Chlorambucil-monoglutathionyl conjugate is sequestered by human alpha class glutathione S-transferases

Alkylating Agents, the Road Less Traversed, Changing Anticancer Therapy

Cancer is considered one of the gruelling challenges and poses a grave health hazard across the globe. According to the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), new cancer diagnoses increased to 18.1 million in 2018, with 9.6 million deaths, bringing the global cancer rate to 23.6 million by 2030. In 1942, the discovery of nitrogen mustard as an alkylating agent was a tremendous breakthrough in cancer chemotherapy. It acts by binding to the DNA, and creating cross linkages between the two strands, leading to arrest of DNA replication and eventual cell death. Nitrogen lone pairs of 'nitrogen mustard' produce an intermediate 'aziridinium ion' at molecular level, which is very reactive towards DNA of tumour cells, resulting in multiple side effects with therapeutic consequences. Owing to its high reactivity and peripheral cytotoxicity, several improvements have been made with structural modifications for the past 75 years to enhance its efficacy and improve the direct transport of drugs to the tumour cells. Alkylating agents were among the first non-hormonal substances proven to be active against malignant cells and also, the most valuable cytotoxic therapies available for the treatment of leukaemia and lymphoma patients. This review focus on the versatile use of alkylating agents and the structure activity relationship (SAR) of each class of these compounds. This could provide an understanding for design and synthesis of new alkylating agents having enhanced target specificity and adequate bioavailability.

The mercapturic acid pathway

The mercapturic acid pathway is a major route for the biotransformation of xenobiotic and endobiotic electrophilic compounds and their metabolites. Mercapturic acids (N-acetyl-l-cysteine S-conjugates) are formed by the sequential action of the glutathione transferases, γ-glutamyltransferases, dipeptidases, and cysteine S-conjugate N-acetyltransferase to yield glutathione S-conjugates, l-cysteinylglycine S-conjugates, l-cysteine S-conjugates, and mercapturic acids; these metabolites constitute a "mercapturomic" profile. Aminoacylases catalyze the hydrolysis of mercapturic acids to form cysteine S-conjugates. Several renal transport systems facilitate the urinary elimination of mercapturic acids; urinary mercapturic acids may serve as biomarkers for exposure to chemicals. Although mercapturic acid formation and elimination is a detoxication reaction, l-cysteine S-conjugates may undergo bioactivation by cysteine S-conjugate β-lyase. Moreover, some l-cysteine S-conjugates, particularly l-cysteinyl-leukotrienes, exert significant pathophysiological effects. Finally, some enzymes of the mercapturic acid pathway are described as the so-called "moonlighting proteins," catalytic proteins that exert multiple biochemical or biophysical functions apart from catalysis.

Fluorescence detection of glutathione S-transferases in a low GSH level environment

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) play crucial roles in the detoxification process and the development of drug-resistance and are proved to be important markers for various tumors.

Activity-Based Probes for Isoenzyme- and Site-Specific Functional Characterization of Glutathione S-Transferases

Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) comprise a diverse family of phase II drug metabolizing enzymes whose shared function is the conjugation of reduced glutathione (GSH) to endo- and xenobiotics. Although the conglomerate activity of these enzymes can be measured, the isoform-specific contribution to the metabolism of xenobiotics in complex biological samples has not been possible. We have developed two activity-based probes (ABPs) that characterize active GSTs in mammalian tissues. The GST active site is composed of a GSH binding "G site" and a substrate binding "H site". Therefore, we developed (1) a GSH-based photoaffinity probe (GSTABP-G) to target the "G site", and (2) an ABP designed to mimic a substrate molecule and have "H site" activity (GSTABP-H). The GSTABP-G features a photoreactive moiety for UV-induced covalent binding to GSTs and GSH-binding enzymes. The GSTABP-H is a derivative of a known mechanism-based GST inhibitor that binds within the active site and inhibits GST activity. Validation of probe targets and "G" and "H" site specificity was carried out using a series of competition experiments in the liver. Herein, we present robust tools for the characterization of enzyme- and active site-specific GST activity in mammalian model systems.

The interaction of the chemotherapeutic drug chlorambucil with human glutathione transferase A1-1: kinetic and structural analysis

Glutathione transferases (GSTs) are enzymes that contribute to cellular detoxification by catalysing the nucleophilic attack of glutathione (GSH) on the electrophilic centre of a number of xenobiotic compounds, including several chemotherapeutic drugs. In the present work we investigated the interaction of the chemotherapeutic drug chlorambucil (CBL) with human GSTA1-1 (hGSTA1-1) using kinetic analysis, protein crystallography and molecular dynamics. In the presence of GSH, CBL behaves as an efficient substrate for hGSTA1-1. The rate-limiting step of the catalytic reaction between CBL and GSH is viscosity-dependent and kinetic data suggest that product release is rate-limiting. The crystal structure of the hGSTA1-1/CBL-GSH complex was solved at 2.1 Å resolution by molecular replacement. CBL is bound at the H-site attached to the thiol group of GSH, is partially ordered and exposed to the solvent, making specific interactions with the enzyme. Molecular dynamics simulations based on the crystal structure indicated high mobility of the CBL moiety and stabilization of the C-terminal helix due to the presence of the adduct. In the absence of GSH, CBL is shown to be an alkylating irreversible inhibitor for hGSTA1-1. Inactivation of the enzyme by CBL followed a biphasic pseudo-first-order saturation kinetics with approximately 1 mol of CBL per mol of dimeric enzyme being incorporated. Structural analysis suggested that the modifying residue is Cys112 which is located at the entrance of the H-site. The results are indicative of a structural communication between the subunits on the basis of mutually exclusive modification of Cys112, indicating that the two enzyme active sites are presumably coordinated.

Overexpression of GSTA2 protects against cell cycle arrest and apoptosis induced by the DNA inter-strand crosslinking nitrogen mustard, mechlorethamine

The effectiveness of bifunctional alkylating nitrogen mustard compounds in chemotherapy is related to their ability to form DNA inter-strand crosslinks. Patients exposed to DNA inter-strand crosslinking (ICL) agents subsequently experience an elevated incidence of myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) and MDS related acute myeloid leukemia. Fanconi's anemia (FA) patients are deficient in the repair of crosslink DNA damage and they experience a high incidence of MDS. These observations indicate that hematopoietic cells are specific target for the transforming effects of DNA crosslinking damage. Changes in transcript levels were characterized in human hematopoietic cells occurring in response to the nitrogen mustard, mechlorethamine (HN2), but not in response to monofunctional analogs. Only modest changes in a few gene transcripts were detected in HL60 cells exposed to levels of HN2 tittered to maximal dose that caused growth suppression with minimal cell death and allowed eventual resumption of normal cell growth. Under conditions of transient growth suppression, a subset of glutathione-S-transferase (GST) isoenzyme genes was consistently upregulated three to fourfold by HN2, but not by monofunctional analogs. Subsequent efforts to confirm the changes detected by microarray analyses revealed an unexpected dependence on treatment conditions. The GST alpha class A2 subfamily member transcripts were upregulated 24 h after a 1 h exposure to HN2 that caused an extensive, but transient block in late S/G2 cell cycle phase, but were minimally altered with continuous exposure. The 1-h exposure to HN2 caused a transient late S/G2 cell cycle arrest in both the HL-60 cell line and the Colo 320HSR human colon cancer cell line. Overexpression of GSTA2 by transient transfection protected Colo 320HSR cells against both cycle arrest and apoptosis following exposure to HN2. Overexpression of GSTA2 in Colo 320HSR cells induced after exposure to HN2 did not alter cycle arrest or apoptosis. The results indicate that human GSTA2 facilitates the protection of cells from HN2 damage and not repair. Our results are consistent with the possibility that GSTA2 polymorphisms, variable isoenzyme expression, and variable induced expression may be factors in the pathogenesis of MDS.

SYNTHESIS AND CHARACTERIZATION OF SOME NEW PHASE II METABOLITES OF THE ALKYLATOR BENDAMUSTINE AND THEIR IDENTIFICATION IN HUMAN BILE, URINE, AND PLASMA FROM PATIENTS WITH CHOLANGIOCARCINOMA

The alkylating agent bendamustine is currently in phase III clinical trials for the treatment of hematological malignancies and breast, lung, and gastrointestinal tumors. Renal elimination mainly as the parent compound is thought to be the primary route of excretion. Because polar biliary conjugates were expected metabolites of bendamustine, three cysteine S-conjugates were synthesized, purified by quantitative high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), and characterized by NMR spectroscopy and mass spectrometry (MS). HPLC assays with MS, as well as fluorescence detection of bile, urine, and plasma after single-dose intravenous infusion of 140 mg/m(2) bendamustine in five subjects with cholangiocarcinoma, indicated the existence of these phase II metabolites, which were identified as cysteine S-conjugates by comparison with the previously characterized synthetic reference standards. The sum of the three cysteine S-conjugates of bendamustine was determined in human bile and urine to be 95.8 and 26.0%, respectively, expressed as mean percentage of the sum of the parent compound and identified metabolites. The percentage of administered dose recovered in urine as cysteine S-conjugates ranged from 0.9 to 4.1%, whereas the total percentage of the administered dose excreted in urine as the parent drug and seven metabolites ranged from 3.8 to 16.3%. The identification of cysteine S-conjugates provide evidence that a major route of bendamustine metabolism in humans involves conjugation with glutathione. Results indicate the importance of phase II conjugation in the elimination of bendamustine, besides phase I metabolism and hydrolytic degradation, and require further investigation.

Functional polymorphism of human glutathione transferase A3: effects on xenobiotic metabolism and steroid biosynthesis

The alpha class glutathione transferase GSTA3-3 is involved in steroid biosynthesis and the metabolism of some xenobiotics. A bioinformatics approach was utilized to identify novel coding region polymorphisms in the glutathione transferase A3 gene (GSTA3). We describe an I71L polymorphism in GSTA3 that occurs at a low frequency in African populations. The activity of the leucine containing isoform was significantly reduced in a range of glutathione-conjugating reactions due to a diminished affinity for reduced glutathione, indicating that this allele could be implicated in disease caused by oxidative stress in steroidogenic tissue. By contrast, the delta(5)-androsten-3,17-dione isomerase activity of GSTA3-3 was not affected by this substitution, indicating that there is no direct effect on steroid synthesis. However, the L71 isoform displayed diminished stability at 45 degrees C. If this relative instability is mirrored in vivo, testosterone and progesterone synthesis may be affected in individuals carrying this allele.

Glutathione S-transferase polymorphisms and survival in primary malignant glioma

PURPOSE

The purpose of this research was to investigate the relationship between glutathione S-transferase (GST) polymorphisms and survival, and chemotherapy-related toxicity in 278 glioma patients.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We determined genetic variants for GSTM1, GSTT1, and GSTP1 enzymes by PCR and restriction fragment length polymorphisms. We conducted Kaplan-Meier and Cox-proportional hazard analyses to examine whether the GST polymorphisms are related to overall survival, and logistic regression analysis to explore whether the GST polymorphisms are associated with toxicity.

RESULTS

For patients with anaplastic astrocytoma, anaplastic oligodendroglioma, anaplastic oligoastrocytoma, and anaplastic ependymoma (n = 78), patients with GSTP1*A/*A-M1 null genotype survived longer than did the rest of the group (median survival "not achieved," and 41 months, respectively; P = 0.06). Among patients treated with nitrosoureas (n = 108), those with GSTP1*A/*A and GSTM1 null genotype were 5.7 times (95% confidence interval, 0.9-37.4) more likely to experience an adverse event secondary to chemotherapy, compared with the others.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with anaplastic astrocytoma, anaplastic oligodendroglioma, and anaplastic oligoastrocytoma, combination of germ-line GSTP1*A/*A and GSTM1 null genotype confers a survival advantage. Patients with this genotype also have an increased risk of adverse events secondary to chemotherapy that primarily comprised nitrosourea alkylating agents.

Functional polymorphism of human glutathione transferase A2

OBJECTIVES

Single nucleotide polymorphisms that cause amino acid substitutions in enzymes involved in the metabolism of xenobiotics can potentially have a significant effect on the efficacy and safety of therapeutic drugs.

METHODS

We have utilized a bioinformatic approach to identify new polymorphisms in the glutathione transferase super family.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

In this report we describe a P110S polymorphism in GSTA2 that occurs at a low frequency in Africans, Chinese and Europeans. The serine containing isoform has significantly diminished activity with a range of substrates including, delta-Androsten-3,17-dione, 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene and cumene hydroperoxide. The activity with cumene hydroperoxide may reflect a diminished physiological function since the glutathione peroxidase activity of GSTA2-2 plays a role in prostaglandin synthesis. In contrast, activity with p-nitrophenol acetate was significantly elevated. The position of this polymorphism in the active site and its effects on model substrates suggest that further investigation of its capacity to conjugate alkylating drugs is warranted.

Role of Multidrug Resistance Protein 2 (MRP2, ABCC2) in Alkylating Agent Detoxification: MRP2 Potentiates GlutathioneS-Transferase A1-1-Mediated Resistance to Chlorambucil Cytotoxicity

Our previous studies have shown that the glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) can operate in synergy with the efflux transporter multidrug resistance protein 1 (MRP1, ABCC1) to confer resistance to the cyto- and genotoxicities of some anticancer drugs and carcinogens. The current study was designed to determine whether the alternative efflux transporter, MRP2 (ABCC2), can also potentiate GST-mediated detoxifications in HepG2 cells. HepG2 cells, which express high-level MRP2 but not MRP1, were stably transduced with GST expression vectors under tetracycline-repressible transcriptional control. MRP2 was able to support GSTA1-1-mediated resistance to chlorambucil (CHB) cytotoxicity in HepG2 cells. Resistance was GST isozyme-specific in that GSTP1a-1a and GSTM1a-1a failed to confer protection from CHB toxicity. Moreover, inhibition of MRP2 with sulfinpyrazone completely reversed GSTA1-1-associated resistance, indicating that MRP2-efflux function is required to potentiate GSTA1-1-mediated resistance. Relative transport by MRP1 versus MRP2 of monoglutathionyl-CHB (CHB-SG) was examined using inside-out plasma membrane vesicles derived from MCF7 cells transduced with MRP1 or MRP2 expression vectors. Both MRP1 and MRP2 transported CHB-SG efficiently, at the levels of protein expressed, with similar Vmax and with Km of 0.39 and 10 microM, respectively. We conclude that detoxification of CHB by GSTA1-1 requires the removal of the glutathione conjugate formed and that either MRP1 or MRP2 can serve this efflux function. These findings have implications for the role of MRP2 in detoxification of alkylating agents in the apical epithelium of liver and kidney where it is highly expressed as well as the role of MRP2 in the emergence of alkylating drug resistance in cancer cells.

Conjugation of chlorambucil with GSH by GST purified from human colon adenocarcinoma cells and its inhibition by plant polyphenols

Chlorambucil (CMB) combines with glutathione (GSH) spontaneously in vitro to form monochloromonoglutathionyl CMB (MG-CMB). This was identified and quantified by an HPLC-UV method. Glutathione S-transferase (GST) purified from human colon adenocarcinoma cells increased the formation of the conjugate significantly. The GST-mediated conjugation, represented by the difference between total and spontaneous conjugation showed Michaelis-Menten kinetics with apparent Km and Vmax values of 0.2 mM and 75.8 nmol/min/mg for CMB and 5.2 mM and 127.0 nmol/min/mg for GSH respectively. Unexpectedly, we found in our study that both the spontaneous and the enzymatic conjugation of chlorambucil with GSH were affected markedly by a change in pH from 6.0 to 8.0. The optimum for the enzymatic conjugation was about 7.0, above which the spontaneous conjugation increased rapidly, while the enzymatic conjugation became lower. The plant polyphenols namely tannic acid, butein, quercetin, morin, 2-hydroxychalcone and 2'-hydroxychalcone at 40 microM inhibited the GST-mediated conjugation of CMB with GSH by 38 to 62%. Their action in this respect may contribute to sensitisation of tumour cells to anticancer drugs.

Role of multidrug resistance protein 1 (MRP1) and glutathione S-transferase A1-1 in alkylating agent resistance. Kinetics of glutathione conjugate formation and efflux govern differential cellular sensitivity to chlorambucil versus melphalan toxicity

We investigated the role of phase II (conjugation) and phase III (efflux) detoxification of the anticancer drugs melphalan (MLP) and chlorambucil (CHB). Although both drugs are substrates of Alpha-class glutathione S-transferases (GST) and the monoglutathionyl conjugates formed in these enzymatic reactions are transported by MRP1, we found that GSTA1-1 and MRP1 acted in synergy to confer resistance to CHB but not to MLP (Morrow, C. S., Smitherman, P. K., Diah, S. K., Schneider, E., and Townsend, A. J. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 20114-20120). To explain this selectivity of MRP1/GST-mediated resistance, we report results of side-by-side experiments comparing the kinetics of MLP- versus CHB-glutathione conjugate: formation, product inhibition of GSTA1-1 catalysis, and transport by MRP1. The monoglutathionyl conjugate of CHB, CHB-SG, is a very strong competitive inhibitor of GSTA1-1 (K(i) 0.14 microM) that is >30-fold more potent than that of the corresponding conjugate of MLP, MLP-SG (K(i) 4.7 microM). The efficiency of GSTA1-1-mediated monoglutathionyl conjugate formation is more than 4-fold higher for CHB than MLP. Lastly, both CHB-SG and MLP-SG are efficiently transported by MRP1 with similar V(max) although the K(m) for CHB-SG (0.37 microm) is significantly lower than for MLP-SG (1.1 microM). These results indicate that MRP1 is required for GSTA1-1-mediated resistance to CHB in order to relieve potent product inhibition of the enzyme by intracellular CHB-SG formed. The kinetic properties of MRP1 are well suited to eliminate CHB-SG at pharmacologically relevant concentrations. For MLP detoxification, where product inhibition of GSTA1-1 is less important, GSTA1-1 does not confer resistance because of the relatively poorer catalytic efficiency of MLP-SG formation. Similar analyses can be useful for predicting the pharmacological and toxicological consequences of MRP and GST expression on cellular sensitivity to various other electrophilic xenobiotics.

Role of multidrug-resistance protein 2 in glutathione S-transferase P1-1-mediated resistance to 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide toxicities in HepG2 cells

Previous studies in our laboratory have shown that the phase III efflux transporter multidrug-resistance protein (MRP)1 can act synergistically with the phase II conjugating glutathione S-transferases (GST) to confer resistance to the toxicities of some electrophilic drugs and carcinogens. To determine whether the distinct efflux transporter MRP2 could also potentiate GST-mediated protection from electrophilic toxins, we examined the effect of regulatable GSTP1-1 expression in MRP2-rich HepG2 cells on 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide (4NQO)-induced cytotoxicity and genotoxicity (nucleic-acid adduct formation). Expression of GSTP1-1 was associated with a fourfold to tenfold protection from 4NQO-induced cytotoxicity. Inhibition of MRP2-mediated efflux activity by sulfinpyrazone or cyclosporin A completely reversed GSTP1-1-associated resistance-a result indicating that GSTP1-1-mediated cytoprotection is absolutely dependent on MRP2 efflux activity. Moreover, MRP2 efflux activity also augmented GSTP1-1-mediated protection from 4NQO-induced nucleic-acid adduct formation. We conclude that MRP2-mediated efflux of the glutathione conjugate of 4NQO and/or another toxic derivative of 4NQO is required to support GSTP1-1-associated protection from 4NQO toxicities in HepG2 cells.

Glutathione and the regulation of cell death

The association of elevated levels of glutathione and glutathione S-transferases with the development of resistance to alkylating agents was established more than 10 years ago. Although numerous similar reports have appeared since this time work in this area has tended to dwindle as interest has become focused on more fashionable areas of drug resistance research. However, over the past 3 or 4 years there has been a revival of interest in the study of glutathione and glutathione utilising enzymes driven by recent discoveries which have implicated redox balance as an important regulator of cell death and transmembrane drug transport. In this brief review I highlight some of the more rapid areas of advance.

GST function in drug and stress response

Glutathione (GSH) is the major non-protein thiol in cells and is a co-factor for many types of conjugation reactions involving glutathione S-transferases (GST). Because of the defined role of GST in drug metabolism, elevated expression of GSTpi either as a tumor marker or in drug resistance has automatically been linked to detoxification. Similarly, GSH has mostly been viewed as a passive cellular supply of nucleophilic sulfur. This mini-review highlights recent reports which advocate a novel, non-catalytic role for GSTpi as an integral determinant of cellular pathways of stress response, proliferation and apoptosis. Copyright 1999 Harcourt Publishers Ltd.

Different expression of glutathione S-transferase alpha, mu and pi in childhood acute lymphoblastic and myeloid leukaemia

Expression of three major classes of glutathione S-transferases (GSTs), i.e. alpha, mu and pi class, P-glycoprotein (P-gp) and multidrug resistance-associated protein (MRP) were studied in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL), acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) and normal peripheral blood lymphocytes by flow cytometry. In vitro cytotoxicity of 4-hydroxy-ifosfamide (IFOS), daunorubicin (DNR) and prednisolone (PRED) was assessed by the MTT assay. Expression of alpha, mu and pi class GST did not significantly differ between leukaemic cells from 100 initial and 14 unrelated relapse ALL patients (GSTalpha P=026; GSTmu P=O009; GSTpi P=0.13). The expression of GSTalpha (1.4-fold, P=0.0004), GSTpi (13-fold, P = 0001) and to a lesser extent also GSTmu (1.1-fold, P=0.03) was higher in ALL compared with normal peripheral blood lymphocytes. Expression of GSTmu and GST7pi was significantly higher in 18 AML compared with 100 ALL patients at initial diagnosis (respectively 1.3-fold, P=0.0005 and 2-fold, P<0.0001). In contrast, GSTalpha was median 2-fold lower expressed in the AML samples (P< 0.0001). Expression levels of alpha, mu and pi class GSTs were not related to the degree of resistance to IFOS, DNR and PRED nor to immunophenotype, white blood cell count or age at presentation of childhood ALL. One exception was a remarkably low expression of GSTalpha in IFOS-sensitive samples compared with a heterogenous expression in IFOS-resistant samples (P= 0.02). Expression of GSTpi, but not of GSTalpha or GSTmu, weakly correlated with the expression of MRP (Rs 0.36, P = 0.002, n = 74) but not with P-gp. However, a high expression of both GSTpi and MRP was not associated with in vitro resistance to IFOS, DNR or PRED. The present data suggest that expression of GSTs is not linked to the degree of resistance to IFOS, DNR and PRED or clinical risk factors in childhood ALL. Whether the high expression of GSTmu and GSTpi in AML cells contributes to the relative resistance to IFOS, DNR and PRED compared with ALL samples (P < or = 0.0001) warrants further study.

Combined expression of multidrug resistance protein (MRP) and glutathione S-transferase P1-1 (GSTP1-1) in MCF7 cells and high level resistance to the cytotoxicities of ethacrynic acid but not oxazaphosphorines or cisplatin

We tested the hypothesis that combined increased expression of human glutathione S-transferase P1-1 (GSTP1-1), an enzyme that catalyzes the conjugation with glutathione of several toxic electrophiles, and the glutathione-conjugate efflux pump, multidrug resistance protein (MRP), confers high level resistance to the cytotoxicities of anticancer and other drugs. To accomplish this, we developed MCF7 breast carcinoma cell derivatives that express high levels of GSTP1-1 and MRP, alone and in combination. Parental MCF7 cells, which express no GSTP1-1 and negligible MRP, served as control cells. We found that either MRP or GSTP1-1 alone conferred significant resistance to ethacrynic acid cytotoxicity. Moreover, combined expression of GSTP1-1 and MRP conferred a high level of resistance to ethacrynic acid that was greater than resistance conferred by either protein alone. Increased MRP was also associated with modest resistance to the oxazaphosphorine compounds mafosfamide, 4-hydroxycyclophosphamide, and 4-hydroperoxycyclophosphamide. However, coordinated expression of GSTP1-1 with MRP failed to augment this modest resistance. Similarly, GSTP1-1 had no effect on the sensitivities to cisplatin of MCF7 cells regardless of MRP expression. These results establish that coordinated expression of MRP and GSTP1-1 can confer high level resistance to the cytotoxicities of some drugs, including ethacrynic acid, but that such resistance is variable and does not apply to all toxic drugs that can potentially form glutathione conjugates in either spontaneous or GSTP1-1-catalyzed reactions.

Coordinated action of glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) and multidrug resistance protein 1 (MRP1) in antineoplastic drug detoxification. Mechanism of GST A1-1- and MRP1-associated resistance to chlorambucil in MCF7 breast carcinoma cells

To examine the role of multidrug resistance protein 1 (MRP1) and glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) in cellular resistance to antineoplastic drugs, derivatives of MCF7 breast carcinoma cells were developed that express MRP1 in combination with one of three human cytosolic isozymes of GST. Expression of MRP1 alone confers resistance to several drugs representing the multidrug resistance phenotype, drugs including doxorubicin, vincristine, etoposide, and mitoxantrone. However, co-expression with MRP1 of any of the human GST isozymes A1-1, M1-1, or P1-1 failed to augment MRP1-associated resistance to these drugs. In contrast, combined expression of MRP1 and GST A1-1 conferred approximately 4-fold resistance to the anticancer drug chlorambucil. Expression of MRP1 alone failed to confer resistance to chlorambucil, showing that the observed protection from chlorambucil cytotoxicity was absolutely dependent upon GST A1-1 protein. Moreover, using inhibitors of GST (dicumarol) or MRP1 (sulfinpyrazone), it was shown that in MCF7 cells resistance to chlorambucil requires both intact MRP1-dependent efflux pump activity and, for full protection, GST A1-1 catalytic activity. These results are the first demonstration that GST A1-1 and MRP1 can act in synergy to protect cells from the cytotoxicity of a nitrogen mustard, chlorambucil.

Multidrug resistance protein-mediated transport of chlorambucil and melphalan conjugated to glutathione

The human multidrug resistance protein (MRP1) confers resistance of cells to a number of different cytostatic drugs and functions as an export pump for glutathione S-conjugates, glucuronides and other amphiphilic anions. The present study details for the first time MRP1-mediated ATP-dependent transport of various glutathione S-conjugates of the bifunctional alkylating agents chlorambucil and melphalan. In membrane vesicles prepared from cells expressing recombinant MRP1, the conjugates were transported at rates in the following order: monoglutathionyl chlorambucil > bisglutathionyl chlorambucil > monohydroxy monoglutathionyl chlorambucil and monoglutathionyl melphalan > monohydroxy monoglutathionyl melphalan. In addition, we show that membranes from chlorambucil-resistant GST-alpha-overexpressing CHO cells as well as from their parental cells express the hamster homologue of MRP1. With both CHO cell membrane preparations, we observed ATP-dependent transport of monoglutathionyl chlorambucil and of leukotriene C4, a glutathione S-conjugate and high-affinity substrate of MRP1. The transport rates measured in the resistant cells were only two- to three-fold higher than those measured in the control cells. These results together with cytotoxicity assays comparing MRP1-overexpressing cell pairs with the CHO cell pair indicate that, although MRP1-mediated transport is active, it may not be the rate-limiting step in chlorambucil resistance in these cell lines.

Inhibitors of glutathione S-transferases as therapeutic agents

Glutathione S-transferases (GST) are a family of phase II detoxification enzymes with broad substrate specificities. They catalyze the conjugation of glutathione with many different types of xenobiotics, rendering the compound more water soluble and thus more easily eliminated. Resistance to cancer chemotherapeutic drugs, such as the alkylating agents, has been directly correlated with the overexpression of GSTs. Subsequently, a rationale has been established to utilize agents that inhibit GST in combination with alkylating agents to circumvent this resistance. Two such agents, ethacrynic acid (EA) and Terrapin 199 (TER 199), have been examined for this purpose. EA, an inhibitor of all classes of GST isozymes, has been used clinically in combination with thiotepa. More recently, TER 199, a glutathione analog-based GST inhibitor, has been modeled specifically to inhibit GST pi, an enzyme which is commonly found at high levels in human tumor biopsies. Furthermore, a therapeutic strategy has been designed to take advantage of GST pi activation of a prodrug, TER 286. Recent studies have investigated the molecular mechanisms involved in the cellular response to GST inhibitors and have employed techniques such as differential display to examine altered gene expression as well as to identify novel genes induced by these agents. Overall, this strategy may provide further insight into the action of these agents in the cell as well as prove useful in endeavors to modulate anticancer drug resistance.

Purification and characterization of class alpha and Mu glutathione S-transferases from porcine liver

Six cytosolic GSTs from porcine liver were purified by a combination of glutathione affinity chromatography and ion-exchange HPLC. The isoenzymes were characterized by SDS-PAGE, gel filtration, isoelectric focusing, immunoblotting analysis and determination of substrate specificities and inhibition characteristics. The purified GSTs belong to the alpha and mu classes, respectively. No class pi isoenzyme was isolated or detected. The class alpha GST pA1-1* exists as a homodimer (M(r) = 25.3 kDa), whereas GST pA2-3* consists of two subunits with different M(r) values (27.0 and 25.3 kDa). The estimated pI values were 9.5 and 8.8, respectively. Furthermore, four class mu porcine GSTs, pM1-1*, pM1-2*, pM3-?* and pM4-?*, were isolated. The isoenzyme pM1-1* possesses a relative molecular mass of 27.2 kDa and a pI value of 6.2. Additional pM1 isoenzymes hybridize with the subunit pM2* (M(r) = 25.2) to furnish a heterodimer, which shows a pI value of 5.8. The other class mu isoenzymes are heterodimers with pI values of 5.45 and 5.05. Substrate specificities and inhibition characteristics correlate very well with those of the corresponding human isoenzymes. The results are discussed with regard to the usefulness of porcine GSTs as an in vitro testing model.

Phosphono analogues of glutathione as new inhibitors of glutathione S-transferases

Phosphono-analogues of glutathione containing the O = P(OR)2 moiety in place of the cysteinyl residue CH2SH 1a-1d were prepared by solution phase peptide synthesis. Benzyl, benzyloxy-carbonyl, and tert-butyl protecting groups were used to mask the individual amino acid functional groups. The formation of peptide bonds was achieved by the usual peptide synthesis via activation of carboxylic functions with cyclohexylcarbodiimide and subsequent reaction with free amino groups. The thus obtained, fully-protected peptides were each purified by normal phase column chromatography. Deprotection was accomplished by hydrogenolysis and by treatment with HBr/acetic acid yielding the desired phosphonic acid diester 1a-1d. The inhibition of the glutathione conjugation of 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene by human placental glutathione S-transferase was studied by determining the IC50 values of the new glutathione analogues. The IC50 values were 291 microM, 139 microM, 64 microM, and 21 microM for the dimethyl, diethyl, diisopropyl, and di-n-butyl esters, respectively. The results clearly show that the formal substitution of the glutathione thiol function by phosphonic acid esters leads to a new class of glutathione S-transferase inhibitors. Further investigations directed at the question of whether or not these glutathione analogues are suitable for a modulation in chemotherapy are in progress.

The relationship between tumour glutathione concentration, glutathione S-transferase isoenzyme expression and response to single agent carboplatin in epithelial ovarian cancer patients

There is evidence to suggest that glutathione (GSH) and glutathione-S-transferases (GST) are important factors in determining sensitivity to cytotoxic drugs in vitro and in preclinical in vivo model systems. To define the relationship between tumour GSH concentration, GST isoenzyme expression and response to carboplatin in epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC), tumour samples from 39 patients with assessable disease after primary surgery were analyzed for GSH content and GST expression. Response was assessed after completing six courses of single agent carboplatin therapy. GSH was measured by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) in fresh tumour samples taken at primary laparatomy. GST isoenzyme expression was assessed by immunohistochemistry of fixed tumour material using antibodies specific for pi, alpha and mu classes. GST isoenzyme expression was defined as positive if the staining intensity was strong and more than 10% of tumour cells were involved. The mean GSH concentrations were: 8351 +/- 4496, 7211 +/- 5026, 6559 +/- 4573 and 3758 +/- 1885 (nmol g-1 tissue dry weight mean +/- s.d.) for tumours from patients who subsequently achieved a complete response (CR, n = 18), partial response (PR, n = 10) or who had static disease (SD, n = 7) or progressive disease (PD, n = 4) respectively. There was no relationship between GSH concentration and response (ANOVA, P = 0.32). There were also no relationship between GST isoenzyme expression and response (P Fisher's exact test 0.51-0.55 and chi-squared test 0.98-0.99). In conclusion, there was no association between the concentration of GSH or expression of GST isoenzymes and response to single agent carboplatin in primary previously untreated EOC.

Forward and reverse catalysis and product sequestration by human glutathione S-transferases in the reaction of GSH with dietary aralkyl isothiocyanates

The reversible reaction of GSH with two dietary anticarcinogens, benzyl isothiocyanate (BITC) and phenethyl isothiocyanate (PEITC), has been studied in the absence and presence of human glutathione S-transferases (GSTs). The spontaneous reaction at pH 7.4 and 37 degrees C yielded values for k2 of 17.9 and 6.0 M-1.s-1 for GSH conjugation of BITC and PEITC respectively (forward reaction), and k1 values of 6.9 x 10(-4) and 2.4 x 10(-4) s-1 for dissociation of the respective GSH conjugates, BITC-SG and PEITC-SG (reverse reaction). GSTs A1-1, A2-2, M1a-1a and P1-1 catalysed both the forward and reverse reactions with specific activities (mumol/min per mg at 30 microM isothiocyanate or GSH conjugate) ranging from 23.1 for the GSH conjugation of BITC by GST P1-1 to 0.03 for the dissociation of BITC-SG by GST A1-1. When present at similar concentration to substrates (12 microM), GSTs A1-1 and A2-2 but not GST M1a-1a shifted the equilibrium in favour of BITC-SG or PEITC-SG. Kinetic studies confirmed that GST A1-1 interacted selectively with the GSH conjugates in the micromolar range (Km 6.9 microM, Ki 4.3 microM), whereas GST M1a-1a interacted with BITC-SG and PEITC-SG with approx. 5-fold lower affinity. In conclusion, GSTs are true catalysts; at high intracellular concentration they also sequester GSH conjugates, promoting GSH conjugation, whereas trace extracellular GSTs promote dissociation of effluxed organic isothiocyanate-GSH conjugates.

The glutathione S-transferase supergene family: regulation of GST and the contribution of the isoenzymes to cancer chemoprotection and drug resistance

The glutathione S-transferases (GST) represent a major group of detoxification enzymes. All eukaryotic species possess multiple cytosolic and membrane-bound GST isoenzymes, each of which displays distinct catalytic as well as noncatalytic binding properties: the cytosolic enzymes are encoded by at least five distantly related gene families (designated class alpha, mu, pi, sigma, and theta GST), whereas the membrane-bound enzymes, microsomal GST and leukotriene C4 synthetase, are encoded by single genes and both have arisen separately from the soluble GST. Evidence suggests that the level of expression of GST is a crucial factor in determining the sensitivity of cells to a broad spectrum of toxic chemicals. In this article the biochemical functions of GST are described to show how individual isoenzymes contribute to resistance to carcinogens, antitumor drugs, environmental pollutants, and products of oxidative stress. A description of the mechanisms of transcriptional and posttranscriptional regulation of GST isoenzymes is provided to allow identification of factors that may modulate resistance to specific noxious chemicals. The most abundant mammalian GST are the class alpha, mu, and pi enzymes and their regulation has been studied in detail. The biological control of these families is complex as they exhibit sex-, age-, tissue-, species-, and tumor-specific patterns of expression. In addition, GST are regulated by a structurally diverse range of xenobiotics and, to date, at least 100 chemicals have been identified that induce GST; a significant number of these chemical inducers occur naturally and, as they are found as nonnutrient components in vegetables and citrus fruits, it is apparent that humans are likely to be exposed regularly to such compounds. Many inducers, but not all, effect transcriptional activation of GST genes through either the antioxidant-responsive element (ARE), the xenobiotic-responsive element (XRE), the GST P enhancer 1(GPE), or the glucocorticoid-responsive element (GRE). Barbiturates may transcriptionally activate GST through a Barbie box element. The involvement of the Ah-receptor, Maf, Nrl, Jun, Fos, and NF-kappa B in GST induction is discussed. Many of the compounds that induce GST are themselves substrates for these enzymes, or are metabolized (by cytochrome P-450 monooxygenases) to compounds that can serve as GST substrates, suggesting that GST induction represents part of an adaptive response mechanism to chemical stress caused by electrophiles. It also appears probable that GST are regulated in vivo by reactive oxygen species (ROS), because not only are some of the most potent inducers capable of generating free radicals by redox-cycling, but H2O2 has been shown to induce GST in plant and mammalian cells: induction of GST by ROS would appear to represent an adaptive response as these enzymes detoxify some of the toxic carbonyl-, peroxide-, and epoxide-containing metabolites produced within the cell by oxidative stress. Class alpha, mu, and pi GST isoenzymes are overexpressed in rat hepatic preneoplastic nodules and the increased levels of these enzymes are believed to contribute to the multidrug-resistant phenotype observed in these lesions. The majority of human tumors and human tumor cell lines express significant amounts of class pi GST. Cell lines selected in vitro for resistance to anticancer drugs frequently overexpress class pi GST, although overexpression of class alpha and mu isoenzymes is also often observed. The mechanisms responsible for overexpression of GST include transcriptional activation, stabilization of either mRNA or protein, and gene amplification. In humans, marked interindividual differences exist in the expression of class alpha, mu, and theta GST. The molecular basis for the variation in class alpha GST is not known. (ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)

Detoxication of base propenals and other alpha, beta-unsaturated aldehyde products of radical reactions and lipid peroxidation by human glutathione transferases

Radiation and chemical reactions that give rise to free radicals cause the formation of highly cytotoxic base propenals, degradation products of DNA. Human glutathione transferases (GSTs; RX:glutathione R-transferase, EC 2.5.1.18) of classes Alpha, Mu, and Pi were shown to promote the conjugation of glutathione with base propenals and related alkenes. GST P1-1 was particularly active in catalyzing the reactions with the propenal derivatives, and adenine propenal was the substrate giving the highest activity. The catalytic efficiency of GST P1-1 with adenine propenal (kcat/Km = 7.7 x 10(5) M-1.s-1) is the highest so far reported with any substrate for this enzyme. In general, GST A1-1 and GST M1-1, in contrast to GST P1-1, were more active with 4-hydroxyalkenals (products of lipid peroxidation) than with base propenals. The adduct resulting from the Michael addition of glutathione to the alkene function of one of the base propenals (adenine propenal) was identified by mass spectrometry. At the cellular level, GST P1-1 was shown to provide protection against alpha, beta-unsaturated aldehydes. GST P1-1 added to the culture medium of HeLa cells augmented the protective effect of glutathione against the toxicity of adenine propenal and thymine propenal. No protective effect of the enzyme was observed in the presence of the competitive inhibitor S-hexylglutathione. GST P1-1 introduced into Hep G2 cells by electroporation was similarly found to increase their resistance to acrolein. The results show that glutathione transferases may play an important role in cellular detoxication of electrophilic alpha, beta-unsaturated carbonyl compounds produced by radical reactions, lipid peroxidation, ionizing radiation, and drug metabolism.

Co-variation of glutathione transferase expression and cytostatic drug resistance in HeLa cells: establishment of class Mu glutathione transferase M3-3 as the dominating isoenzyme

Qualitative and quantitative analyses of glutathione, glutathione transferases (GSTs) and other glutathione-linked enzymes in HeLa cells have been made in order to study their significance in cellular resistance to electrophilic cytotoxic agents. The cytosolic concentrations of three GSTs, GST M1-1 (53 +/- 9 ng/mg of cytosolic protein), GST P1-1 (11 +/- 3 ng/mg) and GST A1-1 (1.1 +/- 0.4 ng/mg) were quantified by isoenzyme-specific enzyme-linked immunoassays. Electrophoretic analysis and immunoblotting demonstrated another component, GST M3-3, which was identified by amino acid sequence analysis. GST M3-3 was quantified (1550 +/- 250 ng/mg) by slot-blot immunoanalysis and was the most abundant GST in HeLa cells. An additional cytosolic 13 kDa protein with high affinity for immobilized glutathione or S-hexyglutathione was found to be identical with a macrophage migration-inhibitory factor, previously identified as a lymphokine. Cells grown in roller bottles (HR) rather than in ordinary culture flasks contain a significantly lower concentration of all the GSTs and were found to be more sensitive to the cytostatic agents doxorubicin (2.3-fold), cisplatin (1.7-fold) and melphalan (1.4-fold). The cytosolic concentrations of glutathione reductase and glyoxalase I were also lower in HR cells, whereas the total glutathione concentration was unchanged and the glutathione peroxidase activity was increased. The results indicate that GSTs contribute to the cellular resistance phenotype.

Significance of an unusually low Km for glutathione in glutathione transferases of the alpha, mu and pi classes

1. Interactions of glutathione transferases (GST) of the alpha, mu and pi classes with glutathione (GSH) and glutathione conjugates (GS-X) are in contrast with those of a GST of the theta class (GST5-5). 2. GST 5-5 has a Km for GSH of approx. 5 mM. Thus Km/ambient [GSH] is approx. 1, within the range of Km/ambient [s] of glycolytic enzymes. GSTs of the alpha, mu and pi classes yield much lower values of Km for GSH (approx. 0.1 mM) hence Km/ambient [s] is significantly lower than those of most (non-GST) enzymes (p < 0.025). 3. GSTs of the alpha, mu and pi classes are sensitive to inhibition by GS-X (i.e. product) and GS-X analogues. GST 5-5 is not. 4. Rate enhancements up to 10(10), similar to an average enzyme (10(8)-10(12)), are seen in catalysis by GST 5-5, but not in catalysis by GSTs of alpha, mu and pi classes (> 10(7)). 5. Comparisons of primary structure indicate that theta class GSTs may have a decreased binding of the glu-alpha-amino- and gly-COO(-)-groups of GSH compared with GSTs of the other classes. 6. It is concluded that GSTs of alpha, mu and pi classes have evolved towards increased product binding at the expense of catalytic efficiency. Thus GSH is uniquely utilized both as a nucleophile and a 'tag' which can be used to bind and sequester product particularly during GSH-depletion. This interpretation unifies the catalytic and binding properties of these GSTs and alters their perceived role in detoxication.

Glutathione-related enzymes, glutathione and multidrug resistance

This review examines the hypothesis that glutathione and its associated enzymes contribute to the overall drug-resistance seen in multidrug resistant cell lines. Reports of 34 cell lines independently selected for resistance to MDR drugs are compared for evidence of consistent changes in activity of glutathione-related enzymes as well as for changes in glutathione content. The role of glutathione S-transferases in MDR is further analyzed by comparing changes in sensitivity to MDR drugs in cell lines selected for resistance to non-MDR drugs that have resulting increases in glutathione S-transferase activity. In addition, results of studies in which genes for glutathione S-transferase isozymes were transfected into drug-sensitive cells are reviewed. The role of the glutathione redox cycle is examined by comparing changes in elements of this cycle in MDR cell lines as well as by analyzing reports of the effects of glutathione depletion on MDR drug sensitivity. Overall, there is no consistent or compelling evidence that glutathione and its associated enzymes augment resistance in multidrug resistant cell lines.