Flow cytometric detection of peripheral blood involvement by mycosis fungoides and Sézary syndrome using T-cell receptor Vbeta chain antibodies and its application in blood staging

cyTRBC1 evaluation rapidly identifies sCD3-negative peripheral T-cell lymphomas and reveals a novel type of sCD3-negative T-cell clone with uncertain significance

The flow cytometry-based evaluation of TRBC1 expression has been demonstrated as a rapid and specific method for detecting T-cell clones in sCD3-positive TCRαβ+ mature T-cell lymphoma. The aim of the study was to validate the utility of surface (s) TRBC1 and cytoplastic (cy) TRBC1 assessment in detecting clonality of sCD3-negative peripheral T-cell lymphomas (PTCLs), as well as exploring the existence and characteristics of sCD3-negative clonal T-cell populations with uncertain significance (T-CUS). Evaluation of sTRBC1 and cyTRBC1 were assessed on 61 samples from 37 patients with sCD3-negative PTCLs, including 26 angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma (AITL) patients and 11 non-AITL patients. The sCD3-negative T-CUS were screened from 1602 patients without T-cell malignancy and 100 healthy individuals. Additionally, the clonality of cells was further detected through T-cell gene rearrangement analysis. We demonstrated the monotypic expression patterns of cyTRBC1 in all sCD3-negative PTCLs. Utilizing the cyTRBC1 evaluation assay, we identified a novel and rare subtype of sCD3-negative T-CUS for the first time among 13 out of 1602 (0.8%) patients without T-cell malignancy. The clonality of these cells was further confirmed through T-cell gene rearrangement analysis. This subset exhibited characteristics such as sCD3-cyCD3 + CD4 + CD45RO+, closely resembling AITL rather than non-AITL. Further analysis revealed that sCD3-negative T-CUS exhibited a smaller clone size in the lymph node and mass specimens compared to AITL patients. However, the clone size of sCD3-negative T-CUS was significantly lower than that of non-AITL patients in both specimen groups. In conclusion, we validated the diagnostic utility of cyTRBC1 in detecting sCD3-negative T-cell clonality, provided a comprehensive analysis of sCD3-negative T-CUS, and established a framework and provided valuable insights for distinguishing sCD3-negative T-CUS from sCD3-negative PTCLs based on their phenotypic properties and clone size.

Immunosequencing applications in cutaneous T-cell lymphoma

Immunosequencing has emerged as a newer clinical test for assessment of T-cell clonality in the blood and skin of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL) patients. Utilization of immunosequencing, also known as high-throughput sequencing of the T-cell receptor (HTS-TCR), enables identification and quantification of the precise genetic signature of dominant T-cell clones. Although immunosequencing is more sensitive than commonly used methods such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR) paired with capillary electrophoresis or flow cytometry, it remains underutilized for CTCL management. Nonetheless, incorporation of HTS-TCR in clinical practice offers distinct advantages compared to other molecular analyses that may improve diagnostic evaluation, prognostication, and disease monitoring in CTCL. The objective of this comprehensive review is to provide a thorough explanation of the application of immunosequencing in the context of CTCL. We describe the significance of T-cell clonality and the methods used to detect it, including a detailed comparison between PCR paired with capillary electrophoresis and HTS-TCR. The utilization of immunosequencing in the blood and skin of CTCL patients is discussed in depth, specifically outlining how HTS-TCR can assist in diagnosing CTCL, predicting outcomes, and tracking disease progression. Finally, we address the potential applications of immunosequencing in clinical management and research as well as the novel challenges it presents.

Molecular techniques drive cutting edge advancements in management of cutaneous T cell lymphoma

Cutaneous 5T cell lymphoma (CTCL), characterized by malignant T cells infiltrating the skin with potential for dissemination, remains a challenging disease to diagnose and treat due to disease heterogeneity, treatment resistance, and lack of effective and standardized diagnostic and prognostic clinical tools. Currently, diagnosis of CTCL practically relies on clinical presentation, histopathology, and immunohistochemistry. These methods are collectively fraught with limitations in sensitivity and specificity. Fortunately, recent advances in flow cytometry, polymerase chain reaction, high throughput sequencing, and other molecular techniques have shown promise in improving diagnosis and treatment of CTCL. Examples of these advances include T cell receptor clonotyping via sequencing to detect CTCL earlier in the disease course and single-cell RNA sequencing to identify gene expression patterns that commonly drive CTCL pathogenesis. Experience with these techniques has afforded novel insights which may translate into enhanced diagnostic and therapeutic approaches for CTCL.

Rapid evaluation of T cell clonality in the diagnostic work-up of mature T cell neoplasms: TRBC1-based flow cytometric assay experience

The identification of mature T cell neoplasms by flow cytometry is often challenging, due to overlapping features with reactive T cells and limitations of currently available T cell clonality assays. The description of an antibody specific for one of two mutually exclusive T cell receptor (TCR) β-chain constant regions (TRBC1) provides an opportunity to facilitate the detection of clonal TCRαβ+ T cells based on TRBC-restriction. Here we prospectively analyzed 14 healthy controls and 63 patients with the flow cytometry protocol currently used for suspected T cell neoplasm implemented with immunostaining targeting TRBC1. Specimens were firstly classified in 3 groups based on clinical records data, laboratory findings and immunophenotypic features. T cell clonality was assessed by TCR Vβ repertoire analysis and the new rapid TRBC1 assay. Results showed that TRBC1 unimodal expression was unequivocally associated with samples presenting with immunophenotypic aberrancies. Moreover, we demonstrated that the use of TRBC1 is useful in solving uncertain cases and confirmed the high sensitivity of the method in identifying small T cell clones of uncertain significance (T-CUS). Finally, we found a high degree of concordance (97%) comparing the currently available clonality assessment methods with the proposed new method. In conclusion, our results provided real-life evidence of the utility of TRBC1 introduction in the flow cytometric clonality evaluation for the routine diagnostic work-up of T cell neoplasms.

How I Diagnose Mature T-Cell Proliferations by Flow Cytometry

OBJECTIVES

Mature T-cell neoplasms are a challenging area of diagnostic hematopathology. Flow cytometry has emerged as a useful technique for T-cell assessment.

METHODS

We discuss the application of flow cytometry to the evaluation of mature T-cell proliferations, to include illustrative cases, theoretical framework, detailed review of normal and reactive T-cell subsets, and examination of diagnostic pitfalls.

RESULTS

Immunophenotypic aberrancy can be construed as a direct expression of the neoplastic phenotype, in contrast to clonal expansion, which is seen in reactive and neoplastic T-cell proliferations. Major and minor T-cell subsets show characteristic patterns of antigen expression. Reactive states can manifest expansions of normal minor subsets and also show alterations of antigen expression on certain populations. However, some patterns of antigen expression are either never or very rarely encountered in reactive T cells. Flow cytometric tools are now available to directly assess clonality in specific T-cell populations. Technical and biological pitfalls may complicate the interpretation of T-cell flow cytometry.

CONCLUSIONS

Flow cytometry is a very useful tool in the diagnostic armamentarium for the assessment of mature T-cell proliferations, but it must be interpreted based on a thorough knowledge of the T-cell immune response, as well as an awareness of clinical context.

PD-1 improves accurate detection of Sezary cells by flow cytometry in peripheral blood in mycosis fungoides/Sezary syndrome

BACKGROUND

Accurate Sezary cell detection in peripheral blood of mycosis fungoides/Sezary syndrome (MF/SS) patients by flow cytometry can be difficult due to overlapping immunophenotypes with normal T cells using standard markers. We assessed the utility of programmed death-1 (PD-1/CD279), a transmembrane protein expressed in some hematopoietic cells, for identification and quantitation of circulating Sezary cells among established markers using flow cytometry.

METHODS

50 MF/SS and 20 control blood samples were immunophenotyped by flow cytometry. Principal component analysis (PCA) assessed contributions of antigens to separation of abnormal from normal T cell populations. PD-1 was assessed over time in blood and bone marrow of available MF/SS cases.

RESULTS

Normal CD4+ T cells showed dim/intermediate to absent PD-1 expression. PD-1 in Sezary cells was informatively brighter (≥1/3 log) than internal normal CD4+ T cells in 39/50 (78%) cases. By PCA, PD-1 ranked 3rd behind CD7 and CD26 in population separation as a whole; it ranked in the top 3 markers in 32/50 (64%) cases and 1st in 4/50 (8%) cases when individual abnormal populations were compared to total normal CD4+ T cells. PD-1 clearly separated Sezary from normal CD4+ T cells in 15/26 (58%, 30% of total) cases with few and subtle alterations of pan-T cell antigens/CD26 and was critical in 6 (12% of total), without which identification and quantification were significantly affected or nearly impossible. PD-1 remained informative in blood/bone marrow over time in most patients.

CONCLUSIONS

PD-1 significantly contributes to accurate flow cytometric Sezary cell assessment in a routine Sezary panel.

Sézary syndrome patient-derived models allow drug selection for personalized therapy

Patient-derived SS cells show highly heterogeneous drug responses.

We have developed a joint in vitro/in vivo platform to predict SS therapy response.

Current therapeutic approaches for Sézary syndrome (SS) do not achieve a significant improvement in long-term survival of patients, and they are mainly focused on reducing blood tumor burden to improve quality of life. Eradication of SS is hindered by its genetic and molecular heterogeneity. Determining effective and personalized treatments for SS is urgently needed. The present work compiles the current methods for SS patient–derived xenograft (PDX) generation and management to provide new perspectives on treatment for patients with SS. Mononuclear cells were recovered by Ficoll gradient separation from fresh peripheral blood of patients with SS (N = 11). A selected panel of 26 compounds that are inhibitors of the main signaling pathways driving SS pathogenesis, including NF-kB, MAPK, histone deacetylase, mammalian target of rapamycin, or JAK/STAT, was used for in vitro drug sensitivity testing. SS cell viability was evaluated by using the CellTiter-Glo_3D Cell Viability Assay and flow cytometry analysis. We validated one positive hit using SS patient–derived Sézary cells xenotransplanted (PDX) into NOD-SCID-γ mice. In vitro data indicated that primary malignant SS cells all display different sensitivities against specific pathway inhibitors. In vivo validation using SS PDX mostly reproduced the responses to the histone deacetylase inhibitor panobinostat that were observed in vitro. Our investigations revealed the possibility of using high-throughput in vitro testing followed by PDX in vivo validation for selective targeting of SS tumor cells in a patient-specific manner.

Flow cytometry for the assessment of blood tumour burden in cutaneous T-cell lymphoma: towards a standardised approach

Mycosis fungoides (MF) and Sézary syndrome (SS) are the best-studied subtypes of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, a rare non-Hodgkin lymphoma that primarily presents in the skin but can also involve blood, lymph nodes, and viscera. The role of blood involvement in the assessment and staging of MF and SS has evolved in recent years from being classed as simply 'present' or 'absent', with no impact on staging, to full analysis of abnormal peripheral-blood T cells using flow cytometry (FC) to detect and quantify aberrant T-cell phenotypes and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to characterise T-cell receptor gene rearrangements. These sensitive peripheral-blood assessments are replacing manual Sézary cell counts and have become an important part of clinical work-up in MF and SS, providing the potential for more accurate prognostication and appropriate management. However, although international recommendations now include guidelines for FC analysis of peripheral-blood markers for staging purposes, many clinics only perform these analyses in advanced-stage patients, if at all, and there is still a need for standardised use of validated markers. Standardisation of a single effective multiparameter FC panel would allow for accurate identification and quantification of blood tumour burden for diagnosis, staging, assessment of therapeutic response, and monitoring of disease progression at all stages of disease. Once defined, validation of an MF/SS biomarker FC panel will enable uptake into clinical settings along with associated standardisation of protocols and reagents. This review discusses the evolution of the role of FC in evaluating blood involvement in MF and SS, considers recently published international guidelines, and identifies evidence gaps for future research that will allow for standardisation of FC in MF and SS.

CD158k and PD-1 expressions define heterogeneous subtypes of Sezary syndrome

SS can be divided into 3 subtypes, each with a different immune environment and response to treatment.

Sezary syndrome (SS) is a rare leukemic form of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. Diagnosis mainly depends on flow cytometry, but results are not specific enough to be unequivocal. The difficulty in defining a single marker that could characterize Sezary cells may be the consequence of different pathological subtypes. In this study, we used multivariate flow cytometry analyses. We chose to investigate the expression of classical CD3, CD4, CD7, and CD26 and the new association of 2 markers CD158k and PD-1. We performed lymphocyte computational phenotypic analyses during diagnosis and follow-up of patients with SS to define new SS classes and improve the sensitivity of the diagnosis and the follow-up flow cytometry method. Three classes of SS, defined by different immunophenotypic profiles, CD158k⁺ SS, CD158k⁻PD-1⁺ SS, CD158k and PD-1 double-negative SS, showed different CD8⁺ and B-cell environments. Such a study could help to diagnose and define biological markers of susceptibility/resistance to treatment, including immunotherapy.

Monitoring malignant T-cell clones by direct TCR expression assay in patients with leukemic cutaneous T-cell lymphoma during extracorporeal photopheresis

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Accurate assessment of malignant T-cell clones in patients with leukemic cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (L-CTCL) is crucial for diagnosis, treatment, and monitoring disease. Although multiple approaches to quantitate malignant T-cell clones have been reported, a cost-effective assay with broad coverage is not available. We report a NanoString-nCounter-Technology-based direct TCR expression assay (DTEA) that was previously developed to quantify both TCR-Vα and TCR-Vβ usages after adoptive immunotherapy. This study was performed to test the effectiveness of DTEA in assessing malignant T-cell clones in L-CTCL patients.

METHODS

Total RNAs extracted from peripheral blood mononuclear cells of patients before starting extracorporeal photopheresis (ECP) (n = 15) and during therapy at 3 months and 6 months (n = 12) were used for DTEA, with customized probes for 45 TCR-Vα and 46 TCR-Vβ family members.

RESULTS

At baseline, DTEA detected TCR-Vβ clones in all 15 patients (100%) compared to flow cytometry that detected TCR-Vβ clones in 9 of 13 patients (69.2%). In addition to predominant TCR-Vβ clones, DTEA also detected additional TCR-Vβ clones in 8 of 15 patients (53.3%). Furthermore, DTEA simultaneously identified clonal TCR-Vα usages, which allowed us to pair TCR-Vα and TCRVβ usages by malignant T-cells and identify diversified clonotypes. Changes in the relative frequencies of clonal TCR-Vβ and TCRVα usages over therapy were consistent with patients' clinical responses.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that DTEA can effectively assess malignant T-cell clones by detecting clonal TCR-Vα and TCR-Vβ usages. By providing a global view of TCR repertoires, DTEA may also help us understand the origin(s) of malignant T-cells and pathogenesis of CTCL.

T-Cell Receptor Gene Rearrangement Clonality, Flow Cytometry Status, and Associated Outcomes in Early-Stage Cutaneous T-Cell Lymphoma

Importance

The prognostic significance of clonal T-cell receptor (TCR) rearrangement or low-level blood involvement as assessed by flow cytometry for patients with early-stage cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL) is not clear.

Objective

To assess the association of low-level blood involvement by TCR clonality and flow cytometry with outcomes for patients with early-stage CTCL.

Design, Setting, and Participants

A retrospective cohort analysis was conducted from September 1, 2019, to February 29, 2020, of 322 patients with early-stage (I-IIA) CTCL seen at the Winship Cancer Institute of Emory University and Grady Memorial Hospital. T-cell receptor gene rearrangement and flow cytometry records from the peripheral blood were documented at initial assessment.

Exposures

T-cell receptor clonality and peripheral blood flow cytometry.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Univariate and multivariable models and Kaplan-Meier assessments were analyzed for overall survival (OS) and time to next treatment. The primary outcome was OS from diagnosis and time to next treatment, and the hypotheses were formulated prior to data collection.

Results

A total of 322 patients (166 female patients [51.6%]; median age at diagnosis, 53.8 years [range, 8.6-87.4 years]) with early-stage CTCL diagnosed from 1990 to 2018 were identified; of these, 258 had data available for both flow cytometry and TCR. Positive results for both TCR clonality and flow cytometry were associated with inferior OS in early-stage CTCL compared with both having negative results (hazard ratio [HR], 2.86; 95% CI, 1.02-8.06; P = .046). Positive results for only TCR clonality or only flow cytometry were not associated with OS (TCR clonality: HR, 1.31; 95% CI, 0.70-2.47; P = .40; flow cytometry: HR, 1.21; 95% CI, 0.58-2.52; P = .61) or time to next treatment (TCR clonality: HR, 1.05; 95% CI, 0.77-1.43; P = .76; flow cytometry: HR, 0.74; 95% CI, 0.47-1.16; P = .12). However, positive flow cytometry results were associated with reduced OS in the stage IIA subgroup (n = 94; HR, 1.17; 95% CI, 1.18-8.74; P = .02). Covariates associated with reduced survival included advanced age at diagnosis, male sex, and higher disease stage.

Conclusions and Relevance

This cohort study of patients with early-stage CTCL suggests that low-level blood involvement as indicated by positive results for both TCR gene rearrangement and flow cytometry was associated with inferior OS, whereas positive results for either flow cytometry or TCR clonality was not. More precise measurements of blood involvement in CTCL and larger multi-institutional cohorts are needed to validate the prognostic significance of low-level blood involvement in early-stage CTCL.

Emerging Role of T-cell Receptor Constant β Chain-1 (TRBC1) Expression in the Flow Cytometric Diagnosis of T-cell Malignancies

T-cell clonality testing is integral to the diagnostic work-up of T-cell malignancies; however, current methods lack specificity and sensitivity, which can make the diagnostic process difficult. The recent discovery of a monoclonal antibody (mAb) specific for human TRBC1 will greatly improve the outlook for T-cell malignancy diagnostics. The anti-TRBC1 mAb can be used in flow cytometry immunophenotyping assays to provide a low-cost, robust, and highly specific test that detects clonality of immunophenotypically distinct T-cell populations. Recent studies demonstrate the clinical utility of this approach in several contexts; use of this antibody in appropriately designed flow cytometry panels improves detection of circulating disease in patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, eliminates the need for molecular clonality testing in the context of large granular lymphocyte leukemia, and provides more conclusive results in the context of many other T-cell disorders. It is worth noting that the increased ability to detect discrete clonal T-cell populations means that identification of T-cell clones of uncertain clinical significance (T-CUS) will become more common. This review discusses this new antibody and describes how it defines clonal T-cells. We present and discuss assay design and summarize findings to date about the use of flow cytometry TRBC1 analysis in the field of diagnostics, including lymph node and fluid sample investigations. We also make suggestions about how to apply the assay results in clinical work-ups, including how to interpret and report findings of T-CUS. Finally, we highlight areas that we think will benefit from further research.

The immunopathogenesis and immunotherapy of cutaneous T cell lymphoma: Pathways and targets for immune restoration and tumor eradication

Cutaneous T cell lymphomas (CTCLs) are malignancies of skin-trafficking T cells. Patients with advanced CTCL manifest immune dysfunction that predisposes to infection and suppresses the antitumor immune response. Therapies that stimulate immunity have produced superior progression-free survival compared with conventional chemotherapy, reinforcing the importance of addressing the immune deficient state in the care of patients with CTCL. Recent research has better defined the pathogenesis of these immune deficits, explaining the mechanisms of disease progression and revealing potential therapeutic targets. The features of the malignant cell in mycosis fungoides and Sézary syndrome are now significantly better understood, including the T helper 2 cell phenotype, regulatory T cell cytokine production, immune checkpoint molecule expression, chemokine receptors, and interactions with the microenvironment. The updated model of CTCL immunopathogenesis provides understanding into clinical progression and therapeutic response.

Utility of TRBC1 Expression in the Diagnosis of Peripheral Blood Involvement by Cutaneous T-Cell Lymphoma

Peripheral blood involvement by cutaneous T-cell lymphoma is typically assessed by flow cytometry and plays a critical role in diagnosis, classification, and prognosis. Simplified strategies to detect tumor cells (Sezary cells) fail to exclude reactive subsets, whereas tumor-specific abnormalities are subtle and inconsistently present. We implemented a flow cytometric strategy to detect clonal Sezary cells based on the monotypic expression of one of two mutually exclusive TCR constant β chains, TRBC1 and TRBC2. Analysis of CD4⁺ T-cell subsets and TCR variable β classes from healthy donors showed polytypic TRBC1 staining. Clonal Sezary cells were identified by TRBC1 staining in 56 of 111 (50%) samples from patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma, accounting for 7-18,155 cells/μl and including 13 cases (23%) lacking tumor-specific immunophenotypic abnormalities. CD4⁺ T-cell subsets from 86 patients without T-cell lymphoma showed polytypic TRBC1 staining, except for five patients (6%) with minute T-cell clones of uncertain significance accounting for 53-136 cells/μl. Assessment of TRBC1 expression within a comprehensive single-tube flow cytometry assay effectively overcomes interpretative uncertainties in the identification of Sezary cells without the need for a separate T-cell clonality assay.

Determination of immunophenotypic aberrancies provides better assessment of peripheral blood involvement by mycosis fungoides/Sézary syndrome than quantification of CD26- or CD7- CD4+ T-cells

BACKGROUND

Blood involvement by mycosis fungoides (MF)/Sézary syndrome (SS) influences prognosis and therapeutic decisions. MF/SS blood stage is currently determined by absolute CD4 + CD26- or CD4 + CD7-cell counts, which quantification method may overestimate MF/SS by including CD26- or CD7- normal CD4+ T-cells, or underestimate disease burden when MF/SS cells show incomplete loss of CD26 and/or CD7. Recently, through the standardization effort led by the International Clinical Cytometry Society (ICCS), recommendation was made to quantify MF/SS by enumerating immunophenotypically aberrant CD4+ T-cells, rather than CD26- or CD7- in isolation.

METHODS

We compared these two quantitation methods in 309 MF/SS patients who had blood samples analyzed by flow cytometry immunophenotyping (FCI) over a 1-year period.

RESULTS

Using the European Organization of Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC)/International Society for Cutaneous Lymphomas (ISCL) criteria, 221 (71.5%) patients had a blood stage corresponding to B0, 57 (18.4%) to B1, and 31 (10%) to B2. By FCI analysis, a total of 62 patients (20.0%) were found positive for MF/SS. Among EORTC B0 patients, 11/221 (5%) were positive by FCI (false negatives), and among EORTC Stage B1 patients, 35/57 (61%) were negative by FCI (false positives). Regarding patients positive for MF/SS cells by FCI, there was an overall excellent correlation (r = .999, p < .001) between the EORTC/ISCL method and FCI method; however, four (6.5%) patients would have an altered B stage between B0 and B1.

CONCLUSION

The MF/SS cell quantification method using immunophenotypic aberrancies, as recommended by the ICCS, allows to distinguish MF/SS cells from background benign T-cells and enables for more accurate staging, especially among patients currently being considered to have B0 and B1 stage diseases.

A suggested immunohistochemical algorithm for the classification of T-cell lymphomas involving lymph nodes

T-cell lymphomas are a heterogeneous group of neoplasms derived from mature T lymphocytes. These neoplasms are uncommon and usually diagnostically challenging. The focus of this article is to suggest an immunohistochemistry-based, practical approach to assist in the diagnosis of nodal T-cell lymphomas. These neoplasms fall into two major groups: those with many CD30+ tumor cells (group A) and neoplasms that are negative or show only partial expression of CD30 (group B). The differential diagnosis of group A neoplasms mainly includes ALK+ anaplastic large-cell lymphoma (ALCL), ALK-negative ALCL, mycosis fungoides with CD30+ large-cell transformation, adult T-cell leukemia/lymphoma, extranodal T-cell lymphomas involving lymph nodes (usually regional), and peripheral T-cell lymphoma, not otherwise specified (PTCL-NOS). Group B neoplasms also include two groups based on the presence or absence of T follicular helper (TFH) markers. Those neoplasms expressing at least 2 TFH markers include angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma, nodal PTCL with a TFH phenotype, and follicular T-cell lymphoma. Neoplasms expressing ≤1 TFH marker can be further subdivided based on the expression of CD8 and cytotoxic markers and mainly include PTCL-NOS and a series of unusual subsets including primary Epstein-Barr virus-positive nodal natural killer/T-cell lymphoma, PTCL-NOS with a cytotoxic immunophenotype, and γ/δ T-cell lymphomas. Using this algorithmic approach, we suggest that the pathologist can establish a diagnosis for most nodal T-cell lymphomas encountered in daily practice.

Flow cytometric evaluation of peripheral blood for suspected Sézary syndrome or mycosis fungoides: International guidelines for assay characteristics

A peripheral blood flow cytometric assay for Sézary syndrome (SS) or circulating mycosis fungoides (MF) cells must be able to reliably identify, characterize, and enumerate T-cells with an immunophenotype that differs from non-neoplastic T-cells. Although it is also important to distinguish SS and MF from other subtypes of T-cell neoplasm, this usually requires information in addition to the immunophenotype, such as clinical and morphologic features. This article outlines the approach recommended by an international group with experience and expertise in this area. The following key points are discussed: (a) At a minimum, a flow cytometric assay for SS and MF should include the following six antibodies: CD3, CD4, CD7, CD8, CD26, and CD45. (b) An analysis template must reliably detect abnormal T-cells, even when they lack staining for CD3 or CD45, or demonstrate a phenotype that is not characteristic of normal T-cells. (c) Gating strategies to identify abnormal T-cells should be based on the identification of subsets with distinctly homogenous immunophenotypic properties that are different from those expected for normal T-cells. (d) The blood concentration of abnormal cells, based on any immunophenotypic abnormalities indicative of MF or SS, should be calculated by either direct enumeration or a dual-platform method, and reported.

Recent Advances in Cutaneous T-cell Lymphoma: Diagnostic and Prognostic Considerations

This review describes the latest advances in the diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma focusing on the most clinically useful features introduced since the publication of the World Health Organization revision in 2017. Clinical entities described include mycosis fungoides, Sézary syndrome, lymphomatoid papulosis, primary cutaneous anaplastic large cell lymphoma, primary cutaneous gamma delta T-cell lymphoma, primary cutaneous acral CD8⁺ T-cell lymphoma, primary cutaneous CD4⁺ small/medium T-cell lymphoproliferative disorder, and hydroa-vacciniforme-like lymphoproliferative disorder. Distinguishing histologic clues to diagnosis are discussed, and important molecular advances are described. Key prognostic indicators that may assist clinicians with timely and appropriate management options are presented.

The clinical importance of CD4+ CD7- in human diseases

The CD7 antigen is a member of the immunoglobulin superfamily that expresses on the surface of all thymocytes, a majority of mature T cells, and also natural killer cells. Interestingly, under physiological and different pathological conditions, the loss of CD7 antigen occurred in the subset of CD4⁺ memory T cells. Various functions have been proposed for CD7, including its role in the activation and intercellular adhesiveness of T cells. Several studies indicate that the number of CD4⁺ CD7^- T cells increases in diseases such as chronic inflammation and T-cell malignancies, these being skin inflammatory lesions. Therefore, this can be useful for the diagnosis of cancer cells, especially with reference to blood origin, treatment monitoring, and establishment of new therapies. Therefore, a comprehensive review could be useful to increase our knowledge about the clinical importance of these cells in human disease.

Cutaneous T-cell Lymphoma

Cutaneous T-cell lymphomas comprise a heterogeneous group of diseases characterized by monoclonal proliferations of T lymphocytes primarily involving skin, modified skin appendages, and some mucosal sites. This article addresses the basic clinical, histologic, and immunohistochemical characteristics of this group of diseases, with additional attention to evolving literature on dermoscopy, reflectance confocal microscopy, flow cytometry, and molecular data that may increasingly be applied to diagnostic and therapeutic algorithms in these diseases. Select unusual phenotypes or diagnostic examples of classic phenotypes are demonstrated, and flags for consideration while making a pathologic diagnosis of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma are suggested.

Advances in the understanding and management of T-cell prolymphocytic leukemia

T-prolymphocytic leukemia (T-PLL) is a rare T-cell neoplasm with an aggressive clinical course. Leukemic T-cells exhibit a post-thymic T-cell phenotype (Tdt-, CD1a-, CD5+, CD2+ and CD7+) and are generally CD4+/CD8-, but CD4+/CD8+ or CD8+/CD4- T-PLL have also been reported. The hallmark of T-PLL is the rearrangement of chromosome 14 involving genes for the subunits of the T-cell receptor (TCR) complex, leading to overexpression of the proto-oncogene TCL1. In addition, molecular analysis shows that T-PLL exhibits substantial mutational activation of the IL2RG-JAK1-JAK3-, STAT5B axis. T-PLL patients have a poor prognosis, due to a poor response to conventional chemotherapy. Monoclonal antibody therapy with antiCD52-alemtuzumab has considerably improved outcomes, but the responses to treatment are transient; hence, patients who achieve a response to therapy are considered for stem cell transplantation (SCT). This combined approach has extended the median survival to four years or more. Nevertheless, new approaches using well-tolerated therapies that target growth and survival signals are needed for most patients unable to receive intensive chemotherapy.

Clinical Experience With Modified, Single-Tube T-Cell Receptor Vβ Flow Cytometry Analysis for T-Cell Clonality

OBJECTIVES

Analysis of T-cell clonality using the IO Test Beta Mark (Beckman Coulter, Fullerton, CA) flow cytometry assay is cumbersome owing to the required eight-part analyses that limit its clinical utility. Here, we describe a simple modification that may improve its clinical utility.

METHODS

By simply combining all T-cell receptor (TCR) Vβ antibodies into one reagent tube, we show that T-cell repertoire analysis can be efficiently performed with an increased potential to closely link the aberrant immunophenotype of a neoplastic T-cell clone to its apparent clonal TCR Vβ restriction. We review our clinical experience and include flow cytometry sorting studies in conjunction with TRG gene rearrangement analysis to demonstrate the feasibility of this approach.

RESULTS

We show in representative cases that this modified approach permits evaluation of TCR Vβ clonality in T-cell neoplasms without a priori knowledge of the TCR Vβ isoform restriction and that this approach is suitable for samples containing a minor population of neoplastic T cells, hypocellular samples such as skin biopsy specimens and body fluids, and fine-needle aspirations. We estimate a false-positive rate for identifying a clonal population for this approach to be less than 6.2%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our modified approach of TCR Vβ analysis could improve routine clinical evaluation for abnormal T-cell populations by flow cytometry.

Cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL): Current practices in blood assessment and the utility of T-cell receptor (TCR)-Vβ chain restriction

BACKGROUND

Accurate quantification of malignant cells in the peripheral blood of patients with cutaneous T-cell lymphoma is important for early detection, prognosis, and monitoring disease burden.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to determine the spectrum of current clinical practices; critically evaluate elements of current International Society for Cutaneous Lymphomas (ISCL) B1 and B2 staging criteria; and assess the potential role of T-cell receptor-Vβ analysis by flow cytometry.

METHODS

We assessed current clinical practices by survey, and performed a retrospective analysis of 161 patients evaluated at Yale (2011-2014) to compare the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of parameters for ISCL B2 staging.

RESULTS

There was heterogeneity in clinical practices among institutions. ISCL B1 criteria did not capture 5 Yale cohort cases with immunophenotypic abnormalities that later progressed. T-cell receptor-Vβ testing was more specific than polymerase chain reaction and aided diagnosis in detecting clonality, but was of limited benefit in quantification of tumor burden.

LIMITATIONS

Because of limited follow-up involving a single center, further investigation will be necessary to conclude whether our proposed diagnostic algorithm is of general clinical benefit.

CONCLUSION

We propose further study of modified B1 criteria: CD4/CD8 ratio 5 or greater, %CD4(+) CD26(-) 20% or greater, or %CD4(+) CD7(-) 20% or greater, with evidence of clonality. T-cell receptor-Vβ testing should be considered in future diagnostic and staging algorithms.

Flow Cytometric Analysis of T, B, and NK Cells Antigens in Patients with Mycosis Fungoides

We retrospectively analyzed the clinicopathological correlation and prognostic value of cell surface antigens expressed by peripheral blood mononuclear cells in patients with mycosis fungoides (MF). 121 consecutive MF patients were included in this study. All patients had peripheral blood flow cytometry as part of their first visit. TNMB and histopathological staging of the cases were retrospectively performed in accordance with International Society for Cutaneous Lymphomas/European Organization of Research and Treatment of Cancer (ISCL/EORTC) criteria at the time of flow cytometry sampling. To determine prognostic value of cell surface antigens, cases were divided into two groups as stable and progressive disease. 17 flow cytometric analyses of 17 parapsoriasis (PP) and 11 analyses of 11 benign erythrodermic patients were included as control groups. Fluorescent labeled monoclonal antibodies were used to detect cell surface antigens: T cells (CD3(+), CD4(+), CD8(+), TCRαβ(+), TCRγδ(+), CD7(+), CD4(+)CD7(+), CD4(+)CD7(-), and CD71(+)), B cells (HLA-DR(+), CD19(+), and HLA-DR(+)CD19(+)), NKT cells (CD3(+)CD16(+)CD56(+)), and NK cells (CD3(-)CD16(+)CD56(+)). The mean value of all cell surface antigens was not statistically significant between parapsoriasis and MF groups. Along with an increase in cases of MF stage statistically significant difference was found between the mean values of cell surface antigens. Flow cytometric analysis of peripheral blood cell surface antigens in patients with mycosis fungoides may contribute to predicting disease stage and progression.

Clonality assessment of cutaneous B-cell lymphoid proliferations: a comparison of flow cytometry immunophenotyping, molecular studies, and immunohistochemistry/in situ hybridization and review of the literature

Cutaneous lymphoid infiltrates are diagnostically challenging. Although ancillary techniques to assess clonality can help distinguish between reactive lymphoid hyperplasia and lymphoma, one of the most widely used techniques in hematopathology, flow cytometry immunophenotyping (FCI), has not been routinely applied to skin specimens. We performed FCI on 73 skin specimens from 67 patients clinically suspected of having a cutaneous B-cell lymphoma (CBCL) and compared the results with those obtained from immunoglobulin heavy chain (IGH) gene molecular studies (58 cases, primarily by polymerase chain reaction) and either immunohistochemistry (IHC) or in situ hybridization to evaluate for light chain restriction (22 and 2 cases, respectively). Sufficient quantity of CD45 (leukocyte common antigen)-positive cells and staining quality were achieved in 88% of cases by FCI, and clonality was detected in 68% of CBCLs versus molecular studies showing sufficient DNA quality in 74% and only 39% clonality detection, and interpretable/contributory IHC results in 84% of cases with 55% clonality detection. Clonality was documented more frequently in secondary rather than primary CBCLs by all 3 techniques. Therefore, FCI is feasible and appears to be more reliable than molecular studies or IHC/in situ hybridization for detecting clonality in CBCLs and can provide additional prognostically and therapeutically relevant information. The exception is cases with plasmacytic differentiation such as marginal zone lymphoma for which IHC might be a superior tool. We have also shown that a large subset of primary cutaneous follicle center lymphomas express CD10 and/or BCL2 by FCI. Recent advances in FCI beg the question of applicability to cutaneous T-cell and NK-cell lymphomas.

Flow cytometric identification of immunophenotypically aberrant T-cell clusters on skin shave biopsy specimens from patients with mycosis fungoides

OBJECTIVES

To assess the ability of flow cytometry (FC) to detect putative neoplastic T-cell subsets on skin shave biopsy (SSB) specimens from patients with mycosis fungoides (MF) and to study the immunophenotype of skin-infiltrating tumor cells in MF.

METHODS

SSB specimens from patients with suspected MF were bisected and submitted for both FC and routine histopathology. Six-dimensional gating strategies were applied to identify putative neoplastic cells, independently from their expected immunophenotype.

RESULTS

Aberrant T cells were detected by FC in 18 of 33 SBB specimens, of which all had clinicomorphologic features of MF. Of the remaining 15 SSB specimens, six had clinicomorphologic features of MF and nine were diagnosed with benign inflammatory dermatoses. Unexpectedly, CD26 was aberrantly overexpressed in 11 (73%) and lost in three (20%) of 15 SSB specimens from patients with MF where this antigen was evaluated. Other detected aberrancies included CD3 dim- (13/18 [72%]), CD7 dim- (15/18 [83%]), and CD4-/CD8- (3/18 [17%]).

CONCLUSIONS

FC is capable of identifying putative neoplastic cells on SSB specimens from patients with MF. Bright homogeneous CD26 expression is a common and previously undescribed immunophenotypic aberrancy on MF skin infiltrates.

Blood flow cytometry in Sézary syndrome: new insights on prognostic relevance and immunophenotypic changes during follow-up

OBJECTIVES

Sézary syndrome (SS) is characterized by erythroderma, generalized lymphadenopathy, and the presence of circulating atypical lymphocytes, which are difficult to identify by morphologic data.

METHODS

We revised our series of 107 patients in an attempt to better define the phenotypic aberrancies in blood at diagnosis and the immunophenotypic stability over time detected by flow cytometry. Polymerase chain reaction assay was also used to study CD26/dipeptidyl peptidase IV (DPPIV) gene methylation.

RESULTS

The most common aberrancies were represented by the lack of CD26 (96/107) or CD38 (101/107) expression and the presence of a "dim" CD3, CD4, or CD2 population. There was a high variability in CD7 expression. In total, 31% of the patients had phenotypical heterogeneity in CD26 and CD7 expression at diagnosis. The phenotype was stable over time in 73 of 95 patients with available follow-up data, while 22 of 95 patients developed changes in CD26, CD7, or CD2 expression. CD4+CD26- SS showed hypermethylation of the CpG islands for the promoter region of CD26/DPPIV. Multivariate analysis showed that CD26 expression is a favorable prognostic factor (hazard ratio, 2.94; P = .045).

CONCLUSIONS

We confirm the relevance of CD26 negativity in SS diagnosis and monitoring. Nevertheless, the presence of rare CD26+ cases suggests that a multiparameter flow cytometry approach should be used. Changes in methylation profile could account for phenotypical heterogeneity.

Quantitative flow cytometric identification of aberrant T cell clusters in erythrodermic cutaneous T cell lymphoma. Implications for staging and prognosis

AIMS

Assessment of peripheral blood tumour burden for staging of cutaneous T cells lymphoma is most often accomplished by flow cytometry (FC) using various non-standarised strategies. We report the results of calculating absolute Sezary cell counts (SCCs) by FC, based on the identification of aberrant T cell clusters on a virtual 6-dimensional space and independently of the expected immunophenotype (6D-FC SCC).

METHODS

6D-FC SCCs were calculated on 65 peripheral blood specimens from 28 patients with erythrodermic cutaneous T cells lymphoma (stage III or IV). Comparisons were made with recommended FC strategies and correlations with overall mortality were studied.

RESULTS

At first visit, 17 of 28 patients (61%) had 6D-FC SCCs meeting current criteria for Stage IV disease (≥1000 SC/μL); while only 2 patients (7%) met Stage IV criteria on other tissues. As defined by comprehensive staging using clinicomorphological criteria and 6D-FC SCCs, Stage IV disease identified a subgroup of patients with worse overall survival (p=0.0227). Residual non-aberrant CD4 T cells were markedly decreased in Stage IV disease (p=0.018). Among 65 specimens, discrepancies were observed between 6D-FC SCCs and usual FC thresholds for Stage IV disease, namely a CD4:CD8 ratio ≥10:1 (9 discrepancies, 14%), and ≥40% aberrant CD4 T cells (4 discrepancies, 6%). Surprisingly, 8 cases (12%) from 6 patients exhibited two distinctively separate clusters of aberrant CD4 T cells with different CD7 and/or CD26 expression.

CONCLUSIONS

Visual 6-dimensional identification of aberrant T cell clusters by FC allows for the calculation of clinically significant SCCs. Simplified gating strategies and relative quantitative values might underestimate the immunophenotypical complexity of Sezary cells.

Accurate detection of the tumor clone in peripheral T-cell lymphoma biopsies by flow cytometric analysis of TCR-Vβ repertoire

Multiparametric flow cytometry has proven to be a powerful method for detection and immunophenotypic characterization of clonal subsets, particularly in lymphoproliferative disorders of the B-cell lineage. Although in theory promising, this approach has not been comparably fulfilled in mature T-cell malignancies. Specifically, the T-cell receptor-Vβ repertoire analysis in blood can provide strong evidence of clonality, particularly when a single expanded Vß family is detected. The purpose of this study was to determine the relevance of this approach when applied to biopsies, at the site of tumor involvement. To this end, 30 peripheral T-cell lymphoma and 94 control biopsies were prospectively studied. Vβ expansions were commonly detected within CD4+ or CD8+ T cells (97% of peripheral T-cell lymphoma and 54% of non-peripheral T-cell lymphoma cases); thus, not differentiating malignant from reactive processes. Interestingly, we demonstrated that using a standardized evaluation, the detection of a high Vβ expansion was closely associated with diagnosis of peripheral T-cell lymphoma, with remarkable specificity (98%) and sensitivity (90%). This approach also identified eight cases of peripheral T-cell lymphoma that were not detectable by other forms of immunophenotyping. Moreover, focusing Vβ expression analysis to T-cell subsets with aberrant immunophenotypes, we demonstrated that the T-cell clone might be heterogeneous with regard to surface CD7 or CD10 expression (4/11 cases), providing indication on 'phenotypic plasticity'. Finally, among the wide variety of Vβ families, the occurrence of a Vβ17 expansion in five cases was striking. To our knowledge, this is the first report demonstrating the power of T-cell receptor-Vβ repertoire analysis by flow cytometry in biopsies as a basis for peripheral T-cell lymphoma diagnosis and precise T-cell clone identification and characterization.

Immunophenotypic stability of Sézary cells by flow cytometry: usefulness of flow cytometry in assessing response to and guiding alemtuzumab therapy

Flow cytometry (FC) is frequently used to detect aberrant peripheral blood (PB) T cells ("Sézary cells") in patients with mycosis fungoides (MF) and Sézary syndrome (SS). However, immunophenotypic stability of MF/SS over time is not well characterized. We analyzed 141 PB samples from 9 cases (2 SS, 7 MF). At diagnosis, there were 3 to 5 immunophenotypic aberrancies per case (median, 4), including dim or absent CD2, CD3, CD4, CD5, CD7, or CD26 and bright CD45RO. Of 9 patients, 7 had a subsequent change in immunophenotype. All patients retained multiple aberrancies at follow-up (median, 3 per analysis; range, 2-6), of which 22.0% (81/369) were new. In 5 patients, a more than 99% decrease in absolute Sézary cell (ASC) counts by FC after alemtuzumab therapy or total skin electron beam radiation was associated with clinical improvement. We observed minor immunophenotypic changes over time in most patients with MF/SS; however, the Sézary clones maintain persistently aberrant immunophenotypes and seem amenable to follow-up with limited FC panels. ASC counts by FC correlated well with clinical response.

Simplified flow cytometric assessment in mycosis fungoides and Sézary syndrome

By using flow cytometry with markers for CD3, CD4, CD26, and CD7, we examined the blood samples of 109 patients for abnormal T cells: 69 patients with mycosis fungoides (MF)/Sézary syndrome (SS), 31 hospitalized control subjects, and 9 patients with inflammatory skin disease. T cells were identified as quantitatively abnormal (>15% CD26- or CD7- T cells) or phenotypically abnormal (CD26- or CD7- T cells with bright or dim CD3 or CD4 or bright CD7). Patients were followed for a median of 82 months, and abnormal T cells were correlated with diagnosis, clinical outcome, and other laboratory parameters. Abnormal T-cell populations were identified in 46% of patients with MF/SS (32/69) and correlated with disease extent. Quantitative abnormalities were more frequent than phenotypic abnormalities, and CD4+/CD26- T cells were more frequent than CD4+/CD7- T cells. CD26- T cells correlated better with disease extent than did CD7 -. Increasing numbers of abnormal T cells were associated with worsening disease. Flow cytometry provides valuable information for diagnosis, prognosis, and therapeutic efficacy in MF/SS.

Immunophenotypic correlation between skin biopsy and peripheral blood findings in mycosis fungoides

In mycosis fungoides (MF) with blood involvement, T-cell immunophenotypes in skin and blood have not been compared. Our aim was to evaluate T-cell immunophenotypes in skin by immunohistochemical analysis and compare results with flow cytometric (FC) findings in blood. Of 20 patients with MF with blood involvement, the immunophenotype was discrepant in 11 (55%). Compared with FC findings in blood, immunohistochemical analysis of skin samples failed to detect partial deletion of CD2 (5/11 [45%]), CD3 (3/11 [27%]), and CD5 (3/11 [27%]) and overrepresented deletion of CD7 in 2 (18%) of 11 patients. In addition, CD8+ MF was missed by immunohistochemical analysis in 2 (18%) of 11 patients. Identical T-cell populations were demonstrated by T-cell gene polymerase chain reaction in skin and blood in 8 of the 11 patients who had a discrepant immunophenotype. Awareness of the limitations of immunohistochemical analysis of skin samples is of practical value for pathologists interpreting skin biopsies in MF patients. In addition, our findings suggest CD8+ MF to be more common than previously reported.