Tetrahelical Monomolecular Architecture of DNA: A New Building Block for Nanotechnology

Defined folding pattern of poly(rG) supports inherent ability to encode biological information

The RNA World hypothesis posits that RNA can represent a primitive life form by reproducing itself and demonstrating catalytic activity. However, this hypothesis is incapable of addressing several major origin-of-life (OoL) questions. A recently described paradox-free alternative OoL hypothesis, the Quadruplex (G4) World, is based on the ability of poly(dG) to fold into a stable architecture with an unambiguous folding pattern using G-tetrads as building elements. Because of the folding pattern of three G-tetrads and single-G loops, dG15 is programmable and has the capability to encode biological information. Here, we address two open questions of the G4 World hypothesis: (1) Does RNA follow the same folding pattern as DNA? (2) How do stable quadruplexes evolve into the present-day system of information transfer, which is based on Watson-Crick base pair complementarity? To address these questions, we systematically studied the thermodynamic and optical properties of both DNA and RNA G15- and G3T (GGGTGGGTGGGTGGG)-derived sequences. Our study revealed that similar to DNA sequences, RNAs adopt quadruplexes with only three G-tetrads. Thus, both poly(dG) and poly(rG) possess inherent ability to fold into 3D quadruplex architecture with strictly defined folding pattern. The study also revealed that despite high stability of both DNA and RNA quadruplexes, they are vulnerable to single-nucleotide substitutions, which drop the thermal stability by ~40°C and can facilitate introduction of the complementarity principle into the G4 World.

Which came first: the chicken, the egg, or guanine?

The main goal of the origin of life (OoL) hypothesis is to reconstruct the missing link between the primordial soup and the extant biology. However, the OoL itself is just the initial part of the link representing the bootstrapping operation of Darwinian evolution. The rest of the link is the emergence of the evolution to the present day primary biological system-the ribosome-based translation apparatus. A valid hypothesis must (i) not invoke Darwinian evolution in the bootstrapping and (ii) transform the ab initio life form into the translation apparatus without violating the principle of continuity (i.e., only incremental steps without foresight). Currently, no such hypothesis exists. Here, I discuss the Quadruplex World hypothesis, which fully complies with these requirements and suggests a spontaneous emergence of the ab initio life form. The spontaneity of OoL arises from the physicochemical properties of guanine monomers in a manner of causal determinism: each step of the process (i.e., scaffolding, polymerization, and folding) is caused by the most recent past step such that in the end only the specific 3D architecture forms. The architecture (i) has a length-independent folding pattern; (ii) can play the role of the predecessor of tRNA and single-handedly conduct a primitive form of translation; and (iii) can evolve into the extant translation apparatus without any paradoxes.

Trinity of G-tetrads and origin of translation

BACKGROUND

The RNA world hypothesis cannot address most of the questions of the origin of life without violating the continuity principle (small Darwinian steps without foresight and miracles). Moreover, the RNA world is an isolated system incapable of accommodating the genetic code and evolving into extant biochemistry. All these problems are rooted in the central assumption of the hypothesis: de novo appearance of the ribozymes, production of which represents a multistep reaction requiring the complementarity principle. Thus, even the basis of the RNA world is at odds with the continuity principle-it uses foresight (multistep reaction) and a miracle (complementarity principle). Can a three-dimensional (3D) architecture, capable of molecular recognition and catalysis, be formed in a single-step reaction without the complementarity or any other preexisting rules?

HYPOTHESIS

At first glance, the above question sounds rhetoric since the complementarity principle is the essential feature of the RNA world; it turns an RNA polymer into a genetic material. Without it, the RNA world becomes as shapeless and unconvincing as other hypotheses based on the non-hereditary molecules (i.e., protein world). However, it was suggested recently that the quadruplexes could initiate life and take necessary evolutionary steps before the arrival of the complementarity rules. The hypothesis relies on the unique properties of guanines (Gs) to self-assemble into G-tetrads and efficiently polymerize without any external help or preexisting rules. Interestingly, polyG folds into an unusually stable and well-structured monomolecular architecture that uses the quadruplex domain (QD) assembly. The QD has a strictly defined zigzag-like building pattern to accommodate only three G-tetrads. Since both QD architecture and codon length are based on triplets, the inevitable question arises: are they related? Or could QD play the role of the early adapter and determine the codon length? The current paper is an attempt to answer this question.

CONCLUSION

While without translation apparatus most of the steps of the extant translation are physically impossible, the QD-mediated translation is sterically feasible and can be explained by physicochemical properties of the QD and the amino acids without violating the continuity principle. Astonishingly, the quadruplex world hypothesis can address all the shortcomings of the RNA world, including its most significant challenge-step-by-step evolution from the polymerization of the first polynucleotide to the extant biochemistry.

Structure of Tetrahelical DNA Homopolymers Supports Quadruplex World Hypothesis

We previously reported a tetrahelical monomolecular architecture of DNA, tmDNA, which employs G-quartets and an all-parallel GGGTGGGTGGGTGGG (G3T) quadruplex as the repeating unit. Based on thermodynamic and kinetic studies, we proposed that covalently joined (G3T) _n units formed an uninterrupted programmable homopolymer; however, structural evidence for the tmDNA architecture was lacking. Here, we used NMR spectroscopy of wild-type and single-inosine-substituted constructs to characterize both monomolecular (G3T)₂ and bimolecular quadruplex-Mg-coupled versions of tmDNA. The NMR results support an architecture consisting of uninterrupted stacked G-tetrads in both the monomolecular constructs and bimolecular assemblies. Taken together, these data support the formation of a stable programmable homopolymeric tmDNA architecture, which may have been a precursor to the modern-day Watson-Crick DNA duplex.

Quadruplex World

The RNA world hypothesis relies on the double-helix complementarity principle for both replication and catalytic activity of RNA. However, the de novo appearance of the complementarity rules, without previous evolution steps, is doubtful. Another major problem of the RNA world is its isolated nature, making it almost impossible to accommodate the genetic code and transform it into modern biochemistry. These and many other unanswered questions of the RNA world led to suggestions that some simpler molecules must have preceded RNA. Most of these alternative hypotheses proposed the double-helical polymers with different backbones but used the same complementarity principle. The current paper describes a fundamentally different idea: the de novo appearance of a nucleic acid polymer without any preexisting rules or requirements. This approach, coined as the quadruplex world hypothesis, is based on (i) the ability of guanines to form stable G-tetrads that facilitate polymerization; and (ii) the unique property of polyguanines to fold into a monomolecular tetrahelix with a strictly defined building pattern and tertiary structure. The tetrahelix is capable of high-affinity intermolecular interactions and catalytic activities. The quadruplex world hypothesis has the potential to address almost all the shortcomings of the RNA world.

Rational design of guiding elements to control folding topology in i-motifs with multiple quadruplexes

Nucleic acids are versatile scaffolds that accommodate a wide range of precisely defined operational characteristics. Rational design of sensing, molecular computing, nanotechnology, and other nucleic acid devices requires precise control over folding conformations in these macromolecules. Here, we report a new approach that empowers well-defined conformational transitions in DNA molecular devices. Specifically, we develop tools for precise folding of multiple DNA quadruplexes (i-motifs) within the same oligonucleotide strand. To accomplish this task, we modify a DNA strand with kinetic control elements (hairpins and double stranded stems) that fold on a much faster timescale and consequently guide quadruplexes toward the targeted folding topology. To demonstrate that such guiding elements indeed facilitate formation of the targeted folding topology, we thoroughly characterize the folding/unfolding transitions through a combination of thermodynamic techniques, size exclusion chromatography (SEC) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Furthermore, we extend SAXS capabilities to produce a direct insight on the shape and dimensions of the folded quadruplexes by computing their electron density maps from solution scattering data.

Quadruplex-Templated and Catalyzed Ligation of Nucleic Acids

Template-guided chemical reactions between nucleic acid strands are an important process in biomedical research. However, almost all of these reactions employ an oligonucleotide-templated approach that is based on the double-helix alignment. The moderate stability of the double helix makes this approach unsuitable for many chemical reactions, so alternative nucleic acid alignment mechanisms, demonstrating higher thermal and chemical stability, are desirable. Earlier, we described a noncovalent coupling mechanism between DNA strands through a quadruplex-and-Mg²⁺ connection (QMC). QMC is based on G-quadruplexes and allows unusually stable and specific interactions. Herein, a novel catalytic nucleic acid reaction, based on QMC, is described. This approach uses G-tetrads as a structural and recognition element without employing Watson-Crick complementarity rules at any stage of substrate/catalyst formation or interaction between them. Quadruplex-templated ligation can be achieved through the self-ligation of two nucleic acid strands, or through a quadruplex catalyst, which forms a G-triplex and specifically connects the strands. The process is extraordinarily robust and efficient. For instance, the ligation of carbodiimide-activated substrates can proceed in boiling solutions, and complete ligation is demonstrated within a minute. The quadruplex-templated and catalyzed reactions will create new opportunities for chemical reactions requiring harsh experimental conditions.

GC ends control topology of DNA G-quadruplexes and their cation-dependent assembly

GCn and GCnCG, where n = (G2AG4AG2), fold into well-defined, dimeric G-quadruplexes with unprecedented folding topologies in the presence of Na+ ions as revealed by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Both G-quadruplexes exhibit unique combination of structural elements among which are two G-quartets, A(GGGG)A hexad and GCGC-quartet. Detailed structural characterization uncovered the crucial role of 5'-GC ends in formation of GCn and GCnCG G-quadruplexes. Folding in the presence of 15NH4+ and K+ ions leads to 3'-3' stacking of terminal G-quartets of GCn G-quadruplexes, while 3'-GC overhangs in GCnCG prevent dimerization. Results of the present study expand repertoire of possible G-quadruplex structures. This knowledge will be useful in DNA sequence design for nanotechnological applications that may require specific folding topology and multimerization properties.

Structure and Function of Multimeric G-Quadruplexes

G-quadruplexes are noncanonical nucleic acid structures formed from stacked guanine tetrads. They are frequently used as building blocks and functional elements in fields such as synthetic biology and also thought to play widespread biological roles. G-quadruplexes are often studied as monomers, but can also form a variety of higher-order structures. This increases the structural and functional diversity of G-quadruplexes, and recent evidence suggests that it could also be biologically important. In this review, we describe the types of multimeric topologies adopted by G-quadruplexes and highlight what is known about their sequence requirements. We also summarize the limited information available about potential biological roles of multimeric G-quadruplexes and suggest new approaches that could facilitate future studies of these structures.

Stability Factors of the Parallel Quadruplexes: DNA Versus RNA

One of the most stable quadruplexes is formed by the G3T sequence (GGGTGGGTGGGTGGG) that folds into a parallel quadruplex with three G-tetrads and chain-reversal T-loops. For example, in 1 mM K⁺, it unfolds at 75 °C and at physiological conditions, it unfolds above 100 °C. The RNA analogue, ggguggguggguggg (g3u), which employs exactly same folding topology, demonstrates even higher thermal stability. Here, we performed melting experiments of G3T, g3u, and more than 30 chimeric constructs (G3T with RNA nucleotides at certain positions). Although the g3u quadruplex is 13 °C more stable than G3T, majority of G → g (DNA-for-RNA) substitutions destabilize G3T. Only three G → g and loop T → u substitutions stabilize the structure. However, stabilization effects of these six substitutions overcome destabilization of other nine G → g, resulting in higher stability of all-RNA g3u. The present work clearly indicates that the stacking interactions are more favorable in parallel DNA quadruplexes, whereas the chain-reversal loops play an important role in higher stability of RNA quadruplexes. In addition, we have shown that the 5'-end of RNA quadruplexes represents a more favorable target for stacking interactions than the 3'-end. Based on the current study, rational design of the quadruplexes for particular biotechnological applications and drugs, targeting the quadruplexes, may be envisaged.

DNA Quadruple Helices in Nanotechnology

DNA has played an early and powerful role in the development of bottom-up nanotechnologies, not least because of DNA's precise, predictable, and controllable properties of assembly on the nanometer scale. Watson-Crick complementarity has been used to build complex 2D and 3D architectures and design a number of nanometer-scale systems for molecular computing, transport, motors, and biosensing applications. Most of such devices are built with classical B-DNA helices and involve classical A-T/U and G-C base pairs. However, in addition to the above components underlying the iconic double helix, a number of alternative pairing schemes of nucleobases are known. This review focuses on two of these noncanonical classes of DNA helices: G-quadruplexes and the i-motif. The unique properties of these two classes of DNA helix have been utilized toward some remarkable constructions and applications: G-wires; nanostructures such as DNA origami; reconfigurable structures and nanodevices; the formation and utilization of hemin-utilizing DNAzymes, capable of generating varied outputs from biosensing nanostructures; composite nanostructures made up of DNA as well as inorganic materials; and the construction of nanocarriers that show promise for the therapeutics of diseases.

Monomolecular tetrahelix of polyguanine with a strictly defined folding pattern

The G₃TG₃TG₃TG₃ (G3T) sequence folds into a monomolecular quadruplex with all-parallel G₃ segments connected to each other by chain-reversal loops. The homopolymer consisting of n number of G3T domains directly conjugated to each other folds into an uninterrupted and unusually stable polymer, tetrahelical monomolecular DNA (tmDNA). It was demonstrated that the tmDNA architecture has strong potential in nanotechnologies as highly programmable building material, high affinity coupler and the driving force for endergonic reactions. Here, we explore capability of analogous DNA sequences (i.e., monomolecular quadruplexes with G₂ or G₄ segments) to construct tmDNA architecture. The study demonstrates that tmDNA can have only one building pattern based on a quadruplex domain with three G-tetrads and single-nucleotide loops, G3N (N = G, A, C and T); all other domains demonstrate antiparallel topologies unsuitable for tmDNA. The present study also suggests that polyguanine is capable of tmDNA formation with strictly defined building pattern; G₃ segments connected to each other by chain-reversal G-loops. These findings can have significant impact on (i) DNA nanotechnologies; (ii) structure prediction of G-rich sequences of genome; and (iii) modeling of abiogenesis.

Stable Domain Assembly of a Monomolecular DNA Quadruplex: Implications for DNA-Based Nanoswitches

In the presence of K⁺ ions, the 5′-GGGTGGGTGGGTGGG-3′ (G3T) sequence folds into a monomolecular quadruplex with unusually high thermal stability and unique optical properties. In this study we report that although single G3T molecules unfold and fold rapidly with overlapping melting and refolding curves, G3T multimers (G3T units covalently attached to each other) demonstrate highly reproducible hysteretic behavior. We demonstrate that this behavior necessitates full-length tandem G3T monomers directly conjugated to each other. Any modification of the tandem sequences eliminates the hysteresis. The experimentally measured kinetic parameters and equilibrium transition profiles suggest a highly specific two-state transition in which the folding and unfolding of the first G3T monomer is rate-limiting for both annealing and melting processes. The highly reproducible hysteretic behavior of G3T multimers has the potential to be used in the design of heat-stimulated DNA switches or transistors.

Assembly of supramolecular DNA complexes containing both G-quadruplexes and i-motifs by enhancing the G-repeat-bearing capacity of i-motifs

The single-step assembly of supramolecular complexes containing both i-motifs and G-quadruplexes (G4s) is demonstrated. This can be achieved because the formation of four-stranded i-motifs appears to be little affected by certain terminal residues: a five-cytosine tetrameric i-motif can bear ten-base flanking residues. However, things become complex when different lengths of guanine-repeats are added at the 3′ or 5′ ends of the cytosine-repeats. Here, a series of oligomers d(XG_iXC₅X) and d(XC₅XG_iX) (X = A, T or none; i < 5) are designed to study the impact of G-repeats on the formation of tetrameric i-motifs. Our data demonstrate that tetramolecular i-motif structure can tolerate specific flanking G-repeats. Assemblies of these oligonucleotides are polymorphic, but may be controlled by solution pH and counter ion species. Importantly, we find that the sequences d(TG_iAC₅) can form the tetrameric i-motif in large quantities. This leads to the design of two oligonucleotides d(TG₄AC₇) and d(TG^BrGG^BrGAC₇) that self-assemble to form quadruplex supramolecules under certain conditions. d(TG₄AC₇) forms supramolecules under acidic conditions in the presence of K⁺ that are mainly V-shaped or ring-like containing parallel G4s and antiparallel i-motifs. d(TG^BrGG^BrGAC₇) forms long linear quadruplex wires under acidic conditions in the presence of Na⁺ that consist of both antiparallel G4s and i-motifs.

Quadruplex-and-Mg(2+) Connection (QMC) of DNA

This work highlights a novel method of coupling of nucleic acids through formation of an extraordinary stable, specific and fully reversible quadruplex-and-Mg(2+) connection (QMC). QMC employs the monomolecular tetrahelical architecture of DNA and has two key components: (i) shape complementarity between QMC partners, which is introduced by specific modifications of the quadruplexes, and (ii) Mg(2+) ions. The on-rate of QMC formation is between 10(5)-10(6) M(-1) s(-1), while the off-rate is undetectable even at 80 °C. However, QMC dissociates rapidly upon removal of Mg(2+) ions (i.e., by EDTA). QMC is characterized by high specificity, as even a single-nucleotide modification of one of the connectors inhibits complex-formation. QMC has the potential to revolutionize biotechnology by introducing a new class of capture molecules with major advantages over traditional systems such as streptavidin-biotin. The advantages include reversibility, multiplexing, higher stability and specificity, longer shelf life and low cost.