Large-Scale Inhomogeneities in Solutions of Low Molar Mass Compounds and Mixtures of Liquids: Supramolecular Structures or Nanobubbles?

Monomers Versus Prenucleation Clusters En Route to Polymorphism of Supramolecular Polymers

Polymorphism in supramolecular polymers is strongly correlated with the polymerization pathways underlying their formation. To effectively control emerging polymorphs, a comprehensive understanding of nucleation pathways and mechanisms is essential. Herein, a coronene-dipeptide conjugate (Cr-o-FFOEt) is introduced and its self-assembly into two different stable 1D supramolecular polymorphs (Agg 1 and 2f) is observed in the same solvent composition (water/THF, 7:3 v/v) and same concentration at room temperature, following two competitive self-assembly pathways. The difference in the mode of solvent addition triggers the two self-assembly pathways. Furthermore, the isolated intermediate Agg 2i is found to transform into Agg 1 or Agg 2f under controlled experimental conditions. The supramolecular aggregates of Cr-o-FFOEt are thoroughly examined with the help of optical, chiroptical, and morphological techniques to understand the subtle difference in choosing the self-assembling pathways. The studies reveal that the nanotube formation of Agg 1 follows a classical nucleation-elongation supramolecular polymerization mechanism (involving monomers). In contrast, the helical fibers of Agg 2f are formed by the involvement of preorganized oligomers (nonclassical process). The observation highlights the underappreciated role of prenucleation clusters in pathway complexity and polymorphism of supramolecular 1D polymers.

Characterisation of Aqueous Ultra-high Homeopathic Potencies: Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

 Over the past decade, research using various methods has claimed the material nature, including nanoparticles (NPs), of high homeopathic potencies. The current study aims to verify these findings using NP tracking analysis (NTA).

METHODS

 Six independent serial dilutions of commonly used homeopathic medicines-either soluble (Gelsemium, Pyrogenium, Kalium mur) or insoluble (Cuprum, Argentum, Silicea)-were prepared according to European Pharmacopoeia standards. We compared the homeopathic dynamisations (DYNs) in pure water with their potentised controls and with simple dilutions (DIL) up to 30cH/10-60. We also tested the influence of the container (glass or PET) on the solvent controls.

RESULTS

 We observed the presence of particles from 20 to 300-400 nm in all DYNs, DILs and controls, except in pure unstirred water. The sizes and size distributions of NPs in high homeopathic potencies were smaller than those in controls for soluble sources and larger for insoluble sources, even above 11cH. The opposite behaviour was observed in the number of NPs. When comparing DYN and DIL, the number, size, presence of aggregates or chains and brightness of NPs increased with DYNs, which was also observed above 11cH. Many NPs scattered light of low intensity, indicating the presence of material particles. The container had a significant effect on the number and size of NPs, indicating the involvement of the atmosphere and leaching processes.

CONCLUSION

 Homeopathic medicines contain NPs with specific properties, even when diluted beyond Avogadro's number. Homeopathic potentisation is not a simple dilution. The starting material, the solvent used, the type of container and the manufacturing method influence the characteristics of these NPs. The nature of these NPs is not known, but most likely they are a mixture of nanobubbles and elements from the atmosphere and container, including insoluble ones.

Deciphering Density Fluctuations in the Hydration Water of Brownian Nanoparticles via Upconversion Thermometry

We investigate the intricate relationship among temperature, pH, and Brownian velocity in a range of differently sized upconversion nanoparticles (UCNPs) dispersed in water. These UCNPs, acting as nanorulers, offer insights into assessing the relative proportion of high-density and low-density liquid in the surrounding hydration water. The study reveals a size-dependent reduction in the onset temperature of liquid-water fluctuations, indicating an augmented presence of high-density liquid domains at the nanoparticle surfaces. The observed upper-temperature threshold is consistent with a hypothetical phase diagram of water, validating the two-state model. Moreover, an increase in pH disrupts the organization of water molecules, similar to external pressure effects, allowing simulation of the effects of temperature and pressure on hydrogen bonding networks. The findings underscore the significance of the surface of suspended nanoparticles for understanding high- to low-density liquid fluctuations and water behavior at charged interfaces.

Molecular Signal Transfer of Highly Diluted Antibodies to Interferon-Gamma Regarding Kind, Time, and Distance of Exposition

Physicochemical examinations of very high dilution (UHD) solutions subjected to certain physical factors (such as shaking) are becoming more frequent and are increasingly producing conclusive results. A much less studied phenomenon is the transfer of molecular information (i.e., UHD signals of dilute substances) from one liquid to another without an intermediate liquid phase. The aim of this study was to investigate the possibility of such a transfer of the UHD signal from the UHD solutions to the receiver solution, in particular, if the molecular source used in the donor solutions was the biologically active antibodies to interferon-gamma molecule. We were especially interested in how the transfer of the UHD signal is affected by the time of exposure of the receiver to the donor, the distance between the two, and how the transfer is affected by activation (striking) versus exposure alone. Signal transfer was evaluated by differential measurements of electrical conductivity, ORP, pH, and UV/VIS spectroscopy of the exposed liquid. The results showed that activation strongly influences signal transfer and that this can be compensated to some extent by prolonged direct exposure. In principle, exposure time has a positive effect on signal transfer. Interestingly, the results of different distances between the donor and receiver showed similar changes in the parameters in the range of 0-4 cm, as estimated in this study. While the study mainly confirms the two hypotheses, it also raises a number of new questions and provides clues for further research.

Nanobubbles in water and wastewater treatment systems: Small bubbles making big difference

Since the discovery of nanobubbles (NBs) in 1994, NBs have been attracting growing attention for their fascinating properties and have been studied for application in various environmental fields, including water and wastewater treatment. However, despite the intensive research efforts on NBs' fundamental properties, especially in the past five years, controversies and disagreements in the published literature have hindered their practical implementation. So far, reviews of NB research have mainly focused on NBs' role in specific treatment processes or general applications, highlighting proof-of-concept and success stories primarily at the laboratory scale. As such, there lacks a rigorous review that authenticates NBs' potential beyond the bench scale. This review aims to provide a comprehensive and up-to-date analysis of the recent progress in NB research in the field of water and wastewater treatment at different scales, along with identifying and discussing the challenges and prospects of the technology. Herein, we systematically analyze (1) the fundamental properties of NBs and their relevancy to water treatment processes, (2) recent advances in NB applications for various treatment processes beyond the lab scale, including over 20 pilot and full-scale case studies, (3) a preliminary economic consideration of NB-integrated treatment processes (the case of NB-flotation), and (4) existing controversies in NBs research and the outlook for future research. This review is organized with the aim to provide readers with a step-by-step understanding of the subject matter while highlighting key insights as well as knowledge gaps requiring research to advance the use of NBs in the wastewater treatment industry.

Water as a sensor of weak impacts on biological systems

A characteristic feature of weak impacts is the non-monotonic response of living organisms and model biological systems to monotonically decreasing impacts. The qualitative similarity of the effects caused by the different acting factors makes one think about the common cause of the observed effects, which is water. A comprehensive analysis of the actual composition of water indicates that water under normal conditions is a multicomponent open non-equilibrium system. Nanobubbles that are always present in water play a significant role in the properties of dilute aqueous solutions. When collapsed, they can produce active oxygen and nitrogen species that have a strong effect on biological systems. Significant non-monotonic changes in electrical conductivity found in a series of sequentially diluted solutions subjected to vigorous shaking after each dilution convincingly demonstrate the presence of chemical changes in the composition of aqueous solutions explained by mechanochemical processes. Similar changes were observed in water samples prepared in the same manner with vigorous shaking and dilution without the addition of any chemical compounds. The long-term evolution of the conductivity of such solutions depends on the chemical structure of the solutes.

Physicochemical Study of the Molecular Signal Transfer of Ultra-High Diluted Antibodies to Interferon-Gamma

Physicochemical investigations of (UHD) solutions subjected to certain physical factors (like shaking) are becoming more frequent and increasingly yielding convincing results. A much less studied phenomenon is the transfer of molecular information (UHD signals) from one fluid to another without an intermediate liquid phase. The purpose of this study was to investigate the possibility of such a UHD signal transfer from UHD solutions into the receiver fluid, especially when the molecular source used in solutions was a biologically active molecule of antibodies to interferon-gamma. We used physicochemical measurements and UV spectroscopy for this purpose. The results of this large pilot study confirm the possibility of such a transfer and a rough similarity to the original UHD signal donors, the weaker signal detection relative to the original donor fluids, and that exposure time improves the effect.

Phase-Transfer Catalyzed Microfluidic Glycosylation: A Small Change in Concentration Results in a Dramatic Increase in Stereoselectivity

Phase-transfer catalysis (PTC) is widely used in glycochemistry for the preparation of aryl glycosides by the glycosylation reaction. While investigating the possibility of synthesis of 4-(3-chloropropoxy)phenyl sialoside (Neu5Ac-OCPP) from N-acetylsialyl chloride with O-acetyl groups (1), we have recently discovered a strong dependence of the PTC glycosylation outcome on the mixing mode: under batch conditions, only α-anomer of Neu5Ac-OCPP was obtained, albeit in low yield (13%), while under microfluidic conditions the yield of Neu5Ac-OCPP increased to 36%, although stereoselectivity decreased (α/β ≤ 6.2). Here, we report that the outcome of this reaction, performed under microfluidic conditions using a Comet X-01 micromixer (at 2 μL/min flow rate), non-linearly depends on the concentration of N-acetylsialyl chloride 1 (5–200 mmol/L). The target Neu5Ac-OCPP was obtained in a noticeably higher yield (up to 66%) accompanied by enhanced stereoselectivity (α/β = 17:1–32:1) in the high concentration range (C > 50 mmol/L), whereas the yield (10–36%) and especially, stereoselectivity (α/β = 0.9:1–6.2:1) were lower in the low concentration range (C ≤ 50 mmol/L). This dramatic stepwise increase in stereoselectivity above critical concentration (50 mmol/L) is apparently related to the changes in the presentation of molecules on the surface of supramers of glycosyl donor, which exist in different concentration ranges.

Solvophobicity-Driven Mesoscale Structures: Stabilizer-Free Nanodispersions

Solvophobicity-driven mesoscale structures that lack any stabilizers are perhaps the most common spontaneously formed stable colloidal objects (particles, droplets). In spite of this, they have been significantly overlooked for a long time and the knowledge on solvophobicity-driven mesoscale structures (SDMSs) is rather limited. Here, we follow up on our previous work on mesoscale solubility [Rak, D.; Sedlák, M. On the Mesoscale Solubility in Liquid Solutions and Mixtures. J. Phys. Chem. B 2019, 123, 1365-1374. 10.1021/acs.jpcb.8b10638] and aim at providing a fully consistent picture of the nature, formation, and stability of SDMSs. We investigate both aqueous and nonaqueous mixtures, showing that this phenomenon is universal and not limited to aqueous systems. An experimental regime diagram is constructed as a function of the concentration of the solvophobic component and the solvophobicity strength given by mixtures of various organic solvents. Aqueous mixtures are investigated using well-defined ternary systems comprising water, ethanol (or other organic solvents), and a series of linear alkanes serving as hydrophobes. This investigation covers unique long-time monitoring of SDMS stability (up to three years). Another parameter studied in detail is the temperature of the mixture. SDMSs are characterized in terms of their shape and size distributions obtained using orthogonal techniques. Last but not least, we bring some insights into the SDMS surface zeta potential─the key quantity behind the stability of SDMSs. We investigate zeta potential as a function of the mixture composition, pH, and temperature.

Doxorubicin aqueous systems at low concentrations: Interconnection between self-organization, fluorescent and physicochemical properties, and action on hydrobionts

Doxorubicin (Dox) is a highly effective cytostatic antibiotic that exhibits activity against a wide range of malignant neoplasms and is often used as the basis of various anti-tumor compositions. However, the use of Dox in therapeutic doses is associated with high systemic toxicity, which makes it urgent to find ways to reduce therapeutic concentrations, which is necessary primarily to minimize the side effects on the patient's body, as well as to reduce the harmful effects on aquatic ecosystems, commonly polluted by toxic pharmaceuticals. Studying the self-organization, physicochemical and spectral patterns, and their relation to bioeffects of Dox solutions in the range of low concentrations can reveal useful insights into the unknown effects of Dox as a cytostatic and potential pollutant of ecosystems. The self-organization in solutions and on substrates, physicochemical and spectral properties, and action of Dox solutions on hydrobionts were studied in the range of calculated concentrations from 1·10-20 to 1·10-4 M by methods of dynamic and electrophoretic light scattering (DLS and ELS), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), scanning probe microscopy (SPM), fluorescence spectroscopy, UV absorption spectroscopy, conductometry, tensiometry, pH-metry. Certified techniques for monitoring the toxicity of natural water and wastewater were used to establish the interconnection between these phenomena. It was shown that aqueous solutions of Dox are dispersed systems which rearrange their dispersed phase measuring hundreds of nm in size (nanoassociates) at dilution, followed by concerted changes in nanoassociates' parameters (size and ζ-potential) and properties of systems, as well as their bioassay results. SPM and SEM results confirm and complement the DLS and ELS data indicating the existence of nanoassociates in dilute Dox solutions.

Xenon and Krypton Dissolved in Water Form Nanoblobs: No Evidence for Nanobubbles

We demonstrate, experimentally and by molecular dynamics simulations, that krypton and xenon form nanostructured water-gas domains. High pressure was applied to force the inert gases to dissolve in water following Henry's law, then the liquid was depressurized, centrifuged, and inspected by dynamic light scattering. The observed objects have similar sizes and electrical properties to nanobubbles, but we found that they have fairly neutral buoyancy even at high gravitational fields. We posit that the formed nano objects are not bubbles but blobs, unique structures conceived as clathrate-hydrate precursors, thus resolving the so-called Laplace pressure bubble catastrophe.

Online Monitoring of the Concentrations of Amorphous and Crystalline Mesoscopic Species Present in Solution

Despite the growing evidence for the existence of amorphous mesoscopic species in a solution and their crucial roles in crystallization, there has been the lack of a suitable method to measure the time-resolved concentrations of amorphous and crystalline mesospecies in a lab-scale stirred reactor. This has limited experimental investigations to understand the kinetics of amorphous and crystalline mesospecies formation in stirred solutions and made it challenging to measure the crystal nucleation rate directly. Here, we used depolarized light sheet microscopy to achieve time-resolved measurements of amorphous and crystalline mesospecies concentrations in solutions at varying temperatures. After demonstrating that the concentration measurement method is reasonably accurate, precise, and sensitive, we utilized this method to examine mesospecies formation both in a mixture of two miscible liquids and in an undersaturated solution of dl-valine, thus revealing the importance of a temperature change in the formation of metastable and amorphous mesospecies as well as the reproducibility of the measurements. Moreover, we used the presented method to monitor both mesospecies formation and crystal nucleation in dl-valine solutions at four different levels of supersaturation, while achieving the direct measurement of the crystal nucleation rates in stirred solutions. Our results show that, as expected, the inherent variability in nucleation originating from its stochastic nature reduces with increasing supersaturation, and the dependence of the measured nucleation rate on supersaturation is in reasonable agreement with that predicted by the classical nucleation theory.

L-Tryptophan Aqueous Systems at Low Concentrations: Interconnection between Self-Organization, Fluorescent and Physicochemical Properties, and Action on Hydrobionts

As shown by fluorescence monitoring of dissolved organic matter, amino acid L-Trp can be present in natural water. The consequences of the presence of L-Trp at low concentrations in surface water systems are not yet established for hydrobionts. Studying the physicochemical patterns, as well as their relationships to the bioeffects of L-Trp solutions in the low concentration range, can provide new and important information regarding the unknown effects of L-Trp. The self-organization, physicochemical properties, fluorescence, UV absorption, and action of L-Trp solutions on Paramecium caudatum infusoria, Chlorella vulgaris algae were studied in the calculated concentrations range of 1 × 10⁻²⁰–1 × 10⁻² mol/L. The relationship between these phenomena was established using the certified procedures for monitoring the toxicity of natural water and wastewater. It was shown for the first time that aqueous solutions of L-Trp are dispersed systems in which the dispersed phase (nanoassociates) undergoes a rearrangement with dilution, accompanied by coherent changes in the nanoassociates’ parameters and the properties of systems. The non-monotonic concentration dependence of fluorescence intensity (λ_ex at 225 nm, λ_em at 340 nm) is in good agreement with the data on the nanoassociates’ parameters, as well as with both the physicochemical properties of the systems and their bioassay results.

Diclofenac Ion Hydration: Experimental and Theoretical Search for Anion Pairs

Self-assembly of organic ions in aqueous solutions is a hot topic at the present time, and substances that are well-soluble in water are usually studied. In this work, aqueous solutions of sodium diclofenac are investigated, which, like most medicinal compounds, is poorly soluble in water. Classical MD modeling of an aqueous solution of diclofenac sodium showed equilibrium between the hydrated anion and the hydrated dimer of the diclofenac anion. The assignment and interpretation of the bands in the UV, NIR, and IR spectra are based on DFT calculations in the discrete-continuum approximation. It has been shown that the combined use of spectroscopic methods in various frequency ranges with classical MD simulations and DFT calculations provides valuable information on the association processes of medical compounds in aqueous solutions. Additionally, such a combined application of experimental and calculation methods allowed us to put forward a hypothesis about the mechanism of the effect of diclofenac sodium in high dilutions on a solution of diclofenac sodium.

Citric Acid: A Multifunctional Pharmaceutical Excipient

Citric acid, a tricarboxylic acid, has found wide application in the chemical and pharmaceutical industry due to its biocompatibility, versatility, and green, environmentally friendly chemistry. This review emphasizes the pharmaceutical uses of citric acid as a strategic ingredient in drug formulation while focusing on the impact of its physicochemical properties. The functionality of citric acid is due to its three carboxylic groups and one hydroxyl group. These allow it to be used in many ways, including its ability to be used as a crosslinker to form biodegradable polymers and as a co-former in co-amorphous and co-crystal applications. This paper also analyzes the effect of citric acid in physiological processes and how this effect can be used to enhance the attributes of pharmaceutical preparations, as well as providing a critical discussion on the issues that may arise out of the presence of citric acid in formulations.

The fate of bulk nanobubbles under gas dissolution

Artificially added or undesired organic and inorganic contaminants in solution that are interfacially active always tend to be adsorbed at the gas-liquid interface of micro- and nano-bubbles, affecting the stability of the tiny bubbles. In this work, by using molecular dynamics simulations we study how the adsorbed surfactant-like molecules, with their amphiphilic character, affect the dissolution of the existing bulk nanobubbles under low gas supersaturation environments. We find that, depending on the concentration of the dissolved gas and the molecular structure of surfactants, two fates of bulk nanobubbles whose interfaces are saturated by surfactants are found: either remaining stable or being completely dissolved. With gas dissolution, the bubble shrinks and the insoluble surfactants form a monolayer with an increasing areal density until an extremely low (close to 0) surface tension is reached. In the limit of vanishing surface tension, the chemical structure of surfactants crucially affects the bubble stability by changing the monolayer elastic energy. Two basic conditions for stable nanobubbles at low gas saturation are identified: vanishing surface tension due to bubble dissolution and positive spontaneous curvature of the surfactant monolayer. Based on this observation, we discuss the similarity in the stability mechanism of bulk nanobubbles and that of microemulsions.

Exploiting non-covalent interactions in selective carbohydrate synthesis

Non-covalent interactions (NCIs) are a vital component of biological bond-forming events, and have found important applications in multiple branches of chemistry. In recent years, the biomimetic exploitation of NCIs in challenging glycosidic bond formation and glycofunctionalizations has attracted significant interest across diverse communities of organic and carbohydrate chemists. This emerging theme is a major new direction in contemporary carbohydrate chemistry, and is rapidly gaining traction as a robust strategy to tackle long-standing issues such as anomeric and site selectivity. This Review thus seeks to provide a bird's-eye view of wide-ranging advances in harnessing NCIs within the broad field of synthetic carbohydrate chemistry. These include the exploitation of NCIs in non-covalent catalysed glycosylations, in non-covalent catalysed glycofunctionalizations, in aglycone delivery, in stabilization of intermediates and transition states, in the existence of intramolecular hydrogen bonding networks and in aggregation by hydrogen bonds. In addition, recent emerging opportunities in exploiting halogen bonding and other unconventional NCIs, such as CH-π, cation-π and cation-n interactions, in various aspects of carbohydrate chemistry are also examined.

Can bulk nanobubbles be stabilized by electrostatic interaction?

It has been suggested that electrostatic stress arising from charges accumulated at the surface of nanobubbles might balance Laplace pressure leading to their stability. This mechanism has been widely discussed in the nanobubble field for the past decade. However, the stress in the diffusive double layer was overlooked when calculating the electrostatic effect in previous theories. In this communication, we recalculated this effect using the classical double layer theory. Combined with experimentally measured zeta potential, we find that the ratio of electrostatic pressure to Laplace pressure is much less than 10-2, which suggests that electrostatic interaction may not be the main factor for stabilizing bulk nanobubbles.

Effect of nanoparticles on spontaneous Ouzo emulsification

Particles stabilize fluid interfaces. In particular, oil/water Pickering emulsions undergo limited coalescence, yielding droplets of smaller size as the amount of particles is increased. Herein, we studied the effect of hydrophobic nanoparticles (<10 nm, alkyl-coated) on submicronic droplets (ca 100 nm) formed in an Ouzo system. We investigated thoroughly the water/tetrahydrofuran (THF)/butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) reference diagram, in the absence and in the presence of nanoparticles, using the Nanoparticle Tracking Analysis (NTA) technique. This allowed us to characterize the size distributions in a much finer way than what is usually obtained using conventional Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS). Both a Surfactant-Free Microemulsion (SFME, thermodynamically stable) and an Ouzo (metastable spontaneous emulsion) domains were identified and the transition from one to the other could be characterized by specific features of the droplet size distributions. We found that the presence of the nanoparticles limits coalescence in the metastable domain. We also show that the alkyl-coated nanoparticles are irreversibly attached to the liquid-liquid interface.

Free-Radical Generation from Bulk Nanobubbles in Aqueous Electrolyte Solutions: ESR Spin-Trap Observation of Microbubble-Treated Water

Microbubbles are very fine bubbles that shrink and collapse underwater within several minutes, leading to the generation of free radicals. Electron spin resonance spectroscopy (ESR) confirmed the generation of hydroxyl radicals under strongly acidic conditions. The drastic environmental change caused by the collapse of the microbubbles may trigger radical generation via the dispersion of the elevated chemical potential that had accumulated around the gas-water interface. The present study also confirmed the generation of ESR signals from the microbubble-treated waters even after several months had elapsed following the dispersion of the microbubbles. Bulk nanobubbles were expected to be the source of the spin-adducts of hydroxyl radicals. Such microbubble stabilization and conversion might be caused by the formation of solid microbubble shells generated by iron ions in the condensed ionic cloud around the microbubble. Therefore, the addition of a strong acid might cause drastic changes in the environment and destroy the stabilized condition. This would restart the collapsing process, leading to hydroxyl radical generation.

Effect of Gas Type and Its Pressure on Nanobubble Generation

The dependence of the volume number density of ion-stabilized gas nanobubbles (bubstons) on the type of gas and the pressure created by this gas in deionized water and saline solution has been investigated. The range of external pressures from the saturated water vapor (17 Torr) to 5 atm was studied. It turned out that the growth rate of the volume number density of bubstons is controlled by the magnitude of the molecular polarizability of dissolved gases. The highest densities of bubstons were obtained for gases whose molecules have a dipole moment. At fixed external pressure and the polarizability of gas molecules, the addition of external ions leads to a sharp increase in the content of bubstons.

Diluted Aqueous Dispersed Systems of 4-Aminopyridine: The Relationship of Self-Organization, Physicochemical Properties, and Influence on the Electrical Characteristics of Neurons

A variety of physicochemical methods were used to examine the self-organization, physicochemical, UV absorption, and fluorescent properties of diluted aqueous solutions (calculated concentrations from 1·10-20 to 1·10-2 M) of the membrane voltage-dependent potassium channels blocker 4-aminopyridine (4-AP). Using the dynamic light scattering method, it was shown that 4-AP solutions at concentrations in the range of 1·10-20-1·10-6 M are dispersed systems in which domains and nanoassociates of hundreds of nm in size are formed upon dilution. An interrelation between the non-monotonic concentration dependencies of the size of the dispersed phase, the fluorescence intensity (λ ex 225 nm, λ em 340 nm), specific electrical conductivity, and pH has been established. This allows us to predict the bioeffects of the 4-AP systems at low concentrations. The impact of these diluted aqueous systems on the electrical characteristics of identified neurons of Helix lucorum snails was studied. Incubation of neurons in the 4-AP systems for which the formation of domains and nanoassociates had been established lead to a nonmonotonic decrease of the resting potential by 7-13%. An analysis of the obtained results and published data allows for a conclusion that a consistent change in the nature and parameters of the dispersed phase, as well as the pH of the medium, apparently determines the nonmonotonic nature of the effect of the 4-AP systems in a 1·10-20-1·10-6 M concentration range on the resting membrane potential of neurons. It was found that the pre-incubation of neurons in the 4-AP system with a concentration of 1·10-12 M led to a 17.0% synergistic decrease in the membrane potential after a subsequent treatment with 1·10-2 M 4-AP solution. This finding demonstrates a significant modifying effect of self-organized dispersed systems of 4-AP in low concentrations on the neurons' sensitivity to 4-AP.

Generating Bulk Nanobubbles in Alcohol Systems

Bulk nanobubbles (NBs) have attracted wide attention due to their peculiar physicochemical properties and great potential in applications in various fields. However, so far there are no reports on bulk NBs generated in pure organic systems, which we think is very important as NBs would largely improve the efficiency of gas-liquid mass transfer and facilitate chemical reactions to take place. In this paper, we verified that air and N₂ NBs could be generated in a series of alcohol solutions by using various methods including acoustical cavitation, pressurization-depressurization, and vibration. The experiments proved that NBs existed in alcohol solutions, with a highest density of 5.8 × 10⁷ bubble/mL in propanol. Our results also indicated that bulk NBs could stably exist for at least hours in alcohol systems. The parameters in generating NBs in alcohols were optimized. Our findings open up an opportunity for improving gas-liquid mass transfer efficiency in the field of the chemical industry.

Response to "Comment on Bulk Nanobubbles or Not Nanobubbles: That is the Question"

Advanced techniques that combine high spatial resolution with chemical sensitivity to directly probe the observed nanoentities and provide direct evidence that they are truly gas-filled nanobubbles do not exist. Therefore, in our paper, we focused on providing, for the first time, multiple types of indirect evidence using a variety of physical and chemical techniques that the nanoentities are not due to contamination and, hence, they must be bulk nanobubbles (BNBs). It should be noted that such techniques require good experimental skills, sound protocols, good scientific expertise, and reliable equipment. While no single piece of indirect evidence on its own can be considered as conclusive proof, we estimate that our results combined provide strong evidence that bulk nanobubbles do exist and they are stable. The work presented in our paper is the culmination of a series of studies, and many authors have either directly or indirectly confirmed our findings. Nonetheless, in their Comment, Rak & Sedlak reject all of the work we reported. We here address their comments point by point and show that their criticisms are unwarranted and unfounded, as follows.

Comment on "Bulk Nanobubbles or Not Nanobubbles: That is the Question"

In a recent article, Jadhav and Barigou ( Langmuir 2020, 36 (7), 1699-1708) investigated the question of the existence of stable bulk nanobubbles in water generated by hydrodynamic cavitation, ultrasound cavitation, and the addition of an organic compound (namely, ethanol) to water. They firmly conclude that these procedures result in stable bulk nanobubbles. However, a number of previous works documented that the nanoentities observed in water upon such procedures are not nanobubbles. Here, we analyze work of Jadhav and Barigou and show that conclusions regarding the nanobubble nature of the nanoentities are incorrect and are due to the choice of experimental techniques with weak sensitivity, methodical issues in the use of otherwise proper experimental techniques, and ambiguous outcomes of the rest of experiments.

A Henry's law method for generating bulk nanobubbles

A new technique for generating bulk nanobubble suspensions has been developed based on Henry's law which states that the amount of dissolved gas in a liquid is proportional to its partial pressure above the liquid. This principle which forms the basis of vacuum degasification has been exploited here to produce stable bulk nanobubbles in excess of 10⁹ bubble mL^-1 in pure water, through successive expansion/compression strokes inside a sealed syringe. We provide evidence that the observed nano-entities must be gas-filled nanobubbles by showing that: (i) they cannot be attributed to organic or inorganic impurities; (ii) they disappear gradually over time whilst their mean size remains unchanged; (iii) their number density depends on the concentration of dissolved gas in water and its solubility; and (iv) added sparging of gas enhances process yield. We study the properties of these nanobubbles including the effects of type of dissolved gas, water pH and the presence of different valence salts on their number density and stability. Given the potential of the technique for large scale production of nanobubble suspensions, we describe a successfully tested automated model and outline the basis for process scale-up.

From nano-seggregation to mesophases: probing the liquid structure of perfluoroalkylalkanes with 129Xe NMR spectroscopy

In this work we demonstrate that pure perfluoroalkylalkane diblock molecules are not isotropic liquids and self organize forming domains at the nanometric scale. 129Xe NMR spectra were obtained as a function of temperature for seven liquid perfluoroalkylalkanes, covering a range of relative lengths of the hydrogenated and fluorinated segments. The results support the presence of domains richer in the hydrogenated groups, in which xenon is preferentially dissolved. The average local concentration within the xenon coordination sphere is estimated to be 0.05 mole fraction higher in hydrogenated groups than the stoichiometric proportion. Atomistic molecular dynamics simulations support this analysis and allow a detailed analysis of the liquid structure. Furthermore, 129Xe NMR spectra in perfluorohexylhexane (F6H6) and perfluorohexyloctane (F6H8) obtained as a function of temperature, clearly detect the existence of two distinct environments in the fluid, one richer in hydrogenated groups and another richer in fluorinated groups, consistent with the formation of mesophases. It is important to stress that nano-segregation is this case observed in liquids interacting exclusively through dispersion forces, unlike most common examples of segregation which are determined by hydrogen bonding and polarity. Given the simple molecular structure and interactions of the studied PFAA, we believe that the present results can have a general impact in understanding the early mechanisms of segregation, phase separation and self-assembly.

Surface enrichment of ions leads to the stability of bulk nanobubbles

Numerous experiments have shown that bulk nanobubble suspensions are often characterized by a high magnitude of zeta potential. However, the underlying physical mechanism of how the bulk nanobubbles can stably exist has remained unclear so far. In this paper, based on theoretical analysis, we report a stability mechanism for charged bulk nanobubbles. The strong affinity of negative charges for the nanobubble interface causes charge enrichment, and the resulting electric field energy gives rise to a local minimum for the free energy cost of bubble formation, leading to thermodynamic metastability of the charged nanobubbles. The excess surface charges mechanically generate a size-dependent force, which balances the Laplace pressure and acts as a restoring force when a nanobubble is thermodynamically perturbed away from its equilibrium state. With this negative feedback mechanism, we discuss the nanobubble stability as a function of surface charge and gas supersaturation. We also compare our theoretical prediction with recent experimental observations, and a good agreement is found. This mechanism provides new fundamental insights into the origin of the unexplained stability of bulk nanobubbles.

Proving and interpreting the spontaneous formation of bulk nanobubbles in aqueous organic solvent solutions: effects of solvent type and content

We show that the mixing of organic solvents with pure water leads to the spontaneous formation of suspended nano-entities which exhibit long-term stability on the scale of months. A wide range of solvents representing different functional groups are studied: methanol, ethanol, propanol, acetone, DMSO and formamide. We use various physical and chemical analytical techniques to provide compounded evidence that the nano-entities observed in all these aqueous solvent solutions must be gas-filled nanobubbles as they cannot be attributed to solvent nanodroplets, impurities or contamination. The nanobubble suspensions are characterized in terms of their bubble size distribution, bubble number density and zeta potential. The bubble number density achieved is a function of the type of solvent. It increases sharply with solvent content, reaching a maximum at an intermediate solvent concentration, before falling off to zero. We show that, whilst bulk nanobubbles can exist in pure water, they cannot exist in pure organic solvents and they disappear at some organic solvent-water ratio depending on the type of solvent. The gas solubility of the solvent relative to water as well as the molecular structure of the solvent are determining factors in the formation and stability of bulk nanobubbles. These phenomena are discussed and interpreted in the light of the experimental results obtained.

Bulk Nanobubbles or Not Nanobubbles: That is the Question

Bulk nanobubbles are a novel nanoscale bubble system with unusual properties which challenge our understanding of bubble behavior. Because of their extraordinary longevity, their existence is still not widely accepted as they are often attributed to the presence of supramolecular structures or contaminants. Nonetheless, bulk nanobubbles are attracting increasing attention in the literature, but reports generally lack objective evidence that the observed nano-entities are indeed nanobubbles. In this paper, we use various physical and chemical analytical techniques to provide multiple evidence that the nano-entities produced mechanically in pure water by a continuous high-shear rotor-stator device or acoustic cavitation and spontaneously by water-ethanol mixing are indeed gas-filled domains. We estimate that the results presented here combined provide conclusive proof that bulk nanobubbles do exist and they are stable. This paper should help close the debate about the existence of bulk nanobubbles and, hence, enable the scientific community to rather focus on developing the missing fundamental science in this area.

Diclofenac sodium aqueous systems at low concentrations: Interconnection between physicochemical properties and action on hydrobionts

Diclofenac sodium (DS) is a widely used nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAIDs). NSAIDs are poorly removed during standard wastewater treatment. The consequences of the presence of NSAIDs in rivers and lakes at 10^-11-10^-8 mol/L are not yet established; therefore, ecotoxicologists have focused their efforts on studying the effect of low-concentration NSAIDs on fish and hydrobionts, and also on predicting the potential risks to humans. Literature provides some information about the bioeffects of some NSAID solutions in low concentrations but there is no physicochemical explanation for these phenomena. Studying the physicochemical patterns of DS solutions in the low range of concentrations and establishing an interconnection between the solutions' physicochemical properties and bioeffects can provide a conceptually new and important source of information regarding the unknown effects of DS. The physicochemical properties and action of DS solutions on Ceriodaphnia affinis cladocerans, Paramecium caudatum infusoria, Chlorella vulgaris unicellular green algae, as well as on the growth of the roots of Triticum vulgare wheat seeds, were studied in the calculated concentration range of 1 × 10^-3-1 × 10^-18 mol/L. The relationship between these phenomena was established using the certified procedures for monitoring the toxicity of natural water and wastewater. It was shown for the first time that water solutions of DS are dispersed systems in which the dispersed phase undergoes a rearrangement with dilution, accompanied by changes in its size and properties, which affects the nonmonotonic dependences of the system's physicochemical properties and could cause nonmonotonic changes in action on hydrobionts in the low concentration range.

(Non)Existence of Bulk Nanobubbles: The Role of Ultrasonic Cavitation and Organic Solutes in Water

A drawback of studies on bulk nanobubbles is the absence of direct proof that the nano-objects reported are really nanobubbles. The aim of our work was to provide such a proof or disproof. We focused on two effects (processes) commonly considered in research on nanobubbles: ultrasonic cavitation and addition of organic compounds to water, which could create in principle a barrier at the gas/water interface contributing to the stability of nanobubbles. We found that both of these processes lead to the generation of nano-objects, which are, however, not bulk nanobubbles. Ultrasonication leads to the formation of fine metal nanoparticles originating from the disintegration of the surface of the metal ultrasonic probe. Addition of organic solutes to water leads to the formation of a population of nanoparticles/nanodroplets originating from the so-called mesoscale solubilization of hydrophobic compounds present in the added solute as molecularly dissolved impurities. Subsequent ultrasonication of such mixtures adds metal nanoparticles and only slightly modifies the size distribution of mesoscale particles. While our results do not dismiss existence of nanobubbles in general, described effects must be seriously taken into account, especially in the case of biomedical applications where they can result in serious side effects.

State of Oxygen Molecules in Aqueous Supersaturated Solutions

The state of oxygen in aqueous supersaturated solutions prepared by different methods was studied using high-resolution ultrasonic spectroscopy in combination with other techniques. This allowed for nondestructive evaluation of the properties of oxygen solute particles, composed of oxygen molecules and surrounding (coordinating) molecules of water, at equilibrium, supersaturated conditions, and different temperatures and concentrations of O₂. The results were compared with the behaviors of other types of solutes in water, including H₂O₂, which has similar molecular size and mass to O₂ but is characterized by a significantly different type of interaction with water molecules. Additionally, theoretical modeling was performed to assess the ultrasonic characteristics of dispersions of oxygen nanobubbles stabilized by a surface electrical charge. The obtained data indicate a clathrate-like organization of water in the coordination shells of single molecules of O₂. We did not find any signs of formation of clusters of oxygen molecules in supersaturated solutions. No quantifiable presence of oxygen nanobubbles in the solutions was detected. The state of O₂ molecules was not affected by supersaturation within the analyzed concentration range of oxygen. The results also demonstrated the potential of the ultrasonic technique in precision real-time nondestructive monitoring of oxygen solubilization and outgassing processes.

From nano-emulsions to phase separation: evidence of nano-segregation in (alkane + perfluoroalkane) mixtures using 129Xe NMR Spectroscopy

In this work we demonstrate that mixtures of (hexane + perfluorohexane) above the upper critical solution temperature segregate by forming domains at the nanometric scale. 129Xe NMR spectra obtained for solutions of xenon in liquid mixtures of (hexane + perfluorohexane) as a function of temperature suggest the existence of domains richer in the hydrogenated component, in which xenon "prefers" to be solvated. The average local concentration within the xenon coordination sphere is at least 0.05 higher in hexane mole fraction than the nominal concentration of the mixture. Atomistic molecular dynamics simulations support this analysis in excellent agreement with the experimental data. Additionally, 129Xe NMR spectra in pure perfluoroalkanes allow a detailed analysis of the liquid structure, continuing that previously reported for the liquid alkanes. It should be emphasised that nano-segregation is here observed in fluids governed exclusively by dispersion interactions, in contrast to other examples in which hydrogen bonding and polarity play important roles. Given its simplicity, this case study is thus prone to have a general impact in understanding the early mechanisms of segregation, phase separation and self-assembly.

Bulk Nanobubbles from Acoustically Cavitated Aqueous Organic Solvent Mixtures

We investigate the existence and stability of bulk nanobubbles in various aqueous organic solvent mixtures. Bulk nanobubble suspensions generated via acoustic cavitation are characterized in terms of their bubble size distribution, bubble number density, and zeta potential. We show that bulk nanobubbles exist in pure water but do not exist in pure organic solvents, and they disappear at some organic solvent-water ratio. We monitor the nanobubble suspensions over a period of a few months and propose interpretations for the differences behind their long-term stability in pure water versus their long-term stability in aqueous organic solvent solutions. Bulk nanobubbles in pure water are stabilized by their substantial surface charge arising from the adsorption of hydroxyl ions produced by self-ionization of water. Pure organic solvents do not autoionize, and therefore, nanobubbles cannot exist in concentrated aqueous organic solvent solutions. Because of preferential adsorption of organic solvent molecules at the nanobubble interfaces, the surface charge of the nanobubbles decreases with the solvent content, but the strong hydrogen bonding near their interfaces ensures their stability. The mean bubble size increases monotonically with the solvent content, whereas the surface tension of the mixture is sharply reduced. This is in agreement with literature results on macro- and microbubbles in aqueous organic solutions, but it stands in stark contrast to the behavior of macro- and microbubbles in aqueous surfactant solutions.

Interpreting the interfacial and colloidal stability of bulk nanobubbles

This paper elucidates parts of the mystery behind the interfacial and colloidal stability of the novel bubble system of bulk nanobubbles. Stable bulk nanobubble suspensions have been generated in pure water using hydrodynamic cavitation in a high-pressure microfluidic device. The effects of pH adjustment, addition of different types of surfactant molecules and salts on the nanobubble suspensions have been studied. Results show that nanobubble interfaces in pure water are negatively charged, suggesting the formation of an electric double layer around the nanobubbles. It is presumed that the external electrostatic pressure created by the charged nanobubble interface, balances the internal Laplace pressure; therefore, no net diffusion of gas occurs at equilibrium and the nanobubbles are stable. Such stability increases with increasing alkalinity of the suspending medium. The addition of mono- and multi-valent salts leads to the screening of the electric double layer, hence, destabilizing the nanobubbles. Different surfactant molecules (non-ionic, anionic, cationic) affect the stability of bulk nanobubbles in different ways. Calculations based on the DLVO theory predict a stable colloidal system for bulk nanobubbles in pure water and this could be a further reason for their observed longevity. All in all, in pure water, the long-term stability of bulk nanobubbles seems to be caused by a combination of ion-stabilisation of their interface against dissolution and colloidal stability of the suspension.

On the Existence and Stability of Bulk Nanobubbles

Bulk nanobubbles are a novel type of nanoscale bubble system. Because of their extraordinary behavior, however, their existence is not widely accepted. In this paper, we shed light on the hypothesis that bulk nanobubbles do exist, they are filled with gas, and they survive for long periods of time, challenging present theories. An acoustic cavitation technique has been used to produce bulk nanobubbles in pure water in relatively large numbers approaching 10⁹ bubble·mL^-1 with a typical diameter of 100-120 nm. We provide multiple evidence that the nanoentities observed in suspension are nanobubbles given that they disappear after freezing and thawing of the suspensions, their nucleation rate depends strongly on the amount of air dissolved in water, and they gradually disappear over time. The bulk nanobubble suspensions were stable over periods of many months during which time the mean diameter remained unchanged, suggesting the absence of significant bubble coalescence, bubble breakage, or Ostwald ripening effects. Measurements suggest that these nanobubbles are negatively charged and their zeta potential does not vary over time. The presence of such a constant charge on the nanobubble surfaces is probably responsible for their stability. The effects of pH, salt, and surfactant addition on their colloidal stability are similar to those reported in the literature for solid nanoparticle suspensions, that is, nanobubbles are more stable in an alkaline medium than in an acidic one; the addition of salt to a nanobubble suspension drives the negative zeta potential toward zero, thus reducing the repulsive electrostatic forces between nanobubbles; and the addition of an anionic surfactant increases the magnitude of the negative zeta potential, thus improving nanobubble electrostatic stabilization.

Stable Air Nanobubbles in Water: the Importance of Organic Contaminants

Nanobubbles, surprisingly stable submicrometer gas bubbles in water, appear to be common in water and biological fluids and are of great interest in technical applications ranging from ultrasound contrast agents to flotation in the mining industry. Nanobubbles on surfaces have been more researched than freely floating bulk nanobubbles, and the reason for their stability appears to be better explained. The stability of bulk nanobubbles is less well explained, several theories exist, and even their existence is sometimes questioned. In the present study, an attempt was made to generate nanobubbles through hydrodynamic cavitation as well as through vigorous shaking in test tubes, and it was found that none of these methods generated a detectable concentration of possible bulk nanobubbles if pure water was used, with or without a small addition of NaCl, the equipment was cleaned properly, and certain plastic materials were avoided. These results indicate that trace organic contaminants are necessary for nanobubble stabilization. Experiments were also made with the dissolution of a high concentration of inorganic salts, which generated bubbles by creating air supersaturation. Light scattering submicron particles were found in all solutions and appeared to be actual gas bubbles in at least one case. However, in many cases, these light scattering particles were unaffected by vacuum and pressure and appear, therefore, to be something else other than air bubbles. It is concluded that, in future research on nanobubble stability, it is very important to avoid contamination, as well as to ascertain that light scattering objects really are bubbles and not oil droplets or particles.

Bias and misleading concepts in an Arnica research study. Comments to improve experimental Homeopathy

Basic experimental models in Homeopathy are of major interest because they could get insightful data about the ability of high dilutions to work in a biological system. Due to the extreme difficulty in the highlighting any possible effect and trusting its reliability, methods should be particularly stringent and highly standardized. Confounders, handling process, pre-analytical errors, misleading statistics and misinterpretations may lead to experimental biases. This article tries to elucidate those factors causing bias, taking into account some recent reported evidence in the field.