Accessory cell-dependent selection of specific T-cell functions

Recent advances in photoelectrochemical cells (PECs) for organic synthesis

The application of PECs in organic synthesis reactions and their reaction mechanisms are highlighted.

B lymphocytes in vivo fail to prime naive T cells but can stimulate antigen-experienced T lymphocytes

The ability of B cells or macrophages and dendritic cells (DC) to elicit class II-restricted T cell responses in vivo was compared using a mouse chimera model. Severe combined immunodeficient (SCID) mice (H-2d), reconstituted either with T or T+B lymphocytes from (H-2d x H-2b) donors, were immunized subcutaneously with protein antigen (Ag) to induce a class II-restricted T cell response. The frequency and major histocompatibility complex restriction of the resulting Ag-specific T cells were analyzed to establish whether B cells were necessary for the induction of class II-restricted T cell responses, and to determine the cell type on which priming had occurred. The results indicated that: (a) B cells are not necessary for the induction of a class II-restricted T cell response in vivo, as the frequencies of interleukin 2 (IL-2)- or IL-3-secreting T cells induced in the presence or absence of B cells were comparable. (b) Activation of naive T cells requires presentation of Ag on DC; Ag presented only on B cells is not sufficient to elicit a response. No H-2b-restricted, IL-3-secreting cells could in fact be detected in SCID mice reconstituted with naive (H-2d x H-2b) T cells and nonimmune or antigen-primed (H-2d x H-2b) B cells. (c) Previously primed T cells are able to be stimulated by Ag presented by both B cells and DC. H-2b-restricted, IL-3-secreting cells could in fact be readily demonstrated in SCID mice reconstituted with antigen-primed (H-2d x H-2b) T and B cells. Irrespective of whether the T cells were naive or previously activated, B cells were able to respond with an Ag-specific immunoglobulin G response, indicating that B cells were functional and able to present Ag in order to receive specific T cell help. Therefore, it appears that B cells are not necessary and do not participate in the initial priming of T cells; however, Ag presented by B cells can reactivate previously primed T cells. Taken together, these data indicate that during the course of an immune response Ag is first presented to naive T cells via DC, and only subsequently primed T cells can be stimulated by Ag presented by B cells.

Functional heterogeneity of CD4-positive T-cell subsets: the correlation between effector functions and lymphokine secretion is limited

Several effector functions and the lymphokine secretion pattern of 30 antigen-specific CD4+ T-cell clones have been investigated. The clones were generated directly by limiting dilution cloning of nylon wool-purified T-cells obtained from KLH immunized BALB/c mice and avoiding an initial bulk culture phase. Using this approach the CD4+ T-cell clones were grouped into helper and nonhelper subsets. Among the helper subset, clones which helped B-cells for specific antibody production by either cognate or noncognate recognition were identified. Some but not all of these helper clones fitted into the Th1 and Th2 scheme, if the lymphokine secretion pattern was evaluated. Among the nonhelper subset CD4+ clones which killed activated APC in a MHC class II-restricted and antigen-specific manner were identified. In addition, one clone which suppressed B-cell antibody production mediated by helper clones was found. However, neither the suppression of antibody responses nor the inability of the nonhelper clones to help B-cells is due to the killing of B-cells. Various attempts were made to convert nonhelper into helper clones and helper into killer clones, without success. Thus, the functional properties of these clones are stable traits and not convertible by varying the experimental conditions.

Mechanisms of dendritic cell function

There is now considerable evidence, from in vivo and in vitro studies, supporting the claim that dendritic cells are the principal accessory cells of the vertebrate immune system. Until recently, however, the biology of the dendritic cell accessory mechanism has remained obscure. Here, Philip King and David Katz review recent findings that have clarified several aspects of this mechanism, providing a possible basis for the potent T-cell stimulating capacity of the dendritic cell, and yielding clues to the ontogenetic relationships of these cells and to their role in immunopathology.

Evidence for a subpopulation of antigen-presenting cells specific for the induction of the delayed-type hypersensitivity response

Young adult SJL mice (8 weeks of age or younger) do not mount a delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response due to the failure of a macrophage antigen-presenting cell (APC) to induce TDTH effector cells. SJL mice that are 10 weeks of age or older produce a normal DTH response. This genetic defect provides a model for the investigation of functional subpopulations of APC which interact with specific subpopulations of T cells. In this study, we used this model to examine whether macrophage APC impairment involves APC-dependent immune responses other than DTH. No age-dependent differences were found in the ability of spleen cells from SJL mice to proliferate and synthesize interleukin-2 in response to concanavalin A; nor was the proliferative response to a variety of antigenic stimuli affected. In addition, no differences were observed in the contact sensitivity response or in the in vitro generation of allogeneic cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). In contrast, the in vivo generation of allogeneic CTL was significantly depressed in 6-week-old SJL and could not be restored to normal by the adoptive transfer of macrophages from DTH responsive 12-week-old SJL mice. Finally, examination of the humoral response of 6-week-old SJL indicated no impairment in IgM or IgG serum antibody levels or in the induction of splenic B cells. Thus, the macrophage APC regulating the induction of TDTH effector cells does not appear to participate in the induction of T helper cells for other cellular and humoral responses. These data support the hypothesis that distinct subpopulations of APC may regulate the induction of specific immune effector mechanisms.

Regulation of constitutive and lymphokine-induced Ia expression by murine alpha-fetoprotein

alpha-Fetoprotein (AFP) has been shown to suppress a variety of immune responses in vitro. The immunosuppressive properties of AFP can be partly attributed to the ability of this protein to decrease the cell surface expression of Ia antigens on macrophages. The experiments described in this report define more precisely the regulatory effects of AFP on Ia expression. Using the "dendritic-like" cell line P388 AD2 and bone marrow-derived macrophages we have shown that AFP can suppress the constitutive expression of cell surface Ia antigens. This decrease is detectable on the cell surface 24 hr after the addition of AFP. In further experiments we also examined the effect of AFP on lymphokine-induced Ia expression. Our results show that AFP has no suppressive influence on the inductive phase of lymphokine-induced Ia antigen expression but can decrease elevated levels of Ia antigen subsequent to their induction.

Melanophages in inflammatory skin disease demonstrate the surface phenotype of OKM5+ antigen-presenting cells and activated macrophages

Previous studies in our laboratory revealed that ultraviolet light induces the appearance of epidermal melanophages that have potent antigen-presenting ability, that can activate autoreactive T cells, and that exhibit the immunophenotype OKM5+, OKM1-, T6-, and DR+. Therefore we undertook immunophenotyping of melanophages in selected inflammatory mucocutaneous lesions to determine whether the OKM5+, OKM1- phenotype was limited to ultraviolet-induced inflammation or whether the occurrence of melanophages expressing this antigen-presenting cell phenotype was a more generalized phenomenon. Ten of the eleven patients with chronic inflammatory skin lesions demonstrated melanophages expressing the OKM5+, OKM1-, T6-, DR+ immunophenotype. In addition, they often expressed Mo3e, a marker of activated macrophages. In contrast, melanophages of a patient with post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, although DR+, failed to express OKM5. These results are taken to support an active role for OKM5+, OKM1-, T6-, DR+ melanophages in inflammatory skin disease because these cells demonstrate the phenotype of activated inflammation-producing monocytes and potent antigen-presenting cells.

Antigen presenting cells in human decidual tissue: III. Role of accessory cells in the activation of suppressor cells

Human decidual antigen presenting cells (DAPCs) exposed to fetal cells in vitro induce generation of suppressor T cells among a population of peripheral blood lymphocytes. Human lymphocyte antigen (HLA)-class II positive antigen presenting cells were isolated from early normal human decidual tissue and from peripheral blood (PAPCs) by adhering Ficoll-Paque separated cell suspensions to fibronectin. In contrast to PAPCs, DAPCs pulsed with fetal antigens induced a radio-sensitive, Leu 1,2-positive T suppressor cell population. A nylon wool adherent B cell population is required during the in vitro induction of the suppressor cells. These suppressor cells impair primary mitogen and mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) responses, generation of anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) cytotoxic T lymphocytes, and antibody response of autologous and allogeneic lymphocytes. Only intact viable embryonic cells can effectively confer upon DAPCs the ability to induce T suppressor cells. The T suppressor cell induction by DAPCs primed with fetal antigens is restricted by the major histocompatibility complex. Our results show that the HLA-DR molecules are the most prominent restriction elements.

Analysis of murine lymphocyte subpopulations by dual-color flow cytometry: technical considerations and specificities of monoclonal antibodies directed against surface markers

We performed detailed phenotypic analysis of murine lymphocytes from thymus, spleen, lymph node, and peripheral blood using commercially available monoclonal antibodies, each with specificities for membrane surface markers and dual-color flow cytometry. Erythrocyte lysis techniques were utilized for lymphocyte preparation so that inherent difficulties with gradient techniques would be avoided, such as the potential for loss of abnormally sized cells. These studies demonstrated that the specificities of each monoclonal must be carefully determined; for example, the Lyt-1 monoclonal, frequently utilized to identify helper/inducer T cells, also reacts with suppressor/cytotoxic (Lyt-2+) cells; helper/inducer cells are better studied with a more recently available monoclonal, L3T4. Cells from different tissues may differ greatly not only in the presence of surface markers, but also in the surface density of each marker; this density can be studied and quantitated using appropriate analytic software. We also show that larger and more granular lymphocytes appear to be enriched for surface Ia antigen, indicating that these cells may be activated or regulatory subsets; these large, Ia+ T-cells will be lost from analysis if standard, narrow gate settings are used for analyzing forward and side-scatter characteristics or for cell sorting.

High efficiency antigen presentation by thyroglobulin-primed murine splenic B cells

B cells primed in vivo with mouse or rat thyroglobulin present these antigens at very low concentrations to CH9, an Ly 1+2- T cell hybridoma specific for mouse and rat thyroglobulin. Presentation measured by interleukin 2 release from CH9 is sensitive to treatment with a monoclonal antibody eliminating splenic B cells but is unaffected by anti-Thy-1.2 or 33D1 (which destroy T cells and dendritic cells, respectively). Presentation is specific for the priming antigen and is blocked by preincubation of the B cells with sheep anti-mouse F(ab')2. We suggest that in this system, primed B cells present thyroglobulin and that this may represent a means by which an initial triggering event priming both B and T cells could allow maintenance of autoreactive responses in vivo in the presence of low concentrations of circulating antigen.

Characterization of suppressor-inducer cells which control the production of rat erythrocyte-induced anti-erythrocyte autoantibodies

Mice immunized with rat erythrocytes produce autoantibodies to their own red blood cells, distinct anti-rat agglutinins and autoantigen-specific suppressor cells. Suppressor cells were detected by adoptive transfer of rat erythrocyte-immunized spleen cells to naive recipients. Such recipients failed to make erythrocyte autoantibodies after immunization with rat erythrocytes although their anti-rat erythrocyte response was unimpaired. Depletion and enrichment studies were performed to identify the cell type(s) which transfer suppression. B cell depletion of rat erythrocyte-immunized spleen cells by passage over Ig/anti-Ig-coated bead columns abrogated the transfer of suppression. However, suppression was still transferred after rat erythrocyte immunized spleen cells were passed over beads coated with a complex of 4-azido-2-nitrophenyl (NAP)-mouse IgG-rabbit IgG anti-NAP suggesting that T cells bearing Fc gamma receptors are not responsible for suppression. Positively selected B cells from rat erythrocyte-immunized spleen cells caused some suppression of erythrocyte autoantibodies but only after high numbers of cells were transferred. Neither positively selected Lyt-1+2- nor Lyt-1-2+ T cell subpopulations transferred suppression. By contrast, rat erythrocyte-immunized spleen cells which contained a mixture of B memory and T cells were suppressive and retained their suppressor activity after removal of Lyt-1-2+ but not Lyt-1+2- cells. It is proposed that these Lyt-1+2-T cells belong to a distinct population of suppressor-inducer cells which together with memory B cells stimulate the generation of effector T suppressor cells in naive recipients.

The mechanism of antigen presentation by dendritic cells and splenic adherent cells in the induction of an allogeneic cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response to H-2Kk liposomes

Induction of an allogeneic cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response to purified alloantigen is partially dependent on uptake and processing of the class I alloantigen by antigen-presenting cells (APC) followed by recognition of the alloantigen and self Ia by helper T cells (TH). The activated TH provides the helper signal(s) to the alloantigen-specific CTL for proliferation and differentiation into an active effector CTL. The role of antigen processing and presentation of major histocompatibility complex alloantigens was examined and the ability of different types of APC to present purified H-2Kk liposomes was investigated. Splenic adherent cells (SAC), splenic dendritic cells (DC), and B-cell lymphoblastoid lines were all shown to be effective in the presentation of H-2Kk liposomes. The relative ability of these cells to serve as APC was determined to be DC greater than B-cell tumors greater than SAC. The role of processing of H-2Kk liposomes by SAC and DC was examined by investigating the effect of weak bases on pulsing of the APC. These experiments suggest that presentation of alloantigen by both SAC and DC involves a step which is sensitive to inhibition by weak bases. We examined whether the TH were activated by similar mechanisms when stimulated by the various APC. The functional involvement of the T-cell surface marker L3T4 was demonstrated in the induction of TH. In contrast, L3T4 was not involved in the subsequent generation of CTL since monoclonal antibody (MAb) specific for L3T4 was not effective in blocking CTL function in the presence of nonspecific T helper factor (THF). Similarly, Ia on the APC was shown to be involved in the stimulation of the TH pathway but not directly in the differentiation of the CTL. Thus, DC and B cells in addition to SAC can present H-2Kk to TH. The presentation of alloantigen by both cell types may involve an intracellular route as demonstrated by the blocking of the TH response by weak bases. Both Ia and L3T4 are required on the APC for induction of the TH response. The minimal requirements for activation of the CTL were H-2Kk liposomes and a source of THF.

Antigen-presenting OKM5+ melanophages appear in human epidermis after ultraviolet radiation

Ultraviolet radiation of murine skin in vivo or epidermal cells (EC) in vitro dramatically inhibits the antigen-presenting capacity of EC in vitro and results in the inhibition of immune responses to antigen challenge. In humans, UV exposure in vivo markedly inhibits alloantigen presentation by EC in the EC-lymphocyte reaction (ELR) when EC are harvested immediately after the administration of 4 times the minimal erythema dose (4 MED), whereas EC harvested 72 h after 4 MED (UV-EC) exhibit enhanced allostimulatory capacity in the ELR. This enhanced ELR reactivity is due to the appearance, in the epidermis, of bone marrow-derived OKT6- DR+ cells which are distinct from Langerhans cells (LC) in their lack of surface OKT6 and in their ultrastructural morphology. This report focuses on the phenotype and function of T6- Dr+ UV-EC and on their relationship to known human antigen presenting cell (APC) subsets. Approximately 60% of T6- Dr+ UV-EC bore the monocyte marker defined by monoclonal antibody OKM5, but lacked determinants recognized by OKM1, Leu M1, Leu M3, Leu M4, Leu M5, and Mac1. All T6- Dr+ UV-EC bore the class II MHC antigen HLA-DQ (DC/DS), which is associated with a specialized subset of antigen-presenting monocytes capable of stimulation in the autologous mixed leukocyte reaction (AMLR). Panning of OKM5+ UV-EC resulted in a population of cells which was markedly enriched in melanophages and which exhibited potent alloantigen-presenting capacity in the ELR. Since OKM5+ T6- Dr+ UV-EC were similar to the specialized APC minor subset of OKM1- OKM5+ blood monocytes both in phenotype and in apparent phagocytic function, we examined other APC functions of UV-EC to assess the extent of this analogy. Relative to control EC (containing only LC as APC), UV-EC (containing functionally inactivated LC but many T6- Dr+ APC) induced significantly greater degrees of T-cell proliferation in the presence of either tetanus toxoid antigen or the mitogen concanavalin A. UV-EC, as well as panning-purified OKM5+ UV-EC, were also able to induce autologous T-cell proliferation in the absence of added antigen (autologous ELR), in contrast to control EC which were poor stimulators of an autologous ELR. Thus, although human EC 72 h after UV exposure are numerically and functionally depleted of LC, at least 2 additional subsets of T6- Dr+ APC appear in the epidermis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The defect in delayed-type hypersensitivity of young adult SJL mice is due to a lack of functional antigen-presenting cells

SJL mice exhibit a strain-specific age-dependent delay in the maturation of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responsiveness. They do not attain "adult" levels of DTH responsiveness until the 10th week of age, which is 4 to 6 weeks later than the other strains of mice tested. In this report we demonstrate that spleen cells, resident peritoneal cells and thioglycollate-elicited peritoneal exudate cells are all able to transfer DTH responsiveness from naive 12-week-old DTH responders to 6-week-old nonresponders. Transfer prior to immunization was more efficient at eliciting a response than transfer after immunization. As few as 5 X 10(4) cells from 12-week-old SJL mice can adoptively transfer responsiveness to unresponsive 6-week-old animals. The active cell was found to be adherent, radiation (2000 rds) resistant, I-A+, Thy-1- and Mac-1+. I-A compatibility between the adoptively transferred population and the nonresponder mice is required. These data suggest that young adult SJL mice lack a functional population of antigen-presenting cells specific for DTH and that the appearance of these cells is under maturational control.

Induction of IgE-secreting cells and IgE isotype-specific suppressor T cells in the respiratory lymph nodes of rats in response to antigen inhalation

Repeated exposure of high-IgE-responder Brown Norway (BN) rats to an aerosol of ovalbumin (OVA) once weekly triggered progressively increasing levels of OVA-specific IgG in serum. In contrast, responses in the IgE class were transient, declining from peak titers during the third week to background levels by Week 5, despite continuing aerosol exposure. Subsequent parenteral challenge of these animals revealed a state of antigen- and IgE isotype-specific tolerance. Adoptive transfer of splenocytes or pooled respiratory tract lymph node (RTLN) cells from aerosol-exposed animals to naive rats abrogated subsequent OVA-specific primary IgE responses in the recipients, but did not affect specific IgG responses, and kinetic studies indicated that these suppressor cells arose first in the RTLN. Transfer studies employing individual lymph node groups which constituted the RTLN pool pinpointed the superficial cervical nodes, which drain the uppermost portion of the respiratory tract, as the major source of suppressor cells. Fractionation of cell populations before adoptive transfer employing monoclonal antibodies directed against T-cell markers, defined a population of suppressor cells generated by aerosol exposure which expressed both the W3/13 (pan T-cell) and OX8 (cytotoxic/suppressor T-cell) antigens, but which was negative for the W3/25 (helper T-cell) marker. Analysis of the IgE and IgG responses induced by OVA inhalation was performed employing the ELISA plaque technique, recently developed in this laboratory. These studies revealed the parathymic and posterior mediastinal nodes draining the lower lung, as the major sites of specific IgE and IgG production; smaller numbers of OVA-specific IgG-secreting cells (but none secreting specific IgE) were detected in the nodes draining the upper respiratory tract, while antibody secretion outside the respiratory tract was restricted to comparatively few cells in the spleen. The ELISA plaque assay was also employed to enumerate total numbers of cells secreting the IgE isotype in aerosol-exposed and control rats, employing samples from 10 different lymphoid organs. Approximately 50% of the IgE-secreting cells in these animals were localized in RTLN, as opposed to 25% in gut-associated lymphoid tissues. These data are discussed in relation to the pivotal role of respiratory-tract associated lymphoid tissues in regulation of IgE responses to aeroallergens.

Evaluation of accessory cell heterogeneity. III. Role of dendritic cells in the in vitro activation of the antibody response to soluble antigens

Dendritic cells and macrophages obtained from spleen and peritoneal exudate were tested as accessory cells for the activation of lymphokine production by T cells, for supporting T-B cooperation and for the induction of antigen-specific T helper cells. Dendritic cells as well as macrophages were able to activate T cells for interleukin-2 secretion and functioned as accessory cells in T-B cooperation, but only macrophages induced T helper cells, which cooperate with B cells by a linked recognition interaction, to soluble antigens. Dendritic cell- and antigen-activated T cells also did not help B cells in the presence of Con A supernatants which contained various T cell- and B cell-stimulatory factors. The failure of dendritic cells to differentiate memory into functional T helper cells, but their efficient accessory cell function in T-B cooperation, where functional T helper cells are already present, can be best explained by a differential accessory cell requirement for T helper cell activation dependent on the differentiation stage of the T helper cell.

Antigen-presenting capacity of mouse decidual tissue and placenta

The antigen-presenting capacity of cells within mouse decidual tissue and the fetal placenta was assessed using the antigen-presenting cell assay to measure immune T cell proliferation stimulated by a second presentation of antigen. Cells within decidual tissue bind and present the soluble antigen dinitrophenylated ovalbumin in an antigen-specific and major histocompatibility complex-restricted manner. Antigen-presenting cells (APCs) were detected in decidual tissue from day 8 until day 15 of pregnancy, in deciduoma and in fetal placental tissues. These findings show that cells within decidual tissue may serve as APCs with the ability to process and present fetal antigens to the maternal immune system and may therefore determine the direction of the maternal immune response of pregnancy.

Evaluation of accessory cell heterogeneity. II. Failure of dendritic cells to activate antigen-specific T helper cells to soluble antigens

The activation of antigen-specific T cells requires Ia+, antigen-presenting accessory cells (AC). Dendritic cells (DC) and macrophages (M phi) isolated from spleen an peritoneal exudate were tested as AC for the activation of the activation of T helper cells and the induction of T cell proliferation. The cell separations to obtain DC and splenic M phi were performed by discontinuous bovine serum albumin gradients, adherence on petri dishes and rosetting with opsonized sheep erythrocytes. DC as well as the M phi were able to induce antigen-specific T cell proliferation, but only the M phi and not the DC activated antigen-specific T helper cells which help B cells for antibody production to soluble antigens. Keyhole limpet hemocyanin-specific T cells repeatedly stimulated with DC and antigen also did not express helper activity. The failure of DC to induce T helper cells was not due to the activation of a suppressor pathway. Thus, dendritic cells, although very efficient as AC in the induction of various T cell functions, are not able to activate T helper cells required for carrier-specific T-B cooperation and therefore cannot be the sole accessory cells. Based on these results and on previous data using Ia+ tumor cell lines as AC, we confirm the existence of functional AC heterogeneity.

Evaluation of accessory cell heterogeneity. I. Differential accessory cell requirement for T helper cell activation and for T-B cooperation

Several Ia+ tumor cell lines and peritoneal exudate macrophages were tested as accessory cells (AC) for the activation of antigen-specific T cells and for T-B cooperation. The macrophages and all the Ia+ tumor lines tested induced the release of lymphokines from T cells in a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted fashion and reconstituted the antibody responses of AC-depleted spleen cells or of purified T and B cells. However, only the normal macrophages but none of the tumor lines induced carrier-specific T helper (Th) cells which help B cells for specific antihapten antibody responses by linked recognition. For T-B cooperation accessory cells were also required, but in contrast to Th cell activation any type of Ia+ AC (e.g. macrophage or tumor line) was effective. Strong MHC-restriction between the lymphocytes and the AC was seen if antigen-pulsed AC were added into the AC-depleted T-B cooperation cultures. If the AC and antigen were concomitantly added to the AC-depleted T-B cultures, MHC-restriction was less obvious. Concanavalin A supernatant reconstituted the response of AC-depleted T-B cultures provided antigen-specific Th cells and the hapten-carrier conjugate were present. If, however, tumor line-activated T cells were added instead of macrophage-induced Th cells, no cooperation with B cells took place even in the presence of Con A supernatant. The results obtained demonstrate a differential AC requirement for the induction of Th cells depending on the differentiation stage of the Th cells.

Ia determinants on macrophages

It is well established that T cells cannot be activated by antigen alone but only if antigen is presented in context with I region associated (Ia) determinants. As a matter of fact, antigen-presenting cells or accessory cells, which are obligatory for the induction of any type of immune response, all share the same major characteristic of Ia expression. Thus, there seems to be a direct correlation between accessory cell function and Ia expression. Originally, Ia determinants were only detected on a few cell types, B cells and macrophages being the first. However, during the course of time, more and more cells were found to be Ia positive (Ia +) and it is possible that most cells can express Ia, if appropriately induced. The regulation of Ia expression has been best studied in macrophages, where it has been found that positive induction elements include phagocytosis and gamma-interferon, while prostaglandin E and alpha-fetoprotein tend to down-regulate the expression of Ia. The regulation of Ia expression on accessory cells is thus an integrated part of immune regulation. It is highly likely, although not yet directly proven, that the Ia molecules are the products of the immune response (Ir) genes located within the major histocompatibility complex. They may even be the mediators of the Ir genes which determine whether an immune response can take place at all and/or the extent of the response. Recently, it has been shown that not all Ia + cells are able to activate every known T cell function.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Autologous cellular immune response to primary and metastatic human melanomas and its regulation by DR antigens expressed on tumor cells

Evidence for heterogeneity of several biological features of human malignant melanoma (Me) like morphology, cytogenetics, oncogenes activation, antigenic expression, metastatizing capacity and procoagulant activity are briefly reviewed in an attempt to distinguish findings related to primary vs. metastatic lesions. In our own studies monoclonal antibodies were used to study expression of MHC class I, class II products and of Me-associated antigens (MAA) on primary and metastatic Me cells. High expression of class I antigens was found in a high percentage of both primary and metastatic tumors, whereas DR and MAA showed a significant variation (from 3 to 90% of cells) in expression both in primary and in metastatic Me. When autologous cell-mediated immune responses were evaluated, it was found that Me cells from primary tumors but not those from lymph node metastases were able to stimulate autologous lymphocytes to proliferate and become cytotoxic for autologous Me. Clonal analysis of cytotoxic lymphocytes was then carried out in order to see whether the lack of lymphocytes reactivity to metastatic cells was due to the absence or to a low frequency of cytotoxic cells in the unstimulated PBL. CTL clones cytotoxic for autologous Me (Auto-Me) cells were indeed isolated. Three classes of CTL clones were identified: 1) one which is cytotoxic for Auto-Me; 2) a second one which lyse Auto-Me and allogeneic Me; and 3) a third one which is cytotoxic for Auto-Me and allogeneic normal and neoplastic cells. Metastatic Me cells, however, had the ability to suppress the stimulation of autologous PBL by alloantigens or IL-2. This effect was dose-dependent and was not due to absorption of IL-2 by Me cells. Since it has been reported that Me cells express class II MHC antigens, we investigated whether there was any correlation between autologous immune responses and DR expression on Me cells. Autologous lymphocytes stimulation was found to occur only with DR+ Me cells from primary lesions, whereas metastatic cells, either DR+ or DR-, did not stimulate autologous PBL. Moreover, the suppressive effect of metastatic Me cells was associated with their expression of DR antigens. The modulation of DR antigens on Me cells by Interferon-gamma correlated positively with their suppressive capacity. Thus, it appears that primary Me can behave differently from the metastatic one in their interactions with the immune system of autologous host. These findings suggest that DR antigens on Me cells may have an important role in the regulation of autologous immune responses.

The inhibition of lymphocyte stimulation by autologous human metastatic melanoma cells correlates with the expression of HLA-DR antigens on the tumor cells

Previous studies indicated that peripheral blood lymphocytes from patients (Pt-PBL) with lymph node metastatic melanomas proliferated in vitro and developed into tumor-restricted cytotoxic lymphocytes in response to alloantigens or interleukin 2 (IL-2). However, Pt-PBL were not stimulated by irradiated autologous metastatic melanoma (Auto-Me) cells. In the present study we report that the lack of stimulatory activity of Auto-Me cells may be due to a suppressive effect exerted by Auto-Me cells on the responder lymphocytes. In fact, we found that in 62% of cases examined, the addition of 5-10% Auto-Me cells to Pt-PBL cultures strongly inhibited both proliferation and the generation of tumor cytotoxic lymphocytes induced by alloantigens or IL-2. The inhibition was dose-dependent and tumor-restricted, and was not due either to toxicity, medium depletion or IL-2 absorption by Auto-Me cells. Normal fibroblasts, K562 cells and autologous E-lymphocytes were not suppressive. Auto-Me cells were able to inhibit Pt-PBL responses only when added during the first 24 h of culture and not later. Phenotypic analysis of Auto-Me cells using monoclonal antibodies directed against HLA-A,B,C, HLA-DR and melanoma-associated antigens revealed that the expression of high levels of DR antigens on Auto-Me cells was associated with an elevated suppressive activity. Conversely, Auto-Me cells with low or undetectable levels of DR antigens were not inhibitory. Furthermore, the increased expression of DR antigens on Auto-Me cells obtained by in vitro treatment with human interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) also resulted in an increased suppressive activity. We conclude that HLA-DR+ metastatic melanoma cells can interfere with the generation of an anti-tumor immune response, thus potentially favoring the escape of the tumor from the host's control mechanism.

Selection of the delayed hypersensitivity T effector and T suppressor cell response by antigen-presenting macrophages

The T effector lymphocytes of delayed type hypersensitivity reactions (TDH) are regulated by a complex T suppressor (Ts) cell circuit. Induction of TDH cells requires Ia+ adherent cells as antigen-presenting cells. Little is known about the antigen presentation of the induction of Ts cells. We describe an experimental model in which TDH and Ts cells are induced separately by different antigen-presenting macrophages grown from bone marrow stem cells. Bone marrow derived macrophages grown in L cell-conditioned medium for various periods and labeled with 2,4-dinitrobenzene sulfonic acid differ in their ability to induce TDH and Ts cells in vitro. The functional activity of the two T subpopulations was assessed in vivo by epicutaneous challenge or sensitization with 2,4-dinitrofluorobenzene of mice receiving the in vitro educated cells. Ear swelling or suppression of swelling was recorded. It could be shown that 5-7 day bone marrow-derived DNP-labeled macrophages preferentially induced Thy 1+ Lyt 1+ antigen-specific TDH cells; 7-10 day old antigen-presenting bone marrow-derived macrophages induced preferentially Thy 1+ Lyt 2+ antigen specific Ts cells. Characterization of various phenotypic markers revealed different surface antigen expression and functional differences such as MIF responsiveness or transglutaminase activity on the two macrophage populations. These data support the concept that activation of the Ts regulatory circuit may require antigen presentation by specialized antigen presenting cells, characterized by certain surface and functional markers and different from those inducing preferentially TDH cells.

Selective induction of delayed hypersensitivity T-effector and T-suppressor lymphocytes in vitro by haptenized bone marrow-derived macrophages

The role of various subpopulations of antigen-presenting macrophages in the induction of T-lymphocyte subpopulations has been difficult to study in the past. We have used an in vitro system of bone marrow cell culture both to induce T-effector (TDH) and T-suppressor (Ts) cells active in delayed-type hypersensitivity. Bone marrow-derived macrophages (BM-MA) grown in Teflon bag cultures were allowed to attach to culture dishes and were pulse-labeled with 2,4-dinitrobenzene sulfonate (DNBSO3). Spleen cell lymphocytes from nonsensitized BALB/c mice were cocultured with antigen-pulsed or control BM-MA for 3 days. The lymphocytes were harvested, and injected iv into BALB/c mice which were challenged within 1 hr after injection by painting the right ear with 2,4-dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB, effector test) or sensitized with DNFB on 2 days following iv injection of the cells and challenged 5 days later (suppressor test). Ear swelling was measured 24 hr later to assess the effector or suppressor function of the in vitro educated lymphocytes. BM-MA grown for 5 days (BM-MA 5) in L-cell conditioned medium induced only TDH cells (Thy 1+, Lyt 1+2-) whereas BM-MA grown for 10 days in conditioned medium induced only Ts cells (Thy 1+, Lyt 1-2+). In both cases, induced TDH and Ts cells were antigen specific. Functionally, induced Ts cells suppressed the afferent limb of the delayed response. When DNP-BM-MA 5 and DNP-BM-MA 10 were used to induce TDH or Ts cells in vivo by subcutaneous or intravenous injection respectively, only BM-MA 5 were able to sensitize recipient mice. Both 5- and 10-day macrophage populations induced Ts cells in vivo. Functionally, these Ts cells appeared to act on the efferent limb of the delayed reaction. We conclude that different populations of antigen-presenting macrophages can preferentially induce TDH or Ts cells, perhaps depending on antigen presentation in association with class II antigens or on the functional state of the antigen-presenting cell.

Heterogeneity in the response of T cells to antigens presented by B lymphoma cells

Proliferation of antigen-specific T-cell populations was induced in cultures stimulated with antigen and a suitable source of antigen-presenting cells. Soluble (keyhole limpet hemocyanin) and particulate (horse red blood cells) antigens were presented by irradiated spleen cells and by a variety of B-lymphoma-cell lines, providing support for antigen-specific H-2-restricted T-cell responses. A marked heterogeneity was demonstrated, however, in the capacity of T-cell lines to proliferate in response to antigen presented by the B-lymphoma cells. T-cell populations were prepared from the lymph nodes of antigen-primed mice and restimulated in vitro in the presence of antigen and irradiated spleen cells. During the first six in vitro restimulations, these T-cell populations maintained the capacity to respond to antigen presented either by irradiated spleen cells or by B-lymphoma cells. Continued growth of these T-cell populations, again in the presence of antigen and irradiated spleen cells, resulted in the generation of T-cell lines which had lost the ability to respond to antigen presented by B-lymphoma cells. These lines however, fully retained the capacity to proliferate in the presence of antigen and irradiated spleen cells. T-cell clones derived from one of these lines were also unable to respond to antigen presented by B-lymphoma cells but again proliferated in the presence of antigen and irradiated spleen cells. Supernatants containing high levels of IL-1, IL-2, or IL-3 activity failed to reconstituted the antigen-specific response of T-cell lines which had lost the capacity to respond to antigen presented by B-lymphoma cells. Furthermore, titrated numbers of irradiated spleen cells, while having the capacity to support T-cell proliferation themselves, failed to synergize with B-lymphoma cells in the support of antigen-specific T-cell proliferation. Thus we have defined populations of antigen-specific, H-2-restricted T cells which do not recognize antigen presented by B-lymphoma cells and can therefore discriminate between different antigen-presenting cell types.

T cell-mediated immunity in murine malaria. II. Induction of protective immunity to P. chabaudi by antigen-fed macrophages and antigen-educated lymphocytes

We previously described assay systems for generating antigen specific proliferating T cells to P. chabaudi antigens. In the present study we examine whether the various sensitization approaches confer immunity against a cloned virulent strain IP-PCI of P. chabaudi. We present data indicating that effective specific protective immunity can be induced through P. chabaudi antigen fed macrophages and antigen educated spleen cells (initiator lymphocytes). The expression of this protective immunity is proposed to depend on (a) antigen presentation and/or accessory function of macrophages and (b) the subsequent activation of T cell functions related to protection. Indeed analysis of different macrophage populations revealed a correlation between the expression of Ia molecules and IL-1 secretion with their capacity to induce antigen specific T cells in vivo and subsequent protective immune mechanisms. Thus these results emphasize the critical functions of accessory cells in determining the outcome of malaria infections.

Derivation from an alloreactive T-cell line of a clone which cross-reacts with a self H2-E-restricted minor alloantigen

An alloreactive T-helper-cell line [(A.TH X Balb/c) anti-A.TL] was shown to recognize both H2-Ek and H2-Ed. Both proliferation and polyclonal B-cell activation (protein A plaques) were used in the analyses of specificity. On cloning, the H2-Ek/Ed cross-reaction was shown by one clonotype. This cross-reaction is interpreted in light of the P. Matzinger and M.J. Bevan model (Cell. Immunol. 29, 1, 1977) for antigen recognition by T cells. The antigen recognized was a cell surface non-major histocompatibility (MHC) (minor) alloantigen, shared by the DBA and B10 backgrounds, whose recognition was H2-Ed restricted. This clone is therefore both alloreactive and self-MHC (Ed) restricted minor reactive. Other clones from the cell line were either allospecific or autoreactive. It was shown by antibody blocking that the H2-E alpha (Ia7) determinants involved in the cross-reactive and allospecific recognition were not the same. By antibody blocking it was also shown that the antigenic determinant recognized by the autoreactive clone included H2-Ed. The alloreactive cell line therefore contained three H2-E-reactive clonotypes: allo-Ek specific, H2-Ek and DBA/B10 minor plus H2-Ed cross-reactive, and Ed-associated autoreactive.

Mechanisms of genetic control of immune responses. I. Evidence for distinct multi-step helper T-cell pathways in cellular and humoral responses to GAT

We examined multiple genetically regulated humoral and cell-mediated immune (CMI) responses to poly( glu60ala30tyr10 ) (GAT) using a panel of mouse strains. We show that assignment of responder/nonresponder status depends upon the assay method. In addition, two distinct categories of nonresponder mice were found: (1) those which are unresponsive by all parameters tested (H-2q and H-2s haplotypes) and (2) those which are partially nonresponsive [H-2bm12 mutant strain--a low/nonresponder by splenic plaque-forming cell (PFC) and delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses, but exhibits B6 parental levels of high GAT-specific T-cell proliferation ( Tprlf ) and interleukin-2 production]. The distinction between these two nonresponder types was confirmed by complementation tests in which significant GAT-specific PFC and DTH responses were seen in (H-2q X H-2bm12)F1 hybrids, but not in (H-2q X H-2s)F1 hybrids. Suppressor T cells (Ts) also play a selective role in nonresponsiveness to GAT. Cyclophosphamide treatment of nonresponders (to eliminate Ts activity) as well as immunization with GAT coupled to the immunogenic carrier MBSA result in the development of GAT-specific humoral, but not CMI responses. Our results indicate that the T cell is the cellular site of Ir gene expression and that Tprlf responses do not correlate with functional helper T-cell activity and suggest distinct, multi-step Th/Ts regulatory pathways in the development of humoral and CMI effector functions.