Animal models of lysosomal disease: an overview

Animal models for lysosomal storage disorders

The lysosomal storage disorders (LSD) represent a heterogeneous group of inherited diseases characterized by the accumulation of non-metabolized macromolecules (by-products of cellular turnover) in different tissues and organs. LSDs primarily develop as a consequence of a deficiency in a lysosomal hydrolase or its co-factor. The majority of these enzymes are glycosidases and sulfatases, which in normal conditions participate in degradation of glycoconjugates: glycoproteins, glycosaminoproteoglycans, and glycolipids. Significant insights have been gained from studies of animal models, both in understanding mechanisms of disease and in establishing proof of therapeutic concept. These studies have led to the introduction of therapy for certain LSD subtypes, primarily by enzyme replacement or substrate reduction therapy. Animal models have been useful in elucidating molecular changes, particularly prior to onset of symptoms. On the other hand, it should be noted certain animal (mouse) models may have the underlying biochemical defect, but not show the course of disease observed in human patients. There is interest in examining therapeutic options in the larger spontaneous animal models that may more closely mimic the brain size and pathology of humans. This review will highlight lessons learned from studies of animal models of disease, drawing primarily from publications in 2011-2012.

Modeling human neurodegenerative diseases in transgenic systems

Transgenic systems are widely used to study the cellular and molecular basis of human neurodegenerative diseases. A wide variety of model organisms have been utilized, including bacteria (Escherichia coli), plants (Arabidopsis thaliana), nematodes (Caenorhabditis elegans), arthropods (Drosophila melanogaster), fish (zebrafish, Danio rerio), rodents (mouse, Mus musculus and rat, Rattus norvegicus) as well as non-human primates (rhesus monkey, Macaca mulatta). These transgenic systems have enormous value for understanding the pathophysiological basis of these disorders and have, in some cases, been instrumental in the development of therapeutic approaches to treat these conditions. In this review, we discuss the most commonly used model organisms and the methodologies available for the preparation of transgenic organisms. Moreover, we provide selected examples of the use of these technologies for the preparation of transgenic animal models of neurodegenerative diseases, including Alzheimer's disease (AD), frontotemporal lobar degeneration (FTLD), amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), Huntington's disease (HD) and Parkinson's disease (PD) and discuss the application of these technologies to AD as an example of how transgenic modeling has affected the study of human neurodegenerative diseases.

Early signs of neurolipidosis-related behavioural alterations in a murine model of metachromatic leukodystrophy

Arylsulfatase A (ASA)-deficient mice represent an animal model for the lysosomal storage disorder metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD). Although the model has been applied in pathophysiological and therapeutic studies, the behavioural phenotype of ASA(-/-) mice is only partially characterized, and the most decisive outcome measures for therapy evaluation only emerge beyond 1 year of age. Presently, ASA(-/-) mice and ASA(+/-) control mice were studied at 6 and 12 months of age on an extensive battery including tests of neuromotor ability, exploratory behaviour, and learning and memory. Overt signs of ataxia were not observed in 6-month-old ASA(-/-) mice, but quantitative gait analysis during open-field exploration revealed that ASA(-/-) mice displayed increased hind base width and increased stride lengths for all paws. Their covert motor incoordination was evident in a correlation analysis which unveiled decreased harmonisation of concurrent gait parameters. For example, while ASA(+/-) controls demonstrated substantial convergence of front and hind base width (r=0.54), these variables actually diverged in ASA(-/-) mice (r=-0.37). Furthermore, various behavioural observations indicated emotional alterations in ASA(-/-) mice. Six-month-old ASA(-/-) mice also showed decreased response rates in scheduled operant responding. The present findings could provide relevant behavioural outcome measures for further use of this murine MLD model in preclinical studies.

Human Embryonic Stem Cells

Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) are stable in terms of their pluripotency, karyotype, global gene expression, ability to repair DNA and maintain telomerase levels, and growth characteristics. hESCs offer a renewable source of a wide range of cell types for use in research and cell-based therapies to treat disease. Characterization of cell populations that differentiate from them provides important information on early differentiation events and critical data for subsequent downstream manipulations. A strategy that has evolved in using cells is to develop a master bank of cells from which a working bank is generated, which is then used to generate appropriate cell types for screening, drug discovery, or therapeutic use. Appropriate cells are purified or enriched by one of several selection techniques, and such purified populations are used for most purposes. In this review, the authors discuss recent results and review the progress that has been made in the field, with a focus on using embryonic stem cells for neural targets.

Multivariate neurocognitive and emotional profile of a mannosidosis murine model for therapy assessment

alpha-Mannosidosis is a lysosomal storage disorder caused by lysosomal alpha-mannosidase (LAMAN) deficiency that leads to neurocognitive dysfunctions, psychotic symptoms and emotional changes in human patients. A murine mannosidosis model, LAMAN-deficient mice, was examined on a behavioral task battery that included test for neuromotor, exploratory and neurocognitive (spatial learning and memory) abilities, and multivariate statistical analyses were used to identify behavioral and neurocognitive domains that are most heavily affected by LAMAN deficiency. In addition, we further investigated synaptic plasticity recordings on hippocampal slices that may relate to these behavioral alterations. Correlation analysis revealed significant intra- and intertask correlations and factor analysis that included all 21 behavioral variables identified three main factors (exploration/emotionality, locomotion and learning/memory abilities). Significant correlations were observed between genotype, and factor 1 (exploration/emotionality) and factor 3 (learning/memory abilities). Discriminant function analysis showed that "path length in the open field test" and "time spent in the target quadrant during the water maze probe trial" were the most decisive variables to distinguish between the genotypes. We therefore suggest that these variables would be especially important in forthcoming therapy assessment experiments using this murine mannosidosis model. LAMAN-deficient mice displayed severe changes in synaptic plasticity, which may have contributed to the neurocognitive impairments observed. The present report further shows that targeted deletion of the LAMAN gene in mice mimics many aspects of human alpha-mannosidosis, and these data provide a basis for future therapeutic experiments.

NPC1 late endosomes contain elevated levels of non-esterified ('free') fatty acids and an abnormally glycosylated form of the NPC2 protein

NPC (Niemann-Pick type C) disease is a rare lipidosis characterized by the accumulation of LDL (low-density lipoprotein)-derived non-esterified cholesterol in the E/L (endosomal/lysosomal) system. The gene products that are responsible for the two NPC complementation groups are distinct and dissimilar, yet their cellular and disease phenotypes are virtually indistinguishable. To investigate the relationship between NPC1 and NPC2 and their potential role in NPC disease pathogenesis, we have developed a method for the rapid and efficient isolation of late endocytic vesicles from mouse liver by magnetic chromatography. Late endosomes from Wt (wild-type) and NPC1 mice were found to differ not only in their cholesterol and sphingomyelin content, as expected, but also in their non-esterified ('free') fatty acid content, with NPC1 vesicles showing an approx. 7-fold increase in non-esterified fatty acid levels compared with Wt vesicles. Furthermore, we show that the NPC2 protein is in an incompletely deglycosylated form in NPC1 late endosomes by a mechanism that is specific to the NPC2 protein and not a global aberration of protein glycosylation/deglycosylation or trafficking, since NPC2 secreted from NPC1 cells is indistinguishable from that secreted from Wt cells. Also, a greater proportion of the normally soluble cellular NPC2 protein partitions with detergent-insoluble late endosomal internal membrane domains in NPC1 vesicles. In addition, we show that, although a small amount of the NPC2 protein associates with these membranes in Wt vesicles, this localization becomes much more pronounced in NPC1 vesicles. These results suggest that the function of the NPC2 protein may be compromised as well in NPC1 endosomes, which might explain the paradoxical phenotypic similarities of the two NPC disease complementation groups.

Disruption of PPT2 in mice causes an unusual lysosomal storage disorder with neurovisceral features

The palmitoyl protein thioesterase-2 (PPT2) gene encodes a lysosomal thioesterase homologous to PPT1, which is the enzyme defective in the human disorder called infantile neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis. In this article, we report that PPT2 deficiency in mice causes an unusual form of neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis with striking visceral manifestations. All PPT2-deficient mice displayed a neurodegenerative phenotype with spasticity and ataxia by 15 mo. The bone marrow was infiltrated by brightly autofluorescent macrophages and multinucleated giant cells, but interestingly, the macrophages did not have the typical appearance of foam cells commonly associated with other lysosomal storage diseases. Marked splenomegaly caused by extramedullary hematopoiesis was observed. The pancreas was grossly orange to brown as a result of massive storage of lipofuscin pigments in the exocrine (but not islet) cells. Electron microscopy showed that the storage material consisted of multilamellar membrane profiles ("zebra bodies"). In summary, PPT2 deficiency in mice manifests as a neurodegenerative disorder with visceral features. Although PPT2 deficiency has not been described in humans, manifestations would be predicted to include neurodegeneration with bone marrow histiocytosis, visceromegaly, brown pancreas, and linkage to chromosome 6p21.3 in affected families.

Lysosomal storage disease in Sida carpinifolia toxicosis: an induced mannosidosis in horses

REASONS FOR PERFORMING STUDY

This study reports a neurological disease unrecognised until now in ponies in southern Brazil.

HYPOTHESIS

Epidemiological data strongly suggests that the ingestion of Sida carpinifolia is involved in the aetiology. We tested the hypothesis that it is an acquired lyosomal storage disease.

METHODS

Following the death of 3 ponies, all ponies from the premises were closely monitored; epidemiological data and clinical findings carefully recorded. Fragments of several organs, including CNS, were fixed in neutral formalin and embedded in paraffin-wax. Sections were stained with haematoxylin and eosin. Representative sections of the cerebellum and trigeminal ganglia were submitted to lectin histochemical procedures.

RESULTS

The neurological disorder, characterised by stiff gait, muscle tremors, abdominal pain and death, was observed on a farm with 3 hectares of pasture. Three of 11 ponies died 15-20 days after they had been introduced into a new paddock heavily infested by the plant Sida carpinifolia. No significant gross lesions were observed. The main histological findings included multiple cytoplasmatic vacuoles in swollen neurones in the brain, cerebellum, spinal cord, autonomic ganglia (trigeminal and celiac ganglia), and submucosal and myenteric plexus of the intestines. In the kidneys, there was marked vacuolation of the proximal convoluted tubular cells. Sections of cerebellum and trigeminal ganglion were submitted to lectin histochemistry. The vacuoles in different cerebellar and ganglion cells reacted strongly to the following lectins: Concanavalia ensiformis, Triticum vulgaris and succinylated-Triticum vulgaris.

CONCLUSIONS

The pattern of staining coincides with that of both swainsonine toxicosis and inherited mannosidosis reports. The histopathological changes were similar to those described in S. carpinifolia spontaneous and experimental poisoning in goats. This disease seems to be similar to Swainsona, Oxytropis and Astragalus toxicosis.

POTENTIAL RELEVANCE

S. carpinifolia should be evaluated as a possible cause in the diagnosis of equine neuropathies.

Substrate reduction therapy in mouse models of the glycosphingolipidoses

Substrate reduction therapy uses small molecules to slow the rate of glycolipid biosynthesis. One of these drugs, N-butyldeoxynojirimycin (NB-DNJ), shows efficacy in mouse models of Tay-Sachs, Sandhoff and Fabry diseases. This offers the prospect that NB-DNJ may be of therapeutic benefit, at least in the juvenile and adult onset variants of these disorders. The infantile onset variants will require an additional enzyme-augmenting modality if the pathology is to be significantly improved. A second drug, N-butyldeoxyglactonojirimycin, looks very promising for treating storage diseases with neurological involvement as high systemic dosing is achievable without any side-effects.

Hyperactivity, neuromotor defects, and impaired learning and memory in a mouse model for metachromatic leukodystrophy

Deficiency of arylsulfatase A (ASA) causes the autosomal recessive lipidosis, metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD). Performance on tests of activity, motor ability and learning/memory was assessed in ASA-deficient mice and normal controls at 3, 6 and 12 months-of-age. ASA-deficient mice showed consistently increased cage activity in all age groups, whereas open field activity was increased only in the 3-month-old group. Motor coordination and equilibrium, as tested in the rotarod test, was impaired in 12-month-old ASA-deficient mice. Passive avoidance learning was tested in the step-through box. Performance on this test was impaired in the 12-month-old group only. Spatial learning and memory abilities were tested in the Morris water maze. Six-month-old ASA-deficient mice displayed slightly impaired hidden-platform acquisition performance. Three-month-old animals, on the other hand, did not show any acquisition or retention defect on this task, notwithstanding significantly reduced swimming velocity. Acquisition training, both in the hidden- and visible-platform conditions of the Morris water maze, and retention performance during the probe trials were impaired in 12-month-old ASA-deficient mice. The hyperactivity, motor incoordination and slowing, and the age-related learning/memory defects, reported here in ASA-deficient mice, may relate to the decline of neuromotor and cognitive functions in MLD patients, and could be used as correlative or outcome measures in the study of MLD pathophysiology and treatment.

Inhibition of substrate synthesis as a strategy for glycolipid lysosomal storage disease therapy

The glycosphingolipid (GSL) lysosomal storage diseases are caused by mutations in the genes encoding the glycohydrolases that catabolize GSLs within lysosomes. In these diseases the substrate for the defective enzyme accumulates in the lysosome and the stored GSL leads to cellular dysfunction and disease. The diseases frequently have a progressive neurodegenerative course. The therapeutic options for treating these diseases are relatively limited, and for the majority there are no effective therapies. The problem is further compounded by difficulties in delivering therapeutic agents to the brain. Most research effort to date has focused on strategies for augmenting enzyme levels to compensate for the underlying defect. These include bone marrow transplantation (BMT), enzyme replacement and gene therapy. An alternative strategy that we have been exploring is substrate deprivation. This approach aims to balance the rate of GSL synthesis with the impaired rate of GSL breakdown. The imino sugar N-butyldeoxynojirimycin (NB-DNJ) inhibits the first step in GSL biosynthesis and has been used to evaluate this approach. Studies in an asymptomatic mouse model of Tay-Sachs disease have shown that substrate deprivation prevents GSL storage in the CNS. In a severe neurodegenerative mouse model of Sandhoff disease, substrate deprivation delayed the onset of symptoms and disease progression and significantly increased life expectancy. Combining NB-DNJ and BMT was found to be synergistic in the Sandhoff mouse model. A clinical trial in type I Gaucher disease has been undertaken and has shown beneficial effects. Efficacy was demonstrated on the basis of significant decreases in liver and spleen volumes, gradual but significant improvement in haematological parameters and disease activity markers, together with diminished GSL biosynthesis and storage as determined by independent biochemical assays. Further trials in type I Gaucher disease are in progress; studies are planned in patients with GSL storage in the CNS.

Sphingolipids and cell signalling

The sphingolipid storage disorders constitute a group of inherited metabolic disorders in which the structure of the stored sphingolipid and the corresponding genetic defect have been established. However, the pathological mechanism(s) behind the disorders has not been fully elucidated. Sphingolipids are known to be recognition molecules involved in intercell communication and altered expression might lead to dyscommunication. The impaired degradation and lysosomal accumulation of specific sphingolipids might influence the metabolism of other molecules and/or intracellular transport, which in turn might alter the distribution of these molecules. However, the progress of these diseases indicates that additional factors, besides the stored sphingolipid itself, might be involved. During the last decade, several sphingolipids have emerged as active participants in intracellular signalling processes such as growth control and apoptosis. Particular interest focused on the sphingolipid metabolites, ceramide and sphingosine, as potential mediators in intracellular events and an altered presence of these metabolites in sphingolipidoses cannot be ruled out. Some sphingolipids have been found to influence cytokine release and thereby might induce immunological processes, which are known to exist in at least one of the sphingolipidoses--Gaucher disease. These processes might already have a pathogenic effect during early development, before significant storage has occurred.