Contrasting the Reactivity of Ethylene and Propylene with P/Al and P/B Frustrated Lewis Pairs

Aluminum in Frustrated Lewis Pair Chemistry

This review article describes the development of the use of aluminum compounds in the chemistry of frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) over the last 14 years. It also discusses the synthesis, reactivity and catalytic applications of intermolecular, intramolecular and so-called hidden FLPs with phosphorus, nitrogen and carbon Lewis bases. The intrinsically higher acidity of aluminum compounds compared to their boron analogs opens up different reaction pathways. The results are presented in a more or less chronological order. It is shown that Al FLPs react with a variety of polar and non-polar substrates and form both stable adducts and reversibly activate bonds. Consequently, some catalytic applications of the title compounds were presented such as dimerization of alkynes, hydrogenation of tert-butyl ethylene and imines, C-F bond activation, reduction of CO2, dehydrogenation of amine borane and transfer of ammonia. In addition, various Al FLPs were used as initiators in polymerization reactions.

Mechanistic Insight Into the Reactivity of Frustrated Lewis Pairs: Liquid-State NMR Studies

Frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) have been widely investigated as promising catalysts due to their metal-free feature and ability to activate small molecules. Over the last few years, the structure, dynamics and interactions between the Lewis centers and their effects on the reactivity with different substrates have been studied. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is a powerful tool in studying the reaction intermediates, kinetics and mechanism of frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs). Various NMR experiments have been applied to precisely determine the association or cooperativity of FLPs and one or two-dimensional spectra were obtained. Herein, insights coming from NMR spectroscopy for FLPs are presented, the structure and reactivity of FLPs in solution are described, and their effects on the kinetics and mechanism of different substrates are also illustrated in this review.

Aluminum(III) Cations [(NHC) ⋅ AlMes2 ]+ : Synthesis, Characterization, and Application in FLP-Chemistry

The three-coordinate aluminum cations ligated by N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHCs) [(NHC) ⋅ AlMes2 ]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- (NHC=IMeMe 4, IiPrMe 5, IiPr 6, Mes=2,4,6-trimethylphenyl) were prepared via hydride abstraction of the alanes (NHC) ⋅ AlHMes2 (NHC=IMeMe 1, IiPrMe 2, IiPr 3) using [Ph3 C]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- in toluene as hydride acceptor. If this reaction was performed in diethyl ether, the corresponding four-coordinate aluminum etherate cations [(NHC) ⋅ AlMes2 (OEt2 )]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- 7-9 (NHC=IMeMe 7, IiPrMe 8, IiPr 9) were isolated. According to a theoretical and experimental assessment of the Lewis-acidity of the [(IMeMe ) ⋅ AlMes2 ]+ cation is the acidity larger than that of B(C6 F5 )3 and of similar magnitude as reported for Al(C6 F5 )3 . The reaction of [(IMeMe ) ⋅ AlMes2 ]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- 4 with the sterically less demanding, basic phosphine PMe3 afforded a mixed NHC/phosphine stabilized cation [(IMeMe ) ⋅ AlMes2 (PMe3 )]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- 10. Equimolar mixtures of 4 and the sterically more demanding PCy3 gave a frustrated Lewis-pair (FLP), i.e., [(IMeMe ) ⋅ AlMes2 ]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- /PCy3 FLP-11, which reacts with small molecules such as CO2 , ethene, and 2-butyne.

Reactivity of Oxygen-Bridged Geminal Al/P and Si/P Frustrated Lewis Pairs towards Heterocumulenes

The two oxygen-bridged geminal frustrated Lewis pairs (FLP) tBu₂ P-O-AlBis₂ (Bis=CH(SiMe₃ )₂ ; 1) and tBu₂ P-O-Si(C₂ F₅ )₃ (2) were reacted with the heterocumulenes PhNCO, PhOCN, PhNCS, CS₂ and PhNSO as well as SO₂ . With isocyanate and cyanate, both 1 and 2, form addition products under formation of five-membered rings. With CS₂ , isothiocyanate and sulfinylaniline, only 1 forms stable adducts, whereas 2 shows reactivity towards sulfinylaniline, but the product decomposed after a few minutes. The reaction of 1 with SO₂ led to partial cleavage of the P-O-Al and Al-C units, as confirmed by X-ray diffraction studies of a complex aggregate. The reaction of 2 with SO₂ affords the 1,2-addition product. All adducts were characterized by means of multinuclear NMR spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography and CHN analyses.

Progressing the Frustrated Lewis Pair Abilities of N-Heterocyclic Carbene/GaR3 Combinations for Catalytic Hydroboration of Aldehydes and Ketones

Exploiting the steric incompatibility of the tris(alkyl)gallium GaR₃ (R = CH₂SiMe₃) and the bulky N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) 1,3-bis(tert-butyl)imidazol-2-ylidene (ItBu), here we report the B-H bond activation of pinacolborane (HBPin), which has led to the isolation and structural authentication of a novel ion pair, [{ItBu-BPin}⁺{GaR₃(μ-H)GaR₃}^-] (2). Contrastingly, neither ItBu or GaR₃ was able to react with HBPin under the conditions of this study. Combining an NHC-stabilized borenium cation, [{ItBu-BPin}⁺], with an anionic dinuclear gallate, [{GaR₃(μ-H)GaR₃}^-], 2 proved to be unstable in solution at room temperature, evolving to the abnormal NHC-Ga complex [BPinC{{N(tBu)]₂CHCGa(R)₃}] (3). Interestingly, the structural isomer of 2, with the borenium cation residing at the C4 position of the carbene, [{aItBu-BPin}⁺{GaR₃(μ-H)GaR₃}^-] (4), was obtained when the abnormal NHC complex [aItBu·GaR₃] (1) was heated to 70 °C with HBPin, demonstrating that, under these forced conditions, it is possible to induce thermal frustration of the Lewis base/Lewis acid components of 1, enabling the activation of HBPin. Building on these stoichiometric studies, the frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) reactivity observed for the GaR₃/ItBu combination with HBPin could then be upgraded to catalytic regimes, allowing the efficient hydroboration of a range of aldehydes and ketones under mild reaction conditions. Mechanistic insights into the possible reaction pathway involved in this process have been gained by combining kinetic investigations with a comparative study of the catalytic capabilities of several gallium and borenium species related to 2. Disclosing a new cooperative partnership, reactions are proposed to occur via the formation of a highly reactive monomeric hydride gallate, [{ItBu-BPin}⁺{GaR₃(H)}^-] (I). Each anionic and cationic component of I plays a key role for success of the hydroboration, with the nucleophilic monomeric gallate anion favoring the transfer of its hydride to the C═O bond of the organic substate, which in turn is activated by coordination to the borenium cation.

μ-Methyl-ene-bis-[di-bromido(diethyl ether-κO)aluminium(III)]: crystal structure and chemical exchange in solution

The crystal structure of μ-methyl­ene-bis­[(di­bromo)(diethyl ether-κO)aluminium(III)] has established that the Al—CH₂—Al angle, 118.4 (2)°, is the smallest observed for structure where this moiety is not part of a ring.

In the title compound, [Al₂Br₄(CH₂)(C₄H₁₀O)₂], the mol­ecule lies on a crystallographic twofold axis passing through the bridging C atom. Each Al^III atom is four-coordinate, being bonded to two bromide ions, bridging the CH₂ group as well as the oxygen atom of a diethyl ether ligand in a slightly distorted tetra­hedral arrangement with angles ranging from 101.52 (8) to 116.44 (5)°. The Al—CH₂—Al angle, 118.4 (2)°, is the smallest observed for a structure where this moiety is not part of a ring. In the crystal, weak C—H⋯Br inter­actions, characterized as R²₂(12) rings, link the mol­ecules into ribbons in the [101] direction. The title compound is monomeric and coordinatively saturated in the solid state, as each aluminum is four-coordinate, but in solution the ether mol­ecules from either or both Al atoms can dissociate, and would be expected to rapidly exchange, and this is supported by NMR data.

Borane-induced ring closure reaction of oligomethylene-linked bis-allenes

The trimethylene-linked bis-allene 3a reacts with Piers' borane [HB(C₆F₅)₂] by a hydroboration/allylboration sequence to generate the cyclization product 5a. Its pyridine adduct was isolated and characterized by X-ray diffraction. Compound 5a undergoes a typical frustrated Lewis pair 1,2-P/B alkene addition reaction with PPh₃ to give the heterobicyclic bridged olefinic zwitterionic product 9a. The tetramethylene-linked bis-allene 3b and its phenylene annulated analogue 3c react with HB(C₆F₅)₂ to give the analogous seven-membered ring products 5b,c under mild conditions. The cyclization product 5a undergoes a series of sequential allylboration reactions with two equivalents of allene followed by ring-closure to give the four-component coupling product 12a. It undergoes FLP addition to an exo-methylene group upon treatment with PPh₃. Compound 12a is oxidatively converted to the boron-free alcohol.

Halogenoborane mediated allene cyclooligomerization

Allene reacts with the strongly electrophilic halogenoboranes XB(C₆F₅)₂ (X: Cl or Br) by forming a mixture of 1,3,5-trimethylenecyclohexane and the stoichiometric halogeno-borated tetramerization products.

The halogenoboranes XB(C₆F₅)₂ (X: Cl, Br) react with allene to give a mixture of the cyclotrimer 1,3,5-trimethylenecyclohexane (1) and the related halogenoborylated cyclotetramerization products 3a and 3b. Alkyl-substituted allenes were catalytically cyclotrimerized metal-free by XB(C₆F₅)₂ (X: Cl, Br) to give cis,trans-2,4,6-trialkyl-1,3,5-trimethylenecyclohexanes under mild conditions.

Borane-Induced Dimerization of Arylallenes

A series of arylallenes react with HB(C₆ F₅ )₂ in a 2:1 molar ratio to give the tail-to-tail 1,6-diaryl-2-boryl-hexa-1,5-diene coupling products. The reaction of the phenylallene substrate with HB(C₆ F₅ )₂ was shown to initially give the 2-boryl-3,4-diphenyl-1,5-hexadiene head-to-head coupling product which then rearranged, by a thermally induced Cope rearrangement, into the final product.

Halogenated triphenylgallium and -indium in frustrated Lewis pair activations and hydrogenation catalysis

The Lewis acids Ga(C₆F₅)₃, In(C₆F₅)₃ and Ga(C₆Cl₅)₃ are prepared and their Lewis acidity has been probed experimentally and computationally. The species Ga(C₆F₅)₃ and In(C₆F₅)₃ in conjunction with phosphine donors are shown to heterolytically split H₂ and catalyse the hydrogenation of an imine. In addition, frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) derived from Ga(C₆F₅)₃ and In(C₆F₅)₃ and phosphines react with diphenyldisulfide to phosphoniumgallates or indates of the form [tBu₃PSPh][PhSE(C₆F₅)₃] and [tBu₃PSPh][(μ-SPh)(E(C₆F₅)₃)₂] (E = Ga, In). The potential of the FLPs based on Ga(C₆F₅)₃, In(C₆F₅)₃ and Ga(C₆Cl₅)₃ and phosphines is also shown in reactions with phenylacetylene to give pure or mixtures of the products [tBu₃PH][PhCCE(C₆X₅)₃] and R₃P(Ph)C=C(H)E(C₆X₅)₃ A number of these species are crystallographically characterized. The implications for the use of these species in FLP chemistry are considered.This article is part of the themed issue 'Frustrated Lewis pair chemistry'.

"Masked" Lewis-acidity of an aluminum α-phosphinoamide complex

The reaction of Ph₂P(DIPP)NH with AlMe₃ cleanly gives an aluminum amide complex that crystallizes as a centrosymmetric dimer with a six-membered Al-N-P-Al-N-P ring. In aromatic solvents the dimer remains intact but the Al-P bond is readily broken upon addition of THF to form Ph₂P(DIPP)NAlMe₂·THF. Efforts to use [Ph₂P(DIPP)NAlMe₂]₂ as a "masked" Lewis acidic activator for olefin polymerization catalysts were unsuccessful but the complex showed a Frustrated Lewis pair reactivity instead. The P/Al complex reacts with isocyanates to give the C[double bond, length as m-dash]O inserted product that crystallizes as a five-membered ring system Al-O-C(NR)-P-N. The reaction of [Ph₂P(DIPP)NAlMe₂]₂ with CO₂, however, gave an insertion in the N-Al bond and the dimeric product [Ph₂P(DIPP)NCO₂AlMe₂]₂ was isolated. The dimer [Ph₂P(DIPP)NAlMe₂]₂ is one of the few Al/P FLPs that can activate C[double bond, length as m-dash]C double bonds irreversibly. A reaction with allyl methyl sulfide and 1-hexene led to the clean formation of the structurally similar activated alkene products [(DIPP)N-Ph₂P-CH(CH₂SMe)CH₂]AlMe₂ and [(DIPP)N-Ph₂P-CH(C₄H₉)CH₂]AlMe₂.

Activation of Dihydrogen by Masked Doubly Bonded Aluminum Species

Activation of dihydrogen by masked dialumenes (Al=Al doubly bonded species) is reported. Reactions of barrelene-type dialumanes, which have the reactivity as masked equivalents of 1,2-diaryldialumenes ArAl=AlAr, with H2 afforded dihydroalumanes ArAlH2 at room temperature (Ar: bulky aryl groups). These dihydroalumanes form hydrogen-bridged dimers [ArHAl(μ-H)]2 in the crystalline state, while a monomer-dimer equilibrium was suggested in solution. The 1,2-diaryldialumenes generated from the barrelene-type dialumanes are the putative active species in the cleavage of H2 .

Cationic aluminum hydride complexes: reactions of carbene–alane adducts with trityl-borate

Reaction of (Idipp)AlH₃ with [Ph₃C][B(C₆F₅)₄] in toluene affords the dimeric aluminum dication [((Idipp)AlH(μ-H))₂][B(C₆F₅)₄]₂ with the corresponding reaction of (IBn)AlH₃ gives [(IBn)₂AlH][B(C₆F₅)₄]₂.

Frustrated Lewis pair chemistry: development and perspectives

Frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) are combinations of Lewis acids and Lewis bases in solution that are deterred from strong adduct formation by steric and/or electronic factors. This opens pathways to novel cooperative reactions with added substrates. Small-molecule binding and activation by FLPs has led to the discovery of a variety of new reactions through unprecedented pathways. Hydrogen activation and subsequent manipulation in metal-free catalytic hydrogenations is a frequently observed feature of many FLPs. The current state of this young but rapidly expanding field is outlined in this Review and the future directions for its broadening sphere of impact are considered.