Infantile spasms related to a 5q31.2-q31.3 microdeletion including PURA

Differences in manifestations of epilepsy and developmental delay in PURA syndrome and 5q31 microdeletions

PURA is mapped to chromosome 5q31 and plays a vital role in neuronal development and synapse formation. Here, we aim to explore PURA's impact on cognitive development and epilepsy phenotype by comparing patients with single nucleotide variants (SNPs) in the PURA gene (PURA-SNP patients) to those with 5q31 microdeletions including PURA (5q31del + PURA) and those with 5q31 microdeletions not including the PURA gene (5q31del-PURA). A systematic literature search was conducted in PubMed. Two separate searches were performed in order to find patients with PURA SNPs and 5q31 microdeletions. This review includes data from 191 patients collected from a total of 18 articles; 174 of the patients had PURA SNPs, 13 had 5q31 microdeletions involving the PURA gene, and 4 had 5q31 microdeletions without PURA gene implication. All patients exhibited hypotonia, feeding difficulties and dysmorphic features, however epilepsy was primarily present in patients with PURA syndrome, that is, groups PURA-SNP and 5q31del + PURA. Regarding the developmental milestones the 5q31del + PURA group stood out as being the most severe, while the 5q31del-PURA group showed a relatively mild phenotype. Our findings support the hypothesis of PURA being the key contributor of developmental delay and epilepsy among patients with PURA syndrome.

Neuromuscular and Neuromuscular Junction Manifestations of the PURA-NDD: A Systematic Review of the Reported Symptoms and Potential Treatment Options

PURA-related neurodevelopmental disorders (PURA-NDDs) are a rare genetic disease caused by pathogenic autosomal dominant variants in the PURA gene or a deletion encompassing the PURA gene. PURA-NDD is clinically characterized by neurodevelopmental delay, learning disability, neonatal hypotonia, feeding difficulties, abnormal movements, and epilepsy. It is generally considered to be central nervous system disorders, with generalized weakness, associated hypotonia, cognitive and development deficits in early development, and seizures in late stages. Although it is classified predominantly as a central nervous syndrome disorder, some phenotypic features, such as myopathic facies, respiratory insufficiency of muscle origin, and myopathic features on muscle biopsy and electrodiagnostic evaluation, point to a peripheral (neuromuscular) source of weakness. Patients with PURA-NDD have been increasingly identified in exome-sequenced cohorts of patients with neuromuscular- and congenital myasthenic syndrome-like phenotypes. Recently, fluctuating weakness noted in a PURA-NDD patient, accompanied by repetitive nerve stimulation abnormalities, suggested the disease to be a channelopathy and, more specifically, a neuromuscular junction disorder. Treatment with pyridostigmine or salbutamol led to clinical improvement of neuromuscular function in two reported cases. The goal of this systematic retrospective review is to highlight the motor symptoms of PURA-NDD, to further describe the neuromuscular phenotype, and to emphasize the role of potential treatment opportunities of the neuromuscular phenotype in the setting of the potential role of PURA protein in the neuromuscular junction and the muscles.

A 25 Mainland Chinese cohort of patients with PURA-related neurodevelopmental disorders: clinical delineation and genotype-phenotype correlations

PURA-related neurodevelopmental disorders (PURA-NDDs) include 5q31.3 microdeletion syndrome and PURA syndrome. PURA has been proposed as a candidate gene responsible for 5q31.3 microdeletion syndrome. Phenotype comparisons between patients with PURA mutations and 5q31.3 microdeletions encompassing more than PURA gene are lacking. A total of 25 previously undescribed Mainland China patients were evaluated. Clinical data were obtained from medical record review and standardized medical history questionnaire. Clinical profile and genetic spectrum of the patients with PURA syndrome and genotype-phenotype correlations between PURA mutations group and 5q31.3 microdeletions group were analyzed. Our identified seventeen de nove PURA variants were novel, and two recurrent frameshift variants, c.697_699del (p.F233del) and c.159dup (p.L54Afs*147) were detected in the four independent pedigrees. One patient with 5q31.3 microdeletion further supported the shortest overlapping region only contains PURA and IGIP gene. Developmental delay/intellectual disability, neonatal hypotonia, neonatal feeding difficulties, hypersomnolence and dysmorphic features were prominent clinical features in PURA syndrome. There was no significant difference between two groups in incidence of neonatal problems, developmental delay and common medical comorbidities. We observed a higher frequency of abnormal brain MRI and specific facial dysmorphism in 5q31.3 microdeletion group. This is the first work describing a largest cohort of Mainland China patients broaden the clinical and molecular spectrum of PURA-NDDs. Our findings not only demonstrated that PURA haploinsufficiency was a major contributor to the important phenotypes of 5q31.3 microdeletion, but also implied that additional genes still played a role in the 5q31.3 microdeletion.

Structural Protein Effects Underpinning Cognitive Developmental Delay of the PURA p.Phe233del Mutation Modelled by Artificial Intelligence and the Hybrid Quantum Mechanics–Molecular Mechanics Framework

A whole-exome capture and next-generation sequencing was applied to an 11 y/o patient with a clinical history of congenital hypotonia, generalized motor and cognitive neurodevelopmental delay, and severe cognitive deficit, and without any identifiable Syndromic pattern, and to her parents, we disclosed a de novo heterozygous pathogenic mutation, c.697_699del p.Phe233del (rs786204835)(ACMG classification PS2, PM1, PM2, PP5), harbored in the PURA gene (MIM*600473) (5q31.3), associated with Autosomal Dominant Mental Retardation 31 (MIM # 616158). We used the significant improvement in the accuracy of protein structure prediction recently implemented in AlphaFold that incorporates novel neural network architectures and training procedures based on the evolutionary, physical, and geometric constraints of protein structures. The wild-type (WT) sequence and the mutated sequence, missing the Phe233, were reconstructed. The predicted local Distance Difference Test (lDDT) for the PURAwt and the PURA–Phe233del showed that the occurrence of the Phe233del affects between 220–320 amino acids. The distortion in the PURA structural conformation in the ~5 Å surrounding area after the p.Phe233del produces a conspicuous disruption of the repeat III, where the DNA and RNA helix unwinding capability occurs. PURA Protein–DNA docking corroborated these results in an in silico analysis that showed a loss of the contact of the PURA–Phe233del III repeat domain model with the DNA. Together, (i) the energetic and stereochemical, (ii) the hydropathic indexes and polarity surfaces, and (iii) the hybrid Quantum Mechanics–Molecular Mechanics (QM–MM) analyses of the PURA molecular models demarcate, at the atomic resolution, the specific surrounding region affected by these mutations and pave the way for future cell-based functional analysis. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of a de novo mutation underpinning a PURA syndrome in a Latin American patient and highlights the importance of predicting the molecular effects in protein structure using artificial intelligence algorithms and molecular and atomic resolution stereochemical analyses.

Expanding the PURA syndrome phenotype: A child with the recurrent PURA p.(Phe233del) pathogenic variant showing similarities with cutis laxa

BACKGROUND

PURA syndrome is rare autosomal dominant condition characterized by moderate to severe neurodevelopmental delay with absence of speech in nearly all patients and lack of independent ambulation in many. Early-onset problems include excessive hiccups, hypotonia, hypersomnolence, hypothermia, feeding difficulties, recurrent apneas, epileptic seizures, and abnormal nonepileptic movements. Other less common manifestations comprise congenital heart defects, urogenital malformations, and various skeletal, ophthalmological, gastrointestinal, and endocrine anomalies. Up to now, 78 individuals with PURA syndrome and 64 different pathogenic variants have been reported, but no clear-cut genotype-phenotype correlations have emerged so far. Herein, we report the clinical and molecular characterization of a 3-year-old girl with severe hypotonia, global developmental delay, and soft, loose skin, who came to our attention with a suspicion of cutis laxa (CL), which denotes another condition with variable neurodevelopmental problems.

METHODS

Amplicon-based whole exome sequencing was performed, and an in-house pipeline was used to conduct filtering and prioritization of variants. New prediction algorithms for indels were used to validate the pathogenicity of the PURA variant, and results were confirmed with the Sanger method. Finally, we collected clinical and mutational data of all PURA syndrome patients reported yet and compared the clinical features with those of our patient.

RESULTS

Clinical evaluation and biochemical investigations excluded CL and prompted to perform whole exome sequencing, which confirmed the absence of pathogenic variants in all CL-related genes and revealed the known PURA c.697_699del, p.(Phe233del) variant, identified hitherto in seven additional children with PURA syndrome.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data expand the phenotypic spectrum of PURA syndrome by showing that it can be regarded as a differential diagnosis for cutis laxa in early infancy. Our patient and literature review emphasize that a wide clinical variability exists not only between individuals with different PURA variants, but also among patients with the same causal mutation.

West syndrome: a comprehensive review

Since its first clinical description (on his son) by William James West (1793–1848) in 1841, and the definition of the classical triad of (1) infantile spasms; (2) hypsarrhythmia, and (3) developmental arrest or regression as “West syndrome”, new and relevant advances have been recorded in this uncommon disorder. New approaches include terminology of clinical spasms (e.g., infantile (IS) vs. epileptic spasms (ES)), variety of clinical and electroencephalographic (EEG) features (e.g., typical ictal phenomena without EEG abnormalities), burden of developmental delay, spectrum of associated genetic abnormalities, pathogenesis, treatment options, and related outcome and prognosis. Aside the classical manifestations, IS or ES may present with atypical electroclinical phenotypes (e.g., subtle spasms; modified hypsarrhythmia) and may have their onset outside infancy. An increasing number of genes, proteins, and signaling pathways play crucial roles in the pathogenesis. This condition is currently regarded as a spectrum of disorders: the so-called infantile spasm syndrome (ISs), in association with other causal factors, including structural, infectious, metabolic, syndromic, and immunologic events, all acting on a genetic predisposing background. Hormonal therapy and ketogenic diet are widely used also in combination with (classical and recent) pharmacological drugs. Biologically targeted and gene therapies are increasingly studied. The present narrative review searched in seven electronic databases (primary MeSH terms/keywords included West syndrome, infantile spasms and infantile spasms syndrome and were coupled to 25 secondary clinical, EEG, therapeutic, outcomes, and associated conditions terms) including MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane Central, Web of Sciences, Pubmed, Scopus, and OMIM to highlight the past knowledge and more recent advances.