Genome editing for Duchenne muscular dystrophy: a glimpse of the future?

Targeted genetic therapies for inherited disorders that affect both cardiac and skeletal muscle

Skeletal myopathies and ataxias with secondary cardiac involvement are complex, progressive and debilitating conditions. As life expectancy increases across these conditions, cardiac involvement often becomes more prominent. This highlights the need for targeted therapies that address these evolving cardiac pathologies. Musculopathies by and large lack cures that directly target the genetic basis of the diseases; however, as our understanding of the genetic causes of these conditions has evolved, it has become tractable to develop targeted therapies using biologics, to design precision approaches to target the primary genetic causes of these varied diseases. Using the examples of Duchenne muscular dystrophy, Friedreich ataxia and Pompe disease, we discuss how the genetic causes of such diseases derail diverse homeostatic, energetic and signalling pathways, which span multiple cellular systems in varied tissues across the body. We outline existing therapeutics and treatments in the context of emerging novel genetic approaches. We discuss the hurdles that the field must overcome to deliver targeted therapies across the many tissue types affected in primary myopathies.

How Can Proteomics Help to Elucidate the Pathophysiological Crosstalk in Muscular Dystrophy and Associated Multi-System Dysfunction?

This perspective article is concerned with the question of how proteomics, which is a core technique of systems biology that is deeply embedded in the multi-omics field of modern bioresearch, can help us better understand the molecular pathogenesis of complex diseases. As an illustrative example of a monogenetic disorder that primarily affects the neuromuscular system but is characterized by a plethora of multi-system pathophysiological alterations, the muscle-wasting disease Duchenne muscular dystrophy was examined. Recent achievements in the field of dystrophinopathy research are described with special reference to the proteome-wide complexity of neuromuscular changes and body-wide alterations/adaptations. Based on a description of the current applications of top-down versus bottom-up proteomic approaches and their technical challenges, future systems biological approaches are outlined. The envisaged holistic and integromic bioanalysis would encompass the integration of diverse omics-type studies including inter- and intra-proteomics as the core disciplines for systematic protein evaluations, with sophisticated biomolecular analyses, including physiology, molecular biology, biochemistry and histochemistry. Integrated proteomic findings promise to be instrumental in improving our detailed knowledge of pathogenic mechanisms and multi-system dysfunction, widening the available biomarker signature of dystrophinopathy for improved diagnostic/prognostic procedures, and advancing the identification of novel therapeutic targets to treat Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

Cellular pathogenesis of Duchenne muscular dystrophy: progressive myofibre degeneration, chronic inflammation, reactive myofibrosis and satellite cell dysfunction

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is a highly progressive muscle wasting disease of early childhood and characterized by complex pathophysiological and histopathological changes in the voluntary contractile system, including myonecrosis, chronic inflammation, fat substitution and reactive myofibrosis. The continued loss of functional myofibres and replacement with non-contractile cells, as well as extensive tissue scarring and decline in tissue elasticity, leads to severe skeletal muscle weakness. In addition, dystrophic muscles exhibit a greatly diminished regenerative capacity to counteract the ongoing process of fibre degeneration. In normal muscle tissues, an abundant stem cell pool consisting of satellite cells that are localized between the sarcolemma and basal lamina, provides a rich source for the production of activated myogenic progenitor cells that are involved in efficient myofibre repair and tissue regeneration. Interestingly, the self-renewal of satellite cells for maintaining an essential pool of stem cells in matured skeletal muscles is increased in dystrophin-deficient fibres. However, satellite cell hyperplasia does not result in efficient recovery of dystrophic muscles due to impaired asymmetric cell divisions. The lack of expression of the full-length dystrophin isoform Dp427-M, which is due to primary defects in the DMD gene,  appears to affect key regulators of satellite cell polarity causing a reduced differentiation of myogenic progenitors, which are essential for myofibre regeneration. This review outlines the complexity of dystrophinopathy and describes the importance of the pathophysiological role of satellite cell dysfunction. A brief discussion of the bioanalytical usefulness of single cell proteomics for future studies of satellite cell biology is provided.

Role of CRISPR/Cas9 in the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy and its delivery strategies

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a neuromuscular disorder brought on by mutations in the DMD gene, which prevent muscle cells from expressing the dystrophin protein. CRISPR/Cas9 technology has evolved as potential option to treat DMD due to its ability to permanently skip exons, restoring the disrupted DMD reading frame and leading to dystrophin restoration. Even though, having potential to treat DMD, the delivery, safety and efficacy of this technology is still challenging. Several delivery methods, including viral vectors, nanoparticles, and electroporation, have been explored to deliver CRISPR/Cas9 to the targeted cells. Despite the potential of CRISPR/Cas9 technology in the treatment of DMD, several limitations need to be addressed. The off-target effects of CRISPR/Cas9 are a major concern that needs to be addressed to avoid unintended mutations. The delivery of CRISPR/Cas9 to the target cells and the immune response due to the viral vectors used for delivery are a few other limitations. The clinical trials of CRISPR/Cas9 for DMD provide valuable insights into the safety and efficacy of this technology in humans and the limitations that need to be known. Therefore, in this review we insightfully discussed the challenges and limitations of CRISPR/Cas9 in the treatment of DMD and delivery strategies used, and the ongoing efforts to overcome these challenges and restore dystrophin expression in DMD patients in the ongoing trials.

Systemic deletion of DMD exon 51 rescues clinically severe Duchenne muscular dystrophy in a pig model lacking DMD exon 52

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a fatal X-linked disease caused by mutations in the DMD gene, leading to complete absence of dystrophin and progressive degeneration of skeletal musculature and myocardium. In DMD patients and in a corresponding pig model with a deletion of DMD exon 52 (DMDΔ52), expression of an internally shortened dystrophin can be achieved by skipping of DMD exon 51 to reframe the transcript. To predict the best possible outcome of this strategy, we generated DMDΔ51-52 pigs, additionally representing a model for Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD). DMDΔ51-52 skeletal muscle and myocardium samples stained positive for dystrophin and did not show the characteristic dystrophic alterations observed in DMDΔ52 pigs. Western blot analysis confirmed the presence of dystrophin in the skeletal muscle and myocardium of DMDΔ51-52 pigs and its absence in DMDΔ52 pigs. The proteome profile of skeletal muscle, which showed a large number of abundance alterations in DMDΔ52 vs. wild-type (WT) samples, was normalized in DMDΔ51-52 samples. Cardiac function at age 3.5 mo was significantly reduced in DMDΔ52 pigs (mean left ventricular ejection fraction 58.8% vs. 70.3% in WT) but completely rescued in DMDΔ51-52 pigs (72.3%), in line with normalization of the myocardial proteome profile. Our findings indicate that ubiquitous deletion of DMD exon 51 in DMDΔ52 pigs largely rescues the rapidly progressing, severe muscular dystrophy and the reduced cardiac function of this model. Long-term follow-up studies of DMDΔ51-52 pigs will show if they develop symptoms of the milder BMD.

Time to diagnosis of Duchenne muscular dystrophy in Austria and Germany

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is an X-linked genetic disorder manifesting in early childhood with progressive muscular weakness and atrophy, and resulting in early loss of ambulation. The collection and evaluation of epidemiological data for this disease is crucial for an early diagnosis and disease management. In Germany, data are collected via the TREAT-NMD DMD patient registry ( www.dmd-register.de ). In contrast, data collection in Austria has not yet been performed systematically. For collecting data from Austrian DMD patients, an online survey of the patient's caregivers was conducted. Data of 57 patients were collected entailing initial symptoms, diagnosis and therapeutic measures. Comparable data has been collected for Germany via the TREAT-NMD DMD patient registry. 57 DMD patients aged 4-34 years completed the Austrian survey. On average, first symptoms of the disease appeared at the age of 3.1 years. As the most frequent first symptom, 46% of the patients described problems in climbing stairs. In 40% of the patients, DMD was diagnosed early due to an accidentally detected hyperCKemia in infancy or early childhood. Corticosteroids represented the main therapeutic option in our cohort. At the time of the survey, only 52% of the patients were treated with corticosteroids. Patients from Germany reported that first symptoms appeared at the age of 3.06 years. Diagnosis was established by genetic testing or muscle biopsy. 47% of the patients were treated with corticosteroids. Time between first symptoms and diagnosis was 7 months in Austria, and 4.7 months in Germany, respectively. Compared to earlier international studies, the Austrian data show encouraging results regarding earlier start of corticosteroid therapy in a larger percentage of patients. Austrian and German data show a trend towards an earlier diagnosis of DMD, while the age at symptom onset was similar to previous studies. The collection and evaluation of epidemiological data of DMD patients is important and will hopefully contribute to accelerate DMD diagnosis and treatment access for the patients.

Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells for Modeling Physiological and Pathological Striated Muscle Complexity

Neuromuscular disorders (NMDs) are a large group of diseases associated with either alterations of skeletal muscle fibers, motor neurons or neuromuscular junctions. Most of these diseases is characterized with muscle weakness or wasting and greatly alter the life of patients. Animal models do not always recapitulate the phenotype of patients. The development of innovative and representative human preclinical models is thus strongly needed for modeling the wide diversity of NMDs, characterization of disease-associated variants, investigation of novel genes function, or the development of therapies. Over the last decade, the use of patient's derived induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSC) has resulted in tremendous progress in biomedical research, including for NMDs. Skeletal muscle is a complex tissue with multinucleated muscle fibers supported by a dense extracellular matrix and multiple cell types including motor neurons required for the contractile activity. Major challenges need now to be tackled by the scientific community to increase maturation of muscle fibers in vitro, in particular for modeling adult-onset diseases affecting this tissue (neuromuscular disorders, cachexia, sarcopenia) and the evaluation of therapeutic strategies. In the near future, rapidly evolving bioengineering approaches applied to hiPSC will undoubtedly become highly instrumental for investigating muscle pathophysiology and the development of therapeutic strategies.

Isolation and Characterization of Primary DMD Pig Muscle Cells as an In Vitro Model for Preclinical Research on Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is the most frequent genetic myopathy in childhood and leads to progressive muscle atrophy, weakness, and premature death. So far, there is no curative treatment available. Therapeutic development from bench to bedside takes time, and promising therapies need to be tested in suitable preclinical animal models prior to clinical trials in DMD patients. Existing mouse and dog models are limited with regard to the comparability of the clinical phenotype and the underlying mutation. Therefore, our group established a tailored large animal model of DMD, the DMD pig, mirroring the human size, anatomy, and physiology. For testing novel approaches, we developed a corresponding in vitro model, facilitating preclinical testing for toxicity, dosing, and efficacy, which we describe here. We first extracted primary muscle cells from wild-type and DMD pigs of different age groups and characterized those cells, then improved their differentiation process for identification of dystrophin and utrophin in myotubes. Our porcine in vitro model represents an important step for the development of novel therapeutic approaches, which should be validated further to minimize the need for living animals for bioassays, and thereby support the '3R' (replace, reduce, refine) principle, as fewer animals have to be raised and treated for preclinical trials.

The skeletal muscle phenotype of the DE50-MD dog model of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Background: Animal models of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) are essential to study disease progression and assess efficacy of therapeutic intervention, however dystrophic mice fail to display a clinically relevant phenotype, limiting translational utility. Dystrophin-deficient dogs exhibit disease similar to humans, making them increasingly important for late-stage preclinical evaluation of candidate therapeutics. The DE50-MD canine model of DMD carries a mutation within a human 'hotspot' region of the dystrophin gene, amenable to exon-skipping and gene editing strategies. As part of a large natural history study of disease progression, we have characterised the DE50-MD skeletal muscle phenotype to identify parameters that could serve as efficacy biomarkers in future preclinical trials. Methods: Vastus lateralis muscles were biopsied from a large cohort of DE50-MD dogs and healthy male littermates at 3-monthly intervals (3-18 months) for longitudinal analysis, with multiple muscles collected post-mortem to evaluate body-wide changes. Pathology was characterised quantitatively using histology and measurement of gene expression to determine statistical power and sample sizes appropriate for future work. Results: DE50-MD skeletal muscle exhibits widespread degeneration/regeneration, fibrosis, atrophy and inflammation. Degenerative/inflammatory changes peak during the first year of life, while fibrotic remodelling appears more gradual. Pathology is similar in most skeletal muscles, but in the diaphragm, fibrosis is more prominent, associated with fibre splitting and pathological hypertrophy. Picrosirius red and acid phosphatase staining represent useful quantitative histological biomarkers for fibrosis and inflammation respectively, while qPCR can be used to measure regeneration ( MYH3, MYH8), fibrosis ( COL1A1), inflammation ( SPP1), and stability of DE50-MD dp427 transcripts. Conclusion: The DE50-MD dog is a valuable model of DMD, with pathological features similar to young, ambulant human patients. Sample size and power calculations show that our panel of muscle biomarkers are of strong pre-clinical value, able to detect therapeutic improvements of even 25%, using trials with only six animals per group.

Mineralocorticoid Receptor Signaling in the Inflammatory Skeletal Muscle Microenvironments of Muscular Dystrophy and Acute Injury

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a striated muscle degenerative disease due to loss of functional dystrophin protein. Loss of dystrophin results in susceptibility of muscle membranes to damage, leading to muscle degeneration and continuous inflammation and fibrosis that further exacerbate pathology. Long-term glucocorticoid receptor (GR) agonist treatment, the current standard-of-care for DMD, modestly improves prognosis but has serious side effects. The mineralocorticoid receptor (MR), a ligand-activated transcription factor present in many cell types, has been implicated as a therapeutic target for DMD. MR antagonists (MRAs) have fewer side effects than GR agonists and are used clinically for heart failure. MRA efficacy has recently been demonstrated for DMD cardiomyopathy and in preclinical studies, MRAs also alleviate dystrophic skeletal muscle pathology. MRAs lead to improvements in muscle force and membrane stability and reductions in degeneration, inflammation, and fibrosis in dystrophic muscles. Myofiber-specific MR knockout leads to most of these improvements, supporting an MR-dependent mechanism of action, but MRAs additionally stabilize myofiber membranes in an MR-independent manner. Immune cell MR signaling in dystrophic and acutely injured normal muscle contributes to wound healing, and myeloid-specific MR knockout is detrimental. More research is needed to fully elucidate MR signaling in striated muscle microenvironments. Direct comparisons of genomic and non-genomic effects of glucocorticoids and MRAs on skeletal muscles and heart will contribute to optimal temporal use of these drugs, since they compete for binding conserved receptors. Despite the advent of genetic medicines, therapies targeting inflammation and fibrosis will be necessary to achieve optimal patient outcomes.

[Principles of translational gene therapy for neuromuscular diseases]

BACKGROUND

In recent years the theoretical hope has become reality and the first hereditary neuromuscular diseases have become causally treatable. Neuromuscular diseases have thus become the pacemaker of this form of therapy for the whole of neurology.

AIMS

This article describes the principles of precision gene therapy for neurogenetic diseases using examples of neuromuscular diseases.

DISCUSSION

Various strategies of gene therapy have become established and are being tested in preclinical and clinical trials and evaluated as approved forms for long-term efficacy. The aim of every gene therapy is the modification or introduction of the target gene with initiation of a degradation of dysfunctional proteins. Various techniques, such as gene transfer, gene substitution or gene editing in vivo and ex vivo are now usable. For example, a modification of the pre-mRNA using antisense oligonucleotides or RNA interference (siRNA) can be used for exon skipping. An initiation of gene expression to produce the target protein can be based on a modification of the DNA by means of gene replacement, cell-based therapy (iPS cells), regulation by compensatory proteins or pharmacological treatment with so-called small molecules. Each method has advantages and complex disadvantages that must be individually evaluated. Phenotypic peculiarities of a rare disease often only become apparent through specific translational therapy. It is already becoming obvious that a very early point in timing of gene therapy is probably the most effective. Newborn screening is therefore gaining additional importance as early diagnosis can achieve the best possible success of therapies, possibly even preventively.

Myeloid mineralocorticoid receptors contribute to skeletal muscle repair in muscular dystrophy and acute muscle injury

Suppressing mineralocorticoid receptor (MR) activity with MR antagonists is therapeutic for chronic skeletal muscle pathology in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) mouse models. Although mechanisms underlying clinical MR antagonist efficacy for DMD cardiomyopathy and other cardiac diseases are defined, mechanisms in skeletal muscles are not fully elucidated. Myofiber MR knockout improves skeletal muscle force and a subset of dystrophic pathology. However, MR signaling in myeloid cells is known to be a major contributor to cardiac efficacy. To define contributions of myeloid MR in skeletal muscle function and disease, we performed parallel assessments of muscle pathology, cytokine levels, and myeloid cell populations resulting from myeloid MR genetic knockout in muscular dystrophy and acute muscle injury. Myeloid MR knockout led to lower levels of C-C motif chemokine receptor 2 (CCR2)-expressing macrophages, resulting in sustained myofiber damage after acute injury of normal muscle. In acute injury, myeloid MR knockout also led to increased local muscle levels of the enzyme that produces the endogenous MR agonist aldosterone, further supporting important contributions of MR signaling in normal muscle repair. In muscular dystrophy, myeloid MR knockout altered cytokine levels differentially between quadriceps and diaphragm muscles, which contain different myeloid populations. Myeloid MR knockout led to higher levels of fibrosis in dystrophic diaphragm. These results support important contributions of myeloid MR signaling to skeletal muscle repair in acute and chronic injuries and highlight the useful information gained from cell-specific genetic knockouts to delineate mechanisms of pharmacological efficacy.

A Hybrid Protocol for Finding Novel Gene Targets for Various Diseases Using Microarray Expression Data Analysis and Text Mining

The advancement in technology for various scientific experiments and the amount of raw data produced from that is enormous, thus giving rise to various subsets of biologists working with genome, proteome, transcriptome, expression, pathway, and so on. This has led to exponential growth in scientific literature which is becoming beyond the means of manual curation and annotation for extracting information of importance. Microarray data are expression data, analysis of which results in a set of up/downregulated lists of genes that are functionally annotated to ascertain the biological meaning of genes. These genes are represented as vocabularies and/or Gene Ontology terms when associated with pathway enrichment analysis need relational and conceptual understanding to a disease. The chapter deals with a hybrid approach we designed for identifying novel drug-disease targets. Microarray data for muscular dystrophy is explored here as an example and text mining approaches are utilized with an aim to identify promisingly novel drug targets. Our main objective is to give a basic overview from a biologist's perspective for whom text mining approaches of data mining and information retrieval is fairly a new concept. The chapter aims to bridge the gap between biologist and computational text miners and bring about unison for a more informative research in a fast and time efficient manner.

A scalable, clinically severe pig model for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Large animal models for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) are crucial for evaluation of diagnostic procedures and treatment strategies. Pigs cloned from male cells lacking DMD exon 52 (DMDΔ52) resemble molecular, clinical and pathological hallmarks of DMD, but die before sexual maturity and cannot be propagated by breeding. Therefore, we generated female DMD+/- carriers. A single founder animal had 11 litters with 29 DMDY/-, 34 DMD+/- as well as 36 male and 29 female wild-type offspring. Breeding with F1 and F2 DMD+/- carriers resulted in additional 114 DMDY/- piglets. With intensive neonatal management, the majority survived for 3-4 months, providing statistically relevant cohorts for experimental studies. Pathological investigations and proteome studies of skeletal muscles and myocardium confirmed the resemblance of human disease mechanisms. Importantly, DMDY/- pigs reveal progressive myocardial fibrosis and increased expression of connexin-43, associated with significantly reduced left ventricular ejection fraction already at age 3 months. Furthermore, behavioral tests provided evidence for impaired cognitive ability. Our breeding cohort of DMDΔ52 pigs and standardized tissue repositories provide important resources for studying DMD disease mechanisms and for testing novel treatment strategies.

Complexity of skeletal muscle degeneration: multi-systems pathophysiology and organ crosstalk in dystrophinopathy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is a highly progressive muscle wasting disorder due to primary abnormalities in one of the largest genes in the human genome, the DMD gene, which encodes various tissue-specific isoforms of the protein dystrophin. Although dystrophinopathies are classified as primary neuromuscular disorders, the body-wide abnormalities that are associated with this disorder and the occurrence of organ crosstalk suggest that a multi-systems pathophysiological view should be taken for a better overall understanding of the complex aetiology of X-linked muscular dystrophy. This article reviews the molecular and cellular effects of deficiency in dystrophin isoforms in relation to voluntary striated muscles, the cardio-respiratory system, the kidney, the liver, the gastrointestinal tract, the nervous system and the immune system. Based on the establishment of comprehensive biomarker signatures of X-linked muscular dystrophy using large-scale screening of both patient specimens and genetic animal models, this article also discusses the potential usefulness of novel disease markers for more inclusive approaches to differential diagnosis, prognosis and therapy monitoring that also take into account multi-systems aspects of dystrophinopathy. Current therapeutic approaches to combat muscular dystrophy are summarised.

Applications and challenges of CRISPR-Cas gene-editing to disease treatment in clinics

Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-associated systems (Cas) are efficient tools for targeting specific genes for laboratory research, agricultural engineering, biotechnology, and human disease treatment. Cas9, by far the most extensively used gene-editing nuclease, has shown great promise for the treatment of hereditary diseases, viral infection, cancers, and so on. Recent reports have revealed that some other types of CRISPR-Cas systems may also have surprising potential to join the fray as gene-editing tools for various applications. Despite the rapid progress in basic research and clinical tests, some underlying problems present continuous, significant challenges, such as editing efficiency, relative difficulty in delivery, off-target effects, immunogenicity, etc. This article summarizes the applications of CRISPR-Cas from bench to bedside and highlights the current obstacles that may limit the usage of CRISPR-Cas systems as gene-editing toolkits in precision medicine and offer some viewpoints that may help to tackle these challenges and facilitate technical development. CRISPR-Cas systems, as a powerful gene-editing approach, will offer great hopes in clinical treatments for many individuals with currently incurable diseases.

Current Pharmacological Strategies for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a lethal, X-linked neuromuscular disorder caused by the absence of dystrophin protein, which is essential for muscle fiber integrity. Loss of dystrophin protein leads to recurrent myofiber damage, chronic inflammation, progressive fibrosis, and dysfunction of muscle stem cells. There is still no cure for DMD so far and the standard of care is principally limited to symptom relief through glucocorticoids treatments. Current therapeutic strategies could be divided into two lines. Dystrophin-targeted therapeutic strategies that aim at restoring the expression and/or function of dystrophin, including gene-based, cell-based and protein replacement therapies. The other line of therapeutic strategies aims to improve muscle function and quality by targeting the downstream pathological changes, including inflammation, fibrosis, and muscle atrophy. This review introduces the important developments in these two lines of strategies, especially those that have entered the clinical phase and/or have great potential for clinical translation. The rationale and efficacy of each agent in pre-clinical or clinical studies are presented. Furthermore, a meta-analysis of gene profiling in DMD patients has been performed to understand the molecular mechanisms of DMD.

Epigenetic reprogramming of cell identity: lessons from development for regenerative medicine

Epigenetic mechanisms are known to define cell-type identity and function. Hence, reprogramming of one cell type into another essentially requires a rewiring of the underlying epigenome. Cellular reprogramming can convert somatic cells to induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) that can be directed to differentiate to specific cell types. Trans-differentiation or direct reprogramming, on the other hand, involves the direct conversion of one cell type into another. In this review, we highlight how gene regulatory mechanisms identified to be critical for developmental processes were successfully used for cellular reprogramming of various cell types. We also discuss how the therapeutic use of the reprogrammed cells is beginning to revolutionize the field of regenerative medicine particularly in the repair and regeneration of damaged tissue and organs arising from pathological conditions or accidents. Lastly, we highlight some key challenges hindering the application of cellular reprogramming for therapeutic purposes.