In Situ Scanning Tunneling Microscopy of a Redox Molecule as a Vibrationally Coherent Electronic Three-Level Process

Generic dynamic molecular devices by quantitative non-steady-state proton/water-coupled electron transport kinetics

Dynamic molecular devices operating with time- and history-dependent performance raised new challenges for the fundamental study of microscopic non-steady-state charge transport as well as functionalities that are not achievable by steady-state devices. In this study, we reported a generic dynamic mode of molecular devices by addressing the transient redox state of ubiquitous quinone molecules in the junction by proton/water transfer. The diffusion limited slow proton/water transfer-modulated fast electron transport, leading to a non-steady-state transport process, as manifested by the negative differential resistance, dynamic hysteresis, and memory-like behavior. A quantitative paradigm for the study of the non-steady-state charge transport kinetics was further developed by combining the theoretical model and transient state characterization, and the principle of the dynamic device can be revealed by the numerical simulator. On applying pulse stimulation, the dynamic device emulated the neuron synaptic response with frequency-dependent depression and facilitation, implying a great potential for future nonlinear and brain-inspired devices.

Transition from stochastic events to deterministic ensemble average in electron transfer reactions revealed by single-molecule conductance measurement

Electron transfer reactions can now be followed at the single-molecule level, but the connection between the microscopic and macroscopic data remains to be understood. By monitoring the conductance of a single molecule, we show that the individual electron transfer reaction events are stochastic and manifested as large conductance fluctuations. The fluctuation probability follows first-order kinetics with potential dependent rate constants described by the Butler-Volmer relation. Ensemble averaging of many individual reaction events leads to a deterministic dependence of the conductance on the external electrochemical potential that follows the Nernst equation. This study discloses a systematic transition from stochastic kinetics of individual reaction events to deterministic thermodynamics of ensemble averages and provides insights into electron transfer processes of small systems, consisting of a single molecule or a small number of molecules.

Bias-induced conductance switching in single molecule junctions containing a redox-active transition metal complex

ABSTRACT

The paper provides a comprehensive theoretical description of electron transport through transition metal complexes in single molecule junctions, where the main focus is on an analysis of the structural parameters responsible for bias-induced conductance switching as found in recent experiments, where an interpretation was provided by our simulations. The switching could be theoretically explained by a two-channel model combining coherent electron transport and electron hopping, where the underlying mechanism could be identified as a charging of the molecule in the junction made possible by the presence of a localized electronic state on the transition metal center. In this article, we present a framework for the description of an electron hopping-based switching process within the semi-classical Marcus-Hush theory, where all relevant quantities are calculated on the basis of density functional theory (DFT). Additionally, structural aspects of the junction and their respective importance for the occurrence of irreversible switching are discussed.

GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT

Force modulation and electrochemical gating of conductance in a cytochrome

Scanning probe methods have been used to measure the effect of electrochemical potential and applied force on the tunnelling conductance of the redox metalloprotein yeast iso-1-cytochrome c (YCC) at a molecular level. The interaction of a proximal probe with any sample under test will, at this scale, be inherently perturbative. This is demonstrated with conductive probe atomic force microscopy (CP-AFM) current-voltage spectroscopy in which YCC, chemically adsorbed onto pristine Au(111) via its surface cysteine residue, is observed to become increasingly compressed as applied load is increased, with concomitant decrease in junction resistance. Electrical contact at minimal perturbation, where probe-molecule coupling is comparable to that in scanning tunnelling microscopy, brings with it the observation of negative differential resistance, assigned to redox-assisted probe-substrate tunnelling. The role of the redox centre in conductance is also resolved in electrochemical scanning tunnelling microscopy assays where molecular conductance is electrochemically gateable through more than an order of magnitude.

Electric double layer effect on observable characteristics of the tunnel current through a bridged electrochemical contact

Scanning tunneling microscopy and electrical conductivity of redox molecules in conducting media (aqueous or other media) acquire increasing importance both as novel single-molecule science and with a view on molecular scale functional elements. Such configurations require full and independent electrochemical potential control of both electrodes involved. We provide here a general formalism for the electric current through a redox group in an electrochemical tunnel contact. The formalism applies broadly in the limits of both weak and strong coupling of the redox group with the enclosing metal electrodes. Simple approximate expressions better suited for experimental data analysis are also derived. Particular attention is given to the effects of the Debye screening of the electric potential in the narrow tunneling gap based on the limit of the linearized Poisson-Boltzmann equation. The current/overpotential relation shows a maximum at a position which depends on the ionic strength. It is shown, in particular, that the dependence of the maximum position on the bias voltage may be nonmonotonous. Approximate expressions for the limiting value of the slope of the current/overpotential dependence and the width of the maximum on the bias voltage are also given and found to depend strongly on both the Debye screening and the position of the redox group in the tunnel gap, with diagnostic value in experimental data analysis.

Negative differential resistance and switching behavior of redox-mediated tunnel contact

Theoretical description of various properties of redox-mediated tunnel contacts is presented. The dependences of the current on the overpotential and bias voltage under the sweeping voltammetry conditions are addressed. The effect of switching between two redox states on the shape of current/voltage characteristics is discussed. The shot noise and telegraph noise of the bridged contacts involving redox group are considered. Functional properties of the contact as a means for the information processing are discussed.

Electronic coupling between azurin and gold at different protein/substrate orientations

By means of constrained classical molecular dynamics simulations, we have computed the structure of azurin deposited on a Au(111) surface at different possible orientations and the azimuthal forces acting on the protein at each sampled conformation. We have then evaluated the effect of the angular variation on the speed of electron tunneling between the protein redox site and the metal surface. We find that the azurin/gold electronic coupling has a strong dependence on the molecular orientation and is greatly enhanced by inclining the protein to lie as flat as possible on the surface. We discuss the implications of our results for scanning probe microscopy experiments in which tunneling currents are measured while the protein is subjected to mechanical forces exerted by the tip of the instrument.

The reorganization energy of azurin in bulk solution and in the electrochemical scanning tunneling microscopy setup

The total reorganization energy lambda of azurin is theoretically studied both for the electron self-exchange reaction and for the protein in the electrochemical scanning tunneling microscopy (ECSTM) setup. The results demonstrate the importance of the proximity between the active sites in the encounter complex to reduce lambda for the electron self-exchange reaction and quantifies the effects of the presence of an STM environment (tip and substrate) on lambda. A comparison of the calculated results with experimental data is performed, and the relative magnitudes of the inner and outer contributions to lambda are discussed.

Electrochemical Origin of Voltage-Controlled Molecular Conductance Switching

We have studied electron transport in bipyridyl-dinitro oligophenylene-ethynelene dithiol (BPDN) molecules both in an inert environment and in aqueous electrolyte under potential control, using scanning tunneling microscopy. Current-voltage (IV) data obtained in an inert environment were similar to previously reported results showing conductance switching near 1.6 V. Similar measurements taken in electrolyte under potential control showed a linear dependence of the bias for switching on the electrochemical potential. Extrapolation of the potentials to zero switching bias coincided with the potentials of redox processes on these molecules. Thus switching is caused by a change in the oxidation state of the molecules.

Unravelling single metalloprotein electron transfer by scanning probe techniques

This review is intended to account for the experimental and theoretical achievements obtained in a period of about 15 years on the investigation of the electron transport through single redox metalloproteins by scanning probe techniques. A highly focussed research effort has been deployed by the scientists active in this particular field towards measuring and interpreting electronic current signals flowing via blue copper, redox metalloproteins (e.g. azurin). The field has taken a remarkable advantage of the use of electrochemically assisted scanning tunnelling microscope (EC-STM) which has allowed to probe single molecule signals under full control of all the potential values involved in the experiments. This experimental activity has both triggered more comprehensive theoretical interpretations and has been, in its turn, stimulated by theoreticians to test always new predictions. The authors hope to have succeeded in providing the reader with a valuable appraisal of this fascinating field.

Long-range interfacial electron transfer of metalloproteins based on molecular wiring assemblies

We address some physical features associated with long-range interfacial electron transfer (ET) of metalloproteins in both electrochemical and electrochemical scanning tunneling microscopy (ECSTM) configurations, which offer a brief foundation for understanding of the ET mechanisms. These features are illustrated experimentally by new developments of two systems with the blue copper protein azurin and enzyme nitrite reductase as model metalloproteins. Azurin and nitrite reductase were assembled on Au(111) surfaces by molecular wiring to establish effective electronic coupling between the redox centers in the proteins and the electrode surface for ET and biological electrocatalysis. With such assemblies, interfacial ET proceeds through chemically defined and well oriented sites and parallels biological ET. In the case of azurin, the ET properties can be characterized comprehensively and even down to the single-molecule level with direct observation of redox-gated electron tunnelling resonance. Molecular wiring using a pi-conjugated thiol is suitable for assembling monolayers of the enzyme with catalytic activity well-retained. The catalytic mechanism involves multiple-ET steps including both intramolecular and interfacial processes. Interestingly, ET appears to exhibit a substrate-gated pattern observed preliminarily in both voltammetry and ECSTM.

Long-range protein electron transfer observed at the single-molecule level: In situ mapping of redox-gated tunneling resonance

A biomimetic long-range electron transfer (ET) system consisting of the blue copper protein azurin, a tunneling barrier bridge, and a gold single-crystal electrode was designed on the basis of molecular wiring self-assembly principles. This system is sufficiently stable and sensitive in a quasi-biological environment, suitable for detailed observations of long-range protein interfacial ET at the nanoscale and single-molecule levels. Because azurin is located at clearly identifiable fixed sites in well controlled orientation, the ET configuration parallels biological ET. The ET is nonadiabatic, and the rate constants display tunneling features with distance-decay factors of 0.83 and 0.91 A(-1) in H(2)O and D(2)O, respectively. Redox-gated tunneling resonance is observed in situ at the single-molecule level by using electrochemical scanning tunneling microscopy, exhibiting an asymmetric dependence on the redox potential. Maximum resonance appears around the equilibrium redox potential of azurin with an on/off current ratio of approximately 9. Simulation analyses, based on a two-step interfacial ET model for the scanning tunneling microscopy redox process, were performed and provide quantitative information for rational understanding of the ET mechanism.

Protein dynamics and electron transfer: electronic decoherence and non-Condon effects

We compute the autocorrelation function of the donor-acceptor tunneling matrix element <T(DA)(t)T(DA)(0)> for six Ru-azurin derivatives. Comparison of this decay time to the decay time of the time-dependent Franck-Condon factor {computed by Rossky and coworkers [Lockwood, D. M., Cheng, Y.-K. & Rossky, P. J. (2001) Chem. Phys. Lett. 345, 159-165]} reveals the extent to which non-Condon effects influence the electron-transfer rate. <T(DA)(t)T(DA)(0)> is studied as a function of donor-acceptor distance, tunneling pathway structure, tunneling energy, and temperature to explore the structural and dynamical origins of non-Condon effects. For azurin, the correlation function is remarkably insensitive to tunneling pathway structure. The decay time is only slightly shorter than it is for solvent-mediated electron transfer in small organic molecules and originates, largely, from fluctuations of valence angles rather than bond lengths.

A protein-based three terminal electronic device

Because of their natural functional characteristics, involving inter- and intramolecular electron transfer, metalloproteins are good candidates for biomolecular nanoelectronics. In particular, blue copper proteins, such as azurin, can bind gold via a disulfide site present on its surface and they have a natural electron transfer activity that can be exploited for the realization of molecular switches whose conduction state can be controlled by tuning their redox state through an external voltage source. We report on the implementation of a prototype of protein transistor operating in air and in the solid state, based on this class of proteins. The three terminal devices exhibit various functions depending on the relative source-drain and gate-drain voltages bias, opening a way to the implementation of a new generation of logic architectures.

Molecular bioelectronics

Biological macromolecules have evolved over many millions of years into structures primed, in some cases, for both specific surface recognition and facile, directional electron tunnelling. The redox-active centres of metalloproteins play a central role in photosynthesis and respiration. The processes by which constructive man-made interfaces to these moieties can be generated have advanced greatly during the past two decades or so. Together with recent advances in molecular manipulation, analyses and lithographic fabrication, this knowledge has led to us to the point where bioelectronic devices can be designed and interrogated with good levels of reproducibility.

Monolayer assemblies of a de novo designed 4-alpha-helix bundle carboprotein and its sulfur anchor fragment on Au(111) surfaces addressed by voltammetry and in situ scanning tunneling microscopy

Mapping and control of proteins and oligonucleotides on metallic and nonmetallic surfaces are important in many respects. Electrochemical techniques based on single-crystal electrodes and scanning probe microscopies directly in aqueous solution (in situ SPM) have recently opened perspectives for such mapping at a resolution that approaches the single-molecule level. De novo design of model proteins has evolved in parallel and holds promise for testing and controlling protein folding and for new tailored protein structural motifs. In this report we combine these two strategies. We present a scheme for the synthesis of a new 4-alpha-helix bundle carboprotein built on a galactopyranoside derivative with a thiol anchor aglycon suitable for surface immobilization on gold. The carboprotein with thiol anchor in monomeric and dimeric (disulfide) form, the thiol anchor alone, and a sulfur-free 4-alpha-helix bundle carboprotein without thiol anchor have been prepared and investigated for comparison. Cyclic and differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) of the proteins show desorption peaks around -750 mV (SCE), whereas the thiol anchor desorption peak is at -685 mV. The peaks are by far the highest for thiol monomeric 4-alpha-helix bundle carboprotein and the thiol anchor. This pattern is supported by capacitance data. The DPV and capacitance data for the thiolated 4-alpha-helix bundle carboproteins and the thiol anchor hold a strong Faradaic reductive desorption component as supported by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. The desorption peak of the sulfur-free 4-alpha-helix bundle carboprotein, however, also points to a capacitive component. In situ scanning tunneling microscopy (in situ STM) of the thiol anchor discloses an adlayer with small domains and single molecules ordered in pin-striped supramolecular structures. In situ STM of thiolated 4-alpha-helix bundle carboprotein monomer shows a dense monolayer in a broad potential range on the positive side of the desorption potential. The coverage decreases close to this potential and single-molecule structures become apparent. The in situ STM contrast is also strengthened, indicative of a new redox-based tunneling mechanism. The data overall suggest that single-molecule mapping of natural and synthetic proteins on well-characterized surfaces by electrochemistry and in situ STM is within reach.

An approach to long-range electron transfer mechanisms in metalloproteins: in situ scanning tunneling microscopy with submolecular resolution

In situ scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) of redox molecules, in aqueous solution, shows interesting analogies and differences compared with interfacial electrochemical electron transfer (ET) and ET in homogeneous solution. This is because the redox level represents a deep indentation in the tunnel barrier, with possible temporary electronic population. Particular perspectives are that both the bias voltage and the overvoltage relative to a reference electrode can be controlled, reflected in spectroscopic features when the potential variation brings the redox level to cross the Fermi levels of the substrate and tip. The blue copper protein azurin adsorbs on gold(111) via a surface disulfide group. Well resolved in situ STM images show arrays of molecules on the triangular gold(111) terraces. This points to the feasibility of in situ STM of redox metalloproteins directly in their natural aqueous medium. Each structure also shows a central brighter contrast in the constant current mode, indicative of 2- to 4-fold current enhancement compared with the peripheral parts. This supports the notion of tunneling via the redox level of the copper atom and of in situ STM as a new approach to long-range electron tunneling in metalloproteins.