Self-management interventions for skin care in people with a spinal cord injury: part 1-a systematic review of intervention content and effectiveness

Triangulation of veteran and provider models of preventing community-acquired pressure injuries in spinal cord injury to reveal convergence and divergence of perspectives

CONTEXT/OBJECTIVE

Community-acquired pressure injuries (CAPrI) are a common and costly complication of spinal cord injury (SCI). The majority of PrIs occur in the community, but there is little guidance in CAPrI prevention. This study describes how provider and veteran perspectives of CAPrI prevention converge and diverge.

DESIGN

The Farmer triangulation method was used to compare two models from previous qualitative research describing provider and veteran perspectives of CAPrI prevention based on the framework of CAPrI risks, resources, and preventive activities. The previous qualitative research revealed the provider model of CAPrI prevention using semi-structured interviews with interprofessional SCI providers at the Veteran Health Administration (VA) (n = 30). A qualitative descriptive design using photovoice (n = 30) with or without guided tours (n = 15) revealed the Veteran model of CAPrI prevention.

SETTING

The previous qualitative research was conducted at three geographically different VA spinal cord injury/disorder centers in the United States (north, south, west).

PARTICIPANTS

30 interprofessional SCI providers; 30 Veterans living with SCI at three VA SCI Centers in the United States.

INTERVENTIONS

n/a.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Provider-Veteran perspectives of CAPrI prevention that demonstrated agreement, partial agreement, divergence, and silence.

RESULTS

Providers and veterans agreed on what is basic care, and the importance of family, caregiver and health provider/system supports, but they viewed motivation, veteran role, informal supports, and adequacy of supports differently.

CONCLUSION

Understanding how SCI providers and veterans living with SCI view prevention in the community informs how to promote preventive care in the context of veterans' lives.

Co-design of the Spinal Cord Injury Health Maintenance Tool to Support Self-Management: A Mixed-Methods Approach

Background

There is a lack of consumer-friendly tools to empower and support people living with spinal cord injury (SCI) to self-manage complex health needs in community. This article describes the co-design process of the new SCI Health Maintenance Tool (SCI-HMT).

Methods

Co-design of the SCI-HMT using a mixed-methods approach included a rapid review, e-Delphi surveys with range of multidisciplinary health care professionals (n = 62), interviews of participants with SCI (n = 18) and general practitioners (n = 4), focus groups (n = 3 with 7, 4, and 4 participants with SCI, respectively), design workshops with stakeholders (n = 11, 8), and end-user testing (n = 41).

Results

The SCI-HMT (healthmaintenancetool.com) was developed based on participatory research with data synthesis from multiple sources. Five priority health maintenance issues for bladder, bowel, skin, pain, and autonomic dysreflexia were originally covered. Best practice recommendations, red flag conditions, referrals, and clinical pathways were agreed on through an e-Delphi technique. Qualitative analysis identified six broad key concepts for self-management, including early symptom recognition, role of SCI peers, knowledge sharing with primary care, general practitioners as gatekeepers, and shared decision-making and highlighted a need to place much stronger emphasis on mental health and well-being. Design workshops and end-user testing provided key insights about user experience, functionality, and content for the SCI-HMT.

Conclusion

The co-design process engaging end users, including people with SCI and general practitioners, enabled a shared understanding of the problem and identification of important needs and how to meet them. Informed by this process, the SCI-HMT is a freely accessible resource supporting SCI self-management, shared decision-making, and early problem identification.

Veteran model of preventing community-acquired pressure injuries associated with spinal cord injury: A qualitative descriptive study

CONTEXT/OBJECTIVE

Pressure injuries (PrIs) are the second leading cause of hospitalization in people with spinal cord injury (SCI). The majority of PrIs occur in the community, but there is little known about prevention of community acquired PrI (CAPrI). The purpose of this study was to better understand risks, resources, and actions associated with CAPrI prevention from the perspective of veterans living with SCI in the community.

METHODS

A qualitative descriptive design using photovoice (n = 30) with or without guided tours (n = 15) was conducted with Veterans living with SCI at 3 sites across the United States to determine environmental/lifestyle risks at home, prevention activities, resources used, and challenges in CAPrI prevention. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analyzed using thematic analysis, followed by inductive thematic synthesis.

RESULTS

Qualitative analyses revealed a model describing veteran's perspective of preventing CAPrIs associated with SCI. The model included 3 themes and 9 subthemes: Factors that Lead to Risk for Pressure Injury (Challenges and Barriers), Factors that Affect Chosen Actions (Veteran Motivators, Veteran Values, Veteran Satisfaction with Provider Relationships, and Veteran Supports), and Preventive Activities within Context of Life (Physical Care, Coping, Advocacy).

CONCLUSION

Incorporating the veteran model of prevention within the context of life into clinical care could support provider-veteran collaboration to identify and integrate successful strategies that prevent CAPrIs while also improving veteran quality of life.

Skin self-management of community-dwelling patients with spinal cord injury: A cross-sectional study

BACKGROUND

community-acquired pressure injury is one of the most common and troublesome complications of discharged patients with spinal cord injury. Previous studies have shown that pressure injury can not only increase the financial burden and care burden of patients, but also seriously affect their quality of life.

AIM

To evaluate the skin self-management of community-dwelling patients with spinal cord injury and to explore the related independent influencing factors.

METHODS

This was a cross-sectional survey study. A convenience sample of 110 community-dwelling patients with spinal cord injury recruited from three rehabilitation centers in Guangzhou and Chengdu in China completed the survey from September 2020 to June 2021. They were asked about their demographic data, skin self-management, knowledge about skin self-management, attitude to skin self-management, self-efficacy, and functional independence. Univariate analysis and multiple linear regression were performed to isolate the most important relationships.

RESULTS

The skin self-management of community-dwelling patients with spinal cord injury was relatively low, and they also performed poorly in the three categories of: skin check, preventing pressure ulcer, and preventing wounds. Skin self-management was found to be most often associated with level of knowledge about skin self-management, higher reimbursement and self-efficacy.

CONCLUSION

Community-dwelling patients with spinal cord injury with lower level of knowledge about skin self-management, with lower self-efficacy, and those with higher reimbursement have worse skin self-management.

Development of Smart Clothing to Prevent Pressure Injuries in Bedridden Persons and/or with Severely Impaired Mobility: 4NoPressure Research Protocol

Pressure injuries (PIs) are a major public health problem and can be used as quality-of-care indicators. An incipient development in the field of medical devices takes the form of Smart Health Textiles, which can possess innovative properties such as thermoregulation, sensing, and antibacterial control. This protocol aims to describe the process for the development of a new type of smart clothing for individuals with reduced mobility and/or who are bedridden in order to prevent PIs. This paper's main purpose is to present the eight phases of the project, each consisting of tasks in specific phases: (i) product and process requirements and specifications; (ii and iii) study of the fibrous structure technology, textiles, and design; (iv and v) investigation of the sensor technology with respect to pressure, temperature, humidity, and bioactive properties; (vi and vii) production layout and adaptations in the manufacturing process; (viii) clinical trial. This project will introduce a new structural system and design for smart clothing to prevent PIs. New materials and architectures will be studied that provide better pressure relief, thermo-physiological control of the cutaneous microclimate, and personalisation of care.

The content and effectiveness of self-management support interventions for people at risk of pressure ulcers: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Pressure ulcers are a common complication with a high impact on well-being and quality of life in people with impaired mobility and/or dysfunctional pain sensations. Prevention is therefore crucial. However, persons at risk seem to experience difficulties in adhering to self-management regimens that can help to prevent or diminish the development of pressure ulcers. Self-management support interventions might help to improve their self-management skills.

OBJECTIVES

To review the content, components and effectiveness of self-management support interventions on clinical and behavioral outcomes for people at risk of pressure ulcers.

METHODS

A systematic literature search for the period of January 2000 to February 2020 was conducted in five databases (CINAHL, Cochrane, PsycINFO, PubMed, and Web of Science). Inclusion criteria were: (1) studies including persons at a high risk of pressure ulcers; (2) studies investigating interventions focused on self-management support; (3) studies describing clinical and behavioral outcomes related to prevention and care of pressure ulcers. All studies were independently screened on title, abstracts and full text by two researchers. The PRISMS taxonomy of 14 components was used to code intervention content.

RESULTS

The search yielded 5297 papers, which resulted in the inclusion of 16 papers on self-management support interventions for persons at risk of pressure ulcers. Interventions focused mostly on 'Information about condition and/or management' (13 interventions), 'Training in practical self-management activities' (7 interventions), and 'Training in psychological strategies' (6 interventions). 'Provision of equipment' was not investigated. The intensity of the interventions varied in delivery mode, frequency and duration. Improvements were found in clinical outcomes in four studies and in behavioral outcomes in ten studies. Four studies showed improvements in clinical outcomes and ten studies in behavioral outcomes. Knowledge was positively influenced in eight studies.

CONCLUSION

Self-management support interventions show potential. The extensiveness and intensity of the interventions seem to be predictive for the effectiveness, but specific content components cannot be recommended. This review revealed recommendations for future research and international consensus should be reached about patient-relevant outcomes.

The functioning of social support in long-term prevention after spinal cord injury. A qualitative study

BACKGROUND

The impact of social support on the long-term condition after a spinal cord injury (SCI) varies across studies mainly involving self-report questionnaires.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to establish the common factors associated with social support leading individuals with an SCI to the effective prevention of secondary complications, including via adherence to medical follow-up.

METHODS

Inclusion criteria were a history of acquired SCI of any etiology, wheelchair use, and age≥18 years at the time of the study. Participants should have completed their initial rehabilitation program in France≥1 year earlier and were also enrolled according to 2 related study variables: routine medical follow-up (patients were or were not followed up) and the medically supervised reporting of a pressure ulcer after the initial rehabilitation session (0 or≥1 pressure ulcers). We performed a preparatory quantitative and qualitative literature review to identify factors affecting long-term follow-up after SCI, then adopted a narrative design with semi-structured interviews, transcribed and analyzed progressively by using qualitative analysis software.

RESULTS

We included 32 participants. We categorized our results based on the knowledge, attitudes, beliefs and practices of participants with respect to pressure ulcer prevention and long-term medical follow-up. Our narrative approach allowed us to identify 3 main domains relevant to social support: reciprocity, self-management and timing related to social support.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed social support as a dynamic process, a reciprocal phenomenon evolving in variations over time. These findings should be central to short- and long-term therapeutic education programs for patients and for people providing social support. Effective changes should also be implemented through the concept of the Learning Health System.

"What pressure ulcers mean to me?" Representations of pressure ulcer in persons with spinal cord injury: A qualitative study

OBJECTIVES

Explore the perceptions and beliefs related to pressure ulcers (PU), their prevention and treatment strategies, in order to discuss potential learning objectives for PU-related therapeutic education in persons with spinal cord injury (SCI).

DESIGN

Qualitative study, using grounded theory for the analysis of data collected via a questionnaire.

SETTING

Nine SCI referral centers, inpatient care.

PARTICIPANTS

131 persons with SCI were included. 76% were male, and 65% presented with paraplegia. The median age was 48 years (33.5; 58) and median time since injury was 11 years (3; 24.5). 70% had experience with PU.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Data collection via an open-ended questionnaire on the representation of PU, its prevention and life experience of having a PU.

RESULTS

Six categories were identified: (1) identifying what might become problematic, (2) daily preventive actions, (3) detecting the early signs, (4) managing the early signs, (5) need for care, (6) experience with PU and being bedridden. Pressure ulcers have dramatic consequences on psychosocial health. Prevention and treatment require self-management skills, such as self-risk assessment abilities, self-detection skills and problem-solving strategies, to optimise daily PU prevention in persons with SCI.

CONCLUSION

PU prevention tackled by persons with SCI bears some specificities that the physician must take into account in the construction of a self-management program in this high-risk population.

Co-designing a Self-Management App Prototype to Support People With Spinal Cord Injury in the Prevention of Pressure Injuries: Mixed Methods Study

BACKGROUND

Spinal cord injury is a complex chronic health condition that requires individuals to actively self-manage. Therefore, an evidence-based, self-management app would be of value to support individuals with spinal cord injury in the prevention of pressure injuries.

OBJECTIVE

The main objectives of this study were to (1) establish a co-design approach for developing a high-fidelity prototype app for the self-management of individuals with spinal cord injury, (2) design the prototype that resulted from this process, and (3) conduct the first usability assessment of the prototype app.

METHODS

We adopted a co-design approach to develop an evidence-based app prototype. Starting from a preliminary content model (based on clinical guidelines for the prevention of pressure injuries) and three research-based user personas, we conducted an ideation workshop involving individuals with spinal cord injury and health care professionals. The ideation workshop formed the basis for two consecutive design sprints. The result of this co-design phase was an interactive app prototype. The prototype was evaluated in two rounds of usability testing (N=4 and N=15, respectively) using a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods.

RESULTS

The co-design process resulted in a high-fidelity prototype with two key components: a self-management component and a communication component. The final prototype included a combination of features to support individuals with spinal cord injury in the prevention of pressure injuries, namely a smart camera, pressure injury diary, expert consultation, reminders, and knowledge repository. Findings of the usability testing showed that most participants navigated the app fluently with little back and forth navigation and were able to successfully complete a set of assigned tasks. These positive results are supported by the average system usability score achieved (78.5/100; range 47.5-95.0) and our qualitative analysis of the semistructured interviews. Despite an overall positive evaluation of the app prototype, we identified areas for improvement (eg, inclusion of a search function).

CONCLUSIONS

Individuals with spinal cord injury often need to navigate competing interests and priorities, paired with uncertainty about the accuracy and relevance of clinical recommendations. Understanding what matters to individuals with spinal cord injury can help guide the design of behavioral interventions that are useful and acceptable to these individuals in their daily lives. This study shows that involving individuals with spinal cord injury and health care professionals in co-designing a self-management app can foster knowledge cocreation at the intersection of lived experience, medical expertise, and technical solutions.

Self-management interventions for skin care in people with a spinal cord injury: part 2-a systematic review of use of theory and quality of intervention reporting

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review.

OBJECTIVES

To examine use of theory and quality of reporting in skin care self-management interventions for people with SCI.

SETTING

International.

METHODS

The Theory Coding Scheme (TCS) and the Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist were applied by two independent researchers to 17 interventions identified in a systematic review of self-management interventions for skin care in people with SCI.

RESULTS

Six (35%) of the 17 interventions reviewed were reported to have a theoretical basis. Theories used included three of the most commonly featured in health behavior research (the Health Belief Model, Social Cognitive Theory, and the Transtheoretical Model). In these six interventions, theory was used to design content but not to select participants or tailor strategies. None of the interventions were used to test theories in the SCI population, or to propose theoretical refinements. Reporting quality was found to vary by TIDieR item, with 6-100% of interventions including recommended information. Information on two intervention fidelity items was missing in 53 and 82% of descriptions.

CONCLUSIONS

Use of theory and reporting quality in SCI self-management research remains suboptimal, potentially slowing down advancements in this area of research. Rehabilitation researchers should direct their efforts toward improving these practices to help build a science of SCI self-management that is cumulative and reproducible by clinicians, scientists, and policy makers.

SPONSORSHIP

This work was funded through a postdoctoral fellowship awarded to the first author by the Rick Hansen Institute.