Conformation of an Shc-derived phosphotyrosine-containing peptide complexed with the Grb2 SH2 domain

Resurgence of phosphotyrosine binding domains: Structural and functional properties essential for understanding disease pathogenesis

BACKGROUND

Phosphotyrosine Binding (PTB) Domains, usually found on scaffold proteins, are pervasive in many cellular signaling pathways. These domains are the second-largest family of phosphotyrosine recognition domains and since their initial discovery, dozens of PTB domains have been structurally determined.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Due to its signature sequence flexibility, PTB domains can bind to a large variety of ligands including phospholipids. PTB peptide binding is divided into classical binding (canonical NPXY motifs) and non-classical binding (all other motifs). The first atypical PTB domain was discovered in cerebral cavernous malformation 2 (CCM2) protein, while only one third in size of the typical PTB domain, it remains functionally equivalent.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

PTB domains are involved in numerous signaling processes including embryogenesis, neurogenesis, and angiogenesis, while dysfunction is linked to major disorders including diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, Alzheimer's disease, and strokes. PTB domains may also be essential in infectious processes, currently responsible for the global pandemic in which viral cellular entry is suspected to be mediated through PTB and NPXY interactions.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

We summarize the structural and functional updates in the PTB domain over the last 20 years in hopes of resurging interest and further analyzing the importance of this versatile domain.

Redefining PTB domain into independently functional dual cores

Current understanding of phosphotyrosine binding (PTB) domain is limited. Recently, we revealed a novel atypical phosphotyrosine binding (aPTB) domain in CCM2, making it a dual PTB domain-containing protein. Since aPTB domain is only 1/3 of the size of typical PTB domain, we explored the possibility to decrease the size of PTB domain and demonstrate that the typical PTB domain can be divided into two similarly structural and functional cores that can independently bind to NPXY motif. Further, we reduced each PTB core into a minimum core motif (mCore) which is the functional unit of PTB domains and structurally similar to the novel aPTB domain. Based on structural data, we developed several cis- and trans-inhibitors for NPXY binding scheme, with potential applications for therapeutic strategies in human health conditions.

Crystal Structures and Thermodynamic Analysis Reveal Distinct Mechanisms of CD28 Phosphopeptide Binding to the Src Homology 2 (SH2) Domains of Three Adaptor Proteins

Full activation of T cells and differentiation into effector T cells are essential for many immune responses and require co-stimulatory signaling via the CD28 receptor. Extracellular ligand binding to CD28 recruits protein-tyrosine kinases to its cytoplasmic tail, which contains a YMNM motif. Following phosphorylation of the tyrosine, the proteins growth factor receptor-bound protein 2 (Grb2), Grb2-related adaptor downstream of Shc (Gads), and p85 subunit of phosphoinositide 3-kinase may bind to pYMNM (where pY is phosphotyrosine) via their Src homology 2 (SH2) domains, leading to downstream signaling to distinct immune pathways. These three adaptor proteins bind to the same site on CD28 with variable affinity, and all are important for CD28-mediated co-stimulatory function. However, the mechanism of how these proteins recognize and compete for CD28 is unclear. To visualize their interactions with CD28, we have determined the crystal structures of Gads SH2 and two p85 SH2 domains in complex with a CD28-derived phosphopeptide. The high resolution structures obtained revealed that, whereas the CD28 phosphopeptide bound to Gads SH2 is in a bent conformation similar to that when bound to Grb2 SH2, it adopts a more extended conformation when bound to the N- and C-terminal SH2 domains of p85. These differences observed in the peptide-protein interactions correlated well with the affinity and other thermodynamic parameters for each interaction determined by isothermal titration calorimetry. The detailed insight into these interactions reported here may inform the development of compounds that specifically inhibit the association of CD28 with these adaptor proteins to suppress excessive T cell responses, such as in allergies and autoimmune diseases.

Discovery of thioether-bridged cyclic pentapeptides binding to Grb2-SH2 domain with high affinity

Blocking the interaction between phosphotyrosine (pTyr)-containing activated receptors and the Src homology 2 (SH2) domain of the growth factor receptor-bound protein 2 (Grb 2) is considered to be an effective and non-cytotoxic strategy to develop new anti-proliferate agents due to its potential to shut down the Ras activation pathway. In this study, a series of phosphotyrosine containing cyclic pentapeptides were designed and synthesized based upon the phage library derived cyclopeptide, G1TE. A comprehensive SAR study was also carried out to develop potent Grb2-SH2 domain antagonists based upon this novel template. With both the peptidomimetic optimization of the amino acid side-chains and the constraint of the backbone conformation guided by molecular modeling, we developed several potent antagonists with low micromolar range binding affinity, such as cyclic peptide 15 with an K(d)=0.359microM, which is providing a novel template for the development of Grb2-SH2 domain antagonists as potential therapeutics for certain cancers.

Structure-based design of potent Grb2–SH2 domain antagonists not relying on phosphotyrosine mimics

Development of Grb2-SH2 domain antagonists is considered to be an effective and non-cytotoxic strategy to develop new antiproliferative agents because of their potential to shut down the Ras signaling pathway. We developed a concise route for the efficient synthesis of G1TE analogs on solid phase. Using this route, a series of cyclic peptides that do not rely on phosphotyrosine or its mimics were designed and synthesized based upon the phage library-derived cyclopeptide, G1TE. Considering that Gly7 plays prominent roles for G1TE binding to the Grb2-SH2 domain, we introduced different amino acids in the 7th position. The D-Ala7-containing peptide 3 demonstrates improved binding affinity by adopting favorable conformation for protein binding. This can be rationalized by molecular modeling. The optimization at the Leu2 position was also studied, and the resulting cyclopeptides exhibited remarkably improved binding affinity. Based upon these global modifications, a highly potent peptide ligand 9 was discovered with a Kd = 17 nM, evaluated by Biacore binding assay. This new analog is one of the most potent non-phosphorus-containing Grb2-SH2 antagonists reported to date. This potent peptidomimetic provides a new template for the development of non-pTyr containing Grb2-SH2 domain antagonists and acts as a chemotherapeutic lead for the treatment of erbB2-related cancer.

Binding affinity difference induced by the stereochemistry of the sulfoxide bridge of the cyclic peptide inhibitors of Grb2-SH2 domain: NMR studies for the structural origin

The SAR study on a phage library-derived non-phosphorylated cyclic peptide ligand of Grb2-SH2 domain indicates that the configuration of the cyclization linkage is crucial for assuming the active binding conformation. When the thioether linkage was oxidized to the two chiral sulfoxides, the R-configured sulfoxide-cyclized peptide displayed 10-30 times more potency than the corresponding S-configured one in binding affinity to the Grb2-SH2 domain. In this paper, the solution structures of such a pair of sulfoxide-bridged cyclic peptide diastereoisomers, i.e., cyclo[CH(2)CO-Gla(1)-L-Y-E-N-V-G-NPG-Y-(R/S)C(O)(10)]-amide, were determined by NMR and molecular dynamics simulation. Results indicate that the consensus sequence of Y(3)-E(4)-N(5)-V(6) in both diastereoisomers adopt a beta-turn conformation; however, the R-configured peptide forms an extended structure with a circular backbone conformation, while the S-configured isomer forms a compact structure with key residues buried inside the molecule. The average root-mean-square deviations were found to be 0.756 and 0.804 A, respectively. It is apparent that the chiral S-->O group played a key role in the solution structures of the sulfoxide-bridged cyclic peptides. The R-sulfoxide group forms an intramolecular hydrogen bond with the C-terminal amide, conferring a more rigid conformation with all residues protruding outside except for Leu2, in which the Gla1 and Tyr3 share an overlapping function as previous SAR studies proposed. Additionally, the extended structure endows a more hydrophilic binding surface of the R-configured peptide to facilitate its capture by its targeted protein. In comparison, the S-configured sulfoxide was embedded inside the ligand peptide leading to a compact structure, in which the essential residues of Gla1, Tyr3, and Asn5 form multiple intramolecular hydrogen bonds resulting in an unfavorable conformational change and a substantial loss of the interaction with the protein. The solution structures disclosed by our NMR and molecular dynamics simulation studies provide a molecular basis for understanding how the chirality of the cyclization linkage remarkably discriminates in terms of the binding affinity, thus advancing the rational design of potent non-phosphorylated inhibitors of Grb2-SH2 domain as antitumor agents.

Structure-based design of thioether-bridged cyclic phosphopeptides binding to Grb2-SH2 domain

A series of phosphotyrosine containing cyclic peptides was designed and synthesized based upon the phage library derived cyclopeptide, G1TE. Considering the type-I beta-turn feature of peptidic ligand binding to Grb2 SH2 domain, we introduce alpha,alpha-disubstituted cyclic amino acid, Ach, into the 4th position of the cyclic peptide to induce a local right handed 3(10) helical conformation. In order to stabilize the favorable binding conformation, the bulky and hydrophobic amino acids, neopentylglycine (NPG) and phenylalanine, were introduced into the 8th and 2nd positions of the peptide ligand, respectively. To facilitate the sidechain of pTyr3 reaching into the phosphotyrosine binding pocket, a less bulky alanine was preferred in position 1. Based upon these global modifications, a highly potent peptide ligand 12 was discovered with an IC(50)=1.68 nM, evaluated by ELISA binding essay. Ligand 12 is at least 10(5) more potent than the lead peptide, termed G1TE.

N-terminal carboxyl and tetrazole-containing amides as adjuvants to Grb2 SH2 domain ligand binding

High affinity binding of peptides to Src homology 2 (SH2) domains, often requires the presence of phosphotyrosyl (pTyr) or pTyr-mimicking moieties in the N-terminal position of the binding ligand. Several reports have shown that N(alpha)-acylation of the critical pTyr residue can result in increased SH2 domain binding potency. For Grb2 SH2 domains which recognize pTyr-Xxx-Asn-NH(2) motifs, significant potency enhancement can be incurred by N(alpha)-(3-amino)Z derivatization of tripeptides such as pTyr-Ile-Asn-NH(2). Using ligands based on the high affinity pY-Ac(6)c-Asn-(naphthylpropylamide) motif, (where Ac(6)c=1-aminocyclohexanecarboxylic acid), additional reports have shown moderate potentiating effects of N(alpha)-oxalyl derivatization. The current study examined variations of the N(alpha)-oxalyl theme in the context of a Xxx-Ac(6)c-Asn-(naphthylpropylamide) platform, where Xxx=the hydrolytically stable pTyr mimetics phosphonomethyl phenylalanine (Pmp) or carboxymethyl phenylalanine (Cmf). The effects of N(alpha)-(3-amino)Z derivatization were also investigated for this platform, to ascertain whether the large binding enhancement reported for tripeptides such as pTyr-Ile-Asn-NH(2) could be observed. In ELISA-based extracellular Grb2 SH2 domain binding assays, it was found for the Pmp-based series, that extending the oxalyl carboxyl out by one methylene unit or replacing carboxyl functionality with a tetrazole isostere, resulted in binding potency greater than the parent N(alpha)-acetyl-containing compound, with enhancement approximating that observed for the N(alpha)-oxalyl derivative. When Cmf was used as the pTyr mimetic, only modest differences in IC(50) values were observed for the series. Examination of the N(alpha)-(3-amino)Z derivatized Pmp-Ac(6)c-Asn-(naphthylpropylamide), showed that binding affinity was reduced relative to the parent N(alpha)-acetyl analogue, in contrast to the reported significant enhancement of affinity observed with other peptide ligands. Treatment of MDA-453 tumor cells, which are mitogenically driven through erbB-2 tyrosine kinase-dependent pathways, with Pmp-containing inhibitors resulted in growth inhibition, with the N(alpha)-oxalyl and N(alpha)-malonyl-containing compounds exhibiting IC(50) values (4.3 and 4.6 microM, respectively) approximately five-fold lower than the parent N(alpha)-acetyl-containing compound. Tetrazole and N(alpha)-(3-amino)Z-containing inhibitors were from two- to four-fold less potent than these latter analogues in the growth inhibition assays.

Dimer formation through domain swapping in the crystal structure of the Grb2-SH2-Ac-pYVNV complex

Src homology 2 (SH2) domains are key modules in intracellular signal transduction. They link activated cell surface receptors to downstream targets by binding to phosphotyrosine-containing sequence motifs. The crystal structure of a Grb2-SH2 domain-phosphopeptide complex was determined at 2.4 A resolution. The asymmetric unit contains four polypeptide chains. There is an unexpected domain swap so that individual chains do not adopt a closed SH2 fold. Instead, reorganization of the EF loop leads to an open, nonglobular fold, which associates with an equivalent partner to generate an intertwined dimer. As in previously reported crystal structures of canonical Grb2-SH2 domain-peptide complexes, each of the four hybrid SH2 domains in the two domain-swapped dimers binds the phosphopeptide in a type I beta-turn conformation. This report is the first to describe domain swapping for an SH2 domain. While in vivo evidence of dimerization of Grb2 exists, our SH2 dimer is metastable and a physiological role of this new form of dimer formation remains to be demonstrated.

Inhibition of Grb2 SH2 domain binding by non-phosphate-containing ligands. 2. 4-(2-Malonyl)phenylalanine as a potent phosphotyrosyl mimetic

Nonhydrolyzable phosphotyrosyl (pTyr) mimetics serve as important components of many competitive Grb2 SH2 domain inhibitors. To date, the most potent of these inhibitors have relied on phosphonate-based structures to replace the 4-phosphoryl group of the parent pTyr residue. Reported herein is the design and evaluation of a new pTyr mimetic, p-malonylphenylalanine (Pmf), which does not contain phosphorus yet, in Grb2 SH2 domain binding systems, approaches the potency of phosphonate-based pTyr mimetics. When incorporated into high affinity Grb2 SH2 domain-directed platforms, Pmf is 15-20 times more potent than the closely related previously reported pTyr mimetic, O-malonyltyrosine (OMT). Pmf-containing inhibitors show inhibition constants as low as 8 nM in extracellular Grb2 binding assays and in whole cell systems, effective blockade of both endogenous Grb2 binding to cognate erbB-2, and downstream MAP kinase activation. Evidence is provided that use of an N(alpha)()-oxalyl auxiliary enhances effectiveness of Pmf and other inhibitors in both extracellular and intracellular contexts. As one of the most potent Grb2 SH2 domain-directed pTyr mimetics yet disclosed, Pmf may potentially have utility in the design of new chemotherapeutics for the treatment of various proliferative diseases, including breast cancer.

Solution structure and dynamics of G1TE, a nonphosphorylated cyclic peptide inhibitor for the Grb2 SH2 domain

The solution structure and dynamics of G1TE, a nonphosphorylated cyclic peptide inhibitor for the Grb2 SH2 domain, was determined using two-dimensional NMR and simulated annealing methods. G1TE consists of 10 amino acids and a C-terminal Cys cyclized through its side-chain sulfur atom by a thioether linkage to its N terminus. The results indicate that G1TE assumes a circle-like shape in solution in which all the side chains are protruding outside, and none of the residues are involved in intramolecular hydrogen bonding. The average root-mean-square deviations were found to be 0.41 +/- 0.11 A for the backbone heavy atoms C, Calpha, and N, and 1.03 +/- 0.14 A for all heavy atoms in a family of 10 structures. (15)N relaxation measurements indicate that G1TE has rather restricted dynamics in the fast time scale within its backbone. However, residues Tyr3, Val6, and Gly7 may be involved in a possible conformational exchange. The structural comparison between G1TE in solution and the BCR-Abl phosphopeptide bound to Grb2 SH2 domain revealed that G1TE may form a larger circle-like binding surface than the BCR-Abl phosphopeptide in the bound form. Also, the restricted backbone dynamics of G1TE may result in a reduced loss of entropy and can compensate for the absence of a phosphate group at the Tyr3 position. These structural and dynamic properties of G1TE may provide a molecular basis for understanding its interactions with the Grb2 SH2 domain.

Significant compensatory role of position Y-2 conferring high affinity to non-phosphorylated inhibitors of Grb2-SH2 domain

Systematic modification of amino acid at position Y-2 of a library-derived non-phosporylated thioether-cyclized peptide, cyclo(CH2CO-Glu2-Leu-Tyr0-Glu-Asn-Val-Gly-Met-Tyr-Cys) -amide, aided by molecular modeling, demonstrates that the Glu(-2) sidechain compensates for the absence of Tyr0 phosphorylation in retaining effective binding to Grb2-SH2 domain. Replacement of Glu(-2) with gamma-carboxyglutamic acid produced a high affinity inhibitor, the first example with submicromolar affinity (IC50 = 640 nM).

Structural and conformational requirements for high-affinity binding to the SH2 domain of Grb2(1)

Following earlier work on cystine-bridged peptides, cyclic phosphopeptides containing nonreducible mimics of cystine were synthesized that show high affinity and specificity toward the Src homology (SH2) domain of the growth factor receptor-binding protein (Grb2). Replacement of the cystine in the cyclic heptapeptide cyclo(CYVNVPC) by D-alpha-acetylthialysine or D-alpha-lysine gave cyclo(YVNVP(D-alpha-acetyl-thiaK)) (22) and cyclo(YVNVP(D-alpha-acetyl-K)) (30), which showed improved binding 10-fold relative to that of the control peptide KPFYVNVEF (1). NMR spectroscopy and molecular modeling experiments indicate that a beta-turn conformation centered around YVNV is essential for high-affinity binding. X-ray structure analyses show that the linear peptide 1 and the cyclic compound 21 adopt a similar binding mode with a beta-turn conformation. Our data confirm the unique structural requirements of the ligand binding site of the SH2 domain of Grb2. Moreover, the potency of our cyclic lactams can be explained by the stabilization of the beta-turn conformation by three intramolecular hydrogen bonds (one mediated by an H2O molecule). These stable and easily accessible cyclic peptides can serve as templates for the evaluation of phosphotyrosine surrogates and further chemical elaboration.

Monocarboxylic-based phosphotyrosyl mimetics in the design of GRB2 SH2 domain inhibitors

Three monocarboxylic-containing analogues, O-carboxymethyltyrosine (cmT, 5), 4-(carboxymethyl)phenylalanine (cmF, 6), and 4-(carboxydifluoromethyl)phenylalanine (F2cmF, 7) were utilized as phosphotyrosyl (pTyr) replacements in a high affinity B-bend mimicking platform, where they exhibited IC50 values of 2.5 microM, 65 microM and 28 microM, respectively, in a Grb2 SH2 domain Biacore binding assay. When a terminal N(alpha)-oxalyl axillary was utilized to enhance ligand interactions with a critical SH2 domain Arg67 residue (alphaA-helix), binding potencies increased from 4- to 10-fold, resulting in submicromolar affinity for cmF (IC50 = 0.6 microM) and low micromolar affinity for F2cmF (IC50 = 2 microM). Cell lysate binding studies also showed inhibition of cognate Grb2 binding to the p185erbB-2 phosphoprotein in the same rank order of potency as observed in the Biacore assay. These results indicate the potential value of cmF and F2cmF residues as pTyr mimetics for the study of Grb2 SH2 domains and suggest new strategies for improvements in inhibitor design.