Integrated SDS Removal and Peptide Separation by Strong-Cation Exchange Liquid Chromatography for SDS-Assisted Shotgun Proteome Analysis

Detergent-Assisted Protein Digestion-On the Way to Avoid the Key Bottleneck of Shotgun Bottom-Up Proteomics

Gel-free bottom-up shotgun proteomics is the principal methodological platform for the state-of-the-art proteome research. This methodology assumes quantitative isolation of the total protein fraction from a complex biological sample, its limited proteolysis with site-specific proteases, analysis of the resulted peptides with nanoscaled reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography-(tandem) mass spectrometry (nanoRP-HPLC-MS and MS/MS), protein identification by sequence database search and peptide-based quantitative analysis. The most critical steps of this workflow are protein reconstitution and digestion; therefore, detergents and chaotropic agents are strongly mandatory to ensure complete solubilization of complex protein isolates and to achieve accessibility of all protease cleavage sites. However, detergents are incompatible with both RP separation and electrospray ionization (ESI). Therefore, to make LC-MS analysis possible, several strategies were implemented in the shotgun proteomics workflow. These techniques rely either on enzymatic digestion in centrifugal filters with subsequent evacuation of the detergent, or employment of MS-compatible surfactants, which can be degraded upon the digestion. In this review we comprehensively address all currently available strategies for the detergent-assisted proteolysis in respect of their relative efficiency when applied to different biological matrices. We critically discuss the current progress and the further perspectives of these technologies in the context of its advances and gaps.

Mass spectrometry and the cellular surfaceome

The collection of exposed plasma membrane proteins, collectively termed the surfaceome, is involved in multiple vital cellular processes, such as the communication of cells with their surroundings and the regulation of transport across the lipid bilayer. The surfaceome also plays key roles in the immune system by recognizing and presenting antigens, with its possible malfunctioning linked to disease. Surface proteins have long been explored as potential cell markers, disease biomarkers, and therapeutic drug targets. Despite its importance, a detailed study of the surfaceome continues to pose major challenges for mass spectrometry-driven proteomics due to the inherent biophysical characteristics of surface proteins. Their inefficient extraction from hydrophobic membranes to an aqueous medium and their lower abundance compared to intracellular proteins hamper the analysis of surface proteins, which are therefore usually underrepresented in proteomic datasets. To tackle such problems, several innovative analytical methodologies have been developed. This review aims at providing an extensive overview of the different methods for surfaceome analysis, with respective considerations for downstream mass spectrometry-based proteomics.

Automated Electrokinetic Platform for High-Throughput Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate Depletion Ahead of Proteome Analysis by Mass Spectrometry

Sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) provides numerous benefits for proteome sample preparation. However, the surfactant can be detrimental to downstream mass spectrometry analysis. Although strategies are available to deplete SDS from proteins, each is plagued by unique deficiencies that challenge their utility for high-throughput proteomics. An optimal approach would rapidly and reproducibly achieve less than 10 ppm residual SDS while simultaneously maximizing analyte recovery. Here, we describe improvements to a simple electrokinetic device termed transmembrane electrophoresis, which we previously reported for automated, rapid SDS depletion of proteome samples. Voltage-driven transport of SDS across a molecular weight cutoff membrane is enhanced at higher electric fields, which is herein achieved by integrating an active cooling mechanism to mitigate the impacts of Joule heating. We report 99.9% reduction of SDS (final concentration < 5 ppm) in 5 min. The device is employed in a detergent-based proteomic workflow for analysis of an enriched yeast membrane proteome extract, demonstrating quantitative protein recovery (>98%) and increasing the number of identifications by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry.

An Integrated Approach for the Efficient Extraction and Solubilization of Rice Microsomal Membrane Proteins for High-Throughput Proteomics

The preparation of microsomal membrane proteins (MPs) is critically important to microsomal proteomics. To date most research studies have utilized an ultracentrifugation-based approach for the isolation and solubilization of plant MPs. However, these approaches are labor-intensive, time-consuming, and unaffordable in certain cases. Furthermore, the use of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and its removal prior to a mass spectrometry (MS) analysis through multiple washing steps result in the loss of proteins. To address these limitations, this study introduced a simple micro-centrifugation-based MP extraction (MME) method from rice leaves, with the efficacy of this approach being compared with a commercially available plasma membrane extraction kit (PME). Moreover, this study assessed the subsequent solubilization of isolated MPs in an MS-compatible surfactant, namely, 4-hexylphenylazosulfonate (Azo) and SDS using a label-free proteomic approach. The results validated the effectiveness of the MME method, specifically in the enrichment of plasma membrane proteins as compared with the PME method. Furthermore, the findings showed that Azo demonstrated several advantages over SDS in solubilizing the MPs, which was reflected through a label-free quantitative proteome analysis. Altogether, this study provided a relatively simple and rapid workflow for the efficient extraction of MPs with an Azo-integrated MME approach for bottom-up proteomics.

SCASP: A Simple and Robust SDS-Aided Sample Preparation Method for Proteomic Research

SDS is widely used in sample preparation for proteomic research. However, SDS is incompatible with LC and electrospray ionization. SDS depletion is therefore required ahead of LC-MS analysis. Most of current SDS removal strategies are time consuming, laborious, and have low reproducibility. Here, we describe a method, SDS-cyclodextrin (CD)-assisted sample preparation, by which CD can bind to SDS and form CD-SDS complexes in solutions, allowing for direct tryptic digestion. We demonstrate that SDS-CD-assisted sample preparation is a simple, fast, and robust SDS-based sample preparation method for proteomics application.

A simple apparatus for electrokinetic removal of sodium dodecyl sulfate from protein digests

Sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) in proteomics samples needs to be removed and estimated prior to mass spectrometry (MS)-based analysis and to avoid MS ion-source contamination. Here, we describe an organic solvent free method to remove SDS using a simple apparatus that mainly consists of an agarose gel inside a 1 mL plastic micropipette tip and a voltage power supply with electrodes. A small volume of sample (e.g., 50 μL) is loaded on top of the gel and then voltage (cathode at the sample side) is applied with an acidic solution at the other end of the micropipette tip. Within 25 min, SDS was removed (e.g., ≥99% SDS in 3.5 mM SDS) and the peptides were retained in the sample solution. The strategy was compared to the commercially available and expensive Pierce spin column for the removal of SDS and recovery of peptides from a digested bovine serum albumin sample.

Mass spectrometry profiling of low molecular weight proteins and peptides isolated by acetone precipitation

Solvent-based protein precipitation provides exceptional recovery, particularly when the ionic strength of the solution is controlled. While precipitation is ideally suited for intact protein purification ahead of mass-spectrometry, low molecular weight (LMW) proteins and peptides are considered less susceptible to aggregation in organic solvent. As the combination of salt and organic solvent (i.e. acetone) has yet to be exploited to precipitate LMW proteins, we herein determine the low mass limit for solvent-based protein precipitation. We establish optimized conditions for high recovery precipitation of LMW proteins and peptides. Our results demonstrate a strong dependence on the type of salt to recover LMW components from complex mixtures. Inclusion of 100 mM ZnSO₄ with 97% acetone provides near quantitative recovery of all peptides down to 2 kDa, and continues to exceed 90% yield for peptides at a molecular weight of 1 kDa. A detailed characterization of the precipitated peptides resulting from trypsin and pepsin digestion of complex systems is provided by bottom-up mass spectrometry.

Investigating Phosphorylation Patterns of the Ion Channel TRPM7 Using Multiple Extraction and Enrichment Techniques Reveals New Phosphosites

The study of membrane proteins, and in particular ion channels, is crucial to understanding cellular function. Mass spectrometry-based approaches including bottom-up strategies to study membrane proteins have been successful yet still can remain challenging. In this study, we sought to evaluate the phosphorylation patterns of the ion channel TRPM7 which is involved in a range of critical physiological functions. To overcome extraction obstacles associated with analyzing membrane proteins, we incorporated the use of 5% SDS solubilization coupled with SCAD and S-Trap digestion methods to eliminate detergent interference in downstream LC-MS/MS analysis. We found that the SCAD method was more efficient, yielding 84% of the overall identified proteins; however, the variability was greater than the S-Trap method. Using both methods together with TiO₂ and Fe-NTA phospho-enrichment protocols, we successfully observed the phosphorylation pattern of TRPM7 in a transfected cell line. An average of 22 ± 6% of the TRPM7 amino acid sequence was observed. In addition to several previously reported phosphorylation sites, we identified six new phosphosites (S5, S233, S554, S824, T1265, and S1401), providing new targets for further functional analyses of TRPM7.

Evaluation of a Methylcellulose and Hyaluronic Acid Hydrogel as a Vehicle for Rectal Delivery of Biologics

Biologics have changed the management of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD), but there are concerns regarding unexpected systemic toxicity and loss of therapeutic response following administration by injection. Local delivery of biologics directly to the inflamed mucosa via rectal enema administration addresses the problems associated with systemic administration. Hydrogels are potentially useful delivery vehicles enabling rectal administration of biologics. Here, we prepared a hydrogel system based on methylcellulose (MC) and hyaluronic acid (HA), which possesses mucosal healing properties, incorporating a model macromolecular drug, namely (fluorescently-labeled) bovine serum albumin (BSA). The BSA-loaded MCHA hydrogel showed temperature-dependent gelation (liquid-like at 20 °C and gel-like at 37 °C) and shear thinning behavior, with these being important and desirable characteristics for rectal application (enabling easy application and retention). BSA release from the MCHA system at 37 °C was linear, with 50% of the loaded drug released within 2 h. The system demonstrated acceptable toxicity towards intestinal (colon) Caco-2 epithelial cells, even at high concentrations. Importantly, application of the BSA-loaded MCHA hydrogel to polarized Caco-2 monolayers, with or without an exemplar absorption enhancer, resulted in transintestinal permeability of BSA. The study therefore indicates that the MCHA hydrogel shows potential for topical (rectal) delivery of biologics in IBD.

Membrane-Free Electrokinetic Device Integrated to Electrospray-Ionization Mass Spectrometry for the Simultaneous Removal of Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate and Enrichment of Peptides

The removal of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) in SDS-assisted proteomics with electrospray-ionization-mass-spectrometric (ESI-MS) analysis is an essential step in the analysis. Off-line state-of-the-art sample-preparation strategies can allow 100% removal of DS^- and up to 100% peptide recoveries. These strategies, however, are typically laborious and require long analysis times and a complex experimental setup. Here, we developed a simple, membrane-free, electrokinetic, on-line, integrated SDS removal-ESI-MS device that was able to enhance ESI-MS signals of bradykinin and peptides from trypsin-digested bovine serum albumin (BSA) in samples that contained SDS micelles. The significant peptide-signal improvements were contributed by the complete removal of DS^- and the enrichment of the peptides in the presence of an electric field. Enrichment was via micelle-to-solvent stacking, initially developed in capillary electrophoresis. Bradykinin percent recovery was 800%, and BSA peptide percent recovery was 87%. Enhancement factors in ESI-MS signals (after and before removal) for selected m/ z values of peptides from the BSA digest were 535-693.

Electro-ultrafiltration to remove sodium dodecyl sulfate in proteins extracted for proteomics

A creative electro-ultrafiltration method was developed to remove sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) from proteins extracted for proteomics analysis.

Activation of the Na+/H+ exchanger in isolated cardiomyocytes through β-Raf dependent pathways. Role of Thr653 of the cytosolic tail

The mammalian Na⁺/H⁺ exchanger isoform 1 (NHE1) is a ubiquitous plasma membrane protein that is a key regulator of intracellular pH in isolated cardiomyocytes. A 500 amino acid membrane domain removes protons and is regulated by a 315 amino acid cytosolic domain. In the myocardium, aberrant regulation of NHE1 contributes to ischemia reperfusion damage and to heart hypertrophy. We examined mechanisms of regulation of NHE1 in the myocardium by endothelin and β-Raf. Endothelin stimulated NHE1 activity and activated Erk-dependent pathways. Inhibition of β-Raf reduced NHE1 activity and Erk-pathway activation. We demonstrated that myocardial β-Raf binds to the C-terminal 182 amino acids of the NHE1 protein and that β-Raf is associated with NHE1 in intact cardiomyocytes. NHE1 was phosphorylated in vivo and the protein kinase inhibitor sorafenib reduced NHE1 phosphorylation levels. Immunoprecipitates of β-Raf from cardiomyocytes phosphorylated the C-terminal 182 amino acids of NHE1 and mass spectrometry analysis showed that amino acid Thr⁶⁵³ was phosphorylated. Mutation of this amino acid to Ala resulted in defective activity while mutation to Asp restored the activity. The results demonstrate that Thr⁶⁵³ is an important regulatory amino acid of NHE1 that is activated through β-Raf dependent pathways by phosphorylation either directly or indirectly by β-Raf, and this affects NHE1 activity.

Integral membrane proteins in proteomics. How to break open the black box?

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) are coded by 20-30% of human genes and execute important functions - transmembrane transport, signal transduction, cell-cell communication, cell adhesion to the extracellular matrix, and many other processes. Due to their hydrophobicity, low expression and lack of trypsin cleavage sites in their transmembrane segments, IMPs have been generally under-represented in routine proteomic analyses. However, the field of membrane proteomics has changed markedly in the past decade, namely due to the introduction of filter assisted sample preparation (FASP), the establishment of cell surface capture (CSC) protocols, and the development of methods that enable analysis of the hydrophobic transmembrane segments. This review will summarize the recent developments in the field and outline the most successful strategies for the analysis of integral membrane proteins.

SIGNIFICANCE

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) are attractive therapeutic targets mostly due to their many important functions. However, our knowledge of the membrane proteome is severely limited to effectively exploit their potential. This is mostly due to the lack of appropriate techniques or methods compatible with the typical features of IMPs, namely hydrophobicity, low expression and lack of trypsin cleavage sites. This review summarizes the most recent development in membrane proteomics and outlines the most successful strategies for their large-scale analysis.

Streamlined Membrane Proteome Preparation for Shotgun Proteomics Analysis with Triton X-100 Cloud Point Extraction and Nanodiamond Solid Phase Extraction

While mass spectrometry (MS) plays a key role in proteomics research, characterization of membrane proteins (MP) by MS has been a challenging task because of the presence of a host of interfering chemicals in the hydrophobic protein extraction process, and the low protease digestion efficiency. We report a sample preparation protocol, two-phase separation with Triton X-100, induced by NaCl, with coomassie blue added for visualizing the detergent-rich phase, which streamlines MP preparation for SDS-PAGE analysis of intact MP and shot-gun proteomic analyses. MP solubilized in the detergent-rich milieu were then sequentially extracted and fractionated by surface-oxidized nanodiamond (ND) at three pHs. The high MP affinity of ND enabled extensive washes for removal of salts, detergents, lipids, and other impurities to ensure uncompromised ensuing purposes, notably enhanced proteolytic digestion and down-stream mass spectrometric (MS) analyses. Starting with a typical membranous cellular lysate fraction harvested with centrifugation/ultracentrifugation, MP purities of 70%, based on number (not weight) of proteins identified by MS, was achieved; the weight-based purity can be expected to be much higher.

Liquid phase based separation systems for depletion, prefractionation, and enrichment of proteins in biological fluids and matrices for in-depth proteomics analysis-An update covering the period 2011-2014

This review article expands on the previous one (S. Selvaraju and Z. El Rassi, Electrophoresis 2012, 33, 74-88) by reviewing pertinent literature in the period extending from early 2011 to present. As the previous review article, the present one is concerned with proteomic sample preparation (e.g., depletion of high-abundance proteins, reduction of the protein dynamic concentration range, enrichment of a particular subproteome), and the subsequent chromatographic and/or electrophoretic prefractionation prior to peptide separation and identification by LC-MS/MS. This review article, however, is distinguished from its earlier version by expanding on capturing/enriching subphosphoproteomes by immobilized metal affinity chromatography and metal oxide affinity chromatography. Seventy-seven papers published in the period extending from mid-2011 to the present have been reviewed. By no means this review article is exhaustive, given the fact that its aim is to give a concise treatment of the latest developments in the field.

A two-stage spin cartridge for integrated protein precipitation, digestion and SDS removal in a comparative bottom-up proteomics workflow

Protein precipitation with organic solvent is an effective means of depleting contaminants such as sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), while maintaining high analyte recovery. Here, we report the use of a disposable two-stage spin cartridge to facilitate isolation of the precipitated protein, with subsequent enzyme digestion and peptide cleanup in the cartridge. An upper filtration cartridge retains over 95% of the protein (10 μg BSA), with 99.75% detergent depleted from a sample initially containing 2% SDS. Following precipitation, a plug attached to the base of the filtration cartridge retains the solution to enable tryptic digestion in the vial, while a solid phase extraction cartridge attached to the base of the filter facilitates peptide cleanup post-digestion. A GELFrEE fractionated Escherichia coli proteome extract processed with the spin cartridge yields similar protein identifications compared to controls (226 vs 216 for control), and with an increased number of unique peptides (1753 vs 1554 for control). The device is applied to proteome characterization of rat kidneys experiencing a surgically induced ureteral tract obstruction, revealing several statistically altered proteins, consistent with the morphology and expected pathophysiology of the disease.

BIOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE

Conventionally, protein precipitation involves extended centrifugation to pellet the sample, with careful pipetting to remove the supernatant without disturbing the pellet. The method is not only time consuming but is highly subject to the skill of the individual, particularly at lower protein concentrations where the pellet may not be visible. As such, protein precipitation is often overlooked in proteomics, favoring column-based approaches to concentrate or purify samples. Here, all aspects of sample manipulation are integrated into a simple disposable cartridge. The device enables SDS depletion, sample preconcentration, resolubilization, derivatization, digestion, and peptide cleanup in a highly repeatable and easily multiplexed format. The device is ideally suited for comparative proteome studies. Antenatal hydronephrosis is a congenital disorder affecting 1-5% of all pregnancies, and can require surgical intervention to avoid loss of renal function. Using our device, we investigated the impact of hydronephrosis on the kidneys in a surgically induced animal model of the disease. Proteome analysis points to decreased metabolic activity in the obstructed kidney, with upregulation of proteins involved in cytoskeletal organization. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein dynamics in health and disease. Guest Editors: Pierre Thibault and Anne-Claude Gingras.

Comparison of detergent-based sample preparation workflows for LTQ-Orbitrap analysis of the Escherichia coli proteome

This work presents a comparative evaluation of several detergent-based sample preparation workflows for the MS-based analysis of bacterial proteomes, performed using the model organism Escherichia coli. Initially, RapiGest- and SDS-based buffers were compared for their protein extraction efficiency and quality of the MS data generated. As a result, SDS performed best in terms of total protein yields and overall number of MS identifications, mainly due to a higher efficiency in extracting high molecular weight (MW) and membrane proteins, while RapiGest led to an enrichment in periplasmic and fimbrial proteins. Then, SDS extracts underwent five different MS sample preparation workflows, including: detergent removal by spin columns followed by in-solution digestion (SC), protein precipitation followed by in-solution digestion in ammonium bicarbonate or urea buffer, filter-aided sample preparation (FASP), and 1DE separation followed by in-gel digestion. On the whole, about 1000 proteins were identified upon LC-MS/MS analysis of all preparations (>1100 with the SC workflow), with FASP producing more identified peptides and a higher mean sequence coverage. Each protocol exhibited specific behaviors in terms of MW, hydrophobicity, and subcellular localization distribution of the identified proteins; a comparative assessment of the different outputs is presented.

Photophysics of novel coumarin-labeled depsipeptides in solution: sensing interactions with SDS micelle via TICT model

N-Acylbenzotriazoles enable the synthesis (69-92% yield) of blue to green fluorescent coumarin-labeled depsidipeptides 8a-f (quantum yields 0.004-0.97) and depsitripeptides 12a-d (quantum yields 0.02-0.96). Detailed photophysical studies of fluorescent coumarin-labeled depsipeptides 8a-f and 12a-d are reported for both polar protic and polar aprotic solvents. 7-Methoxy and 7-diethylaminocoumarin-3-ylcarbonyl depsipeptides 8c,f and 12d are highly solvent sensitive. These highly fluorescent compounds could be useful for peptide assays. Further photophysical studies of 7-diethylaminocoumarin-labeled depsipeptides 8c,12d within the micellar microenvironment of SDS reflect their ability to bind with the biological membrane, suggesting potential applications in the fields of bio- and medicinal chemistry.

Coupling a detergent lysis/cleanup methodology with intact protein fractionation for enhanced proteome characterization

The expanding use of surfactants for proteome sample preparations has prompted the need to systematically optimize the application and removal of these MS-deleterious agents prior to proteome measurements. Here we compare four detergent cleanup methods (trichloroacetic acid (TCA) precipitation, chloroform/methanol/water (CMW) extraction, a commercial detergent removal spin column method (DRS) and filter-aided sample preparation (FASP)) to provide efficiency benchmarks with respect to protein, peptide, and spectral identifications in each case. Our results show that for protein-limited samples, FASP outperforms the other three cleanup methods, while at high protein amounts, all the methods are comparable. This information was used to investigate and contrast molecular weight-based fractionated with unfractionated lysates from three increasingly complex samples ( Escherichia coli K-12, a five microbial isolate mixture, and a natural microbial community groundwater sample), all of which were prepared with an SDS-FASP approach. The additional fractionation step enhanced the number of protein identifications by 8% to 25% over the unfractionated approach across the three samples.

Comparative study of workflows optimized for in-gel, in-solution, and on-filter proteolysis in the analysis of plasma membrane proteins

Proteomic studies of plasma membrane proteins are challenged by the limited solubility of these proteins and the limited activity of proteolytic enzymes in solubilizing agents such as SDS. In this work, we have evaluated three bottom-up workflows to obtain tryptic peptides from plasma membrane proteins solubilized with 2% SDS. The workflows are in-gel digestion, in-solution digestion, and on-filter digestion. The efficiencies of these strategies, optimized to employ different matrices for trypsin cleavage, were compared using a plasma membrane sample enriched from multiple myeloma cells using a nanoparticle pellicle. On the basis of the number of proteins identified, number of transmembrane proteins identified, hydrophobicity, and spectral count per protein, the workflow that uses in-gel digestion is the most advantageous approach for analysis of plasma membrane proteins.