Effect of antibody charge and concentration on deposition of antibody to glomerular basement membrane

Sialylated Autoantigen-Reactive IgG Antibodies Attenuate Disease Development in Autoimmune Mouse Models of Lupus Nephritis and Rheumatoid Arthritis

Pro- and anti-inflammatory effector functions of IgG antibodies (Abs) depend on their subclass and Fc glycosylation pattern. Accumulation of non-galactosylated (agalactosylated; G0) IgG Abs in the serum of rheumatoid arthritis and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients reflects severity of the diseases. In contrast, sialylated IgG Abs are responsible for anti-inflammatory effects of the intravenous immunoglobulin (pooled human serum IgG from healthy donors), administered in high doses (2 g/kg) to treat autoimmune patients. However, whether low amounts of sialylated autoantigen-reactive IgG Abs can also inhibit autoimmune diseases is hardly investigated. Here, we explore whether sialylated autoantigen-reactive IgG Abs can inhibit autoimmune pathology in different mouse models. We found that sialylated IgG auto-Abs fail to induce inflammation and lupus nephritis in a B cell receptor (BCR) transgenic lupus model, but instead are associated with lower frequencies of pathogenic Th1, Th17 and B cell responses. In accordance, the transfer of small amounts of immune complexes containing sialylated IgG Abs was sufficient to attenuate the development of nephritis. We further showed that administration of sialylated collagen type II (Col II)-specific IgG Abs attenuated the disease symptoms in a model of Col II-induced arthritis and reduced pathogenic Th17 cell and autoantigen-specific IgG Ab responses. We conclude that sialylated autoantigen-specific IgG Abs may represent a promising tool for treating pathogenic T and B cell immune responses in autoimmune diseases.

T cell-independent B cell activation induces immunosuppressive sialylated IgG antibodies

Antigen-specific Abs are able to enhance or suppress immune responses depending on the receptors that they bind on immune cells. Recent studies have shown that pro- or antiinflammatory effector functions of IgG Abs are also regulated through their Fc N-linked glycosylation patterns. IgG Abs that are agalactosylated (non-galactosylated) and asialylated are proinflammatory and induced by the combination of T cell-dependent (TD) protein antigens and proinflammatory costimulation. Sialylated IgG Abs, which are immunosuppressive, and Tregs are produced in the presence of TD antigens under tolerance conditions. T cell-independent (TI) B cell activation via B cell receptor (BCR) crosslinking through polysaccharides or via BCR and TLR costimulation also induces IgG Abs, but the Fc glycosylation state of these Abs is unknown. We found in mouse experiments that TI immune responses induced suppressive sialylated IgGs, in contrast to TD proinflammatory Th1 and Th17 immune responses, which induced agalactosylated and asialylated IgGs. Transfer of low amounts of antigen-specific sialylated IgG Abs was sufficient to inhibit B cell activation and pathogenic immune reactions. These findings suggest an immune regulatory function for TI immune responses through the generation of immunosuppressive sialylated IgGs and may provide insight on the role of TI immune responses during infection, vaccination, and autoimmunity.

Prostaglandin E2 promotes cellular recovery from established nephrotoxic serum nephritis in mice, prosurvival, and regenerative effects on glomerular cells

We postulated that prostaglandin E2 (PGE2), which exhibits regulatory functions to control immune-mediated inflammation, fibrosis, oxidative stress, and tissue/cellular regeneration, has the potential to improve the course of nephritis. Therefore, the therapeutic potential of prostanoid on established nephritis in mice was evaluated focusing on its role on renal cellular recovery, with emphasis on its cytoprotecting and growth-promoting effects. Acute nephritis was induced in mice by single injection of nephrotoxic serum (NTS), followed by PGE2 administration with severity of nephritis evaluated over time. Mice injected with PGE2 recovered promptly with normalization of blood urea nitrogen and urine protein levels and histology. Recovery was observed with dosing of prostanoid at day 1, as well as day 4. With the use of selective EP1-4 receptor agonists, EP3 receptor has been identified as important in mediating beneficial effects of PGE2 in our system. PGE2 normalized glomerular cell losses during nephrotoxic serum-induced nephritis, restored synaptopodin distribution and F-actin filaments arrangement in glomeruli. In cell culture, PGE2 reduced nephrotoxim serum (NTS)-induced apoptosis of glomerular cells and promoted cell reproliferation after NTS-mediated injury. In conclusion, PGE2 treatment promotes resolution of glomerular inflammation. Consistent with this observation, the regenerative and cytoprotective effects of prostanoid on glomerular cells in culture were observed, suggesting that PGE2 may be beneficial in the treatment of glomerulonephritis.

Pathology and protection in nephrotoxic nephritis is determined by selective engagement of specific Fc receptors

Introduction of heterologous anti–glomerular basement membrane antiserum (nephrotoxic serum, NTS) into presensitized mice triggers the production of IgG anti-NTS antibodies that are predominantly IgG2b and the glomerular deposition of pathogenic immune complexes, leading to accelerated renal disease. The pathology observed in this model is determined by the effector cell activation threshold that is established by the coexpression on infiltrating macrophages of the IgG2a/2b restricted activation receptor FcγRIV and its inhibitory receptor counterpart, FcγRIIB. Blocking FcγRIV with a specific monoclonal antibody thereby preventing IgG2b engagement or treatment with high dose intravenous γ-globulin (IVIG) to down-regulate FcγRIV while up-regulating FcγRIIB, protects mice from fatal disease. In the absence of FcγRIIB, IVIG is not protective; this indicates that reduced FcγRIV expression alone is insufficient to protect animals from pathogenic IgG2b immune complexes. These results establish the significance of specific IgG subclasses and their cognate FcγRs in renal disease.

Susceptibility to anti-glomerular basement membrane disease and Goodpasture syndrome is linked to MHC class II genes and the emergence of T cell-mediated immunity in mice

We developed a new mouse model of human anti-glomerular basement membrane (GBM) disease to better characterize the genetic determinants of cell-mediated injury. While all major histocompatibility complex (MHC) haplotypes (H-2a, k, s, b, and d) immunized with alpha3 NC1 domains of type IV collagen produce anti-alpha3(IV) NC1 antibodies that cross-react with human Goodpasture [anti-GBM/anti-alpha3(IV) NC1] autoantibodies, only a few strains developed nephritis and lung hemorrhage associated with Goodpasture syndrome. Crescentic glomerulonephritis and lung hemorrhage were MHC-restricted in haplotypes H-2s, b, and d (A beta/A alpha region in H-2s) and associated with the emergence of an IL-12/Th1-like T cell phenotype. Lymphocytes or anti-alpha3(IV) NC1 antibodies from nephritogenic strains transfer disease to syngeneic recipients. However, passive transfer of isogenic alpha3(IV) NC1 antibodies into -/- T cell receptor-deficient mice failed to produce nephritis. Finally, nephritis and its associated IL-12/Th1-like T cell response attenuate in disease-susceptible mice tolerized orally to alpha3(IV) collagen before immunization. Our findings suggest collectively, as a hypothesis, that anti-GBM antibodies in mice only facilitate disease in MHC haplotypes capable of generating nephritogenic lymphocytes with special T cell repertoires.

Autoantibodies from mixed cryoglobulinaemia patients bind glomerular antigens

Mixed cryoglobulinaemia (MC) is a disorder characterized by the presence of large amounts of cryoprecipitating IgM-IgG complexes. An immune complex glomerulonephritis develops in one third of all patients, but its occurrence does not seem related to the amount of cryoglobulins in the sera, nor to their complement-fixing ability. In this study we investigated the presence of IgG antibodies reactive with kidney antigens in 33 MC patients (11 with glomerulonephritis, 22 without renal involvement). A total glomerular extract was run on a 10% acrylamide gel, blotted to nitrocellulose and probed with the patients' sera. Sera from half of the patients without renal involvement reacted with several glomerular antigens whose molecular weight ranged between 200 and 29 kD. In the group with renal involvement, sera from 7/11 patients reacted with an antigen of 50 kD, which is also expressed in thymus, but not in the heart or liver. In a follow-up study of four patients with renal involvement, the amount of serum antibody specific for the 50-kD antigen fluctuated, either spontaneously or in response to therapy. These results show that antibodies specific for glomerular antigens are detectable in MC sera. The immune response against a 50-kD antigen expressed in the kidney and thymus seems to be restricted to a subset of MC patients with renal involvement. Circulating autoantibodies specific for glomerular antigens might contribute to the induction of glomerulonephritis in MC forming immune complexes in situ.

Nephritogenicity of proteoglycans. II. A model of immune complex nephritis

Antibodies to glomerular basement membrane, heparan sulfate-proteoglycans are nephrotoxic but possess a weak nephritogenic potential. In order to enhance the nephritogenic potential, the antibodies were intravenously administered into rats presensitized with heterologous rabbit IgG. This resulted in the integration of heterologous and autologous phases, the two phases characteristic of the traditional model of nephrotoxic serum nephritis. The presensitization caused a dramatic shift in the binding characteristics of the heterologous antibodies between the kidney and lymphoid tissues. A proliferative form of immune complex glomerulonephritis associated with a remarkable proteinuric response was observed. In addition, a moderate degree of hematuria was noted as well. The proteinuria was largely complement-dependent and may possibly be cell-mediated as well. The proteinuria became severe with increasing production of host IgG antibodies and with their subsequent sequestration in the glomeruli. The predominant glomerular lesions were in the form of epimembranous/subepithelial immune deposits, which became more frequent with timely increasing titer of host autologous IgG antibodies. These findings indicate that antibodies to heparan sulfate-proteoglycan, an authentic component of the basement membrane, are capable of mediating a glomerular injury with acquisition of nephritogenic potential in an appropriate environment of the host. At present, it seems that this is the sole constituent of the basement membrane whose antibodies are capable of inducing an immune complex nephritis.

Glomerular localization of circulating single-stranded DNA in mice. Dependence on the molecular weight of DNA

Although it has been observed that DNA has a high binding affinity for the glomerular basement membrane (GBM) in vitro, glomerular localization of DNA has not been demonstrated in vivo. To evaluate this possibility, after injection of 125I ssDNA of varying molecular weight (mol. wt.) to normal mice, we measured glomerular levels of DNA in vivo. Following administration of 2 mg of 125I high mol. wt. purified single stranded(ss) DNA (2-6 kilobases; 0.7-2.0 x 10(6)D) to normal mice, DNA was not detected in glomeruli, despite measurable blood levels of DNA for 72 h. In contrast, after injection of 280 micrograms of low mol. wt. 125ssDNA (160-200 bases; mol. wt. = 5.3-6.6 x 10(4)D) to normal mice, glomerular localization was observed throughout the 24-h study period despite relatively low 125IssDNA blood levels. The results of these studies indicate that free circulating DNA can bind to sites within glomeruli in vivo, and that the size of DNA is crucial for this interaction. Since low mol. wt. DNA is present in the plasma of patients with active lupus, these findings raise the possibility that DNA may bind to glomeruli and serve as a planted antigen for in situ immune complex formation with circulating anti-DNA antibodies.

Effect of diet, age and sex on the renal response to immune injury in the rat

We investigated the effect of three factors, namely dietary protein intake, age and sex, on the susceptibility of the renal glomerulus to the binding of antiglomerular basement membrane antibody (anti-GBM) in the early (heterologous) phase of anti-GBM nephritis, and the consequent reduction in glomerular filtration rate (GFR) as measured by inulin clearance (CIn). The effect of diet was examined in approximately equal to 8 week-old female Munich-Wistar rats fed a 40% high (HP) or a 6% low (LP) protein diet, and that of sex and age in male and female rats, 6 week or 10 month old. Following an intravenous dose (3 to 20 micrograms/g body wt) of radiolabeled nephritogenic anti-GBM, assessment of glomerular function was followed by quantitation of anti-GBM binding (values corrected for GBM surface area) in isolated glomeruli. At a given plasma level of antibody, the degree of binding of anti-GBM was slightly but significantly higher in HP than LP-fed rats; the decrease in GFR was significantly more pronounced in HP than LP-fed animals. The amount of anti-GBM binding was significantly greater in adult than young animals; however, the consequent decrease in GFR was more pronounced in the young than adult animals. Sex dependency was not discernible in anti-GBM binding or reduction in GFR. In all of the above experimental groups, the degree of anti-GBM binding was closely correlated with the plasma level of anti-GBM, but not with effective renal plasma flow rate, measured by PAH clearance. Separate groups of rats were subjected to experimental manipulation of single nephron GFR, glomerular capillary hydraulic pressure and glomerular plasma flow rate, by partial aortic constriction and saralasin administration. This set of experiments, using a tracer amount of non-nephritogenic anti-GBM, revealed that glomerular anti-GBM binding is independent of any of the above parameters. The studies indicate that dietary protein intake and age, but not sex, are among the factors determining the susceptibility of the glomerulus to acute immune injury. Since the binding of anti-GBM is determined by the affinity property of the glomerulus per se, and not by the prevailing hemodynamic pattern, the observed dependence of susceptibility to functional impairment on age and protein intake appears to also reflect a property of the glomerulus, which is influenced by age and the degree of dietary protein intake.

Interaction of toxic cations with the glomerulus: binding of Ni to purified glomerular basement membrane

Basement membrane was prepared from the glomeruli of bovine kidneys using either detergent extraction, sonication or trichloroacetic acid (TCA) treatment. An assay was developed to measure the binding of radiolabelled metal salts to particulate suspensions of the membrane. 63Ni bound to the anionic glycosaminoglycan (GAG) sites of the membrane. This binding could be blocked by the cationic dye ruthenium red, and was sensitive to treatment with heparitinase but not to mild collagenase digestion. At pH 7.4 at low ionic strength (5 mM Tris-HCl), a high affinity (Ka = 4.5 X 10(6) M-1) binding site was distinguished. It was insensitive to increasing salt concentration, but was abolished by desulfation of the basement membrane preparation. 54Mn showed a similar binding pattern to Ni, while 65Zn and 109Cd lacked the high affinity site. In all cases the bulk of binding was of lower affinity and was of a non-specific electrostatic nature. Most, but not all, was abolished by salt concentrations comparable to those of the plasma filtrate (140 mM NaCl). These results are discussed in the context of sensitivity of the glomerular charge barrier to toxic divalent ions.

Interaction of immune complexes with glomerular heparan sulfate-proteoglycans

The binding characteristics of cationic and more neutral immune complexes with heparan sulfate-proteoglycan enriched anionic sites of glomerular basement membrane and mesangial matrix were studied. Rat kidneys were treated either with buffers alone or buffers containing heparitinase or chondroitinase-ABC followed by perfusion with cationic or native immune complexes. Tissues were processed for immunofluorescence and transmission electron microscopy after fixation with glutaraldehyde or tannic acid glutaraldehyde. Kidneys perfused with radioiodinated immune complexes were processed for light and electron microscopic autoradiography. In addition, glomeruli from kidneys perfused with radioiodinated immune complexes were isolated and counted for radioactivity. By immunofluorescence the cationic immune complexes deposited linearly along the glomerular basement membrane. By electron microscopy, the cationic complexes localized mainly in the inner and outer layers of the glomerular basement membrane and to a certain extent in the mesangial matrix in a distribution that corresponded to previously documented anionic sites. Whereas heparitinase treatment abrogated the binding of cationic immune complexes in both glomerular basement membrane and mesangial matrix, chondroitinase-ABC treatment did not cause any decrease in binding. In contrast, more neutral immune complexes appeared to be nonspecifically trapped in the mesangium, and their distribution was unaffected by both enzymatic treatments. Light and electron microscopic autoradiography and counts of isolated glomeruli confirmed these findings. The results overall indicate that cationic immune complexes bind electrostatically to the heparan sulfate-proteoglycan enriched anionic sites of the glomerular basement membrane and mesangial matrix, while more neutral immune complexes are nonspecifically trapped in the mesangium of the renal glomerulus.

Charge selective properties of the glomerular capillary wall influence antibody binding in rat membranous nephropathy

IgG antibodies, eluted from kidneys of rats with Heymann nephritis were separated into cationic and anionic fractions, labeled with 125I and 131I, respectively, mixed in equal amounts, and then injected in incremental doses into 10 rats. Glomerular antibody binding was highly correlated with blood concentration of antibody at 24 hr, however, significantly more cationic antibody bound to glomeruli than did anionic antibody at all blood levels studied. The differences were not due to greater antibody content and/or avidity of the cationic preparation, as measured by binding to isolated glomeruli in vitro. These studies demonstrate the influence of glomerular permselectivity and antibody charge on subepithelial antibody deposition.

Antibody, antigen, and glomerular capillary wall charge interactions: influence of antigen location on in situ immune complex formation

These studies examined the charge interactions between the glomerular capillary wall, antibody and antigen at different sites in the glomerulus. Sheep IgG was separated into differently charged subclasses and immunologically placed in one of two glomerular locations (subepithelial or subendothelial) to serve as planted antigen. Single kidneys with planted antigen were transplanted into uninephrectomized recipients that received affinity-purified, cationic and anionic rat anti-sheep IgG labelled with 125I and 131I, respectively. Glomerular bound antibody was determined and corrected for antibody delivery. Specificity of antibody binding was confirmed by comparison of kidneys with or without planted antigen. The results indicate that the influence of charge on glomerular antibody binding depends on the site of the antigen. When antigen was planted in the subepithelial space, significantly more (15 to 25%) cationic than anionic antibody bound despite the fact that the antigen was cationic. Conversely, when the antigen was planted subendothelially, significantly more anionic (13 to 22%) antibody bound when the antigen was cationic, and significantly more cationic (7 to 16%) antibody bound when the antigen was anionic. Thus, the negatively-charged glomerular filtration barrier retards the permeation of anionic antibodies that complex with antigens located in the subepithelial space, but antigen-antibody charge interactions appear to predominate when the antigen is more proximally located.

Nature of the glomerular capillary injury in human membranous glomerulopathy

A differential solute clearance technique was used to evaluate glomerular capillary wall function in 20 patients with membranous glomerulopathy and massive proteinuria. The clearance of inulin, the filtration fraction, and the fractional clearance of uncharged dextrans of a radius of 28-48 A were depressed significantly below control values in 20 healthy volunteers (P less than 0.01). In contrast, the fractional clearance of dextrans of radius greater than 50 A was elevated markedly. A theoretical model of solute transport that depicts the major portion of the glomerular capillary wall as an isoporous membrane and the minor portion as a nondiscriminatory shunt pathway revealed the calculated glomerular ultrafiltration coefficient to be five times lower and mean pore radius of the major membrane component to be 4 A smaller than control values. However, the fraction of filtrate volume permeating the shunt pathway was three- to fourfold above control values and correlated strongly in individual patients with the fractional clearance of albumin (r = 0.76) and of IgG (r = 0.80). Lowering renal plasma flow by 24% during indomethacin therapy in seven patients resulted in a 74% reduction in proteinuria accompanied by a corresponding diminution of filtrate formed through the shunt pathway. Morphometric analysis of glomerular ultrastructure revealed the magnitude of depression of the glomerular filtration rate and of urinary protein leakage to be related strongly to changes in the epithelial layer of the glomerular capillary wall, but not to the density of subepithelial immune deposits. We conclude that glomerular capillaries in membranous glomerulopathy are characterized by a loss of ultrafiltration capacity and of barrier size-selectivity, and that subepithelial immune deposits do not provide a structural basis for these functional alterations.

Nephritogenicity of antibodies to proteoglycans of the glomerular basement membrane--I

We investigated nephritogenic potential of antibodies to heparan sulfate-proteoglycan of glomerular basement membrane. Glomeruli were isolated, basement membranes were prepared, proteoglycans extracted, and purified core protein was obtained. We immunized rabbits with the core protein, IgG fraction prepared from the antisera and specificity of the antibody determined. A single immunoprecipitin line in agar diffusion plate and a single band (approximately 18,000 mol wt) on the immunoblot autoradiograms were visualized. The antibody showed precise reactivity with the glomerular basement membranes. The clearance studies indicated that approximately 75% of the radioiodinated antibody disappeared from circulation within 1 h and 1-2% bound to the kidney. For nephritogenicity experiments, the antibody was intravenously administered into rats and we examined their kidneys at 1 h to 24 d later. A linear immunofluorescence of glomerular basement membranes was observed with rabbit IgG at all times while that of C3 until the 10th day. Early morphologic changes included glomerular infiltration of polymorphonuclear leukocytes with focal exfoliation of endothelium. The leukocytic infiltration subsided by the third day and was followed by progressive thickening of basement membranes, focal mesangial cell proliferation, increase in mesangial matrix, and accumulation of monocytes. Focal knob-like thickening of glomerular basement membrane was observed from the 15th day onward. Regularly-spaced electrondense deposits were seen in the lamina rara interna and externa of glomerular basement membranes and persisted throughout the investigatory period. No significant proteinuria was observed at any stage of the experiment. These findings suggest that the antibodies to the basement membrane heparan sulfate-proteoglycan are nephrotoxic but possess weak nephritogenic potential.

Influence of antigen distribution on the mediation of immunological glomerular injury

To determine if the site of immune reaction could influence the mediation and morphological expression of glomerular injury in experimental anti-glomerular basement membrane (anti-GBM) nephritis and membranous nephropathy, we studied the events that followed the in situ reaction of rat antibody with antigen planted in either the GBM (especially the lamina rara interna) or in the subepithelial space (SE). Non-nephritogenic amounts of noncomplement-fixing sheep anti-GBM or anti-tubular brushborder antibody were injected into separate groups of rats to plant sheep IgG in the GBM and SE, respectively. Kidneys containing sheep IgG were then transplanted into naive recipients that were passively immunized with rat anti-sheep IgG. There was marked proteinuria after 2 days (antigen in GBM: 226 +/- 50.7; antigen in SE: 69 +/- 50.7 mg/24 hr) that was abrogated by prior depletion of complement in both groups (antigen in GBM: 10.2 +/- 1.7; antigen in SE: 14.3 +/- 8.7 mg/24 hr). When antigen was planted in SE, inflammatory-cell depletion with either anti-neutrophil (PMN) serum or lethal irradiation had no effect on proteinuria. In contrast, anti-PMN abolished proteinuria (12.0 +/- 5.6 mg/24 hr) and irradiation reduced it by 60% when antigen was in GBM. Glomeruli of kidneys with antigen in GBM were significantly larger and more hypercellular than those with antigen in SE after transplantation into immunized recipients. Endothelial cell injury and adherence of inflammatory cells to denuded GBM were prominent in the former (antigen in GBM), while glomeruli with antigen in SE showed only subepithelial deposits, adjacent slit-diaphragm displacement, and epithelial cell foot-process effacement. Thus, the reaction of antigen and antibody in glomeruli produced complement-mediated injury which was cell-independent when complex formation occurred on the outer aspect of the GBM but was cell-dependent when the same reagents reacted more proximally to the circulation. We therefore conclude that antigen distribution can critically influence the mediation and morphologic expression of immune glomerular injury and may, in part, account for variations in the clinical and histological manifestations of antibody-induced glomerular disease in humans.