RNA under tension: Folding Landscapes, Kinetic partitioning Mechanism, and Molecular Tensegrity

Key criteria for engineering mycotoxin binding aptamers via computational simulations: Aflatoxin B1 as a case study

Due to the difficulties in monoclonal antibody production specific to mycotoxins, aptameric probes have been considered as suitable alternatives. The low efficiency of the SELEX procedure in screening high affinity aptamers for binding mycotoxins as small molecules can be significantly improved through computational techniques. Previously, we designed five new aptamers to aflatoxin B₁ (AFB1) based on a known aptamer sequence (Patent: PCT/CA2010/001 292, Apt1) through a genetic algorithm-based in silico maturation strategy and experimentally measured their affinity to the target toxin. Here, integrated molecular dynamic simulation (MDs) studies with molecular mechanics Poisson-Boltzmann surface area (MM-PBSA) analysis to clarify the binding modes, critical interacting nucleic bases and energy component contributions in the six AFB1-binding aptamers. The aptamer F20, which was selected in the first work, showed the best free binding energy and complex stability compared to other aptamers. The trajectory analysis revealed that AFB1 recognized F20 through the groove binding mode along with precise shape complementarity. The MD simulation results revealed that dynamic water intermediate interactions also play a key role in promoting complex stability. According to the MM-PBSA calculations, van der Waals contacts were identified as dominant energy components in all complexes. Interestingly, a high consistency is observed between the experimentally obtained binding affinities of the six aptamers with their free energy solvation. The computational findings, confirmed via previous experiments, highlighted the binding modes, the dynamic hydration of complex components and the total free interacting energy as the crucial criteria in discovering high functional aptameric probes.

Regulation of the ThiM riboswitch is facilitated by the trapped structure formed during transcription of the wild-type sequence

The ThiM riboswitch from Escherichia coli is a typical mRNA device that modulates downstream gene expression by sensing TPP. The helix-based RNA folding theory is used to investigate its detailed regulatory behaviors in cells. This RNA molecule is transcriptionally trapped in a state with the unstructured SD sequence in the absence of TPP, which induces downstream gene expression. As a key step to turn on gene expression, formation of this trapped state (the genetic ON state) highly depends on the co-transcriptional folding of its wild-type sequence. Instead of stabilities of the genetic ON and OFF states, the transcription rate, pause, and ligand levels are combined to affect the ThiM riboswitch-mediated gene regulation, which is consistent with a kinetic control model.

Modeling the structure of the frameshift-stimulatory pseudoknot in SARS-CoV-2 reveals multiple possible conformers

The coronavirus causing the COVID-19 pandemic, SARS-CoV-2, uses -1 programmed ribosomal frameshifting (-1 PRF) to control the relative expression of viral proteins. As modulating -1 PRF can inhibit viral replication, the RNA pseudoknot stimulating -1 PRF may be a fruitful target for therapeutics treating COVID-19. We modeled the unusual 3-stem structure of the stimulatory pseudoknot of SARS-CoV-2 computationally, using multiple blind structural prediction tools followed by μs-long molecular dynamics simulations. The results were compared for consistency with nuclease-protection assays and single-molecule force spectroscopy measurements of the SARS-CoV-1 pseudoknot, to determine the most likely conformations. We found several possible conformations for the SARS-CoV-2 pseudoknot, all having an extended stem 3 but with different packing of stems 1 and 2. Several conformations featured rarely-seen threading of a single strand through junctions formed between two helices. These structural models may help interpret future experiments and support efforts to discover ligands inhibiting -1 PRF in SARS-CoV-2.

Molecular dynamics study of ways of RNA base-pair formation

Base pairing is a fundamental phenomenon in RNA structure and function. However, although there have been considerable recent advances, some important aspects of base-pair formation are still unknown, including the ways of base-pair formation and detailed roles of metal ions. Here we show that base pairs can form through four different ways: stabilizing, bridging, rotating, and shifting. Among them the stabilizing and bridging ways involve direct binding of metal ions while the rotating and shifting ways do not in most cases. Furthermore, we find that the formations of base pairs in different positions of the hairpin stem may adopt different ways.

Single-Molecule Mechanical Folding and Unfolding of RNA Hairpins: Effects of Single A-U to A·C Pair Substitutions and Single Proton Binding and Implications for mRNA Structure-Induced -1 Ribosomal Frameshifting

A wobble A·C pair can be protonated at near physiological pH to form a more stable wobble A⁺·C pair. Here, we constructed an RNA hairpin (rHP) and three mutants with one A-U base pair substituted with an A·C mismatch on the top (near the loop, U22C), middle (U25C), and bottom (U29C) positions of the stem, respectively. Our results on single-molecule mechanical (un)folding using optical tweezers reveal the destabilization effect of A-U to A·C pair substitution and protonation-dependent enhancement of mechanical stability facilitated through an increased folding rate, or decreased unfolding rate, or both. Our data show that protonation may occur rapidly upon the formation of an apparent mechanical folding transition state. Furthermore, we measured the bulk -1 ribosomal frameshifting efficiencies of the hairpins by a cell-free translation assay. For the mRNA hairpins studied, -1 frameshifting efficiency correlates with mechanical unfolding force at equilibrium and folding rate at around 15 pN. U29C has a frameshifting efficiency similar to that of rHP (∼2%). Accordingly, the bottom 2-4 base pairs of U29C may not form under a stretching force at pH 7.3, which is consistent with the fact that the bottom base pairs of the hairpins may be disrupted by ribosome at the slippery site. U22C and U25C have a similar frameshifting efficiency (∼1%), indicating that both unfolding and folding rates of an mRNA hairpin in a crowded environment may affect frameshifting. Our data indicate that mechanical (un)folding of RNA hairpins may mimic how mRNAs unfold and fold in the presence of translating ribosomes.

Ensemble simulations: folding, unfolding and misfolding of a high-efficiency frameshifting RNA pseudoknot

Massive all-atom molecular dynamics simulations were conducted across a distributed computing network to study the folding, unfolding, misfolding and conformational plasticity of the high-efficiency frameshifting double mutant of the 26 nt potato leaf roll virus RNA pseudoknot. Our robust sampling, which included over 40 starting structures spanning the spectrum from the extended unfolded state to the native fold, yielded nearly 120 μs of cumulative sampling time. Conformational microstate transitions on the 1.0 ns to 10.0 μs timescales were observed, with post-equilibration sampling providing detailed representations of the conformational free energy landscape and the complex folding mechanism inherent to the pseudoknot motif. Herein, we identify and characterize two alternative native structures, three intermediate states, and numerous misfolded states, the latter of which have not previously been characterized via atomistic simulation techniques. While in line with previous thermodynamics-based models of a general RNA folding mechanism, our observations indicate that stem-strand-sequence-separation may serve as an alternative predictor of the order of stem formation during pseudoknot folding. Our results contradict a model of frameshifting based on structural rigidity and resistance to mechanical unfolding, and instead strongly support more recent studies in which conformational plasticity is identified as a determining factor in frameshifting efficiency.

Ligand-Induced Stabilization of a Duplex-like Architecture Is Crucial for the Switching Mechanism of the SAM-III Riboswitch

Riboswitches are structured RNA motifs that control gene expression by sensing the concentrations of specific metabolites and make up a promising new class of antibiotic targets. S-Adenosylmethionine (SAM)-III riboswitch, mainly found in lactic acid bacteria, is involved in regulating methionine and SAM biosynthetic pathways. SAM-III riboswitch regulates the gene expression by switching the translation process on and off with respect to the absence and presence of the SAM ligand, respectively. In this study, an attempt is made to understand the key conformational transitions involved in ligand binding using atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations performed in an explicit solvent environment. G26 is found to recognize the SAM ligand by forming hydrogen bonds, whereas the absence of the ligand leads to opening of the binding pocket. Consistent with experimental results, the absence of the SAM ligand weakens the base pairing interactions between the nucleobases that are part of the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) and anti-Shine-Dalgarno (aSD) sequences, which in turn facilitates recognition of the SD sequence by ribosomes. Detailed analysis reveals that a duplex-like structure formed by nucleotides from different parts of the RNA and the adenine base of the ligand is crucial for the stability of the completely folded state in the presence of the ligand. Previous experimental studies have shown that the SAM-III riboswitch exists in equilibrium between the unfolded and partially folded states in the absence of the ligand, which completely folds upon binding of the ligand. Comparison of the results presented here to the available experimental data indicates the structures obtained using the MD simulations resemble the partially folded state. Thus, this study provides a detailed understanding of the fully and partially folded structures of the SAM-III riboswitch in the presence and absence of the ligand, respectively. This study hypothesizes a dual role for the SAM ligand, which facilitates conformational switching between partially and fully folded states by forming a stable duplex-like structure and strengthening the interactions between SD and aSD nucleotides.

Nonlinear irreversible thermodynamics of single-molecule experiments

Irreversible thermodynamics of single-molecule experiments subject to external constraining forces of a mechanical nature is presented. Extending Onsager's formalism to the nonlinear case of systems under nonequilibrium external constraints, we are able to calculate the entropy production and the general nonlinear kinetic equations for the variables involved. In particular, we analyze the case of RNA stretching protocols obtaining critical oscillations between different configurational states when forced by external means to remain in the unstable region of its free-energy landscape, as observed in experiments. We also calculate the entropy produced during these hopping events and show how resonant phenomena in stretching experiments of single RNA macromolecules may arise. We also calculate the hopping rates using Kramer's approach obtaining a good comparison with experiments.

Reconstructing folding energy landscapes by single-molecule force spectroscopy

Folding may be described conceptually in terms of trajectories over a landscape of free energies corresponding to different molecular configurations. In practice, energy landscapes can be difficult to measure. Single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS), whereby structural changes are monitored in molecules subjected to controlled forces, has emerged as a powerful tool for probing energy landscapes. We summarize methods for reconstructing landscapes from force spectroscopy measurements under both equilibrium and nonequilibrium conditions. Other complementary, but technically less demanding, methods provide a model-dependent characterization of key features of the landscape. Once reconstructed, energy landscapes can be used to study critical folding parameters, such as the characteristic transition times required for structural changes and the effective diffusion coefficient setting the timescale for motions over the landscape. We also discuss issues that complicate measurement and interpretation, including the possibility of multiple states or pathways and the effects of projecting multiple dimensions onto a single coordinate.

Sequence-dependent folding landscapes of adenine riboswitch aptamers

Expression of a large fraction of genes in bacteria is controlled by riboswitches, which are found in the untranslated region of mRNA. Structurally riboswitches have a conserved aptamer domain to which a metabolite binds, resulting in a conformational change in the downstream expression platform. Prediction of the functions of riboswitches requires a quantitative description of the folding landscape so that the barriers and time scales for the conformational change in the switching region in the aptamer can be estimated. Using a combination of all atom molecular dynamics (MD) and coarse-grained model simulations we studied the response of adenine (A) binding add and pbuE A-riboswitches to mechanical force. The two riboswitches contain a structurally similar three-way junction formed by three paired helices, P1, P2, and P3, but carry out different functions. Using pulling simulations, with structures generated in MD simulations, we show that after P1 rips the dominant unfolding pathway in the add A-riboswitch is the rupture of P2 followed by unraveling of P3. In the pbuE A-riboswitch, after P1 unfolds P3 ruptures ahead of P2. The order of unfolding of the helices, which is in accord with single molecule pulling experiments, is determined by the relative stabilities of the individual helices. Our results show that the stability of isolated helices determines the order of assembly and response to force in these non-coding regions. We use the simulated free energy profile for the pbuE A-riboswitch to estimate the time scale for allosteric switching, which shows that this riboswitch is under kinetic control lending additional support to the conclusion based on single molecule pulling experiments. A consequence of the stability hypothesis is that a single point mutation (U28C) in the P2 helix of the add A-riboswitch, which increases the stability of P2, would make the folding landscapes of the two riboswitches similar. This prediction can be tested in single molecule pulling experiments.

Stretching single polymer chains of donor-acceptor foldamers: toward the quantitative study on the extent of folding

Single-molecule force spectroscopy has proven to be an efficient tool for the quantitative characterization of flexible foldamers on the single-molecule level in this study. The extent of folding has been estimated quantitatively for the first time to the best of our knowledge, which is crucial for a better understanding of the "folding-process" on single-molecule level. Therefore, this study may provide a guidance to regulate folding for realizing rational control over the functions of bulk materials.

Ligand-induced stabilization of the aptamer terminal helix in the add adenine riboswitch

Riboswitches are structured mRNA elements that modulate gene expression. They undergo conformational changes triggered by highly specific interactions with sensed metabolites. Among the structural rearrangements engaged by riboswitches, the forming and melting of the aptamer terminal helix, the so-called P1 stem, is essential for genetic control. The structural mechanisms by which this conformational change is modulated upon ligand binding mostly remain to be elucidated. Here, we used pulling molecular dynamics simulations to study the thermodynamics of the P1 stem in the add adenine riboswitch. The P1 ligand-dependent stabilization was quantified in terms of free energy and compared with thermodynamic data. This comparison suggests a model for the aptamer folding in which direct P1-ligand interactions play a minor role on the conformational switch when compared with those related to the ligand-induced aptamer preorganization.

Kinetics of allosteric transitions in S-adenosylmethionine riboswitch are accurately predicted from the folding landscape

Riboswitches are RNA elements that allosterically regulate gene expression by binding cellular metabolites. The SAM-III riboswitch, one of several classes that binds S-adenosylmethionine (SAM), represses translation upon binding SAM (OFF state) by encrypting the ribosome binding sequence. We have carried out simulations of the RNA by applying mechanical force (f) to the ends of SAM-III, with and without SAM, to get quantitative insights into the f-dependent structural changes. Force-extension (z) curves (FECs) for the apo (ON) state, obtained in simulations in which f is increased at a constant loading rate, show three intermediates, with the first one being the rupture of SAM binding region, which is greatly stabilized in the OFF state. Force-dependent free energy profiles, G(z,f), as a function of z, obtained in equilibrium constant force simulations, reveal the intermediates observed in FECs. The predicted stability difference between the ON and OFF states using G(z,f) is in excellent agreement with experiments. Remarkably, using G(z,f)s and estimate of an effective diffusion constant at a single value of f allows us to predict the f-dependent transition rates using theory of first passage times for both the apo and holo states. To resolve the kinetics of assembly of SAM-III riboswitch in structural terms, we use force stretch-quench pulse sequences in which the force on RNA is maintained at a low (fq) value starting from a high value for a time period tq. Variation of tq over a wide range results in resolution of elusive states involved in the SAM binding pocket and leads to accurate determination of folding times down to fq = 0. Quantitative measure of the folding kinetics, obtained from the folding landscape, allows us to propose that, in contrast to riboswitches regulating transcription, SAM-III functions under thermodynamic control provided the basal concentration of SAM exceeds a small critical value. All of the predictions are amenable to tests in single molecule pulling experiments.