific for abnormal mRNA.

CONCLUSIONS

DNA enzymes with 2'-O-methyl modifications are potentially useful as gene-inactivating agents in the treatment of diseases such as CML. In contrast to conventional antisense DNAs, some of the DNA enzymes used in this study were highly specific and cleaved only abnormal BCR-ABL mRNA.

Effects of helical structures formed by the binding arms of DNAzymes and their substrates on catalytic activity

As a part of our efforts to clarify structure-function relationships in reactions catalyzed by deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes), which were recently selected in vitro , we synthesized various chimeras and analyzed the kinetics of the corresponding cleavage reactions. We focused on the binding arms and generated helices composed of binding arms and substrates that consisted of RNA and RNA, of RNA and DNA or of DNA and DNA. As expected for the rate limiting chemical cleavage step in reactions catalyzed by DNAzymes, a linear relationship between log( k cat) and pH was observed. In all cases examined, introduction of DNA into the binding helix enhanced the rate of chemical cleavage. Comparison of CD spectra of DNAzyme. substrate complexes suggested that higher levels of B-form-like helix were associated with higher rates of cleavage of the substrate within the complex. To our surprise, the enhancement of catalytic activity that followed introduction of DNA into the binding helix (enhancement by the presence of more B-form-like helix) was very similar to that observed in the case of the hammerhead ribozymes that we had investigated previously. These data, together with other observations, strongly suggest that the reaction mechanism of metal-ion-dependent DNAzymes is almost identical to that of hammerhead ribozymes.

Explanation by the double-metal-ion mechanism of catalysis for the differential metal ion effects on the cleavage rates of 5'-oxy and 5'-thio substrates by a hammerhead ribozyme

In a previous examination using natural all-RNA substrates that contained either a 5'-oxy or 5'-thio leaving group at the cleavage site, we demonstrated that (i) the attack by the 2'-oxygen at C17 on the phosphorus atom is the rate-limiting step only for the substrate that contains a 5'-thio group (R11S) and (ii) the departure of the 5' leaving group is the rate-limiting step for the natural all-RNA substrate (R11O) in both nonenzymatic and hammerhead ribozyme-catalyzed reactions; the energy diagrams for these reactions were provided in our previous publication. In this report we found that the rate of cleavage of R11O by a hammerhead ribozyme was enhanced 14-fold when Mg2+ ions were replaced by Mn2+ ions, whereas the rate of cleavage of R11S was enhanced only 2.2-fold when Mg2+ ions were replaced by Mn2+ ions. This result appears to be exactly the opposite of that predicted from the direct coordination of the metal ion with the leaving 5'-oxygen, because a switch in metal ion specificity was not observed with the 5'-thio substrate. However, our quantitative analyses based on the previously provided energy diagram indicate that this result is in accord with the double-metal-ion mechanism of catalysis.